Why Spain Collapsed Into Civil War - Kings and Generals Modern
Kings and Generals
0:11 In the summer of 1936, Spain tore itself apart.
0:15 What started as a rebellion of large swathes of the Spanish
0:19 army against the left-wing government quickly turned into a bloody civil war,
0:23 which killed hundreds of thousands of people and became
0:26 one of the great ideological battlegrounds of the twentieth century.
0:29 On one side stood the Spanish Republic,
0:32 defended by a reluctant coalition of republicans,
0:36 socialists, communists, who wanted to build a centralised socialist state,
0:39 anarchists, who wanted to abolish state authority altogether;
0:42 and regional nationalists fighting against the rebellious army,
0:47 conservatives, monarchists and fascists.
0:48 In this first video in our series on the Spanish Civil War,
0:52 we will discuss the broad struggle
0:54 between liberalism and conservatism that defined
0:56 pre-war Spain and became the driving cause of the civil war,
1:00 and describe the first stage of the war.
1:26 BACKGROUND Spain, once arguably the richest
1:49 and most powerful empire in the world, had become a poor and backward European
1:53 periphery by the time the 20th century arrived.
1:57 For centuries, Spain had struggled between libertarian and authoritarian ideas,
2:01 revolutionary ideals and monarchy,
2:03 aspirations of regional autonomy and centralization,
2:07 and the wealthy landowner class and millions of poor peasants.
2:12 From 1814 to 1874, Spain experienced 37 attempted coups, 12 of which succeeded.
2:18 But at no point did this struggle of ideas lead to a prosperous,
2:23 or democratic, or stable, or fair, or powerful country.
2:27 By the time 16-year-old Alfonso XIII became king of Spain in 1902,
2:32 it was far behind industrialized powerhouses like Britain,
2:36 France, Germany, and the United States.
2:38 It had lost its empire in a war against the United States,
2:42 and it had done so in a whimper.
2:45 It had been experiencing a massive population exodus to the New World.
2:49 Life expectancy was around 35 years, roughly the same as it was 4 centuries ago,
2:55 when Columbus set sail to discover a western route to India.
2:58 More than 60% of Spaniards were illiterate,
3:01 with roughly the same number engaged in agriculture,
3:04 indicating low industrial development.
3:06 The Church and the military, Spain's two strongest organized forces,
3:10 remained pillars of old feudal Spain
3:13 and the biggest supporters of conservative order and monarchy,
3:16 with little tolerance for liberalism or other progressive ideas.
3:21 However, dissatisfaction with the monarchy, church and army had been growing.
3:26 In July 1909, anti-military protests
3:28 in Barcelona developed into widespread unrest,
3:31 church burnings and anticlerical violence.
3:34 This foreshadowed what was to come.
3:36 Spain was weak, which was probably the main reason why it
3:40 stayed out of the power politics of the early XX century.
3:43 It ended up being a blessing in disguise,
3:46 as Spain remained neutral in World War 1.
3:49 The capital repatriated to the metropole
3:51 after the loss of the empire's remnants,
3:54 along with European investment related to the Great War,
3:57 helped produce a temporary economic boom.
3:59 Demand for Spanish agricultural products, manufactured goods,
4:03 and raw materials increased significantly during the war,
4:06 but toward the end of the war, demand dropped,
4:09 and Spain returned to its accustomed economic and political troubles.
4:13 In 1921, the Spanish army suffered a disastrous defeat at the hands
4:17 of the Moroccans led by Abd el-Krim at the start of the Rif War.
4:22 Around 10,000 Spanish soldiers were killed in what
4:25 became known as the Disaster of Annual, which created a massive public outcry.
4:30 This outcry, in turn, created fertile ground for Captain-General Miguel
4:33 Primo de Rivera to launch a coup in 1923 and establish a military
4:39 dictatorship while formally maintaining the monarchy.
4:42 Although certainly authoritarian,
4:43 Primo de Rivera tolerated dissent to some degree,
4:47 which ultimately led to his downfall.
4:49 In 1931, a strike at the Central University of Madrid
4:53 against the military dictatorship grew into a nationwide movement,
4:57 eventually forcing Alfonso XIII to call for municipal elections,
5:01 which were dominated by Republicans and Socialists.
5:04 On April 14, 1931, the monarchy was
5:07 overthrown and the Second Spanish Republic proclaimed.
5:11 But establishing a republic did not mean
5:14 all of Spain’s structural problems disappeared overnight.
5:16 Far from it.
5:18 The new Republic had inherited several major issues, like economic difficulties,
5:23 land being mostly in the hands of large landowners,
5:26 oversized and politically unreliable military,
5:28 Catalan and Basque aspirations for autonomy
5:31 and the major influence of the Church.
5:34 The new government found itself in conflict with the army
5:36 due to the reduction of the size of the officer corps,
5:39 with the Catholic church for proclaiming the separation of Church and state,
5:43 and for instances of churches being burned.
5:46 In August 1932, the government suppressed a coup attempt by General Sanjurjo.
5:51 But the government also found itself
5:53 at odds with many politically active landless peasants,
5:56 socialists, communists and anarchists- a truly
5:59 powerful new force in Spanish politics- who,
6:02 on the one hand, demanded progressive reforms,
6:04 while many of these groups saw the Republic as a temporary measure,
6:08 before they could remould Spain in accordance with their vision.
6:12 They pursued revolutionary politics and regularly staged protests and strikes.
6:16 The high point of this process was the Asturias revolution of 1934,
6:21 wherein socialist and anarchist trade unions and their militias
6:25 took over Asturias by force and proclaimed a proletarian revolution.
6:29 The government ordered the military to suppress the rebellion,
6:32 which did so in their usual heavy-handed manner, killing around 1700 people.
6:37 The situation was politically disastrous for the moderate republican government.
6:42 The left's revolutionary politics and the government's
6:45 violent suppression alienated the left.
6:47 The right's inherent distrust of the republic and its progressive tendencies,
6:51 along with its inability to establish law and order, alienated the right.
6:56 As a result, Spain was deeply fragmented among
6:59 many powerful and influential groups across the political spectrum.
7:03 This was a recipe for disaster.
7:06 In that sense, the 1936 elections would be pivotal for Spain's future.
7:11 Center-left and left-wing parties united
7:13 in an electoral alliance called the Popular Front,
7:16 similar to France, to signal their intention to fight the rising fascist threat.
7:21 The Popular Front won those elections by promising to continue
7:25 agrarian reform and release prisoners from the Asturias rebellion.
7:29 A new government of liberal and left-wing
7:32 republican politicians headed by Manuel Azana,
7:34 also known as the Father of the Republic, was established.
7:37 Immediately, some monarchists and army generals,
7:40 including the future leader of the nationalist coup, General Fransicso Franco,
7:44 considered taking over the government,
7:46 but they decided to stand down for the time being.
7:49 However, the Popular Front government struggled to control the situation.
7:53 As soon as they won the elections, crowds began releasing political prisoners,
7:58 refusing to wait for the government's formal proclamation of amnesty.
8:01 Political militia groups on the left and the right started to proliferate.
8:06 Strikes, factory occupations,
8:07 political violence and assassinations proliferated.
8:10 By spring of 1936, Spain had become ungovernable.
8:15 THE COUP And the military conspiracy was brewing in the shadows.
8:18 In March 1936, General Emilio Mola- the principal organizer
8:22 of a military conspiracy started meeting with potential co-conspirators,
8:27 Generals Franco, Goded, Varela and others.
8:29 Two right-wing militias were to provide
8:32 additional manpower alongside the army: the Carlists,
8:34 traditionalist monarchists loyal to a rival royal line,
8:38 and the Falangists, Spain’s fascist movement.
8:40 The plan was to start military rebellions across Spain,
8:44 including Spanish Morocco, combine with Carlist and Falangist militias,
8:47 civil guards and other security forces
8:50 sympathetic to them and crush the republic.
8:52 Spain had around 100k men in its army at the time,
8:56 and its best-equipped and trained force was the Army of Africa,
9:00 with almost 40k men.
9:01 It was to be the driving force of the rebellion.
9:05 Resistance to the plot existed even within the army’s own ranks.
9:09 However, the conspirators failed to keep their plans secret,
9:12 as a group of left-wing officers in the Spanish
9:15 Army known as the Union Militar Republicana
9:17 Antifascista (UMRA) warned the government about the planned
9:20 coup and offered to kidnap coup leaders in Morocco.
9:24 However, the Prime Minister Casares Quiroga refused
9:27 to believe that an anti-Republican coup was being plotted,
9:31 claiming that Mola, specifically, was loyal to the republic.
9:34 By July 1936, the main preparations for the coup were complete.
9:39 And soon the plotters got the pretext they needed to push the button.
9:43 On July 12, a Falangist gunman murdered
9:45 a socialist officer of the Assault Guard, Lieutenant Jose Castillo.
9:49 In retaliation, other socialist officers murdered
9:52 a prominent monarchist political leader, Jose Calvo Sotelo.
9:56 The plotters had already had everything planned out,
9:59 and Calvo Sotelo’s assassination gave them a pretext.
10:02 According to Mola’s plan, the Army of Africa was to start the rebellion at 5
10:07 am on July 18 with mainland forces to follow later.
10:11 The Army of Africa was to secure Morocco,
10:13 before crossing the Strait of Gibraltar to crush the republic on the mainland.
10:17 However, by midday on July 17,
10:19 the commander of the forces in Melilla, General Romerales discovered the plot.
10:23 It was a “now or never” moment for the plotters.
10:27 And they did not hesitate.
10:29 Local rebel officers immediately arrested Romerales,
10:32 mobilized troops and started capturing
10:35 government buildings and key military installations.
10:37 The rebellion quickly spread to the rest of Spanish Morocco
10:41 and by the next day all the resistance by the republicans had been defeated.
10:45 The same was true for the Canary Islands,
10:47 where General Franco had declared for the rebels and quickly moved to Morocco.
10:51 At the same time, the rebellion began to spread across mainland Spain.
10:56 Many army garrisons declared for the rebellion, but success was not guaranteed.
11:01 Much depended on the reaction of the government,
11:04 left-wing militias, and other security forces.
11:06 The speed of action often determined the success.
11:10 In Sevilla, the rebel General Quiepo de Llano arrested his superior
11:13 and anyone else in the military loyal to the republic,
11:17 gave weapons to the Falangists,
11:18 forced other official security forces like the Assault Guard
11:22 and the Civil Guard to either join the rebellion or surrender.
11:25 By the time, the government and ordinary citizens loyal
11:28 to the republic started to act, it was too late.
11:31 The capture of Sevilla was a strategically important victory for the rebels,
11:35 as it provided the Army of Africa a bridgehead to come ashore in southern Spain.
11:40 Soon Cadiz, Algeciras,
11:41 Jerez and much of the coastline near Portugal fell to the rebels,
11:45 paving the way for easier landing of the Army of Africa.
11:49 But the rebellion failed in many other Spanish cities.
11:52 In Malaga, the Assault Guard remained loyal to the government
11:56 and forced the rebel troops back into their barracks.
11:58 Spain’s two largest trade union federations,
12:01 the socialist UGT and the anarchist CNT,
12:04 had armed members ready to resist the coup in cities across the country.
12:09 In Jaen, the governor immediately distributed weapons
12:11 to the UGT and CNT trade unions, preventing the nationalist takeover.
12:15 On many occasions, this was the single biggest
12:18 difference between the Republic's victory and its defeat.
12:21 In the first couple of days of the coup,
12:24 the republican government was utterly disorganized and paralyzed,
12:27 failing to understand the gravity of the situation and rise to the occasion.
12:31 On July 18, a day after the rebellion began,
12:34 Prime Minister Casares Quiroga refused to distribute
12:37 weapons to those willing to fight the coup,
12:39 claiming it had been confined to Morocco.
12:41 The republican government also feared
12:43 that distributing weapons would strengthen left-wing groups,
12:46 many of which undoubtedly saw the republican government
12:49 as merely a stepping stone to a socialist government.
12:52 But by that point, the government had already lost its monopoly over violence-
12:56 the single most important trait of rule and failing to arm the people,
13:00 who wanted to fight against the coup,
13:03 meant losing time and several important regions to the rebels.
13:06 Once it became clear that the rebellion had spread, Casares Quiroga resigned,
13:10 with Diego Martinez Barrio becoming the new prime minister.
13:14 His government lasted only a few hours,
13:17 as he also had to resign after unsurprisingly failing
13:19 to convince Mola to stop the violence through negotiations.
13:23 Only after Jose Giral became prime minister on July 19 was the decision
13:28 made to distribute weapons to people who wanted to fight for the republic.
13:32 In any case, by that point,
13:34 many members of trade unions, anarchists, communists,
13:36 members of the left-wing militia
13:38 and ordinary people had already armed themselves
13:41 by raiding armories and obtaining weapons
13:43 from pro-Republican members of the military.
13:46 But it was not just the Republicans, who were disorganized,
13:49 as the nationalists also lost a crucial moment to crush the republic by taking
13:54 over its two largest cities- Madrid and Barcelona at the start of the rebellion.
13:59 In the capital, General Fanjul entered the Montana barracks to lead
14:03 some 2500 rebel officers and Falangist volunteers only on July 19,
14:07 2 days after the start of the rebellion.
14:10 By that point, a hostile crowd,
14:12 encouraged by the “No Pasaran!” speech of the communist leader Dolores Ibarruri,
14:17 organized and partially armed by the UGT and CNT,
14:20 had surrounded the barracks and forced the rebels back into the barracks.
14:24 On the following day, the Assault Guard,
14:26 which remained loyal to the government in Madrid,
14:29 brought artillery and, together with the armed pro-Republican citizens,
14:33 stormed the Montana barracks.
14:34 The initial rebellion in Madrid had been defeated,
14:37 and the Republicans still held the capital.
14:40 The battle in Barcelona was even bloodier.
14:43 The rebels had around 12,000 men,
14:45 who waited for General Goded to arrive from Mallorca and assume command.
14:49 Although Catalan president Lluis Companys initially refused
14:52 to distribute arms to the anarchist CNT, the latter found a way to arm
14:57 themselves through sympathetic military members by the time
15:00 Goded left the barracks to take over Barcelona on the morning of July 19.
15:05 Goded sent his men to capture major positions around Barcelona,
15:09 including central squares, major government buildings and hotels.
15:12 But the Assault Guard and the armed workers kept the rebel soldiers
15:16 at bay by erecting barricades and resisting with whatever weapons they had.
15:21 Once the 800 members of the Civil Guard led
15:23 by Colonel Escobar entered the battle on the Republican side,
15:26 the tide turned against the rebels.
15:29 Goded was forced to surrender.
15:31 WHO CONTROLS WHAT?
15:31 THE SPANISH AIRLIFT By the time the dust settled,
15:33 neither side had a definitive advantage.
15:35 The Republic controlled Madrid, Barcelona, and virtually all Catalonia,
15:39 Valencia, Murcia, and most of the Mediterranean coast,
15:42 along with a zone in the North containing Bilbao, San Sebastian,
15:46 and Santander, which was separated
15:47 from the rest of the Republican-controlled territory.
15:50 As a result, the Republicans controlled the largest cities,
15:54 the most industrialized territories,
15:56 most of the Mediterranean coast, and the border with France.
16:00 Meanwhile, the Nationalists controlled Galicia, Leon,
16:03 much of old Castile, Burgos, Valladolid, Salamanca,
16:06 Zaragoza, Pamplona, a separate bridgehead in Andalucia,
16:09 and Mallorca, Ibiza, and Spanish Morocco.
16:12 While the Republic controlled the most important and richest areas,
16:16 the Nationalists controlled both sides of the Strait of Gibraltar,
16:19 which would soon be a huge help.
16:21 Because the fate of the rebellion depended on how soon General Franco was going
16:26 to transport the strongest Spanish military force-
16:28 the Army of Africa onto the mainland.
16:31 In the first days of the rebellion, almost 700 men were brought
16:35 to the Andalusian shores aboard Spanish Navy vessels,
16:38 as most naval officers sympathized with the rebellion.
16:41 But very soon sailors and petty officers mutinied against
16:45 pro-nationalist officers and took control of most of the fleet.
16:49 And the Republican fleet started the blockade of the Strait of Gibraltar,
16:53 making the nationalist task of transporting its army even more difficult.
16:57 A few hundred men were transported via aircraft, but this was not nearly enough.
17:01 Both Mola and Franco petitioned Hitler and Mussolini,
17:04 their natural allies, for support.
17:06 Almost immediately, Hitler agreed to help out
17:09 the Nationalists and launched Operation Magic Fire,
17:12 with 20 Junkers Ju 52/3m transport aircraft and 6
17:16 Henkel fighters being allocated to transport the Spanish troops.
17:20 Soon Mussolini joined in by providing 12
17:23 Savoia-Marchetti SM.81 bombers to serve as transport aircraft.
17:28 This operation not only allowed Franco to transport thousands
17:31 of his troops and their equipment onto the mainland,
17:33 but also provided enough deterrence to reduce
17:36 the Republican fleet's presence in the Strait of Gibraltar.
17:39 This also allowed Nationalist-loyal vessels to transport troops.
17:43 For instance, on August 5, approximately 1600 troops, 6 artillery guns,
17:48 hundreds of tons of ammunition and other
17:51 equipment were transported from Ceuta to Algeciras,
17:54 which the Nationalist propaganda dubbed the Convoy
17:57 de la Victoria- Convoy of Victory.
18:00 By mid-October about 13,500 soldiers of the Army
18:03 of Africa had been transported into the Iberian Peninsula.
18:06 And once the threat of the Republican
18:09 fleet in the Strait of Gibraltar had decreased,
18:12 the Nationalists continued transporting their men via sea.
18:14 Thanks to this help by Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy,
18:17 the Nationalist side of the Spanish Civil War
18:20 now had a superior army on the mainland.
18:23 Meanwhile, the only official help that Republican Spain received at the start
18:27 of the Civil War was a handful of obsolete aircraft from the French.
18:30 CONCLUSION In our next episode,
18:32 we'll discuss the internationalization of the Spanish
18:34 Civil War and foreign aid to both sides.
18:37 For now, let’s conclude by looking at the general
18:40 picture at the initial stage of the Spanish Civil War.
18:43 The Republic had Madrid, Barcelona,
18:44 the industrialized portion of the Basque Country,
18:47 and the gold and monetary reserves of the Spanish national bank.
18:51 The Nationalists controlled roughly half of Spain,
18:54 most of its agricultural output,
18:56 the strongest and best-prepared portion of the Spanish army,
18:59 and two powerful foreign allies.
19:01 Once these allies ensured the Army of Africa had come ashore in Andalucia,
19:05 the Nationalist leadership decided to capture Madrid
19:08 and break Republican resistance once and for all.
19:11 In our next episode, we will talk about the Nationalist drive to Madrid,
19:15 the battle for the capital, other crucial engagements of the Spanish Civil War,
19:19 along with its external and internal dynamics,
19:21 so make sure you are subscribed and have pressed the bell button to see them.
19:26 Please consider liking, subscribing, commenting,
19:28 and sharing, it helps immensely.
19:30 Our patrons and YouTube members can watch more than 300 exclusive videos,
19:34 join their ranks via the link in the description or by pressing
19:37 the join button under the video to watch these weekly videos,
19:41 learn about our schedule, get early access to our videos,
19:44 access our private Discord, and much more.
19:46 This is the Kings and Generals channel, and we will catch you on the next one.