You Don’t Have to Solve Everything | Buddhist Wisdom
Einzelgänger
0:01 Imagine a bad-tempered man in a boat
0:04 colliding with another boat on a misty river.
0:07 If the other boat were empty,
0:10 he might be irritated, but probably not very angry.
0:13 But if there were another man in it, he might start shouting,
0:17 calling him an idiot and telling him to learn how to steer.
0:22 This comparison, found in the Taoist text Zhuangzi,
0:26 raises an interesting question:
0:29 If the impact of the collision is the same in both cases,
0:33 why does one provoke rage while the other barely bothers him?
0:38 Aside from the man in the boat,
0:41 difference is what the mind adds to the collision: a story about what happened:
0:46 that someone caused it, that he shouldn’t have done so,
0:50 that he’s inconsiderate, and that he needs to change his ways.
0:55 If you have an average human mind,
0:58 you may have noticed that it loves stirring the pot.
1:01 Wherever we go, wherever our boats
1:04 collide with reality (to follow Zhuangzi’s metaphor),
1:07 our minds seem eager to point out what’s wrong,
1:10 insisting that we cannot, for a moment, sit back, relax, and enjoy the journey.
1:16 Instead, they tell us to be outraged, afraid,
1:20 and ready to fix whatever problem has appeared.
1:23 Before we know it, life begins to feel like an endless stream of problems,
1:29 many of which disturb our peace of mind.
1:32 And because the mind keeps adding new concerns to the pile,
1:37 we become perpetual problem solvers,
1:40 often spending our lives feeling as though we’re carrying water in a sieve.
1:46 But what if many, if not most, of our problems don’t need to be solved?
1:52 This video explores the nature of what we consider everyday problems,
1:56 why we may be better off not solving them, and what to do instead.
2:01 My name is Stefan.
2:03 If you enjoy my work, you can subscribe to my newsletter on Substack.
2:08 You can also support me on both Patreon and YouTube,
2:11 and my books are available on Amazon.
2:15 Thank you, and I hope you’ll enjoy this video.
2:23 Many people experience life as an endless stream of problems to solve;
2:29 problems that just keep coming, never giving them a break.
2:33 For some, this becomes so overwhelming that they feel constantly overloaded,
2:39 often leading to anxiety, despair, or even anger.
2:44 Having a history of depression, I’m very prone to this.
2:47 I’m a massive overthinker, and I remember already being so as a child.
2:52 Many times in the past,
2:54 I’ve felt my troubles piling up faster than I could possibly deal with them.
2:58 It’s like a dark cloud slowly spreading across the sky,
3:02 until there’s barely enough light left to see where I might even begin.
3:07 The pressure was often overpowering, and I couldn’t see a way out.
3:12 Feeling swamped by problems isn’t very pleasant.
3:16 But in many cases, it’s also unnecessary.
3:20 Before we continue, let’s define ‘problem’ first.
3:24 Cambridge Dictionary defines ‘problem’ as “a situation, person,
3:28 or thing that needs attention and needs to be dealt
3:33 with or solved,” and Merriam-Webster offers a handful of descriptions,
3:37 such as “a question raised for inquiry, consideration,
3:41 or solution” and “a source of perplexity, distress, or vexation”.
3:47 Oxford Dictionary defines it as “a thing
3:50 that is difficult to deal with or to understand”.
3:54 In the ordinary sense of the word,
3:56 a problem is not merely a neutral situation to be dealt with.
4:00 It’s also something we experience as difficult, troubling, or distressing.
4:06 Hence, “talking about our problems” often
4:09 goes hand in hand with expressing discontent,
4:12 implying that what we’re talking about isn’t very good and needs addressing.
4:18 But this raises a question:
4:20 how does a situation become a problem in the first place?
4:24 What happens between something simply occurring
4:27 and our experiencing it as difficult, troubling, or needing resolution?
4:32 In Buddhism, there’s a concept called papañca in Pali, or prapañca in Sanskrit.
4:39 There’s no real consensus on how to translate it,
4:43 as the concept is notoriously difficult to define.
4:47 But terms such as mental proliferation, conceptual proliferation,
4:51 complication, elaboration, and objectification are often used.
4:57 Broadly speaking, papañca seems to describe
5:00 the mind’s tendency to expand on an experience,
5:03 generating interpretations, judgments, memories, fantasies,
5:08 theories, and other mental constructions.
5:11 Now, aren’t most of our problems the result of mental proliferation?
5:16 Aren’t they first and foremost stories created by the mind,
5:22 rather than the actual events they refer to?
5:25 In other words, aren’t we creating the problem by adding
5:30 our own narratives and judgments to an otherwise neutral world?
5:37 When we look at our own problems, we see they come in all sizes,
5:42 fragrances, and intensities, and they concern the past, present, and future.
5:46 When it comes to the past, we may experience a memory,
5:50 perhaps triggered by our surroundings,
5:53 which quickly evokes thoughts about that memory,
5:56 judgments about why that particular event was wrong, who was to blame,
6:01 and why we’re still suffering in the present because of it.
6:04 And before we know it,
6:06 we’ve written a whole novel in our heads about something that happened
6:09 back then that we now consider a problem to be solved.
6:13 When the past doesn’t give us something bitter to chew
6:17 on, there’s plenty of misery to be found in the present.
6:20 We may encounter something in the street that we don’t like:
6:24 someone acting very rudely or inconsiderately.
6:26 Instead of simply noticing it and letting it go,
6:30 we begin to create a whole narrative around this individual:
6:34 that society is getting worse,
6:36 that we’re witnessing an erosion of civility in the West,
6:40 that Europe is going down the drain.
6:42 So what began as a single encounter turns
6:45 into an ever-growing collection of problems bouncing around in our minds.
6:52 Many everyday occurrences also have the potential
6:54 to become problems in our minds,
6:56 such as a friend not responding to a text message,
6:59 a coworker who doesn’t like us,
7:01 someone expressing an absurd opinion, a brief feeling of loneliness,
7:05 looking in the mirror and noticing we’re getting older,
7:09 embarrassing ourselves— all these things can lead us to create
7:14 stories that occupy our minds for hours on end,
7:18 asking us to be dealt with in some way.
7:22 And then there’s the future.
7:24 Many of us are experts at navigating a future that, as we all know,
7:30 doesn’t even exist yet.
7:32 Suppose we have an important conversation coming up next week.
7:36 Nothing has happened yet,
7:37 but we’re already imagining everything that could go wrong:
7:41 what the other person might say,
7:43 how we might respond, whether we’ll say something stupid,
7:46 and what the consequences might be.
7:49 So, long before even a word is exchanged,
7:53 we’re already trying to solve a future that exists only in our imagination.
7:59 Whether it’s rumination on the past,
8:01 worry about the present, or catastrophic thinking about the future,
8:06 all these stories generate not-so-pleasant emotions,
8:09 from grief to anger, from anxiety to full-blown panic.
8:14 But as you probably have concluded, many of these mental proliferations
8:20 vary from superfluous to downright ridiculous.
8:23 They don’t benefit us in any way.
8:26 Yet, the mind keeps producing them,
8:29 like a problem machine that, in many cases, refuses to shut down.
8:34 It might do so to protect us, which is a nice gesture,
8:38 but it isn’t doing a very good job,
8:42 and it brings about a lot of emotional suffering as a byproduct.
8:46 Aside from generating problems,
8:48 there’s something else the mind is good at: solving problems.
8:57 When we’re drowning in problems, what else can we do but try to solve them?
9:02 After all, if we don’t tackle everything life throws at us,
9:06 how will we ever get out of this mess?
9:09 How will we ever get the break we feel we deserve?
9:13 The problem-solving part of the mind seems to work like a hammer:
9:18 whatever it encounters begins to look like a nail that needs to be struck.
9:23 A memory, an awkward interaction, an unanswered message,
9:27 something a family member could say in the future…
9:30 each can quickly become another problem to solve.
9:33 We imagine that once all the nails have been hammered
9:37 in, we’ll finally be able to sit back and relax,
9:41 like carpenters at the end of a long day.
9:44 However, as you may have noticed, the mind keeps producing new nails to pound.
9:50 We’re like Hercules chopping off Hydra’s heads, only for them to grow back.
9:55 And so, our efforts never seem to bring us any closer to the finish line.
10:01 There is always something else to reconsider,
10:03 anticipate, correct, understand, or resolve.
10:07 In that sense, solving never really solves it.
10:12 We’re basically mopping the floor with the tap still running.
10:15 And for many of us, this is what life feels like from dawn to dusk:
10:20 trying to address one problem after another, yet still feeling overwhelmed.
10:25 And here we see the diabolical situation a restless,
10:29 discursive mind puts itself in: it creates the very
10:33 issues it is so anxious to get rid of.
10:37 It is both the arsonist and the firefighter.
10:41 So, while we’re busy putting out fires, we’re starting new ones all around us.
10:46 Sure, for some this might be a nice form of occupational therapy,
10:51 but for most of us (for me, at least) it’s not a pleasant way to live.
10:58 Luckily, there’s another way of dealing
11:00 with the problems that arise in our minds.
11:03 Instead of buying a better mop or hiring
11:06 a cleaning crew to deal with the unending stream,
11:09 we could simply turn off the tap.
11:15 Returning to the Taoist example of the boat:
11:18 not every collision needs to make the front page,
11:22 becoming the subject of outrage, analysis, and possible solutions.
11:26 Likewise, not every thought or situation we encounter
11:30 needs to become an issue that demands our attention.
11:34 It’s important to distinguish between mental
11:37 proliferations that pose as problems and things
11:40 we actually need to do in order to prevent unwanted trouble later on.
11:45 We need to pay our electricity bills to keep the lights
11:49 on, pay our rent to keep a roof over our heads,
11:52 and take our medication to treat an illness.
11:55 These are practical issues with relatively straightforward solutions.
12:00 Of course, some of these problems can become more serious and immediate,
12:04 and really need our attention, preferably from a place of calm.
12:08 But as we’ve discussed earlier, many of the things we consider problems,
12:14 things that genuinely feel like problems, are largely stories.
12:20 They may be rooted in real events and situations,
12:23 but much of their content is made up:
12:26 exaggerated versions of what happened, misinterpretations of reality,
12:30 or even complete fantasies, and all the judgments we attach to them.
12:36 These are the narratives we construct around events in the past,
12:40 present, and future.
12:41 And even though the mind can’t wait to solve whatever it insists needs solving,
12:46 we could ask ourselves: Do we really need to?
12:50 Do we really need to ‘solve’ a coworker who doesn’t like us?
12:54 Do we really need to solve every disagreement?
12:57 Do we really need to ‘solve’ the fact
12:59 that others are doing better than us in their careers
13:03 or that people we don’t even know might judge
13:06 us for not living up to the societal ideal?
13:09 Do we need to do something about every piece of bad news,
13:15 every opinion, every comment, every potential threat we encounter in the media?
13:20 Do we need to find closure for every old regret,
13:24 or set right every past mistake?
13:27 Are all these things truly the problem?
13:31 Or is the real problem the mind’s endless proliferation around them—
13:36 the narratives about why all these things or people are horrible,
13:40 how things could and should have been different,
13:43 and how everything only gets worse?
13:46 Is ‘the problem’ the problem?
13:48 And if so, instead of trying to solve all these apparent issues one by one,
13:54 wouldn’t we be better off addressing the root of it all:
13:58 the mind that keeps manufacturing story after story?
14:02 Wouldn’t we be better off turning off the tap?
14:07 So, how do we turn off the tap?
14:09 How do we put an end to this endless
14:12 generation of thoughts and stories about the past, present, and future?
14:17 Maybe the Buddha’s surprisingly simple reminder is exactly what we need:
14:23 You shouldn’t chase after the past or place expectations on the future.
14:29 What is past is left behind.
14:31 The future is as yet unreached.
14:34 Whatever quality is present, you clearly see right there, right there.
14:40 The “right there, right there” speaks to me.
14:44 What truly matters is what’s right here, as it is,
14:48 in the present— not what we’ve constructed in our minds.
14:52 Simply put, the Buddha teaches us
14:55 not to keep feeding these mental proliferations,
14:58 not to welcome them, cling to them, or relish them.
15:02 What remains is simply what is, right there.
15:05 The man in the boat is a man in a boat.
15:10 There’s no need to make him into anything more.
15:15 The burden of a haunting past that should have been different,
15:18 a present that seems too full of trouble to endure,
15:22 and a future that looks too intimidating and bleak
15:26 to face is simply too much to bear.
15:29 At least for me, trying to carry it all has often made me miserable.
15:35 We don’t need an inner agitator constantly pulling us down into the flames
15:39 of suffering and depriving us of the lightness
15:43 that comes with an unencumbered mind.
15:45 What we need is equanimity in a world already challenging enough on its own.
15:56 Thank you for watching.