Nothing Headphone 1 Pro: They Copied the Wrong Thing!

Nothing Headphone 1 Pro: They Copied the Wrong Thing!

Marques Brownlee

0:02 So Nothing, the company,

0:04 Nothing has decided to jump into the ring of super-premium,

0:08 $400 plus dollar, active noise-canceling headphones.

0:11 And this is where the heavy hitters have lived for years!

0:15 The Sony Mark 6s, the Bose QuietComfort Ultras,

0:17 the new Beats 360s, the AirPods Max of course.

0:19 The type of headphones where you literally just wanna have the best

0:23 of the best and you can't really have any major flaws anymore.

0:26 So these new Nothing Headphone 1 Pros are $400!

0:29 It's the most expensive headphones they've ever tried to sell.

0:33 It's got pro in the name and everything.

0:35 So, all right!

0:36 You wanna play with the big dogs, you're gonna get tested like the big dogs.

0:41 So honestly, I do think they get a lot of things right with these.

0:44 Okay, so they've made other headphones in the past

0:47 that I've reviewed and they've always been design-focused.

0:49 And they've introduced some new features that are genuinely

0:52 really nice for these pros that match the name.

0:55 But they also unfortunately make one huge mistake

0:57 by copying the wrong thing from the competition.

1:00 And so we'll get to that shortly too.

1:02 But I do feel like since they're Nothing headphones,

1:04 I kind of have to start with the design, and so I will!

1:07 And I actually love the design of these headphones.

1:08 They're like an evolution of the other Nothing products, but even better.

1:13 So it keeps the cassette tape square shape and of course the transparent

1:16 aesthetic that's become basically a Nothing trademark over the past few years,

1:20 and then just kind of tweaks and refines it in little ways.

1:23 Materials are all premium everywhere you touch!

1:26 The ear and the headband cushions are super, super soft!

1:29 It's aluminum frames, titanium arms,

1:31 and then it's 9H Panda Glass on these sides to see inside.

1:34 And that's actually not the drivers you're looking at from the outside.

1:38 It's just kind of a cool look,

1:39 in my opinion, that kind of resembles the speaker drivers.

1:42 But yeah, it's a cool shape!

1:44 It's got textures and text and everything!

1:45 The only thing that annoys me is how easily this glass gathers fingerprints,

1:48 because it does gather a lot of fingerprints very easily.

1:51 That annoys me to no end.

1:52 I also don't think it's too heavy.

1:54 It is on the heavier side and I I definitely

1:56 would have liked it to be a little bit lighter.

1:58 And if they used more plastic, it would have been lighter.

2:01 But these weigh somewhere in between.

2:02 Their all-plastic competition, but less than the AirPods Max.

2:06 Like, AirPods Max are ridiculously heavy.

2:07 I guess it's not saying much to be

2:09 lighter than those, but they're somewhere in between.

2:11 Still has the red box on the right side.

2:13 R for red, R for right.

2:15 It's clever!

2:15 Uh...

2:16 and then on the back of the right-hand side,

2:18 you always have the rocker and the roller.

2:21 Huh?

2:21 Rocker and roller.

2:22 Uh...

2:22 that I think are the best physical controls in the headphone space still.

2:26 Like, headphones are blind.

2:28 so since you're wearing them on your head, you can't see the controls.

2:32 And these are dang near perfect.

2:34 You can always quickly identify them.

2:36 The roller up top, you move forward or backwards

2:38 to roll up or roll down the volume.

2:40 And it's also a button that you can press once to play/pause,

2:43 or long press to turn ANC on and off.

2:45 And it's super easy to find with your thumb.

2:47 Then under it is a sort of flipper!

2:49 They call it a paddle.

2:50 And it's a forward track or backward track button.

2:53 And you can even scrub forward or backward through some

2:55 media apps if you press and hold, which is cool.

2:58 And then there's a single button on the outside of the right

3:01 ear cup that just triggers your voice assistant by default.

3:03 The more hidden buttons on the inside of the cups

3:06 are the Bluetooth pairing button on the right side,

3:08 which makes sense, you probably only need that once or twice.

3:11 And then on the other side is a new button up at the top left here,

3:14 it's just a switch that says flat.

3:16 And this here is very interesting,

3:18 honestly, probably its most interesting feature.

3:20 See, I'm about to talk about sound quality,

3:23 but also with headphones, just like any other product,

3:25 you do have to think about the target

3:27 demographic for that product as you evaluate it.

3:30 So like, if I'm reviewing the Sennheiser HD 600s,

3:33 I'm trying to figure out how neutral and how

3:35 flat that sound signature is when you actually go

3:38 in to use them and you can actually appreciate

3:40 your mix and hear everything the way it's supposed to sound.

3:43 But if I'm reviewing the Beats 360s, I'm actually trying to figure out how good

3:47 do they sound listening to music or watching movies,

3:50 or canceling out the sound from the airplane

3:52 that you're on when you're listening to them.

3:54 Those are two totally different sound signatures,

3:57 two totally different experiences, but they're both headphones!

4:00 So these Nothing Headphones Pro are attempting to give you both.

4:05 They of course have their out-of-the-box, baked-in sound,

4:07 which you can of course adjust with the EQ,

4:09 but they're also giving you this flat EQ switch,

4:12 which they're saying totally cuts all audio processing and coloration

4:16 for when you need to hear the original track without any enhancements.

4:19 And that to me specifically is a very interesting idea,

4:23 maybe applies directly to me because I'll often,

4:26 you know, get on a plane or train and go to an event to make a video.

4:29 Oftentimes, the same pair of headphones that would be

4:32 really good for listening to music on the plane

4:35 is not the exact same pair of headphones

4:37 that would be best for editing the video.

4:40 But what if one pair of headphones could do both?

4:43 So Nothing has...

4:43 dropped the KEF Audio partnership from their last headphones,

4:47 which honestly, great!

4:48 And they've actually moved to a triple-driver setup.

4:51 So there's now three drivers in each headphone instead of one.

4:55 Which sounds like an automatic upgrade, but not necessarily.

4:58 It's kind of like the megapixel number in cameras.

5:01 Like, is the 200-megapixel camera

5:04 guaranteed better than the 48-megapixel camera?

5:07 No, of course not!

5:08 But if you made a chart, there's probably some...

5:11 slight positive correlation.

5:13 I just remember when I first started getting into in-ear monitors,

5:17 getting introduced to these 64 Audio IEMs

5:20 that had like 18 drivers in them or something, which just sounds ridiculous!

5:23 It was crazy to see!

5:25 But this isn't their flagships and it's not

5:28 necessarily the best to have a ton of drivers!

5:30 But the idea is that each individual driver can sort

5:33 of better specialize at certain sections of the frequency response range.

5:38 So with these triple drivers, nothing is saying that there's one big bass driver

5:43 that can handle 10 Hz up to 10 kHz.

5:46 Then there's a mid-sized precision driver that does 5 kHz to 15 kHz,

5:50 and then the treble driver does 10 kHz all the way up to the top at 40 kHz.

5:55 So— how do these things sound?

5:57 Well, big picture, I do think they sound really fun!

6:00 They are a classic, very V-shaped EQ with plenty

6:03 of bass and pretty distinct mids and bright highs.

6:06 They have the whole range.

6:08 There's an overall pretty colorful sound.

6:10 I would say the two biggest weaknesses for me were...

6:13 punchiness and the precision of the bass and instrument separation.

6:17 So it's not that they're lacking bass, there's still plenty of it.

6:20 It's just that it's not as responsive, it's not as punchy as I was hoping...

6:24 It's kind of like hitting a drum with a mitten over it.

6:26 It's just a little bit less impact.

6:28 But then the instrument separation is really the big one.

6:31 Like, I did a lot of back-to-back listening with these, with the Sony XM6s,

6:34 and with AirPods Max, and these sounded by far the most,

6:37 like, muddied together of all the different sounds.

6:40 Again, it's a subtle thing.

6:41 Like, there's.

6:42 There's all sorts of different instruments and sounds that you like

6:45 to be able to pick out and hear as you're listening.

6:48 And if you're paying this much, you like to be able to do that.

6:51 And this was the weakest at that.

6:53 So if the big dogs are like at a 9 with overall sound quality,

6:57 then these are punching at like a 7, almost a 7.

7:00 But then there's the flat switch, right?

7:02 So when you flip to flat, it removes the processing.

7:05 The EQ is literally disabled.

7:07 And so the sound completely changes in character.

7:09 It goes from that V-shape to this pretty respectably neutral version of.

7:14 With way less contrast, way less bass.

7:16 This also removes the option for transparency mode,

7:18 but you can still have noise cancellation on while flat.

7:21 And this is so...

7:22 interesting, even flipping back and forth between flat and not flat.

7:26 I know you're not meant to flip back and forth between them,

7:29 like, all the time, but you can do that mid-song.

7:31 And it's just.

7:32 It's like...

7:33 watching a video with a Rec.

7:35 709 LUT on it and then switching to watching in Log and suddenly

7:38 uncovering all this extra detail that you weren't really meant to see,

7:42 but in all the shadows and all the highlights.

7:44 And then flipping it back to the LUT and it looks finished again.

7:47 It looks fun again.

7:48 And I actually did find that I enjoyed listening to some music...

7:52 more in flat mode.

7:54 It's possibly because I'm so used to listening

7:55 to the HD600s and that's like the signature...

7:58 I'm most comfortable with.

7:59 Maybe that's why.

8:01 But there was overall just more evenness to everything.

8:04 Instead of the V-shape, I felt like I was hearing more.

8:07 And...

8:07 that was interesting to see.

8:09 But even without that flat processing removal switch,

8:11 the new EQ in the Nothing app is also...

8:13 way more powerful as far as adjusting exactly the way it sounds.

8:17 So it still maxes out at eight bands, but it now lets you...

8:20 You can choose exactly what frequency each point is at.

8:23 And lets you get really granular with exactly how wide each

8:25 band is and how much you want to change each piece here...

8:28 Plus, there's a whole bunch more custom EQ presets you

8:31 can load up for all different genres and listening experiences.

8:34 So it's just really good stuff in here for audio enthusiasts to explore...

8:38 dialing in exactly how these sound.

8:39 The noise cancellation part though is actually I think my favorite part.

8:44 It's nice, it's smooth.

8:46 These for some reason remove more of the, like, mid-frequency, like,

8:51 office-type sounds like keyboards and voices and, like,

8:54 chairs and furniture moving...

8:56 than AirPods Max or Sonys without being uncomfortable.

8:59 like, I feel like when you turn the ANC way,

9:01 way up, sometimes it gets a little bit much.

9:03 But these do a good job of removing that stuff and not being harsh.

9:07 Hey, okay, editor Marques here...

9:09 It turns out it's because of the seal.

9:10 It's because these cushions are actually really good.

9:13 They do an amazing job of canceling out some of those faster,

9:16 quicker sounds like voices and keyboards than the software would have.

9:20 Now, are they as good as the Sonys overall?

9:22 No.

9:23 But if the Sonys are a 9 in ANC,

9:25 then these are close to an 8, which is better than expected.

9:27 Also, this is what it would sound like if I got

9:30 on a call with you and I was using these headphones...

9:32 as my microphone.

9:33 There's like 10 mics all around these for ANC,

9:36 but perfectly average sounding voice if you ask me...

9:39 And then the transparency mode, which comes with noise-canceling headphones...

9:43 is improved quite a bit, too.

9:45 I really didn't like the ones from the last generation,

9:48 but these do a good job of sounding way less muffled

9:50 and way less like talking into a can or like a sweater...

9:53 and more...

9:54 like real.

9:54 So I don't feel the need to take off the headphones

9:57 when talking to people as much as I did before.

9:59 That's good, a a good threshold to cross.

10:01 And they've got a lot of those little things,

10:03 you know, they connect via Bluetooth 6.1.

10:06 So they do the fast pairing thing.

10:07 They do support multipoint again,

10:09 so you can have two different devices connected at once.

10:12 So for the rest of you,

10:13 Android phone and MacBook at the same time freaks like me, these handle that.

10:17 No problem.

10:18 Battery life is also still excellent.

10:20 Technically down-rated a little bit from the last ones,

10:22 but well over 30 hours of active noise cancellation listening,

10:25 so that's plenty for me.

10:26 I'm never going to wear these for that that long.

10:28 They're great for traveling.

10:29 And then they are IP52 rated so you can work out

10:32 in them and sweat in them if you really want to.

10:35 I wouldn't, me personally,

10:36 but I have also seen people go running in AirPods Max, so...

10:40 clearly that's not stopping anyone.

10:42 So...

10:42 yeah, go right ahead.

10:43 But they did do one stupid thing.

10:45 They did one, one really, really, really dumb thing.

10:49 and that's this case.

10:53 This.

10:55 This is the dumbest...

10:57 This is the worst case I've ever seen...

10:59 with headphones...

11:00 Weirdly, like, for such a good rest of the...

11:02 What were they thinking with this?

11:04 Actually, I have a theory about what they were thinking.

11:06 I think they saw the AirPods Max case...

11:08 and thought we should do that.

11:11 But way worse.

11:12 These headphones still don't fold...

11:15 So you take them off, then you have to flip them over,

11:18 and then they go in this hard shell plastic case like this, which is...

11:22 so bad.

11:23 What is this?

11:24 You want your $400 headphones in this cheap,

11:26 fingerprinty plastic shell that clamps shut like a cheap Lego set or something?

11:31 And on top of that, by the way, it's not even really very well-built.

11:35 Like, it's only been a week of me using these and I'm

11:38 already seeing a little bit of wiggle on this weird plastic hinge.

11:40 This just does not seem very durable.

11:42 And there's no pass-through at all to charge the headphones.

11:44 So at least, at least Apple thought of that and cut

11:47 out a little flap to plug the headphones in...

11:50 These are a hard shell that you lock shut,

11:52 so you have to open them just to charge them...

11:54 Who thought of this?

11:55 At least with the previous case, they were like fully enclosed,

11:59 so I know they didn't fold also, but at least they're protected.

12:02 This...

12:03 now leaves the top band unprotected now voluntarily.

12:06 So when you try to put it in your bag or something, it will just catch on stuff.

12:10 And I don't know, man.

12:12 I really cannot find one nice thing to say about this case.

12:16 You can attach lanyard...

12:18 stuff to the side...

12:19 for like keychains and stuff, I guess.

12:24 This has almost ruined the headphones for me.

12:26 Honestly, this is so bad.

12:27 I don't know why they did this.

12:29 It's kind of like the Magic Mouse charging

12:32 situation where we can all admit it's bad...

12:34 and it's just whether we choose to allow it to ruin it for us,

12:38 that's the question.

12:39 But look, one pair of headphones that can pull double duty as a fun...

12:42 fun listening pair of headphones with decent bass and a huge

12:45 range of EQ customization for music listening and movie watching.

12:49 And then flip a switch and turn into my editing

12:51 headphones when I need to do some more critical listening.

12:54 That is compelling.

12:55 It's definitely not a need most people have with their headphones.

12:57 But also, hey, it's right there in the name Pro...

13:00 we're not all pros, but pros might like that.

13:02 But another one of my golden rules in tech is

13:05 that 2-in-1 devices are rarely actually good at both things.

13:08 They're usually, in fact, a little bit worse at each thing...

13:11 to combine them.

13:12 So like a 2-in-1 laptop is usually a slightly worse laptop than

13:15 a dedicated laptop and a slightly worse tablet than a dedicated tablet.

13:19 And so for the headphones, it's still true.

13:21 Like, you probably don't need one pair

13:23 of headphones that does both of these things.

13:25 And if you focus on just getting like a good-sounding pair of headphones,

13:28 you can get better-sounding stuff for this price...

13:31 The Sony stuff, hell, Sony just basically re-released the Mark 4s,

13:34 since everybody loved those so much.

13:35 And I'm seeing them on Amazon right now for like three,

13:38 300 bucks right now, not 400...

13:40 Those are better headphones.

13:42 They sound better.

13:43 The ANC is better...

13:44 They fold up.

13:44 But if you need reference headphones, of course,

13:46 there's a thousand neutral pairs you can find for under 400 bucks.

13:49 But the strength of these...

13:51 is giving you a switch to flip between

13:54 a decent version of both of those types of headphones.

13:57 And a pretty nice design and great controls too...

14:00 They're not perfect, but I respect the execution.

14:04 I do not respect the case at all, but I respect everything else.

14:08 These are pretty cool.

14:09 Good use of the word Pro.

14:11 Thanks for watching...

14:12 Catch you guys in the next one...

14:14 Peace.

Study with Looplines Download Captions Watch on YouTube