Earth’s Core Should Be Impossible. A New State of Matter Explains It.

Earth’s Core Should Be Impossible. A New State of Matter Explains It.

PBS Space Time

0:00 First we discovered Earth's liquid core.

0:02 Then we discovered a solid core within that liquid core.

0:05 Then we discovered that the solid core

0:08 has bizarre properties that are more liquid like.

0:12 So is the inner core solid or liquid?

0:18 The answer is yes.

0:21 Before we get started, a couple quick announcements.

0:24 First, we have some new data:

0:27 liking and commenting really does help get episodes shared.

0:33 And we’ve also learned that the number

0:37 one reason people support us on Patreon isn’t

0:40 actually the perks—it’s simply to support the Space

0:43 Time community and the work we do.

0:45 So for those of you who do support thank you so so much.

0:50 But don't get me wrong, there are perks and they're good.

0:54 There's a link in the description if you'd like to join,

0:58 this really would be a huge help.

1:00 Next up.

1:01 Today’s episode is part of PBS Earth Month!

1:04 PBS is celebrating by releasing a ton of great

1:07 new episodes diving deep into our amazing planet.

1:10 In particular, you might enjoy the latest episode of eons,

1:14 which covers super mountains,

1:16 these ridiculously enormous formations that, as far as we know,

1:19 have only ever existed on Earth twice.

1:21 Links to that episode and the full Earth Month playlist also in the description.

1:26 Next up, we're excited to launch our universe

1:28 in a Black Hole T-shirt and hoodie.

1:29 If you believe we're trapped inside a black hole where space and time

1:32 swapped roles and the Big Bang was just the other side of a collapse,

1:35 then this is the shirt for you.

1:37 We're also still offering up our black hole light curves,

1:39 desktop and gaming mat that shows the ways light

1:41 is warped by the gravity of a black hole.

1:44 Plus, our UV glow kit, rotating black hole designs,

1:47 and dark energy mugs are all still available.

1:49 Links in the description.

1:51 Now onto the episode.

1:52 And no.

1:53 It may be that Earth's inner core is in an exotic

1:58 state of matter that is simultaneously crystalline and fluid.

2:02 The super ionic state the mysteries of our own planet's interior have in many

2:08 ways been harder to crack than those of the rest of the cosmos.

2:13 I mean, we can send probes to the edge of the solar

2:16 system and the 46 billion light years to the cosmic horizon,

2:19 a largely transparent.

2:20 And we can see the most distant galaxies.

2:24 But the 6400 km to Earth's center are both opaque

2:29 to light and far beyond the reach of any conventional drill.

2:33 The best we can do is to listen to the faint rumblings of distant earthquakes,

2:39 and then try to piece together how

2:41 those seismic waves bounce around Earth's interior.

2:44 To give you an idea of how seismology

2:47 has lagged cosmology and the rest of physics,

2:51 it wasn't until 1909, after Einstein, special relativity,

2:55 that anyone realized that seismic waves could teach us about Earth's structure.

3:00 It was Andrija Mohorovičić that noticed that some

3:04 of the P waves that's primary or pressure waves,

3:09 found a shortcut from the earthquake's epicenter

3:12 to seismic stations hundreds of kilometers away.

3:16 He brilliantly inferred that the waves traveled through a denser

3:20 and hence higher velocity region deeper in the Earth,

3:24 thereby discovering the crust mantle boundary.

3:27 That opened the floodgates.

3:29 In 1914, just a year before general

3:32 relativity and the following prediction of black holes,

3:36 we discovered Earth's molten core.

3:38 That was by Benno Gutenberg, who found that S-waves, for secondary or shear,

3:44 were blocked across a broad shadow region on the opposite side

3:48 of the planet to their origin while the P-waves could make it straight through.

3:53 Shear waves only propagate through solids.

3:56 So he realized that this meant there must be a liquid interior to the Earth.

4:02 But even those P waves play funny around the molten core,

4:07 refracting to create smaller shadow zones.

4:09 Taking this game one level deeper.

4:12 It was in 1936, long after we discovered the expansion of the universe,

4:18 and inferred the Big Bang that Inge Lehmann discovered the inner solid core.

4:24 She found that some P waves did enter their shadow zones,

4:28 and brilliantly figured out that these must be reflecting

4:32 off a solid region even deeper than the molten interior.

4:36 Well, better late than never.

4:38 These ideas have been refined and verified over the years,

4:43 leading to our modern, multi-layered model of Earth's interior.

4:47 Our planet is an oblate spheroid with a low

4:51 density crust that carries slow P-waves and even slower S-waves,

4:55 followed by a denser,

4:57 higher wave speed rocky mantle that slowly flows even though it's still solid,

5:03 allowing it to support both wave types.

5:06 Then we have the liquid outer core breathing a solid inner core,

5:10 both mostly of iron.

5:12 It all hangs together neatly, explaining our dynamic planet,

5:16 from its volcanism to its tectonics to its magnetic field.

5:21 For all intents and purposes, it's right.

5:24 So what do we do when new,

5:27 even more refined seismic data disagrees with this model?

5:31 As our seismic monitoring became more sensitive and more widespread,

5:35 we started to probe the inner structure in more detail,

5:38 and we started to see some glitches.

5:41 For example, P-waves pass through the inner core

5:44 faster in the polar direction than the equatorial direction.

5:48 This is typically explained by the fact that sound speed

5:52 in a crystal can depend on the orientation relative to the crystal's lattice.

5:58 If Earth's inner core is crystalline iron

6:01 and the lattice orientation correlates with planetary spin,

6:05 then the polar equatorial difference can be explained.

6:10 There even seems to be an east west hemispheric asymmetry in wave speed,

6:15 and that's taken as evidence of large scale

6:17 lumpiness and or melt regions in the inner core.

6:20 One of the hardest things to explain is really deep in the weeds of the data,

6:26 but it may reveal something really startling about the heart of our planet.

6:31 S-waves, which are completely blocked by the molten outer core,

6:36 do arise in the inner core through conversion of P-waves,

6:40 and it's actually wild that we can even identify

6:44 surface seismic waves that have gone through a P-S,

6:48 then S-P transition through Earth's core,

6:51 then back to P-waves to return to the surface.

6:55 But we do find that these core shear waves travel

6:59 way too slowly in that core compared to what we expect,

7:03 given the core's composition.

7:05 S-waves in the core are also losing energy much more quickly

7:10 as they travel than is expected for a stiff material like crystalline iron.

7:15 Now, this inner core S-wave thing is a real current mystery,

7:20 and to figure it out, we're going to need some geophysics.

7:24 There are two main ways to deform a solid compression/expansion.

7:28 So changing the volume.

7:30 And that's what P-waves do.

7:32 Or shearing changing the shape.

7:34 And that's our S-waves.

7:36 The more resistant a material is to either

7:39 of these, the faster that material will propagate waves in that mode.

7:43 Think about it as a more easily deformable material,

7:47 being sort of soft and sludgy in that mode.

7:50 Crystalline iron is very stiff to both compression and shear,

7:54 and so should have fast P and S waves.

7:58 And Earth's core does transmit P waves as fast as we expect.

8:01 But the S waves are too slow.

8:04 To put numbers on this.

8:06 The relative shear-ability to compressibility of a material

8:09 is encapsulated by the Poisson's ratio,

8:13 which is usually around 0.2 or 0.3 for a typical solid.

8:18 But Earth's core seems to be at around 0.45,

8:22 which is close to the Poisson's ratio for rubber.

8:26 So not very compressible, but very shareable.

8:29 Let's call such a material squidgy.

8:32 That's not a technical term, so don't use it on any geophysicists.

8:38 So what sort of core material could be squidgy like this?

8:43 Well we're going to stick with iron in general

8:46 because we know that this matches the density.

8:49 And because we see that asteroids do develop these iron

8:53 cores as the heavy metal drips to the center during cooling.

8:56 But there are various things that could increase the cores's squidginess.

9:01 The first idea people had was to just add other stuff to the crystal lattice.

9:06 Alloying iron crystal with hydrogen, carbon, oxygen,

9:10 silicon sulfur will significantly increase the poisson's

9:14 ratio and so lower S-wave speed.

9:17 But it's now generally believed that all by itself,

9:20 just alloying with any reasonable amount of these light

9:24 elements could not reduce S-wave speed by enough.

9:27 Another possibility is to make the core grainy.

9:31 Rather than one giant spherical crystal,

9:33 the lattice of the core could be fragmented, potentially on microscopic scales.

9:38 When molten metal solidifies,

9:40 its crystal lattice grows from multiple nucleation points,

9:44 resulting in many misaligned sectors.

9:47 Over time, these grains can merge and align

9:50 to produce larger lattices or even fragment further,

9:53 and it's not clear what we should expect to have happened in Earth's core.

9:58 Because the boundaries between grains lacked the strength of the pure lattice.

10:03 The more able to slide against each other,

10:06 and this is greatly amplified if microscopic membranes

10:09 of molten or heat softened metal formed between those grains.

10:15 This granular ization and melts or pre-built can

10:18 potentially explain the high Poisson's ratio in the core.

10:22 But the challenge with this explanation is

10:24 that there's only a narrow window of grain size,

10:27 plus melt or pre-melt that gives us

10:30 the right core properties to explain S-wave propagation,

10:33 push it too far and the core goes from squidgy to goopy,

10:38 meaning that's waves lose way too much energy compared to what we observe.

10:44 There's also the issue that fine grained

10:47 crystal structures have a harder time organizing globally.

10:50 And remember, we need some level of global lattice

10:54 alignment to explain the polar versus equatorial speed difference.

10:57 Most likely there is some of these granular ization, etc.

11:01 going on, but there are strong arguments that they aren't the whole explanation.

11:06 We're looking for a way to retain the general rigidity of the core,

11:11 potentially allowing a global crystal lattice alignment,

11:13 but to still lubricate things a bit to slow down them S-waves.

11:19 What we need is a new state of matter,

11:21 a state of matter that allows the core to be simultaneously solid and liquid.

11:26 And so let me introduce the superionic state.

11:30 In this state, we have a rigid crystal lattice of some element

11:35 to a molecule with some other atom moving freely within this structure.

11:39 There are lots of examples

11:42 of superionic materials with various technological applications,

11:45 from batteries and fuel cells to various types of sensor.

11:48 We've even observed superionic ice in which

11:52 hydrogen moves freely within an oxygen lattice.

11:55 In the case of Earth's core, the primary lattice would be the hexagonal lattice,

12:00 formed by iron alloyed with nickel.

12:03 Lighter elements like hydrogen, oxygen, and most notably carbon,

12:07 could then live in the interstitial spaces of that lattice,

12:12 moving with a freedom that is liquid like.

12:14 Now, iron doesn't do this in normal circumstances.

12:17 At low temperature, impurities like carbon tend

12:20 to stay at fixed positions in the lattice,

12:23 but molecular dynamic simulations have shown that as temperatures increase,

12:29 carbon atoms begin to move between

12:31 interstitial sites and above a certain temperature,

12:34 they exhibit liquid like behavior.

12:36 According to these simulations,

12:38 the high pressure in a core of the Earth creates the perfect

12:44 conditions for the iron carbon lattice to enter this superionic state.

12:50 Even better, in these simulations,

12:52 the alloy shows a lower shear velocity than pure iron,

12:57 and a Poisson's ratio of around 0.43,

13:00 very close to the observed seismic properties of the real inner core.

13:05 Simulations are great because they can suggest and sharpen hypotheses

13:08 that we can then go and test in the real world.

13:11 Now it's going to be a long,

13:13 long time before we can access Earth's core to do direct tests.

13:17 So in the meantime, we need to recreate the conditions of the core in our labs.

13:22 And this is where the new study by Huang, He, Zhang et al comes in.

13:27 This team created a hexagonal close packed iron

13:30 lattice with a small amount of carbon dissolved interstitially.

13:33 Then they smacked it with particles traveling at high speed to create

13:38 shock pressures and corresponding temperatures high

13:41 enough to unlock the super ionic state.

13:44 Now, the theme of this episode seems to be sound speed in different materials.

13:49 So one side note the projectile in this experiment

13:52 was accelerated by a light gas gun.

13:55 The projectile velocity in a firearm is constrained by the speed of sound.

14:00 Just because a bullet is pushed out of the nozzle by expanding gas,

14:05 and that expansion is limited by sound speed,

14:08 but sound speed increases with molecular mess.

14:12 For air, that's basically dinitrogen.

14:14 If instead you fill the chamber with hydrogen or helium,

14:18 then a higher sound speed behind the bullet results in a faster muzzle velocity,

14:24 where normal firearms can achieve muzzle velocities of Mach a few.

14:29 A light gas projectile can hit Mach 20 plus or actual orbital velocities.

14:35 Because of that, they're often used to study the impacts of, say,

14:40 micro meteoroids on space based hardware.

14:43 But in this experiment,

14:44 the light gas gun is giving us a sort of particle accelerator for geology.

14:49 Anyway, ends tangent mode.

14:51 And let's get back to the experiment.

14:53 Once the supersonic state was created in the iron lattice,

14:57 its properties were studied similar to how we study

15:00 Earth's interior by looking at vibrations on the surface.

15:03 In this case, with photon Doppler velocimetry,

15:05 which is basically pointing a super precise speed gun at the surface,

15:10 now those vibrations reveal the structure of the interior of the sample,

15:16 just as with seismology.

15:18 In this way, the team could infer various properties,

15:21 including the shear velocity and the Poisson's ratio,

15:24 and these values were consistent with what we expect from super ionic iron.

15:30 As predicted by simulations.

15:32 It's worth mentioning that this experiment didn't achieve

15:35 the full pressure and temperature of Earth's inner core, but at the very least,

15:40 we seem to have produced this strange phase of matter in an iron carbon alloy,

15:46 which is an experimental validation of a mechanism

15:50 that had previously existed only in simulation,

15:53 and the supersonic state produced exhibits

15:57 strong shear softening consistent with seismic data

16:01 that strengthens its viability as a candidate

16:04 for the unusual "squidginess" of Earth's inner core.

16:07 If the superironic hypothesis turned out to be true,

16:10 it may help explain other things.

16:12 For example, preferential flow of the interstitial carbon along Earth's

16:16 rotational axis could partially account

16:19 for the polar equatorial speed difference,

16:22 which loosens the constraints on global lattice alignment,

16:25 and the flow of this carbon may even participate

16:29 in the geo-dynamo effect that powers Earth's magnetic field.

16:32 And we should also consider this a victory

16:34 for the philosophy at the heart of all

16:37 of physics that the secrets of nature are best

16:40 revealed by smashing things to other things really hard.

16:44 Earth's interior below us is in many ways

16:48 harder to explore than the vast cosmos above.

16:52 Fortunately, the secrets of both are encoded in vibrations that reach

16:56 the narrow sliver of our human world from both directions.

17:00 And so we build our maps of both astrophysical and geophysical space time.

Study with Looplines Download Captions Watch on YouTube