Jews with Heterodox Views: Joshua Stylman on DarkHorse
Bret Weinstein
0:00 Hey, folks, welcome to the DarkHorse podcast Inside Rail.
0:04 I am sitting this morning with my friend Joshua Stylman.
0:09 OK, if I call you Josh, please do.
0:11 All right.
0:12 Josh is a little hard to describe, but he's somebody you should know about.
0:18 At some point here, you should sign up for his substack,
0:21 which we will link in the description.
0:23 And I'll point you to a couple of pieces that are particularly excellent.
0:27 Josh is sort of I think he says it jokingly, but maybe a standup philosopher.
0:32 He's an independent researcher.
0:34 I know him through encounters at the Brownstone Institute.
0:39 In any case, Josh, welcome to DarkHorse.
0:42 Thank you for having me.
0:45 All right, Josh, I asked you to come on after reading a piece
0:49 that you put out must be a couple of weeks ago at this point.
0:55 And this piece kind of stopped me in my tracks because I have been.
1:01 Having a certain experience since October 7th of 2023,
1:06 and I've been having a hard time articulating it to people.
1:12 I'm, of course, Jewish, as my viewers know, I grew up in a secular Jewish home.
1:18 And, you know, I have a sort of complicated relationship with this.
1:22 I don't really understand people who have pride in their ethnicity.
1:28 I feel like am I supposed to be proud?
1:30 I'm a man.
1:31 No, it just happened to me.
1:32 I'm happy as one.
1:34 But it's not a matter of pride.
1:37 And I feel sort of the same way about Jewishness.
1:39 I got a ton out of it growing up.
1:42 But, you know, I don't know that it makes I don't know that it
1:46 makes logical sense to be proud of something that you had no hand in.
1:51 And in any case, I've been sort of trying
1:54 to keep my head above water as a a Jewish
1:59 person who tries to think very carefully about things
2:03 in an era where that has become extremely difficult.
2:06 And the piece that you wrote described my experience quite well,
2:12 and many of the thoughts that I wrestle with.
2:17 Is it safe to even express them?
2:20 Came through in your piece so beautifully that I decided you
2:23 and I should have a conversation that that would be useful for me.
2:28 I hope for you, but certainly for the audience who might
2:33 not know how people like you or me think about this.
2:38 Our first sponsor this week is Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club.
2:41 Have you ever had a relationship with a product that was
2:44 so uncomplicatedly positive that when you get a box from them,
2:47 you are over the moon with excitement?
2:49 That's how it is with fresh pressed olive oil.
2:51 Always amazing, never disappointing and perennially delicious and nutritious.
2:55 Go to getfreshdarkhorse.com and get a bottle of one
2:59 of the world's finest artisanal olive oils for just one dollar.
3:03 Olive oil is a succulent, delicious food that like pretty much all fats
3:06 is best when it's fresh, fresher the better.
3:09 Olives are actually a fruit making olive oil a kind of fruit juice.
3:13 And like all fruit juices, olive oil is at its peak of flavor
3:16 and nutritional potency when it's fresh pressed.
3:18 But most supermarket olive oil sit on the shelf for months or even years,
3:22 growing stale, dull, flavorless, even rancid.
3:25 The solution is to have fresh pressed artisanal olive
3:28 oil shipped directly to you after each new harvest,
3:30 when the oils flavor and nutrients are at their peak.
3:33 Once again, go to getfreshdarkhorse.com and get a bottle of one of the world's
3:38 finest artisanal olive oils fresh from the newest harvest for just one dollar.
3:43 How can you pass that up?
3:44 Fresh-Pressed Olive Oil Club is the brainchild of TJ Robinson,
3:47 also known as "the olive oil hunter." He brings the freshest,
3:51 most flavorful, nutrient rich olive oils from harvest to your door.
3:55 Olive oil is of course a cornerstone of Mediterranean diets.
3:58 But if you've never had excellent fresh olive oil,
4:01 you may wonder what all the fuss is about.
4:03 TJ's farm fresh oils are incredible.
4:05 That is where the flavor is and TJ's farm fresh
4:08 olive oils are amazingly flavorful and distinct from one another.
4:11 We've used several different varietals now across a wide array
4:14 of delicious foods as marinades on meat and for roasting vegetables,
4:18 fresh in salads or drizzled on cold soups or on freshly grilled halloumi cheese.
4:23 We've made olive oil cake and Italian pesto
4:25 and a Venezuelan green sauce rich in cilantro.
4:29 Every single varietal we've had is superb and the health benefits of olive
4:33 oil are extensive from being high
4:35 in antioxidants to helping prevent Alzheimer's.
4:38 This is a fabulous flavorful fat that you'll never want to run out of.
4:42 As an introduction to TJ Robinson's fresh pressed olive oil club,
4:45 he will send you a full sized $39 bottle
4:48 of one of the world's finest artisanal olive oils.
4:51 Fresh from the new harvest for just $1 to help him cover shipping.
4:54 And there's no commitment to buy anything now or ever.
4:57 Get your free $39 bottle for just
5:00 $1 shipping and taste the difference freshness makes.
5:03 Go to getfreshdarkhorse.com.
5:05 That's getfreshdarkhorse.com for a free bottle and pay just $1 shipping.
5:10 So do you want to say something about
5:11 your, your upbringing and where that places you?
5:16 Sure.
5:16 Well, first of all, thank you for the kind words.
5:17 It means a lot to me.
5:19 Um, you are a very thoughtful person who clearly considers all perspectives.
5:25 And this is a really nuanced one that we're,
5:28 it seems like we're not supposed to talk about.
5:31 Um, I have a tendency to talk about
5:32 the things you're not supposed to talk about.
5:36 So, um, you know, I grew up a progeny of Holocaust survivors.
5:42 Um, half the, essentially half the family,
5:45 everybody I knew, uh, was in the camps, everyone that lived, uh,
5:49 my grandmother was the sole survivor of a town of people.
5:52 Um, all six siblings, parents, neighbors, all gone.
5:57 Um, I am named after her oldest brother who burned in a gas chamber.
6:01 Um, my other grandfather was a freedom fighter
6:07 who fought for Israeli independence or so I'm told.
6:12 And he was Menachem Begin's personal bodyguard for about 20 years.
6:16 So I, I understand certainly the trauma
6:20 associated with that whole generation and those people,
6:24 it was, it was passed down to me.
6:27 Um, I heard never again from the time I was in the crib.
6:30 Uh, I was not raised particularly religious.
6:35 So, you know, this is always a, you know, you sent me a note and said,
6:38 do you want to talk about what it's like being Jewish in America right now?
6:41 And I was like, well, I don't know that I'm qualified to speak to that.
6:45 I can't remember the last time I went to a temple.
6:48 Um, we're, we're not raising our kids Jewish in any way.
6:51 And yet somehow culturally I'm entirely Jewish.
6:54 I think I probably identified more with Jewish as someone who watched Seinfeld.
6:58 Um, then as someone who studied Talmud.
7:01 So, you know, there's, but like you,
7:03 and I think it's a really good, a really good framing.
7:07 This is just who I am right now.
7:08 Identity, our identity that we inherit is the one we just inherit.
7:14 Um, of course I may identify as a Muslim tomorrow.
7:17 Now I'll change that.
7:19 Um, but for the time being, this is what it is right now.
7:22 I guess I'm looking around and I'm watching,
7:25 I'm watching the world go crazy across a lot of different areas, right?
7:30 And pick your topic.
7:31 And this one seems to be one of the moment that's been bubbling for a few years.
7:35 And I hope we can enter that, but I'm watching sort of, let's
7:39 all over simplify and just say half the people say, look around.
7:44 It's the Jews.
7:45 Why do you think they've been kicked out of 109 countries or whatever it is?
7:48 And you see the other half saying, Oh my God, we're so oppressed.
7:53 Look, we've been kicked out of 109 countries.
7:56 And I think that is the mechanism that I've become obsessed with.
8:01 So it, to me, it's either quite obviously it's the Jews
8:04 or it's someone who wants us to think it's the Jews.
8:09 Yeah.
8:10 Uh, I'm watching the same dynamic and I
8:13 will say that it actually strikes at the heart
8:16 of what I would have taken to be the core
8:20 of Jewish identity for lack of a better term.
8:25 So the house I grew up in was really built around careful thinking.
8:33 And, you know, we had arguments at the dinner table about things,
8:38 some of which mattered and some of which
8:41 were just abstractions that were interesting puzzles.
8:45 But what I understood, I mean,
8:47 even just the fact you say that being Jewish is at the core of your identity,
8:52 but you can't remember the last time you were in a temple.
8:55 Well, Judaism is, I don't want to say the unique tradition,
8:58 but maybe it even is.
9:00 It's a tradition in which your relationship to the metaphysical claims is
9:09 not central to what it is to be part of that tradition.
9:16 You know, in most traditions, if you were to become an atheist,
9:19 well, then you're no longer a Catholic or something like that.
9:25 But for Jews, I always understood that we
9:30 were kind of allowed to navigate our own relationship
9:34 with the supernatural and that it still did not
9:40 liberate you from the requirement to be very deliberate.
9:46 In your thinking and after October 7th, like immediately after,
9:51 which is one of the things that comes through in your piece.
9:56 The nuanced thinking seemed to evaporate, you know,
10:03 like isopropyl alcohol that you spray on the counter.
10:06 It just vanished.
10:08 And suddenly there was a perspective that you were expected to adopt.
10:20 And if you didn't, you were morally suspect,
10:22 which is already an analytical violation.
10:26 The idea that your moral position is contingent on an analytical
10:32 conclusion is just a nonstarter where I grew up.
10:37 So in any case, watching that happen has been very troubling for me.
10:44 And one of the other things that you describe in your piece
10:48 is that I've described this on many topics and this one,
10:53 it's especially clear that everybody seems
10:57 to be running an algorithm where either
11:00 you agree with the totality of their perspective or you're with the enemy.
11:08 And the problem is, if you try to be
11:09 nuanced when that algorithm is running for people,
11:13 you become everyone's enemy because you're not
11:15 saying what any of them are saying.
11:18 And instead of thinking, huh, that's interesting.
11:20 Josh is a guy who has spotted difficult things early.
11:25 If he's saying something different than what I'm saying,
11:28 maybe I should think carefully about it.
11:29 He could be wrong.
11:30 That's my instinct.
11:31 But it's at least worth my going back and checking my own
11:35 math in order to see if he's trying to tell me something.
11:39 Well, I don't see any evidence that that's what's going on.
11:41 It's really just a question of teams and jerseys
11:46 and accusations about character for anyone who doesn't fall into line.
11:52 And that seems to me the opposite of the values that I was raised with.
11:58 I'm the Yankees.
11:59 You're the Red Sox.
12:00 We hate each other.
12:02 We have nothing in common.
12:03 Everything you say I am opposed to.
12:05 And I know you are opposed to everything I stand for.
12:09 And as the algorithm takes more control of our thinking,
12:15 it seems as if we keep getting sliced and diced and eventually eventually
12:20 we're sort of atomized into our own unit of one staring at this screen,
12:25 getting the preordained information that we're supposed to know.
12:30 Based on our own pre-existing worldview, right?
12:33 So it seems as if the end I get into a lot of this in the piece,
12:38 I sort of open up with a dear friend of mine had a metaphor not
12:42 that long ago about how essentially if you lock me in a cage with a pitbull,
12:47 I know I need to kill it before it kills me.
12:50 But did it dawn on me who who locked us in the cage together?
12:53 And I sort of use that as a vessel for the story.
12:55 Right.
12:56 So I've become obsessed with that idea.
13:00 And it seems like they're the cage builders are very prevalent in our lives,
13:04 particularly as we get disconnected with nature
13:07 and our neighbors and eye contact and all that.
13:09 Now, most of our reality is filtered through an LED screen.
13:16 So at this stage, you know, the essay is really kind of about that.
13:20 It's about the cage, certainly more than it is about about me being Jewish.
13:24 Right.
13:24 It's, you know, I'm fascinated with this topic of Jewish
13:28 identity and what it means at this particular moment in time,
13:31 because I think it's really, really important.
13:35 But that said, that's the mechanism
13:38 and it's applicable to lots of different topics.
13:41 Right.
13:41 It's been the most obvious that's going on now for forever, really.
13:46 But you've been amplified over the last decade
13:48 or so is the left and right political reality.
13:52 Or, you know, and all the culture wars that fall
13:54 under that, whether it's the trends thing or whatever.
13:58 Based on what you just said, I sort of realized that during Covid.
14:03 Right.
14:03 When I and I think a lot of us have
14:05 this experience in our own little mix of the world,
14:07 some more public than others.
14:08 Right.
14:09 And I thought, you know, because it clearly something was going on, right?
14:13 There was fear in the air and everyone just sort of followed the herd.
14:16 And you have to assume the experts know.
14:18 And I know you've talked extensively about all this, you know,
14:20 through the last few years.
14:21 And you've certainly been influential in not just the what I think about it,
14:28 but the way I think more so the way I think about it.
14:31 Right.
14:31 And kind of zooming out.
14:32 And it seems like every time you zoom out,
14:33 you realize your aperture isn't quite wide enough
14:36 to understand the magnitude of what we're dealing with.
14:39 But I recall talking to some friends, you know, and realizing, well, hey,
14:44 maybe these drugs aren't really tested or maybe
14:47 that mask doesn't work or, you know, whatever the case may be.
14:49 We all have our own unique covid story.
14:53 You would think as I'm a pretty reliable guy like, you know,
14:56 I have a really good reputation in business and personally
14:59 and over that I know I'm in my 50s.
15:02 Right.
15:02 Over decades.
15:04 I am not someone who talks out of my ass bluntly.
15:08 And I would have thought that when I was
15:10 ringing alarm bells saying there's danger here, pay attention.
15:15 And I'm not going to tell you what to think.
15:16 But here's here's a toolkit.
15:17 Right.
15:17 Here's here's Peter Breggans book.
15:19 Here's whatever.
15:20 Right.
15:22 I got this, you know, just ears closed and it didn't fit their frame of reality.
15:28 And the perspective that I got played back to me
15:30 through mutual friends or whatever was Joshua and crazy.
15:34 And it was so reductive and so dismissive when, in fact,
15:37 I was simply presenting a point of view that hadn't hurt.
15:41 And in part, as you all know, it hadn't been heard because it was entirely
15:46 filtered through the reality that's being constructed for us.
15:49 So I guess when the when the 10-7 stuff rolled around.
15:55 You know, it was early in the morning.
15:57 I'm in the East Coast.
15:58 It was early in the morning.
15:58 Our time to my wife was up and, you know, she I woke up,
16:02 I looked over and I was like, oh, my God, there was a terrible attack in Israel.
16:06 And I just looked at her and said.
16:10 Medical freedoms toast because it was instinctively I just knew.
16:14 And I'm on a bunch of message boards and one in particular that was
16:20 vibrant was like a bunch of dissidents from New York that all found each other.
16:24 And unlike I mentioned it in the piece, but unlike a lot of these people,
16:28 I was still attached to my friends and family.
16:30 In fact, we're a strange we're a strange group because we've
16:33 never gotten we never my friends never agreed on anything until COVID.
16:38 And it sort of brought us together for the first time in a while.
16:42 People on this board were mostly strange,
16:44 like friends and family totally turned against them.
16:46 You know, the stories you've been talking about for years now.
16:51 Literally, people sitting around making fun of the news
16:54 and how ridiculous it is and, you know, mockingbird all of it.
16:57 Right.
16:58 By that night, literally by that night,
17:00 people quitting this message board in a huff ever reverted back to the priors.
17:04 I hate you now.
17:05 And oh, you're on that side and you're on that side.
17:07 It's everything you just mentioned about the team.
17:09 So it was truly disheartening.
17:12 And I think now, you know,
17:13 we're two and a half years later and it's it's only amplified.
17:18 Well, I don't know if you remember this or even encountered it.
17:22 Frankly, I don't remember the exact context and whether you were present.
17:26 But immediately after October 7th,
17:30 a I was alarmed that the story of October 7th didn't add up.
17:35 And I think over time, the validity of those concerns has become evident
17:41 to many more than it was initially evident to.
17:45 But the fact that the story didn't add up and the fact that it
17:51 felt like a direct hit on the coalition that had grown up around covid,
17:58 that had I mean, a coalition that had unusual capacity to fight power.
18:05 You know, it had sort of learned
18:06 on the battlefield that it had tools that the enemy
18:11 couldn't deal with, that it had the ability
18:16 to bootstrap capacities that were necessary to fight.
18:20 That coalition was very powerful and it played
18:22 a big role in the twenty twenty four election.
18:26 So my thought was that coalition, whatever it is,
18:32 is on Goliath's mind because Goliath has been bruised by it.
18:37 And then when it evaporated, as you point out on October 8th,
18:42 twenty twenty three, it felt like it was shattered.
18:47 And I said probably unwisely at the time, I said.
18:53 Something to the effect of I wonder if.
18:57 This is not an accident.
18:59 And let's just say in retrospect,
19:03 I'm willing to accept that maybe that was a conjecture that was overly
19:10 context dependent because I had lived at the heart of the fight over covid.
19:13 And I watched the coalition that I was so
19:18 proud to be a part of destroyed in an instant.
19:22 And the historical event that had destroyed it was in some way inorganic.
19:28 I felt like this is about something or at least potentially so.
19:35 And then I took a lot of crap for that because it sounds paranoid and insane.
19:39 And in retrospect, it's certainly, you know, I think it's incorrect.
19:41 And certainly, you know,
19:42 I think it's incumbent on us to wonder about such things.
19:46 We should consider all hypotheses and the ones that are easily dismissed.
19:49 All the better.
19:50 That simplifies the job.
19:52 But but anyway, I said it out loud and.
19:58 You know, years later, I'm now trying to grapple with what what
20:02 part of that suspicion was actually well founded,
20:07 maybe pointed at the wrong object, maybe the there was something maybe it
20:11 was understood by whatever participated in making
20:17 that attack what it was or capitalized on it in the aftermath or both.
20:25 Whatever that thing was,
20:26 has a general instinct about what serves its interest and the division,
20:31 the inability of people who,
20:33 as you point out, the day before would have mocked anything
20:37 in The New York Times were suddenly accepting the presentation as delivered.
20:44 And if I can just say one more thing about it, I feel like there is a adaptive
20:50 evolutionary mechanism for coming together and rallying around.
20:57 I don't use this term pejoratively,
20:58 but rallying around a myth when it is necessary to do so for survival.
21:03 And I feel like that built in mechanism is being artificially triggered in order
21:09 to make sure that we can't point ourselves the right way down the battlefield.
21:16 Yes, to all that, I can draw a straight line
21:19 to a another tragic event and use one of the taglines,
21:25 which was they hate us for our freedom.
21:28 Right.
21:29 So and it it it took me a minute.
21:32 It took a dear friend of mine, who was also my red pill for Covid,
21:36 to demonstrate that we're not going to get into the whole nine eleven thing.
21:40 But when you start to understand that these stories are preposterous,
21:44 like truly preposterous, the official story is a bigger conspiracy theory
21:50 than the conspiracy theorist version of the story.
21:53 Right.
21:54 And we again, we won't really litigate all that.
21:56 But the.
21:57 The fact that you're not even permitted to ask
22:00 these questions without serious social consequence should be the reveal.
22:06 Yes.
22:06 And if I can sort of close that loop.
22:11 I think what happened to Heather and me over Covid.
22:15 It's a very interesting example of something.
22:19 It's a very clean example, because at the beginning of Covid,
22:24 Heather and I pretty much accepted the story that we were told about this virus.
22:30 In fact, when Heather and I were we went into the Amazon,
22:36 into a remote field station, about as remote as you can get.
22:41 To finish our book, first draft of our book was
22:45 completed as we were in the forest disconnected from the world.
22:49 And as we emerged from the from the Amazon,
22:52 we came to a military checkpoint that you had to cross through,
22:56 which was the first place that we had connectivity in weeks.
23:01 And as luck would have it, the first case of Covid,
23:04 I think in the first acknowledged case of Covid,
23:07 at least in South America, maybe it was in the New World,
23:11 had emerged in Ecuador where we were.
23:15 So the news was sort of focused on.
23:19 What this virus was, and we were sort of had our attention called to it,
23:24 and I thought, what's that?
23:26 And it was like, oh, OK, a virus has emerged from a bat in China,
23:33 and I had been a bat biologist in graduate school.
23:37 And so I decided to check the story and just make sure it added up.
23:42 And, you know, I knew the family of bats in question.
23:44 I looked at the basic claim and I sent out a tweet that said,
23:51 yeah, superficially, this story adds up.
23:55 And I got an angry response from a longtime follower who said,
23:59 so it's just a coincidence that this virus
24:03 emerged on the doorstep of a BSL four laboratory.
24:07 Studying these exact viruses.
24:09 And I thought.
24:11 What the hell don't I know?
24:14 So I retracted.
24:15 There's literally it's almost exactly an hour, like almost to the second.
24:19 I sent a second tweet that said, wait a minute, I don't know what I don't know.
24:24 Let me dig deeper.
24:25 And so anyway, my point is this.
24:29 Heather and I started out ready to accept
24:32 what we were being told about this global event.
24:36 And as we pushed back on particular things that were
24:41 clearly being presented in a way that wasn't accurate,
24:43 the right response should have been, oh, OK, let's adjust the story.
24:48 Let's, you know, let's get to the truth.
24:52 That's what we're supposed to be about.
24:54 And the reaction was the exact inverse.
24:56 So the story over the course of several years was that as we took our biology
25:00 toolkit and pointed it at covid and looked
25:03 at the things that didn't add up as presented,
25:06 instead of the story getting better and more robust,
25:09 what we got back was hostility, punishment, misdirection.
25:17 And that tells the story.
25:18 It says this story is not about reality.
25:23 This story is the cage you're describing.
25:27 Somebody has put us in a cage and anybody who notices
25:30 the cage and starts talking about the cage is the problem.
25:35 And once you've seen that, once you've had the experience of being told,
25:40 don't think about this, you know more or less where you are.
25:45 Thinking about this is how you figure out how to get out
25:48 of the cage and the people who built the cage need you in it.
25:52 So we're going to threaten you until you give up that that instinct.
25:59 I think it's ridiculous that you think viruses are real.
26:01 I'll just say that you do.
26:04 I'm just I don't want to get I don't want to get
26:07 the hate now from talking to you about viruses in the first place.
26:11 I'm making I'm making a point.
26:13 Right.
26:13 And it's do you want to clarify your position?
26:16 My position is my position on most things, which is I don't know.
26:20 And I you know, we we got thrust into this thing.
26:24 Right.
26:24 And yes, there were people like my friend who I
26:26 mentioned were far ahead of me 20 years ahead of me.
26:29 And in terms of understanding that the institutions weren't just
26:32 wrong about stuff that they were lying and suppressing actual truth.
26:38 You know, truth, you know,
26:40 verifiable truths, suppressing really important thinkers through,
26:44 you know, through centuries and things of that nature.
26:48 I guess my own my own journey on some of this stuff
26:52 is that I really thought I was a pretty awake person.
26:56 You know, I knew like, you know,
26:58 to question things like nine, like all the worst.
27:01 Let's just say that I've questioned the wars,
27:03 question the pharmaceutical industry.
27:06 Although I'm I'm such a big jackass that when
27:09 I wasn't paying attention at all during Covid,
27:11 because like a lot of people I was disoriented.
27:15 Right.
27:15 So, you know, Covid hit.
27:18 I lived in New York City.
27:20 I owned a brewery there.
27:22 I was just so grateful that we had a place
27:26 about two hours north that we could escape to.
27:29 I remember telling my wife, pack our bags.
27:32 We may be there for a long time.
27:34 I was following someone I knew who lived in China,
27:37 warning me that this thing was coming.
27:39 And I bought it.
27:40 I was scared.
27:42 You know, I got here and I wasn't I
27:44 just I knew there was a culture war going on.
27:48 I wasn't even paying attention to it.
27:49 I was so busy trying to hold my business and my family together
27:53 with Ducky working like 18 hours a day in a physical world business,
27:57 trying to pivot to be an e-commerce company overnight.
28:00 Homeschooling my kids.
28:02 I'm like, we never had to wear masks because we, you know,
28:04 we we live in the woods, which is now my full time residence.
28:10 It was only a little later.
28:12 I was I was stupid enough.
28:14 I got the first jab of J&J.
28:17 Literally rationalized it with I've put so
28:20 much shit in my body through the years.
28:22 How bad could this be?
28:24 Which is embarrassing to verbalize, by the way,
28:27 particularly as you know, as a covid dissident.
28:30 It just makes me a fool and I'll own that.
28:33 A friend of mine, I knew I knew the M.R.A.
28:36 was a thing.
28:37 And truly, I wasn't even paying attention to it.
28:40 A friend of mine got me a copy of Breggett's book,
28:42 which I had mentioned that I went from like
28:44 zero to genocide in about five years ago.
28:46 I was like, I'm going to do it in five minutes.
28:47 Like this, this makes no sense.
28:49 The way my buddy who is a scientist explained it to me.
28:53 And this was, by the way, like a week after I had gotten job,
28:56 the way my buddy explained it to me, it's it's how did he say it?
29:00 It's like trying to cure a headache with a gunshot to the face.
29:05 Headache's gone.
29:07 So except it wasn't even that good
29:10 because even the claims of it being effective.
29:15 But for me, so I was like, what the hell is going on?
29:18 It took me to the core.
29:21 I started pulling back the layers and I've
29:23 been interested in crypto for a while.
29:26 And I was like, oh, my God, they're doing vaccine mandates.
29:31 I always wondered how they were going to usher in central bank digital currency.
29:36 Oh, this is how they're going to do it.
29:37 And it all just kind of clicked.
29:40 And then we started.
29:41 I got together with like a little study group that I'm still
29:43 in five years later that which is just some of my closest friends.
29:47 And there's a couple of scientists and a doctor
29:48 and a couple of people that investigate fraud.
29:51 So it's a pretty eclectic group of people.
29:53 But mostly the thread, the through line was just concerned parents.
29:56 Right.
29:57 It's a bunch of concerned dads that were all sharing notes.
30:00 And we started pulling back the layers like, oh, wait a second.
30:05 This is a financial crime, first and foremost.
30:08 And then, you know, now, you know,
30:09 we know it's the greatest upward transfer of wealth, arguably in human history.
30:14 This is, you know, we eventually you get to the great
30:17 reset and we kept zooming out further and further like,
30:21 oh, wait, Pearl Harbor is a false flag, too.
30:24 And it's sort of like you go through any moment in history.
30:27 And now, you know, I'm forgive the expression,
30:30 but, you know, I've gone full retard.
30:33 And I'm sort of in the space where and again,
30:36 I can consider an idea without believing it.
30:40 But I also know that I need to reopen
30:42 the book on things that I thought was fully close.
30:45 Oh, I I fully agree with that.
30:47 Let me just say a couple of things in passing here.
30:51 One, you're evidencing the.
30:56 Key skill of the moment.
30:59 And I'm increasingly obsessed with it.
31:05 Acknowledging that you got stuff wrong is incredibly painful,
31:11 but necessary to coherent thought never has
31:16 been more necessary than in our current moment,
31:19 because the ability for pure fiction, not myth that's useful,
31:25 but pure fiction to be passed off as fact has never been greater.
31:31 The sophistication of the fiction mechanism is profound.
31:36 And so your ability to look at what you thought and say,
31:42 yeah, got that one wrong.
31:44 Don't love it.
31:45 But it's causing me to reinvestigate other things that I was pretty sure of.
31:49 That is that's the coin of the realm as far as I'm concerned.
31:54 And it's an incredibly rare skill at this moment.
31:57 People are punished for exploring it.
32:00 So even people who have a primordial
32:02 version of it are not elaborating that skill.
32:05 They're retreating from it.
32:07 So anyway, that's kind of I think why
32:09 you and I are able to have this conversation.
32:11 I got lots of stuff wrong and I'm investigating
32:13 lots of things that I was pretty sure of.
32:16 I'm alarmed to hear you say that Pearl Harbor was a false flag.
32:21 And I'm hoping that you're about to tell me false flag is the wrong term,
32:25 that the story is more complex and that the attack was known to be coming.
32:32 Are you going to tell me that there was an actual false flag?
32:36 I won't.
32:36 I know I don't know.
32:38 At a minimum, the story was far more
32:40 complex and they knew the attack was coming.
32:42 That much there is evidence of.
32:45 So.
32:48 I don't think it makes sense for us
32:49 that that's that's probably a whole show into itself,
32:51 although you should do a false flag show on DarkHorse,
32:54 because I'm sort of at the point where my assumption
32:57 is if I'm reading about it in The New York Times,
33:00 it is probably in some way, at least manufactured or distorted at a minimum.
33:07 And I'm far more interested in whatever they're not printing.
33:11 Oh, 100 percent.
33:13 As long as we are here, let me run something by you,
33:17 just a model for how to think about these things.
33:21 We have a unresolved conflict in civilization about how
33:26 to think about what I will loosely call history.
33:31 And the problem is there are a bunch of realms in which two distinct
33:37 things are filed under the same heading
33:40 and we keep tripping over ourselves over it.
33:43 So to give you an example,
33:46 psychology is a therapeutic art that is a replacement for a role
33:51 that used to be played by friends and family and clergy.
33:56 And it's now been turned into a commodity.
33:59 We can argue about the wisdom of that.
34:02 But the point is that therapeutic art psychology flies under
34:05 the same heading as an academic field in which we study cognition.
34:11 And the two things have very little to do with each other.
34:14 Right.
34:14 The person, the psychologist who sits in the chair
34:16 and is able to help you understand your own predicament so
34:20 you can improve the quality of your life is not
34:24 proceeding from what we know about cognition in a scientific sense,
34:27 because in fact, we know very little.
34:31 So the problem with history is that history is two things.
34:36 History is an academic discipline whose mandate
34:39 is to discover what actually happened and why.
34:44 History is also a set of myths that allow us to function.
34:48 And I don't mean fictions.
34:50 I mean, there are myths about a people who we are,
34:53 who the founding fathers were, what it means about our values,
34:57 what it means about our rights and obligations in the world.
35:01 Those stories have a relationship to the truth.
35:04 I assume that Ben Franklin and Thomas
35:06 Jefferson and Adams and all the rest existed.
35:10 And I assume that their story is not made up.
35:14 But I also assume that the picture that we hand over is
35:18 really about functioning more than it
35:20 is about the details that actually occurred.
35:25 And so the point is the academic historians
35:27 and the custodians of the myth are tripping
35:31 over each other because we haven't agreed whether
35:35 history is a functional phenomenon or an analytic phenomenon.
35:41 So.
35:44 There is I mean, you can see how that dynamic applies here,
35:48 but there's a question about.
35:51 What one needs to believe and.
35:57 What's true and we in the moment are in what I call the Cartesian crisis,
36:03 where because the fiction engine, which is not about myth,
36:07 myth is functional fiction is lies, right?
36:11 Now, obviously, there's fiction that is labeled as fiction in the bookstore.
36:16 That's not what I'm talking about.
36:17 But when The New York Times publishes lies to get
36:19 you to behave in a way that's not good for you,
36:22 but is good for whoever motivated the lying,
36:24 that's a whole different architecture.
36:26 It's something that should be resisted at all costs.
36:29 And I don't know that it's true,
36:31 but my guess is The New York Times at one time had a bias
36:37 that there were always fictions in it that served the people who motivated them,
36:44 but that it also had a truth seeking
36:47 element which has more or less evaporated over time.
36:51 And because The New York Times is a mirror for every
36:54 other truth seeking operation which has been captured and commandeered.
36:59 We now are left chasing our own tails over stuff like do viruses exist, right?
37:08 And at some point, you question everything such that you're completely paralyzed
37:11 by the fact that you don't know you're not sure of any of the basics,
37:16 either at the level of myth or the level of analysis.
37:19 You just don't know what you've been fed that's garbage.
37:24 Yes.
37:25 So, you know, it's cliche to say history was written by the victors,
37:29 but it seems to be the case.
37:32 I guess what I keep coming back to is two things.
37:36 That one, the lies must be really,
37:39 really significant for them to go to such great lengths to preserve them.
37:46 What are the fictions where I would use them interchangeably in this case?
37:51 And two, what else are they lying about?
37:55 Because the answer and which is why,
37:58 at least for my mileage is I need to consider
38:02 that everything I thought I knew may not be true
38:06 and that it does require some epistemological humility because I realized
38:12 that I'm a middle age man who actually doesn't know anything.
38:15 I went through the Prussian school system and took Rockefeller medicine.
38:21 And there's this architecture that in modernity we grow up with.
38:25 And to your point, you talked about it in the psychology frame,
38:29 but you can apply this broadly in terms of all the institutions.
38:33 So, yes, we've all been fed the same lines.
38:39 And it's I think at this point, you know,
38:42 and you have a very unique ability to frame
38:44 a particular thing in very accessible, simple terms.
38:48 And I love the Cartesian crisis.
38:49 I think it's perfect.
38:50 I think it's a perfect explanation of where we are at this particular moment.
38:55 And again, like, you know, my friend who my 9-11 friend was like,
39:00 hey, welcome to the party, man.
39:01 We're even for 20 years.
39:04 And, you know, to which I said, well,
39:05 you convinced me that that story didn't make sense.
39:08 I didn't understand.
39:09 I thought it was to start a war.
39:11 And it was about money.
39:12 And then I started zooming out.
39:14 I'm like, well, they control the printing press.
39:16 So they actually control the unit of they don't just control the money.
39:19 They they just find what value is.
39:21 So it has to be bigger than just that.
39:23 And then, you know, what I said to him, of course, is,
39:25 well, the JFK people wondered what the hell took you so long.
39:28 So, you know, but I think the thing is that the group keeps getting larger.
39:33 There's like a crack of light and it
39:36 doesn't seem like anyone's going to the other side.
39:39 Well, wait a second.
39:39 I agree with this completely until October 7th.
39:44 I think what you're you know,
39:46 the picture you paint where people wake up and they
39:49 don't go back to sleep is true in general.
39:55 Yeah.
39:55 But the unique thing about what happened in the aftermath of October 7th was
39:59 that it actually did pull a huge number of people back across the line.
40:04 And a that's just an interesting fact of history.
40:10 And B, I mean, I would say we're in an arms race at the very least,
40:15 no matter what version of October 7th, you believe.
40:21 We are in an arms race where even
40:23 if the enemy is just simply capitalizing on events,
40:27 the enemy is getting better at recovering its.
40:31 Unwitting foot soldiers by delivering events that are
40:36 targeted at particular locations in your psyche.
40:42 And to your earlier point.
40:45 I was raised with never again, too.
40:48 And as you say in your essay on the topic.
40:52 The fact of never again in a analytical Jewish home.
41:00 Came with an analysis of.
41:04 The fact that it could happen here.
41:08 Right.
41:08 It can happen here is an essential thing because
41:12 what it means it builds a an alert mechanism.
41:15 You must be alert to the things that tell
41:17 you it is beginning to happen here because why?
41:20 Because the people who survived were the ones who
41:22 didn't tell themselves this is bad, but it will pass.
41:26 Those people died.
41:27 And the people who said, Holy crap.
41:31 And fled.
41:33 They lived.
41:34 So I mean, I'm painting with too broad a brush,
41:36 but we have that alert mechanism.
41:40 And I think somebody found it.
41:41 And because it's it's not rational.
41:46 What it is is developmental.
41:48 It was built in in childhood and for good reason.
41:52 But because it exists, it's a vulnerability.
41:56 Somebody built a back door into your operating
41:58 system and then somebody found it.
42:01 And anyway, there's more to say there,
42:04 but I'm interested in your reaction to that.
42:06 No, my reaction is I fell into my own trap.
42:09 Right.
42:09 So because, yes, I thought I was going to be a bad guy.
42:11 I thought the wind was blowing one way and ten seven stopped me in my tracks.
42:15 And I think the mechanism you're describing simply in one word is trauma.
42:21 Right.
42:22 So we what I know you call it Goliath.
42:25 I'll call it the cabal.
42:26 You know, I care less about the definition.
42:28 I know we're talking about the whatever this force is.
42:31 Right.
42:32 That understands humanity in a very profound
42:36 way and tends to, I believe, exploit.
42:41 The very best of us or our best attributes, let's say,
42:45 empathy and tap into our worst, which is fear and trauma.
42:50 Right.
42:52 You know, I think that I don't doubt because I grew
42:54 up how I did that my family's trauma was very real.
42:59 I don't doubt that for a second.
43:02 I understand, you know, when they used to wake up in the middle
43:05 of the night in nightmares and, you know, watching your own relatives die.
43:09 There's that will fuck you up forever.
43:13 Right.
43:13 And I'm keenly aware of that.
43:16 I think what the trick is, is to take the real grievances, you know,
43:20 the historical grievances, the generational grievances, you know,
43:24 the kind that people carry like deep,
43:27 deep in their body and maybe aren't even aware of or don't
43:30 even verbalize and then amplify them and aim it everywhere
43:34 to the point where you're you're literally not allowed to talk about
43:40 certain things because you because you're deemed as anti whatever anti somatic.
43:46 In this case, you know, anti women,
43:48 anti trans insert your you know, the flavor of the day.
43:53 I'm at this stage.
43:55 And it's also interesting because the smartest people I know,
43:58 the quote unquote smartest people,
44:00 the most successful people as deemed by societal standard
44:03 seem to be the most susceptible in my observation.
44:09 And I think that's because they they think
44:10 they have the toolkit to figure it out.
44:12 They read they read smarter books than you do.
44:14 So I understand it.
44:16 I want to I want to build on that for a second.
44:19 You know, the joke, you will have heard it many times that, you know,
44:23 every Jewish holiday comes down to the same thing.
44:26 They tried to kill us.
44:28 They didn't succeed.
44:29 Let's eat.
44:30 That joke contains a deep truth, I think, which is this.
44:43 People, children who grow up in a war.
44:48 Have immunities that the rest of us do not have.
44:51 Right.
44:51 If the bomb started to fall around you right now,
44:54 your primordial circuits would kick in and you would find yourself,
44:59 I don't know, quivering under the desk,
45:01 not sure how to even think about your next move.
45:04 But if you've had bombs falling all around you,
45:06 you've watched people blown apart,
45:08 you can metabolize this so that you can act in a coherent way.
45:13 Right.
45:13 It's just a natural fact of your developmental experience.
45:17 And for soldiers or maybe more to the point for special forces, folks,
45:22 they're put through a training regimen that breaks their primordial response so
45:28 that they can function well under circumstances
45:32 that would render an ordinary person paralyzed.
45:37 So Jews have a set of circuits to be analytical, to be funny,
45:43 to use all the tools at our disposal under the most abominable of circumstances.
45:47 That's part of the weird fact of being
45:52 a diaspora population that faces persecution regularly.
45:59 What has happened here is that a people that has
46:04 that capacity has been triggered to do something else.
46:10 And I'm going to talk neurologically here in a way that may be just pure myth.
46:15 I'm not going to talk about that.
46:17 I'm not arguing that this is the literal neurological fact,
46:20 but there's something that happens when people who are
46:24 ordinarily rational and capable are triggered by a deep,
46:29 especially a childhood trauma or maybe a generational trauma,
46:32 which is that they start reacting out of their amygdala.
46:37 Right.
46:38 A primordial self-preservation circuit kicks
46:42 in and sidelines your other capabilities.
46:47 And I think that's harder to do because Jewish homes do talk about never again.
46:54 And it can happen here.
46:55 It's harder to trigger this reflex into this not very effective,
47:00 but, you know, baseline self-protective fight or flight circuitry.
47:06 But I feel like it's happened, right, that the population of Jews.
47:12 I mean, I can't speak to Israeli Jews, but I can speak to diaspora Jews.
47:19 You and I both know many.
47:21 And I feel like the majority have been snapped into a primordial reflex,
47:30 even though the developmental experience that most of us have is,
47:36 you know, to be calmer and more rational and more capable
47:42 under the circumstances that would put other people into that framework.
47:47 I mean, trauma hijacks the nuance of everything.
47:52 Yeah, nuance is not possible when you're reacting out of trauma.
47:55 It's not possible.
47:56 Certainty is a whole lot cheaper than complexity.
48:00 We can digest it in tiny little nuggets and the slogans they provide for us.
48:04 Right.
48:04 So, I mean, this is this is the core of, I think, the whole the whole thing.
48:10 Right.
48:11 And again, we're talking about this particular thing that was triggered.
48:15 And I keep going back and this is this might sound weird.
48:18 But my little study group, remember when Kanye West came out and talked
48:23 and I mentioned this passing in the piece.
48:26 Remember when Kanye West came out,
48:27 it was in 2022 and the anti-Semitism seemed back in vogue.
48:32 And I remember we had a couple of friends like my son wears the Kanye shoes.
48:35 Should he should he be allowed to?
48:37 Which is also an interesting question unto itself.
48:41 But, you know, our little study group just was starting to I guess at the core,
48:45 the main thing we've been exploring is the notion of social engineering.
48:50 Right.
48:50 And you and I may or may not agree on this point.
48:53 Right.
48:53 And I don't have your evolutionary biology lens.
48:56 Right.
48:57 You've forgotten more today than I'll ever know in a lifetime about that.
49:01 Generous and wrong, but it's not really like I'm a dude
49:05 who sits in the woods and studies this weird stuff.
49:08 But I I have understood that much of what we see on the public stage,
49:14 I don't want to go so far as to say it's entirely scripted,
49:17 but it's certainly steered.
49:19 And this could be a longer conversation unto itself.
49:23 And I won't get into all the detail,
49:24 but the gist is that there there are people and organizations that have
49:30 existed for at least 100 years
49:32 that have been seeding ideas into our consciousness.
49:35 And they have evolved as the technological mediums have evolved.
49:41 Right.
49:42 From radio, from print to radio to television.
49:45 And now, of course, you know, to that algorithm machine that is going to put
49:49 us in our own little atomized unit, as I said.
49:52 So as you think about how that how that evolves,
49:55 I remember light bulbs started going off when Kanye was being anti-Semitic.
50:01 Why is this happening now?
50:02 And we were in the middle of a lot of research on mind control and MK Ultra,
50:08 which again might be a little out there for some some of your audience.
50:12 But it's it's it's a thing that's existed for centuries.
50:17 It was perfected post World War Two in the United States.
50:20 That you know, there there's congressional record of this sort of thing.
50:24 We started digging into Kanye and the as it turns out,
50:29 like the guy who who his trainer who reported
50:32 him had a very direct connection to Canadian special forces,
50:38 psychological operations, military,
50:41 which sounds a whole lot like maybe it's related to mind
50:44 control at the very place where the MK Ultra programs were created,
50:48 you know, 60, 70 years ago.
50:50 So this is interesting.
50:54 Is anti-Semitism about to come back and vote?
50:56 And then 10-7 happened.
50:58 It's like, oh, yeah, Kanye, the influencer was was a party to this in some way.
51:03 And maybe that's coincidence.
51:04 And that's not lost on me.
51:06 I know when you start, you know,
51:07 when you have a hammer, everything kind of looks like a nail.
51:10 But but that one stuck out like a little bit
51:12 of a thumb that it was a little bit ahead.
51:14 By the way, same same trainer allegedly
51:17 convinced Elliot Page to to become clear.
51:20 So you start to see, I would say at the core, what I try to do is spot patterns.
51:27 And if you zoom out far enough, you can see certain patterns.
51:30 And I'm not sure what they all mean.
51:33 And but I sense that there's a bunch of signal around some of this stuff.
51:38 And I think on this particular issue,
51:41 it is so deeply loaded for families like yours and mine
51:45 that we stick out like a sore thumb because we're
51:47 willing to pull back some of the things that because
51:48 we're willing to pull back some of the layers and say,
51:50 well, is that my is that my genetic programming or my my programming
51:55 through my upbringing at the dinner table or, you know,
51:58 is that is that what grandma told me or I don't know, or is it something else?
52:04 And it's weird.
52:05 It's really weird.
52:06 Like, again, to your point, like people who are really rational and understand
52:10 the game seem to slip right back into this one.
52:13 And again, I just want to say for the record, which seems to be a misconception,
52:17 whether it's technically a false flag or just a misrepresented story.
52:21 And I don't know the detail on all this stuff,
52:24 right, whether it's Pearl Harbor or 9-11 or 10-7.
52:28 There's clearly a manipulation of the truth
52:30 and a suppression of a part of the story.
52:32 I don't know exactly what it means, but I'm also not suggesting that it's fake.
52:37 I know with all this stuff, all of them,
52:40 there is real tragedy and there is there is real loss.
52:44 And people really, really do suffer like real suffering.
52:48 Death and destruction, you know, from all these false flags.
52:52 The thread through them all is that the trauma bets right now,
52:55 even throw the assassination of JFK in there.
52:59 You know, in the mind control thing, I had a whole thing about OJ Simpson being
53:02 sort of the first one of these that we saw, because if you recall,
53:05 do you remember the division in the reaction after the OJ trial,
53:10 depending on your race?
53:12 I am trying to remember.
53:14 I think Heather and I were out of the country in Latin America,
53:18 and so we saw something very different than Americans who were at home saw.
53:24 What did you say?
53:26 Well, I'm trying to remember it because
53:27 neither Heather nor I speak Spanish well,
53:30 so it's not like we're embedded in that culture
53:33 in anything other than a superficial way.
53:36 But we did see the kind of filtered reaction that makes it,
53:40 you know, used to be newspapers that made it to I can't remember.
53:45 I think we were in we were in Central America somewhere.
53:47 But anyway, point is, what I got from it,
53:50 which may not be an accurate representation, was that the the defense attorneys
54:00 in the trial successfully and not without a certain
54:07 amount of justification triggered a sense of righteous
54:15 indignation amongst blacks and people who profoundly sympathize,
54:24 because what happened was you had an actual Nazi
54:30 sympathizer on the LAPD involved in the mishandling of evidence.
54:37 And so at some level, it stopped mattering whether or not the whether or not
54:44 the evidence actually nailed him beyond a reasonable doubt,
54:48 because the point is the whole thing was unfair.
54:51 So even if you're guilty and then you're you're
54:55 prosecuted by a unfair system that really is evidencing racism,
55:02 then that becomes maybe the primordial concern.
55:06 And so you had a kind of a jury nullification of a compelling case.
55:11 And I will just add one other nuance, which is,
55:14 I think the prosecutors misunderstood a piece of evolutionary biology,
55:20 which if they had consulted somebody who knew what they were talking about,
55:24 they would have spotted coming, which is that they expected the femaleness
55:30 of jurors to override the racial identity.
55:37 And there's a very good reason that they should have expected that not to work.
55:41 And anyway, so I obviously have my own frame.
55:45 It's not what most people experience, but that's that's what I saw.
55:49 Fascinating.
55:51 Those were Jewish lawyers, right?
55:55 So one of the ones that was easy fish in a barrel.
56:00 Yeah, the point I was making, you have a really interesting perspective on that.
56:04 That's certainly more evolved than mine.
56:06 But the point I was making was that there was I just
56:09 I remember the split screen of like a bunch of white people reacting
56:14 and looking completely destitute over this as if the system failed them
56:18 and a bunch of black people jumping for joy as if they were vindicated.
56:23 Which you went the layer back into the mechanism
56:25 which may have caused that, which is which is fascinating.
56:30 My point is less about the what happened and.
56:33 Sort of what why and was that was this a layer of social engineering on its own?
56:39 You know, when I think we got on the topic on trauma, right?
56:42 And I think about these big public events that are made for TV
56:46 as big trauma vessels that we all that are all delivered to us.
56:50 And, you know, until seven years later in 2001, that was our generation's J.F.K.
56:55 moment.
56:56 We all knew where we were.
56:57 You were out of the country.
56:58 So maybe you didn't.
56:58 But those of us living here knew where we were when, you know, when the J.F.J.
57:02 chase was happening.
57:04 And then it played out every single day.
57:07 And it was, you know, that was before all the media was totally fractionalized.
57:12 Right.
57:12 And there were mass media stories that everyone
57:15 was getting and everyone was getting the same version.
57:17 And this was this was really, really interesting.
57:20 And again, I won't turn this into a thing about O.J.
57:22 Simpson, although I think the topic is really interesting.
57:25 You know, if you go back in time, right,
57:27 just before that, there are some other things happening societally.
57:31 And I look a lot of this through the lens of pop culture.
57:35 Right.
57:35 So I remember on the, you know, the sort of, you know,
57:38 the black person side, I remember like boys in the hood and gangster rap.
57:43 And that was, you know,
57:44 I'm part of the first generation of suburban white kids to listen to hip hop.
57:47 So I remember being really into that and really, you know,
57:50 and listening to it ironically and thinking it was awesome.
57:52 But I knew that that was people's real sort
57:54 of lived experience using the parlance of our times.
57:58 On the other side, I remember like Rush Limbaugh was on the ascent.
58:02 And if you remember a film called Falling Down with Michael Douglas,
58:05 which was like the, you know,
58:07 the the down and out white guy and like Ruby Ridge and Waco.
58:12 And I don't know.
58:13 I start to think about all these things in these clusters
58:16 of how they happen all around the same time.
58:19 And, you know, is this just emerging?
58:21 And then, you know, there's sort of an output.
58:24 And we think about these things because they happened.
58:26 Or were they ceded into our even subconsciously
58:29 into our psyche to believe a certain thing?
58:32 And then when there is an output, whether it's engineered or not,
58:36 we react in a way that has been programmed into us.
58:40 Yeah, we're predisposed to a reaction.
58:42 So even if it's actual events unfolding, the reaction is unorganic.
58:48 That's right.
58:49 And I've come to believe.
58:52 I want to go deeper on, you know, your thoughts on the emergent thing,
58:57 because I think that from what I've heard,
59:01 I haven't I haven't listened to read your whole catalog on this.
59:04 But I've heard you say things like there's emergent behavior that's happening.
59:08 And I certainly think the reaction is emergent.
59:13 Right.
59:13 Based on our own our own, you know, experiences growing up, our media diets.
59:22 You know, our relationship with the world or neighbors or friends, whatever.
59:25 Right.
59:26 But I think there's a kernel that's seated.
59:29 And, you know, I I think anyone who gets
59:32 into this social engineering stuff and starts looking in understands that, yeah,
59:37 there was there were certain things that were plugged in.
59:41 Well, and usually through like the through the various
59:44 tentacles of like politics and culture and even science.
59:49 And it's it's really, really unnerving when, you know,
59:54 because as a species and you'll probably correct
59:57 me and tell me the reasons I'm wrong, I think we're mimics.
1:00:01 Right.
1:00:01 Like I'm a father.
1:00:03 So I could have theoretically,
1:00:04 I could have taught my kids from the time they were very little.
1:00:08 You know, we eat dinner and then we go outside and we go cuddle with the trees.
1:00:13 That's part of our routine.
1:00:14 That's what we do.
1:00:15 And my, you know, they if they just lived
1:00:19 with me and they didn't have other outside influence,
1:00:20 they would probably go cuddle with the trees
1:00:23 because that's what our family does.
1:00:25 And I just wonder how much of this and I'm not saying
1:00:28 everyone's in on it because I understand that that would be an impossibility.
1:00:32 But I do think there are people playing their roles.
1:00:34 And I think I do think at the very
1:00:36 top there are kernels being planted and maybe they're loose.
1:00:39 They're steering us in a very particular
1:00:42 direction across a bunch of different topics.
1:00:45 And again, I've heard I've heard you and Heather talk about the trans stuff.
1:00:48 And I think that's maybe the most obvious example, because for a millennium,
1:00:53 there was no there was no question about, you know,
1:00:56 it was not offensive to say a human or a woman.
1:00:59 And somewhere along the line and you can look, you know,
1:01:03 you can look at the charts and I just
1:01:04 wrote a spike somewhere that became a controversial topic.
1:01:08 And that's that's insane.
1:01:11 I mean, I see that's like a flex.
1:01:14 It's a flex.
1:01:15 And that's not to take away.
1:01:16 I know gender dysmorphia is a real thing and that's not to take
1:01:19 away someone who legitimately feels like they're trapped in the wrong body.
1:01:23 And my heart aches for someone like that because I know that that's you know,
1:01:27 that's its own version of trauma.
1:01:29 But like my wife, we fled Brooklyn and, you know,
1:01:33 live in the Hudson Valley in New York now.
1:01:35 And my wife went for a walk with one
1:01:37 of her friends from from Brooklyn not that long ago.
1:01:40 And this person said that in their daughter's fancy private school, 50 percent,
1:01:46 that's five zero percent of the the freshman girls
1:01:49 in high school identify as something other than a girl.
1:01:54 So, in our day, those kids would have painted their nails
1:01:57 black and they would have been called goth or something.
1:02:01 And like the next semester, they come back and try something new on.
1:02:04 And that's like, I don't care, ultimately,
1:02:08 except when you start getting to the intervention level.
1:02:11 Right.
1:02:12 And and again, back to the topic, right.
1:02:16 It's more about the us and them thing.
1:02:18 So like that, that's the nuance that I'll present.
1:02:21 I guess trans people are people and should have, you know,
1:02:23 all of the rights of human beings and all of the empathy that they deserve.
1:02:30 But at the same time, we're not going to rewrite the rules of society.
1:02:34 But that like that, that is not an allowable
1:02:36 position to hold in in some sections of polite society.
1:02:41 Well, the reason that that one is so important
1:02:43 is that it's not even the rules of society.
1:02:45 It's the rules of biology and they have nothing to do with humans at all.
1:02:49 They go back 500 million years at a minimum.
1:02:53 So it really I say it's a flex because the point is if you can break people's.
1:02:58 Ability to identify reality at that level, you've got amazing capacity.
1:03:07 But to your larger point about things being seated,
1:03:10 I think the important thing is to realize
1:03:12 there are those who will want to dismiss.
1:03:15 These patterns as entirely emergent.
1:03:18 Those people are clearly wrong.
1:03:20 There may be cases, but.
1:03:23 There is a degree of orchestration of events, right?
1:03:28 The false flags that are very clear, like Tonkin Golf.
1:03:33 Those are created events for a purpose.
1:03:36 Then there are other events, presumably, where something organically happens,
1:03:40 but either in the run up to it,
1:03:43 something has been seated or they're steering in the aftermath.
1:03:48 But point is, the majority of all of these things is.
1:03:53 An organic response to inorganic things.
1:03:58 And.
1:03:59 You know, I went back and I watched Wag the Dog sometime in the last year.
1:04:07 I wish it had been a better movie.
1:04:10 There's a part of me that is now.
1:04:14 I even wonder if it was not a better movie
1:04:17 because that makes it harder to understand what's going on.
1:04:21 But the idea that, you know, if you'll remember, you've got a phony war.
1:04:28 And support is somehow generated through the phony story of a downed airman.
1:04:38 Who's sending messages to his mom by ripping
1:04:43 holes in his shirt that are in Morse code.
1:04:47 And his name is something like Shoe, like S H O.
1:04:52 And they cook up a song about something like an old shoe,
1:04:59 like a song from the 20s or something.
1:05:02 And they put it in the Library of Congress so that it's discovered.
1:05:06 And the point is, oh,
1:05:08 this is somebody scripted this carefully behind the scenes.
1:05:12 But the reaction of the public is not scripted.
1:05:15 The reaction of the public is predictable.
1:05:18 Yeah.
1:05:19 Right.
1:05:20 And so we, the predictable public, are constantly being jerked around by at best
1:05:27 people taking advantage of organic events.
1:05:31 And often people creating events or seeding things in advance of events.
1:05:38 And the skills, I think skills that you and I
1:05:42 both have where we're willing to question all of those levels.
1:05:46 Did the event actually happen?
1:05:48 OK, it happened.
1:05:50 Did it happen as part of a plan?
1:05:52 Was the timing chosen?
1:05:54 Was the nature of the event chosen?
1:05:56 Was the reporting of the event written before it happened?
1:06:01 Those are not easy questions to ask.
1:06:03 You call your own credibility into question when you do.
1:06:07 But from the point of view of building
1:06:09 a model of the present that actually works, you have to have that skill set,
1:06:14 which means you have to be able to stare
1:06:16 down the stigmas and suspicions that come back
1:06:20 at you when you start to question that which
1:06:22 others feel or de facto feel are sacred.
1:06:29 You have to get really comfortable in your own skin and being very,
1:06:34 very OK with being ostracized in your social groups,
1:06:37 in your professional groups.
1:06:40 Again, I'm very lucky that my family and friends, my closest friends,
1:06:45 all trust me and know me and they can
1:06:48 call out that I sound like a lunatic, but laughing.
1:06:51 And in Covid, I remember thinking, like, I hope I can look back in a year
1:06:56 from now or five years from now and it'll be like,
1:06:58 oh, yeah, that was just the time Josh waved out.
1:07:00 And I hope to be wrong about all of this.
1:07:02 But when the evidence all points one way,
1:07:05 it's really, really hard to come to terms with that.
1:07:08 Right.
1:07:09 And there are some people that I know and I'm sure
1:07:12 you have a similar experience that I feel like are gone.
1:07:15 They're gone forever and they're not coming back.
1:07:18 And I rather than trying to maintain those relationships,
1:07:23 I've taken the approach that I will honor the memory of what we had.
1:07:28 But we no longer look at life through the same frame in any way.
1:07:33 Right.
1:07:33 Like we are living completely, completely fractured realities where, you know,
1:07:39 I say north and they say south and not because I said it,
1:07:42 because that's what they're you know,
1:07:44 that's what their media intake is telling them,
1:07:48 even even if it defies their own eyes and ears.
1:07:52 That's the scariest part to me.
1:07:54 Well, it's a it's a it's a zombie movie where, you know,
1:07:57 the fact that the body of somebody that you
1:08:01 knew and loved has come to your door,
1:08:06 you know, if they've been taken over by the thing, it's not the same person,
1:08:10 you know, or, you know, the example I've used elsewhere,
1:08:12 you know, is a rabid dog.
1:08:16 It really doesn't matter what your relationship with that dog had been.
1:08:20 It's now a rabid dog.
1:08:23 Do you remember?
1:08:24 Did you read or watch Game of Thrones?
1:08:26 Of course.
1:08:28 So I feel like when I see people arguing about, you know, candidates,
1:08:34 politics or what are like stupid culture stuff,
1:08:38 I feel like they're they're on Westeros.
1:08:41 Right.
1:08:41 And they're they're arguing, you know, the order of the day.
1:08:44 And I just see the White Walkers coming.
1:08:47 Like they're getting past the wall and they
1:08:50 are multiplying and there needs to be.
1:08:52 And this is why I think it came back to the topic.
1:08:54 I think that's why 10-7 was so important because there
1:08:56 was a resistance building up that was maybe the most beautiful,
1:09:01 organic thing I've seen in my lifetime.
1:09:03 Learning what I've learned about social engineering.
1:09:06 Like these were the real dissidents that understood what was happening.
1:09:09 Just to be clear, because people are going to misunderstand what you said.
1:09:12 The dissidents are the dissidents in the West
1:09:15 who had fought COVID and then 10-7.
1:09:21 Destroyed their ability to understand each other.
1:09:23 Correct.
1:09:24 Thank you for clarifying.
1:09:26 Are you are you familiar with the Tavistock organization?
1:09:30 A little.
1:09:31 Yeah.
1:09:31 So I feel like this and this is probably a whole show into itself.
1:09:35 So I won't just touch on it for a moment,
1:09:37 but I think it's really, really important.
1:09:39 And to me, I didn't know much about them.
1:09:43 And this is this was like the I think this is one of the most
1:09:47 important organizations in the world that almost no one has ever heard of.
1:09:50 Right.
1:09:50 It started like World War One with shell shock soldiers.
1:09:55 Right.
1:09:55 What we now call PTSD.
1:09:57 And there's a there's a George Carlin bit in there somewhere.
1:09:59 But the you know, the gist is they were the exact phrase was they figured out
1:10:05 how to create psychologically controlled environments.
1:10:08 Designed to give up firmly held beliefs under peer pressure.
1:10:12 Like that is literally what this organization studied.
1:10:15 And they got some of the best behavioral psychologists in the world
1:10:19 and the Frankfurt School and all these brilliant minds together to, you know,
1:10:24 again, under the guise of working with soldiers.
1:10:27 And then it turned into a whole bunch of stuff,
1:10:31 including mind control and others.
1:10:34 And I now start.
1:10:35 This is why I'm really obsessed with the culture piece,
1:10:37 because there are certain things like firmly held beliefs that I have.
1:10:42 Right.
1:10:42 And I wonder that I still have, frankly, all people should be created equal.
1:10:46 That's a really important one.
1:10:47 Right.
1:10:47 And even like, you know, when I learned,
1:10:49 say, Gloria Steinem was affiliated with the CIA.
1:10:53 Right.
1:10:53 Don't make her bad, but it does ask some it
1:10:56 does propagate some questions for me about what that agenda was.
1:11:02 Right.
1:11:02 The whole entirety.
1:11:03 And this was this was a big one for me.
1:11:05 That understanding like, you know, Laurel Canyon,
1:11:08 you mentioned, you know, Gulf Tonkin, right?
1:11:11 The commander of the ship of Gulf of Tonkin, who's to lead that thing.
1:11:17 I think it was an admiral.
1:11:19 His father or his son was Jim Morrison.
1:11:21 Right.
1:11:23 And that's one example.
1:11:24 And that could be in fairness.
1:11:25 That could be OK.
1:11:26 This, you know, this guy is rejecting his military father.
1:11:29 And the list goes on and on and on like, you know, David.
1:11:32 At some point, the number of data points
1:11:34 is too many to be easily explained away.
1:11:37 And I will say that the.
1:11:38 Sorry, I didn't mean to interrupt you.
1:11:40 But the problem with theorizing about.
1:11:45 Conspiracies is a you have to have the proper toolkit.
1:11:48 You can't come up with a conspiracy theory.
1:11:51 You come up with a hypothesis and then it makes predictions.
1:11:53 And if it's actually true, eventually it matures into a theory.
1:11:57 But it is proper to say theorizing.
1:12:00 But the problem is that the rules of logic, Occam's razor does not function well
1:12:05 in the land of conspiracy because there's always
1:12:07 a cover story where the dots are meant to connect and tell a simpler story.
1:12:13 And so conspiracy theorists who are good at it
1:12:16 have to not fall into connecting every dot because some
1:12:18 of those dots aren't some of them are noise
1:12:20 and some of them are seated to create an impression.
1:12:24 And the zone gets flooded with false conspiracy dots that are
1:12:28 meant to be connected by those who aren't very good at it.
1:12:31 So that's an unusual toolkit.
1:12:35 Yeah, we definitely need the that we need
1:12:38 to understand that we are being manipulated at all times.
1:12:43 Right.
1:12:43 So that's I think that's an important part of the toolkit.
1:12:46 We need to actually learn stuff, which is really,
1:12:50 really hard for some of us because we didn't know anything about history,
1:12:55 about science, about civics, whatever, whatever the topic.
1:12:58 Right.
1:13:01 We need to be able to have the ability to hold competing thoughts in our head.
1:13:08 We need to learn how to go to primary source material and not get the you know,
1:13:13 the filtered version of everything.
1:13:16 And in many instances, certainly for me,
1:13:18 I needed to rewire my assumptions of what I thought to be true.
1:13:21 Like, you know, you're doing a basic algebra
1:13:23 problem and they're the they're the give ins.
1:13:26 What if you're given totally wrong?
1:13:29 Your everything flows downstream from there.
1:13:31 And then I think there's another topic that I'm particularly interested in.
1:13:37 And there's a writer named Jason Horsley who calls it the parasocial layer.
1:13:41 And it's, you know, we saw it in COVID.
1:13:45 Right.
1:13:45 There's this notion of taking like public figure
1:13:47 who doesn't know you, but you know them.
1:13:50 And you may play this role for someone right as a public figure.
1:13:53 And you tend to outsource your thinking to that person.
1:13:56 Right.
1:13:57 And why wouldn't we?
1:13:58 Right.
1:13:58 We live in a society where, you know,
1:13:59 you can get door dash in two seconds and you can get over.
1:14:03 Yeah.
1:14:03 You know, we outsource everything.
1:14:04 Of course, we're going to outsource our thinking.
1:14:07 And I think I think the distinction from maybe
1:14:10 the old days and our parents' generation to today is like,
1:14:13 you know, Walter Cronkite used to get on, you know, TV.
1:14:17 And of course, we now know that was
1:14:18 like mockingbird media and not to pass judgment,
1:14:20 particularly against Walter Cronkite.
1:14:23 Everyone at least heard the same propaganda.
1:14:24 Go further back.
1:14:25 Go back to like, you know, Caesar era, the town crier would come and say, here,
1:14:30 everyone probably heard a whole bunch of bullshit,
1:14:33 but at least they heard the same bullshit.
1:14:35 So they had a, they had a common frame.
1:14:37 They had empathy for each other.
1:14:40 Today we've got these lines and wait a second,
1:14:44 Brett, didn't you just go on the Tucker Carlson show?
1:14:46 How you're a Jew.
1:14:47 How dare you?
1:14:48 He hates the Jews.
1:14:51 It's so stupid.
1:14:52 Right.
1:14:52 And, you know, I certainly have opinions on some
1:14:55 of these people and some of these topics.
1:14:57 I am far less interested in the messenger than I am
1:15:02 what they might have to say and understanding back to your point,
1:15:07 like what their toolkit is.
1:15:09 So what are they, what are they presenting and why are they showing their work?
1:15:13 Right.
1:15:13 Don't just tell me what you think.
1:15:14 Show me your work and why.
1:15:16 And I think to your point about like the, you know,
1:15:18 how do we operate as conspiracy theorists and, you know,
1:15:22 in this weird era of the Cartesian crisis, we have to either decide to roll up
1:15:28 our sleeves and try to understand the world around us.
1:15:32 Another option is to just unplug from it all and go outside and look at the sun.
1:15:36 And it's probably the way healthier option.
1:15:37 And I try, I aspire to do that.
1:15:39 And I can't always bring myself to it.
1:15:43 Or be a muppet and know someone's controlling your strengths and just not care.
1:15:50 So I'm probably oversimplifying.
1:15:52 There's probably flavors of all of those things.
1:15:54 But well, I think there's a there's a taxonomy here
1:15:57 that we could productively at least put on the table.
1:16:01 I've come to the conclusion very much in line with what you've just said,
1:16:06 that it's probably more important that we read books
1:16:10 in common than that we read the best books.
1:16:13 That everybody having their own experience of how
1:16:17 to think is deranging in a way that's not sustainable.
1:16:23 And I'm not arguing that you should read garbage books.
1:16:26 But the point is the top quality books may not
1:16:29 be as important as having the same set of songs, the same set of stories,
1:16:34 the same version of events so that you can just simply function.
1:16:40 But I want to point out that this parasocial thing
1:16:42 is actually much worse than that portrayal makes it out.
1:16:49 So somebody proxies their thinking to you because they see
1:16:53 you on a screen and you seem to be making sense.
1:16:56 That's not the craziest thing to do in the world.
1:16:58 In fact, it is how normal thinking is done.
1:17:03 And this is in fact, exactly why Descartes had the crisis that he had was
1:17:12 that he realized that almost everything that he thought was a fact,
1:17:16 he was taking on some kind of cryptic authority.
1:17:19 Somebody reports it as a fact and you take it in and you build on it.
1:17:24 And my point would be that our relationship
1:17:26 to somebody who seems sensible on a screen is
1:17:31 not unlike the relationship of scientists to the version
1:17:35 of their field that's presented in the textbook.
1:17:39 And I know as a biologist, the textbook is wrong on many,
1:17:42 many issues where we refuse to acknowledge that it's
1:17:47 just a model and we refuse to update
1:17:50 it when the evidence becomes overwhelming that the model
1:17:53 is in fact more counterproductive than it is informative.
1:17:58 And so anyway, we have this relationship to truth necessarily that is
1:18:03 based on a cryptic kind of authority because we don't have a choice.
1:18:07 We can't run all the experiments ourselves.
1:18:09 Most of us wouldn't know how to do it and you
1:18:11 just don't have nearly enough time to cover almost any of them.
1:18:15 So that parasocial relationship is normal functioning.
1:18:19 And what I would suggest is that we have various different categories.
1:18:25 There are things that are true that we know, presumably.
1:18:29 There are things that are approximations of truth
1:18:32 that are good enough for us to make progress.
1:18:35 There's stand-ins for the truth, you know,
1:18:38 like the traditional version of cell biology that's presented in the textbook.
1:18:43 There's a lot of truth in it, but it's not true as presented.
1:18:48 But you can do a lot of good work if you just simply say,
1:18:51 "Okay, here are the assumptions and I'll go forward." But at some point,
1:18:54 the wrong part of the assumptions becomes overwhelming
1:18:57 and the model starts misleading you and you should abandon it.
1:19:01 And our resistance to abandoning it means that what we have
1:19:05 are fictions that stand in for approximations without being true themselves.
1:19:11 And so that's what we're seeing in the social
1:19:13 layer is our understanding of where we are
1:19:16 in history and what's going on is maybe
1:19:20 mostly fiction serving somebody else's interest at our expense.
1:19:25 And that is an emergency.
1:19:27 That's not you're dealing with an approximation and you should understand that.
1:19:32 You're dealing with lies serving someone else's
1:19:35 interest at your expense and it can result
1:19:38 in you contracting a surgeon to sterilize your child
1:19:41 thinking that you're doing something good for them.
1:19:46 Okay, so a couple of quick reactions to that.
1:19:48 So first of all, I agree with you.
1:19:51 And yes, you should be able to trust
1:19:53 your doctor as the expert in a particular thing
1:19:56 because we cannot all be expert in probably any
1:20:00 more than one or two things in our lives.
1:20:04 You can go and I remember like when I started
1:20:07 waking up during COVID and exploring mRNA and reading science papers.
1:20:12 I had never done that before.
1:20:14 I should never look through deep, deep direct research.
1:20:18 Like most people, I would read the headlines about it, right?
1:20:21 Or even the whole article, right?
1:20:22 And that was some and now as I've met some of the really crappy people
1:20:27 that cover themes like this, you start
1:20:29 to understand why you shouldn't trust their judgment.
1:20:31 There's some really good ones too.
1:20:32 And I've been had the great fortune
1:20:33 of coming across some over the last few years.
1:20:38 The problem with some of it,
1:20:39 and I think climate is probably the biggest example,
1:20:41 is you don't get the whole story.
1:20:43 There may be truths, there may be actual things that are happening,
1:20:46 but there's a whole other perspective that you're not aware of, right?
1:20:49 And in our little study group that I mentioned,
1:20:51 there's a climate scientist who's like a dear friend of a dear friend.
1:20:56 And we went out for some drinks and I was like,
1:20:58 all right, dude, are we in peril?
1:21:01 Tell me.
1:21:01 This was like 2021.
1:21:03 So no, there is no danger.
1:21:07 Any climate scientist worth their salt understands this.
1:21:11 And if I say that publicly, I lose tenure at university.
1:21:14 And I got to the whole thing about how he's a coward.
1:21:17 He's got to speak out, but he's got kids to support.
1:21:20 I get it.
1:21:20 And not everyone is wired that way.
1:21:22 So I think that's, there's one thing of like the align by omission,
1:21:25 even among partial truths.
1:21:28 I think the other thing, particularly as it relates to some
1:21:30 of the current events and particularly as it relates
1:21:33 to the topic that spawned your interest in talking
1:21:36 about this is at this moment in time,
1:21:40 there are a lot of influencers and I'll use that term in the loosa sense.
1:21:44 Some of them are journalists, some of them are politicians.
1:21:48 Some of them are just public figures because they are,
1:21:49 and I'm not quite sure why they are,
1:21:51 but they have ascended to have a really large voice.
1:21:56 There, these people, I believe some of them,
1:21:59 and the hard part is figuring out who,
1:22:02 you know, and again, I don't really care, right?
1:22:04 Who they are.
1:22:05 I do, but it's not even something I
1:22:07 talk about or write about because I'm less interested
1:22:09 in the individual heroes and villains and I'm more
1:22:12 interested in just getting to the root of the truth.
1:22:14 But I think there is a little bit of a pie-piper strategy happening here,
1:22:18 that there are some folks that are sort of luring us to follow, you know what?
1:22:23 And again, I'll cite Jason Horsley,
1:22:25 I think is the architect of this particular term, but the second matrix, right?
1:22:30 So if the first matrix is the New York Times reading or Fox News listening,
1:22:34 like I'll use those as a mirror of one another,
1:22:39 but you're sort of at the root of the basic of like, all right, this is,
1:22:42 you know, good guys and bad guys, and we're going to take it at face value.
1:22:46 The second layer is, all right, you woke up from mainstream media
1:22:49 and there's this thriving alternative media ecosystem.
1:22:54 And oh yeah, my flavor is Candace Owens,
1:22:57 and you must like this person over here.
1:22:59 And again, it doesn't matter.
1:23:01 And I'm not questioning Tucker Carlson or Candace Owens or any
1:23:04 of the individual people because I'm more interested in, you know,
1:23:07 following their train of thought and what they have
1:23:09 to say and what facts they're going to reveal privately, maybe with my friends,
1:23:13 I'll question what some of their upbringing or schooling might be.
1:23:17 But I think it comes down to like,
1:23:19 are you evaluating evidence or are you following characters?
1:23:23 That's the truth, ultimately.
1:23:25 So if you're just following the characters in particular,
1:23:28 I think there's a particular danger in people
1:23:30 that were right about a lot of stuff,
1:23:33 because were they building their credibility over a period of time?
1:23:37 And if there's anything I've learned about,
1:23:39 I'll call it this game being played, right, or about Goliath, as you'd frame it,
1:23:44 right, they have a bizarrely long time preference.
1:23:48 Right.
1:23:48 So something pops up.
1:23:49 And again, I'll go back to the Kanye example.
1:23:51 Maybe I'm just a conspiracy theorist and I'm seeing things that don't exist.
1:23:55 It's like a year before 10, 7.
1:23:57 That was it was it wasn't even that long.
1:23:59 You could look at other examples of things
1:24:00 being seeded in our consciousness and something happens later.
1:24:03 And again, you rightly point out that could just be capitalizing on someone's
1:24:09 pre-existing belief on a real event or it could be something else.
1:24:13 So I don't know.
1:24:15 I'm there's a lot of layers to this.
1:24:17 And this this psychological operation runs so deep
1:24:20 that even talking about it now with you, I must sound like a raving madman.
1:24:26 Right.
1:24:27 Like it's there are things that I say to people
1:24:30 in my life that if someone said them to me pre 2020,
1:24:33 I would have told them they sound like a lunatic.
1:24:37 But I take really good notes and I'm happy to share them always.
1:24:41 Well, you do it.
1:24:42 You do a very good job of making it clear how you've arrived somewhere,
1:24:46 which is actually brings me to my point in response to your last point.
1:24:51 I'm particularly concerned.
1:24:55 There's a stripe of dissidents that wants to go after
1:25:00 those of us who got things wrong along the way.
1:25:05 And the problem is their point is, look,
1:25:08 being right is the point of the exercise.
1:25:11 Why would you listen to somebody who didn't spot this or that?
1:25:16 And here's my my concern.
1:25:19 There was a way to get COVID right from the beginning.
1:25:26 It involved.
1:25:27 Well, maybe there are two ways.
1:25:29 One way is to just be a cynic.
1:25:33 If you disbelieve everything reflexively,
1:25:36 you nailed COVID because there was it was garbage at almost every level.
1:25:43 That does not establish that you have insight.
1:25:47 You have one insight.
1:25:49 There's a lot of bullshit out there.
1:25:50 And if you bet against things that are being said publicly being true,
1:25:53 you just rack up some wins.
1:25:57 But what you want is a track record and a single correct call.
1:26:03 They're always lying is not a track record.
1:26:06 You know, it may be a decent heuristic.
1:26:10 No, it's a good heuristic.
1:26:12 If what you're trying to do is not get suckered,
1:26:14 but it's paralytic and it's not insightful.
1:26:17 So I'm not arguing that there's nobody in the category who got it all right,
1:26:22 who did so from a deep model.
1:26:24 There might be.
1:26:25 But in general, you don't want the cynics to shout
1:26:28 down the people who learned painful lessons and got smarter
1:26:31 over time because the people who learned painful lessons
1:26:34 and got smarter over time have a model that's actually useful.
1:26:39 So somehow we got to ignore the cynics.
1:26:43 If people got everything right from the get go from a model,
1:26:47 OK, those are people I want to listen to.
1:26:50 But it's hard to distinguish them from the cynics if basically
1:26:53 what they did was the cynics bet it against everything just
1:26:57 because it's a reasonable guess and the people working from a deep
1:27:01 model arrived at each of these conclusions based on something important.
1:27:08 I struggle with this because I look at my own blind spots and how I've gotten
1:27:14 suckered at various times and not just go
1:27:16 over various things in my life throughout the years.
1:27:20 And I'm a fellow pessimist.
1:27:23 I'm an entrepreneur.
1:27:24 You sort of have to be blindly optimistic in some way.
1:27:28 And you also have to hold a deep, deep level of cynicism for power.
1:27:34 That I thought I had and it was impossibly
1:27:39 humbling to realize that I wasn't nearly cynical enough.
1:27:43 But that doesn't also mean you have to be a doomer.
1:27:47 Right.
1:27:47 And I know around the time of the election,
1:27:49 there were people in my life and some people
1:27:52 that we mutually know who would say things to me like,
1:27:56 hey, you're being a black pill.
1:27:58 And I would say no, just because I'm not 100
1:28:01 percent sure I understand what's happening here around these party lines.
1:28:06 And I personally think voting is like Santa Claus for grownups.
1:28:11 And I came to that conclusion over a long period of time.
1:28:13 And I don't say that lately.
1:28:16 So when I got to that conclusion,
1:28:17 that also doesn't necessarily mean that I'm a doomer.
1:28:20 And I think the world's going to end.
1:28:22 It just means that I don't want to rely.
1:28:25 I don't want to outsource my agency to someone else who
1:28:27 is going to the cavalry is going to come and save me.
1:28:31 Right.
1:28:31 And again, I know I don't know.
1:28:31 Right.
1:28:33 As it relates to the current administration,
1:28:34 I had this mental frame that I didn't know.
1:28:38 Like if you're my age and you grew up in this part of the country,
1:28:41 you have a you thought you had a sense of who Donald Trump was.
1:28:44 Right.
1:28:44 He's a you know, I knew the Woody Guthrie song about his father.
1:28:47 Like, you know, he's this second generation real
1:28:50 estate guy who saw something and was opportunistic.
1:28:54 And I've come to believe that that's just silly.
1:28:57 Right.
1:28:57 There's a lot in his in his background in his history.
1:28:58 And he's sort of like the Forrest Gump of the cabal.
1:29:04 Right.
1:29:04 Like he's somehow connected to everyone always and has always been around.
1:29:08 And I didn't notice it at the time.
1:29:10 Now, let's think it's sort of one of three things.
1:29:13 He is either like we're watching a professional wrestling
1:29:16 match and he's the heel or that's one option.
1:29:20 Like he's the heel and he's on their side
1:29:22 and has been on their side the whole time.
1:29:24 And they they like when you are doing,
1:29:25 you know, you know, you're doing a lot of things.
1:29:26 Like when you were doing, you know,
1:29:28 rescue the Republic because you saw a genuine threat, which was real.
1:29:31 I wondered, like, is this is
1:29:34 any reasonable person that understands and understands
1:29:38 like that didn't forget everything that just happened in the whole world?
1:29:43 Is this like where we're being led?
1:29:45 Right.
1:29:45 And it's this was like the only yes,
1:29:47 it's our only other choice because the system is never broken anyway.
1:29:50 And that's a long conversation.
1:29:51 But that's sort of one.
1:29:51 Right.
1:29:53 Two is maybe he's a dueling bad guy.
1:29:54 Right.
1:29:56 And he clearly knows a whole lot more than I ever understood.
1:30:00 And he also speaks in riddles and like weird stuff like it.
1:30:04 I won't get into all the details.
1:30:05 If you remember, like when he famously tweeted Kofi Fe.
1:30:08 Oh, yeah.
1:30:10 So I'm one of my interests is I'm trying
1:30:15 to understand like technology and its role on, you know,
1:30:18 our bodies and stuff like that.
1:30:20 You know, our kids are mad at us because we make them put
1:30:23 these little devices in Faraday bags at night
1:30:25 and we don't let them wear airbuds.
1:30:28 So that all our friends are not going to get brain cancer.
1:30:30 Like, well, you know, grandma was told to smoke cigarettes.
1:30:33 So we don't know.
1:30:37 I was I came across this this bond
1:30:40 that allegedly protects you from 5G radiation.
1:30:43 I don't know if this is true or not.
1:30:44 So I'm not going to present it as a truth.
1:30:46 But it was on like an official science thing that was like a cobalt,
1:30:52 a vanadium and double bonded iron, which just so happens to spell Kofi Fe.
1:30:59 Oh, like this is so it's not a one off thing that draw me to this conclusion.
1:31:03 But, you know, I know his his uncle John as in Donald J.
1:31:08 Trump was like the guy who exclusively got all Tesla's papers.
1:31:13 There's just a lot of weird stuff.
1:31:14 Right.
1:31:15 So and I don't know what it means.
1:31:17 But I know I know it's not what they told me.
1:31:19 Right.
1:31:19 And the third option,
1:31:20 which I think would be the funniest from my vantage point is like a New Yorker,
1:31:24 is that he's the hero of the world.
1:31:26 Right.
1:31:27 That's what that is the hero of the world.
1:31:29 Right.
1:31:29 And that, you know, it's the Q story, basically.
1:31:31 Yeah.
1:31:32 Right.
1:31:32 And, you know, I've got a good friend who is
1:31:35 not who is not the archetype to I thought Q was.
1:31:39 Right.
1:31:39 He's like a 60 year old brilliant doctor from New York City
1:31:43 who is not like some dude living in the woods and, you know,
1:31:47 wherever who is all in on the Q story.
1:31:51 And anytime something happens in the news,
1:31:53 including the current Iran war, which,
1:31:55 you know, I'm not qualified to get into a lot of detail about.
1:31:58 He gives me the map of why this is going
1:32:01 to save the world and why we are defeating the globalists.
1:32:04 And it's it's fast.
1:32:05 It's almost like a case study.
1:32:07 It's fascinating to me.
1:32:09 I can still hold a percentage chance on my head that maybe he's right,
1:32:13 although that that window maybe is closing.
1:32:16 But it's fascinating how people can watch
1:32:18 the same events and have totally different takeaways.
1:32:22 And it's not just it's not just opposite.
1:32:24 It's fractured across a landscape of, you know,
1:32:26 it's a collage of takeaways that are all predisposed based
1:32:29 on who we were five minutes before we heard it.
1:32:32 Yeah, I agree with this.
1:32:33 And it fits very well with the argument you make in your piece,
1:32:37 which I want to return to as we wrap up here.
1:32:42 You lay out a case in your piece that I had not heard or put together before.
1:32:52 So there's a lot in your piece that resonates.
1:32:55 You wrote it very well, but I feel like I could have written
1:32:57 something that would have made the same points.
1:32:59 But this one I would not have written.
1:33:01 And it made a lot of sense to me.
1:33:03 I want you to articulate it.
1:33:05 And it has to do with how to think about
1:33:09 the role of Jews as we are watching power do its thing.
1:33:16 And all of these Jewish names clearly associated with it,
1:33:21 Zionism clearly associated with it.
1:33:25 And anyway, you want to lay out your case
1:33:27 because I've been fighting the battle of, look,
1:33:30 anybody who says the Jews is obviously just wrong, right?
1:33:35 You and I are Jews.
1:33:36 You and I are not involved in some conspiracy to control the world.
1:33:41 Therefore, it ain't the Jews.
1:33:42 That's a nonstarter.
1:33:46 But what do you make of the presentation that is delivered to the public
1:33:53 where you see an unmistakable pattern of Jews involved in steering the US,
1:34:01 steering world events, some kind of control architecture?
1:34:06 Well, first, I'll just acknowledge that I hope you get a comment
1:34:11 that Brett Weinstein and Joshua Steinleman are declaring it's not the Jews.
1:34:16 So I really hope you get that comment.
1:34:20 I think there's this notion that there's an ancient setup here, right?
1:34:29 Half-Yud, I think it's called, where it's the court Jew, essentially.
1:34:34 So like going back, Christian nobility and medieval,
1:34:37 in medieval Europe had Jewish financiers as the front.
1:34:42 And this is a thing, and that system works great until it doesn't.
1:34:46 And then eventually, the scapegoat mechanism kicks in.
1:34:49 And historically speaking, the rage has gone to the Jews, not the structure.
1:34:56 And again, that goes back to the comment
1:35:00 I made earlier about the 109 country thing.
1:35:03 So it's the, oh, yeah,
1:35:04 why do you think they've been kicked out of 109 countries?
1:35:06 And I think the people that I said were like, yeah,
1:35:09 why do you think we've been kicked out of 109 countries are
1:35:12 the people like you and I that didn't get the memo, right?
1:35:16 So Arendt called it the appearance of power without its substance, right?
1:35:20 And I think that's a particularly interesting quote that I put in the piece.
1:35:24 It's like, it's visible enough to blame
1:35:26 and never protected enough to survive, right?
1:35:31 And if you keep kind of going through, there's a lot of layers here,
1:35:35 and there's a whole other conversation just about the Holocaust,
1:35:39 which is the third rail.
1:35:41 And I'm already in my little local community considered
1:35:46 anti-Semitic for a lot of reasons, which is awesome.
1:35:51 But it's very well documented, like in 1891,
1:35:53 before political Zionism was even a thing,
1:35:56 there were Americans who were non-Jewish
1:36:00 and I think Christian Rockefeller and JP Morgan,
1:36:04 and Bill Gates and whoever of that time,
1:36:09 editors of the New York Times and the Post
1:36:11 and all of the same media publications we're talking about,
1:36:14 they signed something called the Blackstone Memorial.
1:36:17 And that was pushing for Jewish immigration to Palestine.
1:36:20 And I didn't know this, this never was on my radar.
1:36:24 I don't even know if my family knew about it.
1:36:25 I grew up hearing about the importance of Israel as a thing.
1:36:29 And reflexively, even in the last few years,
1:36:32 if I question Israel or question 10-7, how dare I?
1:36:38 I often get back, well, do you think Israel is a right to exist?
1:36:40 Which is that pre-programmed response.
1:36:43 And it's like, I think that's not the question I'm really asking, right?
1:36:47 What is the question?
1:36:48 So what's particularly interesting in this 1891
1:36:50 thing was that, as I understand it, most American Jews actually opposed this.
1:36:55 So there was this sort of scapegoat infrastructure that was
1:36:59 being built and it was by the financial elites.
1:37:03 And you touched on something earlier, I forget the exact way you said it,
1:37:06 but who's this all designed to serve?
1:37:09 I think is the most important question in this framework we can all think about,
1:37:14 Qibono, who benefits?
1:37:17 So you could think about even like your day-to-day life, right?
1:37:21 I was at the bank recently and someone was just yelling at the teller.
1:37:25 I was annoyed that I had to go to the bank in the first place.
1:37:28 And as it turns out,
1:37:28 I had a similar issue to the person that was yelling at the teller,
1:37:31 this poor lady is just trying to do her job.
1:37:34 And she works for JP Morgan.
1:37:36 And I'm listening to this guy who was, and I understand he was frustrated.
1:37:41 I'm like, you're not mad at this lady just trying
1:37:43 to help you that clearly doesn't want to not help you.
1:37:46 You're taking it out on this particular thing.
1:37:49 And I don't know, like there's clearly a visible
1:37:54 layer and I've seen both sides of it, right?
1:37:56 So you see the one side of the like, Oh my God,
1:37:58 look around and Mark Zuckerberg and Larry Fink and, you know,
1:38:01 Bill Soros or George Soros, right?
1:38:04 And the other side is just in denial about that over-representation.
1:38:09 And I guess the nuance point of view
1:38:11 is like the over-representation is so obvious, right?
1:38:15 And again, I'm really hung up on the culture
1:38:17 thing because I think I think it's important,
1:38:18 particularly in an era where, you know, you said read the same books.
1:38:22 I know a lot of people that don't read books at all, right?
1:38:25 And they get their entire worldview shaped
1:38:27 by the social programming that exists on Netflix, right?
1:38:31 Or, you know, Hollywood or or music.
1:38:34 So when you look at the over-representation in banking,
1:38:38 going back to the beginning of, you know,
1:38:40 the federal reserve from before, when you go to Hollywood,
1:38:43 when you hear names like Jeffrey Epstein and, you know, Harvey Weinstein.
1:38:49 And if you grew up in a place that was not around Jewish people like you and I,
1:38:55 putting aside our own homes, putting people,
1:38:57 you know, I have lots of friends who were, you know, Christian or whatever,
1:39:00 but they grew up around me and other friends that were Jewish.
1:39:04 If you grew up in a different way and those are the only names you heard,
1:39:07 like I put myself in that position.
1:39:09 I wonder what would my conclusion be?
1:39:12 What I think it was to do is I like to think I'm above that, but I don't know.
1:39:16 I don't know.
1:39:17 I kind of get how that plays out and we're seeing it in real time.
1:39:23 So I'll pause there and let you react for a moment.
1:39:26 Well, I just want to make sure people understand the model
1:39:28 that you've described and you do describe it very well in your piece.
1:39:33 Your model is that there is a distinct over-representation
1:39:37 of Jews in these stories that connect to the controlled architecture.
1:39:43 But that that actually creates a convenient mirage,
1:39:49 that it's hard to look away from it
1:39:52 and that if you look for the countervailing evidence,
1:39:54 the names that aren't Jewish, that are also involved in these power structures,
1:39:59 that effectively this, it actually is a mirror
1:40:01 for what we've been describing in much of this conversation,
1:40:04 where there are dots that will connect for a purpose.
1:40:10 In other words, it makes a convenient scapegoat,
1:40:13 which is not to immunize any of the terrible people involved.
1:40:20 It doesn't matter what population they come from.
1:40:23 They're involved in a diabolical, I hesitate to use the word conspiracy,
1:40:30 but a diabolical conspiracy against human freedom.
1:40:34 And many of them are Jewish,
1:40:36 but that that's not the fundamental nature of this thing.
1:40:39 That's the thing that allows the power structure to remain intact and escape
1:40:43 out the back door as people become wise to what's being done to them.
1:40:48 So I thought that was a very, I hope I'm representing it accurately.
1:40:54 You certainly are.
1:40:55 And most recently it has popped up in politics and a few
1:40:59 of the examples I cited were like Zelensky and one of the most consequential,
1:41:03 and his whole arc is all sorted into itself.
1:41:07 But in one of the most consequential wars
1:41:11 that's going on that might reshape the geopolitical landscape,
1:41:15 that's interesting that he's the guy.
1:41:19 And the president of Mexico is a shine bound.
1:41:24 I actually looked up the odds of that.
1:41:25 It's like 0.5% chance.
1:41:29 It's just based on the population, let alone the stereotypes of the population.
1:41:33 And by the way, in that particular election,
1:41:35 60, 60 candidates were killed that were running throughout.
1:41:41 So, you know, and depending on your frame, you either think, oh,
1:41:47 it's quite obviously the Jews, or how dare you say it's the Jews.
1:41:52 And to me, it's like quite obviously someone wants to present that as the Jews.
1:41:56 Even what's his name, Javier Millais is not Jewish.
1:42:01 And his first official foreign visit was to Chabad.
1:42:05 That's just weird.
1:42:06 At some point, all this shit just becomes so weird.
1:42:09 And of course, I think the phrase I used in the piece was, you know,
1:42:13 for the people, we are not, you and I are not getting the people off the hook.
1:42:20 I think I use the phrase,
1:42:21 they have their boot on the neck of humanity, because it's true.
1:42:25 But what I'm particularly interested in is
1:42:28 I called it the two stroke engine, right?
1:42:30 And step one is manufacturer blame, right?
1:42:33 Again, not letting the individual players off the hook, but like point,
1:42:37 you know, point at a visible minority in power positions and amplify.
1:42:41 And then stroke two, and I think this is where we are now.
1:42:45 And this is this is the danger is use the resulting in this case,
1:42:50 anti-Semitism, right?
1:42:52 Use it to justify more surveillance, more censorship, more spruce restrictions,
1:42:56 like all that stuff, because we need to be safe.
1:43:00 And you know, I have a friend I mentioned,
1:43:02 I met, I touched on this in the piece,
1:43:03 I have a friend like, like, aren't, aren't, are you nervous about anti-Semitism?
1:43:08 Like, I if I named the top hundred
1:43:11 things in the world that concern me right now,
1:43:13 anti-Semitism does not get on the it's not on the radar at all.
1:43:16 And that's not to say that there is not,
1:43:19 it's not in vogue, and that's not a thing.
1:43:21 I don't know, I, it feels really manufactured to me
1:43:27 in a lot of ways for the regular people.
1:43:31 Which doesn't mean it's not frightening.
1:43:33 I agree with you that there's something about it that is inorganic.
1:43:38 But the emergent part does frighten me that people are
1:43:41 watching dots connecting them reaching conclusions that are not nuanced.
1:43:46 And that that is putting me and my family in danger
1:43:50 in a way that I didn't expect ever to be in my lifetime.
1:43:53 I knew it was a possibility that it would happen.
1:43:55 But I'm shocked at the speed of it.
1:43:58 But I wanted to go ahead.
1:44:01 No, I was just gonna say, I'm sorry to interrupt.
1:44:03 You're also a different thing.
1:44:04 You and I are different.
1:44:04 You're a public figure.
1:44:06 That's true.
1:44:06 You're a public figure who's putting yourself out there making strong points
1:44:11 about really nuanced topics that don't land if you're stuck in this paradigm.
1:44:17 Right.
1:44:17 Whereas I'm just some dude sitting in the woods like,
1:44:20 it's a very, it's a very different thing.
1:44:23 Yeah, I suppose.
1:44:25 All right.
1:44:25 So I wanted to just put one more set of things on the table.
1:44:30 Part of what's bugging me and what I think made your piece seem like such
1:44:37 a relief was that there is some sort of a Jedi mind trick around antisemitism,
1:44:48 Zionism, things in this area.
1:44:54 And it's very hard to dis...
1:44:58 It's very hard to diffuse it.
1:45:00 Right.
1:45:00 It's a bomb that you can't touch in any way or it goes off.
1:45:04 And what you want to do is diffuse it.
1:45:06 But the idea is we've formally seen anti-Zionism is antisemitism.
1:45:14 Oh, wow.
1:45:15 That's an incredible claim.
1:45:16 What is Zionism?
1:45:19 Well, Zionism is two things and the definition will dodge and weave
1:45:24 between them so that you can't get your hands around it.
1:45:28 Right.
1:45:29 Zionism is either Israel's right to exist,
1:45:32 which we could get into what that even means, but that's the safe version.
1:45:40 That's the mot.
1:45:42 And then the bailey is that Zionism is some expansionist
1:45:46 program in which Israel has all kinds of special rights,
1:45:51 not just a right to exist, but a right to expand or something like that.
1:45:55 And so one of the things I got from your piece
1:45:59 is that Zionism is not fundamentally a Jewish project,
1:46:03 that in fact it was opposed by many Jews.
1:46:08 I now see one of the most interesting threads in my feed,
1:46:11 who knows how realistic it is,
1:46:13 but the number of Orthodox Jews who are vocal opponents
1:46:18 of at least modern Zionism and presumably historical Zionism is shocking.
1:46:24 So why is it if Zionism is effectively
1:46:27 some natural extension of being Jewish that you
1:46:30 have these folks who have Jewishness that they're
1:46:34 absolute core are trying to raise objections.
1:46:38 So anyway, the upshot that I get is that in some sense,
1:46:44 not only is it crazy to argue that anti-Zionism is anti-Semitism
1:46:49 or that Israel has some built in right not to be criticized.
1:46:59 So Zionism, at least as it is being
1:47:03 applied by those who are proudly using that term,
1:47:06 I feel like it's actually a threat, not only to Israel,
1:47:10 which it is putting in jeopardy,
1:47:12 but also to diaspora Jews who should not be required to embrace what turns
1:47:20 out to be a very aggressive
1:47:23 and non-fundamental position on Israel and its behavior.
1:47:30 And to just finish this out, I have the sense that the public,
1:47:35 so we tend to think about the trauma of the Holocaust as a feature of Jews.
1:47:42 But I'm thinking actually that I'm watching another kind
1:47:45 of Holocaust trauma that is very much in play here, and I want your take on it.
1:47:50 The trauma is the West waking up to what took
1:47:57 place during the Holocaust had a trauma of its own, right?
1:48:03 There's a kind of shame and fear of such patterns
1:48:08 and this overarching desire to avoid anything that leans in that direction,
1:48:17 which is of course good.
1:48:19 But what it means is that those who
1:48:20 want to control the narrative have a built-in,
1:48:24 just as you can trigger people to resort
1:48:29 to their amygdala and stop thinking, right?
1:48:32 If they're Jews, you can get them to stop thinking based
1:48:36 on a particular pattern that calls forth the events that preceded the Holocaust.
1:48:46 You can also get the public at large to respond out
1:48:49 of their amygdala with accusations that you're
1:48:53 participating this time and that those two
1:48:56 traumas are being played in tandem and the model that you
1:49:01 put forth in your piece where the anti-Semitism is a feature,
1:49:06 not a bug, of the system, that those who are attempting to gain power are using
1:49:12 this as a kind of cloak that just seemed very resonant for me.
1:49:18 Well, thanks for noticing.
1:49:21 I called it the barbell,
1:49:22 which I think is a pretty good metaphor for this, right?
1:49:25 It's like two heavy ends that crush the middle.
1:49:28 So both extremes, I think, need the same lie,
1:49:32 and they're working the same street from the opposite corners, right?
1:49:36 Like the hardliner, including some people in my life,
1:49:40 a koi needs all Jews to equal Israel, right?
1:49:44 Of course, you're Jewish.
1:49:45 You must support Israel.
1:49:47 And the person who doesn't like Jews,
1:49:49 and I actually don't like the term anti-Semitic that will use it.
1:49:52 I think that's like just as an aside, I'm an Ashkenazi Jew, right?
1:49:57 There's really nothing Semitic about my background.
1:49:59 That's a whole can of worms and people don't like when you talk about it.
1:50:03 But it's pretty damn true.
1:50:04 And I think all the DNA testing pretty much proves that.
1:50:07 So to me, that is akin to using
1:50:13 the term anti-vaxxer for a experimental gene therapy, right?
1:50:21 And it also demonstrates the power of language
1:50:23 and how we all wind up in the cage, in part because of the language.
1:50:27 So both extremes need this lie, right?
1:50:30 And then it's sort of plays out in this way
1:50:33 where they're taking us to the same place.
1:50:35 And I remember after 9-11, the same thing happened with Muslims, right?
1:50:39 And it's a really good trick, they pull,
1:50:42 because any person with a more nuanced or complex opinion
1:50:45 that sits in the middle of the barbell gets crushed.
1:50:49 And I think right now you and I occupy that space.
1:50:53 The Holocaust is a way longer conversation because there's
1:50:56 way more to that story than I ever knew.
1:51:00 And that's not to say, I'm not a Holocaust denier,
1:51:03 which I know is one of the other terms they like to use,
1:51:06 because I understand the trauma that I witnessed firsthand from my family,
1:51:11 that they, something happened.
1:51:14 I think, and again, sort of like,
1:51:17 whether you want to call them false vibes or conveniences or whatever,
1:51:20 there were real consequences.
1:51:23 I think the reasons for them are not exactly what we were told.
1:51:29 And I alluded to some of this in the piece,
1:51:31 there's a writer named Anthony Sutton who does show his work.
1:51:35 If you pull back the layers on who funded this, at best,
1:51:41 you've got financial engineers playing both sides
1:51:47 and hoping they're going to come out the winner
1:51:50 or knowing they're going to come out
1:51:51 the winner because they've hedged or something else.
1:51:55 We can save that, we can have a longer conversation about that.
1:52:00 But I will say as well,
1:52:01 if you go back and I came across this newspaper clipping that said,
1:52:10 we need Jews to migrate to, I have this weird habit,
1:52:14 I go through old newspaper databases,
1:52:15 because it's not like Twitter where they even know what you're looking for.
1:52:20 And I start, someone mentioned this to me, that there was a headline of like,
1:52:24 six million Jews will die if we don't get the Jews to Israel from pre-1920s.
1:52:28 And I found it.
1:52:29 And then I found another and another and another.
1:52:32 And they all talk about six million.
1:52:34 I found like 50.
1:52:36 And then I found someone had a book that had way more than that.
1:52:38 And it was all different reasons too.
1:52:41 It was like, you know, Ukraine Jews must migrate to Israel.
1:52:44 There was this thing, this movement happening that we must get Jews to Israel,
1:52:48 which on the tone is interesting.
1:52:50 But the constant threat of the six million was a very,
1:52:54 very specific number that if you now get to my mind is like,
1:52:58 well, that's why did this happen?
1:53:01 And let me ask you, I've of course encountered that same argument.
1:53:05 But my question is, is that number not a natural extrapolation from an estimate
1:53:11 good or bad of how many Jews were in Europe or Eastern Europe?
1:53:19 It could be.
1:53:19 It's also a talismanic number with a six with six euros,
1:53:22 which if you're interested in some of the weird mystical stuff,
1:53:25 which I don't sense you are, is maybe a thing.
1:53:28 And again, I think the takeaway for me is I don't know.
1:53:32 By the way, that's not the only data point.
1:53:35 There's like a lot more to this.
1:53:37 And I can send you a reading list offline,
1:53:41 but there's a bunch of stuff here that again,
1:53:45 doesn't it doesn't mean real people don't suffer, including my family and yours.
1:53:52 It doesn't mean that there aren't massive
1:53:54 consequences at the macro level coming out.
1:53:59 But there may be some intentions that I know I never understood.
1:54:04 Like I never understood the role.
1:54:05 I never understood the role of the bankers,
1:54:07 you know, on a Nazi Germany as a thing.
1:54:09 That's like a matter of fact.
1:54:11 So let's go back to the number.
1:54:14 Now, I asked a Holocaust scholar that I know well,
1:54:21 how robust this number was and how we know.
1:54:27 And what he came back with was very compelling.
1:54:29 His point was effectively,
1:54:30 we know it because this is the number of people killed.
1:54:34 I can't speak to the clippings that you were
1:54:36 looking to ahead of time or ahead of the Holocaust.
1:54:40 But the point was many different independent
1:54:43 lines of evidence can merge near this number, you know, within 500,000 or so.
1:54:49 And so that put my doubts at ease because that's exactly the way evidence works.
1:55:00 You know, if it all came from one source,
1:55:01 you could say, well, how good is that source?
1:55:04 But if multiple different things result in you calculating the same number,
1:55:08 then the point is, okay, that number probably is what it looks like.
1:55:13 So anyway, I don't know that there is anything down that road.
1:55:17 But if there is something down that road,
1:55:21 it has to overcome multiple independent lines of evidence to point toward it.
1:55:26 And to be clear, I know there is a train of thought that questions the number.
1:55:32 Like a lot of things, I know I don't know.
1:55:33 And I have never gone down that rabbit.
1:55:36 That's less interesting to me for whatever reason.
1:55:38 The thing I'm more interested in is the foreshadowing of the number,
1:55:43 although your assessment or your, you know,
1:55:45 your possible assessment of that may be spot on.
1:55:50 All right.
1:55:52 Good.
1:55:55 Well, this has been a fascinating discussion.
1:55:59 I want people who have had their interest piqued to sign up
1:56:03 for your sub stack because you're such a clear headed thinker and writer.
1:56:09 It's well worth your effort.
1:56:10 So what is the name of your sub stack?
1:56:12 Well, first of all, thank you.
1:56:13 It's a lot.
1:56:15 Stylman.
1:56:15 S-T-Y-L-M-A-N.substack.com.
1:56:19 All right.
1:56:20 I'm on Twitter at J Stylman, although I'm heavily shadowpan there.
1:56:24 And I do stupid stories on Instagram all the time, just at Stylman.
1:56:28 S-T-Y-L-M-A.
1:56:29 Cool.
1:56:30 Well, Josh, it's been a pleasure and there's lots more for us to talk about.
1:56:36 I hope we'll get back to it sometime soon.
1:56:38 I hope so.
1:56:39 Thanks so much, Brett.
1:56:40 Really appreciate the time.
1:56:41 All right.
1:56:41 Thanks for joining us.