Why Yugoslavia Collapsed: The Road to War
Kings and Generals
0:11 We don’t think of war when we say “Europe”, do we?
0:16 Most think of a community of democratic nations,
0:20 which, after centuries of conflicts, have seemingly risen above war,
0:25 and seek cooperation and peaceful coexistence rather than armed confrontation.
0:31 And that is mostly true.
0:34 But of course, not entirely.
0:36 The war in Ukraine has been raging for more than 4 years now.
0:41 But it is not just Ukraine.
0:44 The Balkans is one of the most beautiful,
0:47 culturally and historically rich regions of the world.
0:51 Alas, it has long been known as the powder
0:54 keg of Europe because many national, ethnic,
0:57 and religious communities are concentrated in a relatively small area,
1:03 and disputes arise from historical grievances and territorial claims.
1:08 And when you accompany these grievances and claims with ambitious politicians,
1:14 who saw extreme nationalism and chaos as the ladder to power,
1:19 you get a recipe for disaster.
1:22 In a nutshell, this is what happened in Yugoslavia.
1:26 Today we are starting our series about the Yugoslav Wars,
1:31 a bloody series of conflicts,
1:33 which reminded Europe that it was not immune to bloodshed,
1:39 ethnic conflict and genocide.
1:41 WHAT IS YUGOSLAVIA?
1:56 BACKGROUND For centuries, the Balkans had been a border area
2:29 slash battleground between the Ottoman and Habsburg Empires.
2:33 Specifically, Serbia and Montenegro became independent after
2:37 the Ottoman defeat against Russia in 1878,
2:41 while the rest of the country was mostly part of the Austro-Hungarian Empire.
2:46 Then the First World War led to the collapse of the aforementioned two empires,
2:51 and on their ruins emerged the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes,
2:56 which a decade later rebranded itself as the Kingdom of Yugoslavia.
3:02 Although the Serbian Karadjorjevic dynasty ruled it, it was, in a way,
3:08 a product of the aspirations
3:10 of the intelligentsia of the Southern Slavic peoples,
3:13 who saw a Southern Slavic union as liberation from the foreign yoke.
3:19 However, soon Yugoslavia descended into a Serbian-dominated dictatorship,
3:24 which obviously caused disillusionment among other Yugoslav nations.
3:32 In 1941, the Axis invaded Yugoslavia, quickly occupied the Kingdom,
3:37 and created a puppet state in Croatia led by a fascist Ustaše regime.
3:44 But very quickly Yugoslavians started one of the most
3:48 powerful resistance movements against the Nazi occupation,
3:51 led by a half-Croat, half-Slovene communist Josip Broz Tito.
3:56 Tito’s army, admittedly with the help of the Soviet Union and other allies,
4:02 liberated Belgrade in October 1944 and then the rest of Yugoslavia in May 1945.
4:10 In 1945, he proclaimed Yugoslavia
4:13 a communist federation consisting of six republics:
4:17 Serbia, Croatia, Slovenia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Montenegro, and Macedonia.
4:24 Under Tito, Yugoslavia became a truly unique country.
4:28 It was communist, but opposed the Soviet Union’s dominance,
4:33 which caused the two states to fall out.
4:36 It allowed much more contact with Western Europe, welcomed Western tourists,
4:41 and allowed its citizens to travel and work abroad.
4:45 While undoubtedly a dictatorship with little tolerance for dissent,
4:50 especially by communist standards,
4:53 Yugoslavia was a remarkably decentralized country.
4:57 All six republics and Serbia’s autonomous provinces of Kosovo
5:02 and Vojvodina had considerable control over local matters.
5:06 This became even more pronounced with the adoption of the 1974 Constitution,
5:12 which granted the republics significant powers.
5:15 They had their own constitutions, parliaments,
5:18 communist parties, police structures, courts, and other structures.
5:23 Most importantly, the Constitution established a 9-member presidency,
5:27 which was to become Tito’s successor, however strange it may sound.
5:33 It included representatives from each republic, two autonomous provinces,
5:38 and the president of the League of Communists of Yugoslavia.
5:41 This structure was meant to serve as head of state
5:46 and commander in chief of the Yugoslav army after Tito’s death.
5:51 But while Tito sought decentralization,
5:54 he also used the state security apparatus to curb any expression of nationalism.
6:01 Guided by his doctrine of Brotherhood and Unity,
6:05 the Yugoslav leader jailed or exiled nationalists across the country.
6:10 By doing so, he was sweeping
6:13 all potential ethnic-based grievances under the rug,
6:16 making sure that they wouldn’t manifest while he was alive.
6:21 But none of us are immortal, and like many powerful,
6:26 effective strongman leaders before and after him,
6:29 Tito left no viable succession plan.
6:32 His death on May 4, 1980, ended an era.
6:37 The ethnic Albanian communist Mahmut Bakalli later
6:41 said this about Tito’s death: “We all cried, but we did not know we were also
6:49 burying Yugoslavia.” START OF THE CRISIS In Tito’s absence,
6:53 nationalist sentiments previously expressed
6:55 occasionally and violently suppressed
6:57 began to creep back into the political scene.
7:01 Kosovo was where the first signs of trouble emerged.
7:05 According to the 1981 census,
7:08 77% of Kosovo's 1.5 million inhabitants were Albanian,
7:12 with Serbs in the minority at 13%.
7:16 Kosovo was also one of Yugoslavia's poorest regions,
7:21 with extremely high unemployment.
7:23 On March 11, 1981, around 2,000 Albanian students
7:28 gathered in the capital of the Kosovo autonomy,
7:32 Priština, demanding republic status.
7:34 The Yugoslav security forces suppressed
7:37 the movement in their usual heavy-handed manner,
7:40 expelling them from the party and jailing hundreds of Albanians.
7:46 This only exacerbated their discontent.
7:48 At the same time, many Serbs emigrated from Kosovo.
7:52 Economic reasons were obvious, as many Serbs left the autonomous province
7:57 to seek employment and better opportunities elsewhere.
8:01 However, Serb emigrants also complained
8:03 of discrimination by Albanian-dominated institutions,
8:06 with reports of harassment, rape,
8:09 and pressure to leave Kosovo widely circulating in Serbia.
8:15 This soon became a dominant narrative.
8:18 Simultaneously, Tito’s death weakened Yugoslavia’s
8:22 ability to control the historical narratives.
8:26 More and more historians and scholars deviated
8:29 from the official Brotherhood and Unity line,
8:33 revisiting the horrors of World War II and ethnic conflict within Yugoslavia.
8:39 Instead of toeing the line to safeguard Yugoslav unity,
8:43 many authors preferred to write about history
8:46 from the perspective of their countries and peoples,
8:49 which often exaggerated the atrocities of other ethnic groups,
8:53 while downplaying those that were perpetrated by their side.
8:58 Intelligentsias were growing increasingly nationalistic.
9:01 The culmination of this process was the publishing of an unfinished
9:05 Memorandum of the Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts in September 1986,
9:11 which claimed that Yugoslavia was suffering a profound political
9:16 crisis due to the 1974 Constitution and decentralization process.
9:22 It also blamed the Yugoslav system for creating
9:25 an advantage for Croatia and Slovenia over Serbia,
9:29 along with warning about dangers for the Serb
9:33 minority in Croatia and claiming “physical,
9:36 political, legal and cultural genocide” of Serbs in Kosovo.
9:41 To some extent, this memorandum became
9:44 a political program for Serb nationalists.
9:48 Initially, Yugoslavia’s top brass strongly condemned the document,
9:52 and the media followed.
9:54 However, one major name was conspicuously missing.
9:58 The leader of Serbia’s Communist Party, Slobodan Milošević,
10:02 who seemed like an ordinary orthodox Communist bureaucrat,
10:07 did not join the chorus of voices condemning the Memorandum.
10:14 Almost simultaneously, a Serb movement in Kosovo was gaining momentum.
10:19 Remember that Kosovo has a special place in the hearts and minds of the Serbs.
10:25 It is considered the cradle of the Serbian state and its
10:28 Orthodox Church and the place where the Battle of Kosovo,
10:32 an important pillar of Serbian historical memory, took place in 1389.
10:38 In 1986, the Committee of Serbs and Montenegrins
10:42 gathered 50,000 signatures demanding change in Kosovo.
10:46 They lobbied Belgrade for more attention to their plight,
10:51 and their chance arrived on April 24,
10:54 1987, when Milošević went to Kosovo Polje to meet with Kosovo Serbs.
11:00 While Milošević met with movement leaders, a large Serb crowd gathered outside.
11:06 Clashes with the police occurred, as people started hurling rocks taken
11:11 from a truck parked nearby by Serb activists.
11:15 Milošević went outside to check what was happening,
11:18 and demonstrators approached him, complaining of police brutality.
11:22 His words later shown on national television
11:26 transformed him into a leader of Serb nationalism:
11:30 “No one should dare to beat you”,
11:33 calling on Serbs to remain in Kosovo and promising to solve their problems.
11:38 Some, like Albanian Party Chief of Kosovo Azem Vllasi,
11:43 went on to claim that Milošević orchestrated these events to galvanize a public
11:49 movement to support his claim to power and demand changes in Kosovo.
11:54 Things got even more tense when, in September,
11:58 an Albanian military conscript killed four fellow soldiers— two Muslims,
12:03 a Croat, and a Serb at the Paraćin barracks.
12:07 The ethnic composition of the victim group did not prevent
12:11 the Serb media from calling this event an act of Albanian separatism.
12:16 Thousands attended the funeral of the killed Serbian soldier,
12:20 with an anti-Albanian campaign spreading.
12:23 The Communist Party grew alarmed by the rise of nationalist sentiment.
12:28 The Belgrade Party leader, Dragiša Pavlović,
12:31 offered scathing criticism of those stoking nationalism,
12:36 implying Milošević and his clique without explicitly naming him.
12:42 Serbia’s president Stambolić backed Pavlović,
12:45 but Milošević used all his power in the Party and the media to orchestrate
12:51 Pavlović’s dismissal from his post
12:53 at the Eighth Congress of the Communist Party.
12:57 Soon Stambolić met the same fate.
13:00 Riding the wave of nationalism,
13:02 Slobodan Milošević went from an unspectacular bureaucrat to Serbia's
13:07 most powerful political leader in a matter of months.
13:11 With popular support behind him,
13:13 Milošević continued to rely on mass nationalist rallies called
13:18 “Meetings of Truth” to pursue the so-called anti-bureaucratic revolution.
13:22 The goal was to abolish autonomies of Kosovo
13:26 and Vojvodina and to expand the extent of his power.
13:32 The wave of Milošević-organized or -supported
13:35 demonstrations led to the fall of previous
13:38 leaders of Vojvodina and Montenegro in the fall of 1988 and winter of 1989,
13:43 with power switching to politicians aligned with Milošević.
13:48 The same pressure was being applied to Kosovo.
13:52 However, due to very powerful internal dissent,
13:56 expressed in actions like Trepča miners’ strike,
13:59 along with the opposition of other republics, the process was not as easy.
14:04 Other republics feared that if Milošević was now
14:08 taking over autonomous provinces and moving to abolish them,
14:12 the same could happen to them in the future.
14:16 Moreover, Yugoslavia’s 8-member presidency meant
14:19 that Milošević's co-optation of the Kosovo
14:22 Communist Party would guarantee him half the votes on any given vote.
14:29 Specifically, Slovenia openly sided with Kosovo,
14:32 organising a mass demonstration in support
14:35 of Trepča miners in the capital Ljubljana.
14:38 However, this did not stop Milošević.
14:41 In March 1989, he pushed through a new constitution of Serbia,
14:46 which significantly curtailed the autonomy of Kosovo and Vojvodina.
14:51 22 ethnic Albanians and two policemen were
14:54 killed in protests against the new constitution,
14:57 but it did not change the result.
15:00 Serbia’s new nationalist leader Slobodan Milošević
15:03 had won the first round of battle.
15:07 SLOVENIA AND CROATIA INDEPENDENCE However,
15:08 his victory over Serbia’s autonomous provinces
15:11 raised the alarm among the Republics, particularly Croatia and Slovenia.
15:16 The transformation of Yugoslavia after Tito’s death also brought
15:20 the national question to the fore in these republics.
15:24 Both resented what they saw as the dominant position of Serbs in the Union.
15:30 Both saw themselves as part of the greater
15:33 Catholic Austro-Hungarian realm of Central Europe,
15:36 rather than an extension of Orthodox Serbia.
15:39 This resentment and memory of its
15:42 previous independent states made Croat nationalism
15:45 and desire for an independent state
15:48 the central theme of the republic’s dissidents.
15:51 Croatian nationalism was one of the taboo subjects in Yugoslavia,
15:56 and its open expression,
15:58 like the Croatian Spring of 1971, had been ruthlessly crushed by Tito.
16:03 Meanwhile, in Slovenia,
16:04 considered by many as the most developed republic of Yugoslavia,
16:05 the post-Tito thaw paved the way for a different kind
16:05 of political and cultural expression- a more liberal and progressive one.
16:06 The new Slovene communist leadership of Milan Kučan
16:09 showed unusual levels of tolerance for independent journalism,
16:13 alternative youth culture, feminist groups, and other grassroots organisations.
16:19 As in Serbia, the politically active intelligentsia in Slovenia also made
16:24 its views known through a proposed
16:27 national program that advocated more sovereignty,
16:30 more democracy, and less dependence on Yugoslavia.
16:34 Slovenia’s communist leadership criticised the program,
16:38 but did not suppress its authors.
16:41 But a true pro-independence movement in Slovenia was sparked by a reaction
16:46 to the Yugoslav People’s Army arrest of four
16:50 Slovenian journalists of the youth magazine Mladina,
16:53 who leaked secret military documents.
16:56 Slovene dissidents formed the Committee for the Defence
17:00 of Human Rights and soon met with Slovenian President Stanovnik,
17:04 who publicly expressed support for their cause and the arrested journalists.
17:09 Thousands attended the trials.
17:11 And even though the journalists were sentenced, their arrest sparked the start
17:18 of a powerful pro-independence movement in Slovenia.
17:22 In September 1989, the Slovenian parliament adopted constitutional amendments,
17:28 which expanded Slovenia’s sovereignty and gave
17:30 it the right to secede from Yugoslavia,
17:33 after a fierce political battle with the Federal government and Serbia.
17:39 Notably, Croatia supported Slovenia in this, understanding that Slovenia
17:43 “was the only hope of resistance to Milošević”, as Silber and Little put it.
17:50 Croatia’s support for Slovenia became even more
17:53 apparent during the final political breakdown between
17:56 Slovenia and Serbia- at the Fourteenth Extraordinary
18:00 Party Congress on January 23, 1990, in Belgrade.
18:04 The Serbian and Montenegrin delegations rejected all proposals from Slovenia.
18:10 Each rejection was followed by applause.
18:13 All Slovene representatives walked out.
18:16 Then the Croats did the same.
18:18 This was a clear message.
18:21 Two western republics of Yugoslavia did not intend
18:24 to continue with the union in its current form, under someone like Milošević.
18:30 Slovenia, which was already way ahead
18:32 in its reforms to legalise other political parties,
18:35 and Croatia, which did the same in 1989,
18:39 scheduled their first multi-party elections for April 1990.
18:43 In Slovenia, former communist leader Kučan won the election
18:47 to become the country’s first democratically elected president,
18:51 while in Croatia the newly established broad-umbrella nationalist party HDZ,
18:58 led by the former general of the Yugoslav army turned dissident Franjo Tuđman,
19:04 emerged with an absolute majority.
19:07 Šahovnica- Croatia’s checkerboard old national symbol,
19:11 which was also used by the Ustaše puppet regime and was
19:15 associated by the Serbs with Croat nationalism and World War II atrocities,
19:20 once again became the country’s coat of arms.
19:24 Tensions rose further when the always
19:26 highly charged football match in Zagreb between
19:29 Dinamo Zagreb and Red Star Belgrade turned into a massive brawl on May 13.
19:36 Croat Serbs, a large minority of almost 600,000 people, started to organise.
19:43 The Mayor of a Serb town, Knin, Milan Babić,
19:47 created the Association of Serbian Municipalities, and by the end of 1990,
19:52 many Serb-majority areas joined in, and those who were unwilling were
19:57 forced to do so under pressure from repeated demonstrations organised by Babić.
20:03 Around the same time, a Serb police inspector from Knin,
20:07 Milan Martić, wrote a letter to Belgrade, stating that he and his officers would
20:12 refuse to wear new Croatian police uniforms
20:15 with Šahovnica and defied the demands
20:17 of Croat police chiefs in a public meeting,
20:20 which turned him into a military leader of the Serb movement in Croatia.
20:25 After receiving guarantees of support in Belgrade,
20:28 Babić announced plans for a referendum on Serbian autonomy in Croatia in August.
20:35 Croatia declared the referendum illegal and decided to solve the issue by force.
20:41 On August 17, 1990, three columns of Croatian police vehicles with seven
20:47 armoured vehicles and three helicopters moved on Knin to disarm the Serb police,
20:53 which had already distributed weapons to the population.
20:56 But the Croat advance stopped halfway when
20:59 the Yugoslav Air Force intercepted the helicopters, forcing them to back down.
21:05 A month later, Babić proclaimed the Serb Autonomous Region of Krajina
21:09 and then gradually moved to geographically
21:12 link all territories under their control.
21:16 By then, it was becoming clear where the process was heading.
21:20 Slovenia and Croatia were moving towards independence, and in both cases,
21:25 particularly with respect to Croatia,
21:27 a war with Serbia seemed like a real possibility.
21:31 Both countries started covertly building their militaries and smuggling
21:35 weapons from abroad to prepare for a potential conflict.
21:39 However, Yugoslav Military Intelligence exposed the Croat smuggling campaign.
21:43 They even managed to film some of the secret meetings,
21:47 where the smuggling work was being planned,
21:49 and later showed this footage on national television during
21:52 the meeting of the Federal Presidency in January 1991,
21:56 which gathered to decide whether to give the Yugoslav
22:00 Army authorization to disarm paramilitary groups in Croatia and Slovenia.
22:05 Nevertheless, the proposal was rejected.
22:08 Another attempt by the Serbian leadership
22:10 to gain the authorization of the Federal Presidency
22:13 for the intervention of the army to suppress
22:16 the powerful anti-Milošević movement in Belgrade on March 14,
22:20 1991, was rejected as well.
22:23 On the next day, Milošević declared: “Yugoslavia is finished”,
22:28 in all but name announcing Serbia’s secession from the Union.
22:32 On the same day, Croatian Serbs declared independence.
22:36 The first shots of the Yugoslav Wars were about to be fired.
22:42 CONCLUSION In this first video on the Yugoslav Wars,
22:46 we tried to provide a brief political background of very complicated
22:51 processes that eventually led to wars in different parts of Yugoslavia.
22:55 The rise of Milošević riding the nationalist wave in Serbia,
22:59 the initial crisis in Kosovo,
23:01 Slovene and Croatian preparations for independence and war,
23:05 the Serb mobilisation in Croatia and the paralysis of federal structures,
23:10 which was unable to solve these problems,
23:13 snowballed into something truly horrifying.
23:16 In the next episode we will cover the start of the war in Croatia,
23:21 the Croatian and Slovene declarations of independence,
23:23 the Ten-Day War, and other important events
23:26 of the early stage of the Yugoslav Wars.
23:29 So if you don't want to miss it,
23:31 make sure you have subscribed and pressed the bell button.
23:34 Please consider liking, subscribing, commenting,
23:36 and sharing, it helps immensely.
23:38 Our patrons and YouTube members can watch more than 300 exclusive videos,
23:43 join their ranks via the link in the description or by pressing
23:47 the join button under the video to watch these weekly videos,
23:50 learn about our schedule, get early access to our videos,
23:54 access our private Discord, and much more.
23:56 This is the Kings and Generals channel, and we will catch you on the next one.