Behavior and Belief

Behavior and Belief

Vsauce

0:03 Hey, Mind Field!

0:04 Vanessa here.

0:05 Just kidding.

0:06 My name is actually Michael.

0:09 That part when I said that I was Vanessa...

0:11 that was a lie.

0:13 So you're welcome.

0:15 Humans love lies.

0:18 More precisely, we love things that aren't entirely true— because we have to.

0:23 It's often all we have.

0:25 Completely proving something can be difficult, if not impossible.

0:30 So instead, we have the faith of the believer,

0:33 the confidence interval of the scientist.

0:36 What we think we know, we really only believe we know.

0:42 On this episode of Mind Field,

0:43 I'm going to take a look at a kind of lie we tell ourselves.

0:47 And I'm going to use belief to turn a lie...into a truth.

0:55 theme music playing) Michael: If I'm going to harness the power of belief,

1:12 I need to find a good way to study belief and behavior.

1:15 So I'm paying a visit to UCLA's Dr.

1:18 Aaron Blaisdell, who I worked with on last

1:20 season's "Greater Good" Trolley Problem episode.

1:24 train whistle blowing) Dr.

1:25 Blaisdell, great to see you again.

1:27 Nice to see you again, Michael.

1:29 Thank you for your help last season,

1:31 but I've got this new thing I want to look into.

1:34 I started thinking a lot about belief and how we form them.

1:37 Specifically beliefs about what causes our behavior.

1:42 I want to be able to break it down and just look at how

1:45 people respond to the environment around them and how it changes their belief.

1:48 Well, a Skinner Box is a great place to start.

1:51 because what I tell my students is, a Skinner Box,

1:55 for a psychologist like myself, is like a test tube for a chemist.

1:59 Dr.

1:59 Skinner, what are you doing with this pigeon?

2:01 I'm getting ready to demonstrate a fundamental principle of behavior.

2:05 Michael: Invented by Harvard psychologist B.F.

2:07 Skinner, a Skinner Box is a chamber in which

2:10 animals can be isolated and exposed to carefully controlled stimuli.

2:14 In one of his landmark experiments,

2:16 Skinner released food to pigeons in the boxes at regular intervals.

2:20 What he found was that the pigeons seemed to believe that whatever they happened

2:23 to be doing just before the food came actually caused the food to appear,

2:28 and would then repeat that behavior over and over— for example,

2:31 hopping around or spinning in circles.

2:34 Skinner called this "superstitious behavior." So what do

2:39 you want to do— what's your dream test?

2:42 Basically a replication of Skinner's superstitious experiment,

2:46 but instead of with pigeons, with people.

2:49 I would love to see:

2:50 will people develop their own sort of superstitious rituals or beliefs.

2:55 Have we done this with people before?

2:57 I don't think such a rigorous test of this has been done.

3:01 I think primarily, from the literature I know, it's pretty much pigeons.

3:09 B.F.

3:10 Skinner's work showed that if you regularly deliver a reward to a pigeon,

3:14 regardless of how it actually acts, the pigeon won't figure that out.

3:18 Instead, the pigeon will develop superstitious behaviors

3:22 as if it thinks it is in control, despite the lack of any evidence that it is.

3:27 But what about humans?

3:28 Watching people form new superstitions might show us how beliefs are created,

3:33 but here's the thing: You can't just put a person in a Skinner Box.

3:37 People are quite clever, and so instead, along with Dr.

3:40 Aaron Blaisdell, I have developed a much more elaborate ruse.

3:43 Welcome to Victory Vault.

3:50 Michael: "Victory Vault" is a fake game show we made up

3:54 to draw our unsuspecting subjects into taking part in a human Skinner Box.

3:59 To accomplish this, we rented a sound stage

4:01 and constructed what appeared to be a game show set, but was really our study.

4:06 We outfitted the room with a checkboard floor, a button that serves no purpose,

4:11 multiple cameras and a live microphone,

4:13 all of which have absolutely no connection to winning the game.

4:17 We also included an ATM slot on the wall where, instead of food,

4:21 dollar bills would be fed into the room at regular intervals.

4:25 Meanwhile, I would be playing the role of the executive producer

4:28 of this new game show testing out the concept for a television network.

4:32 Our first subject is Rebecca.

4:34 Yes, I know nothing.

4:36 I'm excited.

4:36 Excellent, excellent.

4:38 Well, I'll you some things that you need to know.

4:40 One, you will get to keep all of the money that you get today.

4:44 The object of the game is to collect as much money as possible.

4:49 OK.

4:49 laughs)- Now, you will have ten minutes, and that's all I'm going to tell you.

4:54 Go.

4:55 OK?

4:55 OK.

5:00 Rebecca: OK.

5:01 Michael (over loudspeaker): All right, Rebecca, begin in three, two, one, go!

5:10 Blaisdell: Of course, right to the button,

5:11 but she's not fixated on it, she's definitely looking around there.

5:15 Rebecca: I'm trying to figure out if there's,

5:17 like, a puzzle, or what this is about.

5:19 Am I supposed to just get out?

5:21 No, not supposed to get out.

5:23 OK.

5:26 Oh!

5:27 OK, there's money.

5:28 Is that one clue?

5:29 Rebecca: I've earned one dollar.

5:31 laughs) See?

5:32 She's "earned" one dollar.

5:34 Earned.

5:34 I mean, she thinks she caused it to happen.

5:37 Let's see.

5:37 I think I might be onto something- with this door, maybe?

5:42 Uh-huh.

5:42 OK.

5:43 Blaisdell: The second dollar bill came out

5:45 really shortly after she manipulated the door.

5:48 That's what Skinner would call "adventitious reinforcement." She accidentally

5:52 just happened to be doing something,- and now look.

5:55 Hello?

5:55 Look, it reinforced that behavior, look how strong it's become.

5:58 Now she's doing a lot with the door,

6:00 and this dancing, just like one of Skinner's pigeons.

6:03 Anything?

6:04 See?

6:04 Michael: For the first two minutes,

6:06 Rebecca believed a specific combination of the door

6:08 and the button were triggering the money.

6:11 She had created a superstitious ritual.

6:13 But when her old ritual ceased to line up with the reward being delivered,

6:17 she started exploring new actions.

6:19 Would you like to keep sending money?

6:21 Is it something with this?

6:23 Hello, dollar bill.

6:24 Michael: This change in Rebecca's behavior indicates that she stopped

6:28 believing that pressing the button is associated with money coming out.

6:32 Skinner called this "extinction."( singing)♪ Keep

6:35 sending money, what if I dance?

6:36 Michael: Not it seems she believes her new actions might connect to the reward.

6:40 Five, four, three,-( Rebecca yelps)- two, one...

6:44 Let's try coming out again.

6:46 zero, stop.

6:47 And...

6:47 OK.

6:48 I don't think I solved this mystery.

6:51 laughs) Michael: Rebecca!

6:53 You got some money, huh?

6:56 I did!

6:56 Come take a seat.

6:57 So, first of all, how'd it go?

6:59 Oh!

7:00 Very confusing.

7:02 I wasn't able to fully figure it out,

7:05 but it was something to do with the 20 white squares on the floor.

7:08 Something to do with the red button as well, like a pattern, maybe?

7:11 Oh!

7:11 Maybe I should have tried clicking on the button 20 times.

7:15 Yes!

7:16 OK, you wanna know what makes the money come out?

7:18 Yes.

7:18 It's probably something really crazy.

7:21 It's just 30 seconds passing.

7:22 Blaissdell: Yep.

7:23 It has nothing to do with what you do.

7:24 Ohh!

7:25 You would have gotten the same amount,

7:26 but you could just sat on the floor and done nothing.

7:29 laughing)- Yeah.

7:30 This is actually a psychological experiment based on some work done by B.F.

7:36 Skinner, and we are looking at the kinds

7:39 of behaviors people invent that they think controls the money.

7:43 But I think this was fascinating.

7:45 Blaisdell: Yeah.

7:45 And you really do get to keep the money.

7:47 Yay!

7:47 Rebecca, thank you for your help today.

7:49 Cool.

7:49 Thank you, guys.

7:50 Michael: Rebecca's rituals seemed to indicate that she

7:52 thought performing for the camera would work the best.

7:55 Her beliefs about TV shows informed the kinds of superstitions she would create.

8:00 But will other people develop the same superstitions?

8:03 Or will it depend on the beliefs and expectations they already have?

8:06 The object of Victory Vault is to collect as much money as you can.

8:10 Oh, OK.

8:11 Well, let me take these accessories off there really quickly.

8:14 As soon as that door closes, your ten minutes starts.

8:16 I don't get to ask questions?

8:18 Not on Victory Vault.

8:19 Michael: See you in ten minutes.

8:23 All right.

8:25 Where's the cash?

8:27 It's like an escape room.

8:31 Am I supposed to push this?

8:34 Blaisdell: Some people really wanted instructions.

8:36 Michael: Yeah.

8:37 Contestant: I feel like if I push this, the time is gonna be up.

8:39 Michael: Like Rebecca,

8:40 all of our subjects immediately gravitated to the useless button.

8:43 That button is so salient.

8:45 Push the button?

8:49 Oh, shit!

8:51 Michael, Blaisdell laugh) He was a little surprised at that.

8:54 Push the button?

8:56 Oh!

8:57 OK, I think I get it.

8:58 Is it push the button?

8:59 Will I push the button?

9:01 Am I supposed to push the button?

9:02 rapping)♪ If you're gon' push the button,

9:04 then you're goin' with the button♪♪ And I'm pushin' on the button—♪ Michael:

9:07 It was clear that most of the superstitions began with the button,

9:10 but evolved into something else very quickly,

9:13 including this guy, whose superstitious behavior was doing absolutely nothing.

9:19 Blaisdell: He's just standing there.

9:21 Michael: Yeah.

9:22 Will he do something...?

9:28 chuckling) Maybe taking the money is...bad?

9:33 I know strippers get singles for dancing.

9:36 Blaisdell: Is he gonna dance?

9:38 I hope he doesn't strip for us.

9:39 I can't dance like that.

9:43 Maybe I can sweet talk the machine.

9:45 It's just giving me money at this point.

9:47 I'm not doing anything.

9:48 laughs) Blaisdell: He's no fool.

9:50 He's not really showing much superstitious behavior.

9:53 Even in Skinner's experiments,

9:55 not all the pigeons showed superstitious behaviors.

9:57 Michael: Obviously there's a game, I called it a game show.

10:01 But the money's just piling up like it's contagious.

10:04 Oh, look!

10:06 Uh— Oh.

10:07 He really doesn't want to push it.

10:12 Come on.

10:12 Press it four times, out comes the money.

10:16 Press it four times?

10:17 Out comes the money.

10:18 contestant laughing) Press it four times, out comes the money.

10:25 She believes that pressing the button is necessary, is a cause.

10:29 And the ritual consists of a few actions strung together.

10:33 Five, four, three...

10:37 two...one, stop.

10:41 Can I push the button?

10:42 Time is up.

10:43 Damn.

10:44 Stay where you are.

10:44 We will see you very soon.

10:46 I feel like I was supposed to push the button.

10:49 Michael: Pigeons don't enter a Skinner Box

10:51 with nearly as many preconceived notions as humans do.

10:54 Humans come in with a rich diversity of expectations.

10:57 Some think they need to perform for the camera, or make the producers laugh.

11:01 This guy thought that the secret was to just be different.

11:06 Hold it!

11:07 Oh, I thought— Take a seat.

11:10 What was that?

11:11 Michael: Great work.

11:12 What made the money come out?

11:14 This is what I finally thought.

11:16 It was a test not to push the button, and then as I kept saying a cer—

11:19 a word— like phrase and "button," it kept coming out.

11:22 But I didn't know how it was supposed to be phrased.

11:24 Hit that button.

11:25 Hit it a lot.

11:27 As if your life depended on it.

11:29 I was thinking, "What would people not do?"- Hmm.

11:32 Probably just stand there.

11:34 So I was like, well, let's just stand there and see what happens.

11:37 Maybe they'll reward patience over impulsiveness.

11:40 You started doing exercises.

11:41 Man: Yeah.

11:42 I don't know if it rewarded you for just being— doing crazy things.

11:47 Did you learn anything?

11:48 That it was dispensing like a dollar every,

11:52 I don't know, like 30 seconds or something.

11:54 You're right.

11:56 You had no control over when the money came out.

12:00 It's pretty interesting.

12:01 I'm wondering- if that's because of who you are...

12:05 Yep.

12:06 Wh-Who are you?

12:06 Blaisdell: Elaborate.

12:07 That's just like my thought process, I think, like I'm just very observant.

12:11 You came up with this great entering-and-exiting-the-room thing.

12:14 Tell me about that.

12:16 Because the money didn't start coming out until after I— I waited, I waited,

12:19 I waited, and nothing came out until after I left and came back in.

12:23 You shoulda just left me in there to get more money!

12:25 You made a sistah work hard for her money.

12:28 Michael: Victory Vault, a.k.a.

12:31 human Skinner Box experiment.

12:33 What are your thoughts?

12:35 We're really finding that humans are

12:37 susceptible to superstitious beliefs or behaviors.

12:41 You know what?

12:42 I totally agree.

12:43 Except there were some people who were able to guess

12:46 with some degree of confidence that they didn't have control.

12:50 Some people were probably just skeptical from the get-go.

12:54 Yeah.

12:55 And that's just their personality.

12:56 Yeah, the beliefs that people brought into that room

12:59 really affected what beliefs or lack thereof...

13:02 ...they created in the room once the game started.

13:05 Yeah.

13:06 We're belief machines.

13:07 We're pattern seekers.

13:09 And there's even a belief that in psychology and in anthropology

13:15 that may be the way a lot of rituals got started, by accidental reinforcement.

13:19 And then it becomes codified into a religion or a cultural practice.

13:23 Hmm.

13:31 Our human-sized Skinner Box showed that when confronted with uncertainty,

13:36 people often behaved superstitiously,

13:39 under the belief that they do have control.

13:43 But of course, nothing anyone did in that box

13:46 would make the money come out any faster.

13:48 So those superstitions were lies.

13:52 But sometimes if a lie is believed in enough,

13:56 it can literally become true, like a placebo.

14:01 Now, I've been watching a lot of horror movies lately, and they gave me an idea.

14:06 If I'm able to find just the right preexisting beliefs to wrap around a placebo,

14:12 could I literally make people believe that I am possessing them with a spirit?

14:17 I want to perform a sham reverse exorcism.

14:22 Exorcisms are not some Hollywood fabrication...

14:28 and they didn't only happen hundreds of years ago.

14:31 In fact, in the United States alone, there are currently 50 priests endorsed

14:36 by the Vatican's International Association of Exorcists,

14:39 up from just 12 a decade ago.

14:42 But what's a reverse exorcism?

14:44 It's something I made up where instead of removing a spirit from someone,

14:49 you put one in them.

14:51 I want to do that because I don't think

14:53 it's ethical to tell someone they're possessed by a demon.

14:56 But I'll need some help, and I know just who to ask.

15:03 Michael: Dr.

15:04 Veissiére, thank you.

15:06 I had a blast last season.

15:08 I think that the work we did and the things you showed

15:11 me related to our power-of-suggestion work together on placebos was so powerful.

15:17 Well, Michael, it's a real pleasure.

15:19 I'm honored to be here again.

15:21 It also is why you're the person I thought of for what I want to do next.

15:24 Building on the work we did last season,

15:27 I want to explore belief and what I can and cannot control.

15:33 I want to perform an accessory- assisted reverse exorcism.

15:39 Hmm.

15:39 Reverse exorcism because I'm not gonna tell you that you have a demon

15:43 in you or something in you that I'm gonna remove— you're fine.

15:46 What I can do is make you feel like you're losing control.

15:51 You would like to experimentally induce a spirit possession experience.

15:55 Right.

15:56 I like that.

15:57 All right, let's talk details here.

16:00 Are there things we can do to increase

16:03 the effectiveness of our reverse exorcism ritual?

16:08 Yeah.

16:08 I'm thinking we could probably use some tricks from hypnosis.

16:12 If we went them to have experiences,

16:14 we need to suggest those experiences to them specifically.

16:17 We would be using a lot of props from both

16:20 religion and science to get people's critical minds to relax,

16:23 and then we will throw in some suggestions.

16:26 So we've got religious iconography,

16:29 and we've got the paraphernalia of medical science.

16:33 Let's do this.

16:35 Michael: Almost everyone feels a certain

16:37 way in the presence of medical equipment,

16:39 and, even though not everyone observes the same religion.

16:42 Swiss psychologist Carl Jung posited that a person's belief in a religious

16:47 symbol wasn't necessary for it to exert an influence on them.

16:50 Consciously, they may say it doesn't, but unconsciously, it will.

16:55 With Dr.

16:56 Veissiére onboard, I had Mind Field's art department mock

16:59 up our lab with plenty of scientific and religious iconography.

17:09 Michael: With our lab dressed to Veissiére's specs,

17:12 everything is in place for our reverse exorcism.

17:16 Our five test subjects, pre-screened and vetted by a psychologist,

17:21 arrived at the facility thinking that they were going to take

17:23 part in a broad study on the science of religion.

17:28 Immediately, we exposed them to things that would convince them

17:31 of the seriousness of what they were about to do,

17:33 such as filling out extensive paperwork.

17:37 woman making announcement) Michael: And an extended period of time

17:41 in the waiting room to increase anticipation and tension.

17:45 We even used a fake participant to talk up

17:49 his amazing experience in earshot of the real subjects.

17:52 Woman: Hi.

17:53 Hi.

17:53 How was it?

17:54 That was crazy.

17:55 Yeah?

17:56 That was something else.

17:58 Michael: And to really sell the illusion,

17:59 we used multiple actors, like a fake receptionist,

18:03 a nurse to check the patient's vitals,

18:05 and a pretend priest to add credibility to the religious angle.

18:09 Dr.

18:10 Veissiére played the role of a scientist fascinated by the power of the ritual.

18:14 This should influence our participants,

18:16 because how could this all not be real if a guy

18:18 in a white lab coat is taking it so seriously?

18:21 So we are just about ready to begin.

18:23 Now, I'm watching hidden cameras that we have in the exam room adjacent to us.

18:28 Let's see what sorts of altered states of consciousness we can create today.

18:33 Now, this is Jeremiah, and Jeremiah's been waiting for about an hour.

18:37 Actor/Nurse: So I'm gonna be placing this on your head.

18:39 It's called an EEG cap, it just measures your brain activity.

18:46 This is a really important part of selling

18:48 the scientific realness of what we're doing.

18:51 Jeremiah, very pleased to meet you.

18:53 Thank you so much for coming.

18:55 Thank you so much again for your patience.

18:57 I think it's really important for Veissiére to talk

18:59 about how what's about to happen is special, it's not a normal ritual.

19:03 In fact, it's not a ritual that any lay people really know about yet.

19:06 So the name of the study, it's a bit of a mouthful,

19:08 so we're looking at neural correlates

19:10 and physiologic markers of ritually induced mystical experiences.

19:14 I have run this experiment about 30 times,

19:16 and some people enter some kind of encounter

19:20 with what they may call a divine presence.

19:23 Jeremiah: How's it goin'?

19:24 Michael: Here comes the priest.

19:25 I'm Jeremiah.

19:26 Nice to meet you, sir.

19:27 Father Callahan.

19:27 "Father Callahan," the Stephen King character.

19:30 OK, we might have to change that.

19:32 Actor/Priest: Jeremiah, what I'd like you to do...

19:35 is relax, and I'd like you just

19:39 to casually stare at the crucifix, in the center.

19:42 Michael: We had our "priest" guide Jeremiah through a holy

19:46 ritual which we told him was a thousand years old.

19:49 But in actuality, Dr.

19:50 Veissiére wrote it himself just before the demonstration.

19:55 Actor/Priest: And you may feel a tendency that you want to let

19:59 your hands raise towards the sky as your body falls away.

20:02 Michael: Getting someone to literally act possessed is

20:06 definitely a difficult test of the placebo effect,

20:09 so I'm not exactly sure what kind of results we can expect.

20:12 However, I'm at least hoping that we learn from this how

20:14 to better tap into the power of people's beliefs.

20:17 Actor/Priest: Whatever the spirit needs to speak, it will speak.

20:24 So now, as you keep relaxing, as the spirit prepares...

20:27 Jeremiah sat very still during the whole ritual,

20:30 but we were curious about what he experienced.

20:33 So what did that feel like?

20:34 Jeremiah: It was weird, but I could feel like the presence,

20:38 it's a little graphic, if some, like, cut my head off.

20:42 I didn't feel anything below.

20:45 Right.

20:45 Michael: People don't normally have feelings of decapitation and numbness,

20:49 so either we've stumbled upon a way to summon a spirit,

20:52 or our belief manipulation is working.

20:56 So we've been working together on this project,

20:57 and I was observing you from the other room.

21:00 And there are two really powerful kinds of symbols in the room.

21:03 Which one had the biggest kind of visceral effect on you?

21:06 I guess it was kind of a balance, because, like, OK, it's religious,

21:10 and the nurse comin' in, science— it kinda goes back and forth,

21:13 so I want to say "even." Well,

21:16 more has been going on than what you know at this moment.

21:20 Joe--Father Callahan— was not a priest.

21:23 Mm-hmm.

21:24 He's an actor, and everything that he read was written by Dr.

21:27 Veissiére.

21:27 We're looking at how a thing that has no known causal link

21:32 to any particular reaction or behavior

21:34 or feeling can nonetheless induce a feeling.

21:37 Michael: Jeremiah's experience was pretty curious,

21:41 and since nothing too serious happened— his head didn't spin

21:44 around— we felt more comfortable pushing things a bit further.

21:50 I'm the lead behavioral scientist in charge of the experiment,

21:52 this is my colleague Dr.

21:54 Stevens.

21:54 Michael: First, I interacted with the participants before the ritual,

21:58 to build up their expectation of something happening— like...possession.

22:03 So today, you will be listening to a reverse exorcism.

22:09 OK.

22:10 I'm already possessed.

22:11 I'm already possessed.

22:13 Michael: We also decided to dim the lights

22:15 to decrease their inhibitions and increase the atmosphere.

22:18 Michael: I think it's gonna be great

22:20 for our participants and for the whole mood.

22:21 I mean, it's spooky stuff.

22:23 Before you can fully experience the divine,

22:26 I'll simply just invite you to kind of relax...

22:29 Michael: And we decided to have Dr.

22:30 Veissiére lead the ritual instead of our "priest," so that he could

22:33 use his training in behavioral psychology to harness the power of suggestion.

22:38 The priest continued to serve as an important

22:40 religious anchor point for the subject to focus on.

22:42 Veissiére: All of your actions and reactions gradually fade

22:46 and disappear as your body is now approaching the divine.

22:51 You may notice...

22:53 your fingers tingling a little.

22:56 You may feel your mouth...

22:57 needing to tweak a little.

23:03 Her mouth is opening...

23:06 slowly.

23:07 As the divine tries to speak through you,

23:11 filling your mouth, perhaps, gently, ever so slowly.

23:17 You are now awake.

23:20 Good.

23:22 Michael: When the ritual ended,

23:24 each of our participants had something very interesting to report.

23:27 He did definitely have an aura around him— the Father.

23:31 Woman: I could feel just this everlasting joy and peace of God just covering me.

23:36 There was like a glowing figure, man,

23:40 and then the cross was like right in front of me.

23:43 We've got medical science and we've got ancient religious symbols.

23:49 And what we're specifically looking at is

23:52 how the accessories play into your expectations.

23:56 I liked the visual part.

23:57 I didn't like the audio part.

23:59 Interesting.

23:59 I wasn't connecting with it.

24:00 Woman 2: I've always thought that the kind of traditional,

24:03 ritualistic parts of church, they just never appealed to me.

24:06 I think it was more the symbols that was more comforting,

24:09 because that's just the way I was raised.

24:11 Michael: One of the most intriguing was our final subject, Miriam.

24:15 What was it like for you?

24:17 Um, I went to another place.

24:19 OK, OK.

24:20 I immediately felt my mother's— her spirit with me, she was telling me...

24:26 ...to come towards her.

24:27 OK.

24:28 And when I got close to her, she was comforting me.

24:31 OK.

24:31 Um, and I heard an angel say, "I'm here with you.

24:35 I will never leave you." And I continued to see wings.

24:41 Wings.

24:41 Interesting.

24:42 Yes.

24:42 Michael: Miriam's experience seemed to have a profound effect on her, but I

24:48 wanted to hear more about what exactly happened to her.

24:51 When you say that you saw things, describe for me what that was.

24:55 Was it like a daydream, or was it more like, um, really there?

24:59 It was extremely vivid.

25:01 Um, I could feel the wind when it started going across,

25:05 I could vividly see my mother standing there, smiling at me.

25:09 She looked beautiful.

25:10 Wow.

25:11 Michael: The fact that Miriam had

25:13 an out-of-body experience and saw her deceased mother,

25:16 was almost puzzling, because everything we did in the room was a lie.

25:21 The priest was not real, the ritual was not a thousand years old,

25:25 the nurse was an actress,

25:27 but yet Miriam's experience and those of the other participants were real.

25:32 The thing that surprised me the most

25:35 today was how personal every single moment was.

25:41 I think because of a combination of the powerful imagery,

25:45 both religious and scientific,

25:47 it becomes the most powerful experience they've had.

25:50 Even if you're a very staunch atheist,

25:52 a cross and a lectionary, these things, they're pregnant with meaning.

25:56 We seem to have found that by using those cues,

25:59 people were able to tune in very,

26:01 very deeply, and to relinquish their sense of self-control.

26:04 Here's a question.

26:06 What's the difference between what we did

26:09 today and what an actual priest can do?

26:15 That's a really controversial question.

26:18 Um, I think the difference is that, unlike the priest,

26:21 we understand the mechanisms through a more psychological route,

26:27 whereas many priests may themselves be convinced

26:30 that they are facilitating communication with the divine.

26:32 And perhaps they are.

26:34 The results can be the same, regardless of the intentions of the facilitators.

26:40 There's no way to prove whether or not God worked in this room today.

26:47 I guess ultimately, with the tools of science, no, there isn't.

26:50 These are still some really difficult philosophical questions.

26:58 Michael: So, we have demonstrated that our brains are belief-making machines.

27:04 Rather than accepting confusion and uncertainty,

27:08 we create superstitions and beliefs that make us

27:11 feel like we have control over our lives.

27:14 In fact, to not form a superstition or belief

27:18 or guess about the world around us is to be powerless,

27:22 even when superstitions are unconnected to reality.

27:26 That doesn't mean they can't be powerful.

27:29 Our "reverse exorcism" ritual and its practitioners were all placebos.

27:35 But the mere existence of our subjects'

27:38 beliefs in them made them real and transformative.

27:42 So does that make us all fools?

27:46 I don't know— but I don't believe so.

27:49 And as always...

27:51 thanks for watching.

Study with Looplines Download Captions Watch on YouTube