Classical & Jazz Musicians React: Billlie 'cloud palace (Before sunset live)'
ReacttotheK
0:00 Kevin: Mmh.
0:03 Wow.
0:14 Izaiah: Hello, we are now reacting to Bil-l-lie.
0:17 Cuz there's like 3 Ls.
0:18 (Umu: Not "Bil-l-lie!") Oh, "Bye-III-iei?" Umu:
0:20 Today we are reacting to the girl group ‘Billlie’ and their single ‘cloud
0:23 palace~ false awakening’ which is their conclusion
0:26 to their 4 year ‘palace’ trilogy,
0:29 focusing on themes of self-discovery and confronting lost
0:32 selves at the boundary of dreams and reality.
0:35 Taya: This looks interesting.
0:37 I love when it's all lower case.
0:40 I am a dedicated lower case texter.
0:42 Umu: The singers feel like they are in a dream-like state
0:45 and try to find a shortcut back to someone they care about.
0:49 Umu: Perhaps...
0:49 Billlie?
0:49 Helen: We better have some Helen: some whole tone scales in this.
0:53 So a little pentatonic moment.
0:55 Umu: They describe moving through fog and mysterious paths, refusing to stop,
0:59 wanting to reach the one they are searching for, no matter what.
1:02 Aiden: I feel that, man.
1:03 You know, I have been taking anti-depressants and ever since I started them,
1:06 man, my dreams have been f#%king crazy!
1:09 Umu: The song is composed by minGtion and Junny.
1:12 There are four versions of this song.
1:15 And so I was struggling to choose which version to show you guys,
1:19 so I just ended up going with my favorite.
1:21 Honor: Their band stuff has been cool.
1:22 I am excited.
1:25 Irene: Ooh~ Katherine: Oh, it's live.
1:28 Taya: Oh~ Olivia: Okay.
1:32 Aiden: Good start.
1:39 Honor: And they are sitting too!
1:41 Helen: That's crazy.
1:43 Danica: Do you know the band?
1:44 Umu: They are session musicians.
1:46 Kevin: Oh, session.
1:50 Aiden: Production on the cymbals is pretty nice, on them,
1:53 the way they add the reverb, make it washier.
1:57 Helen: It's a really low timbre.
1:59 Aiden: Wow.
2:02 Taya: That synth.
2:04 Kevin: It so, it's mixed so well.
2:07 Taya: Ooh~ [plays on piano] Taya: Tsuki!
2:18 Izaiah: Nice.
2:18 Honor: Oh, bass comes in.
2:20 Danica: Aah~ Beautiful!
2:24 Ben: This is very much so like the personification
2:27 of "it's the friends we met along the way," I think.
2:30 Taya: Oh, bass!
2:33 Katherine: Oh!
2:34 Helen: Ooh!
2:34 Olivia: Oh my god.
2:36 Ben: Ugh, yeah, nice.
2:38 Honor: Big 2 feel overall.
2:45 Ben: Oh, the band is making them so much more gutsy.
2:47 Like, the band is making them sing with so much more power, and I love that.
2:50 Gaurav: Yes.
2:51 Ben: Uh!
2:53 Ah!
2:57 Honor: Nice.
2:58 Aiden: Kind of a cool modulation, like, a fake out.
3:00 It was pretty badass.
3:12 Honor: Nice Honor: Cute Helen: Yes!
3:22 Danica: Man, that bass is just...
3:23 Danica: ...killing!
3:24 Kevin: That was a crazy harmony.
3:29 Honor: Belt it!
3:32 Danica: This is so tight!
3:33 Kevin: Yeah.
3:39 Kevin: Mm, mmh.
3:40 Danica: Ugh!
3:43 Kevin: Wow.
3:45 Aiden: Oh, those cadence harmonies are so...
3:48 awesome.
3:50 Kevin: This little text painting, it's like you're above the clouds,
3:53 it's like that moment where everything clears up.
3:57 Ben: Ah.
4:01 Oh, I love her voice.
4:03 Taya: Aww.
4:06 Helen: Wooooah.
4:07 Honor: It has sort of like a rock-ish vibe.
4:09 Helen: Yeah.
4:10 Kevin: Almost metal.
4:13 Taya: Yeah, harmonies!
4:20 Honor: Woah.
4:21 [Honor vocalizing guitar lick] Danica: Ah!
4:25 Honor: Nice.
4:27 Kevin: That's crazy.
4:29 Ben: This drum set player is really good.
4:31 He is distracting me, man, this is– oh my god.
4:34 Gaurav: He is really enjoying it.
4:44 Taya: Haa~ Irene: Woow.
4:46 Taya: I was right, it was good.
4:47 [all cheering] Irene: Wow.
4:49 Kevin: Oh, please.
4:51 Please, yes!
4:52 [Danica scatting along] Honor: There is horns in a different version?!
4:58 Ben: Ugh, come on now!
4:59 Kevin: This can, I can hear this jam...
5:02 all day.
5:04 Gaurav: I don't think we are supposed to be
5:05 reacting to this part but this is groovy, you know?
5:07 Ben: Nah, we gotta listen to it, there's saxophone, man!
5:09 Irene: Woo~ Ben: Nice.
5:11 Oh- Taya: Aaah!
5:12 Irene: Yeah, yay!
5:14 Umu: That's a teaser to the other band version uploaded to YouTube.
5:17 Irene: Oh wow.
5:18 Fun fun fun!
5:19 Taya: Oooh!
5:20 Katherine: Cool.
5:20 Cool.
5:21 Umu: Soooo...
5:21 Katherine: Very cool.
5:22 I think you picked the right version.
5:23 I guess I can't compare it to the other versions, but this was, this was cool.
5:26 This was very cool.
5:27 Umu: You're like, "Without hearing the other
5:29 versions," "this was the right version." Katherine: Yeah.
5:31 Taya: I like it, it was funky.
5:33 Irene: Yeah, that was very interesting.
5:34 Danica: What a great arrangement.
5:36 And you can tell, like,
5:38 they put so much work into like making the group sound so together and so whole.
5:44 I think everybody is really connecting rhythmically and also energy wise.
5:48 Like I didn't feel like the voices felt unsupported at all,
5:52 I felt like they were really on, leading the band into things,
5:56 there was like a great synergy between the rhythm section and the vocalists.
6:00 Gaurav: In past songs that we have reacted to, I've always said: "Oh,
6:02 I wish the band was a little louder." I feel like they hit it.
6:05 I think Ben thinks that it was too loud but like,
6:07 I like that because it feels like they are
6:09 not less important but they are a part of it,
6:11 and also it feels more like a live setting,
6:13 cuz like, if you are in a live setting,
6:14 it doesn't matter how like loud you turn up the singer,
6:17 the drum set is gonna overpower them, even if the drum set isn't miked.
6:21 Like you know, the guitar is just, you're using this massive amp,
6:25 and the bass as well, it's all the same, like,
6:28 they will overpower the singer to a certain extend,
6:30 no matter how high you turn up the volume of the singer's microphone.
6:33 That being said, I like that a lot.
6:36 I really like that live feeling and it makes
6:38 you feel a lot more like you are actually...
6:42 like listening live to a performance of this, rather than a recording.
6:46 Honor: It was very clear, like the trajectory of the soundscape,
6:49 and so as that soundscape became clear,
6:51 the instrumentalists like kind of had a different approach to each section,
6:55 so it had like the steady evolution that also
6:58 went with Billlie's changes in like vocal timbre cuz I
7:01 think they definitely went from a more airy vocal
7:03 tone to a more strong vocal tone by the end.
7:05 Olivia: The vocals were quite beautifully sung.
7:07 Almost all the onsets had this like [breath] like added into it.
7:11 They used this kind of breathy onset to be able to lead
7:13 into these like really like ethereal-esque vocals
7:16 and keep the sound in that breathy space, purposefully placing it in a way where
7:21 they're not pointing it towards these resonators, towards this empty space,
7:24 they're pointing it a little bit lifted up, probably towards the soft palate,
7:27 so this is still resonating, cuz otherwise you wouldn't hear it,
7:30 but it's not resonating as much as it could,
7:32 which is why their head voice resonance coming off is quite breathy.
7:35 So it's a very interesting sound, I like it.
7:37 Taya: I loved they all just came together and there was,
7:41 there were so many harmonies happening towards, I think it was the last chorus?
7:46 Everything just felt kind of chaotic in a really good way.
7:49 Irene: Yeah.
7:49 Helen: There was the girl with like the blond-ish,
7:53 like purple-ish hair, whoever that was?
7:55 Yeah!
7:56 She had a good, like very warm sound like to, like her belt,
8:00 which was like really nice,
8:02 cuz I feel like sometimes it sounds like kind of screamy,
8:04 like when people like really go for it.
8:05 But she still kept this beautiful sound.
8:08 Honor: It was st– it didn't sound strained.
8:10 Helen: Like it got more present and it got louder, yeah,
8:13 like it was still what she was comfortable with, it seemed.
8:16 Irene: For me, what stood out the most instrumentally was,
8:19 there was so much cymbal, like– Aiden:
8:22 This is probably the best sounding cymbals
8:24 in any like K-pop group I have ever heard.
8:27 Irene: And I kinda liked it, it gave me this like,
8:30 I wasn't looking too closely at the lyrics, but cloudy, you know, feeling?
8:34 Cuz it wasn't one of those really hard mallets, I suppose,
8:38 because it was so much, but not too much for me?
8:40 And often it would just accent like the vocalist's line.
8:45 Like I think in the 2nd chorus or somewhere, it was just,
8:48 I was hearing it a lot on where the vocalist was singing
8:51 as well and it gave some power to what she was saying.
8:54 Ben: At one point I was like only thinking about the drum set,
8:56 which I know is what they meant, but they were still singing lyrics.
9:00 I couldn't hear what they were saying.
9:01 I mean I don't speak the language, but I genuinely,
9:03 I couldn't hear what they were saying in that moment,
9:06 like the drum set was going:
9:08 [intense and high volume vocal percussion by Ben] Izaiah:
9:12 Dang, I feel bad for their ears.
9:14 Aiden: Yeah, that's a good point.
9:16 Izaiah: The drummer is so close.
9:18 Aiden: Actually they've got in-ears in, they're probably fine.
9:21 Izaiah: You saw her adjust it right now?
9:23 She's like, yeah, that's kinda loud, sorry.
9:25 Honor: I think the changes in like how they worked with the meter,
9:28 cuz it was obviously 4/4 the whole time, but they changed the groove constantly,
9:32 so it was emphasizing different like stretches of beat.
9:36 Taya: They also do a lot of funky things with the rhythm where
9:39 we kind of get our expectations subverted about where the downbeat is gonna be,
9:44 where those instrumental hits land, and then you get thrown off a little
9:49 bit and then you're like anticipating that next hit,
9:53 which is like, it really keeps your ear engaged,
9:55 they do some really interesting things.
9:57 Aiden: Yeah, the hits are pretty nice, where they are syncopated,
10:00 it's pretty, there's a lot of: [demonstrates rhythm] It kinda,
10:06 it catches you of guard,
10:07 it's a very Snarky Puppy kind of way to do band accents.
10:12 Pretty awesome.
10:13 Taya: There were so many moments where we get bass
10:15 and guitar doubling and also like sometimes keyboard joins in, like
10:20 [plays] And then there were moments where the bass was
10:23 doing a different line And there was like contrary motion together,
10:27 where the bass was ascending, the guitar was descending,
10:29 and then we get this like cool kind of like timbral mixture, really really nice.
10:34 And then they had this kind of little modal mixture moment with the chords.
10:38 Ben: So for the majority of this song it feels like we are in E minor,
10:42 but then every single time we get to like the end of a phrase,
10:45 where then they play the tonic chord,
10:47 instead of playing an E minor chord they play an E major chord.
10:50 And when groups do this, it such like
10:54 a "oh yes man!" Like it's such a happy feeling.
10:58 Gaurav: It's like a sunrise moment, almost.
10:59 Ben: It's such a good feeling.
11:01 Cuz I mean, if it keeps being minor for the whole time,
11:03 it's like, well, not sad, but it's driving and there is determination but then
11:07 there is no actual like release of the...
11:09 like a pleasant major chord.
11:10 Katherine: What I was like kind of drawn to in terms
11:12 of the atmosphere is the spaciness of the harmony.
11:16 When I think of really spacey, like really kind of harmonies in the sky,
11:21 I think of 7th chords, 9th chords, chords with a lot of extensions,
11:25 and all of these chords in here are very jazz inspired,
11:28 they all have tons of extensions, there is lots of different notes going on.
11:30 Honor: I also like the chords in the bridge, I think.
11:32 Danica: So with the first chorus, it's like a ii-V, so it's like...
11:35 [Am9] Am7 to then D7.
11:38 Kevin: D7, yeah.
11:40 [D7(add9)] Danica: And then...
11:41 Kevin: And then Emaj7.
11:42 Danica: Let me think about how...
11:43 Kevin: What do you call that?
11:44 Kevin: It's like a thing.
11:45 Ben: In the biz we call that a backdoor Danica:
11:49 ii-V is an expansion of the function of the minor
11:56 iv chord so if you just play like iv-I Kevin: Mhm.
12:01 [plays Am-Emaj] Danica:
12:03 You can expand that, so if you make the minor iv a minor 7.
12:09 And then you voice lead the G to an F♯, to make it D7.
12:15 [D9] [D7] It wants to go to [D7-Gmaj7] Gmaj7.
12:22 But Instead you go a whole step.
12:25 Kevin: Woah.
12:25 [Am7-D7] Danica: Up.
12:27 [Emaj9-Emaj7] Katherine: There was one chord that put me on the freakin' floor.
12:35 Ben: Mm, A-D-E, same thing again.
12:41 [humming along] Uh, we're going D, D minor, to G dominant 7 to C major.
12:47 I think that is just a ii-V-I into C major.
12:50 B, B♭, A, G, F.
12:55 Katherine: Yeah, I just, I love that Fmaj7, because it is out of nowhere,
12:59 but we have had all these resolutions end up randomly in E major.
13:03 And I love how that one ends up randomly in F major instead of E.
13:07 But then it gets us very easily,
13:08 it's a tritone substitution to get us back to...
13:10 back to E minor.
13:11 Kevin: Cool, wow, today I learned.
13:14 I like this: [Melody: B-B-D-D-G-G-B-B] And then: [Emaj7 chord] E major 7,
13:22 and then it goes down to that, A7(add9).
13:28 [Danica singing B-A] Kevin: The colors.
13:31 Danica: This is a 13th.
13:33 Kevin: That's crazy.
13:36 OH, you're so right!
13:38 Kevin: You think?
13:40 [A9(add13)] Kevin: It's just how, yeah...
13:42 [F#m9(♭5)- B7- Emaj7- A9(add13)] [speaking along in gibberish] There you go.
13:48 Danica: And then they get that nice like altered sound.
13:50 Kevin: Mm.
13:50 Danica: ♯9, ♯5.
13:53 It really adds a lot of colorful tension
13:57 tones that when you have these really cyclical,
14:02 very functional, like going around the circle of fifths...
14:05 [t/n: "...harmonic progressions", probably] Tension tones make that all
14:08 the more interesting and colorful to listen to.
14:10 Gaurav: Yeah.
14:11 Ben: Dig this a lot.
14:12 Ben: I definitely felt the "maybe it was the friends
14:15 we made along the way" kind of vibe going on (Umu:
14:17 what do you mean by that) And the reason
14:18 I say that is just because of the, the combination
14:21 of the chords that they are using and also the tempo adds to that a lot.
14:27 This like medium kind of tempo that's not too fast, not too slow,
14:30 but it's still driving,
14:31 especially with the drum set going absolutely buck wild there at the end.
14:34 Helen: I also felt like the articulation was different throughout, like,
14:38 I felt like it got more articulated as it went on.
14:41 Either the swells or the decays like that happen
14:44 kind of more towards the first half of the song,
14:46 I feel like give it kind of like the dreamy quality, just because it's not like,
14:51 "here is a note, and here is another
14:52 note." but there is a little [swell and decay
14:54 of notes] But I feel like as it goes on it's very much like "dah" and it starts.
15:00 And then, but I feel like it gives a different effect
15:05 in terms of the sound itself but also with the time,
15:08 it just feels a lot more, like, settled.
15:10 And like I don't know what the lyrics are but I
15:13 feel like that might have something to do with like,
15:15 I don't know, the progression of the song.
15:17 Olivia: "It's still a bit confusing"
15:18 "The image I wandered through every time." Okay.
15:20 Irene: Yeah, it's just like, foggy, some kind of maze.
15:22 Taya: You're just kind of lost, Taya:
15:24 and in a dream and looking for something and...
15:28 Olivia: Wait, so maybe they feel like they
15:29 are in a little bit of a liminal space and it's starting to crack open and now
15:32 they are like running into their own little world.
15:34 Irene: I think there are some moments of clarity,
15:36 like when it goes to like a major triad or something,
15:38 but in general the lyrics always are painting
15:41 like this kind of lost, foggy feel, cloudy.
15:46 Taya: Dude, I was just vibing.
15:47 Irene: I was vibing too.
15:49 Umu: I forgot, they have lore.
15:50 Olivia: They have lore?
15:51 Umu: On the 11th bell,
15:53 Billlie disappeared and so they are on this journey to find Billlie,
15:56 and then Billlie is inside all of us, so is it discovering your own self?
15:59 Olivia: Oh, okay, I get it now, okay,
16:00 so basically it's a giant metaphor for, they're in a dream state,
16:03 they're in the clouds, the time has stood still,
16:06 and now this second hand will no longer move so there
16:08 is kind of this essence of we are in the same spot,
16:10 we are in the same place constantly, and this crack that's in there,
16:11 that I see, is what I am trying to break through,
16:13 I am trying to get to Billlie, I am trying to get to, it's in you as Billlie,
16:15 and it's just like this giant metaphor for like, head in the clouds,
16:18 and then all of the sudden taking
16:20 myself back down to reality from this unrealistic
16:22 daydream that I keep on seeing myself in, that's really just a trap,
16:25 and I need to be here in reality and seek you.
16:28 So like, so it's a cool idea.
16:31 I like the metaphor, and I hear it in the music now.
16:32 Katherine: I will, I will listen to all the versions now.
16:34 Umu: Yes!
16:35 Katherine: All 85 of them.
16:36 Umu: Yes!
16:40 Sean: I like the rapid pocketing of voices there.
16:44 Ben: Ooh my god.
16:45 Katherine: OH!
16:46 Aiden: You know what an ocean drum is, Umu?
16:48 Izaiah: It's a big drum with things inside and you go:
16:55 Aiden: And it sounds like the ocean.