NYT's Tom Friedman on regulating AI: Something bad is going to happen at some point
CNBC Television
0:00 BE EN W AT CH IN G T HE F UT UR ES T HI S MO RN IN G.
0:02 D OW F UT UR ES R IG HT N OW AR E UP B Y O VE R 1 60 P OI NT S.
0:05 T HE S& P F UT UR ES U P B Y 3 6.
0:07 T HE NA SD AQ I ND IC AT ED U P B Y MO RE TH AN 2 00 P OI NT S.
0:11 I N HI S L AT ES T PI EC E, N EW Y OR K T IM ES,
0:13 O PI NI ON CO LU MN IS T T OM F RI ED MA N S AY S TH AT T HE U NI TE D
0:15 S TA TE S AN D CH IN A M US T S TO P A CT IN G LI KE RI VA LS A ND S
0:19 TA RT A CT IN G L IK E PA RT NE RS T O TR Y A ND P RE VE NT T HE NE XT
0:21 G EN ER AT IO N OF A I F RO M FA LL IN G I NT O T HE W RO NG H AN DS.
0:25 JO IN IN G U S N OW I S P UL IT ZE R PR IZ E W IN NE
0:27 R A ND B ES T SE LL IN G AU TH OR T OM F RI ED MA N.
0:29 A ND T OM, GO OD M OR NI NG.
0:30 I T' S GO OD T O SE E YO U.
0:31 G OO D TO B E WI TH Y OU, BE CK Y.
0:33 Y OU L AY I T O UT P RE TT Y ST AR KL Y I N Y OU R CO LU MN O N T HI S.
0:36 YO U SA Y TH AT T HI S I S P ER HA PS TH E MO ST I MP OR TA NT M EE TI NG,
0:39 IM PO RT AN T M EE TI NG B ET WE EN T HE UN IT ED S TA TE S
0:41 AN D C HI NA S IN CE RI CH AR D N IX ON M ET W IT H M AO,
0:44 MA O ZE DO NG B AC K IN 1 97 2.
0:46 W HY D O YO U TH IN K T HE S TA KE S AR E S O HI GH RI GH T N OW?
0:49 W EL L, B EC KY, W E' RE B AS IC AL LY IN A I N A P HA SE C HA NG E.
0:52 W E' RE MO VI NG F RO M T HE A GE O F IN FO
0:55 RM AT IO N T O T HE A GE O F IN TE LL IG EN CE.
0:58 A ND I N T HE A GE O F IN FO RM AT IO N,
1:01 W E U SE D IN FO RM AT IO N T EC HN OL OG IE S
1:03 A S IN DI VI DU AL S T O E XT EN D OU R R EA CH.
1:06 BU T T HE SE T OO LS R EQ UI RE D Y OU T O HA VE S OM
1:09 E E XP ER TI SE T O D IR EC T TH EM A ND S OM E S KI LL.
1:14 A ND T HE Y AL WA YS H AD A K IN D OF H UM AN I N CH AR GE.
1:17 W E' RE M OV IN G IN T HE A GE OF I NT EL LI GE NC E, DR IV EN B Y A I,
1:22 WH ER E T HE S YS TE M D OE S EV ER YT HI NG F OR Y OU,
1:26 A ND A LL Y OU NE ED T O DO I S N OT H AV E KN OW LE DG E P ER S E,
1:29 B UT J US T EX PR ES S Y OU R I NT EN T.
1:31 N OW, W HE RE YO U R EA LL Y S EE T HI S T RA NS IT IO N WA S
1:34 WI TH T HE R EL EA SE O F T HE MY TH OS M OD EL B Y A NT HR OP IC,
1:40 WH ER E I T D IS CO VE RE D O R IT PR OV ED T HA T I T C OU LD
1:45 F IN D ER RO RS I N C OD E A ND E XP LO IT T HE M AT A S PE ED,
1:50 S CO PE, A ND S CA LE TH AT N O H UM AN C OU LD P OS SI BL Y MA TC H.
1:54 A ND I T CO UL D B E D ON E WI TH, YO U K NO W,
1:57 T HE L IT TL ES T NA TU RA L L AN GU AG
1:58 E I NS TR UC TI ON I N IN O TH ER W OR DS,
2:01 A 1 5 Y EA R O LD WI TH A S TA RL IN K T ER MI NA
2:03 L AN D A LA PT OP C OU LD A TT AC K AN Y C OM PA NY,
2:07 AN Y W AT ER S YS TE M, A NY EL EC TR IC IT Y C OM PA NY.
2:09 W HI CH I S WH Y A NT HR OP IC R ES PO NS IB LY DI DN 'T R EL EA SE I T.
2:13 S AM E W IT H OP EN AI.
2:14 T HE Y HA VE A S IM IL AR O NE.
2:15 YO U CA N B ET G EM IN I OF G OO GL E HA S A S IM IL AR O NE.
2:18 S O W E' RE RI GH T O N T HE E DG E O F B AS IC
2:20 AL LY CH AN GI NG T HE P HY SI CS O F GE OP OL IT IC S.
2:23 A ND T HA T' S GO IN G TO A FF EC T E VE
2:25 RY S MA LL A CT OR A ND EV ER Y B IG A CT OR.
2:28 Y EA H.
2:28 T OM.
2:29 Y ES TE RD AY T HI S I S WE H AD P AU L T UD OR J ON ES O N T HE SE T WI TH U S.
2:32 H E HA D JU ST C OM E FR OM A C ON FE RE NC E L AS T W EE
2:34 K TH AT H AD 5 0 O F T HE L AR GE ST PL AY ER S I N A I,
2:37 F RO M T HE L AR GE LA NG UA GE M OD EL S TO T HE C HI PS T O
2:40 MA NY O F T HE O TH ER T EC H F AC IN G CR EA TO RS O N T HI S.
2:45 A ND H E S AI D BA SE D ON T HA T, T HA T 2 0% O F T HE RO OM L AS T YE AR W
2:50 AS I N F AV OR O F GO VE RN ME NT R EG UL AT IO N,
2:52 T HI S YE AR W AS 8 0% O F TH E RO OM.
2:53 AN D TH EN H E WE NT O N T O SA Y, C LE AR LY, WE N EE D TO R EG UL AT E.
2:56 I, I, WE SH OU LD D O I T TO MO RR OW.
2:58 WE 'R E LA TE A LR EA DY.
2:59 WE S HO UL D HA VE DO NE I T.
3:00 W E NE ED T O DO I T.
3:01 A ND IT S OU ND S LI KE Y OU 'R E E CH OI NG TH AT S AM E UR GE NC Y.
3:04 W EL L, Y OU K NO W, T HE W AY I TH IN K A BO UT I T,
3:06 B EC KY, IS IM AG IN E IT 'S, YO U KN OW,
3:08 T HE 19 40 S A ND W E N EE D TO D EV EL OP A NU
3:12 CL EA R B OM B TO, T O W IN, T O FI NI SH T HE W AR.
3:15 A ND T HE L OS AL AM OS P RO JE CT W AS A CT UA LL
3:19 Y I N TH E H AN DS O F P RI VA TE C OM PA NI ES.
3:22 ON E WA S L ED B Y, Y OU K NO W, M AR K ZU CK ER BE RG, O NE B Y E LO N M US K,
3:27 ON E BY S AM A LT MA N, Y OU K NO W,
3:30 ON E BY W HO EV ER R UN S T HE GO OG LE 'S G EM IN I.
3:33 A ND T HE SE F OU R CO MP AN IE S W ER
3:36 E M AN UF AC TU RI NG NU CL EA R W EA PO NS.
3:39 A I T OO LS A RE NO T.
3:40 A ND W E HA D TO T HE N NE GO TI AT E WI TH T HE M.
3:42 H EY, WH EN DO Y OU R EL EA SE I T?
3:43 W HE RE A RE YO U?
3:44 W HA TE VE R.
3:44 N OW, I 'M N OT SA YI NG A I IS P ER S E A N UC LE AR WE AP ON.
3:47 OF C OU RS E IT 'S N OT.
3:48 BU T IT 'S I T' S I TS A BI LI TY T O C RE AT E MA SS D IS RU PT IO N,
3:52 I F NO T M AS S DE ST RU CT IO N IS G OI NG T O B E PR OF OU ND.
3:55 S O I A GR EE W IT H P AU L TU DO R J ON ES.
3:57 I D ON 'T K NO W T HA T WE 'R E GO IN G
3:59 TO N AT IO NA LI ZE TH ES E C OM PA NI ES,
4:01 B UT T HE I DE A TH AT T HE G OV ER NM EN T HA S T O NE GO TI AT E W IT H
4:04 T HE M O N W HE N TH EY R EL EA SE W EA PO NS O F M AS S DE ST RU CT IO N,
4:08 I D ON 'T T HI NK TH AT 'S A S US TA IN AB LE K IN D O F TH IN G.
4:11 Y OU K NO W?
4:12 J EN -H SU N HU AN G EA RL IE R T HI S W EE K, I N S PE AK IN G WI TH H IM,
4:17 H E D IS AG RE ES W IT H Y OU ON T HE I DE A O
4:19 F TH ES E TH IN GS BE IN G N UC LE AR W EA PO NS.
4:20 H E' LL FI GH T B AC K ON A LL O F T HO SE.
4:22 B UT HE D OE S S AY T HA T T HI S NE ED S
4:25 T O BE R EG UL AT ED B Y T HE G OV ER NM EN T.
4:27 AN D H E B EL IE VE S TH AT T HE U NI TE D ST AT ES
4:29 N EE DS T O BE T AL KI NG T O CH IN A A BO UT T HI S.
4:33 L OO K, I F Y OU CA N G ET T HO SE I N T HE I ND
4:35 US TR Y TO A GR EE T HA T R EG UL AT IO N IS NE ED ED,
4:38 I T SE EM S L IK E IT W OU LD BE A N EA SY S TE
4:40 P TO G ET GO VE RN ME NT S ON B OA RD W IT H T HA T.
4:41 BU T OF C OU RS E, Y OU A ND I K NO W TH AT I T' S NO T T HA T SI MP LE.
4:45 W EL L, Y OU K NO W I T' S G OI NG T O HA PP EN.
4:46 T HE O NL Y Q UE ST IO N IS,
4:47 DO ES I T H AP PE N A FT ER A G IA NT DI SA ST ER O R B EF OR E?
4:52 B UT T HI S ST UF F W IL L GE T L OO SE.
4:55 M AL IG N AC TO RS W IL L U SE I T.
4:56 A ND, Y OU KN OW, L OO K,
4:58 W E I N TH E WE I N T HE SO VI ET U NI ON R EA CH ED A GR EE ME NT S
5:01 ON L IM IT IN G N UC LE AR W EA PO NS TH RO UG H T HR OU GH A RM S C ON TR OL.
5:05 I DO N' T S EE W HY T HA T S AM E, Y OU KN OW,
5:09 A PP RO AC H C AN 'T W OR K F OR TH E US
5:10 A ND C HI NA O N TH IS LI MI TE D D OM AI N, Y OU K NO W, N OT ON Y OU K NO W,
5:15 W E' RE N OT G OI NG T O WE 'R E ST IL L G OI NG T O C OM PE TE.
5:17 BU T I N T HI S L IM IT ED A RE A, W E' RE WE 'R E G OI NG T HE RE, Y OU K NO W,
5:23 WH AT EV ER A NY ON E IN T HE I ND US TR Y TH IN KS B EC AU SE S
5:25 OM ET HI NG B AD I S GO IN G T O H AP PE N A T SO ME P OI NT.
5:28 H EY, T OM, IF W E CO UL D TU RN TO Y OU R OT HE R AR EA O F E XP ER TI SE,
5:31 WH IC H IS T HE M ID DL E E AS T,
5:33 T HE MA RK ET S EE MS T O B E TR AD IN G W IT H TH IS N
5:36 OT IO N T HA T T HE S TR AI T O F HO RM UZ W IL L O PE N.
5:38 I T' S JU ST A QU ES TI ON O F W HE N AN D W HA T P
5:40 RI CE WO UL D Y OU W AL K US T HR OU GH Y OU R TH IN KI NG?
5:43 I S T HE M AR KE T R IG HT AB OU T T HA T,
5:45 O R IS T HE RE S OM E LO NG ER T ER M I SS UE H
5:48 ER E TH AT Y OU TH IN K M IG HT K EE P I T C LO
5:49 SE D F OR LO NG ER T HA N S EE MS T O BE I N A $9
5:52 4 W ES T TE XA S PR IC E O F O IL RI GH T NO W?
5:55 W EL L, I T' S A G OO D Q UE ST IO N, ST EV E.
5:57 Y OU K NO W, T HI S W AR I S GO IN G T O EN D, I 'D S AY,
6:00 I N O NE OF T HR EE W AY S, W HI CH W IL L T HE N AF FE CT H OR MU Z.
6:04 O NE I S T HE B IG DE AL,
6:05 W HI CH T HE P RE SI DE NT H AS BE EN T AL KI NG A BO UT.
6:07 W E OP EN T HE ST RA IT S O F H OR MU Z.
6:10 I RA N G IV ES UP I TS M OS T D AN GE RO US F IS SI LE MA TE RI AL,
6:13 A ND W E TH EN L IF T SA NC TI ON S O N I RA N.
6:17 A ND T HA T I S A C ON CL US IO N T HA T W IL L
6:21 A CT UA LL Y ST RE NG TH EN T HI S I RA NI AN R EG IM E.
6:24 SO A NY ON E W HO W AS H OP IN G F OR RE GI ME C HA NG E,
6:27 Y OU 'L L GE T J US T TH E OP PO SI TE.
6:29 A S EC ON D W OU LD B E A S MA LL ER D EA L, S TE VE.
6:31 I C AL L IT H OR MU Z F OR H OR MU Z,
6:34 T HA T W E SU CC UM B TO T HE P RE SS UR E O F HI GH OI L P RI CE S.
6:37 I RA N S UC CU MB S TO TH E PR ES SU RE O F O UR B LO CK AD E,
6:40 WH IC H I S S TA RV IN G T HE M OF M ON EY AN D A LL T
6:44 HE R ES OU RC ES T HE Y N EE D TO R UN T HE IR E CO NO MY.
6:46 I C OU LD SE E T HA T AS A P OS SI BI LI TY.
6:48 A TH IR D P OS SI BI LI TY I S T HA T Y OU GE T NO D EA L,
6:53 A ND I T L IM PS A LO NG AN D W E G ET O N AN D O FF O PE NI NG S IN H OR MU Z.
6:57 B UT A ND I C OU LD N' T TE LL Y OU W HE RE W E A RE R IG HT N OW,
7:00 ST EV E, B EC AU SE I S EE S IG NS O F AL L T HR EE.
7:03 A ND T HE P RE SI DE NT I S CL EA RL Y T AL KI NG U P A D
7:05 EA L BE CA US E HE 'S T RY IN G TO T AL K DO WN O IL P RI CE S.
7:08 B UT E VE NT UA LL Y TH E LA WS O F G RA VI TY H ER E W IL L AP PL Y.
7:11 A ND A S YO U K NO W, T HE O IL WE 'R E C ON SU MI NG N OW I S O IL T
7:15 HA T WA S B AS IC AL LY O N T HE H IG H S EA S,
7:17 YO U K NO W, A L OT O F IT B EF OR E TH E W AR E VE N S TA RT ED.
7:20 SO W IT H EV ER Y WE EK T HA T G OE S B Y,
7:23 T HE PR IC E I S D EF IN IT EL Y G OI NG T O TI GH TE N.
7:26 T OM, I WA NT T O TU RN T O O NE OT HE R TH IN G,
7:29 W HI CH Y OU V ER Y MU CH O N TO P O F,
7:30 W HI CH I S GE NE RA LL Y T HI S NO TI ON O F GL OB AL IZ AT IO N
7:32 A ND A ME RI CA 'S DE CI DE D TO K IN D OF S TE P OU T OF TH AT G AM E.
7:37 D O WE T UR N A RO UN D AN D S EE C AN AD IA NS
7:39 A ND M EX IC AN S DR IV IN G E LE CT RI C V EH IC LE S,
7:42 S EE OT HE R C OU NT RI ES P UL LI NG A HE AD US IN G A LT ER NA TI VE
7:46 E NE RG IE S A ND AN D OT HE R C OU NT RI ES B EN EF IT IN G FR OM T HE
7:49 C HE AP ER C HI NE SE G OO DS AN D F OR EI GN G OO DS T HA T W E DE
7:52 CI DE D W E DO N' T W AN T T O U SE S O MU CH A NY MO RE A ND S AY,
7:55 W AI T A SE CO ND, MA YB E W E' RE M AK IN G A MI ST AK E H ER E,
7:57 O R DO W E GE T B Y JU ST F IN E WI TH OU T I T?
8:00 W EL L, S TE VE, I T HI NK H IS TO RY WI LL L OO K B AC K O
8:02 N T HR EE O BA MA ER A D EA LS T HA T T RU MP T OR E U P.
8:09 ON E IS T HE N UC LE AR D EA L.
8:11 W E' RE SE EI NG T HE E FF EC TS O F T HA T N OW.
8:13 A S EC ON D IS T HE T RA NS -P AC IF IC PA RT NE RS HI P,
8:15 W HI CH W OU LD H AV E CR EA TE D A B RO AD T RA
8:17 DE A LL IA NC E BA SE D ON T HE M OS T U PD AT ED
8:21 ST AN DA RD S T HA T WE W OU LD T HE N HA VE B EE
8:23 N AB LE T O U SE A S LE VE RA GE A GA IN ST C HI NA,
8:25 AL SO WO UL D HA VE S TI MU LA TE D R EF OR ME RS IN C HI NA.
8:28 A ND T HE T HI RD I S T HE PA RI S CL IM AT E A GR EE ME NT,
8:30 W HI CH WO UL D H AV E D RI VE N T HE C LE AN TE CH I ND US TR Y.
8:33 I M EA N, T O M E, IT I S TH E H EI GH T OF I NS AN IT Y TH
8:36 AT W E' RE A CT UA LL Y C LO SI NG DO WN W IN D P RO JE CT S IN T
8:39 HI S CO UN TR Y T HA T AR E G IV IN G US TH ES E CL EA N E LE CT
8:43 RO NS A T A T IM E WH EN W E N EE D AL L T HE EL EC TR IC IT Y,
8:45 A LL O F T HE A BO VE TH AT W E C AN G ET.
8:47 B UT S TE VE, I' LL J US T G IV E YO U O NE F IG UR E.
8:50 I M AY N OT B E E XA CT LY U P TO D AT E,
8:52 BU T PR ET TY M UC H S O F OR D M OT OR, 40% OF T HE IR
8:55 B US IN ES S I S OU TS ID E T HE U NI TE D S TA TE S,
8:59 OU TS ID E T HE U NI TE D S TA TE S.
9:00 T HE FU TU RE I S A N E LE CT RI C V EH IC LE.
9:02 IT W IL L B E M AS SI VE LY A S WE G O FO RW AR D.
9:06 A ND C HI NA I S C YC LE S AH EA D O F US O N T HA T.
9:09 I N F AC T, IF W E WA NT T O H AV E TH AT IN DU ST RY H ER E,
9:12 W E' RE G OI NG T O HA VE T O HA VE T EC H T RA
9:13 NS FE R F RO M CH IN A IN T HE B AT TE RY R EA LM,
9:16 T HE WA Y W E G IV E T EC H T RA NS FE R T O TH EM I N T HE 7 0S A ND 8 0S.
9:20 S O TH AT 'S I T' S S O C LE AR LY T HE FU TU RE.
9:23 T HI S W AR I S R EI NF OR CI NG IT.
9:25 I 'M G OI NG T O CU T Y OU O FF, TO M,
9:27 B EC AU SE W E B OT H L IV ED TH RO UG H W HE N T HE J
9:30 AP AN ES E RE AL LY O VE RT OO K T HE A ME RI CA N IN DU ST RY.
9:33 AN D I T F EE LS L IK E N OT WH AT 'S H AP PE NI NG I N A ME RI CA.
9:36 WH AT 'S H AP PE NI NG I N T HE R ES T OF TH E
9:38 W OR LD I S T HA T S AM E P RO CE SS AG AI N, W HE RE W E F AL L B EH IN D.
9:41 AN D T HA T S EE MS L IK E A P RE TT Y BI G D EA L.
9:44 W EL L, Y OU K NO W, I T' S C LE AR,
9:46 YO U KN OW, C LE AN T EC H, B RO AD LY SP EA KI NG,
9:47 IS G OI NG T O B E O NE O F TH E NE XT G RE AT G LO BA L IN DU ST RI ES.
9:52 A ND P LE AS E RA IS E YO UR H AN D I F YO U T HI
9:54 NK A ME RI CA CA N B E A G RE AT E CO NO MI C P OW ER,
9:58 IF I T D OE SN 'T L EA D I N TH E NE XT GR EA T GL OB AL I ND US TR Y.
10:00 A ND AG AI N, C HI NA I S D OI NG A LL O F TH E AB OV E.
10:03 T HA T' S WH AT W E SH OU LD B E DO IN G.
10:04 I T' S N OT, I T' S NO T A N EI TH ER O R TH IN G.
10:07 S O, Y OU KN OW, S TE VE, I NF OS YS,
10:09 T HE IN DI AN, Y OU K NO W, O UT SO UR CI NG TE CH C OM PA NY,
10:11 B AC K I N T HE E AR LY 20 00, T HE Y HA D A N AD C AM PA IG N.
10:14 IT W AS C AL LE D Y OU W IN I N T HE TU RN S, Y OU W IN I N TH E TU RN S.
10:17 I N OT HE R WO RD S, Y OU W IN I N TH E BI G TE CH NO LO GI CA L T ER MS.
10:20 TH AT 'S WH EN Y OU O VE RT AK E YO UR R IV AL S.
10:22 I T HI NK W E' RE I N S UC H A T UR N RI GH T N OW O N T HE A I P AR T O F IT.
10:25 WE 'R E C LE AR LY I N T HE L EA D, TH AN K