Pointless Mechanics That Make Games Better
Razbuten
0:00 I’ve been playing a lot of Hades 2,
0:02 and given that I was a big fan of Hades, I’ve unsurprisingly been loving it.
0:06 It expands on the ideas and mechanics
0:08 of the first game in so many interesting ways,
0:11 providing countless intertwined systems that are a joy to engage with.
0:14 There is so much to uncover and dive into, and nearly
0:18 everything you do leads to some type of notable progression,
0:21 creating one of the most satisfying feedback loops I can think of.
0:25 However, there is one mechanic that I’ve been
0:27 thinking about more than all of the rest, and it is actually one of the few
0:30 mechanics that isn’t really part of those intertwined systems,
0:33 that being the salute: When the protagonist,
0:39 Melinoë comes across a character or boon associated with one of the two factions
0:43 she is a part of, she has the option to give a quick salute.
0:47 It is always just a couple words; almost always a mantra of the Unseen,
0:52 the band of folks residing in the main hub area of the Crossroads all
0:55 of whom aim to unseat Chronos the God of Time or the Silver Sisters,
0:59 a group of moon goddesses in service of Nyx, the Goddess of Night.
1:03 The salutes do not increase Melinoë’s relationships with other characters,
1:07 yield any reward, or move the story forward.
1:09 You just get a tiny bit of dialogue—variations on the core set of phrases.
1:15 From a progression standpoint, it has no purpose.
1:19 And even after 30 hours of playtime, I still do it every chance I get.
1:24 It just feels like the right thing to do.
1:27 The thing that my Melinoë would do.
1:29 For such a small action, it somehow holds massive implications,
1:33 and also unique implications depending on who it was being done to.
1:37 With Hecate, the Headmistress of the Crossroads, it seemed like the expectation,
1:41 the call and response of a student
1:43 and teacher after a lifetime of instruction and training.
1:46 With Odysseus it seemed like a way to show respect
1:49 for the wisdom and aid he brought to the cause.
1:51 With Artemis it felt like a way to build camaraderie.
1:54 With Nemesis it felt like a challenge to get on the same page,
1:58 and every time she refused to salute back,
1:59 it made me want to get to a point of common ground all that much more.
2:04 With the shrine of Hades, it felt like a promise to make things right.
2:08 There are a few other interactions similar to the salute.
2:12 Melinoë can confide in her pet frog, brood over a family portrait,
2:16 admire flowers she’s planted,
2:18 assist with incantations being cast, sing alongside with Artemis.
2:21 All of this is in the service of adding flavor,
2:25 and despite it just being a simple button prompt that flavor
2:28 goes so much farther than it has any business going.
2:31 This starts with the fact that there are so many variations of these inputs,
2:36 not just with what Melinoë can do, but also in terms of what is actually said,
2:40 the way it is said, and what the response is.
2:43 Amid all of its incredible gameplay systems,
2:45 one of the most impressive things about the Hades series
2:48 is the sheer scope of unique dialogue the games contain,
2:51 and the fact that that attention to detail is
2:54 present even in these tiny interactions is a little mindblowing.
2:58 Obviously the repetition of mantras Melinoë
3:00 regularly repeats is the whole point,
3:03 but due to the slight variations it somehow manages to never feel repetitive.
3:07 It doesn’t come off as a video game character
3:10 saying the same canned line over and over again.
3:12 It feels like Melinoë making a promise.
3:14 Beyond that it also creates a sense of community within the crossroads.
3:18 This is a group that has long been working together,
3:21 building resistance against the unruly titan.
3:23 While the player is just now being dropped in, Melinoë is not.
3:27 She has a history here, and more importantly has bought into the ways
3:31 of the Unseen and the Silver Sisters,
3:34 of Hecate, and the witchcraft she practices.
3:36 So with something like the incantation, it so easily could have just been
3:40 some set dressing that she stands around watching.
3:42 But instead she has the chance to be part of it,
3:46 to demonstrate her awareness of how the Crossroads works
3:49 and play a small part in helping her mentor.
3:52 It informs who Melinoë is.
3:54 While the player does not have control over how she
3:56 responds to any given situation in the way some titles do,
4:00 they do have control over if she responds to certain things.
4:03 If she is the type of Melinoë who will take a moment to sing with her friend,
4:07 to stop and smell the flowers,
4:09 to pay respects to a father she only knows through stories.
4:13 I have not watched many people play the game—I imagine it is a mechanic
4:17 that falls to the wayside for many because there is no real reason to do it.
4:22 It could be removed and nothing else would really be changed.
4:25 But I have no doubt that the game would feel poorer for it.
4:30 There technically becomes a mechanical purpose for the salute
4:33 later on—once you get a certain incantation,
4:36 doing it effectively changes the seed of your next run, which is to say,
4:40 it doesn’t really have a purpose for 99% percent of people—it’s sort of just
4:44 an easy way to help out speedrunners
4:46 and those doing very specific types of runs.
4:49 And I’m really glad that this is the extent of it
4:52 as had they made it a part of the actual progression,
4:55 it would have cheapened the interactions.
4:59 Consider Red Dead Redemption 2.
5:00 In it there is a mechanic that has some similarities
5:03 to this one where Arthur can greet or antagonize anyone he comes across.
5:08 However, unlike Hades 2, this shapes who Arthur is;
5:11 it isn’t about if he engages, it is how he engages,
5:16 and along with that there are wider mechanical implications as greeting
5:20 or antagonizing people will raise or lower Arthur’s honor respectively.
5:23 This has impacts on how he is treated
5:25 by those he comes across and how certain things play out.
5:28 On one hand, it does seem like a clean
5:31 way to get players to engage with the system.
5:33 The problem though is that as it has a mechanical effect,
5:37 it becomes more of a resource than a form
5:40 of expression—a resource that is easy to farm.
5:42 This encourages players to spam it as much as they can.
5:45 It goes from being a way to characterize Arthur
5:49 and get pulled into the world to being exploitable,
5:53 incentivizing players to do the action
5:54 that will move their honor in the direction
5:56 they want instead of organically engaging with what the moment calls for.
6:00 It certainly still is a fun inclusion that I am glad is there,
6:03 but I can’t help but think it would have been more
6:06 effective if it weren’t tied to any sort of gameplay system.
6:09 If it were mechanically pointless, or at least closer to it.
6:13 Throughout the history of this channel,
6:15 I’ve often advocated for gameplay systems
6:17 that motivate players to engage with every mechanic,
6:20 typically by giving them a notable role within how progression works,
6:24 however, there is something extremely compelling to me about features like
6:28 the Salute in Hades 2 that are pretty much disconnected from everything else.
6:32 It isn’t just that these things are optional;
6:34 it’s that choosing to engage with them doesn’t really net any tangible reward.
6:38 That isn’t to say they have no effect—obvioulsy
6:41 they do otherwise I wouldn’t be making this video.
6:44 But they are things players engage with for intrinsic reasons.
6:48 For some, they are the sorts of things that will be dismissed as a waste of time
6:51 to engage with, but for others they can help
6:53 bring shape to a gaming experience in a significant way.
6:56 A mechanic like this that I appreciate for entirely different reasons than
7:00 the salute in Hades 2 can be found in Grand Theft Auto 5.
7:04 If you hit circle or b depending on the controller
7:07 you’re using while in the middle of a jump,
7:09 whoever you’re playing as will ragdoll in the air.
7:12 To my understanding,
7:13 there really is no real reason or benefit to ever do this—it is not a useful
7:18 mechanic in terms of completing missions or escaping
7:20 chases or getting the edge in gun fights.
7:22 It doesn’t even make sense in terms of being a movement a character
7:25 would want to do as who would ever choose to just faceplant like that.
7:29 Truthfully, the only reason I can imagine
7:32 the developers included it is because it’s very funny.
7:35 Being able to bail mid jump and crash into the ground
7:39 or do flips off a house into a pool or bowl
7:41 into a group of people just trying to enjoy their afternoon provides
7:45 a kind of mechanical experimentation that feels really good to mess with.
7:48 And it just feels so GTA.
7:51 Despite being well crafted games with notable stories and missions,
7:54 a big part of what has made the Grand Theft Auto series so famous
7:57 has nothing to do with what could be considered the core of each game.
8:01 I imagine there are many of you who have
8:03 played dozens and dozens of hours of these titles
8:06 without even playing a mission and instead have
8:08 just engaged with the chaotic playgrounds they provide.
8:11 This small mechanic of being able to ragdoll at will
8:14 is in service of that side of these games.
8:17 The side that isn’t focused on Michael, Franklin,
8:19 and Trevor—that doesn’t care about the corrupt
8:22 antics of the FIB—the side that’s only
8:24 goal is to allow players to create as much chaos as they possibly can.
8:29 This stupid little ragdoll dive opens up so
8:32 many opportunities for self-imposed challenges and general goofing around.
8:35 I imagine it is something many will never even know
8:39 is there—but it does add so much for those who do.
8:42 A less self-destructive version of a mechanic in this vein can be
8:45 seen in Tchia where if you hold right trigger while in mid air,
8:49 you can then use the right joystick to spin and flip.
8:51 There isn’t any sort of scoring system,
8:53 it doesn’t boost your speed or make terrain easier to clear; it is just cool.
8:58 There are many different ways to traverse the world,
9:00 but as running is probably the one you’ll be doing the most,
9:03 it provides a little thing to do when heading from one place to another,
9:07 and as it isn’t just a flip button but rather a series of inputs
9:10 where you need to time things right to not over or under rotate,
9:14 there is just enough skill involved to not be mindless.
9:17 It also fits thematically within the rest of the game—the story is
9:21 all about a treacherous adventure from the perspective of a young girl,
9:24 and so everything is tinged with a sense of whimsy and magic.
9:28 There is a childlike playfulness to being able to flip at will
9:31 that makes the mechanic make sense within the frame of the story.
9:34 It might be that I’ve just been obsessed with pointless flips in video games
9:38 since playing Majora’s Mask as a kid and seeing Link do it in the intro,
9:41 but I find that its inclusion here enhances what
9:44 the game is going for in a notable way.
9:46 Speaking of Majora’s Mask it also has a memorable mechanic that I’d
9:50 throw in the pointless category in the form of the Bremen Mask.
9:54 When worn, it allows Link to march while playing the Ocarina,
9:57 causing some animals in the area to follow behind him.
10:00 Now, this mask is technically needed for a sidequest to get a different mask,
10:04 so it isn’t completely removed from the game’s progression,
10:07 but its usefulness is so limited that it's
10:09 hard not to feel like it is largely pointless.
10:12 And what certainly is pointless is it working in places
10:14 aside from the one zone it is actually needed in.
10:17 But this is where the Bremen mask is at its best.
10:20 When I was a kid who did not appreciate
10:22 the 3 day time limit in the way I do now,
10:24 marching around Clocktown with a dog in tow made me feel oddly powerful,
10:28 like I was disrupting how the game should work.
10:31 And this made me want to test it out everywhere.
10:34 What’s probably the coolest use of it is
10:36 in the Ikana warrior fight who march with you
10:39 if you wear it around them—I suppose technically
10:41 you could say this gives a slight advantage,
10:43 but more than anything it is a fun easter egg
10:46 that rewards players for using something
10:48 that virtually has no practical utility.
10:50 Through the addition of this mask, it made me explore and consider the world
10:54 in a manner I wouldn’t have without it.
10:56 What may be the most common type
10:58 of pointless interaction are ones involving animals,
11:00 more often than not, relating to being able to pet them.
11:03 Its inclusion is almost becoming expected in certain games,
11:06 and honestly it feels a little strange when a title
11:09 has an animal in it but doesn't let pet it.
11:11 The simple reason it gets put in, is
11:13 that it is an action many people connect with.
11:15 They like petting animals,
11:16 and the mere act of watching the character they are controlling do it,
11:20 makes that character easier to connect to and creates a potential bond
11:23 with that animal that makes them care about the world just a little bit more.
11:26 The mileage on this obviously varies depending
11:28 on how much of an animal person you are, but at the very least,
11:32 there is something humanizing about video game characters
11:35 doing pretty normal things—it can even be a nice
11:38 contrast from how the gameplay of a title
11:40 tends to have them interact with the world.
11:42 This can be said for all sorts of interactions
11:45 whether it be Arthur Morgan taking a bath,
11:48 V playing pool in the Glen Apartments,
11:50 Sam Porter messing with the camera while in his private room.
11:53 They act as ways to slow things down and redirect,
11:57 to let us see these characters in new environments.
12:00 Any sort of emote, whether it be contextual or through a menu,
12:05 doesn’t really have a practical purpose within a singleplayer game.
12:08 With no one else there to communicate with, they really only serve
12:12 as fun little things to witness or tiny ways for players to express themselves,
12:15 to get in the mind of the character they are playing as.
12:19 Frankly any sort of clothing or cosmetic customization
12:21 that isn’t meaningfully tied to stats does the same thing.
12:24 It gives players a chance for expression and storytelling.
12:28 Especially with big open-world games, I like to have my character’s outfit
12:32 reflect their status in any given moment—generally
12:35 this takes the form of them wearing nicer clothes as they can afford to do so,
12:39 but also I often will pick based on what they’re going
12:42 through or what I imagine they would value in that moment.
12:44 In a small way it feels like I get to add to the story
12:48 and help set the scene for what everything seems to be building towards.
12:52 Of course none of these things need to be used
12:54 in serious ways—the goal can be for it to just be funny,
12:58 whether it's doing an emote at an inappropriate time
13:00 or wearing the stupidest outfit imaginable during a serious cutscene.
13:04 Either way it gives a small outlet of control for players to create experiences
13:09 unique to their playthroughs and have the tone
13:11 of the experience better reflect their sensibilities,
13:14 even if it is in this tiny way.
13:16 Another kind of pointless mechanic, or in this case more of a pointless feature,
13:20 that I have always found interesting are games
13:23 within or in some cases alongside the main game.
13:26 What is probably the most popular example of this, is Gwent in the Witcher 3.
13:31 There really isn’t much mechanical motivation to play it.
13:34 It does technically tie into a few progression systems—you can get a little gold
13:38 for winning and gain some experience points
13:40 for playing im matches tied to sidequests,
13:42 but the amount you receive for both is so minimal that it
13:45 isn’t worth playing it with either of those things in mind.
13:49 It largely exists in its own space and all rewards are tied to that space.
13:54 It’s inclusion obviously has a pretty massive impact on the game though.
13:59 It makes the world feel fuller,
14:01 as we see and can actually engage with an aspect of its culture.
14:04 Also it can inform how you feel about your version of Geralt.
14:08 If you have him play it a lot,
14:10 maybe you see his Gwent obsession as a humanizing characteristic or a shift
14:13 on how he views his role in the world or a vote
14:16 of confidence in Ciri to take care of herself as he is choosing
14:20 to spend his time on cards instead of urgently following leads about her.
14:23 It also is just a fun game to play.
14:26 I really don’t think Gwent would work
14:29 nearly as well if it benefitted mainline progression.
14:33 If it were a great way to make money or get better gear,
14:36 it would drastically change the stakes of the world and call into question
14:40 why Geralt would risk his life when he could just toss cards.
14:43 It’d also incentivize players to play it,
14:45 which, while I understand many people love Gwent,
14:48 is not how the majority of players want to spend their time
14:51 when engaging in a title as expansive as the Witcher 3.
14:55 Due to it being disconnected from everything else,
14:57 it can be something players engage with because they like it
15:00 instead of being a disruption from the main part of the game.
15:04 Ultimately, regardless of if you spend much or even any time playing it,
15:07 the way Gwent is incorporated builds the world out
15:10 and makes it feel more like an actual place.
15:13 A very similar thing can be said
15:15 for the arcade cabinets in stuff like Stardew Valley, Yakuza,
15:18 and Cyberpunk 2077 as they also don’t
15:20 feed into main progression in any notable way,
15:23 but they do provide more things to engage with, adding some depth to the world.
15:27 They also place your character as someone who likes to play games,
15:32 which says something about them.
15:34 An example of a title taking this a step further
15:36 can be seen with Demon Tower in Night in the Woods.
15:38 It is a fairly robust 2d action game that Mae can play when at her computer,
15:43 and while in some titles,
15:44 spending a bunch of time on a distraction like this may seem off,
15:48 it kind of perfectly plays into Mae’s
15:50 character who when we meet her is directionless.
15:52 She has no real plans and is cagey whenever she is pushed to confront her past,
15:57 so engaging with a distraction like Demon Tower
15:59 kinda just felt like what Mae would do.
16:02 There certainly are instances where these sorts of inclusions
16:05 can be jarring and a little too far off tone,
16:07 but when done well they can create a meaningful way for players
16:10 to dive just a little bit deeper into the themes of a game.
16:14 Another pointless feature that is more hands off than
16:17 any of the ones I’ve mentioned but still feels like
16:20 it fits within this broader idea can seen
16:22 with the player ghosts in the vast majority of FromSoft titles.
16:25 Where the other indirect online interactions in these games like bloodstains
16:29 and messages can help guide folks away from danger or towards secrets,
16:33 the player ghosts almost never reveal anything useful.
16:36 They are just a peak into a couple seconds of someone else’s journey.
16:40 But with titles like these that often leave you
16:42 feeling like you’ll never be able to get through it,
16:45 there is something reassuring about seeing someone else in the same place you
16:49 are—knowing you’re not the only one trying to best some area or some boss.
16:53 It may not bring any tangible benefit,
16:56 but for some it could be the difference between
16:58 ragequitting after a death or recentering and trying again.
17:01 It is an impact that can’t really be measured but certainly is felt.
17:05 It is a mechanic you are almost barely even meant to notice,
17:09 with no meaningful way to engage with it in game,
17:12 but it still manages to add a sense of depth
17:15 and connection for those who do pay attention to it.
17:18 No matter the form it takes, that is the value of these kinds of mechanics.
17:22 They are a way to get pulled in a little bit more.
17:25 And what I think makes them stand out so much
17:27 is in how there is no pressure attached to them.
17:29 These aren’t things players are forced to do or even really incentivized to do.
17:31 They are done purely because they are things the player wants to do.
17:34 Them being disconnected is what brings
17:36 a sort of authenticity to engaging with them.
17:39 When looking at Hades 2, the fact that it has such a tight progression
17:44 system is why the salute mechanic worked for me.
17:46 In the game you can barely take
17:48 3 steps without having some sort of metaprogression,
17:50 and while this does create a solid game flow,
17:52 non-stop rewards can kind of muddy the waters of what is and isn’t important.
17:57 Frankly, this is a sentiment I have been feeling more and more as so many
18:01 things in our lives even outside of video
18:04 games are designed in this type of way.
18:06 That being grasping for your attention with the promise
18:08 of something that will feel like a reward,
18:11 regardless of whether or not it actually is.
18:13 It has proven to be an effective tactic,
18:15 but it does always beg the question whether
18:17 whatever you are engaging with is worth engaging with.
18:19 It is effective, yes, but also it begs the question,
18:19 whether or not those things are worth engaging with.
18:20 Do I actually like these mechanics or does seeing
18:23 the numbers go up just make me think I do?
18:26 In the case of Hades 2, I’d say I largely do enjoy the core mechanics
18:30 even when separated from the dopamine fueled progression system.
18:33 I enjoy the way gameplay shifts based on my weapon and the boons I get,
18:37 not just that the lights and colors become brighter.
18:40 With that said, it is nice to feel attached to a mechanic
18:43 like the salute that is entirely separated from all of that.
18:47 Something I am choosing to do because it provides something
18:49 impactful to the lens through which I view the game.
18:52 It matters because I make it matter.
18:54 It is a tiny reminder that not everything
18:57 I do needs to feed into something else.
19:00 Of course, framing anything not tied to progression
19:02 as being pointless is a vast oversimplification.
19:04 It is a framing I fall into because progression towards some sort of goal,
19:10 whether it be a credit roll or scoring more points than the other team,
19:13 is what turns general play into a game.
19:17 It creates stakes, structure, and meaning.
19:19 I don’t know that I’d go as far as to say that if
19:22 something doesn’t have progression or a goal that it isn’t a video game,
19:25 but obviously titles that are more free form feel different,
19:28 and the way we tend to classify them illustrates that.
19:32 They are simulations or virtual chatrooms and while no one would
19:35 fault you for including them under the wide umbrella of video games,
19:38 they aren’t what we typically think of when talking about video games.
19:42 We think of stuff with progression, and so progression becomes the point.
19:46 I find myself conflicted with this.
19:47 On one hand I think weaving as many ideas and mechanics into a game’s
19:50 core progression has the potential to create
19:53 tight experiences where everything feels like it matters,
19:55 where players will be incentivized to engage
19:57 with systems they otherwise might have ignored.
19:59 On the other hand, I think having a reward
20:01 for everything can feel exhausting, and at its worst,
20:03 it can condition players to care more about
20:06 the act of progression than the gameplay the progression unlocks.
20:09 With how a lot of games are designed now,
20:12 it is easy for your brain to fall into autopilot,
20:14 and I don’t think that is entirely bad.
20:17 Sometimes shutting your brain off is exactly what
20:19 you’re looking for and maybe even what you need.
20:22 However, as more and more things in the world
20:24 are designed to shut your brain off,
20:26 I find myself craving intentionality more than I ever have before.
20:29 And I think that is part of why I’ve spent so
20:32 much time thinking about this stupid salute and mechanics like it.
20:36 No one else’s desire is what gets me to engage with them.
20:40 I am fully in control of making that choice.
20:43 To be very clear, I don’t think games
20:45 should get rid of progression systems or mechanical motivation.
20:48 However, I do think it is important
20:50 for them to include mechanics that are separate.
20:53 That slow things down.
20:54 That gives players a way to play that feels like their own.
20:57 So whether its raising Chao in Sonic Adventure 2 Battle,
21:01 dancing on the ship in Lethal Company, looking out at a vista in Hob,
21:06 yelling Mario when pressing A in Luigi’s Mansion, barking in Okami,
21:11 or saluting in Hades 2,
21:13 I hope we never stop getting pointless mechanics in games.
21:23 While this video has largely stripped
21:25 games down to how they function mechanically, as I touched on earlier,
21:28 there obviously are so many aspects that make a game
21:30 a game that have little to do with their gameplay mechanics.
21:33 Like Hades 2 isn’t Hades 2 without its incredible dynamic soundtrack,
21:37 and something like Okami isn’t Okami without its astounding artstyle.
21:41 IInterestingly, the devolpers of Okami originally planned to use
21:44 an art style inspired by then recent resident evil remake,
21:48 which is jarring given the final product and how
21:51 much the artstyle they went with influences the gameplay.
21:54 I learned this from the first part of KingK’s new series Masterful
21:58 Mimicry which examines the importance
22:00 and influences of Okami among other things,
22:02 and if you’re interested in checking that, it is available right now on Nebula.
22:07 You’ve probably heard me talk about it before and will again,
22:09 but Nebula is a big part of why I’ve been able
22:12 to do what I do for as long as I’ve done it.
22:15 It hosts the work of tons of incredible creators,
22:17 many of whom are in the gaming space like Jacob Geller,
22:21 Game Maker’s Toolkit, Eurothug4000,
22:22 and provides various opportunities to create great stuff.
22:26 Aside from being able to see my main channel videos over there early,
22:31 there is also a ton of exclusive content.
22:34 I’ve made a dozen or so videos you can only watch over there,
22:39 the most a breakdown of all the games I’ve 100%ed.
22:42 There is a ton of incredible stuff over there,
22:44 so if you’d like to check some of it out,
22:47 you can go to nebula.tv/razbuten or click the link
22:49 in the description to get 40% off for the year.
22:53 That comes out to just 3 bucks a month.
22:55 If you really love the idea of Nebula,
22:57 right now you can get a lifetime subscription which
22:59 is normally a one-time payment of $500 for just
23:03 $300 dollars which comes out to barely any money
23:06 at all a month if you live long enough.
23:08 Also, with the holiday season just around the corner,
23:10 if you’re looking to give the gift of good entertainment to those in your life,
23:13 you can get gift cards for both yearly and lifetime memberships.
23:16 For anyone unsure, Nebula just launched a free
23:18 3-day trial so you can spend a couple
23:20 days seeing what all is over there and decide
23:22 for yourself if it's your thing or not.
23:24 Nebula is a massive pillar of support
23:26 for myself and all of the creators on there
23:28 so I appreciate you all for listening to my yap about it for a bit.
23:31 Whether you sign up or use the free trial,
23:33 go check out Masterful Mimicry and everything else the site has to offer.
23:36 Thanks to Nebula for sponsoring this video.
23:39 For those still here.
23:40 Hi.
23:40 Thank you to my patrons for making this channel possible.
23:43 I appreciate ya.
23:44 I hope you have a great day and/or night, and I will see you in the next one.