Couples Therapy Breakthrough Moments 💡 Part 2
Couples Therapy Official
0:00 One thought I'm having is that it's almost like, Natasha,
0:03 your— by withholding your warmth and intimacy,
0:11 you're the mom holding back the dad.
0:15 Oh, yikes.
0:16 ORNA: From Josh.
0:19 You're holding back the good stuff.
0:20 NATASHA: Yeah.
0:23 Wow.
0:25 I could see that connection.
0:26 Yeah.
0:27 And like, to be that in any capacity is like, shocking.
0:30 Like, I kind of just want to push it away.
0:32 It's not a comfortable thought to have.
0:34 ORNA: Mm-hmm.
0:39 DESEAN: I screenshoted a text exchange between us.
0:43 She asked me a question.
0:45 And if you look at the time— let's say it
0:49 was 3:01— and then she texted right after that, 3:02,
0:54 why aren't you answering me?
0:56 One minute later.
0:57 ORNA: Mm-hmm.
0:58 I'm just curious.
0:59 Do you have any thoughts that are not,
1:01 like, within it, but like, thoughts about this dynamic?
1:05 I will say that, um, I hold on to a feeling.
1:14 Something he did made me feel a certain way.
1:17 ORNA: What's the feeling that— Insecure.
1:19 Insecure.
1:20 ORNA: Insecure.
1:21 Absolutely.
1:22 Because if you don't pay— ORNA:
1:23 What you keep going back to that I think is the feeling, is he doesn't care.
1:28 ELAINE: He doesn't.
1:29 Whoa.
1:31 ELAINE: I'm sorry.
1:32 Let's not equate the feeling with truth.
1:35 The feeling that you keep going back to, ultimately, is he doesn't care.
1:40 Correct.
1:41 ORNA: Right?
1:42 So that kind of colors everything.
1:45 He's busy equals he doesn't care.
1:47 He doesn't go to the gym equals he doesn't care.
1:50 Right?
1:51 There's a deep-seated, "he doesn't care." Now, I want to hear more.
1:56 We just touched a little bit on your history.
1:59 But for sure, what you've described is a lot of, no one cared.
2:05 Right?
2:06 And a lot of loneliness, and a lot of doing it on your own.
2:09 [SIGH] Mm-hmm.
2:11 ORNA: Right?
2:14 You're taking a deep breath.
2:15 I'm sorry.
2:15 I'm going right in there.
2:18 [EXHALES] What's the matter?
2:27 Oh.
2:29 Ah.
2:34 Interesting.
2:35 Mm-hmm.
2:36 ELAINE: Very interesting.
2:42 Oh, do I have raccoon eyes?
2:44 No.
2:45 No?
2:48 No.
2:49 OK.
2:50 I think from a very early age, that was pretty much the narrative.
2:57 ORNA: Mm-hmm.
3:00 ELAINE: I left my grandmother's house when I was 15, and I was free.
3:04 I was free.
3:08 ORNA: Free but alone.
3:09 Free but alone.
3:11 Free but alone.
3:14 And then as a young kid, you don't know what you're doing, right?
3:19 So you're going to go back to what feels safe.
3:22 And so I kept going back to my grandmother.
3:24 And you know, you don't think people will do things until you see it.
3:39 Like, I feel like— Are you thinking
3:41 of something in particular when you're saying that?
3:44 --my grandmother and my— my father's people didn't like my mother,
3:50 and the cops were looking for my mother.
3:55 I knew where my mother was.
3:57 I had come in, and they were in the back, my grandmother and my aunt.
4:02 And they were plotting because the detectives were coming,
4:05 looking for my mother at my grandmother's house.
4:08 And they— they were going to say that I told where my mother was,
4:13 and the cops took my mother.
4:15 My mother went to jail thinking that I told on her.
4:19 And— and I heard them say that.
4:23 Like, why would you do that?
4:25 Why would you do that?
4:27 That was a major double betrayal.
4:31 Yeah.
4:32 Yeah.
4:33 But you know, shame on me because I gave the benefit of the doubt,
4:39 and I should have known better.
4:42 And I think— Can I— just pause for a second.
4:45 How are you feeling?
4:47 That is— messed up, man.
4:52 That's— that's a world of hurt.
4:54 That— A world of hurt.
4:56 DESEAN: --yeah.
4:57 Yeah.
4:57 DESEAN: Yeah.
4:58 A world of hurt.
4:59 DESEAN: Yeah.
5:01 ORNA: But to bring it specifically into this dynamic that the two of you
5:05 are here with, the shadow of that, you
5:08 can find it sketched into your relationship.
5:12 Right?
5:13 Because you go towards— with Desean,
5:17 you go towards— what comes up for you repeatedly,
5:20 what pops up like a hologram is this feeling of aloneness, of nobody cares.
5:31 It's interesting.
5:35 It's frustrating for me, though.
5:38 ORNA: Because you're dealing with history.
5:41 You're not only dealing with here and now.
5:42 Yeah.
5:43 I mean, this kind of loneliness that you're describing,
5:46 I mean, you can't make it all better.
5:52 How are you two?
5:54 Good.
5:54 We're good.
5:55 We've been communicating more.
5:56 We've been— like, we try to meditate as often as possible.
6:00 ORNA: You do?
6:01 Yeah.
6:01 Yeah.
6:01 Yeah.
6:02 It's OK, yeah.
6:03 We've been— she got me into it.
6:04 ORNA: Oh.
6:06 Yeah.
6:06 And we've been doing it together.
6:10 Yeah.
6:11 So we've been, like, following like, kind of like a reprogramming.
6:14 Breaking the patterns.
6:16 Yeah.
6:17 Breaking patterns and trying to like, kind of like, move— like,
6:20 let go of the past, like, that kind of stuff.
6:23 Just trying to— Trying to break bad habits.
6:25 Wow.
6:26 Yeah, maybe affecting us.
6:29 I feel like what you mentioned last week about the difference in our approaches,
6:37 like, what she's trying to build on, I'm going in reverse.
6:42 We're doing this dance, and— Yeah.
6:45 --I think it just helped me step back and reflect and like,
6:50 I'm putting myself in the very position that I don't
6:52 want to be in by the way I'm doing things.
6:54 ORNA: Mm-hmm.
6:55 So— Meaning you're weakening the relationship,
6:59 and then you're looking at it and you're saying, it looks weak.
7:01 ALAN: Yeah.
7:02 And like, it's just like, you know,
7:05 a vicious cycle where it's like, I'm never— I can't trust it.
7:09 Yeah.
7:10 I'm not even— so I'm not even giving her an opportunity or for us to, like,
7:14 get something right, because I'm so standoffish about the way things have been.
7:18 That's big.
7:19 So No, that's huge.
7:22 I've noticed a change, even in him from last week.
7:26 Just, you know, just him being more open to, like, listening to me.
7:34 And I don't think he realized, like, how— how that was really happening.
7:40 ORNA: How guarded.
7:41 How guarded he was.
7:42 Yeah.
7:42 ORNA: Yeah.
7:43 No.
7:44 No.
7:44 I didn't.
7:45 It's just, it's almost like I put blame on her, and I've been,
7:48 like, defensive towards her.
7:49 So almost like— I maybe in some ways, I felt like I made up my mind,
7:54 like maybe I didn't want to go— I didn't want to save the relationship.
7:59 It's the same thing with me.
8:01 You know?
8:02 Whenever I would feel like anything had to do with trust,
8:05 I would go back and think about the times
8:07 that he's done these things to me where I felt like,
8:10 well, this is an example of why I can't trust you.
8:13 Like, I had all these things,
8:15 not realizing that I'm actually triggering Alan to, like, more stress.
8:20 You know, I do want us to move forward,
8:24 and I would like to take things a step at a time.
8:30 I just don't want to make any more rash decisions with us anymore.
8:39 EVELYN: Neither do I.
8:45 I love you.
8:46 You know that.
8:49 I'm learning more about that.
8:54 [SNIFFLE] What do you want?
9:05 To be alone with the kids.
9:08 That's what she wants.
9:09 To be alone with the kids.
9:11 Is that what you want?
9:13 It's not always what I want, you know?
9:17 I mean— he— he supports me, you know?
9:27 And I know that if something were to happen, he would always be there for me.
9:32 But I don't know, maybe I'm just scared.
9:38 ORNA: Of?
9:42 Of being close to somebody, of giving somebody that.
9:50 I gotta check on the baby.
9:51 He's crying.
9:52 Giving somebody that power, I guess.
9:56 Of committing to somebody in that way.
10:01 You know?
10:02 It's easier when you're alone.
10:03 It's just you.
10:04 You don't have to depend on anybody.
10:08 So I— it's not easy.
10:11 It's not easy for me.
10:13 I mean— Hi.
10:15 Say hi.
10:16 Hi.
10:16 Good morning.
10:18 [LAUGHS] So sweet.
10:21 You wanna put him on his chair?
10:24 I'll see you for lunch.
10:28 So yeah, I think that— You have a lot of fear of connecting and depending.
10:35 Yeah.
10:37 I do, for sure.
10:45 And that's what I mean when I say, like, I know he's a good guy.
10:48 He's one of the— the best guys that I've ever had.
10:56 So I know that if I continue this way, you know, I may lose him.
11:02 [INDISTINCT] I mean, I'm trying.
11:05 I'm here.
11:07 I'm trying to figure this out and do this with him to the best that I can,
11:14 but sometimes, I don't know if I can.
11:17 YAYA: We had a fight this weekend.
11:19 ORNA: Tell me.
11:20 YAYA: She was going to meet up with her gay boys.
11:23 And then she's getting ready, and I had not done,
11:26 like, the laundry because I was taking care of the kids.
11:29 And then she was like, you didn't do the laundry?
11:31 I have no underwear.
11:33 I would have been able to do it.
11:35 You would have been able to do it when?
11:36 Because you were out the whole day Saturday.
11:38 I could have put it to wash in the morning.
11:40 And then by the time it's getting ready to go— Baby,
11:43 you noticed the piles of sorted laundry to be done, right?
11:47 That's what you do.
11:48 Yeah.
11:49 But it's a little off, what you're describing.
11:53 I mean, I knew I was just being a jerk, saying all that stuff about the laundry.
11:58 But you're still saying it.
11:59 Yeah.
11:59 I know.
12:00 I know.
12:01 ORNA: What's going on?
12:02 I mean, I'm surprised.
12:04 CYN: I feel like— You're going out and having fun for the whole day.
12:06 CYN: And then— And then you're complaining that your laundry's not done for you.
12:12 So how's that for you?
12:16 Well, I'm not a housekeeper.
12:19 Like, I'm not there to just clean, wash clothes, and take care of the kids.
12:25 Right.
12:26 These kids are— You could've said no, and I would've came home.
12:27 ORNA: Wait.
12:28 Keep talking.
12:29 YAYA: You know, in my mind, I'm like, are you— are you fucking kidding me?
12:34 Like, I felt like it was a tantrum.
12:35 Yeah.
12:36 How are you feeling, to be in that position?
12:40 Like, I was upset that she even reacted like that.
12:42 I try to describe the feelings.
12:46 I— ORNA: Try to find your feelings there.
12:54 I'm trying.
12:56 I— Can I ask you?
12:59 I'll give you like, a menu of possible feelings, and choose whichever one.
13:05 Did you feel disappointed?
13:07 Did you feel abandoned?
13:09 Did you feel taken advantage of?
13:12 Did you feel furious?
13:14 Did you feel humiliated?
13:18 If I had to choose one, it would be, like, disappointed.
13:22 And if you had to choose three?
13:24 Disappointed, abandoned, and sad.
13:30 Those are like, the feelings you have towards mommy.
13:34 YAYA: No.
13:35 What do you mean?
13:37 She's saying that those are the feelings that I have towards my mom.
13:40 No.
13:40 No.
13:40 No.
13:41 I have a lot of resentment towards my mother.
13:44 Why?
13:45 Because she abandoned you.
13:46 Not abandoned.
13:47 She neglected.
13:47 Wait.
13:48 She abandoned and— CYN: She abandoned her.
13:50 She would leave her and her sister and her brother,
13:54 and she would go do her own thing, and she would go party.
13:57 Mm-hmm.
13:58 Well, we lived like, in an apartment building.
14:01 So like, random people would have parties
14:04 on the weekends and drink, do drugs, whatever.
14:07 Sometimes, they had the party at our apartment,
14:09 but then my sister and I would lock ourselves in our room.
14:13 I remember one time, it was when we first came here.
14:16 I had issues, and I would wet my bed.
14:18 ORNA: Mm-hmm.
14:19 And then I had like, a thick ass comforter, and I had wet my bed,
14:24 and she made me wash everything by hand in the bathtub.
14:27 And I was probably, like, you know, like, Somalian skinny.
14:32 Like, you see those commercials?
14:33 Like that.
14:34 There were washing machines in the hallway of our floor.
14:38 But because I wet the bed— ORNA:
14:39 So rather than take care of whatever was upsetting
14:42 you and causing you to wet your bed— YAYA: Yeah.
14:44 --she made you work.
14:47 Yeah.
14:48 So— Do the laundry, by the way.
14:52 YAYA: By hand.
14:53 Do the laundry.
14:54 I'm just thinking about the beginning of the session.
14:56 Yeah.
14:57 ORNA: So you're describing a pattern of a lot of really
15:02 intense compliance and ignoring very bad things that are happening.
15:12 So you asked her if she's being compliant,
15:16 and is that like, in relation to how I'm acting?
15:19 Or— Yeah.
15:24 Yeah.
15:25 Because when I say— remember,
15:27 I described my what she now calls tantrums as being a monster?
15:31 That's— I've said that to her.
15:34 ORNA: That's how you end up feeling, because— CYN: I treat her— yeah,
15:37 I treat her like shit, and I feel really bad.
15:39 ORNA: And you feel really bad.
15:40 And then she doesn't say anything.
15:42 Right.
15:43 But there's something that's getting very powerfully
15:46 played out between the two of you
15:48 that you keep taking it upon yourself like it's all generated from you,
15:52 but some of it is coming from you.
15:57 That, like nurturing, like, I'm almost mothering her?
16:01 Or do you feel like she's, like, you're enabling me?
16:05 Is that like—- That's a great word.
16:07 Yeah.
16:08 Well, I'm enabling her behavior?
16:10 Yes.
16:11 In a way, you're— in some kind of in a way,
16:16 beautiful way, but very not good for the two of you,
16:20 you're enacting— each of you are enacting
16:22 parts of your childhoods with each other,
16:25 because you're back in the situation where whatever warning
16:30 signs you're sending the other person is— Not receiving it.
16:34 --not picking up on.
16:35 You're back in the situation where someone's treating you badly,
16:40 and you're just compliant.
16:43 You're really nicely fitting each other to reenact
16:49 what's been very painful for you in the past.
16:53 You have to break out of that mold.
16:58 I'm not allowed in society to just be— be mad.
17:02 ORNA: Mm-hmm.
17:03 You know?
17:05 Hell, there are nights that I take Lincoln, our dog,
17:07 out for a walk, and I'm not even allowed to be cold.
17:11 If I put my hoodie on and I'm walking next to someone,
17:15 immediately, they'll stop and wait for me to pass.
17:18 You know, I'm just cold.
17:21 Right.
17:22 You know?
17:23 But I don't want to get too much into that, but— You can get into that.
17:26 I mean, why not?
17:27 It matters.
17:31 It's a luxury that I don't have.
17:34 And regardless of— But even with that, do you see what just happened?
17:39 Yeah.
17:40 There are a lot of moments like this where I'm almost like,
17:44 are we sharing the same Black experience?
17:46 Because I know you are going through what Black men go through,
17:50 but you don't tap into that.
17:52 You don't talk about that.
17:53 So— Can I ask you— India, you said earlier,
17:58 it's different to speak to someone who's other than to each other.
18:03 Do you feel, as a person of color, a lot of discomfort to talk to me?
18:11 I feel like I have to dress it up a bit for you.
18:17 Mm-hmm.
18:19 Dress it up so I will understand, or dress it up so I will not— Yeah,
18:23 dress it up so you understand, you know, from our scope.
18:26 Because there is still the layer of, I'm speaking to a white woman right now.
18:31 I need to address it in a certain way.
18:32 Yeah.
18:33 But I want to face it head on.
18:35 I want to talk to you, the white person,
18:38 about it, because this is how we move forward.
18:40 This is how we get better.
18:43 We just have to face the traumatic emotions head-on.
18:46 Right.
18:47 Strong feelings like anger.
18:49 Right.
18:50 And I think the difference between the two of us is,
18:55 he doesn't want to acknowledge his emotions.
18:58 He talks about it briefly, but you know— No, I've shared— I've shared with you
19:04 the beginning stages of me starting a business,
19:06 and what that was like, being a Black man.
19:08 I mean, I had people coming to my office that was set up in an office building,
19:13 asking me if I'm running a scam.
19:16 I feel as though I can either let it get me upset and bog me down,
19:21 or I can push through and make things happen.
19:23 I choose to push through and make things happen.
19:27 But there's some way that you deal
19:28 with the emotional implications of whatever we're talking about differently.
19:34 DALE: Yeah.
19:35 And I think India is suggesting that you do some kind of dissociation there,
19:39 that you cut yourself off from that.
19:49 I'm— I'm always torn between that because it's like,
19:54 what am I supposed to do with that?
19:56 It's like, I'm here, trying to just make a living for myself.
20:01 What am I supposed to do with that?
20:02 ORNA: Yeah.
20:06 I'm sorry.
20:08 Why are you sorry?
20:10 Well, the way I see it sometimes is that even the acknowledgment is so taxing.
20:17 So I don't know, sometimes I choose just not to— not to give validation to it,
20:25 and just— But I just want to understand.
20:31 So when you say— when you allow
20:33 yourself more contact with feelings, and you say,
20:36 what am I supposed to do with this, what happens between the two of you?
20:41 Is there somewhere for that to go between the two of you?
20:46 Mm, well, I mean— well— [LAUGHS] --I would ask the question,
20:53 what is she supposed to do with it?
20:55 Yeah.
20:56 You know?
20:57 It's— obviously I share it with her, but I
20:59 don't necessarily want to— But do you get upset?
21:03 In that moment?
21:05 No.
21:06 Just very matter of fact.
21:07 No.
21:08 Because first of all, that is like, a great burden to carry on your own.
21:16 And even if you dissociate from it, it's still there, weighing on you.
21:22 So there's plenty of things that happen when you
21:26 share it with another person and you feel understood.
21:31 It has this kind of miraculous power to transform
21:36 very difficult feelings to something that becomes useful— Yeah.
21:41 --and help the two of you deepen what you have together.
21:44 Mm.
21:46 Yeah.
21:47 And it's— and it's exactly what I yearn for from her at times,
21:53 to be more vulnerable.
21:55 Mm-hmm.
21:56 Yeah.
21:57 ORNA: Yeah.
22:01 JOSH: As fucked up as my childhood was,
22:03 you trying to explore that with me has bothered the shit out of me.
22:11 Like, all week, I'm like, what is she trying to get at?
22:14 It was bothering me that I didn't understand.
22:16 Mm-hmm.
22:17 Like, because it felt like, you know, there's the things you know,
22:21 the things you know you don't know,
22:22 and the things you don't know you don't know.
22:24 ORNA: Right.
22:25 It's set in a place that I don't know I don't know.
22:27 ORNA: Yeah.
22:28 And it was driving me crazy.
22:30 So I'm like, sitting there.
22:31 That's a really good way of putting it.
22:32 JOSH: Yeah.
22:33 ORNA: One thing that happens is when there's
22:36 a very intense thing that gets triggered in the relationship,
22:41 often it comes not only from what's going on, let's say,
22:44 between the two of you, but also fueled by things from your past.
22:48 Yeah.
22:49 ORNA: And the pain and loneliness that you described,
22:52 it was such a palpable description.
22:54 It was so alive, the way you described it,
22:57 that it— it had a feeling that you're— almost like
23:03 you're channeling something that's way beyond the two of you.
23:06 Yeah.
23:07 You know, something that kept replaying in my head
23:09 this past week was these very small micro-moments throughout my childhood.
23:15 Like— ORNA: Tell me.
23:16 JOSH: --I went really long periods of time
23:18 where my mom and my dad were separating.
23:21 ORNA: Mm-hmm.
23:22 I couldn't see my dad, and my dad was my best friend.
23:27 Like, I loved my dad.
23:28 I looked up to my dad.
23:29 He was like a superhero to me.
23:30 Like, if I could be half the father my dad was— like,
23:34 I want to cry right now, thinking about it.
23:37 But like, if I could be half the father my dad was, I'd be proud of myself.
23:41 Because my dad, against— He didn't— he could have been like any of his peers.
23:47 My dad grew up in the projects of Brooklyn, and there's many,
23:51 many fathers that just decided not to be in their children's lives,
23:55 especially in an adversary like my mother.
23:58 But my dad, by any means, made sure he was in my life.
24:02 He would sneak me a phone and be like, this is how I'm going to call you.
24:04 I'll meet you here at this time.
24:05 Bring me an Easter basket.
24:07 You know?
24:08 He would do these things that really meant a lot to me.
24:10 So when I was able to explore it,
24:12 it made me realize that feeling of loneliness stems from the moments
24:16 where I— I felt like I was being kept from my dad.
24:21 Mm-hmm.
24:22 I really appreciate the way you're talking
24:24 about it and following your own process.
24:27 And did you also allow yourself to get connected to these feelings of like,
24:32 longing, and loneliness, and abandonment?
24:35 JOSH: Yeah.
24:37 Yeah.
24:38 I think— I don't think I resolved them in the way,
24:44 but I think I understood them a bit more.
24:46 But I think at the same time,
24:48 I feel justified in what I feel in my relationship,
24:51 my current relationship with Natasha.
24:53 Like, I feel justified.
24:54 ORNA: Well, of course you're justified.
24:57 Let's say, I don't— Natasha, I don't know if you have any thoughts
25:00 about this, how this connects to your dynamic,
25:02 but— I think if I was to look at it from a therapy perspective
25:07 is that if he is feeling in any way like a parallel with his father,
25:13 anything that happens between us, I become a parallel to his mother.
25:17 And that could be really tough to— to reconcile with.
25:20 Right?
25:21 JOSH: Yeah.
25:22 NATASHA: And so, it made me really— This might sound a little strange,
25:25 but one thought I'm having is that it's almost like Natasha,
25:29 you're— by withholding your warmth and intimacy,
25:37 you're the mom holding back the dad.
25:41 Oh, yikes.
25:42 From Josh.
25:45 You're holding back the good stuff.
25:46 NATASHA: Yeah.
25:49 Wow.
25:51 I could see that connection.
25:52 NATASHA: Yeah.
25:53 And like, to be that in any capacity is like, shocking.
25:56 Like, I kind of just want to push it away.
25:58 It's not a comfortable thought to have.
26:02 JOSH: That's interesting.
26:03 That's really interesting.
26:04 I just feel like— I feel like another
26:05 door opened inside my brain and I'm like, OK.
26:07 I gotta— like, there's these rooms in my brain,
26:11 and they're like, nice and organized and compartmentalized.
26:13 And I'm like, I did all this work in there.
26:15 And I'm like, oh, like, I moved the bookshelf, and there's another door.
26:17 And I'm like, where the fuck did this door come from?
26:19 And I opened it, and it's just fucked up and messy.
26:22 And I'm like, oh!
26:23 There's so much work to do in there.
26:24 Uh-huh.
26:25 That's what it feels like just happened at this very moment.
26:27 I'm like, oh.
26:30 Yeah.
26:31 [LIGHT MUSIC]