The Email That Ended Blake Lively's Case
Brett Cooper
0:00 Alright, breaking news, everybody breaking news.
0:02 Emergency episode tonight.
0:03 I feel like I'm Tim Dillon calling an emergency episode,
0:06 but we do need to have an emergency meeting
0:08 of the minds because Blake Lively and Wayfair Studios,
0:11 that is Justin Bell, news Production Company,
0:13 they have officially settled their lawsuit.
0:16 Guys, this happened 10 days before the trial was supposed to start.
0:20 It was supposed to start on May 18th, I believe it was.
0:23 I was so excited about all of it.
0:25 I was so excited to see it, you know, transpire.
0:27 And yet here we are 10 days before and they have officially settled.
0:30 Now, one important piece of information here before
0:32 we dive into the statement and everything that I
0:35 think drove this decision to settle is
0:37 that this is now the Blake Lively Wayfair Studios lawsuit.
0:41 'cause as you might remember from a couple of weeks ago,
0:43 10 of the 13 claims were dismissed.
0:46 All of the claims specifically citing Justin Bald by name,
0:49 the sexual harassment, the, you know, a workplace harassment,
0:52 toxic work environment, all of those claims were dismissed.
0:55 So while Justin Baldoni was obviously still
0:57 involved because it is his production company,
0:59 he was not specifically named anymore.
1:01 So the case that was just settled
1:02 were the remaining claims between Blake and Wayfair.
1:05 All right, so we have the carefully curated statement here.
1:08 Let's read it.
1:09 So this was a joint statement released by both attorneys.
1:11 They said the end product, the movie it ends with us,
1:14 is a source of pride to all of us who worked to bring it to life.
1:17 Raising awareness and making a meaningful impact in the lives of domestic
1:21 violence survivors and all survivors is a goal that we stand behind.
1:24 They're saying the entire party, Blake and Wayfair, we acknowledge the process,
1:28 presented challenges and recognise concerns raised by Ms.
1:31 Lively deserve to be heard.
1:32 We remain firmly committed to workplaces
1:34 free of improprieties and unproductive environments.
1:37 It is our sincere hope that this brings closure and allows
1:39 all parties involved to move forward constructively and in peace,
1:43 including a respectful environment online.
1:46 This is not a throwaway statement.
1:48 Now I want you guys to know that crafting
1:51 a joint statement like this, it is painstaking work.
1:55 Now, in my opinion, I feel like the decision to settle,
1:58 you know, obviously it was thrown around a bunch.
2:00 I'm sure both teams were like, you should come to the table.
2:02 I think they did try to come to the table a couple of times.
2:04 There was mediation, we saw the photos where they were like
2:06 in there matching out outfits a couple of weeks ago.
2:08 But it is really, really hard,
2:09 number one to come to terms that you could agree on.
2:12 Number two, to jointly write a statement that will
2:15 be released to the public that shows both sides.
2:17 I mean it is like pulling teeth like every party involved is
2:21 like gritting their teeth and cringing as they have to bend and give
2:25 a little because it is all about compromise and it kind of, it's
2:28 supposed to feel like everybody gets a little bit of a win,
2:31 but also you're compromising because you don't really get to tell
2:34 the entire story and everybody has their story that they wanna say.
2:36 And within these statements, you know,
2:38 each party gets a little win here and there and maybe has
2:41 a little jab while they simultaneously also
2:43 feel like they're not winning at all.
2:45 Because neither party really gets to say
2:47 everything that they wanna say if they could,
2:48 you know, be fully transparent if they totally want and could say everything.
2:52 And so it's always a bit of a complicated situation,
2:56 you know, emotionally, the process of agreeing to the exact language,
2:59 I mean down to like the comma,
3:01 like I feel like the lawyers were just going at it in regards to this.
3:04 And so I do wanna speculate on what both parties would actually say
3:08 because I think you can kind of see which lawyer included which thing like,
3:12 you know, Blake Lively obviously wanted to have
3:15 the line about the challenges in the workplace.
3:18 She deserved to be heard.
3:19 And then you see Bald Don's team saying, you know,
3:21 we are committed to having workplaces that are free of that.
3:24 We are not admitting that anything bad happened.
3:26 But yes, we would agree that we don't want any workplaces that are toxic,
3:30 we're there as harassment.
3:32 And you know, they would say that that didn't happen.
3:35 But what they can say is that they
3:37 are committing to not having any workplaces like that.
3:39 I do think it was nice that they said that they are proud of the project.
3:42 I think that Bald would love to be able to say
3:45 that he's prouder of it if he had actually gotten his way.
3:47 And if the cut that they, you know,
3:48 sent out to theatres was not Ryan Reynolds cut instead of his.
3:52 Anyway, that is just my take on the statement.
3:55 Alright, so now I do also have some insight
3:57 and then my own theories here about what might have
3:59 brought them to the table and specifically moved this forward
4:02 10 days before the trial was set to start.
4:04 Now number one, and this is based on a source
4:06 that came to me with some information, A tip,
4:08 I guess I should say in that tip was that essentially allegedly
4:12 everyone around Blake Lively thought that keeping
4:15 the lawsuit going at this point, after everything that had gone on over the last
4:19 year and a half was just an idiotic idea.
4:21 Like she was losing in the court of public C opinion.
4:23 And she had already lost at this point.
4:25 She was just continuously getting embarrassed.
4:27 As more and more information came out, it was like, this is an awful look.
4:30 The trial was looming.
4:30 It's like you're gonna have to get on the stand.
4:32 Is this gonna be like an amber herd situation where you're
4:35 gonna have to run away to Spain and never be seen again?
4:37 Apparently also it was costing them millions and millions of dollars.
4:40 That's not just like legal fees,
4:42 but that is all of Blake and Ryan Reynolds businesses,
4:45 her haircare line or the Tossled Blake Lively haircare line,
4:49 her Betty Boop mocktails, all of Ryan Reynolds projects and his businesses.
4:55 Apparently the entire thing was just causing them
4:57 to bleed money and something had to change.
5:00 And so the source said that the people
5:01 around her had been looking for an off ramp,
5:03 something that would make the situation better.
5:05 But she was committed, she was gonna fight this to the end and they were like,
5:08 please no, for all of our sakes, like stop.
5:10 And she was just facing this trial head on.
5:12 However, I do think things changed in the last week or so.
5:16 I think the final blow actually came
5:18 on Friday when the latest court documents released.
5:20 And I think this might've, you know,
5:22 put a fire under their asses to get the settlement settled,
5:25 I should say, to finalise the joint statement
5:27 if they were not already working on that.
5:28 Because on Friday was when the latest court
5:31 documents were late and there was specifically one email
5:34 that put a lot in perspective and I
5:36 think could have just completely destroyed her entire case.
5:39 And it was this, so TV movie addict, this is an account on X says proof.
5:43 This is a woman who works for Sony
5:45 saying that Blake Lively asked them to destroy dailies
5:48 when you were on a film set and you were shooting a TV show or a movie,
5:52 everything that you record on a certain day is called a daily.
5:55 That is the raw footage.
5:57 It's not edited, you know, the 15 takes of this scene,
5:59 the second angle of this, the B cam of this shot, whatever it is,
6:03 everything that gets sent to the editors that the directors are
6:05 looking at the night of to make sure that they got everything.
6:08 Those are called the dailies, that is the raw footage.
6:10 It catches everything.
6:11 If you flub up a line, if Blake lively,
6:15 you improvise and kiss your CoStar and then tell
6:18 people that he actually was coming onto you and improvising,
6:21 kissing you, that might not be stuff that you want
6:24 the world to see when you're accusing him of sexual harassment.
6:26 All of that would be in the dailies.
6:30 So this is the email, this is from Andrea Ginetti at Sony.
6:34 She said, call me when you can, not urgent,
6:36 but Blake is asking us to destroy some of the dailies.
6:39 Want to tell you what we will and won't do.
6:40 Also going to ask Bridgette to contact all vendors and ask
6:43 them to delete all dailies and need them to proof.
6:46 Okay, first time I've ever been asked to do this in a movie with no nudity,
6:49 but okay, already in this email,
6:51 the Sony executive is acknowledging how odd this is.
6:54 But this email really is important for a few reasons.
6:57 Number one, I want you guys to zoom in here and look at the date.
7:00 This email about destroying the dailies was sent on September 3rd, 2024.
7:05 It ends with us.
7:07 Came out on August 9th, 2024.
7:10 So Blake is retroactively going to Sony after
7:13 the movie has already been out in theatre.
7:15 She's already sent Justin bald down to the basement, allegedly.
7:17 Allegedly she's wearing her florals.
7:19 It's a month after this the internet is talking
7:22 about her, the failed movie, how odd it was.
7:25 Where is Justin Bald?
7:26 It's around the time that all of this is starting.
7:30 The movie's not being edited anymore,
7:31 it's totally out in theatres and she's asking Sony to delete the raw footage.
7:37 And so obviously everyone with a single brain cell online is going, okay,
7:40 well was there other evidence there that she didn't want out before
7:43 she filed a lawsuit about the things that took place on set?
7:47 She's alleging this toxic work environment,
7:48 everything that was totally out of hand
7:50 that she had no control over the situation.
7:52 I mean, what were the things that she didn't want people to see?
7:54 We've already talked about the improvising kisses.
7:56 Was it her simultaneously saying that she had no control over the film
8:00 and yet in the dailies we might see that she was actually directing scenes,
8:03 rewriting things on the spot?
8:04 I'm, I'm just like speculating and alleging,
8:06 I mean she did this presumably knowing that she was about to file a lawsuit,
8:11 that that lawsuit would somehow get leaked to the New
8:14 York Times and all of this would start.
8:16 So that's number one.
8:17 Now, number two, it's important because in her deposition
8:20 that took place in July of 2025, Blake Lively was asked directly twice actually.
8:25 She was asked directly if she ever destroyed
8:28 any dailies or instructed anybody to do so.
8:32 And she said no both times when she was asked directly,
8:35 not in a subversive way directly, she said, no, look at this.
8:39 So you never asked or had anybody on your behalf
8:42 ask anyone from Sony to destroy the dailies.
8:44 Is that correct?
8:45 She said, no, I never asked anyone to destroy the dailies.
8:50 What about, did you ask anyone on your behalf
8:52 to contact Sony to destroy the dailies,
8:54 to destroy the, no, she said so all of this came
8:58 out in court documents that were released on Friday.
9:01 So this made huge waves on social media.
9:03 The evening on Friday, over the weekend it got picked up by TMZ.
9:07 I saw an article about it this morning.
9:08 It was actually my topic for tomorrow's episode.
9:11 I was very excited to dive into everything that was transpiring.
9:14 There were a few different articles that came out about the lawsuit
9:16 and the, the impending trial that I wanted to talk about.
9:20 And so I guess Blake caught wind that going
9:23 into a trial where she's saying that she had no control,
9:26 that it was such a toxic work environment, that she was helpless,
9:29 that Wayfair did all these awful things to her.
9:30 That if she has the power to go to Sony
9:33 and have evidence destroyed after the fact that she
9:37 apparently allegedly lied in her depositions about that, that that probably
9:41 does not put her in a great position,
9:43 that that probably would've been even more embarrassing
9:46 than what she has endured on her own
9:47 behalf by things that she has done over the last year and a half.
9:51 So that brings us to now about 15 minutes
9:53 before I sat down to film this emergency episode,
9:55 emergency meeting of the mines, they announced their settlement.
9:58 Somebody commented on one of these posts and said,
10:00 what a stinking mess, typical Hollywood trash.
10:01 What upsets people the most is that they have been
10:04 forced to give a shit about this for way too long.
10:05 Not me.
10:06 I am not upset in the slightest.
10:08 I am upset that I will not get to watch a trial take place.
10:12 I mean at this rate, I probably would've like shown up at the courthouse
10:16 in New York City like, please let me in.
10:18 I have my notebook, I'm ready,
10:19 I'm ready to get the firsthand account of everything that's going on.
10:22 I was not tired of this.
10:24 And obviously, you know, this is celebrity bs, it's pop culture,
10:27 but it really is about something so much more.
10:29 It's about the Me Too movement.
10:31 It is about honesty and transparency in Hollywood.
10:34 It is about the power of PR to destroy reputations.
10:37 I think that it has shown a light on the underbelly of Hollywood
10:40 and a lot of people are seeing just how terrible so many of their idols are.
10:44 So it's about so much more than just a stupid lawsuit.
10:47 Very similar to why Amber Heard.
10:49 And Johnny Depp's case was not just a stupid piece of Hollywood gossip,
10:53 it was something that really impacted culture and Hollywood at large,
10:57 which is what I care about.
10:58 Somebody else commented and said Blake Lively
11:00 knew that she would turn into the next, Amber heard if this went to trial.
11:02 Ryan Reynolds career might have been permanently affected as well.
11:05 Good decision by her.
11:06 I, I think that that is spot on.
11:07 Like I don't know if she finally came to maybe, you know,
11:10 seeing what she saw on social media over the weekend,
11:12 knowing what was released in those court documents.
11:14 I dunno if the people around her finally took charge,
11:16 were like, get outta the way Blake.
11:18 Like we have to do something.
11:19 But obviously somebody in her orbit realised that she
11:22 needed to jump ship salvage as much of her reputation,
11:25 she and Ryan's careers, all of their money.
11:28 Something had to happen.
11:29 And I think that Ryan Reynolds is big
11:31 enough that he will still have a big career.
11:33 He has his whiskey and Mint mobile and all the other things.
11:36 He has an ad agency now.
11:37 They have a million different, you know, companies and projects.
11:40 I think he'll be fine.
11:41 She has enough of a ride or die fan base.
11:43 Kind of like how Amber her does.
11:44 But I think a little bit bigger.
11:45 She has the gossip girl money, the residuals that she gets every single time.
11:49 One of us Rees one of those amazing episodes.
11:51 The Thanksgiving episode, that's me like every other month.
11:53 I'm rewatching it.
11:54 She has enough of that money to last her a lifetime.
11:56 I'm not worried about them in the slightest.
11:58 They'll be fine.
11:58 She'll probably be hanging out with Taylor Swift in the next couple of months.
12:01 Everything will relatively be back to normal,
12:03 but I do think she'll have a quieter life since this took place.
12:05 But what I do care about,
12:07 as I hope that Hollywood welcomes Justin bald back into the fold,
12:11 I hope that we continue to see his company, Wayfair,
12:13 just grow and do better and better projects and bigger projects.
12:16 'cause that's really the path that he was on before all of this started.
12:19 So I hope he can just pick up where he left off.
12:21 And I hope that this means he really can put all of this behind him,
12:23 especially for his wife's sake and his children's sake,
12:25 because I cannot imagine what would feel like to go through this and feel
12:28 so helpless as you were watching
12:30 your significant other fight for his reputation,
12:32 your family's reputation, your entire business and livelihood.
12:35 So I hope that for them, and I'm guessing I would guess that this settlement
12:39 means that he will not be refiling for defamation.
12:42 As you guys knew, he filed for defamation.
12:44 The judge threw it out because you can't actually, you know,
12:46 determine defamation when there is an active case that's running congruently.
12:49 Anyway, I did episodes about that, but they threw that out.
12:52 I would assume that him not filing for defamation
12:54 after the fact is part of their settlement agreement.
12:57 But I think he knows,
12:58 I think we all know that he won in the court of public opinion, he did win.
13:02 And so I hope that that lets him rest easy at night.
13:04 Hopefully he takes a big long vacation, a big long nap.
13:07 And so that is my update for you guys.