Why the Pope Stayed Silent - Vatican Wouldn’t Condemn Hitler
Kings and Generals
0:05 A lot has been written and said about the Second World War.
0:09 Still, even an event as epic in its impact on human history
0:14 as the most destructive war ever fought
0:16 is inevitably going to have less-discussed subjects.
0:19 And the place of the Vatican in the Second World War is one of them.
0:25 At the head of the largest religion in the world,
0:28 the leader of the Catholic Church has wielded immense spiritual power
0:32 over the lives of hundreds of millions of people for centuries,
0:37 but how was this spiritual power utilized
0:39 during the single bloodiest conflict in human history?
0:43 In this video, we will talk about the cautious, yet controversial,
0:47 diplomacy of the Holy See and Pope Pius XII during the Second World War.
1:32 CONTEXT By the interregnum years of the 1930s,
1:40 the Vatican was far from the geopolitical and cultural force it used to be.
1:45 It still exerted a significant influence
1:47 over Catholic Christians throughout the world.
1:50 Still, its impact on politics had become much smaller than
1:53 it had been during the Middle Ages and the Renaissance.
1:56 The 20th century was the time of massive armies and monumental conflict,
2:01 which dwarfed whatever soft power the Holy See had at that point.
2:05 Perhaps the best way to illustrate the mismatch
2:08 between the Vatican and the global powers
2:11 fighting for ideological and military supremacy is
2:14 to mention the quote attributed to Joseph Stalin,
2:18 said to Churchill during the Potsdam Conference:
2:20 “How many divisions did you say the Pope has?” However, on the eve of the war,
2:26 the Vatican was quite active trying to bring the emerging
2:30 blocs to the table to avoid another conflict in Europe.
2:34 In addition, it was also taking steps to prevent the persecution of Catholics.
2:39 In 1933, Pope Pius XI signed a concordat with Nazi Germany in 1933,
2:44 giving legitimacy to Hitler to safeguard the Catholic minority in Germany.
2:48 However, when the Nazi regime launched a campaign
2:51 of persecution against Catholic clergy in the 1930s,
2:55 the Pope delivered an encyclical called Mit brennender Sorge- meaning ‘With deep
3:00 anxiety.’ This encyclical was to be
3:03 read by Catholic priests to their congregations,
3:06 and disseminating it was quite a courageous step to take by the Pope,
3:10 which nevertheless caused only further repressions against the clergy.
3:14 Pius XI was also critical of antisemitic laws adopted by Italy in 1938.
3:20 Mussolini, who was not a big fan of criticism,
3:22 had no choice but to put up with the pesky Pope,
3:26 who was revered by millions of Italians.
3:28 Mussolini was happy when Pius XI passed away and was succeeded by Pius XII,
3:34 who was known for his cautious character and unwillingness to rock the boat.
3:40 The new Pope saw the Holy See as a neutral force
3:43 for good in a Europe where the clouds of war were already gathering.
3:47 Pius XII considered it important to maintain
3:50 good relations with all European powers, including the Nazi Germany,
3:53 to have a chance at engaging in diplomacy
3:56 with them and protect Catholics from suffering.
3:59 Thus, he refused to condemn the German assault on Czechoslovakia.
4:03 Instead, he worked behind the scenes to organize a peace conference in France,
4:08 Germany, England, Italy, and Poland.
4:10 The French saw it as a concerted effort between Italy
4:13 and the Vatican to force them into concessions in North Africa,
4:18 while Mussolini resented the protagonism of the Pope.
4:21 Hence, the initiative failed.
4:23 Here, Germany also stood with its Italian allies, but at the same time,
4:28 Hitler was keen to improve relations with the Holy See.
4:31 Hitler had a secret envoy to the Vatican
4:34 by the name of Prince Philipp von Hessen, who met with Pius XII several times.
4:39 This became known only after the archives of Pius XII were opened.
4:43 The talks mostly focused on the treatment of Catholic Germans
4:46 by the Nazi regime and both sides said nice things to each other,
4:51 but when the Second World War started in September 1939, the priorities shifted.
4:56 THE START OF THE WAR.
4:58 POLISH QUESTION After occupying Czechoslovakia in 1938,
5:01 Hitler’s attention was now on Poland.
5:02 The question of the port city of Danzig was
5:05 one of the main points of contention between the sides.
5:09 In his very cautious diplomatic style,
5:11 Pius XII preferred to call the Germans to calmness not directly,
5:15 but through their Italian allies.
5:17 At the same time, the Pope urged the Polish
5:20 leaders to consider a compromise to avoid war.
5:22 Of course, Poland rejected any compromise,
5:24 while the French calls to the Pope to make
5:27 a public declaration in support of Catholic Poland went unfulfilled too.
5:32 The Pontiff sympathized with the Poles,
5:35 but he did not issue a condemnation even after the war started.
5:39 Pius XII even refused to accept the phrase “the Pope has blessed Poland”
5:44 being published in the press in fear of reprisals against Catholics in Germany.
5:49 The only public manifestation of the Vatican’s
5:51 opposition to Hitler’s war of aggression at its initial stage was the criticism
5:57 by the Holy See-owned newspaper L’Osservatore Romano,
6:00 which caused friction with the Mussolini government
6:03 and Pius XII’s first encyclical Summi Pontificatus,
6:07 which called for the unity of mankind and condemned
6:11 the elevation of the State into the place of God.
6:14 Some saw this as a criticism of Germany and the Soviet Union,
6:18 but it was far from the overt condemnation that many expected.
6:21 Not that it would have changed anything at this point,
6:25 as Germany and its new Soviet ally completely overwhelmed Poland.
6:30 As previously mentioned, Hitler’s personal envoy had developed a rapport
6:33 with the Pope by the early stages of the war,
6:37 and both sides continued to pursue bettering
6:39 relations with one another as the war continued.
6:42 For the Vatican, the goal was to persuade
6:44 the Nazis from further oppressing the Catholic Church in Germany,
6:48 while also maintaining the functioning channels of communication.
6:52 For Hitler, the goal was arguably to minimize any risk
6:55 of trouble coming from the Catholics in Germany and recently occupied countries,
7:00 along with further increasing his legitimacy by leveraging good
7:04 relations with such a powerful institution like the Church.
7:08 At one point, Hitler decided to send his foreign minister,
7:11 Ribbentrop, to meet with the Pope, which indicated that he thought that having
7:15 good relations with the Church was important.
7:18 Pius XII asked the Germans to stop anti-Church activities
7:22 as a means to create fruitful conditions for cordial talks.
7:25 Upon the Pope’s insistence, the meeting with Ribbentrop was going to be secret.
7:29 Again, the protocol of the meeting shows that the Pope’s
7:33 main focus was the well-being of Catholics in Germany
7:36 and Austria rather than calling Ribbentrop to stop the war
7:39 or take measures to decrease the suffering of civilians.
7:43 THE WESTERN FRONT.
7:44 ITALY AT WAR Meanwhile, the German army was marching through Europe
7:47 and turning its attention to the western front.
7:50 At this point, Italy had still not entered the war,
7:53 as Mussolini and his generals were aware
7:55 of the shortcomings of the Italian army.
7:58 The Italian dictator initially preferred to wait and see what happened.
8:02 Still, as the Germans clearly had the upper hand,
8:05 Mussolini itched to join his ally Hitler,
8:07 thinking that they would win the war rather quickly.
8:10 At this point, Pius XII felt that his main
8:12 mission was to stop Italy from entering the war.
8:15 However, all the back-room diplomacy and telegrams sent
8:18 by the Pope did nothing to dissuade Mussolini from this.
8:22 The situation got worse when Germany invaded Belgium,
8:26 the Netherlands and France.
8:27 It is reported that the Pope was aware of Hitler’s
8:30 intention to start a western offensive through his German contacts,
8:34 and the Vatican sent coded messages to the Church in Belgium
8:38 and the Netherlands to warn these countries about the imminent invasion.
8:42 Up until then, the Vatican did its utmost to avoid angering Germany and Italy,
8:48 both to not risk their ability to operate
8:51 while surrounded by Mussolini’s fascist regime and to maintain
8:54 the illusion that the Holy See could act as a neutral mediator in this war.
8:59 However, the invasion of these three countries finally
9:02 prompted the Pope to speak publicly and relatively openly.
9:05 He sent public telegrams published on the front page of the L’Osservatore
9:09 Romano newspaper of the Holy See to leaders of France,
9:12 Belgium and the Netherlands, expressing his sympathy and lamenting
9:15 the expansion of war onto their territories.
9:18 Yet once again, Pius XII avoided placing blame on the aggressor,
9:23 which created an uncomfortable situation for him.
9:26 On the one hand, Mussolini was angry at this public
9:29 display of opposition to war in the middle of Italy.
9:33 His son-in-law and foreign minister, Ciano,
9:35 noted in his diary that Mussolini “often repeats that the papacy
9:39 is a cancer that eats away at our national life,
9:43 and that he intends- if necessary- to liquidate this problem once and for all”.
9:49 On the other hand, the attacked countries were
9:52 unhappy with the timid nature of the telegrams,
9:54 urging the Pope to condemn and denounce the Nazis.
9:58 There was hope that an open condemnation of the Nazi
10:01 invasion would dissuade Mussolini from joining the war.
10:05 Unfortunately, the rapid Nazi advance
10:07 and the Pope’s unwillingness to alienate Germans
10:10 and Italians further meant that the Vatican
10:12 was not going to condemn the invasion.
10:15 Pius XII remarked that: “I am profoundly and firmly
10:18 convinced that I have done my precise duty, taking care not to offend anyone,
10:24 avoiding any particular references, indeed,
10:27 studiously taking care to say the least possible.” The German
10:33 success was the final argument Mussolini needed to join the war.
10:37 On June 10, 1940, Il Duce announced that Italy had joined
10:41 the war against Britain and France to a cheering crowd in Rome.
10:46 All the Pope was able to do was keep the Roman church bells silent,
10:50 contrary to Mussolini’s expectations.
10:52 Meanwhile, Italian Catholic organizations and the press threw
10:56 their support behind Mussolini and the Italian Army,
11:00 while L’Osservatore Romano was ordered by the Pope
11:03 to avoid antagonizing the Italian government.
11:06 The Pope himself called on the Italian Catholics to obey the authorities.
11:11 Although Pius XII never openly supported the Italian participation in the war,
11:15 he feared that any public condemnation would prompt
11:18 a violent reaction by the Fascist government against the Vatican.
11:22 On the other hand, the Church and the Pope were revered by Italians,
11:27 so any state attack on the Vatican would
11:30 have been an extremely risky endeavour for Mussolini.
11:32 Thus, both sides preferred to maintain
11:35 a delicate balance instead of taking risky steps.
11:40 Immediately after Italy’s entrance into the war, Britain started bombing it.
11:44 Italy’s outdated air force and air defence were no match for the RAF bombers,
11:49 which bombarded Italian cities throughout the war with near impunity.
11:53 For a while, Rome was spared,
11:55 both for its cultural significance and in order not to alienate Catholics.
12:00 Yet in 1943, the war came to Italy with the Allied invasion.
12:04 As Rome was one of the logistical centers of the Italian military,
12:08 the question of targeting the capital for bombing re-emerged.
12:11 Throughout the war, the Pontiff was very active
12:14 in trying to prevent the bombing of Rome.
12:16 Pius XII appealed to Roosevelt through secret
12:18 messages and via his envoy to the Vatican,
12:21 Myron Taylor, to continue sparing Rome.
12:24 Churchill had no sympathy for this request of the Vatican,
12:28 since he argued that the Pope never protested
12:31 the bombing of London and other British cities,
12:33 but the Allies still agreed to target Rome only in daylight
12:36 and as far from the Vatican as possible to avoid damaging it.
12:41 In 1943, the Allies started bombing the Eternal City,
12:45 causing significant destruction, including to the Basilica of Saint Lawrence.
12:49 So, even though the Pope’s opposition to the bombing
12:52 of Rome arguably prevented a more widespread destruction,
12:55 the military consideration of the allies outweighed his actions.
13:00 But by the time the Allied invasion of Italy had become imminent,
13:04 Mussolini’s fascist regime was already crumbling.
13:06 Part of the Fascist elite, the military establishment,
13:10 and the wealthiest businessmen were looking for a way out.
13:14 Simultaneously, the Allies were looking for political
13:16 ways to get Italy out of the war.
13:18 Both saw the Italian king Victor Emmanuel III as a person who
13:23 could depose Mussolini and sign a separate peace treaty with the Allies.
13:27 At the same time, both saw the Pope as the person
13:30 who could persuade a frail but stubborn king to agree.
13:34 The pope’s representative met with the king to discuss these matters,
13:38 but Victor Emmanuel III refused to take any action.
13:41 HOLOCAUST Of course,
13:43 the question that looms large when talking about the Vatican and World War 2
13:47 is the reaction of the Holy See to the persecution of Jews in Europe.
13:52 The Catholic Church throughout history has played
13:54 a significant role in discrimination of the Jewish people,
13:58 but one wonders whether the scale of tragedy unfolding in Europe forced
14:02 the Vatican to take any steps to protect the Jews from the Nazis.
14:08 In 1938, Italy adopted the so-called racial law,
14:11 which gave the persecution of a small
14:14 Jewish minority in the country a systemic character.
14:17 Unlike Nazi Germany, Fascist Italy did not aim to eradicate Italian Jews,
14:22 but oppressed them in many other ways.
14:25 They were stripped of their property, prevented from travelling abroad,
14:29 and forbidden from being employed in banking, education and public service.
14:33 Jewish people fleeing the German occupation in Austria and Czechoslovakia,
14:37 who found refuge in Italy, were forced into concentration camps.
14:41 As the war went on, the restrictions and persecution got worse.
14:46 Many Italian Jews tried to escape this discrimination by getting baptized,
14:51 hoping that the Catholic Church would save them.
14:54 And indeed, Pius XII and the Church urged
14:57 Mussolini to refrain from targeting converted Jewish people,
15:01 since according to the Catholic doctrine, once someone is baptized,
15:04 they are Catholic and are under the protection of the Church.
15:08 Nevertheless, the Fascist leader refused this advocacy attempt by the Pope.
15:13 The pontiff’s policy was the same with regard
15:15 to the racial laws of Vichy France.
15:17 He did not oppose them explicitly, but tried to save baptized Jewish people.
15:23 But what about the Pope’s attitude towards the Nazi-perpetrated Holocaust?
15:28 The first indication of the pontiff’s knowledge
15:30 of the systematic extermination of Europe’s Jews was a journal
15:34 note written by his envoy to Turkey
15:37 in October 1941 about his meeting with Pius XII,
15:40 where they discussed the Nazis’ actions in Europe.
15:43 Around the same time the nuncio in Bratislava, Giuseppe Barzio,
15:47 informed the Holy See about the German army
15:51 systematically murdering the Jewish people in occupied areas.
15:54 In November 1941, the Pope heard about the mass extermination of Jews
15:59 by the Germans in the Soviet Union
16:01 from an Italian military chaplain Father Pirro Scavizzi.
16:05 The priest recalled seeing the Pope “cry like a child
16:08 and pray like a saint” in reaction to this report.
16:11 In their meeting on January 9, 1942, the Pope told Scavizzi that he had
16:17 considered excommunicating perpetrators of the most heinous atrocities,
16:21 but ultimately decided against it.
16:24 His argument was that proclamation of excommunication would
16:27 only make it worse for the Jewish people.
16:30 Scavizzi also urged the Pope to publish
16:33 evidence of atrocities in L’Osservatore Romano,
16:35 but Pius XII feared angering Hitler and Mussolini.
16:39 At times, Catholic priests decided to take matters
16:43 into their own hands and dared to stand up to dictators,
16:47 asking them to stop mass murder.
16:50 The pope’s nuncio in Bratislava met with the fellow Catholic Josef Tiso,
16:54 the dictator of the Slovak republic and Nazi puppet.
16:57 When Tiso ordered the deportation of Slovak Jews to death camps,
17:02 the nuncio urged him to reconsider,
17:04 but Tiso went along with his heinous plan to please Hitler.
17:09 Reports of atrocities kept coming to Rome as the war went on, as did
17:14 the urges from around the world for the Pope to speak out against them.
17:17 In his 1942 Christmas radio broadcast,
17:20 the Pope said: “hundreds of thousands of people who,
17:24 through no fault of their own and solely because of their nation or their race,
17:29 have been condemned to death or progressive extinction”.
17:32 He did not specifically mention Nazis or Jews,
17:35 but many saw it as a clear condemnation of atrocities against the Jewish people.
17:40 Despite this, the Pope also said other things which
17:43 the Axis were happy to use in their propaganda.
17:47 Those who urged Pius XII to speak
17:49 out expected him to make an explicit condemnation,
17:52 but even this implicit statement was seen as a risky move by him.
17:56 And the Pope was disappointed to see others not
17:59 recognize the conditions under which he had to speak out,
18:02 which limited his rhetoric.
18:05 At times, the Pope’s direct intervention helped some people.
18:09 For instance, in April 1943,
18:11 there were reports about the German request from the Italians
18:15 to deport Jewish people from Italian-occupied France and the Dalmatian coast.
18:19 On this occasion, the Pope decided to intercede,
18:22 and the Italian foreign ministry assured
18:24 his representative that this would not happen.
18:27 On other occasions, he was not as successful.
18:30 When the Germans occupied Italy,
18:32 they started enacting their Holocaust policies there too,
18:35 taking the persecution of Italian Jews to a whole new level.
18:39 Many Jews went into hiding, with some taking shelter within Rome’s churches.
18:44 The Nazis started rounding them up in Autumn
18:47 1943 with the help of the Italian fascists,
18:50 who literally gathered up hiding Jews from beneath the Vatican’s windows.
18:54 Again, all the Pope could do was to ask
18:58 the Germans for the release of baptized Jews.
19:01 Curiously, unlike the Mussolini government,
19:03 the Nazis accommodated these requests.
19:04 On the other hand, the Church was
19:07 demanded to stop sheltering Jewish people in Italy.
19:10 Initially, the Pope gave in and ordered
19:13 the eviction of refugees, but ultimately,
19:15 he was persuaded by some of his cardinals to rescind this order.
19:19 CONCLUSION It is important to recognize that the Vatican had no real power
19:24 to stop the Second World War from happening
19:26 or the Nazis from perpetrating the Holocaust.
19:29 The Holy See and Pius XII were aware of the genocide going on in Europe,
19:35 but mostly chose to remain silent, fearing reprisals from the Axis.
19:39 Their main focus was on protecting the Catholics and hoping
19:43 that they could act as mediators in this war.
19:45 There were moments when they would successfully
19:48 interfere to save some Jewish people from death,
19:50 but there were other moments when the Vatican refrained from acting.
19:54 The Holy See and the Pope arguably could have done more,
19:57 but they felt that the costs of these actions could have been too high.
20:01 Whatever the case, their inaction is being criticized to this day.
20:05 The words of Cardinal Tisserant summarized the situation quite well:
20:09 “I fear that history will have much to reproach the Holy
20:13 See for having adopted a policy of convenience for itself
20:16 and not much more.” More videos on the lesser discussed
20:21 aspects of the Second World War are on the way,
20:24 so make sure you are subscribed and have pressed the bell button to see it.
20:27 Please consider liking, subscribing, commenting,
20:29 and sharing- it helps immensely.
20:31 Our patrons and YouTube members can watch more than
20:34 200+ exclusive videos- join their ranks via the link
20:37 in the description or by pressing the join
20:40 button under the video to watch these weekly videos,
20:43 learn about our schedule, get early access to our videos,
20:46 access our private Discord, and much more.
20:48 This is the Kings and Generals channel, and we will catch you on the next one.