CARTA: The Human Brain in its Usual, Extraordinary and Compromised States with Bruce Miller
University of California Television (UCTV)
0:26 I am really thrilled and honored to be with CARTA today.
0:31 The topic that was given to me by Pascal Gagneux,
0:35 the human brain in its usual extraordinary and compromised states, is perfect.
0:44 What I will do is tell two different stories
0:47 that I think reflect upon our evolution as a species.
0:52 One is about the up-regulation of artistic creativity
0:57 in a subset of patients with frontotemporal dementia.
1:03 After that, I'm going to describe the loss of our social
1:09 brain functions as we descend into the degeneration of frontotemporal dementia.
1:16 I think both stories give us insights
1:19 into the parts of the brain that evolved in late
1:22 homo sapiens that allowed us to create visual
1:26 art and to live together in large groups.
1:32 There's a story across the world, Lasko in Europe,
1:38 this incredible cave painting in Colombia, recently discovered.
1:44 The story is really both beautiful and simple.
1:48 That is human beings wherever they lived
1:53 began creating art about 40-50,000 years ago.
1:59 The art was spectacular, precise, vibrant,
2:03 and had never appeared like that on the planet before.
2:09 It really strongly suggests that there was
2:12 a change in the human brain that allowed,
2:16 I think, I would even say mandated that we create art.
2:21 I think lots of questions about where in the brain that happened,
2:26 and I'm going to tell you a little story
2:29 about visual creativity in the setting of frontotemporal dementia.
2:34 I began to realize this when I was at UCLA,
2:37 visual creativity in frontotemporal dementia is not rare.
2:41 I would say, it's common in certain sub types.
2:45 People with FTD develop new artistic skills,
2:48 even after the onset of a degenerative disease.
2:52 Remarkable.
2:52 As the brain is suffering from progressive degeneration,
2:57 there is this emergence of something quite extraordinary with visual creativity.
3:04 It's more common, and I'll touch on this much more when
3:08 the anterior temporal lobes or the left frontal lobe show focal degeneration.
3:14 My first paper on this was in 1996, but began to document this story.
3:22 Many people, when I started writing about this said, this is a coincidence.
3:27 It is not a coincidence.
3:29 Almost everything with human behavior,
3:32 it's driven by the up-regulation of very specific circuits in the brain.
3:39 One of the groups, and I'll come back to this again
3:42 and again that is particularly prone to visual creativity,
3:47 this uniquely homo sapiens capacity are patients
3:53 with a diagnosis of the semantic variant of progressive aphasia.
4:00 These people have profound deficits in naming.
4:04 Not only can't they name,
4:05 but they also lose the ability to understand the meaning of word.
4:11 They lose the understanding of single words.
4:15 They have impaired knowledge about objects.
4:18 What is that?
4:19 Not only do they lose the name, they lose the concept of that object.
4:25 They have very specific features with writing and reading,
4:31 they tend to spare repetition and speech production.
4:35 The theme in this subset of patients with frontotemporal dementia,
4:43 is left temporal, particularly anterior temporal lobe degeneration.
4:49 Very focal.
4:50 Other parts of the brain are allowed to continue to function.
4:54 As I'll argue, some areas increase
4:58 activity allowing this unique visual creativity.
5:03 Here's an example of a patient
5:05 with a semantic variant of primary progressive aphasia.
5:09 She's attempting to name simple objects like apple, rabbit, sled, can, and frog.
5:18 You can see her absolute befuddlement as she
5:22 tries to go through this naming exercise.
5:25 Is that a fruit?
5:29 A fruit, but doesn't call it an apple.
5:33 Doesn't know what a rabbit is.
5:36 I don't know what that is.
5:37 Doesn't know what a sled is.
5:40 Can?
5:42 Gets the garbage can.
5:43 I think this is quite remarkable here.
5:47 Cat?
5:49 Cat.
5:50 The very concept, the frog has.
5:55 The cup.
5:57 Good.
5:57 Let me show some more naming.
6:01 She gets the cub.
6:03 Matches.
6:05 Matches.
6:06 Does know what matches are?
6:11 I don't know what the matches are.
6:15 Very focal deficit in naming.
6:20 One of the things that I've documented over
6:23 many years is beginning in Lancet in 1996,
6:28 is the emergence of visual creativity.
6:32 These people become visually obsessed with their world,
6:37 and they use whatever artistic capacity they have to create
6:44 objects or paintings that reflect the environment as they see it.
6:50 This is one of my patients who became remarkably visually creative.
6:55 He was a welder and never had done
6:58 anything with welding before in the artistic area.
7:02 This is his representation of a bird has many
7:05 features of an insect that shows this semantic confusion.
7:10 But the use of color shape and form, I think, is truly extraordinary.
7:17 I own this piece and look at it every day.
7:20 It's wonderful.
7:22 Here's one of the people that we have written about extensively,
7:27 and this is the brilliant scientist Ann Adams,
7:31 who in the setting of a progressive loss of language,
7:36 began to create unbelievable paintings.
7:41 This is Ann's masterpiece,
7:43 written a few years before she manifested with progressive aphasia.
7:48 She became obsessed with Ravel's Bolero, the repetition,
7:54 the crescendo, the lack of change until the 323rd meter,
8:02 where there was gaudy fluorescent pinks that represent the change in key.
8:08 Ann became obsessed with Ravel, in particular,
8:12 this piece that Ravel described as an experiment in sound, but not true music.
8:19 A few years later, Ann had evidence for progressive aphasia.
8:26 Bill Seely, from our group was able to compare Ann Adams's brain at the time
8:33 that she produced unraveled with the brains of 30 age matched control women,
8:39 very high education like Ann.
8:42 The remarkable story is just before Ann developed progressive aphasia,
8:48 she showed massive atrophy in the left frontal opercular region.
8:54 Statistically different than 30 age match controls,
8:58 but also increased volume, yes, increased volume in the regions of the brain
9:05 that I think are critical for the creation of art,
9:09 the right posterior parietal temporal and occipital regions.
9:15 The brain is reshaping with this degenerative disease
9:19 as one circuit turns down the back of the brain, particularly on the right,
9:25 becomes overactive and becomes visually obsessed
9:31 and creates a series of magnificent paintings.
9:36 This is the last example of Ann's work.
9:41 Her husband took her in 2004, this point, having trouble with the right hand,
9:47 completely mute and asked her to enjoy this city in Belgium,
9:53 Gent, the picture that she made on the left,
9:57 remarkably, she made this after she returned, no pictures, nothing.
10:02 Looks remarkably like the picture that Robert Adams
10:06 had taken of Gent and remembered this, re-imagined it,
10:12 and replicated into a gorgeous painting on Canvas.
10:17 This is the artist that really changed the way
10:21 Bill Seely and I think about art in the brain.
10:24 One of the most remarkable aspects of this story is that Maurice Ravel,
10:30 who created Bolero developed progressive aphasia
10:36 just before he created his masterpiece, Bolero.
10:42 These two people separated by almost a century
10:45 locked together with the same neurodegenerative disease,
10:51 we believe Ann would never have created
10:54 art if the progressive aphasia had not happened.
10:58 Similarly, Ravel would never have produced Bolero
11:01 if he was not suffering from this focal
11:05 degeneration in the left front of the brain
11:07 that released posterior circuits involved with his creativity.
11:13 This story has been put into a play
11:16 that showed at the Annenberg Center in Los Angeles.
11:19 We'll soon tour across the country.
11:21 It's a beautiful story of Ravel and Adams, the uniqueness of human creativity,
11:28 and it shows a story of Ann as her artistic ability evolved.
11:37 Adit Freiberg, along with Bill Seely and I looked at all
11:41 of the artists that we had ever seen in whom we documented visual creativity.
11:46 I think this vastly underestimates the number of people
11:51 who became visually preoccupied or creative in our setting.
11:56 But we found that about 2.5% of our FTD spectrum
12:03 patients had developed visual creativity in the setting of degenerative disease.
12:09 This just is extremely rare, almost never occurs in Alzheimer's disease.
12:15 Even more remarkably,
12:18 almost 70% of the artists had this semantic variant of frontotemporal dementia,
12:24 which I gave you an example of a few slides earlier.
12:28 In most of these people, the artistic creativity was de novo.
12:33 Seven of the 17 had some prior interest.
12:38 There were only two people who were
12:40 actually artists before the onset of the disease,
12:43 and they were dramatically changed, we think, for the better.
12:46 What did we find in our artist, severe atrophy in the anterior temporal lobe,
12:52 amygdala, left side in particular, ventral striatum and insula.
12:59 A very specific focal degeneration in a language circuit.
13:04 All of the patients with FTD,
13:07 and you can see this had up-regulation and posterior circuits.
13:14 But the thing that separated the artists from those who did not become artists
13:19 was strong correlation between the left motor
13:24 strip and this posterior dorsal parietal occipital region.
13:30 The summary of these artists was the visual creativity occurred early in FTD.
13:36 Strongly associated with degeneration of the anterior temporal lobe,
13:41 and we think that this suggests that damaged
13:44 regions normally suppress dorso-medial occipital cortical circuits.
13:50 When you lose those regions,
13:52 there is increased curiosity, activity in the visual cortex,
13:56 and in many people, it actually leads to artistic creativity.
14:02 This is the region that we need for visual creativity,
14:07 posterior brain, in particular right more than left.
14:12 What did the art look like, bright colors,
14:14 rarely focused on human faces, no surprise,
14:18 anterior temporal lobes, process human faces.
14:22 You can see these gorgeous animals, cartoons, motor car.
14:30 Two of the semantic variant PPA patients generated animal sculpture,
14:35 but lacking the features of the species, you saw the bird.
14:39 When facial expressions were present,
14:41 they were bizarre, did not convey normal emotions.
14:45 The art is unique in the vibrance of his colors,
14:50 but also in the lack of human faces and emotion.
14:54 That's one story.
14:56 The second story is social
15:00 decline in behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia.
15:04 Around 40-50,000 years ago, we humans began to live in larger and larger groups.
15:10 Eventually, by 10,000 years ago, we had large societies where people live,
15:18 work together, developed rules,
15:20 and needed very strong circuitry that I call social brain.
15:27 What do we see in behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia,
15:31 loss of altruism, loss of emotional regulation, loss of empathy,
15:37 inappropriate behavior toward others,
15:39 and loss of the human characteristic that allowed us to live in large groups.
15:45 This disappeared.
15:46 One of the stories that Bill Seeley has
15:50 developed is the story of these phylogenetically new neurons,
15:53 Von Economo neurons.
15:55 They are largely a feature of big brain social species,
16:01 elephants, the cetaceans, and the great apes.
16:07 We have far more of these Von Economo
16:10 neurons than our nearest relative, the bonobo chimp.
16:15 This is a feature in particular of right frontal insular brain.
16:21 We have twice as many of these van
16:23 economo neurons on the right side of the brain,
16:26 which is strongly devoted to social behavior than we do on the left.
16:31 One of the features of these animals that have
16:36 van economo neurons is they have theory of mind.
16:39 They can look at their own face in a mirror and recognize that that is me.
16:45 This is one aspect of this social cognition.
16:49 How am I different from others?
16:50 How do I treat others?
16:52 These are the things that soon follow.
16:55 As we have learned, the van economo neuron
16:59 count is normal in Alzheimer's disease and, of course,
17:03 in healthy controls in front of temporal dementia,
17:07 profound loss of van economo neurons and the related fork neurons.
17:13 Not only does this happen in FTD, we think in behavioral variant FTD,
17:18 it is usually the first neuron to die.
17:22 A phylogenetically new neuron involved with social cognition is lost,
17:29 then we lose our capacity to interact in an altruistic way with others.
17:35 What happens when van economo neurons are lost, we lose social brain circuits,
17:41 we lose theory of mind, we lose altruism,
17:44 we lose empathy, we lose emotional regulation.
17:49 We lose this social brain capacity that evolve late in our species.
17:57 My conclusions art emerges with homo sapiens,
18:02 changes in posterior parietal regions, posterior temporal regions.
18:08 I think that must explain the difference
18:12 between our species and prior homo species.
18:16 The artistic creativity emerges in association with left hemisphere dysfunction,
18:23 particularly left temporal.
18:25 This leads to rewiring of posterior brain,
18:29 up rate collating circuits that we need to develop art.
18:33 Social brain emerges with homo sapiens evolution,
18:38 we lose social brain with behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia.
18:42 This correlates loss of new neurons,
18:45 the van economo neurons in the right frontal region.
18:49 This story gives us insight into the degenerative process,
18:54 which is very focal and gives insights into our humanity.
19:00 I think one of the things I've learned from this story is
19:03 that brain asymmetry is both at the core of our strengths and weaknesses.
19:09 Thank you.