Why people think they see ghosts
Vox
0:00 If you believe the dead can return to haunt the living, you’re not alone.
0:04 According to one poll,
0:05 45% of Americans believe in ghosts and 28% claim to actually have seen a ghost.
0:10 They show up in our movies, I see dead people.
0:14 books, and Bone Thugs-N-Harmony music videos.
0:18 As far back as we can trace human life,
0:20 there’s evidence that almost every culture
0:21 has expressed curiosity about what comes after.
0:25 Many people believe in them, but is there actually any proof that ghosts exist?
0:33 I went to Buffalo, New York, to talk to Joe Nickell,
0:35 a paranormal investigator who’s been trying
0:37 to answer that question for almost 50 years.
0:39 I’m the world’s only full-time,
0:43 salaried, professional, science-based paranormal investigator.
0:47 I’m looking to explain a case, not debunk it, not promote it.
0:54 Explain it.
0:55 Nickell is a true renaissance man,
0:56 drawing from a wide variety of disciplines for his cases.
0:58 I mean, at one time or another I’ve used linguistic analysis,
1:02 I’ve used blood pattern analysis, psychological insights.
1:07 Nearly anything could be used if it would illuminate a particular case.
1:13 So in the hundreds of cases in his half-century of investigation,
1:16 has he ever found anything that would make him believe in ghosts?
1:19 Not only have I never found a single case that I thought was proof of a ghost,
1:28 neither has science.
1:29 Not a single ghost or haunting has been authenticated by science.
1:34 Part of what makes it difficult to investigate is all
1:36 the different ways people have defined “ghosts.” Books flying off a shelf?
1:42 Orbs in photos?
1:45 Mysterious footsteps in the attic?
1:48 Patrick Swayze seductively helping you throw a vase?
1:51 Definitely ghost.
1:53 All of the would-be evidence that ghosts
1:55 exist consists of ambiguous photographs, videos,
1:58 The next day, his HDTV literally begins rocking
2:01 violently from side to side all by itself.
2:03 and first hand accounts, Even if it’s during the day,
2:06 there’s this eerie feeling that you get that there’s someone there.
2:10 which, while fun and spooky, are not exactly scientific proof.
2:14 Ghost hunters often use gadgets such as EMF meters,
2:16 a tool that measure electromagnetic fields,
2:19 which ghosts can supposably manipulate.
2:21 But nobody’s been able to explain exactly what the link is,
2:24 and most scientists are pretty skeptical of this stuff.
2:27 So there might not be any empirical,
2:29 scientific evidence that shows that ghosts exist,
2:32 but that doesn’t actually mean that you’re crazy if you think you see one.
2:39 One is infrasound, a sound that falls below the audible 20Hz frequency.
2:44 Infrasound can be produced by many things,
2:48 including or certain machinery like engines or fans.
2:52 Researchers have hypothesized that exposure
2:53 to infrasound can induce feeling of depression,
2:56 chills, and the sense that somebody’s presence is near you.
3:00 The sound can even cause visual hallucinations.
3:02 At the frequency of 18Hz, it resonates with the structure of the human eyeball.
3:08 And if you have a sound that resonates with something material,
3:11 it will make the material vibrate at that frequency.
3:15 And when that happens to you,
3:16 your eye begins to see things that are in fact not there.
3:19 Swiss scientists have also been able to simulate a ghost in a lab.
3:23 They made a robot that mimics the movement of the subject’s
3:25 hands with a mechanical arm that touches your back, but with a slight delay.
3:29 When you delay the movement, it creates an unmistakable sensation for subjects
3:33 that there’s a ghostly presence in the room.
3:35 This time it really felt like I was playing with somebody, something.
3:39 So it wasn’t myself that was poking me in the back,
3:41 but it was as if I was playing with an animal,
3:43 a monkey, that was poking me in the back or something like that.
3:46 While most ghost sightings can’t be written off as a robot poking your back,
3:49 this experiment does highlight how manipulating
3:50 certain parts of your brain can produce
3:53 what researcher Olaf Blanke calls which can
3:58 easily be misconstrued as a ghostly presence.
4:00 Sometimes even just a person’s state of consciousness
4:02 can make them feel or see presences.
4:04 We can actually have people see ghosts,
4:08 and those tend to be waking dreams that occur
4:12 in the twilight between being fully asleep and fully awake.
4:16 These kind of waking dreams can also be called sleep paralysis,
4:20 which about 8% of people experience at some point in their lifetime.
4:24 You feel like you’re awake, but you’re unable to move your body,
4:27 and it’s often accompanied by terrifying visuals like shadows,
4:31 people, or even monsters, which, if you didn’t know what was happening,
4:35 would be easy to confuse for having seen a ghost.
4:38 Another possible explanation for ghostly sightings is grief.
4:41 One study found that up to 60% of people that lose
4:43 a spouse claim to see or hear their dead loved ones.
4:46 In his book about hallucinations,
4:48 neurologist Oliver Sacks said that seeing the face of a deceased
4:51 loved one can actually help you cope with your grief.
4:54 This sort of hallucination is not frightening; it’s often very comforting.
4:58 It seems to be part of the mourning process.
5:02 A sudden hole has been left in one’s life, and this helps it to heal over.
5:11 There is no question that most
5:14 of the paranormal promotes something very positive.
5:17 There are a few exceptions, but all have to do with our hopes and our fears.
5:25 We’re hopeful that ghosts exist because then we don’t really die.
5:30 Our loved ones are not gone from us; they are real and alive.
5:35 I remember when my grandmother died and how much
5:38 I did not want that to be the case.
5:40 But the ghost idea, the idea that we just get
5:43 up out of our bodies and continue on, is powerful.
5:48 Because who doesn’t have an instance in which he or she would say,
5:53 I just wish I could’ve told my mother this one thing.
5:58 Or I wish my father knew I wasn’t really mad at him that time.
6:02 So ghosts may not actually exist,
6:05 but that doesn’t mean that you might not see one.