MS NOW Highlights - May 2
MS NOW
0:00 We begin this morning with another
0:02 resounding rebuke of the Trump administration.
0:04 Demonstrators poured into the streets across the country yesterday
0:08 for Mayday protests build as quote workers over billionaires.
0:12 Organizers say that over three 3,300 events took place in American
0:18 cities from coast to coast where protesters called for peace,
0:22 higher wages, and better working conditions.
0:24 and they sent a strong message
0:27 to the Trump administration that working Americans should
0:30 be the government's focus as Trump's war
0:33 with Iran continues to cause economic pain.
0:36 Meanwhile, Trump speaking in Florida yesterday on the economy
0:40 continued to downplay concerns about the high cost of living,
0:43 including rising gas prices.
0:45 And I thought oil would be much, much higher than it turned out to be.
0:50 I mean, it's not low.
0:51 It's certainly not low.
0:53 It's going to come crashing down as soon as this war is over.
0:56 These people tried to hold up our country for years and years,
0:58 the world, by closing up the straight of hormones.
1:01 When all of that stuff comes out,
1:03 you're going to see prices dropping on gasoline like you've never seen.
1:07 And and all of that, electricity, gasoline, anything having to do with energy.
1:14 I mean, the straight of Hormuz is closed now.
1:19 now because Iran closed the straight of Hormuz because
1:23 the president of the United States launched a war against Iran.
1:28 A situation in a circumstance that his military adviserss told
1:33 him would happen if he did this and he ignored them.
1:37 I just want to lay that out.
1:38 Time is a flat circle.
1:39 Time is a flat circle.
1:40 You don't have to listen to your advisors apparently if you're this president.
1:43 I think the thing that's so interesting and as you were laying that out
1:47 Jackie is this is a president who is behaving as someone who has like
1:51 a 60% approval rating right like that as if there's this mandate for him
1:55 to kind of do whatever he wants
1:57 and the American people they're watching thing after
1:59 thing after thing happen so much action but what they're not seeing is action
2:03 on the thing they care about you're
2:04 talking about gas prices being higher and it'd
2:06 be one thing if it was only gas prices it'd be great for the American
2:10 people if the only thing they had to deal with were higher gas prices,
2:13 but groceries are high and have been high.
2:15 Healthc care costs are high and have been high.
2:18 Child care is high and has been high.
2:21 And so, you don't have any cushion if you are your everyday American.
2:25 And when you're watching the president of the United
2:27 States say things like that that don't make any sense,
2:30 but also talking about a ballroom, you start to ask and then start to demand
2:35 for them to focus on the thing that changes your lives.
2:37 And they're not doing that.
2:38 Right.
2:39 And as the White House and the president are
2:41 are struggling and sort of grasping to find whatever
2:45 midterm message they're going for, basically the the biggest
2:48 takeaway I think here is that we're not Joe Biden.
2:51 Things are still better than they were under Joe Biden,
2:54 which one factually is starting to become inaccurate.
2:57 I mean, gas prices have hit a fourtime low the last four time high,
3:02 a fouryear highoo Saturday morning.
3:04 uh they have not been this high since Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022.
3:10 That is a number that economists anticipate is going to continue
3:13 to go up so long as the straight is closed.
3:15 Um and it's certainly not a winning campaign message.
3:19 It's backwards looking.
3:20 It's not forward-looking.
3:21 It's not what Republicans want him to be talking about.
3:24 When you hear them talk publicly and privately about this, they do say
3:27 in earnest that there are things that the president could be touting, right?
3:32 um tax cuts, uh lower drug prices, better border security, reduced crime.
3:39 None of these things,
3:40 none of this message discipline is coming from the president right now,
3:43 who in the last few weeks has been fixated
3:46 on his gilded ballroom and the war with Iran,
3:48 a gilded ballroom that now apparently we're all paying for.
3:51 Ping.
3:51 But gee, who didn't see that coming?
3:53 And to to all of our points about the president not being
3:57 focused on what people are worried about when it comes to the economy,
4:02 Reuters Ipsos poll puts it in plain black and white.
4:05 Um Trump's handling of the economy, 27% approve, 63% disapprove.
4:10 So we're not just flapping our gums here.
4:14 This is what the America how the American people feel.
4:18 And for the first time,
4:20 Democrats are doing better than Republicans on this issue,
4:23 which will be a central part of Democrats campaign message in November.
4:28 But let's listen to what some of the protesters had to say yesterday,
4:30 which could give us a better idea
4:32 of what voters are thinking ahead of the midterms.
4:35 You have families that aren't able to eat.
4:37 We're aren't able to put gas in our car
4:39 to drop off our kids and pick them up from school.
4:41 We have to figure out we should pay the light bill or put gas in the car.
4:45 It's is disheartening, disheartening, rather.
4:47 Um, but it's embarrassing.
4:48 This day represents that day to be able to come
4:51 out against an administration that doesn't value working people,
4:56 that has attacked our immigrant community
4:59 that puts corporations and billionaires over working people.
5:02 Right now, I think all of us are really just getting paycheck to paycheck.
5:06 Like, it's this economy has been really tough and we're trying to to fix that.
5:10 Trying to rebalance our skills.
5:12 Sign says, "Fund education, not war." Why you holding this sign today?
5:15 I mean, because Trump is putting us on the brink of an economic
5:19 crisis when he should be investing in uh things that help improve our economy.
5:26 Joining us now, Susan Paige,
5:28 Washington bureau chief at USA Today and author of The Queen and Her Presidents:
5:32 The Hidden Hands That Shaped History,
5:34 and David Ducker, MS Now contributor, senior writer at The Dispatch,
5:38 an author of In Trump's Shadow: The Battle for 2024 and the Future of the GOP.
5:45 Guys, thanks for joining us.
5:47 First thing this morning, it's been it's been a week.
5:51 It's been a week.
5:52 It's been a week.
5:53 Um, David, I want to start with you and and get your response to Trump's
5:59 continued lack of economic empathy that he has
6:03 exhibited now doing so on the campaign trail.
6:05 Before it was sort of from the White House in in in fits and bursts,
6:10 but but now he's someone who the White House chief of staff
6:12 has said is going to be dispatched to the campaign trail weekly.
6:16 We saw him the villages yesterday.
6:18 Is this a winning campaign message?
6:21 Well, we're going to find out.
6:24 But look, it's it's never good when the president, any president, number one,
6:31 isn't focused on the key issues that Americans want him to focus on.
6:37 That always causes president's problems, Democrat or Republican,
6:40 and it's causing this president a problem.
6:43 That's a particular problem when people are not doing well
6:47 economically or they don't feel as though they're doing well economically.
6:52 And one of the things we've learned about President Trump
6:55 is that he's very disciplined in his uh undisiplined behavior.
6:59 And so he is going to continue to talk about what he wants to talk about.
7:05 And he is going to continue to cast
7:08 the US economy and the war that we're still in.
7:11 So eventually gas prices will go down.
7:13 Except we're not in it.
7:15 So, Congress doesn't have to um pass an authorization
7:18 for use of military force the way he wants,
7:21 which is not the way right now most Americans see things.
7:26 And it's really interesting because one of the things that made Donald
7:31 Trump a good candidate in 2016 and 2024 is more voters than not,
7:36 at least when it came to the people who shut up the polls thought that he was
7:39 the one that was more accurately describing the state
7:42 of the economy and their economy versus the opposition.
7:46 But as an incumbent president, as the president, he does the exact opposite.
7:50 And so here we are.
7:52 It is very easy to be running as a candidate and say it's all raggedy,
7:55 but when it's your job to do it and fix it,
7:58 there's a different you have to say something different.
8:00 You said you talked about him not being focused on the issue.
8:03 It also feels he's actively trying to tell the American
8:06 people the issue they have is not a real issue.
8:09 And that is also like an added aspect
8:11 of this that other presidents don't usually have.
8:13 And when you talk the official line out of the White
8:16 House is that he is his best comm's director.
8:18 He is the best messenger of us all.
8:21 And yet you have this quote from someone who spoke to Jackie Alamain.
8:24 I don't know if you guys heard of her.
8:26 Nice upstart.
8:27 Michael Schnell and Jake Trailer in this new story.
8:30 Um the vibe right now is we know we are already cooked in the midterms.
8:35 A White House official told MS Now,
8:38 I mean it feels if if they're feeling that and it's it's only May,
8:42 is this is there are they trying to see
8:44 ya or is this how they're really feeling?
8:46 You think you know things can happen.
8:48 We live in a very dynamic world.
8:49 God knows today looks different than a week ago did when you did your show.
8:53 Yeah.
8:54 Uh on the other hand,
8:55 politics does get cooked early on and perceptions that the economy is not good.
9:01 Thinking not only about gas prices but also about the cost of healthare,
9:05 the cost of groceries.
9:06 Uh these are issues that perceptions are getting firmer
9:09 and firmer in a way that is unhelpful to Republicans.
9:13 And one of the problems with dispatching
9:15 President Trump out on the campaign trail, which you're not talking about,
9:18 is is that uh you can say he's going to talk about affordability,
9:22 uh but you can't make him talk about affordability.
9:24 And if he wants to talk about the ballroom,
9:26 that is what he's going to talk about.
9:29 Yeah.
9:29 You know, I'm I'm scribbling here before I forget.
9:32 um this impact um you know I think David you
9:35 just said you know the president is famously undisiplined or whatever
9:39 the the term of art you used that I loved disciplined
9:42 at being undisiplined yes disciplined as being
9:44 undisiplined and you know great that's
9:46 great if you're the president you don't have to run again
9:49 you're not on the ballot but there are Republicans down ballot
9:54 in house races senate races state legislative races who have to answer
9:58 to the voters for what the president is doing or not doing.
10:03 How I mean Jackie's got the reporting where
10:06 there's a divide now is that we're cooked.
10:09 Um but that's from the White House's perspective.
10:12 What about the congressional candidates perspective?
10:15 When are we going to see that self-preservation kick in that we always see
10:22 of of um candidates from a party where the president is not doing so well?
10:28 Yeah, really good question.
10:29 I wouldn't expect it to be during the primary season, right?
10:32 So, we're we're sort of in the thick
10:34 now of Republican and Democratic primary season.
10:37 The president still has a really
10:39 good relationship with committed Republican voters.
10:41 I was in Kentucky for a few days this week reporting on on a Republican primary.
10:46 Uh it's a very red district and the voters
10:50 there are primarily very satisfied with the president
10:53 and his leadership and you know they think
10:55 that wherever he's taking them it's it's he
10:57 knows what he's doing and he's going to get them to a better place even though
11:01 you turn on the local news and it's all about gas prices being over $4 a gallon.
11:06 So nobody wants to get on the wrong side of uh the president when
11:10 he can endorse against you and that endorsement still carries a lot of weight.
11:13 Um, we are beginning to see some grumbling on Capitol Hill.
11:16 Like you talk to Republicans quietly,
11:19 privately, not for attribution, and they'll concede,
11:22 you know, and some of them, by the way, will concede on the record.
11:25 Yeah, some of my colleagues are getting,
11:27 you know, we're getting a little itchy here.
11:29 Um, I think we get into the fall and in those states
11:33 and districts where you kind of need to create some sort of separation,
11:37 you're going to see more members speaking out.
11:39 But again, it's this weird dichotomy where the president is doing,
11:43 you know, poorly with independents to say the least, obviously with Democrats,
11:46 but then you look at a majority of Republican voters and even
11:50 though there are certain elements of his coalition that have grown unhappy,
11:53 there's still more that are not and they
11:56 don't want again to get on the wrong side of somebody who can go on social media
12:02 and nuke their political career before they've been renominated.
12:06 This year, President Trump is no stranger to self arandisement,
12:11 but that over-the-top self-promotion has recently hit new heights.
12:15 According to The Atlantic, based on two sources,
12:19 a Trump confidant has reportedly told the publication,
12:22 quote, "He's been talking recently about how he
12:25 is the most powerful person to ever live.
12:28 He wants to be remembered as the one who did things that other
12:32 people couldn't do because of his sheer power and force of will.
12:35 And Trump is certainly not being subtle about it.
12:38 This week, a 15- ft gold statue of Trump
12:42 dubbed Don Colossus was installed at his Miami golf course.
12:46 And in July, the State Department is reportedly finalizing a plan
12:50 to include Trump's photo in US
12:53 passports to celebrate America's 250th anniversary.
12:55 Last night in a truth social posting spree,
12:59 Trump posted a photo of himself alongside the faces on Mount Rushmore.
13:03 Nikki McCann Ramirez and Paul Butler are back with us.
13:07 So Nikki, there's narcissism and then there's narciss goldplated narcissism.
13:11 Then there's authoritarianism.
13:13 Yes.
13:13 Uh, you know, part of me kind of wonders
13:17 if some of this is about like his insecurity
13:22 about whether America will would would create these kind
13:27 of memorials to him after he is gone.
13:29 Like he wants to see the stuff built now
13:32 because maybe he's a little bit worried about his legacy.
13:35 But maybe I'm I'm No, you're completely correct.
13:37 So, yeah.
13:38 Uh I actually wrote about this today for Rolling Stone,
13:40 but if you think about the manner in which presidential memorials exist in DC,
13:45 they are usually very intentionally built
13:47 to reflect the public legacy of that president.
13:50 FDR has a wheelchair accessible memorial that represents his four terms,
13:53 the chaos of the wars.
13:55 Washington is very austere.
13:57 It's very simple.
13:58 It's supposed to represent American might without being too ornate.
14:01 Lincoln is set up to be in direct dialogue
14:04 with the Lee mansion across the river because of the civil war.
14:08 All these pres none of these presidents picked these memorials for themselves.
14:12 There was a time period after they left office potentially even
14:15 after they died in which the national memory kind of coalesed
14:19 and gelled and people said this person is significant enough that they
14:23 deserve a giant structure so that everyone knows what they did.
14:26 To an extent Trump is building the perfect memorials to himself.
14:31 the arch, this giant statue, the ballroom, they are soulless, empty,
14:36 overly ornate constructions that represent a man
14:40 who is so insecure about how he is going to be remembered that he feels he
14:45 needs to physically impose himself on the landscape.
14:48 A landscape that was very intentionally created
14:50 by the designers of Washington to reflect democratic values.
14:53 The White House is the White House, small democratic values,
14:57 but the White House is the White House, not the presidential palace.
15:01 Congress is huge and on the giant hill next to the PTOIC because it's supposed
15:05 to represent the most important branch of government
15:08 that the founder government government that the founders envisioned.
15:10 Trump doesn't get that that he does it doesn't click for him.
15:15 Well, does he get how it ended for Caesar?
15:18 No, you're you're assuming he's a fan of history.
15:21 Yeah.
15:22 Well, that is actually why I think that for once it is the tail on Trump, right?
15:27 You know, he is this ahistorical figure who
15:30 is coming in with a wrecking ball and he's
15:33 destroying the post-war norms that have governed
15:35 the world and have led to America's greatest prosperity.
15:39 And so, he is taking a wrecking ball and also
15:43 having a potential mil military catastrophe in the form of Iran.
15:47 So, I don't know.
15:49 I do think in some sense he is an ahistorical figure that is outside
15:55 of the scope and realm of a normal
15:58 president who is constrained by American rule of law.
16:02 He's an abnormal figure in a liberal democracy.
16:05 So Aean, I think your comment about authoritarianism is exactly right.
16:09 I live in the District of Columbia.
16:11 It's unrecognizable.
16:12 The White House looks like a a construction site.
16:16 Uh you can walk around government buildings
16:20 and see huge pictures of Donald Trump, including on the Justice Department.
16:25 My my old uh office building was there and National
16:30 Guards troops are patrolling the streets of DC with guns.
16:35 This is all at the president's behest.
16:36 So, I was going to say something a little bit different and not not
16:40 to take away from what you guys were discussing about why Donald Trump is doing
16:44 this, but I think he is in some ways because I do believe he's
16:46 an authoritarian at heart that he is laying
16:48 the groundwork for an attempt to usurp power.
16:50 And one of the ways you do that is you fuse the state
16:54 with the person so that it becomes indistinguishable
16:57 indistinguishable that you no longer have state institutions.
16:59 They are Trump institutions.
17:01 You no longer have memorials
17:02 for previous presidents because everything Trump does
17:05 is greater than anything any individual has done in the state before.
17:10 Let me play for you a sap mash
17:12 of people talking about Trump extending beyond a second term.
17:15 Listen, we're up everywhere,
17:17 but I'm not running Peter unless you unless you say I can.
17:21 He's going to get a third term.
17:23 So Trump 28, Trump is going to be president
17:25 28 and people just ought to get accommodated with that.
17:29 Trump 2028.
17:29 I hope this never ends.
17:31 So, the thing is, I know people can say that they're joking about this, right?
17:36 People like Lindsey Graham,
17:37 but what worries me the most is this is a bit of a distraction for an attempt
17:43 to try and usurp the Constitution in 2028 and try to stay on for a third term.
17:48 I don't know what you're think thinking.
17:49 No, I I don't discount that at all.
17:51 I think it's a very serious threat and it what scares me is
17:55 that the the check I see to that threat isn't necessarily American institutions,
18:01 places like the Supreme Court.
18:03 The thing that is giving me a little reassurance
18:05 right now is that he's pissed off so much
18:08 of his base that initially supported him into a second
18:11 term with the war in Iran, the Epstein files,
18:14 the economic turmoil that I do think that if he attempted to run a third time,
18:19 you would see a faction of that original MAGA base turn against him,
18:23 people like Tucker Carlson, Megan Kelly who still hold a lot of sway.
18:27 That doesn't fully reassure me though because the reality is
18:30 that our institutions should be strong enough that if if a president said,
18:33 "Hey, never mind the Constitution.
18:35 I'm running again." Everyone would rally to stop it.
18:38 And that's not happening.
18:39 Yeah.
18:39 I mean, if they're not stopping the pictures on the building,
18:41 it might not stop the constitution.
18:43 Well, but I I do wonder how I mean,
18:45 I don't know if there's great polling on this, but I do
18:48 wonder how his base views this effort to brand everything with his face,
18:52 with his name, which I'm, you know, they're into the merch.
18:55 I get that.
18:55 like or they have been into the merch and the red hats and everything like that.
19:00 But in light of the foreign adventurism and in light of, you know,
19:04 not delivering on all of the promises or really any
19:07 of the promises that he made to the American people,
19:09 I I wonder if people are kind of tiring his face into the weeds of of this.
19:14 But like if you look at American democracy and the way
19:17 these po the people who voted for Donald Trump are,
19:19 I suspect that you will have 30% and perhaps the truest thing
19:22 Donald Trump ever said was that he could stand on Fifth Avenue,
19:25 shoot somebody, and his supporters will still support him.
19:27 And that has always stayed in my head
19:30 as like the truth about MAGA supporters, the hardcore ones.
19:33 So I do think that there's probably an element of MAGA supporters
19:36 who want to see Trump run for a third term and the fracturing
19:40 of the rest of the of the body politic is where Donald Trump
19:45 thrives and that's how he if you remember kind of won in the Republican
19:49 primary I think it was like 16 candidates and he never went above
19:52 like 20% 30% but all the others were so fractured and they could
19:56 never coalesce around one candidate that it
19:58 ultimately allowed Donald Trump to make
20:00 his way through into the Republican party and And that's where we are.
20:04 And so I fear that something like that could happen again in 2028.
20:07 If he does decide to run, a few people will say, "No, no, no.
20:10 We're against this." But you'll still have
20:11 a third of the Republican party who are like,
20:13 "We are with you ride or die till the very end." So,
20:17 can I say it's unconstitutional?
20:18 I know.
20:19 But he could do something cutesy like say, "Okay, Don Jr.
20:22 or JD Vance is going to be running wink wink,
20:25 but I'll be president." And then the check would be in court.
20:28 And this is not a week when I'm filling Jared Kushner.
20:31 Some people have joked that Jared Kushner is the de facto president right now.
20:35 Don't put that into the universe.
20:37 I know, right?
20:37 Like running around as like seeing
20:39 classified information doesn't have$5 trillion deal.
20:41 Trust Don Jr.
20:43 with the Princess.
20:44 So I do think Jared Kushner might be in better foot.
20:48 All right.
20:48 Nikki McCain Ramirez, Paul Butler.
20:50 It's great to see you.
20:51 Thank you to the both of you.
20:53 Breaking news.
20:53 A top Iranian official today says the war with the US will
20:57 likely resume hours after President Trump
21:00 turned down a new Iranian negotiating proposal.
21:04 They want to make a deal, but I don't I'm not satisfied with it.
21:08 So, we'll see what happens.
21:09 Iran wants to make a deal because they have no
21:13 military left essentially and they want to make a deal, but I'm not satisfied.
21:18 So the president did not elaborate
21:20 on what he saw as the proposal's shortcomings.
21:23 Iran gave no details on the plan,
21:25 but said it was sent to Pakistani mediators on Thursday.
21:28 Of course, it comes amid a shaky 3-week ceasefire as the two
21:32 countries remain locked in a standoff over the Strait of Hormuz.
21:36 Joining me now, another friend of the show, Washington Congressman Adam Smith.
21:40 He is the ranking member of the House Armed Services Committee.
21:43 Welcome, Congressman.
21:43 So, let's get to it here because the Wall
21:46 Street Journal reports the Iranian proposal contains hints of compromise,
21:50 offering to discuss conditions for Iran to reopen the street
21:54 of Hormuz and for the US to end its blockade,
21:58 also postpone nuclear negotiations to a later date.
22:01 What do you make of the president declining to resume peace talks?
22:05 How much longer can the ceasefire hold
22:08 with both sides continually testing each other's limits?
22:11 Well, it just shows how far apart we are
22:15 from Iran and how pointless this war has been to date.
22:17 I mean, the president's done a very good job of lying about where
22:21 we're at, pretending that we're somehow close
22:23 to something that would be passingly acceptable.
22:25 Um, but the bottom line is our goals,
22:28 Trump's goals in this war were to end Iran's nuclear program,
22:32 end their ballistic missile program,
22:34 end their support for terrorist organizations in the region.
22:38 And there was even a hope for goal
22:40 of fundamentally ending the Islamic Republic of shifting
22:43 the regime's priorities uh by getting new leadership
22:46 that would take them in a different direction.
22:49 So that's what Trump was trying to do.
22:51 But the war hasn't accomplished any of that.
22:54 And Iran is offering literally none of that.
22:57 Right now what Iran is negotiating is we'll
23:00 reopen the strait if you pay us enough money.
23:03 So basically, it puts us in a worse position before this war started.
23:07 Now again, the president has been lying throughout
23:10 this process about Iran's begging for a deal.
23:13 He's been saying Iran's been begging for a deal for 9 years.
23:17 Two weeks ago, he pretended that Iran
23:19 had agreed to everything that I just listed.
23:21 And for 24 hours, people reported on this as if it was a fact,
23:24 as if the president wasn't just making it all up, which he was.
23:28 And then 24 hours later, people reported on, well,
23:31 gosh, how did this deal unravel?
23:33 What I really want people to understand is it wasn't raveled in the first place.
23:38 The president doesn't have Iran anywhere near to agreeing
23:41 to the things he said this war was being fought for.
23:44 Now, we're just trying to figure out how how to get the straight open.
23:47 And the final piece of this, what Trump can hope
23:50 for is that our blockade will fundamentally change everything I just said.
23:55 That Iran will change their mind.
23:57 they they will stop putting all that other stuff off the table,
24:00 stop just saying, "Hey, it's all about the strait and actually negotiate
24:04 what Trump wants them to." Will that blockade
24:07 put enough pressure on Iran to to cause
24:09 such a huge change in their negotiating position?
24:12 Most experts say no, or at least not anytime soon.
24:16 Can I just say our director Josh had this video up to the left of the screen,
24:22 sir, and it looks like some giant marina
24:25 with dozens and dozens and dozens of tankers just parked.
24:29 I mean, it's an extraordinary site.
24:32 But look, let's talk about the administration which on Friday informed
24:35 Congress that the war has been terminated since the ceasefire began,
24:38 allowing the White House now to just blow past
24:41 Friday's 60-day deadline to seek congressional authorization for the war.
24:45 Is there sir any language in the war powers resolution
24:49 indicating the 60-day clock can either be paused or restarted?
24:55 Does the ceasefire meet that criteria?
24:57 Yeah.
24:58 No, there's there's no no language in the war
25:01 powers resolution that says anything of the kind.
25:03 But the thing that's puzzled me about this whole conversation is where did
25:07 the expectation that the Trump administration was
25:09 going to follow the law come from?
25:12 Um, this is not surprising.
25:13 Uh we've been voting gosh for almost since the war
25:17 began to insist that Congress must authorize this war.
25:20 The Republicans in Congress have joined President Trump and violating
25:23 that law and allowing the president to continue to pursue this law,
25:27 this war without congressional authorization.
25:29 So 60 days, 90 days is just a continuation of that same
25:33 disregard for the war powers resolution and the role of Congress.
25:37 And the real issue now is is again how do we get out of this?
25:42 uh because we are fundamentally stuck
25:44 and undermining our credibility day after day.
25:47 So to that end, you've got some Republicans who expressed skepticism when
25:53 Defense Secretary Pete Hgse made the determination that and that argument during
25:58 his Senate testimony on Thursday after
26:00 several said the administration should wind
26:02 down operations at the 60-day mark or at least seek authorization from Congress.
26:07 Will more Republicans join Democrats to reign
26:10 in the president's war powers if he continues circumventing Congress?
26:14 Is this do you think why the administration is
26:17 engaging in this kind of legal slight of hand?
26:21 Look, and to be fair, this is not the first administration to engage in legal
26:25 slight of hand when it comes to the War Powers Resolution.
26:28 Fundamentally, no president has ever accepted the constitutionality of the War
26:32 Powers Resolution and has found creative ways to get around it.
26:36 As for the Republicans,
26:37 again getting into the war powers resolution of that the question,
26:40 do you support this war or don't you?
26:42 Do you think it makes sense for us
26:44 to continue this conflict um right now the Republicans
26:46 for all of their sort of hand ringing
26:49 about the obvious failure of the war to date,
26:51 the costs that we have seen without any benefits,
26:54 they seem unwilling to actually take a vote
26:57 to stop it or or reign the president in.
26:59 But we will keep that pressure up.
27:01 Senate and House will keep these votes because I don't
27:04 think this war is in the best interest of this country.
27:06 It certainly shouldn't have been started in the first place.
27:09 Um, and it is costing us a great deal,
27:11 costing the world even more and not getting us
27:14 the benefits that we were promised by the Trump administration.
27:17 And so to that end, you sparred with Hegth
27:20 over what's actually been accomplished in this war.
27:22 Let's take a listen to that.
27:24 Here it is.
27:25 Their nuclear facilities have been obliterated underground.
27:28 are buried and we're watching them 24/7.
27:32 So we know where any nuclear material here second here.
27:36 We had to start this war you just said 60
27:41 days ago because the nuclear weapon was an imminent threat.
27:45 Now you're saying that it was completely obliterated.
27:49 They had not given up their nuclear ambitions.
27:52 So, Iran has resisted US demands to stop
27:55 enriching uranium and just hand over its fuel stockpile.
27:59 How do you square the secretary's response
28:02 that Iran's nuclear ambitions have not been eliminated,
28:05 but its nuclear program has?
28:07 Look, this is a significant problem.
28:09 It really is.
28:10 And it's a tough problem.
28:12 We don't want Iran to have a nuclear weapon.
28:14 We all agree with that.
28:15 the administration sort of takes the position that as long
28:18 as we say Iran with a nuclear weapon is bad,
28:21 therefore everything we do is right, that that we don't have to question them,
28:24 but there has to be a connection between
28:26 what we're doing and stopping that nuclear weapon.
28:29 And look, I've said this a 100 times since this war started.
28:32 For 15 years, we have been looking in the Armed
28:35 Services Committee at the military options to accomplish that objective.
28:39 And for 15 years, military leadership said,
28:41 sadly, there is no military solution.
28:44 You can set the program back weeks, maybe months,
28:47 probably closer to weeks with a military strike, but ultimately,
28:51 as long as the Iranian regime is in place
28:54 and as long as they have that ambition that Secretary Hegsth described,
28:57 you're going to have to get to a negotiated settlement.
29:00 And and the real tragedy of this is prior to the start of this war,
29:04 Iran was as weak as they had ever been.
29:07 Israel prosecuted their 12-day war against Iran.
29:09 Hezbollah has been weakened.
29:11 Hamas has been weakened.
29:12 Assad is gone in Syria.
29:14 We had Iran in the best possible position to negotiate a deal.
29:18 And instead of doing that, Trump precipitously started this war
29:23 because Benjamin Netanyahu convinced him that we could decapitate the regime,
29:27 which was probably never going to happen in the first place.
29:30 And now we're in a worse position
29:32 than the hardline regime has been strengthened.
29:34 We need a negotiated settlement.
29:35 Final point, of course, we had that negotiated settlement under Obama,
29:40 but but Trump's Obama derangement syndrome, if you will,
29:43 the idea that whatever Obama does must be bad, which is Trump world,
29:47 made him tear tear up an agreement that was actually working.
29:50 It was working to stop Iran from getting a nuclear weapon.
29:53 And now the war has put us in a much weaker position to accomplish that goal.
29:58 But a negotiated settlement is still the only way out of this problem.
30:03 A sobering assessment.
30:05 Congressman Adam Smith, thank you so much.
30:07 All right, it's time for a little math.
30:10 Back in the 1980s, Donald Trump used to say that his penthouse
30:13 luxury apartment in Trump Tower in New York City was 30,000 square ft.
30:17 He even upped it to Forb Forbes once,
30:20 claiming that it was a sprawling 33,000 square ft.
30:23 But public records show that that apartment is 10,996 square ft.
30:27 When it comes to how many rooms make up that penthouse apartment, Thomas Wells,
30:33 a former Trump real estate lawyer,
30:35 once noticed that different publications had wildly
30:37 different counts of the number of rooms.
30:39 Shouldn't be that hard to figure out how many rooms there are in your house.
30:41 Wells said in the 1980s,
30:43 some press reports had Trump living in an apartment with eight rooms.
30:46 Some said 16, maybe 20, or even 30.
30:49 So Wells asked Trump how many rooms were actually in his apartment.
30:54 According to Wells, Trump said, quote,
30:56 "However many they will print." Math doesn't
30:59 seem to be Donald Trump's strong suit.
31:01 Let's start with his calculation of percentages,
31:03 particularly when it comes to how much
31:06 he claims to have reduced prescription drug prices.
31:08 This is what he said he was going to do to drug prices last year.
31:13 Now drug prices are going to be going down 100%,
31:17 400%, 600%, 1,000% in some cases.
31:22 A,000% in some cases.
31:25 And here's how he tried to justify his calculations during a recent event.
31:32 I took a lot of heat and say 500 600.
31:37 But we also say sometimes 50%, 60%, different kind of calculation.
31:42 70 80 and 90%.
31:44 And people understand that better.
31:46 But there are two ways of calculating it.
31:49 But uh either way it doesn't make any difference whether it's 60 70 or 80%.
31:53 Nobody's ever heard of it.
31:55 But it's also 500, 600, 700 depending on the way you want to look at it.
32:01 So the way the way you word the calculation, the way you word the calculation,
32:06 what he's saying, I think, or at least he's trying to say,
32:10 is that his administration has lowered drug prices by 500, 600,
32:14 or even 700% as you heard earlier,
32:16 maybe even a,000%, but sometimes it's 50% or 60%.
32:20 So let's do a little math.
32:22 If something is 100% off, it is free.
32:25 It is being given away.
32:28 No money is exchanging hands at all.
32:31 Reducing drug prices or any prices really
32:34 by more than 100% is generally speaking mathematically impossible.
32:38 If you reduce the price of anything by more than 100%,
32:41 that means when you go to buy that thing,
32:43 you get the thing and you get money back.
32:47 There is no alternative calculation that helps make sense of any of this.
32:51 It's the kind of exaggeration that Trump, the businessman and publicity hog,
32:55 has been using for decades to attract attention.
32:57 But now, not only is the president doing this, but a slew
33:01 of underlings who are willing to dignify
33:03 his arithmetical nonsense are offering similar explanations.
33:06 Well, if the drug was $100 and it raised the price to $600,
33:13 that would be a 600% rise.
33:16 If it drops from 600 to 100, that's a 600% savings.
33:21 Now, if he were in middle school, RFK Jr.
33:24 might get partial credit for showing his work,
33:26 but he would fail the class because his calculations
33:29 and indeed his entire concept conceptualization are all wrong.
33:33 Let's do a quick math lesson here.
33:35 If the price of something goes from $100 to $600, it's an increase of $500.
33:40 Uh you by use as as the denominator,
33:43 it is an increase of 500%, not 600% as RFK Jr.
33:48 says.
33:48 Now, if you take the 500% and you divide 500 by 600,
33:53 the the increase by the final price, you get 0.833, multiply that by 100,
33:59 it's an 83% savings, which means if a price drops from $600 to $100,
34:05 it's an 83% discount, which is certainly something,
34:09 but it's not 400%, 500%, 600%, or a,000%.
34:12 And no, you can't use those things interchangeably.
34:15 Trump and RFK Jr., by the way, are not the only ones engaging in bad math.
34:19 It's caught on with other top government officials, too.
34:21 In this case, what you're about to hear, not only is the math wrong,
34:26 but the p person doing the math thing
34:29 is referring to himself in the third person.
34:32 This FBI director has been on the job
34:35 twice as many days as every director before me.
34:38 What that means is I've taken half as many days off as those before me.
34:43 What that means is I've taken a third less vacation than those before me.
34:48 None of those things are connected.
34:50 Setting aside the fact that that too is mathematical nonsense,
34:54 this might be a good time to point out that Cash
34:57 Patel has been on the job as FBI director for 518 days.
35:02 Jay Edoover was the head of the FBI for 17,524 days.
35:06 There's sure to be a spirit of debate about
35:08 around which FBI director was more interesting in his exploits,
35:10 but generally if I were Cash Patel,
35:12 I'd stay away from the how how hard I work comparisons.
35:15 But even that is all besides the point.
35:18 This administration simply does not use
35:20 real numbers to support its political stances.
35:23 It throws numbers and percentages and fractions around to manipulate how you
35:26 should feel about the job that it's doing or about a particular issue.
35:30 And the numbers are they're inconvenient.
35:33 They just ignore them all together.
35:36 Do you know how much it will cost Americans in terms of their increased
35:41 cost in gas and food over the next year because of the Iran war?
35:46 I would simply ask you what the cost is of an Iranian nuclear bomb.
35:50 I'm going to give you that opportunity.
35:51 I would simply ask you what you're playing gota questions about domestic things.
35:55 I'm not You're asking You're saying it's a gotcha question
35:57 to ask what it's going to be in terms of the increase.
36:00 Why won't you answer what it costs
36:02 to to prevent Iran from getting a nuclear bomb?
36:04 I'll give you that, sir.
36:05 Let me What would it cost?
36:06 What would you pay to ensure Iran doesn't get a nuclear bomb?
36:08 Do you What would you pay?
36:09 Can I reclaim my time?
36:11 Do you not know?
36:11 You had no one do the analysis of what the increased cost
36:14 of gas and food on the American people are going to be.
36:17 What is the cost of Iran holding that straight at issue with nuclear weapons?
36:22 It's $631 billion, which means it's an increase
36:25 of $5,000 a year for American households.
36:28 You deal with vague platitudes.
36:30 But I'm asking you about numbers.
36:32 Like you don't know what gas costs.
36:34 You don't know what food costs.
36:35 You don't know what the operation costs.
36:37 You know, I get sound bites, but how about numbers?
36:42 Turns out there are still real statesmen in this country.
36:46 At least there are over at the Federal Reserve.
36:49 President Trump has spent years smearing, bullying,
36:52 threatening to fire, even criminally investigating Fed Chair Jerome Powell.
36:56 All because Powell would not bend to the president's will.
37:00 And now Powell's term as chair is about to end in a couple of weeks.
37:04 But rather than riding off into the sunset,
37:06 he just announced his plans to stay working at the Fed.
37:11 It's an unusual choice, like who wants to stick around after a demotion,
37:15 but Powell says it is necessary given Trump's legal threats against
37:20 him and the president's ongoing efforts
37:23 to politicize the independent central bank.
37:27 These legal actions by the administration are unprecedented in our 113year
37:32 history and there are ongoing threats uh of additional such actions.
37:36 I I worry that these attacks are battering
37:38 the institution and putting at risk the thing that really
37:41 matters to the public which is the ability
37:44 to conduct monetary policy without taking into consideration political factors.
37:48 It is so important for our economy, for the people that we serve,
37:51 that they can depend over time on a central bank that operates that way,
37:56 free of political influence.
37:58 Powell also had a little fun when asked by a reporter whether
38:02 he plans to keep a low profile while staying on the board.
38:06 Take a look.
38:07 You mentioned that uh staying on as a governor,
38:10 you intend to keep a low profile.
38:13 I'm just wondering if you could give us a little more
38:15 detail on what that looks like and how you can touch.
38:19 Joining us now to discuss University of Michigan professor Justin Wolfers.
38:27 Justin, first like talk to us about Powell's
38:30 decision here and what it means for Fed independence.
38:34 Do you think it was the right choice?
38:36 Do you think it matters?
38:37 What happens to the Fed now that he's sticking around?
38:40 Oh, I thought you meant his decision to tell a joke.
38:44 Um, it's not every day that it's not
38:46 every day that economists have that sense of humor,
38:49 but I you know, and it's only taken Jay like you know what,
38:52 six, seven, eight years to get there.
38:54 So, it's been building towards that moment and it
38:56 was quite an extraordinary moment for the US economy.
38:59 Um, look, so pal, look, it is it's not Trump versus the Fed,
39:05 it's Trump versus the American people.
39:08 The question here is should the Fed make
39:10 policy in the best interest of the American people?
39:12 That's what Congress told it to do.
39:14 That's what Powell and the Fed has been doing.
39:16 What has upset Trump is that he's not doing it
39:19 in the best interest of Trump and Trump's political interests instead.
39:23 So, those are the stakes.
39:25 What cards does does Powell have left?
39:27 He's really only got one, which is his time as chair is over.
39:31 Uh he's not going to be renominated,
39:33 but he has the right to stay on as a governor for several more years still.
39:37 and he's not going to give up that card,
39:39 that bit of leverage in order for Trump to put in uh another sock puppet.
39:43 And so he's going to hold on to that card,
39:45 even if that just means turning up to eight meetings.
39:48 But he's using that card, I think, very much for the best interest of you and I,
39:52 the American people, a way of defending the institution.
39:54 Justin, I was just hoping you could break down what is actually happening
40:00 with the economy right now because the predictions are so all over the place.
40:05 We're nearing a recession.
40:06 All of the value is in AI and that's artificially propping up the economy.
40:11 And then you have Schillers out with a chart saying that uh
40:15 you know stocks haven't looked this overvalued since the dot bubble.
40:19 So what exactly is the health of the economy?
40:23 And I note that the economic experts behind Kowi that are betting
40:29 on the prediction market put the chance of recession from 40% to 17% yesterday.
40:35 Yeah.
40:36 So, um, what's going on with the state of the economy?
40:40 It's really hard to tell.
40:42 That's the most honest answer I can give you.
40:44 Look, I could be like a Wall Street guy and come
40:46 on and tell you confidently I knew exactly what was going on.
40:50 that would make me look amazing, but it wouldn't serve your viewers.
40:54 Um, look, there's a lot of things going.
40:56 The most important thing going on, the most
40:58 important economic thing going on is, in fact, the war on Iran.
41:02 It's not just shutting down global oil markets.
41:05 It's also fundamentally changing America's fiscal position.
41:09 This is already a government which has decided to spend,
41:12 spend, spend, go into debt, debt, debt.
41:14 And more spending on defense is literally hundreds of billions of dollars.
41:18 It's a complete it's a story that's not being told very widely but I think is
41:23 really quite important in terms of the current
41:25 pace of what's going on with the economy.
41:29 Um growth in the last quarter was 2% moderate
41:33 but remember that comes after the end of 2025.
41:36 In the end of 2025 we had a government shutdown.
41:39 And so basically what that did is it moved a whole
41:42 lot of economic activity from late 25 through to 26.
41:45 So the latest numbers look better than reality really is.
41:47 So over the last six months, the economy has grown at one and a quarter%.
41:52 That's what you call disappointing.
41:54 And all of that growth has come from the AI sector.
41:58 So just to add to follow up on that, Justin,
42:02 the stock market is something that Donald Trump loves to tout.
42:05 He lives and dies by it.
42:06 He loves to promote it as if it's the end
42:09 all beall of the American economy with record numbers.
42:11 How do you explain what is happening with the stock market?
42:14 And do you anticipate that there is going to be uh
42:17 a sell-off or a correction when it comes to the stock market specifically?
42:21 Right.
42:22 So, first of all, if I knew which way the stock market was going,
42:26 I wouldn't tell you.
42:27 I just go and get a lot of money, I'd be rich.
42:30 Um, but your question is a good one, and it depends really.
42:34 Markets can embed a lot of information and can in fact be very, very helpful.
42:38 So, I'm not talking about markets because I love
42:40 them or because I want rich people to get richer.
42:42 Um it's because they tell us what they it's
42:45 people betting on the future of the American economy.
42:47 And if the question is is the market doing well
42:50 because of or in spite of what's going on in Iran,
42:54 the answer is overwhelmingly no.
42:55 Because in order to figure out are does the market like what's going on in Iran,
42:59 you'd have to say what does the market look like
43:01 if we are at war versus if we're not at war.
43:03 We don't know both of those things.
43:05 But what we do know is every time
43:07 the president becomes more belligerent, the market falls.
43:10 Every time he deescalates, the market rises.
43:13 The market has a very clear judgment on war in Iran.
43:16 It's very, very bad from American business.
43:18 And global markets think it's even worse in other countries.
43:22 The market as a whole is up.
43:24 That says there are other reasons to be optimistic.
43:26 A big part of that reason is AI, but it's not the whole story.
43:31 So Justin, my colleague Aean just asked about stock markets.
43:34 I also want to ask you about what's going on with with bond
43:38 markets or more specifically Kevin Worsh has basically gotten this job
43:42 or is likely to get the job to succeed Jerome Powell
43:46 as Fed chair because Donald Trump expects him to cut interest rates.
43:50 If you look at where markets are,
43:53 they do not expect interest rate cuts for the basically the foreseeable future,
43:56 at least for the next year and a half.
44:00 Uh, how easy or difficult will it be
44:03 for Worsh to deliver on that expected um rate cut,
44:07 that perhaps promised rate cut that Donald Trump is counting on him to give?
44:14 Yep.
44:14 So, um, let's get the facts out there, which is before the war in Iran,
44:18 markets had factored in two or three more
44:20 rate cuts coming through the rest of this year.
44:23 The war basically has meant the end of those.
44:25 The war raised oil prices, raised inflation,
44:27 made it harder for the Fed to cut rates.
44:29 Markets expect nothing good to happen as a result.
44:32 So markets are saying that Trump has destroyed the rate cuts
44:35 that he hungered for by going to war on a run.
44:37 Now these the moral consequences of each are vastly different.
44:40 I don't want to confound that.
44:42 The question is, can Walsh deliver on what the president wants?
44:46 Um Walsh is the Fed chair.
44:49 Historically, Fed chairs have been very very strong.
44:52 They've usually had the majority with them.
44:54 Now chairs move towards the committee and the thing
44:56 is it's a committee of 12 and trust
44:59 is something that's earned and respect is something
45:01 that's earned and he hasn't earned that yet.
45:03 So expect that Walsh is one of 12 votes rather than the entire Federal
45:07 Reserve which means I think it's unlikely
45:09 we're going to see a particularly doubbish turn.
45:14 Justin Wolfers, thank you so much for being with us.