The LDL Theory Is Falling Apart — Focus on THIS Instead | Dr. Aseem Malhotra
Jesse Chappus
0:00 I trained as an interventional cardiologist.
0:01 I love solving puzzles.
0:03 When you've eliminated the impossible, whatever remains,
0:05 however improbable, must be the truth.
0:07 Guideline bodies still say that "LDL" cholesterol is
0:10 the primary causative risk factor for heart disease.
0:12 I'm coming here and saying, at best it's a weak risk factor,
0:15 at worst, it's not a risk factor at all.
0:17 Chronically raised insulin is directly toxic
0:19 to the inner lining of the coronary arteries,
0:21 which is how heart disease develops, the furrowing of the arteries,
0:24 this so-called plaque buildup,
0:26 these fatty deposits of immune cells and cholesterol,
0:28 which are likely arriving there as a response to injury,
0:31 not as the cause of the injury.
0:32 And therefore, the approach should be to try and manage the insulin resistance.
0:36 But from a drug perspective,
0:37 no drug has really been developed to show improved outcomes with that.
0:40 Two markers of the cholesterol profile which
0:42 I think are reflective of insulin resistance,
0:44 those are triglycerides and So these interventions
0:47 for lifestyle rapidly improve your metabolic health,
0:49 and mental and physical health too, within weeks.
0:51 Do it for six weeks.
0:52 You will see a difference at the end
0:54 of six weeks that will make you sustain it afterwards.
0:57 "Aseem," we've had major advances in cardiology over the years,
1:01 widespread use of statins.
1:03 Yet cardiovascular disease still remains the number one killer worldwide.
1:08 Why is this?
1:09 To answer your question directly,
1:11 "Jesse," it's because the benefits of statins are very, very marginal.
1:18 Essentially, if one looks at population data.
1:22 Certainly within Europe,
1:24 there was a study published in the "BMJ" a few years ago that looked at whether
1:29 millions more people being prescribed statins
1:31 in the population had any impact on cardiovascular mortality,
1:36 and they concluded it did not.
1:38 And one can explain that when you look at the fact
1:42 that from the randomized trials conducted by drug companies,
1:46 which, by definition,
1:48 are going to exaggerate the benefits because they are selected patients
1:52 and who are least likely to get side effects, et cetera.
1:57 The median increase in life expectancy over a five-year period,
2:01 even in the highest risk groups of people are
2:05 people who've had heart attacks is just over four days.
2:08 When you combine that with the fact that real-world
2:12 evidence tells us that even in-— those high-risk groups,
2:17 up to 50%, maybe more of those patients stop
2:19 taking their statins within a couple of years of prescription.
2:23 You can actually give a rational explanation for why statins
2:26 have not had an impact on cardiovascular mortality in the population.
2:30 So their benefits are very, very small when you look at population health,
2:35 and they are massively overprescribed because of the fact that both the doctors
2:39 and the patients have an exaggerated view of their benefits in their head.
2:44 Okay, given what you just said, is this starting to make a turn for the better?
2:48 Interesting...
2:49 Really good question.
2:50 I would have hoped so, "Jesse." And certainly pre-pandemic,
2:55 there was a shift I felt, in part because of the work of myself
2:59 and many other people in this space to highlight
3:02 this gross exaggeration of the benefit of statins
3:06 and the underappreciation of quality-of-life limiting side effects,
3:11 to the extent where, in 2015 or '16, if I remember correctly,
3:15 there was a U-turn on a recommendation that essentially everybody
3:20 over 50 should be prescribed statins from the General Practitioners Committee,
3:25 the Primary Care Physicians Committee,
3:29 who— partly because of a campaign in main part because
3:32 of a campaign I was part of to say, hold on.
3:35 Giving more people statins is ultimately going
3:37 to potentially have a negative effect on society because,
3:41 one, people at low risk don't get that much of a benefit.
3:45 It doesn't reduce mortality rates in that group.
3:48 Side effects are significant and will actually increase load
3:53 on primary care because of patients coming with side effects...
3:57 and also distraction from lifestyle, which we'll talk about later.
4:02 And there was a shift towards people becoming more aware of it.
4:06 But as I predicted, the people who have
4:10 the most power and control are essentially these big corporations,
4:14 these pharmaceutical companies,
4:17 whose primary motive is to make profit when the pandemic happened.
4:23 And the conventional narrative, we won't talk about that in any detail now,
4:27 but the conventional narrative was that Big Pharma
4:30 came and saved the day through their "COVID" vaccines.
4:33 I predicted that they would then capitalize
4:35 on that narrative by pushing their most lucrative drug,
4:41 which are cholesterol-lowering drugs, including statins.
4:44 So I'm now seeing more and more people coming to me who are being
4:47 told who otherwise wouldn't have been told
4:50 by their primary care physician in the US.
4:53 I see international patients through telehealth,
4:56 saying that they have been told,
4:58 they've been fear-mongered-— into going on a statin because of high cholesterol.
5:04 So, I haven't got the actual data
5:06 to see what's happening in prescription patterns,
5:09 but what I'm observing is an increased push now
5:11 to get more and more people on cholesterol-lowering drugs.
5:16 Okay, so we know they don't work very well.
5:18 We know that, as you quickly mentioned,
5:21 they can deter from adopting a diet and lifestyle
5:24 that could truly get to the root of this.
5:26 You mentioned side effects.
5:28 Let's go deeper into those and what people experience and how frequently.
5:33 Yeah, so in terms,— I'll reinforce
5:37 this so we don't get misquoted or misrepresented.
5:43 The side effects of statins are not life-threatening,
5:45 but they're quality-of-life limiting.
5:47 And actually, that's just as important, if not more important, for most people.
5:51 We're all going to die at some point, we want to have a good quality of life.
5:56 But those quality-of-life limiting side effects,
5:58 the most common are fatigue and muscle pain,
6:01 which we know mechanistically now is
6:04 probably because of statins causing mitochondrial dysfunction.
6:08 So— in my experience, "Jesse," I would say I see anything from 20 to 50%
6:14 of people at some point-— will experience a side effect from statins.
6:20 In terms of the true prevalence, that's an area of controversy.
6:26 Data does suggest anything from 10% up to 50%.
6:30 There are particular people who are more at risk of statin side effects,
6:34 which I cover in my book,
6:36 "A Statin-Free Life." And they include people who are over 70.
6:39 If you have a low body mass index,
6:41 if you do a lot of exercise, if you have a vitamin D deficiency.
6:46 Those are the types of groups of people that— are
6:50 more likely if you're of South Asian ethnic origin.
6:53 So there's a large group of people that are vulnerable to side effects.
6:58 The good news is they're reversible,
7:00 and people notice a difference from stopping the statin
7:03 or lowering the dose within a couple of weeks.
7:06 So if one isn't sure, one could just stop the statin for a while because
7:11 the benefits are so small over a long period of time,
7:14 they're essentially completely safe to stop.
7:17 Not that I'm advising people to do that without
7:20 talking to their doctor or making an appointment with me,
7:23 so a proper informed-consent discussion can happen.
7:27 But that's the general advice.
7:29 So far, our focus has been on the general healthy,
7:32 not healthy, but general person.
7:35 What about people with "FH?" They
7:37 have a genetic predisposition to high cholesterol.
7:41 Any statin advantage there?
7:43 Another really important group that we need to talk about.
7:46 So "FH," for people that don't know what that is,
7:49 is familial hypercholesterolemia.
7:51 It's a genetic condition which affects about 1 in 250 people.
7:56 And in those people,
7:57 they have genetically high "LDL," so-called bad cholesterol.
8:01 And that's usually at least above 190 milligrams per deciliter,
8:05 or in UK terms, 4.9 millimoles per liter.
8:10 And those people, on average,
8:12 tend to develop heart disease prematurely from original
8:15 data that we've seen over the years.
8:18 However, within that average increase in heart
8:23 disease prevalence in that group of people, they're not homogeneous.
8:28 There are different subgroups within those.
8:31 And just to give you some perspective.
8:35 70% of women and 50% of men with "FH" will not develop premature heart disease.
8:45 So we did research published in "BMJ" Evidence-Based
8:48 Medicine to try and see what was the defining
8:51 characteristics or risk factors of the groups that developed
8:55 heart disease with "FH" versus the ones that didn't.
8:58 What we found is, if you had no markers of insulin resistance,
9:01 if your insulin levels were low, and you had a normal waist circumference,
9:05 your risk of developing heart disease with "FH" was only slightly
9:09 higher than a healthy person with optimal metabolic health in the population.
9:14 We found there was no difference in the "LDL" levels between
9:17 the groups that got heart disease versus the ones that don't,
9:20 which again is another nail in the coffin for the "LDL" cholesterol,
9:23 heart disease-causing hypothesis.
9:25 But the one key difference was "Lp(a)."
9:28 So lipoprotein(a) seemed to be abnormal or high
9:31 in the people that developed heart disease
9:33 with "FH" versus the ones that didn't.
9:37 The conclusion is this, it's a nuanced approach.
9:40 One size doesn't fit all, and automatically,
9:42 people with "FH" shouldn't necessarily be going on statins at all.
9:46 Talk more about the "Lp(a)" piece in this respect and then beyond.
9:51 Well, in this respect,
9:53 I think we know that it's--— kind of a sub-fraction of "LDL." Interestingly,
9:57 when people's "LDL," there's lots of other data
10:00 about "LDL" not being causative in heart disease,
10:03 including when you exclude "Lp(a)" from the equation as being abnormal
10:07 as a sub-fraction of "LDL," as a type of "LDL" particle,
10:11 "LDL" is not a risk factor.
10:12 That's just one bit of data,
10:14 but there's also other data showing "LDL" isn't a risk factor.
10:18 When you correct for triglycerides and "HDL," "LDL"
10:20 is not a risk factor in my view,
10:23 or at worst is a minor risk factor, but effectively becomes irrelevant.
10:28 In other contexts, it's a really interesting one.
10:30 I see patients all the time who come to me
10:33 with this question about "Lp(a)." And certainly observational epidemiological
10:37 studies do show that as-— the higher the "Lp(a)"
10:40 goes the increase in your risk of a cardiovascular event.
10:45 But again, this is in a general population.
10:47 I'm not aware whether this has been studied in people with normal
10:50 triglycerides and "HDL." I'm not aware of a paper on that.
10:53 And it could be that it gets negated, and therefore we can ignore it.
10:57 But more important than that, "Jesse," is one
11:00 of the most important things we're taught in medical school,
11:04 which I think many doctors are losing sight of because
11:07 of a commercialized system which makes sense and is rational.
11:13 Don't organize a test unless it's going to change your management plan.
11:17 At the moment, we don't have any
11:20 data on outcome benefits of lowering "Lp(a)." Now,
11:26 low-carb diets apparently do lower "Lp(a)" and to different degrees.
11:31 But the question is what do we do with that other
11:34 than scare the patient saying they're at slightly higher risk?
11:39 So what we need is some good-quality data saying,
11:42 from a randomized trial, from an intervention, whether it's a low-carb diet,
11:46 whether it's a drug,
11:48 that when we gave patients with "Lp(a)" that was high this intervention,
11:52 we reduce cardiovascular events.
11:54 We don't have that data yet.
11:57 So bottom line, "Jesse," is it can be part of an assessment tool.
12:02 I think it's useful, but I think that we have to look at everything else.
12:07 Markers of insulin resistance, for example,
12:10 markers of chronic inflammation like high-sensitivity "CRP."
12:13 And then we paint a whole picture.
12:16 And then, of course, you've got calcium scores, which is great.
12:20 If you're over 50 as a male, over 50 as a female,
12:23 very well-validated test to tell you essentially whether
12:26 you've got any buildup of plaque in your arteries,
12:29 but also gives you a predictive score better than any other
12:32 test of a heart attack or stroke risk in the next decade.
12:36 So what I will do is then use all of this information,
12:39 and then you have a conversation with the patient
12:42 to make a plan around lifestyle essentially, and drugs if necessary.
12:46 But it's usually lifestyle.
12:48 You mentioned inflammation there, and I've heard you talk about statins,
12:53 the benefit there likely being
12:56 from their anti-inflammatory effect or anti-clotting.
12:59 Yes.
13:00 Bring that in.
13:01 Well, heart disease actually is more likely described as a chronic
13:04 inflammatory condition that is influenced
13:05 by clotting factors and insulin resistance.
13:08 So those are the three major inputs which have a slightly overlapping...
13:11 Because if you combat the insulin resistance, clotting actually gets better.
13:14 You combat the insulin resistance, the inflammation also gets better.
13:18 <break time=“2.72s"/> So...
13:21 in terms of the statins, yes.
13:25 Myself and two other cardiologists in 2021 published a systematic review
13:30 in "BMJ" Evidence-Based Medicine looking
13:32 at 35 randomized controlled trials using statins,
13:36 using some of the new injectable cholesterol-lowering drugs and ezetimibe,
13:41 which is a drug that stops the absorption of cholesterol into the bloodstream.
13:47 And we found there was no clear relationship
13:50 with lowering "LDL" cholesterol and preventing cardiovascular events,
13:55 which completely goes against our indoctrination as doctors,
13:59 as medical students, that the lower the "LDL," the better.
14:02 And of course, that information has come from biased research funding,
14:07 essentially, in my view.
14:09 So I think it's not an independent analysis, we did an independent analysis.
14:13 We could be wrong, but certainly we are not connected to the drug industry,
14:17 and this is what we found was peer-reviewed, et cetera,
14:19 and it does fit with the other data we've already talked about.
14:23 So therefore, yes, heart disease is more likely described
14:26 as a chronic inflammatory condition influenced by those factors.
14:30 And therefore anything that lowers inflammation
14:32 potentially could give you cardiovascular benefit.
14:35 Statins are the drugs that have been most tested
14:39 in randomized trials that give you that small benefit.
14:41 1 in 100 if you're high risk, primary prevention or low risk 1 in 83,
14:45 1 in 39, preventing a heart attack over
14:47 five years if you've had a heart attack already.
14:50 But what we do know about statins, is you're absolutely right,
14:53 they do have anti-inflammatory and anti-clotting properties,
14:56 which is likely where you get that small benefit.
14:58 I think at this point,
15:00 it's important to point out you are a cardiologist who bought into...
15:04 statins fully at one point in your career.
15:08 And now that you've had time to fully dig
15:10 into the research and dive deep for the truth here.
15:14 Only then has your position...
15:16 pivoted.
15:16 Yes.
15:17 Oh yeah, absolutely,
15:18 "Jesse." I was probably— I was a traditional follow the evidence,
15:24 which means I would read up on guidelines.
15:27 I was obsessed with patient outcomes.
15:29 And actually...
15:30 I remember when I worked as a junior doctor in Manchester where
15:35 I did my initial training before I started my subspecialization in cardiology,
15:40 I was the golden child of the-— junior doctors amongst the attendings,
15:45 because I was on it all the time with my drug prescriptions.
15:50 Even prescribing statins and to patients in the "ER" before they're about to go
15:54 to the cardiac catheter lab to have an angiogram for a suspected heart attack.
15:59 So that was me.
16:00 Absolutely.
16:01 And it was only through my clinical experience
16:03 over time and seeing patients coming in with...
16:06 what I was diagnosing as clear side effects that I
16:09 started to look into the data a bit more...
16:11 and realized that...
16:12 we've got this cholesterol hypothesis, very, very wrong.
16:16 Now, with your new perspective, if you were forced to...
16:20 flip the script and argue for statins.
16:24 Is there anything there?
16:25 I think it's about giving the right
16:28 patient the right treatment at the right time.
16:31 I would argue for informed consent and that's what I do with my patients.
16:36 So if a patient comes in...
16:37 the way to approach this, which is actually the gold
16:40 standard of ethical evidence-based medical practice and informed consent,
16:43 which by the way is not the default for 99.9% of doctors,
16:48 because we're not conditioned to explain information
16:51 to patients in the way they can understand...
16:53 that it's more honest and ethical in terms of the benefit of the drug is...
16:57 telling patients who are highest risk...
17:00 based upon industry.
17:01 So you also have to express uncertainties
17:03 in what we call shared decision making.
17:06 So I will say to a patient, and even in my letters,
17:10 I write this back to primary care physicians when...
17:12 they come see me as a specialist.
17:15 Based upon these words, based upon industry-sponsored data that has not
17:21 been independently verified and therefore likely best-case scenario...
17:25 in selected patients who didn't get side effects over a five year period,
17:30 taking a statin religiously every day will give you
17:33 a 1 in 39 benefit in preventing a heart attack...
17:36 and 1 in 83 benefit in delaying your death or saving your life.
17:42 That's before we even talk about side effects.
17:45 And by the way, the side effects,
17:47 the one clear one which is now accepted in literature.
17:49 1 to 2% of those patients will develop type 2 diabetes,
17:52 probably reversible, but still not ideal from taking a statin.
17:56 So that's the information I'll give to patients
17:58 and they will come back with an answer.
18:00 Now many of those patients just say, okay,
18:02 I'll take my chance, I'm high risk or whatever else.
18:05 But many say no.
18:06 They say, Doc, I don't fancy those odds.
18:07 Is there anything else I can do?
18:09 That is my approach rather than a black and white,
18:12 take a statin versus don't take a statin.
18:14 One thing I think it's important we point
18:17 out is absolute versus relative risk and how statistics...
18:22 can be manipulated for...
18:25 outcomes to look a lot better than they are.
18:28 Yes...
18:28 So in simple terms, if you look at a trial, let's just say for example,
18:34 you have a randomized trial, two groups of 100 people.
18:39 They're all matched for age, say they're middle aged men, all matched for age,
18:42 risk factors, et cetera, and you follow them up for five years.
18:47 In one group you give them the statin and the other group,
18:49 you give them a placebo, a dummy pill if you like.
18:52 The patients don't know what they're getting.
18:54 So it's what we call just to remove the chance of bias,
18:57 a double-blinded, randomized controlled trial.
18:59 You follow them up for five years.
19:01 In the group that took the placebo, essentially the dummy pill,
19:05 two out of 100 of those people who were followed up developed a heart attack.
19:10 And the people that took the statin, one of them developed a heart attack.
19:14 So,— the relative risk reduction is you've reduced the risk
19:18 of a heart attack by taking a statin by 50%.
19:21 Basically, one out of two over 100.
19:25 50% less likely to have a heart attack.
19:27 That's what we call relative risk reduction.
19:30 And people aren't told.
19:31 They're just told, if you come in as a patient,
19:34 if you take this pill, you're 50% less likely to have a heart attack.
19:38 It sounds great.
19:39 So in people's minds, it exaggerates the benefit of the pill,
19:42 but the actual true benefit is only one in 100.
19:44 You've had to treat 100 people with a statin for one of them to benefit.
19:48 You don't know who that one person is going to be.
19:50 And that's what you should be telling patients.
19:53 You should be saying your absolute risk reduction, or numbers needed to treat,
19:57 is one in 100, which means 99% chance
19:59 it's not going to give you any benefit whatsoever.
20:02 It's another way of looking at the statistics.
20:04 But patients are not told that.
20:06 And I think they're not told
20:08 that mainly because when patients are fully informed,
20:11 they choose less treatments, "Jesse." And that's not good for the drug industry,
20:16 who are essentially, in my view, a tyranny.
20:19 We're living in a corporate tyranny.
20:21 They have the most power.
20:22 They exert their power, not just to enhance their profits,
20:26 but if people challenge them or tell a greater truth or give
20:30 an alternative and I've been a victim of that, you "Google" me,
20:34 you'll find on my "Wikipedia" page, you'll see smears about me,
20:38 this is part of their modus operandi
20:41 to essentially discredit people like me if they can.
20:45 So that the narrative is continued along the lines of statins are life-saving,
20:52 cholesterol is a major risk factor for heart disease,
20:56 you've got to get it lower, etc, etc.
20:59 But it's not the truth, it's a manipulation.
21:03 Our job, my job as a doctor,
21:05 my duty is to improve my patient outcomes by practicing ethically to maintain
21:10 trust and for us to progress as a society for health purposes.
21:14 So, that's my line.
21:15 That's what I'm sticking to.
21:17 And to make it clear, you're not somebody who's saying don't take a statin.
21:22 You're just saying, I want to really look
21:24 at the research and find out the truth here.
21:27 Absolutely, 100%.
21:28 Well, given everything we've gotten into to this point,
21:32 we really got into the weeds on statins.
21:35 Let's zoom out, look at the macro
21:38 and talk about the 30,000-foot view of statins.
21:41 Yeah.
21:42 So, it's one of the most prescribed, lucrative drugs in the history of medicine.
21:50 It's estimated between 200 million and one
21:53 billion people globally are prescribed statins, "Jesse." And I can guarantee you
21:58 that the overwhelming majority of those patients,
22:01 if not all of them, don't know the true benefits and harms of the drug.
22:07 That's what we're talking about here.
22:08 This is not small fry.
22:09 This is a really big deal.
22:11 Okay, let's talk about heart disease now in a conventional sense.
22:17 How conventional doctors look at that disease forming in the body.
22:21 And then we're going to dip into your alternative view on the real cause.
22:26 Yeah, I think that the conventional view is still,
22:31 guideline bodies still say that "LDL" cholesterol is
22:34 the primary causative risk factor for heart disease.
22:38 I'm coming here and saying at best it's a weak risk factor,
22:41 at worst, it's not a risk factor at all.
22:45 So that's quite a jump.
22:46 <break time=“7.22s"/> My research,
22:54 what other people's research has shown,— not just based upon cherry-picking
22:58 one bit of data it's like looking at the totality of evidence.
23:02 It's not about selective reporting.
23:04 I think the people who are pushing this narrative
23:07 have engaged in selective reporting because of ideology,
23:13 because of a fixed view.
23:15 We've got to remember,
23:16 <break time=“1.85s"/> certainly amongst medicine, unfortunately,
23:20 changing one's mind can be quite difficult,
23:23 even though it's part of evolving science and good practice.
23:26 Just because we're human beings, that's part of being human.
23:31 What actually is at the root of heart disease, which has not been challenged,
23:35 it's just there's no market for the message is insulin resistance,
23:39 essentially your body becoming resistant to the hormone insulin over time.
23:44 Which we know, through different mechanisms,
23:47 is chronically raised insulin is directly toxic
23:50 to the inner lining of the coronary arteries,
23:53 which is how heart disease develops the furring of the arteries,
23:57 this so-called plaque buildup.
23:59 These fatty deposits of immune cells and cholesterol,
24:02 which are likely arriving there as a response to injury,
24:05 not as the cause of the injury and therefore building up these pimples,
24:10 or whatever you want to best describe it for a layperson,
24:13 within the inner lining of the artery.
24:17 And insulin resistance drives that.
24:20 And probably responsible, certainly some studies suggest that in 86% of people,
24:25 some degree of insulin resistance who've had heart attacks,
24:29 some degree of insulin resistance is there.
24:32 And therefore, the approach should be to try
24:35 and manage insulin resistance from a drug perspective.
24:40 No drug has really been developed to show improved outcomes
24:43 with that, but there is a lifestyle approach which we know is effective,
24:48 and that's basically, the very simple way of putting it is a low-carb diet.
24:52 Low-carb diet is the best-proven dietary intervention.
24:57 Any lifestyle intervention, actually,
24:59 to rapidly improve markers of insulin resistance, which include,
25:03 blood pressure, glucose through "HbA1c," which is
25:07 a marker of pre-diabetes or type 2 diabetes.
25:10 Two markers of the cholesterol profile,
25:12 which I think are reflective of insulin resistance those are
25:16 triglycerides and "HDL." So you want triglycerides to be low,
25:19 "HDL" to be high, so-called good cholesterol, and waist circumference,
25:23 that's your belly fat and your visceral fat.
25:26 And if all of those are in the normal range,
25:29 you have minimum insulin resistance, if not, normal levels of.
25:34 You're not insulin resistant and it's called optimal metabolic health.
25:39 And 93%...
25:41 of adult Americans now, "Jesse," have suboptimal metabolic health.
25:49 And what's interesting about metabolic health is it isn't
25:52 just the main driver of heart disease, it's also,
25:55 after smoking, the main driver of cancer,
25:58 and also the most important risk for developing Alzheimer's disease as well.
26:04 So it's important.
26:07 That's what we should really be focusing on with lifestyle.
26:10 And I think if we do that, we'll get better outcomes.
26:13 Now, why am-— I not guaranteeing better outcomes and saying it's most likely?
26:17 Is because we don't have the highest quality level
26:20 of evidence in terms of randomized controlled trial data,
26:23 saying that we'd intervened on insulin
26:24 resistance and we've followed those people up.
26:27 That hasn't been done as far as I know,
26:29 Might be studies ongoing because obviously that needs funding,
26:32 et cetera, et cetera.
26:33 So who's going to profit from that?
26:35 To tell people to avoid ultra-processed food and sugar,
26:39 eat steak and vegetables and improve your gut microbiome.
26:43 Who's going to benefit from that financially?
26:48 This is part of our screwed-up corporate capitalist system, unfortunately.
26:53 <break time=“3.94s"/> Medical knowledge is under commercial control,
26:59 but most doctors don't know that.
27:01 And that knowledge base amongst doctors is coming
27:04 from people producing products to sell you, essentially.
27:08 So if we zoom in on the vessel, you mentioned insulin resistance.
27:12 Yes.
27:13 So we have elevated blood glucose, causes elevated insulin.
27:16 Yes.
27:16 Yeah.
27:17 When it comes to that micro-damage in the vessel,
27:21 is it both of those that are causing it?
27:24 Great question.
27:24 Probably, yes.
27:26 Interestingly, when I did my research during "COVID" because I wrote
27:29 a book called "The 21-Day Immunity Plan," and I did a lot
27:33 of work being an advocate to try and understand what were the lifestyle
27:36 risk factors for "COVID." One of the most interesting papers I found,
27:40 again, it's mechanistic, but it's interesting.
27:43 Is that one high-starch or glucose meal or sugary meal.
27:51 So, raised insulin and glucose, independently they affected markers of clotting.
27:56 So, glucose raised on its own without raised
28:00 insulin interferes with clotting in an adverse way,
28:03 it increases the clottability of the blood.
28:06 And the same thing happens with raised insulin.
28:10 So I think it's probably both.
28:12 There are multiple mechanisms.
28:13 Insulin, for example,
28:15 raised insulin will cause <break time=“1.88s"/> the first cell to be affected
28:20 on the inner lining of the arteries is called the endothelial cell.
28:24 So dysfunction of the endothelial cell,
28:26 which produces something called nitric oxide, which helps dilate the vessel.
28:30 And if the vessels are not able to expand or dilate,
28:33 they're also more likely to get stiff and more likely to get damaged.
28:37 The endothelial dysfunction is the beginning
28:39 of coronary artery disease developing.
28:42 And those are those things you've talked about,
28:45 including smoking, including chronic stress, which we'll come onto.
28:49 The other interesting thing that a lot of people don't know about,
28:53 "Jesse," is this clogged pipe hypothesis is they
28:56 think that heart disease is gradually progressive over time,
29:00 and then it becomes you get,
29:01 and over time it becomes completely blocked and then you have a heart attack.
29:06 That isn't actually what happens.
29:07 Number one, it's not chronically progressive necessarily.
29:11 It's actually, dynamic and it can reverse,
29:13 which I'll explain a little bit later.
29:15 So please remind me about that.
29:18 But the other interesting thing is most heart
29:22 attacks happen at-— blockages that are not severely narrowed.
29:26 A severe narrowing is considered about 70% blocked.
29:30 That's physiological,
29:31 that when— the demand on the heart muscle increases from exercise,
29:36 that's when the— blood supply doesn't meet the demands of the heart
29:41 muscle in terms of oxygenation when the vessel is more than 70% blocked.
29:45 And that's when people get what we call angina, chest pain.
29:50 But...
29:51 the blockages that are likely to rupture,
29:53 like pimples bursting, and cause a complete blockage,
29:56 which causes a heart attack where the blood
29:58 supply is completely reduced for several minutes,
30:00 and then you get damage to the heart muscle,
30:03 which is a heart attack, essentially.
30:05 86% of those plaque ruptures causing the heart
30:09 attack happen at blockages at less than 70%.
30:13 And that's probably one of the main reasons why heart stents...
30:17 And I trained as an interventional cardiologist,
30:19 essentially keyhole heart surgery,
30:21 putting in these little metal scaffolds and expanding
30:24 them in the artery where the blockages are.
30:28 Those stents do not prevent heart attacks in people
30:30 who have what we call stable disease, stable angina.
30:33 So blockages over 70, 80, 90%.
30:36 Because one, that blockage that's 90% is not
30:39 the most likely to cause a heart attack.
30:41 Two, you're disrupting the vessel when you actually put the stent
30:44 in, and that causes a heart attack in maybe 1% of people.
30:48 And then you're ignoring; you're not managing where another plaque,
30:51 which might be 20 or 30%.
30:53 And putting a stent in there doesn't do any benefit either, anyway.
30:56 You wouldn't do that because you're going to cause complications
30:59 of the procedure overall if you
31:01 start stenting people with a non-significant blockage,
31:04 and you don't know which one's going to rupture anyway.
31:07 Those are the plaques that cause the heart attacks.
31:11 So what we need to do is, and this is what I've written about,
31:14 is we institute a lifestyle approach which
31:16 is likely to pacify all of those plaques
31:19 and potentially reverse them and reduce the risk of a heart attack occurring.
31:23 Okay, so far, what we have insulin resistance causing the pimples in the vessel.
31:28 Yep.
31:29 We can get rupture, more likely in the smaller ones.
31:33 Do we know what actually triggers that rupture?
31:36 We don't.
31:36 It's like a ticking bomb.
31:39 It's something that just builds up over time.
31:41 But things like stress can trigger it, for sure.
31:44 A lot of people suffer a heart attack after a life event,
31:48 so it could be that there's this and then suddenly a stressful event.
31:52 A high-carb, sugary meal theoretically could,
31:55 as we've talked about, increasing the clotability of the blood.
31:59 So I think those are the kind of things that will trigger it, for sure.
32:05 One of the things the body does as it incurs blockages is forms collaterals.
32:12 Talk about this safety mechanism that our body uses.
32:15 Yeah, so actually it's a great point because as I talked about earlier,
32:19 there was a thinking that these clogged pipes develop over time
32:23 and then you get 100% blockage and then you get a heart attack.
32:26 That rarely happens.
32:27 If it's increasing slowly,
32:29 if that blockage is occurring over time slowly and it doesn't rupture,
32:34 becomes a stable plaque.
32:36 What happens is the heart adapts and there
32:39 are extra vessels that grow to bypass that blockage.
32:42 And I've done angiograms in patients, for example,
32:45 that have got a complete block, no heart attack.
32:48 A complete blockage of one of their three major arteries.
32:51 There are three major sort of arteries the left anterior descending,
32:55 the circumflex, and the right coronary artery.
32:57 And I've seen people with right coronary arteries completely blocked,
33:00 but the left anterior descending has got an extension
33:03 to it that overcomes the blockage of the right coronary artery.
33:06 And those are collateral vessels.
33:07 And that's fascinating to see.
33:10 They'll probably give some protection to those people.
33:14 But you can't predict.
33:15 You can't predict necessarily.
33:17 We don't know how do you increase collateral flow.
33:21 But it's just like an adaptation mechanism for some people.
33:25 The key thing is to avoid heart disease in the first
33:27 place and then potentially reverse it or manage the risks.
33:29 Well, let's jump into reversal.
33:32 Somebody's developing these pimples, either small, large.
33:36 At that point, what's the best they can do to reverse that?
33:40 In my patients, in general terms, "Jesse," I look at four things.
33:46 I look at the diet.
33:48 So we get them on a diet that's anti-inflammatory, low-carb.
33:52 Because part of the puzzle of heart disease is chronic inflammatory...
33:55 And looking at the best data we have,
33:57 I know nutrition science isn't great, but the best available evidence.
34:01 And that's why I write about in my book,
34:04 it comes from some benefits, clearly from the traditional Mediterranean diet.
34:09 So it's extra virgin olive oil, it's oily fish,
34:12 and the omega-3s from that, it's polyphenols from non-starchy vegetables.
34:18 It's nuts and seeds, and it's minimizing the starch and the sugar.
34:22 So I call it a low-carb Mediterranean diet.
34:25 That's my first-line approach, from a diet perspective.
34:30 It's not being sedentary.
34:31 I think we've overdone the exercise story.
34:33 I think a lot of that's come from the food industry as well,
34:35 from "McDonald's" and "Coca-Cola," the biggest promoters of exercise,
34:38 so they can deflect from their bad diet that they're promoting.
34:42 If you look at these communities with high longevity,
34:45 these people weren't pounding it in the gym,
34:48 they were just outside, essentially, they were walking.
34:51 I think walking is underrated, massively.
34:53 I think walking is a phenomenal way
34:55 of keeping the circulation going without overstraining your body.
35:00 Because, on exercise, by the way, let me just briefly talk about this.
35:04 This gets a lot of eyebrows raised,
35:06 and a lot of people ideologically don't want to accept it.
35:09 And these are especially the people who are--— "OCD" about exercise.
35:13 And you're talking to a guy that is guilty of this myself,.
35:17 I've overtrained, I've caused injuries because I have been.
35:21 My day is not complete unless I've worked out,- I'm that kind of guy.
35:25 My ex-wife used to complain that we were on vacation,
35:29 I was getting out of bed early to go to the gym.
35:32 I'm that guy.
35:33 So I get it.
35:34 It's like a drug,- working out in many ways.
35:37 In fact, that's one of the reasons I do it,
35:39 I think it's great for mental health.
35:41 But you can overdo it.
35:43 And actually,-— one bit of information came to me
35:46 from one of the top sports science cardiologists in the country.
35:51 A letter, and I was like, oh, this is so interesting.
35:55 I haven't been able to look at that specific data, I'm sure it's there.
35:59 But in essence, he said something along the lines of the 11% of elite
36:04 athletes— by the time they hit 50 will have calcium scores over 1,000,
36:09 "Jesse."- Their event rates may be lower,
36:13 but they've developed coronary artery disease.
36:15 And it makes sense to me that if you are training really hard,
36:18 especially with under-recovery and high stress,
36:21 it's probably very, very bad for your heart.
36:23 So I just say keep the exercise simple, keep it moderate.
36:26 If you can do two 30-minute brisk walks a day, amazing.
36:30 Even one 30-minute brisk walk a day is really good,
36:32 walking the dog, for example.
36:33 Great.
36:34 Yeah, add in a bit of resistance training as well,
36:36 good for your joints as you get older, et cetera.
36:39 From a heart disease point of view, I don't think there's any clear data
36:43 that is dose-dependent once you hit moderate exercise.
36:46 Definitely better than being sedentary.
36:49 But once you hit moderate regular exercise,
36:51 I don't think there's any strong data,— and we know that from Olympic athletes,
36:56 <break time=“2.24s"/> elite athletes, from ex-Olympians.
37:01 Elite athletes don't live any longer than people who play golf,
37:05 for example, or cricket.
37:06 So just giving some perspective there.
37:11 The third component...
37:12 well, of course the fourth,— still important to mention is smoking.
37:16 I used to mention on the ward rounds to patients,
37:18 this is true stopping smoking after a heart attack has much greater impact
37:22 in preventing a further heart attack than all the medications we give people,
37:26 including aspirin, et cetera.
37:28 So if you're a smoker,
37:29 and within five years of stopping smoking if you're middle-aged,
37:32 your risk of a heart attack becomes the same
37:34 as someone that's never smoked in their entire life.
37:37 So that's a very powerful intervention for smokers.
37:41 And then,— one that is maybe the most important that is missed is stress.
37:48 Chronic stress, to a reasonable level,
37:51 and I know it's subjective is the equivalent of smoking
37:54 20 cigarettes a day when it comes to heart disease.
37:58 And most-— people are not dealing with it.
38:00 I know this all the time because, invariably,
38:02 every patient I see that comes to me
38:04 with a diagnosis of raised calcium score or heart disease,
38:07 or have had a heart attack, all of them, in the preceding five years,
38:11 have had stress levels that have been at least a six or seven out of ten.
38:17 And what's the mechanism, though.
38:18 This wasn't very well understood.
38:20 We kind of knew stress wasn't good, but it wasn't very well explained.
38:24 And the mechanism is likely chronic inflammation,
38:26 and it can even be explained from an evolutionary perspective.
38:29 So tens of thousands of years ago, we're in the jungle,
38:35 acute stress is life-saving when we're escaping from a saber-toothed
38:41 tiger,- because we need to get the hell out of there.
38:46 And acute stress in that sense, what we know physiologically what happens is it
38:53 increases clotting factors and inflammatory factors in the blood,
38:57 so that if we're attacked, the risk of us bleeding to death becomes reduced.
39:04 Now imagine that chronically turned on at a low grade,
39:07 and that's probably the mechanism of how it contributes to heart disease.
39:11 But this is where the reversal comes in, if
39:14 you're happy for me to mention it now, "Jesse." Please.
39:18 Is that the best available evidence of reversal,
39:20 I write about in my book, "A Statin-Free Life" comes from India.
39:24 And...
39:25 this was called the "Mount Abu
39:26 Healthy Heart Study," something along those lines.
39:31 It's a long name for the title of the paper.
39:34 I actually met the cardiologists that did this study,
39:37 and he started it in the early 2000s.
39:39 There were no statins involved.
39:41 And these were patients that came to him who had
39:45 moderate to significant heart disease diagnosed from the gold standard test,
39:49 which is a coronary angiogram, an invasive coronary angiogram.
39:54 And they had at least a 50 to 70% blockage in multiple areas of the heart.
39:58 They didn't want to have a coronary artery bypass operation.
40:01 They didn't want to have stents either from a preference point of view,
40:06 an ideological we want to avoid medical intervention,
40:09 or because they couldn't afford it.
40:11 So he put them on this lifestyle plan.
40:13 There were hundreds of patients in middle age, and...
40:17 they were devout Hindus.
40:19 And so their diet plan was actually a high fiber,
40:23 more than 50 grams a day of high fiber,
40:26 vegetarian diet, not vegan but vegetarian.
40:30 It was two 30-minute brisk walks a day
40:33 and something called Raj Yoga meditation for 40 minutes.
40:37 Two years later, he repeats the angiograms.
40:41 Extraordinary findings.
40:43 Literally at the time, unbelievable.
40:45 And if you tell this to most cardiologists, they would say it's not possible.
40:49 They've never seen anything like this.
40:51 I actually had to go to India to see
40:52 for myself these angiograms and meet the guy.
40:54 And it was real.
40:55 These were genuine.
40:56 On average, of the people that had adhered to the lifestyle plan,
41:00 there was about a 20% reduction, "Jesse," in the blockages, which is unreal.
41:05 70% became 50, 50 became 30.
41:07 There was also lower event rates as well.
41:10 Which obviously is important,
41:12 so less hospitalizations with angina, heart attacks, etc.
41:17 And then when he did a multivariate analysis, so trying to dig out.
41:22 <break time=“3.28s"/> Was there any independent factor
41:27 of the lifestyle intervention that reversed heart disease?
41:33 And the only independent factor,
41:35 significantly that was associated with— reversing the blockages
41:40 was 40 minutes of Raj Yoga meditation a day.
41:43 Now, that isn't just meditation.
41:45 What he did in this ashram, essentially this place in India, Mount Abu,
41:49 which by the way, if anybody wants
41:50 to go and visit this place, it's extraordinary.
41:53 It's actually free, it's paid for by charities.
41:56 So people basically go there and they live in this ashram for seven days.
42:00 They take family members with them and, it's
42:03 essentially these lectures to explain these Raj Yoga meditation.
42:06 But it's a way of thinking,
42:08 it's almost like a spiritual awakening to reduce anger.
42:10 What's driving your anger, family members involved to support you.
42:14 Why?
42:15 Because again, it's a mindset as well
42:18 as the breathing techniques that are adopted.
42:20 And that's what he did.
42:22 And it has plausible biological mechanism.
42:27 Okay, so 40 minutes a day.
42:29 Do you know specifically what that period of time looked like?
42:32 I think it was a mixture, it could be 20/20 or 40 minutes in one go.
42:36 But what kind of meditation?
42:38 Do you know what they were doing?
42:39 Yeah, well, it was a meditation essentially where you sit and you think
42:45 and you're with your thoughts and you are trying to reduce anger and anxiety.
42:50 There is a breathwork technique as well, which I incorporate,
42:54 which is part of the Raj Yoga, but it's a form of diaphragmatic breathing.
43:00 And I work with a cardio specialist nurse that teaches patients how to do that.
43:04 But essentially, I do it every morning for 20 minutes.
43:07 And it's been shown and proven it's the best evidence-based
43:10 breathing technique for improving cardiovascular
43:12 parameters like blood pressure, heart rate.
43:16 <break time=“2.38s"/> And I think that's essentially the best people can do.
43:21 I myself, "Jesse," still haven't gone.
43:23 I need to do the course because by the way, you might have it in the States.
43:27 People can look it up, they're all over America.
43:30 You need to look for these Raj Yoga meditation centers
43:33 and basically go there and essentially it's just a week.
43:36 You get trained up in a week.
43:37 I haven't had time to do it yet, but I will at some point.
43:41 Okay, so far in the research then, for reversal of plaque,
43:46 this is the only way we've seen it done?
43:48 Yeah, as far as we know there is the "Dean Ornish" study on the vegan diet.
43:56 But the only thing with that is there's
43:58 a big margin of error when you're interpreting angiograms,
44:01 looking at plaque regression.
44:03 And if I remember correctly and I think "Dean's"
44:06 done a lot of amazing work with the multiple lifestyle.
44:10 And I don't think they differentiated all the different
44:12 components in terms of what was driving it, but it was about 1.3% or something.
44:17 Now, what's interesting is the cholesterol "LDL," again in the Mount Abu
44:22 Heart Study did not show any
44:24 independent association with lowering that with reversal.
44:26 So again, it's more evidence that it's not the "LDL" cholesterol,
44:30 and it almost certainly isn't the vegetarian or vegan diet per se.
44:34 Maybe the fact that it's an otherwise healthier diet
44:37 because you're not eating lots of ultra-processed food and sugar,
44:41 although there was a reasonable amount of starch in there,
44:44 albeit very high fiber.
44:47 It was quite clear from his own analysis
44:49 in that paper that it wasn't the vegan diet, the vegetarian diet,
44:53 basically from not "Dean Ornish's" study but the other
44:56 one and even "Dean Ornish's" study didn't show, as far as I remember.
45:00 And "Dean," forgive me if I'm wrong here,
45:02 but it's been a while since I looked at that paper.
45:05 But I remember there wasn't a clear independent association
45:08 with lowering "LDL" from that diet plan and the improvements.
45:12 Okay, so when it comes to the meditation, they were able to show a reversal.
45:17 How quickly did that happen?
45:18 Oh, well, they repeated the angiograms in two years,
45:21 and then they did it again at five years, and it was sustained.
45:23 Okay.
45:24 have they ever been able to continue
45:25 long-term to see if they would completely reverse?
45:28 I saw something.
45:29 I don't think they did any more angiograms after that, "Jesse." Okay.
45:34 Somebody wanting to be really practical with what we talked about here,
45:38 the stress reduction piece, the potential there for reversal.
45:41 What's the easiest way for them to jump into this at home?
45:44 Probably go on "YouTube," first of all,
45:47 and look up Raja Yoga meditation and look up diaphragmatic breathing.
45:51 Tthat would be a free way, an easy way.
45:54 I always think it's better to see a practitioner,
45:57 but if you can learn it from "YouTube" and follow it, then great.
46:00 I think at home, you basically have to just eliminate all ultra-processed foods,
46:05 which is anything packaged that has five or more ingredients,
46:09 usually with additives or preservatives and sugar free,
46:13 so no juice, no candy, no potato chips.
46:17 The way to do this, if you're going, depends where you're starting from.
46:21 But I would say you do this for six weeks
46:23 cold turkey to break the addiction to starch and sugar,
46:26 and then you can maybe modify things.
46:28 But it also depends where you're starting from, "Jesse," as well.
46:32 If-— you've just got one metabolic health marker
46:35 and you're otherwise slim and you're moderately active,
46:37 you may not need to go that extreme.
46:39 So it depends where you're starting from.
46:41 But just eating a healthier diet already is going to make a big difference.
46:45 Sticking with the diet piece,
46:47 somebody wanting to jump right in and take this to the extreme.
46:51 We have ketogenic, we have carnivore, you're a fan of low carb.
46:55 How do you feel about pushing it to the other side of the spectrum?
47:00 Listen, ketogenic is fine.
47:01 Essentially,— when you're doing this for six weeks,
47:03 you're probably going to be in a ketogenic diet anyway.
47:07 For me personally, I did this for a couple of years.
47:10 The only thing I would find,
47:12 my metabolic markers got better and it may have been a stress thing as well,
47:17 but I found that for me personally,
47:19 "Jesse."- And I don't eat processed carbs and it's very high fiber.
47:23 Because I work out, I found that my resistance training was a bit harder.
47:27 So I will eat high fiber porridge
47:29 in the morning with berries and nuts and seeds,
47:32 etc., but only have the carbs in and around the workout.
47:36 And then I— essentially avoid it the rest of the time.
47:40 So it depends where you're starting from.
47:42 I was already slim, etc.
47:43 So for people that are already overweight, got belly fat,
47:46 then it probably isn't going to be an issue for them.
47:48 When I asked patients, how did you feel in your workouts when you went keto?
47:52 And they were like, no, it was great.
47:53 I was like, that's interesting because I had an energy slump.
47:56 They didn't.
47:56 So again, it varies from person to person in terms of keto is fine.
48:00 And I think what you find is the worse the metabolic syndrome the markers
48:04 of poor metabolic health the more extreme you need to go with the diet.
48:10 So I would say keto would probably be right for them.
48:12 When it comes to carnivore, that's an interesting one.
48:15 I'm not averse to carnivore.
48:16 I'm great friends with "Shawn Baker," I know "Paul Saladino," I know
48:20 "Anthony Chaffee." These are the big names pushing the carnivore diet out there.
48:23 And I've seen a lot of patients who've
48:25 felt that their autoimmune conditions have got better, which is fascinating.
48:29 I think that's a really interesting area of research.
48:32 From a heart disease perspective,
48:35 I think that the only thing I would say is the carnivore
48:38 diet doesn't necessarily fit with the anti-inflammatory
48:41 component of the-— nuts and, well,
48:43 not the nuts and seeds, but the non-starchy vegetables for example.
48:47 And— carnivore, it tends to be higher in saturated fat,
48:50 which I obviously busted that myth of saturated fat and heart disease.
48:55 But there was an interesting paper by "Ronald Krauss," who's— one
48:58 of the gurus behind saying that saturated fat isn't a big deal,
49:02 where they found in a subset of people,
49:04 if your saturated fat intake was more than 18% of calories
49:08 so very high saturated fat levels it actually caused atherogenic dyslipidemia.
49:12 It raised triglycerides,
49:13 and I've seen a few patients like that, which is very interesting.
49:18 Not most patients, but a few.
49:20 So in those people, I always say the default is...
49:23 reduce go more...
49:25 olive-oil-based as your base fat,
49:27 and then I'm not too fussed about what else you eat.
49:30 What are your thoughts on seed oils?
49:33 A lot of talk in our world about these, traditionally
49:36 doctors recommending them to bring "LDL" down, which they do.
49:40 I know.
49:41 Talk about your thoughts conventionally what I just shared there
49:46 about the "LDL" piece and then how you see them,
49:49 because there's other people saying they're
49:52 part of the driver of insulin resistance, which again is driving heart disease.
49:57 So a lot of different connections.
50:00 Yeah.
50:01 First of all, we can say without a shadow of a doubt
50:03 that any dietary approach to lowering "LDL" has failed to curb heart disease.
50:07 So that's one thing.
50:09 Is it harmful?
50:09 There is at least one study showing the Sydney Heart Study,
50:14 and I think there was another study, the Minnesota study, if I'm not wrong.
50:18 "Ancel Keys" did unpublished data,
50:20 showed the people that lowered through dietary they
50:23 used some sort of safflower oil, margarine, I think.
50:25 But the people in the intervention
50:27 group who lowered for heart attack patients...
50:30 who lowered their...
50:31 cholesterol from this approach had higher mortality, cardiovascular mortality...
50:35 and probably through the mechanism of being pro-inflammatory.
50:40 So I think it's harmful.
50:42 Are seed oils harmful when not heated?
50:44 Probably less so.
50:45 I think they're definitely toxic when they're used for frying purposes.
50:52 And we know they produce these...
50:54 aldehyde compounds, which are carcinogenic and linked to Alzheimer's.
50:59 So...
50:59 I would say...
51:00 avoid as much at all cost if you can.
51:03 Seed oils.
51:04 Absolutely.
51:05 Overall, you're not a fan of lowering "LDL." But there's
51:09 also talk in dividing "LDL" into small dense and large fluffy.
51:14 Any value in looking there, or any problems with the small dense specifically?
51:17 No.
51:17 I know, I think this is.
51:18 Yeah, I think.
51:19 I think there's over-investigation again,
51:21 just people paying extra money for no reason,
51:24 because I think that your triglycerides and "HDL" are
51:26 basically a marker of your "LDL" particle size anyway...
51:29 So what are you going to do about it?
51:31 Don't order a test unless it's going to change your management plan.
51:34 The other interesting thing as well, "Jesse," which we didn't mention,
51:38 research we found it still throws a few people off.
51:40 But again, another reason you can
51:42 say lowering "LDL" doesn't prevent heart disease.
51:45 But what's the harm?
51:46 Well, there is a potential harm...
51:48 because we know that from observational data,
51:50 the higher "LDL" when you hit over-— 60, the longer you live.
51:54 Because "LDL" is probably involved in the immune system and likely
51:59 has some benefit in being protective against cancer and infection.
52:03 So I think there is a potential harm to lowering "LDL," actually.
52:07 What about oxidized "LDL?" Just for completeness...
52:10 bring that in.
52:11 Well, that's.
52:12 Yeah, that's just the postulated mechanism of how "LDL" can
52:17 maybe cause injury to the inner lining of the arteries.
52:22 And that again, links to "LDL's" interaction with sugar.
52:25 So it still comes-— back to triglycerides
52:27 and "HDL." Once your triglycerides and "HDL" have normalized,
52:31 then you're essentially eliminating the oxidized "LDL" in most cases.
52:36 So it's an academic thing more than anything else.
52:39 You've brought up calcium scores, angiograms.
52:42 Let's go into different forms of testing and where those might be beneficial.
52:48 Yeah.
52:48 So I think I try to keep it simple.
52:51 Unless there's somebody got very unexplained symptoms or they
52:54 develop heart disease prematurely and you haven't got an idea,
52:57 then I wouldn't go in any.
52:58 I'd keep it very simple.
53:00 Your basic fasting cholesterol profile triglycerides,
53:03 "HDL," total cholesterol, "LDL." Although to be honest,
53:06 you probably don't need to measure "LDL" and total cholesterol,
53:09 it's just for interest's sake.
53:11 That's what we want to look at.
53:13 And your triglycerides should be...
53:15 And you'll have to help me here a little bit, "Jesse." I'm trying to remember.
53:20 I think in the US terms, it's less than 150 mg per deciliter.
53:25 In the UK, it's less than 1.7 millimoles per liter.
53:29 I think that's the equivalent.
53:31 And your "HDL" should be above.
53:35 Again, if I'm not wrong, in the US units, it's more than 50, but...
53:40 you can calculate it.
53:41 For the UK, it's more than 1 millimole per liter.
53:44 Ideally, you want your triglycerides less than your "HDL."
53:47 So the ideal way of looking at it when
53:49 you convert to millimoles is triglycerides are less than
53:52 "HDL." And if your ratio is more than 4,
53:54 that's at your highest risk, and less than 1 is lowest risk.
53:57 So that's what you want to measure there from the cholesterol profile.
54:02 And then the blood tests I would recommend
54:05 is "HbA1c," to make sure you're not pre-diabetic.
54:07 So you want your "HbA1c" to be less than 5.7%.
54:10 From 5.7 to sort of 6 is considered pre-diabetic,
54:15 or 6.5, and then above 6.5 is type 2 diabetic.
54:19 But these are all reversible or improvable.
54:24 I would measure blood pressure.
54:27 And blood pressure ideally should be less than 120 over 80.
54:32 Between 120/80 up to 140 over 90 is what we call pre-hypertension.
54:38 And your risk starts to increase gradually
54:40 for stroke as that increases, and heart attack.
54:43 And then you want to measure your waist circumference.
54:46 But actually, rather than getting into the weeds about actual what measurements,
54:50 I think a very useful tool is your waist
54:53 circumference should be less than half of your height.
54:57 So if you're 180 cm tall, just under six foot,
55:01 you want your waist circumference at the belly
55:03 button to be less than 90 centimeters.
55:08 And if all those are normal,
55:10 I think you're in great shape from a heart disease perspective.
55:14 Talk to the angiogram, coronary calcium score, stress tests,
55:19 some of these advanced tests that people might be getting.
55:22 Yeah.
55:23 So...
55:23 let's start with stress tests.
55:25 So traditionally, let's take a step back first and foremost.
55:30 A good doctor makes his diagnosis mainly from the history,
55:37 and that is a conversation with the patient.
55:40 A bad doctor orders tests without speaking
55:43 to the patient or taking a good history.
55:47 Let's start there.
55:48 And the reason for that is 80% of the diagnosis,
55:50 "Jesse," comes from the conversation.
55:53 The symptoms the patients are describing,
55:56 there are certain patterns that have been recognized over decades at least,
56:01 but centuries that fit with the likelihood of a disease process.
56:05 When it comes to heart disease...
56:07 And we'll get on to explaining where the stress test would be helpful.
56:11 The classic symptoms are of angina, of a blockage, not an acute heart attack.
56:17 And acute we'll just talk about acute heart attack, actually.
56:20 So this is where people should be worried.
56:24 An acute heart attack is classically a central heaviness
56:27 or crushing feeling lasting for more than 10 minutes,
56:33 associated with sweating, sometimes radiating,
56:36 traveling up into the neck or into the shoulders.
56:40 And that is a red flag, and that is when you call 911.
56:44 All right?
56:46 A milder form of that is what we call angina,
56:48 which is a patient comes in and they
56:49 say when they're doing exercise or they're stressed,
56:51 they feel the same tightness or squeezing in the center
56:53 of the chest not on the left, not on the right.
56:56 It's a tightness or heaviness, and it's then relieved by rest.
56:59 And those, depending on how severe and how often they are coming...
57:04 That's when you would potentially do a stress test.
57:06 Sometimes you do a stress test if people have atypical symptoms,
57:09 a sharp pain, a stabbing pain isn't necessarily in the center.
57:13 And that's when stress tests become helpful as an exclusionary tool.
57:19 The traditional test would have been an exercise treadmill test.
57:23 You get an "EKG," put people on the treadmill, you get them walking briskly,
57:29 getting their heart rate up to what we call 80% of maximum target heart rate.
57:34 So that's 220 minus your age and 80% of that.
57:39 So if you are 40 years old, for example, 220 minus your age is 180.
57:44 80% of that is.
57:47 Let's figure 18 times 8.
57:49 So it's 180 divided by 10 times by 8.
57:53 So 18 times 8...
57:55 64 plus 80 is 144.
57:57 So I just did in my head.
57:59 So you want your heart rate to get up to over 144
58:02 and you not get chest pain and the "EKG" to be normal,
58:05 not show changes, what would be the different changes you look for?
58:09 ST depression, for example.
58:10 So that is a positive treadmill test, which would suggest a significant...
58:14 blockage of over 70%,
58:16 in which case the gold standard test to look for that is a coronary angiogram,
58:22 which is injecting dye, takes about 20 minutes.
58:25 You pass tubes up to the heart, use X-rays,
58:27 patient's awake, local anesthetic, and you inject dye.
58:30 So I did thousands of these, and-— that's
58:33 the gold standard to look for any significant blockages.
58:38 One of the problems with an exercise treadmill test,
58:41 "Jesse," is what we call false positives.
58:45 And they have up to a 50% false positive rate.
58:47 So that means that the test...
58:48 looks positive, but the ultimate result is that there's nothing wrong.
58:53 And that can cause anxiety, etc, etc.
58:54 So you've got to use a test appropriately.
58:56 What would be better than that it's obviously
58:58 more expensive is what we call stress echocardiogram,
59:02 which is where you do an ultrasound scan of the heart
59:05 and you get people on a treadmill or on a bike.
59:08 And then...
59:09 when your heart rate gets up above 144 in this particular patient,
59:12 you look at their heart muscle and you see how it's pumping.
59:16 And if there's a blockage, the heart muscle stops pumping as well in the area
59:20 of the blockage where the blood vessel is supplying.
59:23 So that's what we call stress echo.
59:25 That's non-invasive.
59:26 Again, very safe.
59:28 Quite a useful tool.
59:29 Calcium scores are usually done,
59:31 "Jesse," in patients that don't have typical symptoms.
59:33 Patients you're not predicting have got a significant blockage.
59:37 Because if you're predicting a significant blockage,
59:39 you should go straight for an angiogram.
59:44 But with a calcium score, it's now used as a risk tool like
59:48 checking your cholesterol or checking your blood pressure.
59:53 And actually, I would say I'm a bit biased because I use them quite a lot,
59:58 and by the way declaration.
1:00:00 I'm not getting paid to promote calcium scores by any device company.
1:00:04 Just so you know, it's important for me to mention that.
1:00:07 But I would say that...
1:00:09 many people, if not most people over 40 these days
1:00:12 if you're a man and over 50 if you're a woman,
1:00:16 because the validation of the test really is only
1:00:19 in those groups because you can miss soft plaque in younger people.
1:00:25 If you're a male over 40 or a female over 50,
1:00:28 calcium score is great if you're worried about heart disease.
1:00:31 The reason why it's also so useful is it gives you a score anything from zero,
1:00:36 which is normal, to over 1,000.
1:00:38 Less than 100 is what we call low risk
1:00:40 of a heart attack or stroke in the next decade.
1:00:43 100 to 400 is moderate risk, more than 400 is considered high risk.
1:00:48 It's a great snapshot tool.
1:00:50 It can be repeated, not more than once a year because of radiation,
1:00:56 but you can then see from an intervention if you have a calcium score done.
1:01:00 Let's say it comes back at 250 and you're like, whoa, no severe blockages.
1:01:04 Not high risk, not low risk.
1:01:06 What do I do, Doc?
1:01:07 Here, go on my protocol.
1:01:08 Let's repeat it in a year.
1:01:09 And then you will see that the calcium
1:01:12 scores remain stable or even improved, maybe reversed.
1:01:15 And then you can be confident that what you
1:01:17 are doing with your lifestyle is actually having an impact...
1:01:21 And I think that's a great way of using the calcium score as well, serially...
1:01:24 to see and to reassure patients that...
1:01:28 that what they're doing is working.
1:01:30 Let's talk more about the soft plaque versus hard and tie
1:01:35 it back to the pimples we were talking about before.
1:01:38 When does plaque solidify and become calcified?
1:01:42 And then we can go from there.
1:01:44 We don't know for sure, "Jesse," on that.
1:01:47 The presumption is over time it can become calcified
1:01:51 because a calcium is a response to the inflammation.
1:01:55 So, it's probably something that happens over time.
1:01:58 It probably doesn't happen quickly.
1:02:00 I think soft plaques develop more early on.
1:02:02 I don't know.
1:02:03 I haven't seen data on serial looking
1:02:05 at when the soft plaque becomes a hard plaque.
1:02:08 But my experience doing angiograms,
1:02:09 you see these people that have usually had coronary artery disease for many,
1:02:13 many years, they're more likely to have more calcified plaques.
1:02:17 And in theory, and likely in practice,
1:02:19 the calcified plaques are more stable and less likely to rupture.
1:02:23 They're also the hardest to stent, because the stent isn't removing the plaque.
1:02:28 When you're putting a stent in, you're putting a little-— balloon,
1:02:31 a deflated balloon on a wire in the middle of where the blockage is.
1:02:36 And you're inflating this balloon.
1:02:39 And if the balloon doesn't inflate on a calcified plaque,
1:02:42 sometimes the balloon actually bursts, because the calcium is so hard.
1:02:46 And that theoretically means that plaque is probably
1:02:48 not going to rupture and cause a heart attack,
1:02:51 because it's now stabilized and it's covered in calcium.
1:02:54 It may be causing angina, and that might be why you want to put a stent
1:02:57 in, but it isn't going to cause a heart attack.
1:03:01 So, in many ways, a calcified plaque is a more stable plaque.
1:03:05 And the more reassuring plaque.
1:03:07 The soft plaque develops earlier.
1:03:09 It doesn't have what...
1:03:11 because the pimple bursting is related to the outer layer,
1:03:16 if you like, if it's very thin.
1:03:20 It's more likely to just burst.
1:03:24 Whereas if it's thick and hard, that's when it doesn't tend to burst and cause
1:03:30 exposure of its contents of the plaque the immune cells,
1:03:34 the "LDL," oxidized cholesterol, "LDL," to the blood,
1:03:38 which then causes the bloodstream to see foreign body,
1:03:41 toxic, I'm going to form a clot there.
1:03:44 So that's how the clot forms and then can completely obstruct the vessel.
1:03:47 Would it be fair to say that the calcified plaque
1:03:52 is older pimples that have solidified and become more structurally sound?
1:03:59 Yes, but the reason people are going to say,
1:04:02 but hold on, that doesn't mean a high calcium score is then good.
1:04:05 No.
1:04:06 <break time=“2.27s"/> The more calcified plaque, the more soft plaque you have.
1:04:11 Okay, so there's a correlation there.
1:04:13 It's a surrogate-— marker of soft plaque.
1:04:16 And there is potential to reverse a calcium score.
1:04:20 You quickly touched on that.
1:04:22 Yeah, it's interesting.
1:04:24 I think a calcium score, I've seen that happen in some of my patients.
1:04:27 But soft plaque, certainly one of my patients had a carotid.
1:04:31 The same process in the heart arteries happens
1:04:34 in the neck vessels which, go to the brain.
1:04:37 And if they cause blockages there, can increase risk of stroke.
1:04:42 One of my patients, and it was pretty extraordinary Irish lady, a few years ago.
1:04:48 She followed my protocol,
1:04:50 except her stress levels had come down by some other means,
1:04:53 but she didn't do the meditation, just a diet.
1:04:57 And she had a 70, 75% blockage in one of her carotid arteries,
1:05:01 having had a mini-stroke.
1:05:03 And five years later, she emailed me, went to the same lab,
1:05:07 the same radiographer that did the ultrasound,
1:05:11 five years later, it had gone less than 25%.
1:05:17 And she said, thank you, Doctor "Malhotra," I've just followed your plan.
1:05:20 And I was like, wow, that's amazing.
1:05:22 It's just one patient.
1:05:23 It's an anecdote, and it could be coincidence,
1:05:26 but I like to think that the plan I recommended probably played a role.
1:05:31 Speaking about the carotid arteries gets me thinking about "CIMT."
1:05:36 Isn't that an ultrasound that can be done on those?
1:05:39 Yeah, that's looking at thickness of the carotid artery,
1:05:43 and that can be a precursor to blockages developing.
1:05:48 I think if we've got access to calcium scores,
1:05:51 "Jesse," I don't think it's of any use to do
1:05:54 a "CIMT." I think just get the calcium score done,
1:05:57 because you can have people with a normal
1:05:59 "CIMT" and have got a raised calcium score.
1:06:01 You can have people with a thickened "CIMT" have a normal calcium score.
1:06:04 The calcium score is most validated in terms of predicting events in the future,
1:06:08 as far as I'm aware, not the "CIMT." As a cardiologist,
1:06:12 are you aware of this talk of an ear crease
1:06:15 on the earlobe and that being associated with certain heart conditions?
1:06:19 I'm aware of it, "Jesse," but you probably
1:06:21 know more than I do right now about it.
1:06:23 I just know there's some kind of association.
1:06:25 I just wondered if there is anything
1:06:26 to be concerned if somebody's looking there.
1:06:29 Yeah, Yeah, yeah there is.
1:06:31 I wouldn't be able to quantify what that risk is,
1:06:33 but it's a marker definitely of heart disease.
1:06:36 So if somebody has that ear crease, then, yes, they should be investigated,
1:06:40 and probably a calcium score would be the thing to do.
1:06:42 So we went into diet.
1:06:44 We want to go low carb.
1:06:46 We want to get metabolically healthy again.
1:06:50 How does fasting, if it does, play a role into this?
1:06:54 I think if fasting plays a role, it's probably by improving insulin resistance.
1:07:02 For fasting, also depends on the person.
1:07:07 For some people, fasting can increase,
1:07:09 if their stress levels are already high and they're exercising,
1:07:13 I think fasting may be a bad idea...
1:07:15 because it increases cortisol so it can make the stress worse.
1:07:19 So it really depends how you feel, why you're doing it, when you're doing it.
1:07:24 I think the data on markers
1:07:26 associated with improved longevity is probably better.
1:07:29 But...
1:07:29 on the fasting side, I think that the best data and "Valter Longo"
1:07:33 is probably the person to look up for this.
1:07:36 There are two approaches.
1:07:38 One is a three-day water fast to do that once, or two or three times a year.
1:07:45 And the other one is a fasting-mimicking diet
1:07:47 for people that can't do the water fast,
1:07:49 which is basically 800 calories essentially of keto-vegan.
1:07:53 So animal products, no animal protein or animal fat, and no starch and sugar.
1:08:00 So you're basically reducing the pathways that are...
1:08:04 in the cell responsible for metabolizing animal
1:08:07 protein as well as keeping the insulin down,
1:08:11 and that encourages autophagy which is essentially a detoxification of the cell.
1:08:19 And that has to be done for five days on three consecutive months.
1:08:23 They've shown from some really interesting data,
1:08:26 "Jesse," that when people did that over a two-year period,
1:08:30 that decreased one's age by two years.
1:08:33 I think a 50-year-old became 48, something like that.
1:08:38 So...
1:08:39 I think that's really interesting.
1:08:41 And it probably indirectly has some role in heart
1:08:45 disease because one of the major causes, if not...
1:08:50 certainly in European men of premature death is dying of a heart attack...
1:08:56 So probably is having some benefit.
1:08:58 That's the best evidence-based approach I would say to fasting.
1:09:05 But some people have found that it amazingly
1:09:06 helps them lose weight and get their metabolic health.
1:09:09 And they do a 16-hour fast every day,
1:09:11 and they might have one or two meals a day as a result of it.
1:09:13 And they come to me, they say they feel great and their metabolic
1:09:16 markers are good and they don't feel stressed.
1:09:18 I'm like great, carry on.
1:09:19 Didn't work for me.
1:09:22 Didn't suit me at all...
1:09:24 actually.
1:09:24 I tried fasting 16 hours and working out and I was a wreck.
1:09:29 Absolute wreck.
1:09:30 And again, you've also got to look at your hormones as a guy.
1:09:33 One of the things that's there in the literature,
1:09:36 if you're keto and you're working out and you're fasting a bit,
1:09:40 even within 10 days it can have
1:09:42 significant negative impact on your testosterone levels.
1:09:45 I may not do that, but if you start to feel that your sleep's getting impaired,
1:09:49 your libido is going down, then you've got to do something.
1:09:52 You've got to work on the stress,
1:09:55 stop the fasting, or reduce the exercise or all three.
1:09:58 What are your thoughts on the microbiome and any connection there to the heart?
1:10:02 I think there is a...
1:10:04 wide body of literature,— it's all
1:10:07 linked <break time=“2.13s"/> to chronic inflammation.
1:10:11 I'm not a microbiome expert, so you'd have to speak to somebody else about that.
1:10:15 But I do think that— it plays a big role.
1:10:17 Yeah, absolutely.
1:10:18 I think cutting out the ultra-processed food and the sugar
1:10:21 has an automatic benefit on the gut microbiome.
1:10:24 And interestingly not, because I knew this by default,
1:10:28 I found that the low-carb diet I recommended was actually endorsed
1:10:32 by "Tim Spector," who's one of the leading microbiome experts in the world,
1:10:36 who endorsed my second book "Immunity Plan." Maybe
1:10:39 the first one as well, I can't remember.
1:10:43 We've been collaborating on campaigns together
1:10:45 in the past but he said that essentially
1:10:47 that the diet plan I was recommending was excellent for the gut microbiome...
1:10:51 So I'm quite happy about that.
1:10:53 Let's talk supplements in general,
1:10:55 and then any specifically related to the heart.
1:10:59 Well, I think in general, the evidence-based supplements I've seen for health,
1:11:04 and again it's going to be tailored to different people...
1:11:07 and we've also got to be.
1:11:08 The supplement industry aren't as big as Big Pharma,
1:11:11 but they're also profit-making industries.
1:11:13 So there's-— clearly a goal from a financial perspective for them
1:11:16 to get more people taking more supplements that's a no-brainer.
1:11:20 So we've got to be wary of that and see the wood through the trees.
1:11:24 I think that the supplements from a heart disease perspective first,
1:11:28 the ones that I think have a good evidence base
1:11:31 behind them and aren't going to do harm are vitamin D,
1:11:34 vitamin C, and keeping your vitamin D levels in the upper range of normal.
1:11:40 Low vitamin D-— deficiency in some studies have been
1:11:43 associated with a six-fold increase in developing heart disease.
1:11:47 So I think vitamin D is protective.
1:11:48 I think vitamin C doesn't do any harm, it's good for the immune system.
1:11:52 There is some historic literature saying
1:11:54 that vitamin C may protect against heart disease.
1:11:57 I take about 2 grams a day myself,— 1 gram with each meal.
1:12:03 And I up it if I'm feeling like I'm getting sick.
1:12:07 And the vitamin D levels as well, I think those are two important ones.
1:12:11 I think for stress...
1:12:12 I think magnesium is wonderful.
1:12:15 Magnesium glycinate is easier on the stomach.
1:12:18 I have that with my food.
1:12:20 And there's one called magnesium L-threonate,
1:12:23 which has better absorption in the brain and does make a big difference.
1:12:27 And I've used it in some of my patients
1:12:30 with "PTSD" who are like veterans from Iraq War.
1:12:33 And this has transformed them.
1:12:35 So I think magnesium from a stress point of view can be helpful...
1:12:40 subjectively in terms of way people feel.
1:12:43 I can't think of any other ones off the top of my head,
1:12:45 "Jesse." I don't know if you've got any ones you want to ask me about,
1:12:49 but those are the three reasonable key ones I think that are useful.
1:12:53 Well, a couple that come to mind.
1:12:54 Oh, sorry, one more.
1:12:55 Go ahead.
1:12:56 Omega-3, potentially...
1:12:58 the data isn't that strong in terms of outcome benefit.
1:13:02 It has obviously a natural blood thinning properties.
1:13:06 I think if you can do two to three portions at least of oily fish a week,
1:13:10 which would be wild salmon, it would mean mackerel or sardines.
1:13:15 And I think that that would be great.
1:13:18 We think there's a better benefit of the omega-3
1:13:20 as a synergy with the olive oil,
1:13:22 with the food, etcetera, in terms of its potency.
1:13:26 But yeah, those are the ones really I would suggest.
1:13:29 Fish oil was one of the ones I was going to bring up in the blood thinning,
1:13:33 so glad you went there.
1:13:33 Yep.
1:13:34 Yep.
1:13:34 The other one related to the heart is K2,
1:13:36 and you hear that it helps put calcium where it's supposed to go.
1:13:39 Yep.
1:13:43 And we talked about the calcifying of the blood vessels,
1:13:46 so just making the connection there.
1:13:48 Often taken with vitamin D.
1:13:50 What are your thoughts?
1:13:52 Yeah, not against it.
1:13:53 I haven't seen any good quality data there
1:13:55 on that, "Jesse," to be honest with you.
1:13:58 And one of the things you have to be keeping your vitamin D levels
1:14:01 in the good range is more important than
1:14:04 whether or not you've got "K2" on board.
1:14:06 I could be wrong.
1:14:08 I'm waiting for someone to contact me and say, "Aseem," look at this data.
1:14:11 But one of the things about "K2" and I've seen it, it happened with me again,
1:14:14 but it also happened to some
1:14:16 of my patients it can actually increase anxiety levels.
1:14:18 So if people start meeting palpitations, feeling more anxious,
1:14:21 stop the "K2." I actually got fasciculations.
1:14:23 I went to see a neurologist because I was getting muscle fasciculations,
1:14:27 twitches, and I stopped the "K2" and it disappeared.
1:14:30 Interesting.
1:14:31 I never heard that.
1:14:32 Yeah.
1:14:34 And--— I looked it up and it is one of the side effects.
1:14:37 I want to come back to your story.
1:14:38 Early on we mentioned the fact that you were very conventional.
1:14:43 Talk about the pivot in your career.
1:14:45 Bit of a.
1:14:46 What switched you on to thinking differently?
1:14:49 Conventional, but always a rebel.
1:14:52 Always a rebel in terms of questioning authority, being curious.
1:14:58 Since I was a kid, since I was at school, it was on my report cards.
1:15:03 So I probably had the capacity through my curiosity for this...
1:15:07 conventional in the sense that.
1:15:11 When I was in this phase where I
1:15:12 was a heavy prescriber of statins in secondary care,
1:15:15 you've got to remember this is in hospital setting.
1:15:18 These are high-risk people.
1:15:20 It was probably because I was so obsessed about passing
1:15:23 my postgraduate examinations quickly because cardiology is one of the most,
1:15:27 if not the most competitive, all subspecialties in medicine,
1:15:30 and you've got to pass your exams quickly,
1:15:33 first time, competitive exams, to succeed.
1:15:36 So I was obsessed with becoming a cardiologist.
1:15:37 So I worked really hard and then I knew my shit, pardon my language.
1:15:41 I was really on it, with all of the literature and the data and everything.
1:15:45 So I think that was probably why I was, <break time=“2.03s"/> a...
1:15:50 conventional prescriber...
1:15:53 But at the same time,
1:15:55 I was also subject early on in my career, which I think helped me.
1:16:01 One of my earliest jobs as a junior doctor,
1:16:03 "Jesse," was when I'd just completed, I think you call it residency in the US.
1:16:08 -When you've done one year.
1:16:09 So my first job after residency was what
1:16:11 we call senior house officer in a hospital,
1:16:13 which was purely for what we call care of the elderly.
1:16:16 So the people that came to hospital to be admitted,
1:16:18 they had to be over 65, they were usually transferred from other hospitals.
1:16:23 And what was fascinating...
1:16:24 is the care of elderly physicians.
1:16:26 The very first thing they would do
1:16:28 in a patient coming in with whatever condition, with a collapse, with confusion,
1:16:31 is look at their medications and reduce the medications.
1:16:35 And I remember learning at that point that up to 25% of all hospital admissions
1:16:39 in people over 65 are because of over-medication
1:16:41 or side effects or interactions of drugs.
1:16:44 So I was exposed early on to iatrogenic harms,
1:16:47 to the harms of over-medication...
1:16:49 And I think that helped a lot.
1:16:52 And then it was a gradual process because I
1:16:55 want to be the best possible doctor I can be, which means being...
1:16:59 curious, being a good diagnostician.
1:17:01 A good doctor is a good diagnostician.
1:17:03 I was also inspired by the story of "Sherlock Holmes." And many
1:17:08 people don't know this, but "Sherlock
1:17:09 Holmes," the fictional greatest detective ever,
1:17:12 was written by "Arthur Conan Doyle," who was a medical
1:17:15 doctor that trained in the same medical school I went to.
1:17:17 And he modeled the character of "Sherlock
1:17:19 Holmes" on one of his professors of medicine,
1:17:22 who he found the most amazing diagnostician.
1:17:24 Where he would sit in a clinic with this doctor
1:17:26 and the patient walks through the room and before they've even sat down,
1:17:30 he's already started to make a diagnosis by looking at the clothes they wear,
1:17:35 their shoes, and which journey they've taken and thinking,
1:17:38 which demographic are they from?
1:17:40 What are their hands?
1:17:41 Are they coughing a little bit?
1:17:43 It could be tuberculosis, whatever.
1:17:46 So, the byline of "Sherlock Holmes" was...
1:17:48 in the same way— how— he used to solve his murder mysteries
1:17:51 is the same thinking of us making a diagnosis, solving a puzzle.
1:17:54 I love solving puzzles.
1:17:56 When you've eliminated the impossible, whatever remains,
1:17:59 however improbable, must be the truth.
1:18:05 So, because of that, I was always curious
1:18:08 about it— and I prided myself on making diagnosis.
1:18:11 And when patients came in, and certainly from a heart disease perspective.
1:18:15 Because I was obsessed with heart disease and cardiology,
1:18:18 and seeing the obesity epidemic.
1:18:20 And coming across also,
1:18:21 part of it is the fact that, why did I go down the diet route?
1:18:25 An interest in there is because I myself learned to cook when I was 16.
1:18:30 I appreciate the importance of healthy, tasty food.
1:18:33 My dad taught me to cook.
1:18:34 I've been cooking since then.
1:18:36 I was known in medical school to cook the best chicken curries.
1:18:39 And you'd have 30 people over my apartment,— where we were staying in our halls,
1:18:44 to eat my chicken curry.
1:18:45 So, I was really into the food stuff.
1:18:47 And then I was appalled with what we were being served in hospitals.
1:18:51 And that's where things started for me to look into the research.
1:18:54 And then I found research showing dietary changes, like stopping smoking,
1:18:57 can rapidly improve heart disease risk and death from heart disease.
1:19:01 I was like, wow, why wasn't I taught this in medical school?
1:19:04 So, that's how things started for me, really.
1:19:06 And someone who's generally, because I'm health-conscious,
1:19:09 I was a sportsman, I like good food.
1:19:12 And knowing that's where most of what health is determined by those factors,
1:19:18 not the medicines people prescribe you.
1:19:21 That's when I decided to become a big advocate for that message,
1:19:25 and that's how things started to turn.
1:19:27 And then you come across,
1:19:29 another moment for me was the "BMJ" 2012 "Too Much Medicine" campaign.
1:19:34 This article was written that was fascinating.
1:19:37 There were three authors,
1:19:39 but the lead author was the editor of the "BMJ," "Fiona Godley,"
1:19:41 who ended up becoming friends of mine when I started writing for them.
1:19:44 And they were basically saying,
1:19:46 too much medicine is one of the greatest threats to public health.
1:19:50 And I was like, holy shit.
1:19:51 Pardon my language, that's a big deal for a medical journal saying
1:19:55 that we are overprescribing because of corruption
1:19:57 in medicine and Big Pharma influencing that.
1:20:00 So, there were several things that happened that got me into this advocacy role,
1:20:06 and I started writing for medical journals myself,
1:20:08 doing my own research and publications, etc.
1:20:11 As somebody that had invested so much time,
1:20:14 so much energy into your craft, becoming a cardiologist,
1:20:18 starting to flip over some of these rocks and see the other side,
1:20:23 what did that feel like?
1:20:24 When you learn something, it's enlightening.
1:20:29 One of the predictors of good mental health is lifelong learning,
1:20:34 "Jesse." For me, I want to learn
1:20:36 something every day that reduces human suffering,
1:20:40 or gives greater meaning to our lives, or improves our health,
1:20:44 which is mental, physical, and social well-being, which I think everybody wants.
1:20:51 That part was fascinating.
1:20:53 I enjoyed it.
1:20:54 I love learning anything that's going to be interesting and help
1:20:58 me and my patients reach a higher state of being.
1:21:04 But it was also interesting to see
1:21:07 the psychological responses to talking about this stuff.
1:21:10 And certainly when we started writing about it,
1:21:13 I think that I became most well-known in the mainstream for being one
1:21:17 of the leading figures in the world highlighting the harms of excess sugar.
1:21:22 Certainly, doctor-wise, I was influenced by a brilliant professor in "UCSF"
1:21:27 called "Robert Lustig," you may have heard of him.
1:21:29 And we became friends, and he mentored me,
1:21:32 and then I started amplifying his message and doing
1:21:35 my own research on sugar in the UK there.
1:21:39 So, the backlash came from the food industry there.
1:21:43 When I wrote "Saturated fat doesn't cause heart disease"
1:21:46 in an opinion editorial in the "BMJ," peer-reviewed in 2013,
1:21:50 all hell broke loose globally.
1:21:52 There was a huge kind of massive attention.
1:21:55 Front page of three British newspapers, "Fox News," "CNN," everyone,
1:21:59 "Cardiologist overturns three decades of dogma that saturated
1:22:03 fat causes heart disease." But the backlash...
1:22:06 wow.
1:22:08 The ideological backlash, the groupthink...
1:22:12 this is heresy.
1:22:14 How dare he.
1:22:16 Oh, yeah.
1:22:17 That was a challenge that I wasn't prepared for until it happened.
1:22:20 But then I learned over time that one
1:22:22 of the lessons in public health advocacy is,
1:22:25 as soon as your work threatens an industry or an ideological cabal,
1:22:28 you will be attacked, sometimes unrelentingly and viciously.
1:22:33 And that's really been my modus operandi.
1:22:35 I will not do it for the sake of it.
1:22:37 It's not for my personal benefit to do this.
1:22:40 It's...
1:22:40 I'm a slave to my conscience.
1:22:42 I'm a slave to data.
1:22:43 I'm a slave to truth.
1:22:44 I'm a slave to ethics, and I'm just a manifestation of that.
1:22:48 I am the sum of my influences.
1:22:50 I'm a medium for a message.
1:22:52 That's what I see myself.
1:22:53 I have to detach myself from it.
1:22:55 So, that's just over time.
1:22:57 But a life lived in darkness has no meaning, and you don't make progress.
1:23:02 And, of course, science evolves anyway.
1:23:05 That's one of the things I think we need in medicine more,
1:23:08 we need more of a culture of humility.
1:23:14 And patients want that.
1:23:15 Patients want you to be honest with them.
1:23:18 You're sharing a journey.
1:23:19 They don't want arrogance.
1:23:21 If you make a mistake, you own up to it.
1:23:24 But my feedback, touch wood,
1:23:26 "Jesse." I've so far probably been lucky enough and not
1:23:29 had a single patient complaint in my entire career, which is very unusual.
1:23:35 And my patient ratings recently are the highest in London in private practice.
1:23:42 And it's not because I think I'm particularly smart.
1:23:45 I look at the history, and I'm empathetic.
1:23:47 <break time=“3.95s"/> For me, ethical behavior is most important...
1:23:54 That's it.
1:23:55 You're doing this from a good place, seeking the truth.
1:23:58 But you have taken a couple of big arrows...
1:24:01 The "RCP," suspending your fellowship.
1:24:04 You're involved in a case, I know,
1:24:06 with "Zoe Harcombe" and "Malcolm Kendrick," both previous guests of the show.
1:24:11 Talk about the specifics there.
1:24:14 Yeah.
1:24:15 So talking about "Malcolm Kendrick" and "Zoe," who are
1:24:18 great friends of mine and brilliant people and doctors/scientists.
1:24:22 2019,-— which is— "Mail on Sunday," which is a major newspaper in the UK,
1:24:29 they did what could be described as a hatchet job article,
1:24:34 front page, linked to myself,
1:24:36 "Zoe Harcombe," and "Malcolm Kendrick" around our...
1:24:41 advocacy on informed consent on statins.
1:24:45 And we were misrepresented.
1:24:47 And essentially, that piece said that we were spreading,
1:24:51 in quotes, deadly propaganda, because we said statins don't work.
1:24:55 As a result of that, I lost my job in the National Health Service,
1:24:58 which I was very proud of working in, and wasn't able to get it back.
1:25:03 They decided to sue the "Mail on Sunday" for libel.
1:25:06 I decided not to get involved in that because I didn't think it
1:25:10 was worth it and I wanted to carry my advocacy and campaigning on statins,
1:25:13 which I did quite effectively.
1:25:15 They were told once they were on a libel case they can't talk about it anymore,
1:25:19 at least until the case is done.
1:25:21 I'm so glad they succeeded.
1:25:22 Last year, two years ago, they were found in favor.
1:25:26 They won their libel case and probably got
1:25:28 awarded quite a lot of substantial amounts of money.
1:25:31 And I'm very happy for them.
1:25:32 Moral victory for me.
1:25:35 So that was hard, of course, and I'm just in private practice now because of it.
1:25:39 But you just have to keep marching on.
1:25:42 And then the other fellowship with Royal College of Physicians...
1:25:45 that was suspended because I wrote a peer-reviewed article
1:25:50 in the "Journal of Insulin Resistance" about the "COVID" vaccines,
1:25:53 calling for their suspension.
1:25:54 But the reason that there was a complaint
1:25:57 to the Royal College of Physicians from six anonymous
1:25:59 doctors or several anonymous doctors was because the fact
1:26:03 that I always do things by the book.
1:26:05 For me, if you're going against the grain, you got to be able to back it up.
1:26:09 I've got to be able to back it up
1:26:10 myself and realize that I've not left any stone unturned.
1:26:13 And therefore, when I realized there was
1:26:15 a potential problem with the "COVID" vaccine, I did my own research and wrote
1:26:19 this extensive peer-reviewed article going into a lot
1:26:22 of detail around the cardiovascular potential harms
1:26:24 of it and even the benefits of the vaccine.
1:26:27 And— that was well publicized.
1:26:29 And I was invited to speak in the British Parliament by a member of Parliament
1:26:35 called Sir "Christopher Chope," who was the head
1:26:38 of a special committee looking at vaccine injuries.
1:26:42 And when the flyer was put out, in small print,
1:26:46 there was "Fellow of the Royal College of Physicians." This is
1:26:51 going to sound very ridiculous to someone in America hearing this.
1:26:54 That was the basis of the complaint,
1:26:55 <break time=“2.46s"/> which I had a fellowship that by definition
1:27:02 that that is bringing the college into disrepute.
1:27:05 I'm invited into the British Parliament
1:27:07 as a doctor to speak at an official meeting
1:27:10 and present the case on a "PowerPoint"
1:27:12 presentation of why the vaccine should be suspended.
1:27:17 That resulted in me getting initial suspension, then ultimately removed.
1:27:21 I was so disgusted with the "RCP," actually...
1:27:24 people don't know this, I'll tell you this now.
1:27:26 I was so disgusted and disappointed with their behavior
1:27:28 that I actually resigned my fellowship while serving a six-month suspension.
1:27:32 And that doesn't mean anything.
1:27:34 It's of no real consequence.
1:27:35 Only people who've done great work get awarded this fellowship anyway.
1:27:39 So not having the fellowship doesn't affect my practice.
1:27:42 But it basically meant I couldn't go and use
1:27:44 the library in the Royal College for six months, which I never used anyway.
1:27:48 I know it sounds funny.
1:27:50 It sounds a bit ridiculous.
1:27:51 Very British.
1:27:52 You can no longer use the library now,
1:27:54 Doctor "Malhotra," during your suspension.
1:27:58 So that was what happened.
1:28:00 I then hijacked the "BBC" in 2023 when I
1:28:03 was asked to talk about statins and I said,
1:28:06 actually, the elephant in the room about
1:28:08 excess deaths here is probably the "COVID" vaccine.
1:28:12 I wrote to them saying I've decided I want to resign my fellowship.
1:28:19 Because I just felt disgusted and disappointed with how I was treated.
1:28:22 I didn't really want the fellowship.
1:28:24 They were insulted.
1:28:26 They said, Doctor "Malhotra," while you are serving a suspension,
1:28:32 you can no longer resign your fellowship.
1:28:34 But by the way, since this has happened,
1:28:37 we've had further complaints about your appearance on the "BBC."
1:28:44 So this then dragged on for a while and ultimately,
1:28:46 they took away my fellowship.
1:28:47 <break time=“4.51s"/> It was just a symptom of medical persecution,
1:28:56 "Jesse," to be honest,
1:28:58 which I've experienced in my career, over my career for a long time.
1:29:02 It's amplified, more recently.
1:29:07 Hopefully things will resolve.
1:29:08 The truth and justice will prevail.
1:29:11 But I'm ready to stand my ground on this.
1:29:14 This is about ethics and duty to patients.
1:29:16 That's it.
1:29:17 That's all I'm obsessed about.
1:29:19 I think groupthinkers and the pandemic and fear <break time=“3.30s"/> has...
1:29:28 unfortunately, taken many parts of the profession.
1:29:32 I think we've lost our way a little bit.
1:29:34 I think we were losing our way before the pandemic anyway
1:29:38 because of lack of addressing the commercial corruption of medical information.
1:29:44 So this is just the chaos before order, "Jesse." That's what I think.
1:29:49 And it is what it is.
1:29:51 I've taken this path.
1:29:53 I have to accept what comes my way.
1:29:55 It's not easy, but it's worthwhile and it's meaningful.
1:29:57 On a positive note, I believe more recently you've joined the "MAHA" movement.
1:30:03 So I was actually appointed as the first chief medical advisor
1:30:06 to "MAHA Action," which is a nonprofit founded by "Kennedy." "Bobby" himself,
1:30:10 who I've known for a while, who's supported me on my advocacy for a few years,
1:30:15 initially wanted me to be with him
1:30:16 in "HHS," potentially as his chief medical advisor.
1:30:19 But because of America First policy and I respect that as a British citizen,
1:30:24 they couldn't give me that role.
1:30:25 The White House said that that can't happen.
1:30:28 So this was the next best thing.
1:30:30 <break time=“2.33s"/> I'm friends with "Bobby" and he listens
1:30:34 to me and as well as "Jay Bhattacharya." So
1:30:37 I've exchanged a lot of information over the last
1:30:39 couple of years of policy changes that should be implemented.
1:30:43 And I'm pleased to see, I'm sure it's not just me,
1:30:45 other people are involved as well,
1:30:47 a lot of the things I've recommended are starting to be implemented.
1:30:50 The food pyramid change,
1:30:53 adopting a vaccine policy that's more in keeping with Europe rather
1:30:56 than the US and giving too many unnecessary vaccines to kids.
1:31:00 These are...
1:31:01 the "mRNA," stopping the research funding or the investments
1:31:04 certainly into "mRNA," half a billion dollars' worth.
1:31:08 All of those have been things that I've supported.
1:31:11 Given this trend with policy.
1:31:12 We still have to work on the cholesterol hypothesis, though.
1:31:15 So— that's still a work in progress.
1:31:17 Given this trend with the policy,
1:31:19 do you see it continuing to head in this direction?
1:31:22 Yes, absolutely.
1:31:22 There's only one way it can go.
1:31:24 Listen, there's going to be pushback from Big Pharma, we've seen that.
1:31:28 We are under a Big Pharma tyranny.
1:31:32 So they are going to do their best to push back.
1:31:37 I think...
1:31:38 their days are numbered.
1:31:40 Their old model is numbered, which is they can manipulate data for profit.
1:31:46 There needs to be independent and even for their benefit.
1:31:50 They're producing drugs.
1:31:51 Most of the new drugs are copies of old ones, hiding data on harm.
1:31:54 It's ultimately self-destructive.
1:31:56 It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure that out,
1:31:58 "Jesse." So we need to create conditions where they're actually
1:32:03 truly innovating and focusing on producing products that are beneficial,
1:32:09 with more funding into basic science research,
1:32:12 not spending 20 times more on marketing than they do on the research.
1:32:17 This is what they do, they spend 20 times more on the drug companies,
1:32:23 on marketing, than they do on basic science research.
1:32:28 So the model is failing.
1:32:31 As we come to a close here,
1:32:33 I want to come back to diet, specifically saturated fat,
1:32:38 because as somebody adopts a lower carb diet,
1:32:41 a lot of times they're going to take on more animal products.
1:32:45 Saturated fat is going to go up.
1:32:47 You've made it clear that it's not connected to heart disease.
1:32:52 But for somebody right now that that's a hang-up of them adopting this diet,
1:32:57 speak to that piece.
1:32:59 Yeah.
1:33:00 So the reason saturated fat doesn't cause heart disease is multifold.
1:33:02 One, we've got randomized controlled trial data showing lowering saturated
1:33:05 fat doesn't prevent heart attacks in high-risk and low-risk groups.
1:33:08 We've got epidemiological,
1:33:09 high-quality observational studies over decades showing no
1:33:12 association with saturated fat and heart disease.
1:33:14 And then on a mechanistic level,
1:33:16 we've already explained "LDL" isn't that important.
1:33:19 But interestingly, even if you accept "LDL" might be important,
1:33:23 saturated fat raises "HDL" as well.
1:33:25 And it's a total cholesterol divided by "HDL" ratio that is,
1:33:29 after triglycerides and "HDL," is what's used in risk calculators,
1:33:32 calculating cardiovascular risk moving forward.
1:33:34 So even if "LDL" goes up a little bit,
1:33:36 and it's going to vary according to whether
1:33:38 it's dairy saturated fat or coconut oil saturated fat,
1:33:42 even olive oil has 14% saturated fat in it.
1:33:45 The ratio is not adversely affected.
1:33:49 So that's all they need to know.
1:33:50 I would not worry about that.
1:33:52 But the triglycerides and "HDL" are getting insulin resistance down,
1:33:56 and certainly when insulin resistance is down,
1:33:58 I don't think there's any clear...
1:34:00 I don't think people need to worry about saturated fat at all.
1:34:04 It shouldn't, however, replace, in my view,
1:34:07 extra virgin olive oil as being good quality
1:34:09 as your base fat because that has positive
1:34:12 benefits mechanistically and from randomized controlled trial data
1:34:16 and observational studies as being <break time=“3.23s"/> cardioprotective.
1:34:23 Any other specific foods, olive oil aside,
1:34:26 when it comes to living healthy and again,
1:34:29 specifically for the heart, people want to consider?
1:34:32 Yeah, I think lots of non-starchy vegetables, I think oily fish.
1:34:37 Garlic...
1:34:38 has some blood-thinning properties.
1:34:41 I can't cite good quality evidence,
1:34:43 but it's a food and it's mechanistic and it tastes good.
1:34:47 So I eat two cloves of raw garlic every day.
1:34:50 How does somebody go about navigating the conventional medicine world,
1:34:55 adopting a diet and lifestyle like this, and trying to explain
1:35:00 to their doctor this new way of living and eating,
1:35:03 and any potential changes in their blood work?
1:35:07 See that as a way of educating your doctor.
1:35:09 I learn from my patients.
1:35:11 I've learned a lot from my patients.
1:35:13 It's a two-way process.
1:35:14 Doctors don't know everything.
1:35:17 We've definitely learned that in the last few years.
1:35:21 If we did, we wouldn't have this massive, worsening burden of chronic disease.
1:35:25 And I think that's a reflection of some of the limitations of modern medicine.
1:35:30 So I think you can get resources.
1:35:32 You can get a copy of my book,
1:35:34 ''A Statin-Free Life." I have patients coming with exactly
1:35:37 the same issue where they've gone back to their doctor.
1:35:40 The problem is the doctors aren't that bothered about lifestyle,
1:35:43 but they're worried about the blood work.
1:35:45 So when the "LDL" goes up, <break time=“2.10s"/> they get flagged.
1:35:49 And I just say, they can see me,
1:35:52 "Jesse." They can arrange an appointment with me through telehealth,
1:35:57 and I will write a letter,
1:35:58 and that usually goes to the doctor and the doctor leaves
1:36:01 them alone because— the primary care physician won't overrule a specialist.
1:36:06 So anybody tuning in from around the world can work with you?
1:36:09 Absolutely.
1:36:10 Absolutely.
1:36:11 And what's the best way to do that?
1:36:13 The best way to do that is to...
1:36:15 there's an email address which is "concierge@hum2n.com"
1:36:19 which is the name of the clinic.
1:36:21 And they can— just look if they're not sure, just look at my website,
1:36:26 "doctoraseem.com" and they'll find a way to get
1:36:29 in touch and make an appointment with me.
1:36:33 And I'm very happy to talk about cholesterol, statins, lifestyle, everything.
1:36:38 Understand their tests, what they can do moving forward,
1:36:41 hopefully limit their fear, give them a feasible plan to work with.
1:36:45 Okay, last question for today.
1:36:47 We've shared a lot here, a lot of details, which is great.
1:36:51 What are three takeaways for somebody feeling overwhelmed right now at the end
1:36:56 that they should apply right away to start building that momentum?
1:37:00 I think broadly, well, three takeaways.
1:37:04 One is these effects in the lifestyle changes have rapid effects.
1:37:10 So these interventions for lifestyle rapidly improve your metabolic health,
1:37:15 and mental and physical health, too.
1:37:17 Within weeks.
1:37:18 People might say, oh my God, it's daunting.
1:37:20 How long am I going to do this for?
1:37:23 Do it for six weeks.
1:37:25 You will see a difference at the end
1:37:26 of six weeks that will make you sustain it afterwards.
1:37:30 Don't underestimate the power of reducing your stress,
1:37:33 not just through breathwork, but just social interaction is so important.
1:37:38 I actually prescribe hugging.
1:37:41 I tell patients with their partners, boyfriends, girlfriends,
1:37:46 even friends, hug for 20 seconds, 10 times a day.
1:37:51 Very beneficial.
1:37:52 <break time=“6.47s"/> I would say the third takeaway is
1:38:01 good health doesn't come out of a medicine bottle.
1:38:03 Most of what determines your longevity, your health,
1:38:06 and your happiness has nothing to do with doctors, unfortunately.
1:38:11 I think medicine is best for acute illnesses.
1:38:13 I think we've done amazing things.
1:38:16 Road traffic accidents, emergency heart surgery, defibrillators,
1:38:20 antibiotics for infections, insulin for type 1 diabetes.
1:38:24 These are where the big gains have come in medicine.
1:38:27 For chronic disease, it's going to be lifestyle first.
1:38:31 "Aseem," I want to acknowledge you for the work you're doing.
1:38:36 You're a truth seeker.
1:38:37 You're somebody that speaks the truth,
1:38:39 putting your flag in the ground and saying,
1:38:42 this is what I stand for, even if it's not easy.
1:38:44 Your work is much appreciated.
1:38:46 We're going to link up your contact info,
1:38:49 your books, your social media, everything in the show notes.
1:38:52 Thank you for this.
1:38:53 "Jesse," I appreciate it.
1:38:55 Thank you.
1:38:56 Thank you for watching.
1:38:57 Stick around here for this other great interview.
1:38:59 You don't want to miss it.
1:39:00 I'll see you over there.
1:39:02 A lot of coronary artery disease is very silent.
1:39:05 That plaque is silently sitting there
1:39:07 in millions of people without them even knowing.
1:39:10 And there are ways to find this out now.
1:39:12 We have the technology, it's just not being done.
1:39:15 And those who