700,000 Images Rebuilt Titanic. What They Revealed Changes Everything We Know About The Wreck

700,000 Images Rebuilt Titanic. What They Revealed Changes Everything We Know About The Wreck

National Geographic

0:03 ominous music playing] [captain] ETA over

0:18 the wreck is approximately ten minutes from now.

0:23 [crew] Roger that, that's secure, here we go.

0:25 Survey, we are headed off.

0:28 -Juliet, survey.

0:29 Yeah, whenever you're happy, I'm happy.

0:32 -Off we go.

0:35 [Narrator] In a remote spot in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean,

0:39 nearly 400 miles from Newfoundland.

0:41 [crew] Clear to dive.

0:42 Clear to dive.

0:43 [Narrator] A remarkable expedition is underway.

0:46 [captain] Roger that.

0:47 Juliet is clear to dive.

0:48 I've got a green board.

0:49 Pumps are now in.

0:55 Heading one eight zero.

0:59 [Narrator] It's destination...

1:00 [captain] Surface LF wreck on Sonar.

1:04 [Narrator] ...the most famous wreck site in history.

1:07 [captain] Present depth, three-eight-one-zero.

1:09 At bottom.

1:20 [Narrator] For over a century,

1:22 the tragic fate of Titanic has been a global obsession.

1:26 [reporter] Scientists have found wreckage of the S.S.

1:28 Titanic.

1:29 [Narrator] A story so compelling that people risk their lives,

1:34 spending millions of dollars just to get a glimpse of the wreck.

1:43 This investigation will allow us to see Titanic in a whole new way.

1:49 -The remarkable new images of the Titanic, as you've never seen it before.

1:53 -The largest underwater scanning project in history.

1:56 It's incredible to see it like this.

1:59 [Narrator] Over 700,000 scanned images, 16 terabytes of data,

2:03 and almost two years of research and processing,

2:06 have produced a full-sized digital replica of the ship,

2:10 a virtual twin of Titanic.

2:14 -Wow.

2:15 This is a view I've never had before.

2:22 [Narrator] A replica so detailed...

2:24 -See the numbers?

2:25 -It's incredible when you see the full scale.

2:27 [Narrator] ...It will offer new insights into the sinking.

2:29 -Looking at it in this scale,

2:31 you would think the ship had been struck by some enormous missile.

2:37 [Narrator] And new evidence of the final moments of those on board.

2:41 -They were trying to launch one last lifeboat.

2:48 theme music playing] [reporter] When she set sail from Southampton,

2:58 England in the spring of 1912,

3:00 she was hailed as the most luxurious steamship in the world.

3:03 And on this her maiden voyage, she was unsurpassed and unsinkable.

3:07 Her name, of course, the Titanic.

3:17 -On tenth of April 1912,

3:19 Titanic begins her maiden voyage from Southampton to New York.

3:24 She's billed as the greatest most luxurious ship of her day.

3:29 [Narrator] It is the golden age of the ocean liner.

3:34 Two companies, White Star Line and Cunard,

3:37 vie for supremacy on the route across the Atlantic.

3:42 Cunard ships were typically faster.

3:45 But White Star had the edge when it came to luxury.

3:49 And the gigantic Titanic was the jewel in their crown.

3:55 [Yasmin Khan] On board, there are aristocrats.

3:56 There are business magnates,

3:57 but there's also immigrants who are going to the Americas to make a new life.

4:03 [Narrator] In just seven days' time,

4:07 Titanic should be steaming triumphantly into New York.

4:11 The world's press, waiting to greet her.

4:14 Instead, she'll be at the bottom of the Atlantic,

4:18 and almost 1,500 people will be dead.

4:29 A century on, many details about the sinking are still debated.

4:37 [Yasmin Khan] Titanic's never given up her secrets easily,

4:40 and for 70 years, nobody even knew where she was.

4:43 And then in 1985, Bob Ballard found the wreck.

4:49 [reporter] Today, the French and the American men,

4:51 who found the Titanic will celebrate.

4:53 [Narrator] Ballard had found the greatest of all lost ships,

4:57 and scientists clamored to study the wreck.

5:01 But 2.5 miles down, under atmospheric pressure,

5:05 almost 400 times greater than at sea level,

5:09 conditions make it hard to see more than fragments of the ship at a time.

5:15 [crew] We're still searching for the stern.

5:17 We can't find it.

5:20 [Yasmin Khan] Many expeditions have been down

5:22 to the wreck over the past 40 years.

5:26 But it's pitch black down there.

5:30 So, it's not being possible to see the whole ship.

5:34 Viewing it has been like shining a flashlight in the dark, until now.

5:42 [captain] Your depth is eight-zero-five meters, heading three-zero-zero.

5:47 [Narrator] After a 2-and- a-half-hour descent to the ocean floor,

5:52 two unmanned subs named, Romeo and Juliet, get to work.

6:00 While Romeo films high-resolution footage of the ship and sea floor.

6:04 [captain] The stronger that laser line gets, it starts to get more defined.

6:08 [crew] Roger that.

6:09 Moving to next position.

6:11 [Narrator] Equipped with lasers recording millions of measurements,

6:14 Juliet captures every inch of the wreck.

6:19 [captain] Oh, yeah, that's looking nice right there.

6:20 You must be really close now.

6:24 -I have every expectation that we're going to see the most

6:28 accurate portrayal of the wreck site that's ever been offered.

6:33 [captain] Park's at the ladder Tom, are you ready?

6:36 [Narrator] World-renowned expert, Parks Stevenson,

6:38 has been on multiple dives to Titanic.

6:40 [captain] Thrusters, we are beginning to pump them now.

6:44 [Narrator] He hopes the scan will offer insights

6:46 into some of the questions which still surround the wreck.

6:49 [captain] Hatch is secure.

6:53 [Parks Stephenson] I'm intrigued by mysteries.

6:56 People thought that the ship could not sink.

7:00 So how did she end up like this on the ocean floor?

7:05 [captain] Coming up on the wreck site.

7:07 [Parks Stephenson] What actually happened that night?

7:11 I often view the shipwreck as the last surviving witness to the disaster.

7:20 The way she's torn apart, the way the pieces of her are bent or torn,

7:27 these all tell a story, and so,

7:30 it's vital that we listen to the stories that the wreck can tell.

7:38 [Narrator] Footage from the Romeo sub quickly offers glimpses of these stories.

7:43 Snapshots of humanity among the scattered wreckage.

7:50 Hundreds of wine bottles.

7:56 A dress.

8:00 A doll's head.

8:04 All are a stark reminder.

8:07 Titanic isn't just an object of fascination.

8:13 She's a graveyard.

8:17 One which the scan will allow us to study from a respectful distance.

8:27 After three weeks at sea, scanning 24 hours a day,

8:34 the work of the expedition team is complete.

8:38 -Hi five.

8:39 Yeah.

8:41 -Job done, sailing home.

8:44 [Narrator] But it will take over a year to research

8:46 and piece together the enormous amount of data gathered.

8:50 [Parks Stephenson] This operation has a lot of promise.

8:53 Having a tool of a virtual twin of the Titanic wreck, that's huge.

9:08 [Narrator] Awaiting access to the digital twin,

9:11 Parks has assembled a team to help him examine it in detail.

9:17 [Parks Stephenson] This will give you just

9:18 basically the context of the ship itself.

9:22 [Narrator] Master Mariner, Captain Chris Hearn,

9:24 wants to study the twin from a sailor's point of view.

9:31 [Chris Hearn] As somebody who has crossed the Atlantic and been in ice,

9:34 a ship is very much about its crew.

9:38 What was their experience when the ship was sinking?

9:42 If you had the whole wreck site, what could you do with that?

9:47 -We can totally recreate that night.

9:49 [Narrator] Metallurgist, Doctor Jennifer Hooper,

9:52 has spent years in the lab studying small fragments of the wreck.

9:57 [Jennifer Hooper] Going from examining the materials in a laboratory

10:01 to feeling like I'm on the sea floor, staring at this wreck site is something I

10:07 never thought I would see in my lifetime.

10:11 -Hopefully, we're going to get the answers to some

10:14 of these questions that have been bugging me for decades.

10:19 [Narrator] After almost two years of research and processing,

10:21 over 700,000 scan images have been painstakingly pieced together.

10:31 At a gigantic sound stage,

10:33 colossal LED panels will project the image of the twin at up to full scale,

10:39 bringing the investigators face to face with the severed wreckage of Titanic.

10:51 ominous music playing] [underwater metal groaning][♪ ominous music playing]

11:13 [underwater metal groaning] [Chris Hearn] Well, look at that.

11:37 I can tell you, I'm in the ship simulation business,

11:40 and I've never seen anything like that.

11:41 [Parks Stephenson] I've actually been here in a submersible,

11:43 but I only see just a little bit out my viewport.

11:47 It's just so immense.

11:53 When you are in a submersible,

11:55 you can see maybe only a few meters in front of you.

11:59 But with the digital twin, you can see the entire wreck site.

12:05 Now, I have a better view of Titanic than I ever did at the Titanic.

12:14 -We're around 12,000 feet at the bottom of the ocean.

12:19 Looking up at the Titanic.

12:23 -Studying this under microscope doesn't really prepare you for this.

12:36 Seeing the Titanic wreck site in full scale, I finally understood how small I am

12:44 in comparison to everything that I'm looking at.

12:49 I was able to truly experience the sense of destruction.

13:04 [Parks Stephenson] This is where she ripped in two.

13:08 [Narrator] The digital twin not only allows the team to explore the ship itself,

13:12 but the destruction caused by the crash that sank her.

13:18 [Chris Hearn] I wasn't really prepared for the level

13:20 of damage that the scan showed us.

13:23 It's catastrophic in its scale.

13:27 That really struck me.

13:34 [Narrator] We've known since her discovery that the ship lies in two parts.

13:38 But the wreck site is so massive,

13:40 no one has ever seen it all at once, until now.

13:46 The stern sits a third of a mile from the bow.

13:51 ominous music playing] [underwater metal groaning] [Parks Stephenson] Okay, now,

14:07 this is something you don't normally see because

14:10 it's very dangerous underneath the overhanging stern here.

14:15 Trying to get in here with a submersible, it's not very often done.

14:24 [Narrator] The twin allows the experts

14:25 to study near inaccessible parts of the ship.

14:30 [Parks Stephenson] Here's a starboard propeller over here.

14:33 [Narrator] Taking in features which are almost impossible

14:35 to see on a manned mission to the site.

14:39 [Parks Stephenson] Ah, you see that right there?

14:42 The numbers.

14:43 That's 401, that's Titanic's hull number.

14:48 [Jennifer Hooper] Oh, wow.

14:49 It's in pristine condition.

14:50 [Parks Stephenson] The best.

14:52 [Narrator] From the tiniest details to its colossal scale,

14:56 the scan offers an entirely new perspective on Titanic.

15:00 And the experts have only just begun to scratch

15:03 the surface of what the twin can tell them.

15:08 [Parks Stephenson] I am really,

15:10 really excited to see what the rest of this is going to look like.

15:17 To have the wreck site at my command to see what happened to the ship.

15:23 Wow.

15:25 The possibilities are endless.

15:28 ominous music playing] [metal groaning] [Yasmin Khan] The disaster of 14th,

15:40 April 1912 happens on a cold, clear,

15:44 starry night, four days into Titanic's maiden voyage.

15:53 Jack Phillips, a wireless operator,

15:55 receives a message that there is pack ice and icebergs up ahead.

16:05 In first class, Captain Smith is with Bruce Ismay,

16:10 chairman of the White Star Line.

16:12 While up on the bridge, First Officer Murdoch is keeping watch.

16:17 At 11:39 p.m., three bells ring out.

16:20 [bell ringing] And that's the warning of an obstacle up ahead.

16:27 First Officer Murdoch rams the engine ship's telegraph to stop,

16:32 sending a signal to cut the power.

16:34 He then demands that Titanic turn harder starboard,

16:38 hoping to steer the ship to safety.

16:40 And seconds later, the Titanic hits the iceberg.

16:44 [thud] Many on board felt nothing.

16:52 Even Frederick Fleet, who sounded that alarm from the crow's nest,

16:56 said it felt like a close shave.

16:59 [Narrator] And yet this glancing blow sank a ship thought to be unsinkable.

17:07 The experts were hoping that the twin can show us how.

17:15 [Jennifer Hooper] With the scan,

17:16 what is exciting is that we actually do have our first visible ice damage.

17:22 So, take a look up here at this porthole.

17:29 This porthole was smashed by the ice.

17:35 First-class passenger, Margaret Swift,

17:38 saw the ice that had come through that porthole.

17:43 That tells us that the iceberg was at least 30 feet above water line.

17:48 So, the scan is telling us the size of the iceberg.

17:52 It's definitively giving us information that will help

17:55 us understand more about the collision that night.

18:06 [Narrator] It's tantalizing new evidence of the iceberg strike,

18:09 but Titanic's fatal wound appears hidden from view.

18:16 When she sank, the ship's bow hit the seabed with such

18:19 force that nearly half of it was buried in mud.

18:29 Now the twin can provide the experts with a brand-new perspective.

18:34 [Parks Stephenson] Okay, I have never seen this depicted before,

18:37 and certainly not in this scale.

18:39 [Chris Hearn] What a different view now.

18:41 [laughs] [Parks Stephenson] You see how much

18:43 of the bow has dug into the ocean bottom?

18:45 Can you imagine the force needed to propel

18:48 that much of the ship into the ocean bottom?

18:53 [Jennifer Hooper] I mean, the iceberg damage should be here, but it's not.

18:58 We can't see it because it's under the sea floor.

19:01 -No, it's at least 20-25 feet below the mud line.

19:07 [Narrator] Although evidence of the impact appears lost to the ocean floor,

19:13 the experts think that the twin could still provide answers.

19:19 To decode the clues offered by the wreckage,

19:21 the investigation turns to Titanic's birthplace.

19:27 [ships horn] Taking over two years to build,

19:33 Titanic was designed and constructed here...

19:38 ...at Harland& Wolff in Northern Ireland, on the shores of Belfast Lough,

19:44 a company at the forefront of shipbuilding, even today.

19:52 Built in this dock, her blueprints were drawn up by skilled draftsmen next door.

20:06 [Yasmin Khan] Titanic was the most technologically advanced ship of the age.

20:13 These original blueprints show she was divided into 16 watertight compartments.

20:20 These were designed to collect floodwater in a small area.

20:25 What's more, Titanic would stay afloat, even if up to four of these flooded.

20:33 This was what cemented her reputation as the unsinkable ship.

20:44 [Narrator] After the tragedy, Harland& Wolff's naval architect, Edward Wilding,

20:49 was called on to explain how

20:50 the ship's fail-safes were so catastrophically overwhelmed.

20:55 His starting point was that more than four

20:58 compartments must have been damaged by the iceberg,

21:01 the weight of the floodwater pulling the ship below the surface.

21:06 -Wilding set about calculating the impact

21:08 of the iceberg and concluded that there had been

21:12 a series of puncture holes along the hull on an area of about 12 square feet.

21:18 Wilding based his findings on the testimony of surviving crew

21:22 and passengers and on his own detailed knowledge of the ship's design.

21:26 But even after the wreck was discovered, testing his theory was impossible.

21:32 The evidence buried below the mud line.

21:38 [Narrator] But now, the investigation has brought together experts

21:43 from around the world to put Wilding's findings to the test.

21:50 At University College London, renowned naval architect Professor Jeom-Kee

21:54 Paik is joined by fellow specialists,

21:59 Doctor Simon Benson, and Doctor Stephen Payne,

22:03 designer of the cruise liner, Queen Mary II.

22:06 [Dr.

22:06 Stephen Payne] This is the first time we can

22:08 actually use a computer simulation to test Wilding's hypothesis.

22:13 [Narrator] Based on information from Titanic's blueprints,

22:15 combined with their estimated speed of 22 knots,

22:19 the team uses cutting-edge technology to simulate the iceberg strike.

22:25 -Wow, here it goes.

22:28 We can see the ship glancing blow,

22:30 and it's actually turning to starboard, as it comes past.

22:33 Ah, yeah, interesting.

22:34 We can see the ice actually splintering off.

22:40 We actually now find out from these simulations that the time

22:42 it took for the Titanic to collide with the iceberg,

22:46 the glancing blow was 6.3 seconds.

22:51 [Narrator] 6.3 seconds.

22:52 A mere moment.

22:54 Yet what could have been a fleeting scrape proved catastrophic.

23:00 And the simulation can now reveal the full

23:02 extent of the damage for the very first time.

23:06 -Well, this for me is where it gets really interesting because here,

23:10 we really see the power of the simulation.

23:14 So, here's the collision.

23:17 And it very quickly spreads quite a thin line of gash, isn't it?

23:23 But we can see the ruptures occurring.

23:28 [Dr.

23:28 Simon Benson] Wilding predicted that the total area

23:30 of the holes would be about 12 square feet.

23:33 We are, with this new prediction, looking at something in the order of 18.

23:38 -The Wilding estimation is incredible.

23:42 [Narrator] The figures may differ slightly, but Wilding was right.

23:46 The scale of the damage was minimal compared to the size of the ship overall.

23:53 But crucially, it wasn't confined to one area.

24:05 [Chris Hearn] Wow.

24:06 [Parks Stephenson] So, this is the damage.

24:09 -We're seeing a simulation of the iceberg damage for the very first time.

24:15 [Narrator] The digital twin allows the experts

24:17 to see the impact pattern precisely mapped out.

24:22 [Jennifer Hooper] The damage begins, the front,

24:25 and it crosses over the compartments, all the way to boiler room number six.

24:33 And then it crosses into boiler room number five.

24:38 You have one small section in boiler room number five,

24:42 and another very small section of damage in the forepeak.

24:49 [Parks Stephenson] How small?

24:50 -That last bit is only the size of two pieces of paper.

24:56 That's six compartments along the starboard side and the ship

25:00 was only designed for four compartments to flood.

25:06 So you've got small margins on one end or the other that sank this ship.

25:15 [Chris Hearn] So, two small holes?

25:17 -That's what the simulation shows us.

25:20 [Narrator] The areas that made all the difference are tiny.

25:26 Small holes either side of the four badly damaged compartments.

25:32 Without them, Titanic might not have sunk.

25:36 -We all imagine that it was a giant hole— -Yeah.

25:41 -That sank such a massive ship.

25:42 In reality, it was a very small amount of damage over a long

25:46 distance and fractions of a second that ended up sinking the ship.

25:58 [Parks Stephenson] So, if true,

25:59 it suggests an irony that in turning to avoid the iceberg,

26:03 the crew had created an area of damage lengthy enough to open

26:08 up too many compartments to the sea and sink the ship.

26:15 [Narrator] The irony doesn't stop there.

26:22 At the British inquiry into the sinking, Wilding,

26:25 one of the men who knew Titanic best,

26:28 predicted that had the crew not turned the ship to try and avoid the iceberg,

26:33 instead, hitting it head-on, she would have stayed afloat.

26:39 The simulation will now put that theory to the test.

26:44 -Because this has never been done before.

26:46 [Dr.

26:46 Stephen Payne] No, absolutely not.

26:47 Let's see it go.

26:54 Oh, wow.

26:56 Look at this crumpling of that deck.

27:00 All the energy of the Titanic is now going into that collision.

27:05 Okay, so, can we have the close-up?

27:08 So we're really gonna see the crumple zone as that wow.

27:15 All that steel mashing into the ice.

27:17 [Dr.

27:17 Simon Benson] Just imagine the noise that there would have been.

27:28 [Dr.

27:28 Stephen Payne] Wilding predicted that with this collision,

27:31 Titanic would survive.

27:35 We look at the blueprint.

27:37 We see, well, where are we going to?

27:38 We've lost the peak tank, cargo tanks, and we've ended.

27:42 -So it's just forwarded the bridge.

27:43 -Just forwarded the bridge.

27:44 So we've actually only lost what, 4 compartments?

27:46 -4 compartments.

27:47 -So.

27:47 -She would have stayed afloat.

27:48 -It would have.

27:56 [Jennifer Hooper] So, based on the simulation, it would not have sunk.

28:04 [Chris Hearn] Yeah.

28:06 [Narrator] The front-on simulation gives us a fleeting

28:08 glimpse of a different outcome for the tragic ship.

28:14 What it doesn't provide is a sailor's perspective.

28:19 -Think about the crew.

28:22 You don't steer directly into an iceberg.

28:26 I doubt very highly anybody would have done it.

28:28 A lot of the crew had their bunks forward.

28:32 And so, if Murdoch making that kind of an action

28:34 to take the iceberg right on the bow,

28:37 he would have likely killed everybody that was in those forward spaces

28:47 But the officer's maneuver to try and turn away from the iceberg,

28:51 as hard as it is to say, essentially seal the Titanic's fate.

28:59 [Narrator] With the ship now taking on water,

29:01 the lives of over 2000 people hang in the balance.

29:06 The decisions made by Titanic's crew,

29:09 are about to become more crucial by the minute.

29:13 ominous music playing] [rushing water] [Narrator]

29:21 Within 20 minutes of the iceberg strike,

29:23 Captain Smith has had multiple reports of flooding in the ship's boiler rooms.

29:30 -Fireman, Fred Barrett, was a witness to what happened.

29:35 He was working in boiler room six.

29:38 When he gave his testimony to the inquiry, he said, "The bell rang.

29:44 He called out "Shut all doors." Then a large

29:47 volume of water came through the side of the ship.

29:59 He ran from that section, just as the watertight doors came down.

30:14 The man responsible for keeping the ship's

30:15 boilers alight was Chief Engineer Joseph Bell.

30:21 He was in charge of 200 men who powered Titanic 24 hours a day.

30:32 [Narrator] The boiler rooms ran over half the length of the ship.

30:37 40 minutes after the collision, number six was already lost,

30:41 and number five had a small, paper-sized breach.

30:48 [Yasmin Khan] Titanic was taking on water fast.

30:51 Wilding estimated that 16,000 tons of it had now entered the ship.

30:57 [Narrator] The damaged compartments fill up.

31:00 The ship tilts forward, water spilling from one compartment to the next.

31:05 -Suddenly...

31:07 [rushing water] ...the water bursts into boiler room five.

31:15 And Bell was heard to say, "My God,

31:17 we are lost." [Narrator] Bell and his men were forced back to boiler room two,

31:33 the only one still capable of providing power to the ship.

31:40 [Yasmin Khan] One hour, 40 after the iceberg strike,

31:43 Chief Bell sent his stokers up on deck to save themselves.

31:54 And all 35 engineering officers stayed with him below deck.

32:00 [Chris Hearn] Ultimately,

32:00 it came down to a skeleton crew in boiler room number two,

32:04 essentially of the engineers themselves.

32:07 Everybody else has been released.

32:11 [Narrator] It's clear to Bell that Titanic is doomed.

32:18 He now had to pivot from saving the ship to saving lives.

32:25 [Yasmin Khan] They were in the middle of the Atlantic, and it was pitch black.

32:29 If the power went off, they would be in total darkness,

32:32 making it incredibly difficult for people to get to the deck and into lifeboats.

32:38 And if the Titanic's wireless room went down,

32:41 the nearby ships couldn't be alerted to stranded survivors.

32:47 [Narrator] In short, without power,

32:49 the chances of those on board surviving were slim.

32:59 The courage of Titanic's engineers is a story that's endured for over a century.

33:07 But now, the digital twin allows the experts to actually examine

33:11 the place where Bell and his men battled on clearly visible,

33:15 where the ship tore apart.

33:24 [Jennifer Hooper] Okay, so we're in Boiler room number two.

33:29 This is essentially the last place where they kept the fires going.

33:42 [Parks Stephenson] This is what's left of the heart of Titanic.

33:45 The steam that's being generated in these boilers is

33:50 providing the power and the light to the ship.

33:55 These engineers down here, they couldn't see what was going on outside.

34:02 [Jennifer Hooper] The conditions must have been terrible.

34:07 Brutally hot.

34:09 The steam.

34:13 -Real tests of leadership often come under the worst of circumstances.

34:20 I reflect on Bell's efforts that night.

34:24 He was going to do everything he could so

34:28 that other people may have a chance to live.

34:41 [Narrator] The digital twin shows us not only the location of Bell's last stand,

34:46 it also offers new evidence of how he kept

34:49 the power on, even as the ship began to sink.

34:57 Nearly 2,300 feet across the wreck site, the experts have spotted a clue.

35:03 [Parks Stephenson] Okay,

35:04 we're coming up on the port side of the stern back here.

35:07 There's the mainmast that's collapsed and lying over the edge.

35:14 So, let's rotate this thing around.

35:16 And take a look at this.

35:23 I found this very interesting.

35:25 It's a steam valve.

35:26 It didn't come from here.

35:27 It landed on the wreck after the stern had settled.

35:31 And the flap is seen in the open position right now.

35:39 [Jennifer Hooper] Why is that important?

35:41 [Chris Hearn] Well, this is a line that was taking

35:43 the remaining steam from the boiler rooms to the emergency dynamos.

35:51 [Parks Stephenson] They provided life to the ship,

35:53 the lighting, the heating, running the pumps.

35:59 [Narrator] Titanic's emergency dynamo was over

36:01 40 feet higher than the main generator, so it would take longer to flood.

36:06 It was connected to boiler room two through an emergency pipe,

36:10 and the valve had to be opened manually.

36:14 [Chris Hearn] You can see this steam valve is clearly open,

36:18 which means steam was continuously flowing through to the emergency dynamos,

36:24 and this action to keep this open saved hundreds of lives.

36:37 [Narrator] Survivors testified that over two hours after striking the iceberg,

36:42 the ship's lights were still on.

36:50 [Jennifer Hooper] So this is proof that the survivors

36:53 who saw lights to the very end, it's true.

36:57 -Yeah.

37:01 [Narrator] This steam valve is frozen in its final act.

37:06 Responding to Bell's orders.

37:10 Keeping the power on and hope alive.

37:24 While Bell and his men fight on, above them, panic is starting to spread.

37:31 At the lifeboats, the crew struggle to keep order,

37:35 and senior officers are faced with life and death choices.

37:49 [Narrator] Until 11:39 P.M.

37:52 passengers had enjoyed a peaceful evening and luxurious surroundings

37:55 and were looking forward to arriving in New York.

38:06 But nearly two hours after Titanic hit the iceberg,

38:10 the situation for those on board is deteriorating fast.

38:21 As water begins to flood the corridors,

38:23 the passengers start rushing to the boat deck.

38:31 [Yasmin Khan] By law in 1912,

38:32 ocean liners were only required to have 16 lifeboats.

38:36 And in an emergency would have been expected to stay

38:38 afloat long enough to ferry people to a rescue ship.

38:41 So, Titanic only had enough lifeboat spaces for about half of those onboard.

38:49 [Narrator] The order is to start loading women and children into the boats.

38:53 In the chaos, most of the lifeboats aren't even launched full.

38:58 A tension quickly turns to panic.

39:10 On the boat deck, there are scenes of both heroism and heartbreak.

39:24 [Yasmin Khan] Ida Strauss, for instance,

39:26 wouldn't board a lifeboat if she couldn't go with her husband and said,

39:30 "We have lived together, and we'll die together." Rhoda Abbott,

39:38 who was traveling with her two teenage sons, reached a lifeboat being boarded.

39:44 But realizing that her boys were considered too old to go in a lifeboat,

39:49 stepped back and remained with her children.

39:52 [Narrator] 17-year-old first-class passenger Jack Thayer,

39:55 noted who joined the boat after Rhoda Abbott retreated.

40:01 -He recorded.

40:03 "There was some disturbance in loading the last two forward starboard boats.

40:07 A large crowd of men was pressing to get to the lifeboats.

40:11 No women were around as far as I could see.

40:14 I saw Ismay, who had been assisting in the loading of the last boat,

40:19 push his way into it.

40:20 It was really every man for himself." Bruce

40:25 Ismay was the chairman of the White Star Line.

40:28 He went on to survive, but his reputation never recovered.

40:37 [Narrator] As passengers become increasingly desperate,

40:39 the crew struggle to keep order.

40:43 [Yasmin Khan] Michel Navratil said, "Honest people didn't stand a chance

40:47 as passengers descended to deviance in order

40:50 to survive." [Narrator] With the sinking

41:01 of Titanic making headlines around the world,

41:04 the press was hungry for heroes and villains.

41:09 But these were some of the most chaotic moments of the whole tragedy,

41:13 and conflicting versions of events quickly emerged.

41:20 -The first officer, William Murdoch,

41:22 was in charge of the lifeboats on the starboard side of the ship,

41:25 and he was desperately trying to lower them

41:27 as the water was gushing up to meet them.

41:32 Afterwards, as these newspaper reports show,

41:34 he was accused of having shot himself on the bridge and abandoning his post.

41:39 It says here "he was seen whipping a gleaming bit of metal from his pocket,

41:43 deliberately placing it to his temple,

41:45 and pulling the trigger." [distant gunshot]

41:54 [Narrator] The story was headline news.

41:58 Murdoch was painted as cowardly, his reputation in tatters.

42:04 But even at the time, his actions were disputed.

42:08 [Yasmin Khan] Second Officer Lightoller,

42:10 the most senior officer who survived the sinking,

42:13 refuted the accusation of suicide,

42:15 writing that he'd seen Murdoch swept overboard

42:17 and that he had died a hero's death.

42:23 [Narrator] Now, Parkes believes that the twin

42:25 can offer clues about Murdoch's final moments.

42:37 [Parks Stephenson] Well,

42:39 this is the number one lifeboat station, the forward davit.

42:44 [Chris Hearn] That was Murdoch station, right?

42:45 [Parks Stephenson] Yes, it was.

42:48 And you'll notice here that that davit is in the upright or retracted position.

42:56 [Narrator] Davits are cranes used to winch lifeboats down to the water.

43:01 Before being wound back to launch the next.

43:06 [Parks Stephenson] This davit is in the up position,

43:09 meaning its crew is basically trying to get a lifeboat ready to be launched.

43:15 [Narrator] In an attempt to save as many lives as possible, Murdoch,

43:19 unlike some officers,

43:21 had allowed men to join the women and children aboard his lifeboats.

43:26 [Parks Stephenson] Murdoch has been watching the water rise this whole time.

43:29 He knows he's out of time, and he's working against the rising water to try

43:33 and get one more boat into the water.

43:36 And this coincides with Second Officer Lightoller's description,

43:41 who was standing on top of the deckhouse back here.

43:45 [Narrator] At 2:15 a.m., minutes before the ship went down,

43:50 Lightoller witnessed Murdoch trying to launch one final boat.

43:56 Suddenly, Titanic dipped and the lifeboat was washed overboard.

44:01 While survivors scrambled onto it from the freezing water,

44:05 Murdoch was swept away.

44:13 [Parks Stephenson] Historians have disputed that, but this davit right

44:18 here stands in mute testimony that supports Lightoller's version of events.

44:26 Because, being in the up position is exactly what Lightoller described.

44:34 [Narrator] History has not been kind to Murdoch.

44:37 And while we may never know exactly how he died,

44:40 the twin does suggest that the accusation of cowardice

44:43 of abandoning his ship may not be fair.

44:50 [Parks Stephenson] I think it really shows that he was struggling

44:53 to save as many lives as possible right up to the very end.

44:58 They were trying to launch one last lifeboat.

45:03 He never gave up on his duty.

45:09 [Narrator] For survivors like Lightoller, the scenes at the lifeboats were some

45:12 of the most distressing of the whole disaster.

45:19 But for those left on board, the worst was still to come.

45:28 [distant screams] [Narrator] Two hours after Titanic hit the iceberg,

45:39 the ship is partially submerged,

45:41 but remarkably, thanks to Bell and his engineers, she still has power.

45:48 [Yasmin Khan] In Titanic's wireless room,

45:50 two operators, Jack Phillips and Harold Bride,

45:52 are still at their post, and desperately sending out messages.

46:15 [Narrator] Shortly after 2:00 a.m., Captain Smith told the men they had done

46:19 their duty and were relieved from their posts.

46:22 Bride prepared to leave, but Phillips worked on.

46:28 [Yasmin Khan] Bride who survived the wreck,

46:30 recalled his colleague Jack Phillips' selfless conduct,

46:34 saying, "He was a brave man.

46:38 I learned to love him that night.

46:41 And I suddenly felt a great reverence to see him

46:44 standing there sticking to his work while everybody was raging about.

46:50 I will never live to forget the work of Phillips

46:53 for the last awful 15 minutes." [Narrator] But soon after 2:00 a.m.,

47:12 The messages abruptly stop.

47:19 Titanic is about to go under.

47:30 eerie music playing] After the sinking,

47:42 two official inquiries concluded that the ship gently slipped below the waves.

47:49 But even at the time, many survivors contradicted that, testifying

47:53 Titanic broke apart before she sank.

47:59 Something confirmed when the wreck was discovered in 1985.

48:05 And the twin now allows us to see in unprecedented detail,

48:07 where the pieces came to rest, a third of a mile apart on the ocean floor.

48:18 But exactly how this great ship broke in two,

48:21 is something Parks has been investigating for decades.

48:28 [Parks Stephenson] There's a lot of mysteries in the Titanic disaster.

48:34 But the one that I've been most focused

48:37 on throughout my career in Titanic research, is the breakup.

48:44 And I think we've got the evidence

48:46 that's going to answer those questions, right here.

48:51 [Narrator] The severed ship is too

48:53 badly damaged to reveal exactly what happened.

48:56 But Parks believes that the scan can still provide answers.

49:01 Not by studying the wounded wreck itself, but the seabed around it.

49:06 [Parks Stephenson] There's an entire debris field of artifacts,

49:09 of steel sections, that you need to take a look at.

49:18 [Jennifer Hooper] Wow.

49:20 [Parks Stephenson] We're flying away.

49:23 [Chris Hearn] Wait a minute.

49:25 Oh it's the stern.

49:26 We're looking down.

49:27 [Parks Stephenson] We're going to get a God's eye view of the debris field.

49:32 [Narrator] Covering around 15 square miles countless sheds

49:36 of Titanic are scattered across the ocean floor.

49:40 Among them, key pieces, which Parks believes may be clues.

49:47 [Parks Stephenson] You can see how immense it is.

49:50 I mean, it looks chaotic, but there is a pattern to this.

49:54 And I bet we can find the evidence

49:55 that we're looking for to reconstruct the breakup here.

50:00 [Narrator] The twin allows the experts to study

50:02 Titanic's shattered fragments in more detail than ever before.

50:08 If they can piece together this twisted metal jigsaw,

50:12 the experts may be able to find out how Titanic

50:14 broke in two and what it meant for those on board.

50:30 [distant screams] [Narrator] When Titanic broke in two at 2:17 a.m.,

50:35 on April 15th, almost 1,500 people were still on board the ship.

50:44 Those in the lifeboats watched on in horror.

50:54 [Yasmin Khan] Jack Thayer, who was a 17-year-old first-class passenger,

50:58 recorded in his memoirs what he saw.

51:01 "Suddenly, the whole superstructure of the ship appeared to split.

51:05 Her stern was gradually rising into the air." "We could see groups

51:16 of people still aboard clinging in clusters or bunches like swarming bees,

51:21 only to fall in masses, pairs or singly as the great after part of the ship,

51:27 250 feet of it, rose into the sky." "Gradually,

51:37 she turned her deck away from us, as though to hide from our sight,

51:41 the awful spectacle." [Narrator] Based on historical accounts like

51:47 these, many have assumed that the ship snapped cleanly in two.

51:54 But the investigation suggests the truth may be more complex.

51:59 To find out what really happened,

52:00 the experts have used the unique level of detail

52:03 provided by the scan to comb through the debris field,

52:08 identifying shattered sections of the hull,

52:13 and painstakingly piecing them back together.

52:22 upbeat music playing] [Chris Hearn] Wow.

52:37 Look at the size of that area.

52:42 [Jennifer Hooper] So we're looking at the side of the ship,

52:45 and we're seeing some of the pieces of the hull found in the debris field.

52:51 They're massive.

52:53 We're talking like 100 feet or more up the side of the ship.

53:02 The big piece at the top,

53:04 I've studied rivets from that big piece under the microscope,

53:08 steel rivets, and how that piece was actually held onto the ship.

53:12 -So, you have a personal connection to this piece.

53:14 [Chris Hearn] Wow, that's amazing.

53:17 I'm speechless, like, the size of these pieces is huge.

53:23 [Narrator] By allowing us to see the hull reassembled,

53:26 the digital twin shows that far from snapping neatly,

53:29 a huge section of the ship was completely destroyed.

53:35 -It was a giant catastrophic fracture.

53:40 As the stresses are building up, you've got tension across the top, compression,

53:45 and buckling on the bottom of the ship,

53:47 and slowly, it turns into a domino effect.

53:51 It's stressed on the next component and the next component.

53:54 It's like a chain reaction.

53:57 [Narrator] Almost all of a ship's strength is in a shell.

54:00 With that compromised, her exposed interior was obliterated.

54:08 [Chris Hearn] I thought it was more of a clean break, and it certainly was not.

54:13 You would think the ship had been struck by some enormous missile.

54:19 It's that catastrophic.

54:23 [Jennifer Hooper] 20% of the ship just

54:26 completely destroyed in probably a matter of seconds.

54:33 So many people lost their lives.

54:36 [Narrator] Titanic shattered in multiple places.

54:40 [Parks Stephenson] This was a cataclysmic moment.

54:43 70, 80 feet of it broke at the same time with human beings in there.

54:52 It's unimaginable.

54:59 [Narrator] As Titanic broke in two,

55:01 the fate of everyone in that part of the ship was sealed.

55:07 The twin can offer a glimpse into the final moments of those on board.

55:16 Including two of America's richest men.

55:32 [Narrator] When Titanic goes down, 80% of the men are lost.

55:42 -Although some male passengers did survive,

55:44 Edwardian ideals of stoicism, and chivalry,

55:47 meant that the vast majority of men would stay behind on the ship.

55:57 Alfred Rush, a 17-year-old,

55:59 he'd only been presented with his first pair of long trousers the night before,

56:03 refused to enter the lifeboat, saying, "I will stay with the men."

56:12 [Narrator] Another famous tale of self-sacrifice,

56:14 was that of multi-millionaire Benjamin Guggenheim.

56:19 -We have the testimony of James Etches, a steward, who said,

56:25 "I gave a life belt to Guggenheim, and he gave me a message.

56:29 It said, 'If anything should happen to me,

56:31 tell my wife in New York that I've done my best in doing my duty.

56:35 We've dressed up in our best and are prepared

56:37 to go down like gentlemen." Another steward reported hearing him say,

56:43 "No woman shall be left on this ship because Ben Guggenheim

56:47 was a coward." The popular narrative is that he escorted his mistress,

56:52 and her servant, to the lifeboats, and then went back to the first-class cabins.

56:59 [Narrator] The image of Guggenheim waiting bravely

57:01 for the waters to meet him is a romantic one.

57:04 But if he did remain in his room, his death would have been far from peaceful.

57:12 The digital twin makes clear the violence that those in this section

57:15 of the ship experienced in their final moments.

57:23 [Yasmin Khan] Guggenheim's suite was right

57:25 at the epicenter of where the ship broke up.

57:30 [Narrator] Near Guggenheim's room,

57:32 was that of another of America's richest men, J.J.

57:36 Astor.

57:39 Titanic had over 300 first class cabins,

57:42 and Astor was reported to have paid over $30,000

57:44 in today's money for a pair of these premium suites.

57:50 What's left of them is visible on the twin.

57:57 Blown apart as the ship went down.

58:06 Astor's body was recovered a week after the sinking.

58:14 [Parks Stephenson] It seems to have been important

58:15 at the time that the noblemen, like the J.J.

58:19 Astors, or the Benjamin Guggenheims, died a very noble, rather peaceful death.

58:28 But, in Titanic, it didn't matter what your status was.

58:34 You would all meet the same fate.

58:39 [Narrator] On that night in 1912, death did not discriminate.

58:45 Over 60 feet below Astor's suite,

58:48 Joseph Bell and his engineers had remained tending

58:51 to the fires as the ship went down.

58:57 Made visible by its position, right at the ship's fracture,

59:01 is what's left of boiler room two.

59:07 [Parks Stephenson] If you look at this boiler here,

59:09 you see the shadow up in the upper quadrant?

59:13 It's concaved inward.

59:15 And that's an indication of an implosive event,

59:18 which means that these boilers had to have

59:21 been operating at the time the ship breaks, and the bow starts to go under.

59:34 [Chris Hearn] They stayed here.

59:36 They steel themselves to their task because they were professionals,

59:39 and they knew their duty.

59:41 And their duty was to give people a chance up on the top deck.

59:46 And for me, this is a really powerful place.

59:53 [Narrator] All 35 engineers would go down with the ship.

1:00:03 [Chris Hearn] We're standing right at the point where their lives ended.

1:00:13 So, this scan gives us an opportunity to observe

1:00:18 a memorial to the bravery and the dedication of those engineers.

1:00:35 [Narrator] Bell's body was never found.

1:00:43 Two hours and 40 minutes after the ship hit the iceberg,

1:00:46 about 700 people are huddled together in lifeboats.

1:00:51 The rest are either fighting for their lives in the freezing water or dead.

1:00:59 But over a century on, the scan can still shine

1:01:02 a light on the lives lost to the ocean floor.

1:01:15 [Yasmin Khan] After the ship broke up, the bow quickly disappeared,

1:01:19 but the stern stayed afloat for a few more minutes.

1:01:22 And up there on the poop deck,

1:01:24 was Assistant Purser Frank Prentice, who saw exactly what was happening.

1:01:29 He recalled that Titanic rose suddenly and described

1:01:33 hearing everything that wasn't secured crashing through the ship.

1:01:39 Then she began to plummet.

1:01:43 Frank Prentice climbed over the railing,

1:01:44 and he dropped down 100 feet into the water below.

1:02:00 [Narrator] The bow sinks first, shedding its contents the whole way down.

1:02:10 It hits the mud with such force that it jackknifes.

1:02:21 dramatic music playing] The stern follows, flattening out into a spiral.

1:02:36 Her freight and furnishings are strewn across the ocean floor.

1:02:47 Thousands of items are buried in the mud.

1:02:50 Some are about to be seen for the first time in over 100 years.

1:03:00 [Jennifer Hooper] When I saw the debris field,

1:03:02 my first instinct was thinking about putting the ship back together,

1:03:07 thinking about the materials.

1:03:09 But, part of me understands that...

1:03:14 ...there are personal possessions.

1:03:17 There's cups.

1:03:18 There's suitcases.

1:03:20 There's bits of leather,

1:03:22 there's people's things that may last a lot longer than the metal.

1:03:32 [Narrator] The debris field has already yielded answers about the ship itself.

1:03:36 But it can also offer a unique insight into life on board.

1:03:56 An ornate bench, which lies 715 feet from the stern,

1:04:01 once adorned one of the upper decks.

1:04:06 And 416 feet away, the centerpiece of a glass ceiling dome,

1:04:11 which once capped one of the grandest staircases on the ship.

1:04:19 Footage captured during the scan has been subject to months of research,

1:04:23 using records and insurance claims to try and identify

1:04:26 the owners of items glimpsed on the seabed.

1:04:31 One of the suitcases matches the claim of first-class passenger,

1:04:35 Charlotte Cardeza, who survived the wreck.

1:04:38 [Yasmin Khan] She was well known for her Louis

1:04:40 Vuitton luggage and her extensive collection of shoes.

1:04:48 Charlotte Cardeza's maid recalled being impressed by her mistress's bravery.

1:04:53 Reporting that she remained entirely calm in spite of the danger.

1:05:02 [Narrator] This array of shoes and opera glasses,

1:05:04 may have belonged to theater owner Henry B.

1:05:07 Harris, who perished in the sinking.

1:05:16 One of the most intriguing personal items lies nearly 500 feet from the stern,

1:05:22 a pigs tusk bangle next to a shark's tooth.

1:05:28 [Yasmin Khan] This shark's tooth is a lucky charm,

1:05:30 and it would have been attached to this pocket

1:05:32 watch which bears an Advance Australia crest.

1:05:36 We've tracked down that belonged to a Scottish businessman, Colonel John Weir.

1:05:42 After his death, a family secret was revealed.

1:05:45 His Scottish wife had a nasty surprise when she made her claim to the estate

1:05:49 because it turned out he had an Australian

1:05:51 family who were making exactly the same claim.

1:05:58 [Narrator] These remarkable findings bring humanity

1:06:01 to the dark and desolate wreck site.

1:06:06 But there are still countless items on the sea floor, whose owners are unknown.

1:06:13 A pair of men's shoes, lying together on the promenade deck,

1:06:18 suggests they mark the final resting place of a third-class passenger,

1:06:22 whose remains are long gone.

1:06:28 And this ornate doll's head, which may have belonged to any of some

1:06:32 60 children who did not survive the tragedy.

1:06:48 For prolific Titanic explorer, Parks Stephenson,

1:06:51 the digital twin enables investigation and study

1:06:53 of the site without disturbing or further damaging the wreck.

1:06:59 [Parks Stephenson] Every time I think I've seen everything I

1:07:02 need to see out of this, I see something new.

1:07:05 This digital twin has opened up a whole new thought process.

1:07:11 And where that takes me, I don't know if I see the end of it.

1:07:20 This is the most impactful thing that has

1:07:23 happened since the wreck was first found in 1985.

1:07:31 [Jennifer Hooper] Look at the rusticles all over the ship.

1:07:35 [Chris Hearn] It's like the by-product of bacteria, right?

1:07:38 [Jennifer Hooper] Yeah, it's actually corrosion on the sea floor.

1:07:43 It's bacteria that eats the iron and produces rust.

1:07:50 So, it's slowly eating the wreck.

1:07:54 It's eating the ship,

1:07:55 and the ship will eventually degrade and just fall in on itself.

1:08:01 This is a unique site.

1:08:04 It's its own ecosystem, now.

1:08:06 It's living and breathing and changing constantly.

1:08:16 [Narrator] Titanic won't be here forever.

1:08:20 But the digital twin is now frozen the evidence in time,

1:08:26 allowing research to continue long after the wreck's inevitable decay.

1:08:38 It has already offered remarkable insights

1:08:40 into what happened to the ship that night, and the response of those on board.

1:08:49 Now, thanks to the twin, the search for answers can continue.

1:08:58 dramatic music playing]

Study with Looplines Download Captions Watch on YouTube