The Making of the Modern Middle East
RealLifeLore
0:02 Throughout all of our lifetimes,
0:03 the Middle East is a region that has been nearly synonymous with warfare,
0:06 instability, and conflict.
0:08 You have heard nearly every single year of your life
0:10 about some kind of conflict going on in this place,
0:13 regardless of when you were born,
0:14 because conflicts have been raging here without a pause
0:17 for nearly the entirety of the past century.
0:19 Just since the turn of the 21st century alone,
0:22 there have been major wars fought across the territories of Iraq,
0:24 Syria, Lebanon, Israel, Palestine,
0:26 and Yemen that have variously attracted the military involvements of Iran,
0:29 Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, the United Arab Emirates, Turkey,
0:32 and powers from even beyond the Middle East,
0:34 like the United States, United Kingdom, France, and Russia.
0:37 These 21st century conflicts in the Middle East
0:39 alone have claimed the lives of millions of people,
0:42 and forced millions more into exile and refugee status,
0:45 while costing trillions of dollars,
0:47 making the Middle East arguably the most geopolitically
0:49 turbulent region anywhere in the 21st century world.
0:53 But why is this part of the world the way that it is?
0:56 Why do you always hear about wars and conflicts taking place here?
0:59 And why will you probably continue hearing about wars
1:02 and conflicts taking place here for the rest of your life?
1:05 The answers [snorts] to those questions are complex,
1:07 because the modern Middle East is the most
1:09 geopolitically complicated chessboard in the world to really understand.
1:13 With dozens of different actors and competing interests all variously working
1:16 against each other at sometimes and then working together at others.
1:20 But in order to understand the root
1:21 cause of the modern Middle East's many problems,
1:24 you only have to rewind the clock a little more than a hundred years
1:26 ago to learn how the Middle East borders we know today came into being,
1:30 and why they have guaranteed more than a centuries worth
1:34 of forever wars and misery for the entire world ever since.
1:37 For many centuries, the Turkish
1:39 Ottoman Empire dominated practically the entirety
1:41 of the Middle East and enforced its own rule of law across the land.
1:45 Dozens of ethnicities, languages,
1:47 and religions all composed the extremely diverse peoples of the empire
1:50 that at one point spanned from Hungary to Yemen.
1:53 The Ottoman Empire had regions within it, but it had no tolerance for nations,
1:57 and nationalism within the empire of any kind was always ruthlessly
2:01 repressed and crushed in the name of greater imperial stability and peace.
2:05 But the Ottoman Empire eventually entered into a long period of gradual decline,
2:09 and by the 19th century,
2:10 the rising British Empire was growing increasingly interested in the Middle
2:14 East that the Ottomans had so thoroughly dominated for so long.
2:17 The Middle East, you see, geographically stood in the way between the British
2:21 Home Islands and the Crown's most important colony, India.
2:24 In order to better safeguard British ships
2:25 traveling between India and the Home Islands,
2:27 the British began gradually acquiring protectorates across the Middle East,
2:31 beginning with the modern United Arab Emirates in 1820,
2:33 and then gradually expanding from there to include Southern Yemen,
2:36 Bahrain, and eventually Egypt itself in 1888.
2:39 Nearly 20 years after the Suez Canal had first been completed,
2:42 which granted the British the quickest possible journey time between the Home
2:45 Islands and India by way across the Mediterranean and the Red Sea.
2:49 The Suez Canal, owned by British
2:50 and French shareholders despite running through Egypt,
2:53 was therefore one of Britain's most geopolitically valuable assets,
2:56 and they intended to ensure their continuous access to it
2:59 by forcing Egypt into the status of a protectorate.
3:02 The British further established protectorates over
3:04 Oman and Kuwait, and then in 1914, alarmed by the increasing British meddling
3:09 in the Middle East and their internal affairs,
3:11 the Ottoman Empire took the decision to join
3:13 the First World War on the side of Imperial Germany.
3:16 It was shortly after that, when the British and the French decided
3:18 that the Ottoman Empire would have to be completely destroyed by them.
3:22 But it was initially unclear what exactly would take
3:24 the place of the centuries-old rule of the Ottomans.
3:28 In 1916, British and French diplomats named Mark [music] Sykes
3:31 and François Georges Picot negotiated
3:33 a secret treaty regarding how their respective
3:35 governments would divide and partition the lands of the Ottoman Empire
3:38 between themselves after the war's
3:40 conclusion and the ancient empire's destruction.
3:43 The agreement became simply known as the Sykes-Picot Agreement,
3:46 and basically went as follows.
3:48 This zone would fall under direct colonial British rule.
3:51 This zone would in time become
3:52 an independent Arab state under British influence.
3:55 This zone would fall under direct colonial French rule.
3:58 This zone would in time become another independent Arab state,
4:00 but under French influence.
4:02 This zone would be given to the Russian Empire,
4:04 while the region of Palestine and Jerusalem,
4:06 with its immense religious significance, would be placed under some kind
4:10 of as of yet unspecified international administration.
4:13 These initial political lines that the British and French
4:15 diplomats drew across the Middle East for the future
4:18 of the region in 1916 paid little attention to the complex
4:22 real borders of the Middle East's various religious beliefs,
4:24 languages, and ethnicities.
4:26 But the lines were also not just arbitrarily drawn, either.
4:30 While not based on ethnicity, language, or religion,
4:32 or really even geography in many cases,
4:35 the lines were instead based upon the older
4:37 Ottoman internal divisions that they had created,
4:40 which also had little to no regard
4:42 for ethnic or religious boundaries in their vast ethnically,
4:45 linguistically, and religiously diverse empire,
4:48 where nationalism and separatism was never tolerated.
4:51 The British zone initially encompassed the Ottomans' provinces of Baghdad
4:54 and Basra and parts of Deir ez-Zor and Damascus,
4:57 while the French zone initially encompassed the Ottomans' provinces of Mosul,
5:00 Deir ez-Zor, Aleppo, Adana, Beirut, and Lebanon,
5:03 while the international Palestine area was
5:05 based on the province of Jerusalem itself,
5:07 that reported directly to the Ottoman capital.
5:09 This was the map that Sykes and Picot
5:11 drafted their own new lines atop of in 1916, rather than any detailed ethnic,
5:17 linguistic, or religious map of the region,
5:19 resulting in massive consequences that have
5:22 reverberated down the decades ever since.
5:24 The initial terms of the 1916 Sykes-Picot Agreement were then
5:28 even further complicated by several
5:29 other British wartime promises, and assumptions.
5:33 In order to encourage an Arab revolt against their Turkish overlords,
5:36 many British officials guaranteed that they would favor the creation of a large,
5:40 unified Arab state [music] across the Arab lands following the end of the war.
5:45 At nearly the same time though,
5:46 in 1917, Britain also proclaimed the Balfour Declaration,
5:50 which promised that the British government would favor the creation
5:53 of a national home for the Jewish people in the land of Palestine.
5:56 And then finally, there was the question of oil.
5:59 Oil had been first discovered in the Middle
6:01 East in a remote part of Iran in 1908, that the British subsequently dominated
6:05 through their state-owned Anglo-Persian Oil Company,
6:08 which would later evolve into the British Petroleum,
6:10 or BP company that we know of today.
6:13 But Iran's oil at the time wasn't considered enough.
6:16 World War I was proving to everyone involved how critical oil was
6:19 becoming as a strategic resource to fuel the new machines of war,
6:23 from battleships to airplanes, and the United States was at that time
6:26 by far the world's largest producer and supplier of oil.
6:30 America therefore provided the British Empire with most of their oil needs.
6:34 But America's president of the time was also Woodrow Wilson,
6:37 a man who was staunchly opposed to the concept of empires in the post-war world,
6:42 including Britain's.
6:43 So, believing America to be a potentially unreliable
6:46 provider of oil to their empire in the future,
6:48 the British government was at the time highly incentivized to acquire influence
6:52 and control over as much of the Middle East nearby to Iran as possible,
6:57 where they believed that potential future massive oil
7:00 deposits would be later discovered and owned by them,
7:03 providing Britain with the critical oil it would need
7:05 to fight through whatever conflict would come to them next.
7:09 After World War I concluded,
7:10 the victorious allies met at Versailles in 1919 to set the terms of the peace,
7:15 and the borders of the Middle East were shifted once again.
7:18 The Ottoman province of Mosul was transferred from the French
7:20 zone of influence over to the British zone of influence,
7:23 and as the Ottoman Empire was actively collapsing,
7:25 the allies pressed the infamous terms of the Treaty
7:27 of Sèvres upon the dying empire in 1920.
7:31 The terms of which made even the Treaty
7:32 of Versailles that was pressed upon Germany seem fairly generous.
7:36 The terms of the previous Sykes-Picot Agreement
7:38 between Britain and France would remain intact.
7:41 With the Russian Empire now gone, a huge independent state of Armenia was
7:45 to be carved out of northeastern Anatolia.
7:47 Another independent state for the Kurdish people was
7:49 to be further carved out of southeastern Anatolia.
7:52 Italy was to seize control over several of the empire's Aegean islands.
7:55 Greece was to annex much of eastern Thrace and a chunk
7:58 around the city of İzmir on the Anatolian mainland,
8:00 while the area around the strategically important Turkish straits was
8:03 to fall under an international
8:05 regime outside of Turkey's remaining jurisdiction.
8:08 The Turkish state that was to be left over was
8:10 doomed to become nothing more than an insignificant rump state.
8:13 And thus, outraged by the treaty's terms,
8:16 the emerging Turkish government almost immediately rebelled and continued
8:20 fighting against the allies for the next two years.
8:23 After the Turkish forces made significant military gains on the battlefield,
8:26 they forced to return back to the negotiating table again,
8:30 and concluded with the terms of the 1923 Treaty of Lausanne,
8:33 which replaced the terms of the previous Treaty
8:35 of Sèvres and were far more favorable to Turkey.
8:38 Finally, the borders of the modern Middle East as we
8:41 roughly know them as today were set in ink.
8:43 But the terms of Lausanne in 1923
8:46 still left many questions and problems unresolved.
8:49 There would be no independent state created for the Kurdish people after all,
8:52 for example, a problem that has vexed the region for the century ever since.
8:56 Today, the Kurds are one of the largest stateless people in the world,
8:59 numbering some 40 million strong with their own separate ethnic,
9:03 cultural, and linguistic identity,
9:05 but divided between the borders of what became Turkey, Syria, Iraq, and Iran,
9:09 where in all four countries they are minority groups
9:12 and have often been subject to persecution and discrimination.
9:15 Kurdish nationalism and separatism,
9:17 and the desire to create an independent Kurdish state out of these areas,
9:20 has been a constant flashpoint of conflict in this region ever since.
9:24 The British also smooshed together
9:26 the former Ottoman provinces of Mosul, Baghdad,
9:29 and Basra into their mandate for Mesopotamia,
9:32 which would later evolve into the state of Iraq.
9:34 But the problem with that was that all three
9:36 of those Ottoman provinces contained very
9:39 different people with very different interests, identities, and beliefs.
9:43 The people of Mosul were mostly ethnically Kurdish.
9:46 The people of the Baghdad province were primarily Sunni Muslim Arabs,
9:49 while the people of the Basra province were mostly Shia Muslim Arabs.
9:53 Even further, what became Kuwait had also been
9:56 a formal part of the Basra province under
9:58 the Ottoman administration until the British showed up
10:01 and transformed it into a protectorate of theirs.
10:04 After World War I, the British legally separated
10:07 Kuwait from the Basra province and from Iraq,
10:10 and they kept Kuwait as their own protectorate until the 1960s,
10:14 which in the end would give the Iraqi state a decent historical claim
10:18 to Kuwait that would eventually be acted
10:19 upon by Saddam Hussein's invasion in 1990.
10:23 Iraq became independent from the British mandate in 1932 and emerged
10:26 as a deeply internally fragmented state with a historical claim on Kuwait.
10:32 And it was also almost completely landlocked with only a tiny sliver
10:36 of a coastline on the Persian Gulf wedged in between Kuwait and Iran.
10:40 And it further controlled neither of the headwaters for the two
10:43 great rivers that it would rely so heavily upon for its civilization,
10:47 the Tigris and Euphrates,
10:49 both of which begin further to the north within Turkey.
10:52 The French mandates weren't created much better either.
10:54 The Lebanon province of the Ottoman Empire
10:56 was deliberately separated as an independent state
10:58 by the French based on that province's
11:00 slight religious majority of Christians at the time.
11:03 But it had very significant minorities of Sunni
11:05 and Shia Arabs and Druze Arabs as well.
11:08 Meanwhile, the polyglot Ottoman provinces of Aleppo, Beirut, Damascus,
11:12 and Deir ez-Zor were all smooshed together to form what became Syria,
11:16 putting large numbers of Sunni Kurds, Sunni Arabs, Alawite Shia Arabs,
11:20 and Christian Assyrians and Arabs all into the same country.
11:24 And then in the 1930s,
11:26 the Turkish government began pressuring the French to cede over
11:29 the Syrian province of Alexandretta owing
11:32 to that province's large Turkish community,
11:34 fearing that if they did not yield to the Turkish
11:36 demands that Turkey may join in an alliance with Nazi Germany.
11:40 The French relented and pushed out Alexandretta from the Syrian
11:43 mandate as the independent state of Hatay in 1938.
11:47 Then the following year in 1939,
11:49 the independent Hatay state held a highly controversial
11:52 referendum on annexation into Turkey that was passed,
11:56 resulting in it entering Turkey as the Hatay province.
11:59 And ever since then,
12:00 the government of what would later become Syria has continually
12:03 claimed the Hatay province as rightfully
12:05 Syrian territory under Turkish occupation.
12:08 And even further, the headwaters for the Euphrates River
12:11 that runs all across Syria begins up in Turkey as well,
12:15 meaning that Turkish-built dams on the Euphrates and the Tigris
12:19 present direct challenges to both Syria's and Iraq's supplies of water,
12:23 leading to further sources of potential conflict between Iraq
12:26 and Syria on one side and Turkey on the other.
12:29 Lebanon became independent from the French mandate in 1943 and Syria in 1946.
12:35 And Syria immediately emerged with territorial disputes with Turkey
12:38 over Hatay and territorial claims to the whole
12:41 of Lebanon based on the French decision
12:43 to artificially separate it based on religious demographics,
12:47 while being itself a deeply internally fragmented state along
12:50 sectarian and ethnic lines just like Iraq and also Lebanon.
12:55 Then all of these political divisions created
12:57 by the Allies' mapmaking between 1916 and 1923 were even
13:01 further exacerbated by the future discoveries of oil
13:04 and gas across all of these brand new countries.
13:07 Oil was only first discovered in Iraq in 1927,
13:11 years after the borders had already been drawn and settled,
13:14 marking the first major discovery of oil in the Arab world.
13:17 Future initial discoveries of oil were made in Kuwait
13:19 and Saudi Arabia a decade later in 1938.
13:22 And then much later in Syria and the United
13:25 Arab Emirates in 1956 and 1958 respectively.
13:28 But the locations of where the oil
13:31 and gas reserves were to be discovered across all
13:33 of these new countries in nearly every single case
13:36 would ensure generations of nearly continuous conflict over them.
13:40 Within Iraq, oil was discovered across
13:42 the former Ottoman provinces of Basra and Mosul,
13:44 home to the Shia Arab and Sunni Kurdish communities,
13:47 but hardly any oil at all would be discovered in the central
13:50 Baghdad province that was primarily home to the Sunni Arabs.
13:54 Even further, an overwhelming 90% of all of Iran's oil
13:58 reserves would simply be discovered within the Iranian province of Khuzestan,
14:02 which encompasses an exposed flat plain on the western side of the Zagros
14:06 Mountains that otherwise largely forms the rest of Iran's westernmost borders.
14:10 [music] And even further,
14:11 Khuzestan was primarily inhabited by Shia Arabs rather than the Shia
14:16 Persians who made up the majority of the rest of the country.
14:19 Kuwait, though small in size, also had enormous oil reserves nearly equal
14:24 to the entirety of Iraq's oil reserves.
14:26 And of course, Iraq contained the historical claim to Kuwait,
14:30 a card that could be theoretically deployed at any
14:32 time to double the Iraqi state's oil resources.
14:35 In Saudi Arabia, home to the largest share of the Persian Gulf's oil,
14:39 the oil would be almost entirely discovered in just
14:41 a small area of the eastern side of the country
14:44 near to the waters of the Gulf itself within
14:46 lands that were home to Saudi Arabia's Shia Muslim minority,
14:50 while hardly any at all would be discovered in the Sunni majority areas.
14:54 And then in Syria, the oil was found
14:55 almost entirely in the east and the northeast
14:58 of the country in the lands of the Sunni Kurds and the Sunni Arabs,
15:02 while hardly any at all was discovered
15:04 in the Alawite Shia Arab lands of the west.
15:07 All in all, the oil found across the Middle
15:09 East scattered across the complicated mosaic of competing ethnic, religious,
15:14 and political identities would prove to make up nearly
15:16 half of the entire world's known supply of oil,
15:20 meaning that outside powers like the British,
15:21 the Soviets, and eventually the Americans
15:24 were all going to be permanently interested
15:27 in influencing the region's events atop all of the dozens of local ethnic,
15:32 religious, and political interests and actors
15:34 seeking to influence events as well.
15:36 And then the British did something else in the Middle East as well.
15:40 They created a Jewish state out of their other mandate
15:43 on the other side of the Middle East in Palestine.
15:46 In the wake of the Holocaust perpetrated by Nazi Germany in Europe,
15:49 hundreds of thousands of Jewish refugees had been fleeing
15:53 for their lives to the British mandate for Palestine,
15:56 encouraged by the British government's own promises for a Jewish
15:59 homeland made in the Balfour Declaration of 1917.
16:02 And in the process, changing the mandate's demographics,
16:05 which had previously been almost entirely populated by Arabs.
16:09 As Britain prepared to release the mandate for Palestine
16:11 as an independent state following the end of World War II,
16:14 the newly created United Nations released a plan for the partition
16:17 of mandatory Palestine in 1947 between a newly created
16:21 Jewish state and a Palestinian Arab state and an international
16:25 administration placed in control over the holy city of Jerusalem.
16:28 The plan was accepted by most of the Jewish groups,
16:31 but nearly universally rejected by most of the Arab groups on the basis
16:35 that the proposal was too unfair and tilted too much towards the Jewish side.
16:40 Despite the Palestinian Arab population at the time in mandatory Palestine
16:44 being more than twice as many as the Jewish population was,
16:47 the 1947 UN partition plan called for giving
16:51 the Jewish state 62% of the mandate's land,
16:55 while only 38% of the land would be allocated to the Arab state.
16:59 Fighting between the Arabs and the Jews in mandatory
17:01 Palestine escalated and as the British withdrew in 1948,
17:05 the state of Israel declared its independence,
17:08 thus starting the continuous Arab-Israeli conflict that has remained ever since.
17:13 Not one Arab country in the world
17:15 would recognize Israel's existence as legitimate at first,
17:18 and a coalition of mostly recently created or independent Arab states went
17:22 to war with Israel in 1948 in support of the Palestinian Arab cause.
17:27 Israel ended up emerging victorious in that war and ended up
17:30 in control over all the lands that the UN had assigned
17:32 to the Jewish state in the 1947 partition plan in addition to 60%
17:37 of the UN-proposed Arab state's land and the western half of Jerusalem,
17:41 while Jordan occupied and then annexed
17:43 the Palestinian-assigned West Bank and international East Jerusalem,
17:47 while Egypt occupied the Palestinian-assigned Gaza
17:49 Strip and transformed it into a protectorate.
17:51 No independent Palestinian Arab state would end up emerging and an estimated
17:56 700,000 Palestinian Arabs were exiled
17:59 or became refugees displaced from their homes,
18:02 with many of them fleeing into neighboring Lebanon in an event
18:05 that they referred to as the Nakba or the catastrophe,
18:08 which would gradually alter that country's
18:10 demographics to being more Muslim-dominated,
18:13 leading to future internal demographic conflict in that country like
18:16 the long Lebanese Civil War that would last between 1975 and 1990.
18:21 At the same time, hundreds of thousands of additional Jews would migrate
18:25 towards Israel from the shattered communities
18:28 left behind by the Nazis in Europe,
18:30 further tilting Israel's demographics more in favor of Jews.
18:34 The defeat of the Arabs against Israel in 1948 gave
18:37 way to the rise of Gamal Abdel Nasser in Egypt,
18:40 a secular Arab nationalist who dreamed of unifying
18:43 all of the Arab lands in the Middle East
18:45 beneath a single Arab superpower state that would utilize
18:48 most of the Middle East's oil as their superweapon,
18:51 a superweapon that he hoped would lead to the defeat
18:54 of Israel and its primary backer, the United States.
18:58 Nasser came to power in Egypt in 1954,
19:01 and he would only be the first of many post-World War II Middle Eastern leaders
19:05 who would set about to change the map
19:07 of the region set into place by Sykes-Picot.
19:10 He railed against not only Israel and the United States,
19:13 but against the Arab monarchies like Saudi Arabia and Kuwait as well,
19:17 whom he saw as corrupted and who were actively developing
19:20 closer relations to the United States over their vast oil resources.
19:24 In 1956, Nasser took the fateful decision of nationalizing
19:28 the Suez Canal and destroying the ownership structure
19:31 over it that had been dominated by the foreign
19:33 British and French shareholders for nearly a century.
19:36 The British, French, and Israelis all retaliated with war and an invasion
19:40 of Egypt to try and regain colonial control over the canal.
19:43 But this time, both the United States and the Soviet
19:45 Union alike rebuked the colonial invaders and Egypt emerged victorious,
19:50 catapulting Nasser and his flavor of secular Arab nationalism
19:53 to the status of much of the Arab world's new champion.
19:57 In 1958, a coup by military officers
19:59 in Syria pledging personal loyalty to Nasser took over the country and joined it
20:03 with Egypt in the short-lived United Arab Republic,
20:06 which only fell apart just 3 years later in 1961 when another group
20:10 of Syrian officers launched another coup
20:13 and restored Syria again as an independent nation.
20:16 Civil war in North Yemen exploded the following
20:18 year in 1962 when the monarchist government
20:21 there and Nasserist-style Arab nationalist Republican rebels leading
20:25 to the modern Middle East's first proxy conflict.
20:28 The monarchist Middle Eastern states like Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Jordan,
20:31 and Imperial Iran all bulked at the prospect of a revolution
20:35 in Yemen toppling the monarchy there and then spreading to their own monarchies.
20:40 And so they all intervened militarily on behalf of the Yemeni monarchist regime.
20:44 While Nasser, wanting to spread the cause of Arab nationalism and unity,
20:48 massively supported the nationalist rebels by sending tens
20:51 of thousands of Egyptian troops and copious volumes of weapons.
20:55 The war ended up turning into Egypt's version of the Vietnam war,
20:59 consuming enormous amounts of manpower
21:01 and resources and developing into a stalemate,
21:04 greatly weakening the Egyptian armed forces in the process.
21:07 By 1967, Nasser was again threatening war with Israel over on another front.
21:12 But, encouraged by Egyptian defeats in Yemen,
21:15 the Israelis decided to strike first.
21:18 Surprise Israeli airstrikes against Egyptian forces caught them completely
21:21 off guard leading to rapid Israeli military gains against Egypt,
21:25 Jordan, and Syria in what would become known as the Six-Day War.
21:28 Israel ended the war by occupying the Golan Heights from Syria,
21:32 the West Bank and East Jerusalem from Jordan,
21:34 and the Gaza Strip and the Sinai Peninsula from Egypt,
21:37 placing Israeli forces on the entire Eastern bank of the Suez Canal itself,
21:41 which caused Egypt to shut the canal down
21:43 to all maritime traffic for the next 8 years.
21:46 Jewish Israeli settlers would then begin to move
21:49 in and colonize all of the recently occupied territories,
21:52 leading to further conflicts between the Israeli
21:54 state and the Arab and Islamic worlds.
21:57 And then, crushed and humiliated by the defeat,
22:00 Nasser was forced to withdraw from the war in Yemen and died
22:03 shortly afterwards from a heart attack at just 52 years old in 1970.
22:07 It was also around that time that the British
22:09 Empire decided that they can no longer financially maintain
22:12 their commitments to security in the Middle East and the Persian
22:14 [music] Gulf and critically all of the oil there.
22:18 In 1971, the British protectorates of Bahrain, Qatar,
22:21 and the modern United Arab Emirates
22:23 in the Gulf were all finally granted their independence.
22:26 And without the British there any longer,
22:28 the United States began taking an increased interest in the region instead,
22:32 wishing to maintain the status quo and regional stability
22:35 in the Gulf in order to safeguard the world supply of oil.
22:38 In contrast to the frequent wars that were being
22:40 fought over on the other side of the Middle East,
22:42 the United States began encouraging their ally at the time,
22:45 Imperial Iran, to step forward as the new guarantor of the region's security
22:50 and to block the expansion of the Soviets from entering into the Gulf.
22:54 Massive amounts of American weapon sales were made
22:56 to arm Imperial Iran for this exact purpose,
23:00 a policy that would quickly backfire very badly.
23:03 But on the other side of the Middle East,
23:05 Nasser's Arab nationalist successor in Egypt,
23:07 Anwar Sadat, and the recently risen to power Arab nationalist in Syria,
23:11 Hafez al-Assad, decided to join forces again and attack Israel
23:16 in order to reclaim the occupied Golan Heights and the Sinai Peninsula.
23:19 Israel once again emerged victorious in that war,
23:21 but fearful that they would not always
23:23 be so capable of winning surrounded by enemies,
23:26 the 1973 Yom Kippur War paved the way for peace between Egypt and Israel 6 years
23:32 later in 1979 following the Camp David Accords
23:36 negotiated by the Carter administration in the United States,
23:39 in which Israel agreed to dismantle all
23:41 of their settlements in the Sinai Peninsula
23:43 and return it back to Egypt in exchange
23:46 for Egypt recognizing the legitimacy of Israel's statehood,
23:49 which made Egypt the first country in the entire Arab world
23:53 to ever do so after more than 30 years of Israel's existence.
23:58 Peace between Israel and Egypt had at last been achieved,
24:01 but the peace was denounced by every other Arab state in the world,
24:05 including most of all by Syria,
24:07 which by that time was under the nearly totalitarian regime of Hafez
24:11 al-Assad and his brand of extremely
24:14 militant secular Arab nationalism or Ba'athism.
24:17 Egypt was expelled from the Arab League for decade over the peace agreement.
24:21 Sadat himself was assassinated by Egyptian Islamist
24:24 militants who believed that he was a traitor,
24:27 and Syria began championing itself as the new
24:30 primary backer of the Palestinian Arab cause.
24:33 As more and more of Palestinian refugees fled into neighboring Lebanon,
24:36 that country's extremely diverse demographics began tilting
24:40 ever more in favor of the Muslims to the point where the Christians eventually
24:43 became less than half of the overall population.
24:46 The Lebanese Christians had generally dominated the government
24:49 and they generally sided with Israel and the Western world,
24:52 while the Lebanese Sunni and Shia Muslims generally
24:54 sided with the Arab and Muslim world instead,
24:57 eventually culminating in the explosion of a complex and multi-sided civil
25:01 war beginning in 1975 that would last for 15 years until 1990.
25:06 Ba'athist Syria would invade Lebanon in 1976 and then
25:10 spent years attempting to integrate and annex the country
25:12 directly into Syria based on the separation
25:15 that the French had done with their map-making after Sykes-Picot.
25:18 Israel would also invade Lebanon in their attempts to fight against
25:21 Palestinian forces there and secure the safety of their northern border,
25:24 leading to direct Israeli and Syrian fighting in the country as well.
25:27 The Israeli occupation in Lebanon would only end in 2000,
25:30 while the Syrian occupation only ended in 2005.
25:34 In retaliation for their worsening relationship with Syria,
25:36 Israel unilaterally declared to annex the occupied territories of East
25:40 Jerusalem in 1980 and the Syrian Golan Heights in 1981,
25:44 setting it on the path of a permanent territorial
25:46 dispute with Syria that lasts into the present day
25:49 as each side ever since has claimed that the Golan
25:51 Heights is a core part of their integral territories.
25:55 And at nearly the same time as these events were ongoing,
25:57 a revolution exploded in Iran in 1979 that toppled
26:01 the autocratic US-aligned monarchy of the Shah and replaced
26:04 him with a new revolutionary theocratic regime dominated
26:07 by the Iranian Shiite Muslim clergy and their leader,
26:10 the Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini.
26:12 The new revolutionary Iran completely changed the way the Middle East worked
26:17 because they emerged as the first truly Islamist government in the region.
26:21 The new Iranian regime's Shia Islamist
26:23 ideology believes and continues to believe in the concept of a grand Islamic
26:28 civilization consisting of all the Islamic peoples
26:31 and territories all across the world and that all of these Islamic territories
26:35 should be united under the rule of the Islamic clergy and their supreme leader.
26:39 The new revolutionary Iran was also open about their desire to export and spread
26:44 their Islamic revolution first to the Shia Muslim
26:46 majority lands across the Middle East in Iraq,
26:48 Syria, Lebanon, Bahrain, Saudi Arabia, and Yemen,
26:51 and then from there to the rest of the Islamic world.
26:54 All of the monarchies in the Islamic world like the Arab monarchies of Saudi
26:57 Arabia and the Gulf states were to be toppled during this revolutionary process.
27:01 While Israel, in the Iranian mind
27:03 a Western occupier of rightfully Islamic lands,
27:06 would have to be completely destroyed.
27:08 These foreign policy goals would ultimately make Iran
27:11 a bitter and irreconcilable enemy of both the Israelis
27:14 and also the Saudis and every other Arab monarchy
27:17 across the region in [music] addition to the United States,
27:20 all of whom wish to contain the Islamic revolution
27:22 within Iran and prevent it from spreading any further.
27:25 It also initially made Iran a terrifying enemy within Iraq,
27:29 where power had just recently been seized by the Ba'athist secular
27:33 Arab nationalist Saddam Hussein just as the revolution in Iran was erupting.
27:38 Saddam and his ruling clique of Ba'athists in Iraq came from the Sunni
27:41 Arab minority of the country from the former Ottoman province of Baghdad,
27:45 and he deeply feared revolutionary Iran's exportation
27:49 of the Shia revolution into the Basra area of Iraq,
27:52 where the majority of the population were also Shia
27:55 and where the majority of Iraq's oil reserves were also located.
27:58 Thus, determined to kill the Iranian revolution
28:01 in its cradle before it could spread,
28:03 Saddam invoked the call of Arab nationalism when he decided to send the Iraqi
28:08 army invading into Iran in 1980 with a stated goal of conquering the Arab
28:12 majority province of Khuzestan on the flat plain west of the Zagros Mountains
28:17 and adding its massive oil resources
28:20 to his own already large existing Iraqi oil arsenal,
28:24 and setting himself down the path as the next great aspirant to the mantle
28:28 of the Arab hero who would rail against
28:30 the map of the Middle East created by Sykes-Picot.
28:34 But instead, the Iran-Iraq War would
28:35 turn into an 8-year-long apocalypse that would
28:38 claim the lives of half a million people and injure around a million more.
28:43 Desperate to keep Iraq afloat as a buffer
28:45 state between themselves and the fiercely
28:47 anti-monarchist and expansionist revolutionary Iran who
28:50 had just toppled their own monarchy,
28:52 the Kuwaitis and the Saudis each lent tens of billions of dollars
28:56 to Saddam in order to keep him in the fight for longer,
28:59 the origin of the long-standing Saudi-Iranian Cold War.
29:03 But for Saudi Arabia, the fear went much deeper.
29:07 You see, across the 17th and 18th centuries, Bahrain,
29:10 an island in the Persian Gulf right off of the Saudi mainland,
29:13 had been ruled by various dynasties coming from Persia and Iran.
29:16 The British had transformed Bahrain into a protectorate of theirs only in 1861,
29:21 and after it was granted independence a century later in 1971,
29:25 the Imperial State of Iran claimed
29:26 the island as rightfully belonging to them instead.
29:30 After the 1979 Islamic Revolution,
29:32 the new theocratic revolutionary Iran continued the claim that Bahrain was
29:36 a lost Iranian province and that it should be returned to them,
29:40 further amplified by the fact that the vast
29:42 majority of Bahraini citizens were and are Shia Muslims,
29:46 but ruled by a Sunni Muslim monarchy friendly
29:49 to the fellow Sunni monarchies in Saudi Arabia,
29:52 Qatar, Kuwait, and the United Arab Emirates.
29:54 Bahrain is these days directly connected
29:56 to Saudi Arabia by an 18-mile-long bridge.
29:59 The island is only located about 60 km
30:02 away from Saudi Arabia's largest single oil field,
30:05 Ghawar, only about 50 km away from the headquarters of Saudi Aramco,
30:09 the state oil company, and only about 80 km away from Ras Tanura,
30:13 which is the Saudi's largest oil export terminal.
30:16 Bahrain is placed directly off the coast
30:19 of the Shia Muslim majority area of Eastern Saudi Arabia,
30:22 where nearly the entirety of Saudi
30:24 Arabia's oil reserves and infrastructure are located,
30:27 meaning that were the Iranians to successfully export the revolution
30:30 into Shia majority Bahrain and topple the Sunni monarchy there,
30:34 the next target would be the next-door
30:36 Shia majority areas of Eastern Saudi Arabia,
30:40 which could place the entire Saudi monarchy and state into jeopardy.
30:44 Thus, to prevent that from ever happening,
30:45 the Saudis decided to bankroll Saddam to keep
30:49 the Iranian revolution contained within just Iran,
30:52 and they have worked tirelessly ever since
30:54 to do whatever they can to bottle Iran up.
30:57 After the Iran-Iraq War concluded in a stalemate
31:00 without any changes made to the borders in 1988,
31:03 Saddam requested that Kuwait forgive the $65 billion worth
31:07 of loans that they had given him to fight against Iran, and after they refused,
31:12 Saddam went on to utilize Iraq's theoretical historical claim to Kuwait
31:16 and invaded that country next just 2 years later in 1990,
31:20 annexing it and adding all of its own oil reserves into Iraq proper.
31:24 The Iraqi conquest of Kuwait suddenly doubled the amount
31:27 of oil reserves that Saddam controlled and placed
31:30 him personally in control of nearly a fifth
31:33 of all the known oil reserves in the world.
31:36 Then, the Iraqi army began lining up
31:38 on the Kuwaiti border with Saudi Arabia next,
31:41 a stone's throw away from the massive oil fields in Saudi Arabia.
31:45 It appeared quite obvious that Saddam was planning on using the Iraqi
31:49 army to invade Saudi Arabia next and conquer their oil fields as well,
31:54 which would have further boosted his control over
31:56 the world supply of oil to nearly 45% of it,
32:00 which would have made Saddam Hussein the master of global
32:03 oil and given him the fuel he needed to continue
32:06 on with his ultimate ambition of unifying the Arab world beneath
32:10 his authority and finally overturning the map drawn up by Sykes and Picot.
32:15 Not willing to allow any of that to happen, however,
32:17 the United States gathered together a massive military coalition of 32 nations
32:22 and militarily intervened against him during the Gulf War of 1990 to 91,
32:27 which rapidly ejected the Iraqi military
32:29 from Kuwait and liberated the nation once again.
32:32 The map of Sykes and Picot was once again restored.
32:36 Afterwards, the United States began fully stepping into the role
32:39 as the new primary security guarantor of the Persian Gulf and its
32:43 oil supplies in order to make sure that the source
32:46 of half of the world's oil would remain stable and accessible.
32:49 The United States Fifth Fleet was reactivated and headquartered in Bahrain,
32:53 providing the US with a big incentive alongside of the Saudis
32:56 to keep the island out of the hands of revolutionary Iranian influence,
33:01 while the United States Air Force set up
33:02 a massive new air base at Al Udeid in Qatar.
33:06 Shortly after that, Jordan became the second Arab state in the world
33:09 to make peace with Israel when they recognized the Jewish state in 1994.
33:14 But the increasing setbacks for secular Arab nationalism
33:17 in the Middle East and the growing presence
33:19 and legitimacy of the United States and Israel
33:21 in the region gave rise to a new brand of Sunni Islamism in the Arab world
33:26 that rivaled both the more Shia Islamism in Iran
33:29 and the secular Arab nationalist movements like Ba'athism
33:32 in Iraq and Syria and the previous Nasserism in Egypt.
33:35 This set the stage for new organizations like Al-Qaeda to emerge,
33:39 who wanted to ignite a worldwide Islamist revolution to unite
33:43 the entire Muslim world beneath a new Islamic state that would fully
33:47 encompass all of the Muslim lands and finally do away
33:51 with the borders and terms of Sykes and Picot once and for all.
33:55 This newest challenge to the map of the Middle East set by Sykes
33:59 and Picot would eventually evolve even further into the form of ISIS,
34:03 an even more radical Sunni Islamist organization with roots
34:07 in Al-Qaeda that for a time in 2014 [music]
34:09 and 2015 exploded onto the world stage with a series
34:13 of conquests across the border between Iraq and Syria,
34:16 a border that had been set by Sykes
34:18 and Picot a century before their time in 1916,
34:22 and a border which they were adamant they
34:24 were going to finally be the ones to destroy,
34:27 just like many others before them and probably like many more in the future.
34:31 Before we get into the next video of this compilation,
34:34 I wanted to suggest some other relevant videos I
34:36 produced that weren't able to make it into here,
34:38 like my documentaries I produced covering the wars
34:39 waged by Saddam Hussein against Iran and Kuwait,
34:42 the American invasion of Iraq in 2003,
34:45 the 20-year-long American occupation of Afghanistan and the eventual
34:48 return of power of the Taliban again, the first and second civil wars in Libya,
34:52 the long civil war in Syria as well as the Russian intervention there,
34:55 the earlier civil war in Lebanon,
34:57 the long conflict between Turkey and the Kurds,
35:00 and the rapid rise and fall of ISIS across Iraq and Syria,
35:04 along with many, many others.
35:06 And you can go and watch all of these other videos
35:08 that I've produced about the making of the modern Middle East on Nebula,
35:11 the sponsor of this compilation that helps fund all
35:13 of my videos and helps to make all of this possible.
35:16 And in addition to all of my exclusive
35:18 content like this that's only available on Nebula,
35:20 we have more than 200 other creators on the platform right now,
35:24 many of whom are also producing exclusive
35:26 and early content like Tom Scott, Lindsay Ellis,
35:29 Real Engineering, Wendover Productions, and Jetlag, and so,
35:32 so many others you probably already are familiar with.
35:35 We also have absolutely no ads and no AI on Nebula either,
35:39 which is why I treat Nebula as my own personal entertainment refuge away
35:43 from the ads and AI that are increasingly
35:45 choking the rest of the internet these days.
35:48 And best of all, when you follow the link
35:50 that's down below in the description at nebula.tv/reallifelore,
35:53 you can go to Nebula and experience all of this right now with a great
35:57 deal we're currently running that'll get you
35:59 a whole 50% off of an annual Nebula subscription,
36:02 which will bring the cost for you down to just
36:04 $30 for the entire year or $2.50 per month,
36:08 a fraction of other streaming platforms.
36:11 Giving us a shot on Nebula is the absolute best thing
36:13 that you can do to help support my channel and my journalism.
36:17 And with that, let's get back to the making of the modern Middle East.
36:21 The United States and Iran have one
36:23 of the world's most complicated and controversial relationships.
36:27 The [music] United States is the world's most preeminent
36:29 superpower with a population of more than 320 million,
36:33 while Iran is a major power in her own
36:35 right with a population of more than 80 million.
36:38 These countries represent 4% and [music] 1% of the living human population,
36:44 and for the past 41 years,
36:46 they've had [music] absolutely zero diplomatic relations and have come close
36:51 to the brink of total war on more than one occasion.
36:55 At the beginning of 2020,
36:56 war between [music] the two sides seemed almost inevitable.
36:59 The United States assassinated an Iranian major general in a drone strike,
37:04 and Iran retaliated by initiating artillery
37:07 strikes against American military bases across Iraq.
37:11 Had a war broken out from there, it had the potential to become the biggest
37:15 conflict in human history since the Second World War.
37:19 This time, that fate was thankfully avoided,
37:22 but in order to understand how it got so close
37:25 and why it could still happen during another crisis in the future,
37:28 you've got to understand [music] the entire history
37:32 of the conflict between America and Iran so far.
37:35 And that story begins back before the start [music] of World War II.
37:39 At the beginning of the 20th century,
37:41 oil was first discovered within the deserts of Iran by the British.
37:44 [music] As more and more of these discoveries were made,
37:47 it was revealed that Iran, in fact,
37:49 contained the fourth largest proven reserves of oil anywhere on the planet
37:54 and that the country was an undiscovered and unrealized energy superpower.
37:59 The only problem for the British, of course,
38:01 was that these discoveries were located within Iran,
38:04 and Iran wasn't within Britain's vast colonial empire
38:07 that already spanned a quarter of the globe.
38:10 Not too worried about that pesky little detail,
38:12 Britain negotiated a deal with Iran to share in the massive profits
38:16 that were bound to come from the extraction of all this oil.
38:19 They created the jointly owned Anglo-Iranian Oil Company,
38:23 but it wasn't exactly set up very fairly.
38:25 [music] Iran, the country where all of this oil was actually located,
38:29 was only entitled to 16% of the company's profits,
38:33 whereas the other 84% of profits were going directly to the British.
38:37 By the start of the Second World [music] War,
38:39 the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company grew to control all of Iran's oil
38:43 and had grown to become the largest company in the entire British Empire.
38:47 But this massively valuable asset was coming under threats.
38:51 Discontent at the company's unfair [music] terms was growing within Iran itself,
38:55 while at the same time in 1941,
38:57 Nazi Germany invaded the Soviet Union and opened up
39:01 the largest military front line ever seen in human history.
39:05 Iran stood geographically at the Soviet Union's southern flank,
39:08 and [music] their intentions were considered suspect
39:11 by both the British and the Soviets.
39:13 Despite having declared neutrality at the onset of the war, Iran's ruling Shah,
39:17 or emperor, was widely considered by the allies
39:20 to be too friendly towards the Nazis.
39:23 If Iran were to have cooperated with the Axis,
39:25 it could have opened up another southern front for the Soviets to deal
39:28 [music] with that would have diverted vital
39:30 troops away from the critical Eastern Front.
39:32 It could have jeopardized the Soviet Union's own
39:35 oil fields in the Caucasus right on Iran's doorstep,
39:38 and it would have potentially placed Britain's largest
39:40 oil company in the hands of the Nazis.
39:42 So, in order to prevent any of that from happening and in order to ensure
39:46 that Iran could be used as a transportation
39:48 corridor to get vital supplies into the Soviet Union,
39:51 neutral Iran was invaded by both the Soviets and the British.
39:56 Vastly outnumbered and far behind in technology,
39:59 Iran never stood a chance and surrendered within just a week.
40:02 The old troublesome Shah was overthrown and replaced
40:05 by the invaders with his much younger 21-year-old son, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi,
40:10 whom the Allies felt would be far
40:12 less capable of acting against their interests.
40:15 Iran was effectively occupied for the entire Second World War by the Allies,
40:19 which eventually saw the deployment of more
40:21 than 30,000 Americans and [music] the transportation
40:24 of nearly 1/3 of all the supplies that America sent to the Soviet Union.
40:29 After the war ended, the Allies left and ended their occupation,
40:33 but the unfair terms that the British had established
40:35 in regards to Iran's oil came back into question.
40:38 By the early 1950s, Britain was still
40:41 taking home the majority of Iran's oil profits,
40:43 while the conditions for Iranian oil
40:45 workers and their families remained terrible.
40:47 [music] At the same time,
40:49 the British were also withholding all of the company's financial records
40:52 from the Iranians and had refused all of their requests that being audited.
40:56 The support for nationalizing the company within
40:59 Iran was getting overwhelmingly massive and by 1951,
41:02 Iran's democratically elected Prime Minister, Mohammad Mosaddegh,
41:06 with unanimous approval from the Iranian Parliament, finally did so.
41:10 Britain responded to this by immediately embargoing all
41:14 Iranian oil and then 2 years later in 1953,
41:18 Britain's MI6 and America's CIA organized a military
41:21 coup within the country to overthrow Mosaddegh's government.
41:25 As many as 300 Iranians were killed during the coup.
41:29 Mosaddegh himself was placed under house arrest for the rest of his life,
41:33 while the Shah was elevated to being
41:34 essentially an authoritarian dictator within the country.
41:38 Having had his position installed and guaranteed by Western powers twice now,
41:42 the Shah became widely viewed in Iran as little more than a Western puppet.
41:48 And as the Cold War developed out of the ashes of the Second World War,
41:51 Iran's strategic location at the Soviet Union's southern flank,
41:55 her vast strategic reserves of oil,
41:58 and her authoritarian leader who owed his position and loyalty to the West made
42:02 Iran a natural and valuable ally of the United States for the very first time.
42:09 The Shah pursued a staunchly pro-American
42:11 and pro-Israel foreign policy and for decades,
42:15 Iran became one of America's most important [music] Cold War era allies.
42:19 But over the decades, the Shah's policies and cozy relations with the West
42:23 alienated much of his home base support.
42:26 [music] He ran a vast network of secret police within
42:29 the country who arrested thousands of political opponents and many more,
42:33 like Ayatollah Khomeini, were exiled.
42:35 Widespread torture of political dissidents in prison was reported.
42:39 He outlawed the Iranian Communist Party.
42:41 He continued friendly relations with both America and Israel,
42:44 despite nearly none of the rest of the Islamic world even recognizing Israel,
42:49 while he carried out a domestic policy of modernization,
42:52 secularism, and the enfranchisement of women.
42:54 All of these policies combined alienated Iran's leftists,
42:58 the working class, and the hardcore Shiite Muslim conservatives and clergy.
43:03 And by the late 1970s, Iran's long-standing political unrest
43:07 had transformed into full-scale revolution.
43:10 A movie theater was set on fire in Abadan that killed at least 420 people,
43:15 with the Shah's regime blaming Marxist [music] and Islamist insurgents,
43:18 while many of the protesters felt like it
43:20 was more likely the Shah's own secret police.
43:23 The following month, protesters gathered in the capital Tehran's main square
43:27 and the Shah's army opened fire on them indiscriminately,
43:30 killing and wounding hundreds more.
43:32 More than 5 million Iranians took to the streets demanding
43:36 the Shah's abdication and after defections from his army became rampant,
43:40 Mohammad Pahlavi realized that his position was impossible to maintain
43:45 and he fled the country in exile in early 1979.
43:49 The new radical Shiite Islamist government that replaced the Shah's
43:52 regime immediately abolished the monarchy and invited Ayatollah Khomeini back
43:57 to the country after 15 years of exile to become Iran's
44:02 new supreme leader and the modern Islamic Republic of Iran was born.
44:07 And this new Iranian regime was radically
44:10 different from the one that it preceded.
44:12 It was a totalitarian Shiite theocracy that was staunchly
44:16 opposed to the United States and Israel and mass
44:19 executions and purges of political opponents and members
44:22 of the former regime were almost immediately carried out.
44:26 To the United States and the rest of the world,
44:28 Iran's Islamic Revolution came as an enormous shock.
44:33 Almost overnight, Iran had flipped from being one of America's
44:36 most important Middle Eastern allies to her greatest Middle Eastern enemy.
44:41 After the Shah was overthrown,
44:43 the United States welcomed him into their country for a cancer
44:46 treatment operation and the new Iran demanded that he
44:49 be extradited back to stand trial for the crimes
44:52 that he had committed throughout his reign against the Iranian people.
44:56 Knowing that his return would mean a certain execution,
44:58 the United States rejected all of Iran's demands,
45:01 but that did little to dissuade Iran's revolutionary paranoia.
45:05 Since the Shah was actively inside America
45:08 and since Western powers had already initiated
45:11 two previous coups in the past him over the will of the Iranian people,
45:16 the paranoia was widespread that America and the CIA could be plotting
45:20 yet another third coup [music] attempt from within their embassy inside Tehran.
45:25 And so, in November of 1979,
45:28 thousands of Iranian revolutionaries and students stormed the American
45:31 embassy and took 52 American diplomats and civilians as hostages.
45:36 America eventually sent the Shah away to Egypt,
45:39 while the Carter administration worked
45:40 for months to secure the hostages' release.
45:43 But when diplomacy went nowhere,
45:44 Carter authorized a raid by the United States Army
45:47 Rangers in April of 1980 to attempt a rescue operation.
45:51 But the raid turned into a disaster.
45:53 Co-named Operation Eagle Claw,
45:56 a helicopter crashed into a transport plane before any contact
45:59 with the Iranians was even made and eight American soldiers lost their lives.
46:03 Carter ordered the mission to be abandoned
46:05 and the hostages remained under Iranian control.
46:08 It was at this point that the United States decided to sever all
46:11 diplomatic relations with Iran's new regime
46:14 and they have been frozen ever since.
46:16 But a few months later, something else incredible and unexpected happened.
46:21 In September of 1980,
46:22 Saddam Hussein's Iraq launched an all-out invasion of conquest into Iran.
46:28 For years preceding this, Saddam had wanted Iraq to overtake
46:32 and supplant Iran as the dominant power in the oil-rich Persian Gulf.
46:36 But they were never capable of doing anything about it because Iran had
46:40 a colossally larger military and they had the support of America and Israel,
46:45 all of which made her vastly more powerful.
46:47 But after Iran was thrown into chaos by her revolution
46:50 and regime change with massive purges and executions of government
46:54 officials and after she was abandoned by both America
46:56 and Israel and was left without any major foreign allies,
47:00 Saddam calculated that now was better than ever to take advantage and attack.
47:05 Iraq expected a rapid victory,
47:07 but the war that followed turned into an 8-year-long stalemate
47:11 that most resembled the Western Front of World War I.
47:14 After the massive Iraqi invasion,
47:17 Iran was forced to re-evaluate the American hostage situation and they agreed
47:21 to release all 52 back into US custody after holding them for 444 days.
47:29 America levied heavy economic sanctions upon Iran
47:31 as a consequence and then began heavily supplying
47:34 Saddam and Iraq in their war effort
47:36 that they hoped would destabilize Iran even further.
47:39 The Iran-Iraq War would ultimately prove to be one of the largest
47:43 and the bloodiest of the 20th century's second half with as many
47:46 as 400,000 Iranians losing their lives across the front line owing
47:52 in part to the widespread deployment
47:55 of chemical weapons and landmines from Iraq,
47:57 who was being heavily supplied and supported
47:59 with conventional weapons by the United States.
48:02 Throughout the war, the US contends that Hezbollah,
48:05 a Shia Islamist militia organization operating out
48:08 of Lebanon who is a client of Iran,
48:10 carried out multiple anti-American terror attacks across the region.
48:15 In 1983, they carried out a bombing of the US embassy in Beirut,
48:19 which killed 17 Americans and later that same year,
48:22 they carried out another massive truck bombing attack
48:25 against the barracks of a military compound in Lebanon,
48:28 which killed a further 241 American and 58 French soldiers.
48:35 These events and others contributed to the United States placing Iran
48:39 on their state sponsors of terrorism list the following year in 1984.
48:43 By April of 1988, the Iran-Iraq War was still raging and Iran had mined
48:49 a large section of the Persian Gulf in order to counter the Iraqi Navy.
48:53 An American frigate who happened to be passing through struck
48:55 one of these mines and became severely damaged and almost sank,
48:59 but with no loss of life.
49:01 Regardless, America decided to initiate a retaliatory attack
49:05 against Iranian targets and initiated Operation Praying Mantis.
49:09 It was the largest US naval combat operation seen
49:12 since the Second World War and it saw two American
49:15 surface groups launching coordinated strikes that blew up two
49:18 Iranian offshore oil platforms and sank six of their warships.
49:23 The attack destroyed or severely damaged half
49:26 of Iran's entire fleet and killed 56 Iranians,
49:30 while resulting in only two American deaths.
49:33 Just 3 months later in July of 1988,
49:36 an American cruiser strayed into Iranian territorial waters
49:40 and received warning shots fired from Iranian speedboats.
49:43 At the same time, Iran Air Flight 655
49:46 that was taking its normal flight route above from Tehran
49:49 to Dubai and was at this point flying
49:51 over Iran's territorial waters above the Strait of Hormuz.
49:55 The American cruiser misidentified this commercial aircraft as an Iranian
49:59 fighter jet and assuming that they could have been under attack,
50:02 they launched a missile that targeted
50:04 and then completely destroyed the whole plane.
50:07 There were 290 people on board that flight and 254 of them were Iranians.
50:14 None of them survived the missile strike [music] and it
50:18 was the deadliest aviation shoot down incident in history until
50:21 the horrible shoot down of Malaysia Airlines Flight 17 over
50:25 Ukraine by pro-Russian rebels more than a quarter century later.
50:30 These deadly events between both sides
50:33 sharply escalated tensions between America and Iran
50:36 and each felt that the other had done grievous harm towards them.
50:40 In 1995, the Clinton administration enacted a total embargo
50:45 on all dealings with Iran by any American-based company,
50:48 which effectively killed all trade between both countries.
50:52 In 1996, the Iranian client Hezbollah [music] carried out yet
50:55 another terror bombing strike against a US target in Saudi Arabia.
50:59 This time killing 19 American Air
51:02 Force personnel and wounding nearly 500 others.
51:06 And then, 5 years after that, came the September 11th attacks.
51:10 Just [music] 4 months after 9/11,
51:12 US President Bush made his Axis of Evil speech in which he lumped Iran,
51:17 Saddam's Iraq, and North Korea all together
51:20 as an axis of evil conspiring against America.
51:23 Just a little more than a year after that speech,
51:25 the United States used the pretext of Saddam possessing weapons of mass
51:29 destruction to invade Iraq and completely toppled his regime in around a month.
51:35 No weapons of mass destruction were ever uncovered and the message
51:38 sent to both Iran and North Korea was clear [music] as day.
51:41 It was either develop nuclear weapons or you would be next.
51:45 North Korea managed to successfully test an atomic bomb
51:48 just 3 years after the American-led invasion of Iraq.
51:52 While Iran hastily carried out their own nuclear weapons research as well.
51:56 However, the United States made it clear
51:58 that a nuclear-armed Iran would never be tolerated
52:01 and a combination of sanctions and diplomacy were used
52:04 for years to try and convince Iran to stop.
52:06 By 2015, [music] the Obama administration had
52:09 successfully negotiated the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action,
52:13 better known colloquially as the Iran nuclear deal.
52:15 The treaty's terms are complex, but the TLDR is that the US agreed to end
52:20 a sweeping series of sanctions they had previously placed upon Iran.
52:24 While Iran agreed to give up their pursuit of nuclear
52:27 research and allowed foreign inspections to routinely investigate them.
52:31 Iran's and America's relationship was beginning
52:33 to show some signs [music] of rapprochement.
52:35 But then, things took another curveball.
52:38 In 2016, Donald Trump was elected the new president
52:41 of the United States on a platform that included
52:43 a vow to fully withdraw the US from the Iran
52:46 nuclear deal and to reinstate tougher economic sanctions.
52:50 In 2018, [music] Trump carried through with these campaign
52:52 promises and Iran counter-threatened that they would continue
52:56 on with their nuclear program and even close the Strait
52:58 of Hormuz to international shipping if things escalated any further,
53:02 which would have completely crashed the global oil economy.
53:05 Relations between the two were back to being tense
53:08 and then things got even worse the next year.
53:10 In May and June of 2019, several merchant ships traveling through the Persian
53:14 Gulf were damaged in two separate violent incidents.
53:17 The West blamed Iran and then Iran denied all involvement.
53:21 In June, Iran shot down an American drone that was
53:24 flying over the Strait of Hormuz and tensions increased even further.
53:27 And then in July, an Iranian oil tanker was seized
53:31 by the UK as it was passing through the Strait of Gibraltar
53:34 on the grounds that it was shipping oil to the Bashar
53:36 al-Assad regime in Syria in direct violation of EU sanctions.
53:40 Iran countered this by capturing a British oil tanker and taking
53:43 its crew hostage as it was later passing through the Persian Gulf.
53:47 Both sides eventually released the other's ships and crew,
53:50 but it was clear that tensions were reaching a boiling point.
53:53 And then, they dramatically escalated near the end of the year.
53:58 On the 27th of December 2019,
54:00 a rocket artillery attack from some assailant on America's K1 military base
54:05 in Iraq left one US civilian contractor dead and four other soldiers wounded.
54:10 America blamed the attack on Hezbollah
54:12 and other Shiite Islamist militias supported by Iran,
54:15 though both Hezbollah and Iran denied all responsibility.
54:18 At this point, there were about 5,000 US troops who were
54:22 stationed in Iraq who were helping in the ongoing fight against ISIL.
54:25 And 2 days later on the 29th,
54:27 they decided to initiate a retaliatory strike against Hezbollah's
54:31 weapons depots and command centers across both Iraq and Syria.
54:34 These American airstrikes killed 25 Hezbollah-affiliated
54:39 militiamen and wounded nearly 60 others.
54:42 Escalating things even further a couple days after that on December the 31st,
54:46 Iran-backed militiamen stormed and attacked
54:49 the United States Embassy in Baghdad.
54:51 The embassy was heavily vandalized, but nobody on either side was killed
54:55 and the US blamed Iran once again for the provocation.
54:58 And then came the 3rd of January 2020 when
55:01 the already high tensions skyrocketed to levels never seen before.
55:06 Qassem Soleimani, an Iranian major general widely believed to be
55:11 the second most powerful figure within the Iranian regime,
55:14 had just arrived in Baghdad on a flight.
55:17 He was scheduled to meet with Iraq's prime minister later on in the day,
55:20 but as he departed the Baghdad airport in a convoy of vehicles,
55:23 a US drone that had been hovering nearby overhead
55:27 fired a series of missiles that completely destroyed them.
55:31 This missile strike had been personally
55:33 authorized and ordered by President Donald
55:35 Trump himself and resulted in the deaths of Soleimani and nine others.
55:40 This event profoundly changed the crisis between Iran and the United States.
55:45 It was the first time that America had
55:47 assassinated a major military leader of a major
55:50 foreign country since the plot to kill Isoroku
55:53 Yamamoto of the Japanese Imperial Navy back in 1943,
55:57 who had been the mastermind of the Pearl Harbor attacks.
56:00 Two days later, Iran announced that it would no longer abide by any of the terms
56:05 of the 2015 nuclear deal and demanded that Iraq
56:08 remove all of the American presence from their country.
56:11 And then, on the 8th of January, 5 days after Soleimani's death,
56:15 Iran launched its own retaliatory strike against America.
56:19 Co-named Operation Martyr Soleimani,
56:22 Iran initiated multiple ballistic missile strikes against two US military
56:26 bases within Iraq and the entire world held its breath.
56:30 This was the closest that America and Iran had ever come
56:35 to full-scale war and the crisis could have easily escalated into that.
56:40 America had already rapidly deployed thousands of soldiers
56:43 to the Persian Gulf from the US East Coast in the days between
56:46 Soleimani's death and this Iranian artillery attack,
56:49 but thankfully, nobody was killed by it.
56:52 The bases experienced significant damage to buildings and infrastructure,
56:55 but everybody present remained alive.
56:58 And this was sort of a godsend because it gave both
57:01 Iran and America the opportunity to de-escalate [music] without losing any face.
57:06 Iran got to look strong and powerful by firing
57:09 rockets at American targets [music] and without any casualties,
57:12 America was given the option not to retaliate, which is what they chose to do.
57:16 [music] Unfortunately though, tragedy still managed to find a way to strike.
57:21 While Iran likely designed the attack
57:23 intentionally to not cause any American casualties,
57:26 Iran didn't necessarily know that the US
57:29 wasn't going to retaliate [music] and their anti-air
57:32 batteries across the country were on high alert for any kind of response.
57:37 One of these missile batteries detected what
57:39 they believed to be an American cruise missile on their radar and they opened
57:43 fire on it with two surface-to-air missiles.
57:46 It turned out that the target wasn't a cruise missile at all,
57:50 but was just a regularly scheduled commercial airliner that had
57:54 just taken off from Tehran International Airport [music] mere minutes before.
57:59 The plane in question was Ukraine International Airlines Flight 752
58:04 traveling from Tehran to Kiev with 176 people on board.
58:08 [music] The Iranian missiles completely destroyed
58:12 the plane and killed everybody on board,
58:14 including 82 Iranian and 63 Canadian citizens.
58:19 Initially, the Iranian government denied all
58:22 responsibility and attempted to cover the disaster
58:24 up by blaming the crash on technical faults with the plane itself.
58:28 [music] But after raising suspicion when they wouldn't
58:30 allow any investigators access to the crash site,
58:33 the government finally admitted to mistakenly shooting the plane
58:37 down a few days later on January 11th.
58:40 That attempted cover-up sparked massive protests
58:43 across Iran and against the regime.
58:46 And the brink of war against the United States had just narrowly been avoided.
58:51 Hundreds of innocent people died as a result
58:54 of the conflict between Iran and the United States in 2020.
58:57 [music] But of course, it could have always been far worse.
59:01 Had the conflict escalated by any number of countless different ways,
59:06 all-out war could have broken out that would
59:08 have resulted in the deaths of many, many more.
59:12 I only hope that peace between my country
59:15 and Iran can be maintained in the future.
59:18 [music] But at the same time, I'm aware of how precarious this peace is
59:22 [music] and the history behind all of this.
59:25 And I'm fearful that one day in the future,
59:28 we might not get as relatively lucky as we did at the beginning of 2020.
59:38 This is a stretch of water that's only a tad more than 30 mi wide.
59:42 It's so small that you couldn't even fit Luxembourg inside of it,
59:45 and yet these 30 mi make up the most
59:48 important location to understand in the entire [snorts] known universe.
59:54 By controlling these 30 mi, you can effectively rule the entire world,
59:59 and by closing them down, you can effectively destroy the world.
1:00:03 And this is why.
1:00:05 The ocean spans most of our planet's surface, about 70% of it to be precise.
1:00:10 In order to transport goods from one of Earth's many continents to another,
1:00:13 this vast ocean that takes up 70% of the planet has to be traveled across.
1:00:19 And in the 21st century, there are many ways to do so.
1:00:22 Simply using an airplane to fly across in mere
1:00:24 hours might be how you choose to do it, but airplanes are expensive,
1:00:29 especially the more and more heavy an object it is that you're moving.
1:00:32 So, when it comes to cargo,
1:00:34 80% of the 21st century's global trade is still being carried out the way
1:00:39 that it generally always has been for thousands of years now, by ship.
1:00:44 At any given normal time, there are around 50,000 merchant vessels carrying
1:00:49 as much as 6 million containers full of cargo and goods all across the world's
1:00:54 oceans and between all the world's continents.
1:00:57 These networks and streams of ships that you
1:01:00 see moving in lines across the world's surface
1:01:02 here are the literal arteries that power
1:01:05 the beating heart of the 21st century global economy.
1:01:08 And unfortunately, the world's oceans aren't very easy to navigate through.
1:01:13 The geographic placement of the world's continents, islands,
1:01:16 and land masses have created numerous natural choke points
1:01:19 that these trade arteries have no other choice but to move through.
1:01:23 And when these choke points become blocked by whatever means,
1:01:26 they can cause a veritable stroke upon the world economy.
1:01:30 This is exactly what happened earlier this year when
1:01:33 one of the most important of these, the Suez Canal,
1:01:36 was blocked for several days when a cargo
1:01:39 ship became unexpectedly stuck in the middle,
1:01:41 which blocked nearly 10 billion dollars
1:01:44 worth of global trade and caused widespread
1:01:46 shipping and logistical delays across the entire
1:01:49 world from North America to Australia.
1:01:51 But there are other strategic maritime choke
1:01:54 points to consider across the world as well.
1:01:56 The Panama Canal controls the flow of trade between
1:01:58 the Atlantic and Pacific Ocean across the American landmass.
1:02:01 The Cape of Good Hope controls the flow of trade around the African continent.
1:02:05 The Strait of Gibraltar controls the flow
1:02:07 between the Mediterranean and the Atlantic,
1:02:09 the Danish Straits between the Baltic and the North Sea,
1:02:11 the Turkish Straits between the Mediterranean and Black Seas,
1:02:14 and the Strait of Malacca between the Pacific and Indian Oceans.
1:02:17 However, none of these are as important nor
1:02:20 as dangerous as the Strait of Hormuz here for many, many critical reasons.
1:02:25 First among them, it's the only possible way for ships to move back and forth
1:02:29 between the Persian Gulf in the west and the Gulf of Oman in the east,
1:02:33 which then leads out to the greater global ocean.
1:02:35 The Persian Gulf is particularly important for this equation
1:02:38 because eight countries share some of its coastline:
1:02:41 Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Bahrain,
1:02:45 Qatar, the United Arab Emirates, and Oman.
1:02:47 And for four of those countries,
1:02:49 the only maritime access they have is within the Persian Gulf,
1:02:53 which means that the 30-mi wide Strait of Hormuz is the only
1:02:57 possible location they can pass through in order to access the world's oceans.
1:03:01 And if you know anything at all about the Middle East and the Gulf countries,
1:03:04 you know that they're pretty much all completely loaded in oil.
1:03:08 But oil is only part of what makes the Persian Gulf,
1:03:11 and the Strait of Hormuz especially, so critically important.
1:03:14 Oil [music] is still the lifeblood of the modern world's economy.
1:03:17 Around a third of our energy worldwide is produced by using it,
1:03:21 and every single day humanity consumes more than 9 million barrels of it.
1:03:26 Oil is still by far the most common source
1:03:29 of energy for human civilization in the 21st century.
1:03:33 And as a non-renewable, it can't simply be produced.
1:03:35 [music] Oil is a resource that can
1:03:37 only be extracted from where it already exists, and [music] as it happens,
1:03:41 it's not naturally found in too many parts of the world.
1:03:45 Around the Persian Gulf basin,
1:03:46 across these dozens of oil fields marked in green,
1:03:49 you can find roughly half of the entire planet's proven reserves of oil,
1:03:55 including the single largest oil field
1:03:57 in the world here in Saudi Arabia, at Ghawar,
1:04:00 which all on its own produces nearly
1:04:03 6% [music] of the entire world's oil supply.
1:04:07 There are dozens of fabulously rich oil fields here that stretch
1:04:11 across all eight of the countries that border [music] the Persian Gulf.
1:04:15 But that's not the only valuable resource that can be found here.
1:04:18 Marked in red, you can also find roughly
1:04:21 40% of the world's proven reserves of natural gas.
1:04:25 Natural gas is the world's third most common source of energy,
1:04:28 behind oil and coal,
1:04:30 and more than a fifth of the world's energy is produced by using it.
1:04:33 Qatar itself produces the highest amount of liquefied natural gas in the world,
1:04:37 [music] and according to British Petroleum,
1:04:39 Iran possesses the world's largest reserves of natural gas.
1:04:43 Between all of these combined reserves,
1:04:45 there is more oil and natural gas in the seas of the Persian
1:04:49 Gulf and the land immediately surrounding it
1:04:52 than anywhere else on the planet Earth.
1:04:55 Since a third of all the world's oil
1:04:57 production is currently taking place around the Gulf,
1:04:59 and a third of the world's energy is powered by oil,
1:05:02 and since a further fifth of natural gas production takes place around the Gulf,
1:05:06 and about a fifth of the world's energy is powered by gas,
1:05:09 it can therefore be said that about 15% of the entire
1:05:14 planet's [music] energy supply comes from around the Persian Gulf,
1:05:19 and largely behind the Strait of Hormuz.
1:05:22 This is why the 30 mi of water here is so insanely important,
1:05:28 because roughly 15% of all the energy that humanity is collectively consuming
1:05:34 right now [music] largely has no other choice but to pass through it.
1:05:40 No other choke point in the 21st century's global transportation network
1:05:44 can come anywhere even close [music] to that level of critical importance.
1:05:49 [snorts] And it doesn't help that navigating
1:05:51 through it is pretty geographically difficult.
1:05:54 There are eight major islands located inside of the strait,
1:05:57 which must be avoided by any ships,
1:05:59 seven of which are de facto controlled by Iran.
1:06:02 These three strategically placed ones are contested by the United Arab Emirates,
1:06:07 but the Iranian military has occupied them since the 1970s,
1:06:10 so they're effectively controlled by Iran.
1:06:12 These areas of water highlighted are too shallow for any tanker to traverse,
1:06:16 while these areas separately highlighted have very limited
1:06:19 visibility due to the obstructions from islands and land.
1:06:22 Dust storms, morning fog,
1:06:23 and haze can all make visibility within the strait even
1:06:26 more challenging and are particularly common events during the summer months.
1:06:30 The UN has established a special traffic separation scheme for tankers
1:06:35 and other ships to take while traveling through to avoid the most risk.
1:06:38 This scheme consists of only two 2-mi wide shipping lanes,
1:06:42 one for incoming and another for outgoing traffic,
1:06:45 while each is only separated by a 2-mi wide buffer zone.
1:06:49 The whole route travels through Iranian, Emirati,
1:06:52 and Omani territorial waters at various times,
1:06:54 and all of the world's largest ships must pass through them and limited
1:06:58 capability to avoid any unexpected obstructions that might or might not crop up.
1:07:03 The overwhelming majority of all the oil that flows
1:07:06 out of the Gulf travels towards East Asia,
1:07:08 76% of it, [music] and most of that travels to only five countries.
1:07:14 China is the world's largest importer
1:07:16 of petroleum and the world's second largest economy,
1:07:19 and is heavily dependent on the oil flow coming out from the Strait of Hormuz,
1:07:23 [music] because it imports about 45% of its
1:07:26 supply from the eight countries around the Persian Gulf.
1:07:29 Japan, the world's third largest economy,
1:07:31 is even more critically dependent and addicted.
1:07:34 Infamously barren of most natural resources
1:07:37 that are required for an industrial society,
1:07:39 Japan has always been forced to seek them
1:07:42 out abroad and away from their home islands,
1:07:44 at times through war, while at other times through trade.
1:07:47 Currently, they rely on trade.
1:07:49 While oil and liquefied natural gas power
1:07:52 more than 60% [music] of Japan's energy needs,
1:07:55 nearly 100% of all of it is imported,
1:07:58 and nearly 80% of that is transported by tankers
1:08:01 from the Persian Gulf and through the Strait of Hormuz.
1:08:05 Therefore, nearly half of Japan's energy,
1:08:08 the fuel that powers the world's third largest economy,
1:08:11 has to travel through the 30 mi of water at the Strait of Hormuz.
1:08:17 And South Korea, the world's 10th largest global economy,
1:08:20 has similar dependencies.
1:08:22 They import nearly 70% of their oil from the Persian Gulf states.
1:08:27 And since oil powers more than 40% of their energy needs,
1:08:30 nearly a third of South Korea's energy supplies also have no other choice
1:08:36 but to be delivered by tankers that are
1:08:38 coming through the 30-mi wide Strait of Hormuz.
1:08:42 Were the strait ever to be obstructed or shut down for very long,
1:08:45 the world's second, third,
1:08:46 and 10th largest economies would immediately come to a screeching halt.
1:08:52 The primary source of revenue for all eight countries
1:08:54 around the Persian Gulf would also immediately dry up,
1:08:58 and the ripple effect from there would
1:09:00 almost certainly crash the entire global economy.
1:09:03 And in that event, there aren't many options
1:09:05 for getting the oil and natural gas around the strait.
1:09:08 Saudi Arabia does have a crude oil and liquefied
1:09:11 natural gas pipeline that they can use to transport
1:09:14 limited amounts from the rich fields around the Persian
1:09:16 Gulf over to their ports on the Red Sea,
1:09:18 while the United Arab Emirates has a similar
1:09:21 pipeline that they can use to transport
1:09:23 further limited amounts to the other side of their country on the Gulf of Oman,
1:09:27 and away from the Strait of Hormuz, but these amounts are all limited,
1:09:31 while Qatar, Bahrain, Kuwait, and Iraq possess no such ability.
1:09:36 At a maximum, it's believed that these pipelines can only divert about 20%
1:09:40 of the oil coming out of the Persian Gulf around the Strait of Hormuz,
1:09:44 and building any more oil pipeline infrastructure is expensive.
1:09:48 All of this means that the 30-mi wide Strait of Hormuz is the most
1:09:52 important choke point [music] in the entire
1:09:54 world for the global economy to function smoothly.
1:09:57 And as a result, it's attracted considerable attention
1:10:00 of countless empires and foreign powers from the outside,
1:10:04 most notably the United States.
1:10:06 The US maintains dozens of bases across Oman,
1:10:09 the UAE, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Bahrain,
1:10:12 Kuwait, and Iraq, seven of the eight countries around the Gulf, save for Iran.
1:10:17 This includes an air force base in Qatar, and the United States' [music] fifth
1:10:20 fleet being further headquartered within Bahrain,
1:10:23 which is generally composed of more than 15,000 sailors, two aircraft carriers,
1:10:28 dozens of other vessels,
1:10:29 and between them and the air force base, countless aircraft.
1:10:33 As the current largest single source for all of humanity's energy,
1:10:37 all of this presence in the area from the United States
1:10:40 is generally in place to ensure that the oil continues flowing,
1:10:44 and to counter Iran's influence over on the other side of the Strait.
1:10:48 The United States and Iran have had no official
1:10:50 diplomatic relations for more than 40 years now, since 1980.
1:10:54 And relations between the two sides of the Strait have been continuously tense.
1:10:59 In the event of a war breaking out,
1:11:01 Iran has made numerous threats over the years to close
1:11:04 the Strait of Hormuz from their side over to Oman,
1:11:07 which, if successful, would shatter the world economy,
1:11:10 and that's enough of a threat to always make America,
1:11:13 or any other foreign power, think twice.
1:11:16 But Iran's capability to do that is realistically pretty limited.
1:11:20 While the Iranian military is powerful, America's is a lot more powerful,
1:11:25 and the presence of the fifth fleet so close by in Bahrain would
1:11:28 almost guarantee American naval and air
1:11:31 superiority almost immediately across the entire Strait.
1:11:34 Iran knows that their navy and air
1:11:36 force couldn't compete though, so as a result,
1:11:39 most of their focus over the past decade has been centered around building air
1:11:42 defenses and missile batteries across the coast
1:11:45 that could simply bombard any ships passing through.
1:11:48 Iran also possesses a massive arsenal of thousands of maritime
1:11:52 mines that they could theoretically quickly fill the 30-mi
1:11:56 wide Strait with that would ground all trading activity
1:11:58 through it to a halt for who knows how long.
1:12:02 Theoretically, Iran could probably shut the Strait down,
1:12:05 but doing so would almost certainly invoke a very sharp response
1:12:10 from a coalition of countries who would be staunchly opposed to it,
1:12:13 likely led by the United States and Saudi Arabia.
1:12:17 That conflict wouldn't be very pretty,
1:12:19 and it's come dangerously close to already happening.
1:12:22 Just two years ago in 2019,
1:12:25 the United States began a military build-up around the Persian Gulf,
1:12:28 while simultaneously withdrawing from the Iran nuclear
1:12:31 deal and imposing new sanctions upon the country.
1:12:33 The conflict escalated from there to the point where an Iranian major
1:12:37 general was assassinated in a US drone strike at the beginning of 2020,
1:12:41 and led from there to Iran bombarding US
1:12:44 military bases across Iraq with rockets and artillery.
1:12:47 It was the closest that America and Iran
1:12:50 have ever come so far to a full-out war, and the tension still hasn't gone away.
1:13:01 There's 62 countries around the world today who
1:13:02 have small populations less than 3 million people.
1:13:05 Because of their small size, they're all generally limited in their power
1:13:08 and influence to their immediate surroundings.
1:13:10 And even then, in the case of places like Armenia, Moldova,
1:13:13 or the Gambia, they're usually minor players even within their own neighborhood.
1:13:16 The fascinating exception to this rule
1:13:18 of thumb for the world's smallest countries, however, is Qatar, a small, dusty,
1:13:23 and largely empty peninsula no larger than the state of Delaware
1:13:26 that juts out from Saudi Arabia into the Persian Gulf.
1:13:29 While Qatar has an overall population of around 2.8 million people,
1:13:33 which is already smaller than Albania,
1:13:35 only 320,000 of them are actually citizens of the country,
1:13:38 while the remaining nearly two and a half million people are almost
1:13:41 entirely foreign and expatriate labor that have come to the country from abroad.
1:13:45 That means that with only around 320,000 citizens,
1:13:49 Qatar's citizen population is only about the same size as tiny Vanuatu,
1:13:53 a little island country in the Pacific Ocean.
1:13:55 And yet, [music] despite its tiny size in both land and people,
1:13:58 Qatar commands global prestige,
1:14:00 power, and influence on the same scale of countries
1:14:03 that are dozens of times larger than it.
1:14:05 For years now, Qatar has often been
1:14:07 described as the wealthiest country in the world
1:14:09 with the highest GDP per capita of all
1:14:11 the world's nations for multiple years in a row.
1:14:14 The Qatari economy was larger than Ukraine's even before the Russian invasion,
1:14:18 and with nearly 16 times fewer people,
1:14:21 even when including all the foreign labor.
1:14:23 The state of Qatar wields the ninth largest sovereign wealth
1:14:26 fund in the world with assets exceeding 450 billion dollars,
1:14:30 including a large 10 and 1/2% stake in the Volkswagen Group,
1:14:34 and the outright ownership of the Paris Saint-Germain Football Club,
1:14:37 the seventh most valuable football club in the entire world.
1:14:40 This is all in addition to a diversified real estate portfolio
1:14:43 that makes the state of Qatar the largest single property owner in London,
1:14:47 including a 95% stake in the tallest building in Western Europe,
1:14:50 the Shard, 100% ownership of the Harrods department store,
1:14:54 a majority stake in the Canary Wharf financial center,
1:14:57 and a 20% stake in London's Heathrow Airport,
1:15:00 the seventh busiest airport in the world by international passenger traffic.
1:15:03 This sovereign wealth fund's assets equate to more
1:15:06 than 1.4 million dollars per citizen of Qatar,
1:15:09 by far the largest of any sovereign wealth fund in the world.
1:15:13 The state-owned airline Qatar Airways is one of the largest
1:15:15 and the most influential in the entire global aviation industry.
1:15:19 Ranked by assets, Qatar Airways is the ninth largest airline in the world,
1:15:23 and is roughly equivalent in scale to Air France-KLM,
1:15:26 and they have even greater revenue numbers than Turkish Airlines.
1:15:29 The state-owned media company Al Jazeera is one
1:15:31 of the largest public media conglomerate in the world,
1:15:34 second only to the BBC in the number of news bureaus located across the world.
1:15:38 And perhaps most infamously of all,
1:15:40 they are by far the smallest country and the first
1:15:42 in the Arab world to ever host the FIFA World Cup,
1:15:46 which is currently ongoing as of the release of this video.
1:15:49 The Qatar of today is a fabulously wealthy country for its small size,
1:15:53 and with that wealth also comes enormous global influence and power.
1:15:57 And as a result, I would argue that Qatar is
1:16:00 by far [music] the most overpowered country in the 21st century world,
1:16:04 with a level of influence ranking it
1:16:06 as a middle power alongside states that are many,
1:16:09 many times larger than it, like Turkey, South Korea, the Netherlands, or Canada.
1:16:14 And they're only going to continue getting
1:16:15 even more overpowered as this decade advances.
1:16:18 But it wasn't always so certain to be this way,
1:16:20 because Qatar only really started getting rich
1:16:23 and overpowered pretty recently in the 1990s.
1:16:26 For thousands of years before then, hardly anybody would have ever been able
1:16:30 to guess how Qatar's fortunes would eventually turn out, because geographically,
1:16:34 Qatar possesses very few advantages to help it become powerful.
1:16:37 It's just a small, dusty,
1:16:39 flat peninsula covered in deserts with scarce arable land,
1:16:43 little rainfall, and without even a single
1:16:45 river to use for fresh water or irrigation.
1:16:48 The prospects for anyone living here were bleak for thousands of years,
1:16:52 and the only way anybody could really make a living was
1:16:54 limited either to fishing or to diving for pearls in the Gulf.
1:16:57 And consequently, hardly anybody actually did live here.
1:17:00 Qatar was an isolated, impoverished,
1:17:03 and underdeveloped backwater for basically all
1:17:05 of human history until things finally began
1:17:08 changing when oil happened to be discovered
1:17:10 in 1939 across the Dukhan field here,
1:17:13 found across the westernmost edge of the peninsula.
1:17:15 But of course, the same year it was discovered
1:17:18 was the same year that World War II began,
1:17:20 so it was never really developed until a decade later in 1949.
1:17:23 By the 1950s, Qatar was producing a modest amount of oil from this field,
1:17:27 but it paled in comparison to the gigantic oil fields
1:17:30 that had been found nearby across Saudi Arabia and Kuwait.
1:17:33 The largest oil field ever discovered in the world is the Ghawar
1:17:36 field less than 150 km away from the Qatari border within Saudi Arabia,
1:17:41 and it alone contains nearly twice the amount of oil found across all of Qatar.
1:17:47 But after scouring across their tiny peninsula,
1:17:49 the Qataris never discovered any other significant oil reserves on land,
1:17:53 and that pushed Qatar and their partnered
1:17:55 Western oil companies to begin searching
1:17:57 for offshore oil reserves around the peninsula
1:17:59 within their territorial waters in the Gulf.
1:18:01 Several were found, but again,
1:18:03 none of them were anything like the huge earth-shattering
1:18:06 finds that the Saudis and Kuwaitis were making just nearby.
1:18:09 It would eventually turn out that Qatar had
1:18:10 the 14th largest reserves of oil in the world,
1:18:13 a significant asset and a boon for the people of the tiny peninsula.
1:18:17 But in the grand scheme of the Persian Gulf,
1:18:19 these oil reserves were still fairly small.
1:18:22 They were but a quarter of the reserves
1:18:24 found in Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates,
1:18:26 and only a tenth of those found just next door in Saudi Arabia.
1:18:29 If it was only ever going to rely on oil,
1:18:32 Qatar would never grow to be as rich as its neighbors.
1:18:35 But naturally, Qatar wanted to strike it big like the rest of them,
1:18:38 and so they kept on searching for more.
1:18:39 And then in 1971, they would finally end
1:18:42 up making the geologic discovery of the century, and it wouldn't even be oil.
1:18:46 With the assistance of Shell,
1:18:48 what they ended up discovering was this, a big offshore
1:18:51 natural gas field in the middle of the Persian Gulf,
1:18:54 split roughly 60/40 between their own exclusive economic zone and Iran's.
1:18:58 Their side of the field became known as the North Field,
1:19:01 while Iran's became known as the South Pars Field, [music]
1:19:04 and its discovery would ultimately change both countries' destinies forever.
1:19:08 Because this field is by far the largest
1:19:11 natural gas field ever discovered in the world.
1:19:14 [music] It is so enormous that the Qatari side of the field
1:19:16 alone contains an estimated fifth of all
1:19:19 the entire world's natural gas reserves.
1:19:22 This single field overnight catapulted little Qatar into the number
1:19:26 three position in the world for natural gas reserves,
1:19:30 just behind Iran and Russia, and nearly double the natural gas
1:19:33 reserves found across the entire United States.
1:19:36 Its discovery would one day transform Qatar into the financial
1:19:39 and economic juggernaut that we know it as today,
1:19:42 and it is the primary source of Qatar's OPEC status on the world stage.
1:19:47 But, when it was first discovered,
1:19:48 the Qataris and Shell were actually disappointed that it
1:19:51 wasn't oil and thought it was almost useless.
1:19:53 You see, back at that time in the '70s,
1:19:55 the natural gas industry was completely different than it is today.
1:19:58 Natural gas is, of course, a gas, and that means it takes up a lot of volume.
1:20:03 Exporting natural gas to somewhere else while it's still
1:20:05 in its gaseous state takes up a lot of space,
1:20:07 and that means that exporting the gas by ship
1:20:09 is incredibly inefficient and doesn't make any financial sense.
1:20:12 This is why the liquefied natural gas, or LNG,
1:20:15 business was born shortly after the Second World War.
1:20:17 By converting natural gas into a liquid,
1:20:19 it takes up only 1/600 of the same volume
1:20:22 it does when it's in its gaseous [music] state,
1:20:24 and that means that LNG can be transported in huge quantities by tanker
1:20:29 ship from any source to any destination in the world, in theory.
1:20:34 The problem with LNG has always been that it's
1:20:36 the most expensive way to transport natural gas because
1:20:40 of all the complicated and advanced infrastructure that needs
1:20:43 to be put in place to get it all running.
1:20:45 You need complicated refrigeration plants at the source of the gas
1:20:47 that can cool it down to its liquid state at -161° C.
1:20:51 No easy task to do around the Persian Gulf,
1:20:54 which has some of the hottest average temperatures in the world.
1:20:56 You need to commission specialized refrigerated tanker
1:20:58 ships that can continue keeping the gas that cold for weeks to months on end
1:21:03 while they carry it across the world's oceans.
1:21:05 And you need another specialized plant at the final destination that can
1:21:08 safely transform the LNG back into gas to be used by consumers.
1:21:12 It costs billions of dollars to get all
1:21:13 of this set up before the first shipments even arrive, and worse, in the 1970s,
1:21:18 there was nowhere near enough of a market or a demand for LNG.
1:21:22 Europe received plentiful cheaper gas from pipelines
1:21:25 coming in from places like Russia, Norway, and the Netherlands,
1:21:28 meaning that expensive LNG was not going to be competitive there.
1:21:31 But, the increasingly advanced and developing island economies
1:21:34 of East Asia were a completely different matter altogether.
1:21:36 Japan, in particular, is an island nation that is bereft of fossil fuels,
1:21:40 meaning that as their economy developed and their demand for gas increased,
1:21:44 their geography was better suited towards importing gas as LNG from container
1:21:47 ships rather than through long pipelines built across or beneath the ocean.
1:21:52 The same became true of Taiwan and eventually South Korea as well,
1:21:55 which effectively functions as an island
1:21:57 as well for the purpose of importing energy
1:21:59 from abroad because of North Korea and the ocean to their other three sides.
1:22:03 All three of these rising East Asian economies'
1:22:05 demand for LNG began to grow over the years,
1:22:08 and at first, their demand was almost
1:22:09 entirely met by nearby producers in Southeast Asia,
1:22:12 Indonesia, Malaysia, and Brunei.
1:22:14 This was the world that Qatar and Shell found themselves in in 1971
1:22:18 when they suddenly discovered the biggest natural gas field in the world,
1:22:22 and they initially decided that they couldn't economically
1:22:24 compete for any of the market in Asia.
1:22:26 Building up an LNG industry from scratch was
1:22:28 thought to be too costly and too risky,
1:22:31 and building out long pipelines to markets in Europe
1:22:33 was just too ridiculous and expensive to even consider.
1:22:36 They had both hoped that their discovery was oil because,
1:22:38 unlike natural gas, oil is naturally a liquid,
1:22:41 and so it's far less costly to just load
1:22:43 it up on tankers and ship it around the world.
1:22:46 So, rather than developing Qatar's natural gas in the North Field,
1:22:49 Shell abandoned the project, and with global oil prices skyrocketing following
1:22:53 the Arab oil embargoes in the '70s,
1:22:55 Qatar continued to focus on its smaller oil reserves for the next 20 years.
1:23:00 And then, everything would begin to change again in the late 1980s.
1:23:04 In 1986, the price of oil unexpectedly crashed by more than
1:23:07 50% production and revenue from oil sales in Qatar crashed alongside it,
1:23:12 and the Qatari economy,
1:23:13 which almost entirely relied upon selling oil at the time,
1:23:16 was put into a crisis mode.
1:23:18 By the 1990s, with oil prices and revenue still low,
1:23:22 the Qataris began turning their attention back towards all of that natural
1:23:25 gas they found 20 years previously in the biggest field in the world.
1:23:29 And at the same time, global demand for natural gas was beginning to increase.
1:23:33 Natural gas emits 50% less CO2 than coal when it's burned for energy,
1:23:38 and about 30% less than oil while releasing less air pollution as well,
1:23:42 making it a desirable and slightly cleaner fuel to use
1:23:45 for electricity for nations weary of climate change and pollution,
1:23:49 or for nations seeking a transitory fuel source while they move
1:23:51 towards full carbon neutrality and green energies like wind or solar.
1:23:55 And at the same time,
1:23:56 the cost of building out LNG infrastructure had dramatically come down
1:24:00 after more than 20 years
1:24:01 of continuous technological developments and understanding.
1:24:05 In 1995, the ambitious son of the ruling Qatari emir
1:24:08 launched a bloodless coup d'état against his father and overthrew him.
1:24:12 And it would be under his leadership that little
1:24:15 Qatar would be transformed into a world power.
1:24:18 Hamad bin Khalifa Al Thani strongly believed in the potential of the natural
1:24:23 gas reserves in the North Field and in the growing LNG business.
1:24:27 Equipped with billions of dollars worth of investment
1:24:29 secured from Western energy companies like ExxonMobil,
1:24:31 the Qataris and their partners set out to build no less than
1:24:34 the largest and the most competitive LNG business the world had ever seen.
1:24:39 Backed up by the single largest gas field ever discovered,
1:24:42 the Qataris managed to increase the scale
1:24:44 of their LNG operations to never-before-seen heights.
1:24:48 They constructed the largest artificial harbor
1:24:50 in the world for their Ras Laffan Industrial City,
1:24:53 which became their primary production and export center for Qatari LNG.
1:24:56 They commissioned larger and larger LNG container ships that could
1:25:00 carry increasingly larger volumes of LNG to customers abroad.
1:25:03 And by 1996, Qatar was exporting their first shipments of LNG
1:25:07 through the Strait of Hormuz and abroad to global markets.
1:25:11 It would end up revolutionizing both Qatar and the entire world in the process.
1:25:15 Within just 10 years of the beginning their operations by 2006,
1:25:19 Qatar had already overtaken all of its LNG competitors like Malaysia
1:25:24 and Indonesia to become the largest exporter of LNG in the world.
1:25:28 With the bulk of their shipments eating into the market
1:25:30 share in the East Asian economies of Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan.
1:25:34 South Korea became their single largest customer,
1:25:37 and they still continue to purchase roughly 27%
1:25:40 of their entire natural gas supply from Qatar alone.
1:25:43 And the vast revenues that these countries were paying for Qatari
1:25:47 LNG flooded back into the coffers of the Qatari government,
1:25:51 which, of course, made them mind-bogglingly rich.
1:25:54 This is a chart of the gross domestic product
1:25:56 per capita in Qatar from 1987 to the present.
1:25:59 This year, 1996, is when Qatar first began exporting LNG to the world market,
1:26:03 and you can clearly see how immediately afterwards,
1:26:06 their wealth began to absolutely skyrocket to the point in 2006
1:26:10 where they became the largest LNG exporter in the world.
1:26:13 Tens of billions of dollars a year began flowing
1:26:16 directly to Qatar in exchange for their shipments of LNG.
1:26:20 But, all of this newfound wealth came with a problem.
1:26:22 Qatar was growing too over-dependent on a single source
1:26:26 of income and was transforming into the world's first LNG state.
1:26:30 By the 2010s, 70% of the entire government's revenue,
1:26:34 60% [music] of the entire country's GDP,
1:26:37 and 85% of their export earnings were all
1:26:39 simply coming from the LNG and petroleum business.
1:26:43 If the business were to ever crash or run out of supplies,
1:26:46 Qatar would be forced into going back to the impoverished,
1:26:49 empty peninsula that it had been for thousands of years beforehand.
1:26:53 And of course, the government has always been aware of this, [music]
1:26:55 and so in order to diversify their income streams and secure their future,
1:26:58 they began investing into other businesses, ideas, and avenues.
1:27:02 Qatar Airways was founded in 1993 and expanded with the LNG and oil
1:27:06 money to become one of the top 10 largest airlines in the world today.
1:27:10 The Qatar sovereign wealth fund was established in 2005 as a means
1:27:13 to invest their massive [music] revenues into projects, real estate,
1:27:17 and companies abroad to the point where today,
1:27:19 the fund's assets are nearly equivalent to the entire annual GDP of Egypt,
1:27:23 [music] a nation of more than 100 million people.
1:27:26 And then in 1996, the same year they began exporting LNG,
1:27:30 they also founded the state-owned Al Jazeera Media Group,
1:27:34 translating from Arabic into English as literally the peninsula,
1:27:38 the Qatar peninsula.
1:27:39 But, Qatar still had a low natural population base
1:27:42 in addition to being located in a dangerous geopolitical neighborhood.
1:27:46 Saddam Hussein's Iraq had previously launched wars of conquest into both
1:27:50 Iran and Kuwait in order to seize control over their oil industries,
1:27:54 and little Qatar was hypothetically a much more
1:27:57 vulnerable target than either of those had been.
1:27:59 There was also the fact that Qatar shared
1:28:01 the largest natural gas field in the world with Iran,
1:28:04 which meant that each of their governments
1:28:05 had to collaborate together and remain friendly
1:28:08 to an extent in order to safely and mutually extract all of the gas there,
1:28:13 a situation that made next door Saudi Arabia,
1:28:15 the greatest rival of Iran, intensely apprehensive.
1:28:19 Qatar's solution to defending themselves
1:28:21 in this precarious geopolitical neighborhood
1:28:23 was by simply aligning itself very closely to the United States.
1:28:27 At the same [music] time as they were getting their LNG business up and running,
1:28:31 Qatar invited both the American and British militaries [music]
1:28:33 to assist in constructing the Al Udeid airbase in the country,
1:28:37 which eventually went on to become the US
1:28:39 military's largest base in the entire Middle
1:28:41 East with more than 11,000 total personnel
1:28:45 and more than 100 operational aircraft as of today.
1:28:48 It became an invaluable asset for the United States through multiple conflicts,
1:28:52 used as a primary airbase to conduct operations from in Afghanistan,
1:28:55 Iraq, and later against ISIS in Syria.
1:28:58 And beyond that base, Qatar also supplied enormous quantities of energy supplies
1:29:03 to many of America's most important allies in Asia,
1:29:06 Japan, South Korea, [music] Taiwan, and India.
1:29:09 This is all in part why
1:29:10 the Biden administration would eventually label tiny Qatar
1:29:13 [music] as a major non-NATO ally of the United States at the beginning of 2022,
1:29:18 a status that is similarly bestowed upon great power nations
1:29:22 like Japan and Brazil with nearly a hundred times Qatar's population.
1:29:27 Meanwhile, Qatar's low population base of only a few hundred
1:29:30 thousand people also proved to make it difficult to actually
1:29:32 use all of that money from LNG and petroleum
1:29:35 to build things like skyscrapers and stadiums for the World Cup.
1:29:39 And so to solve that problem,
1:29:41 Qatar began encouraging enormous migration to the country for low-
1:29:45 skilled workers coming primarily from South Asian nations like Nepal,
1:29:48 India, Bangladesh, and Pakistan.
1:29:50 This is why today, Qatar's demographic structure is one
1:29:53 of the strangest and the most [music] exploitative in the entire world.
1:29:57 Nearly nine in 10 people in the country today are foreign workers
1:30:00 without any citizenship who have recently moved to the country from abroad,
1:30:04 including more than 700,000 from India.
1:30:07 Since the overwhelming majority of the foreign workers
1:30:09 who have come to Qatar are also men,
1:30:11 Qatar's gender profile is by far the most lopsided in the world
1:30:16 with roughly three men in the country for every one woman.
1:30:19 And ever since these migrations began to Qatar,
1:30:22 there have been countless reports of terrible human rights
1:30:25 abuses that have been made against them with many
1:30:28 publications suggesting that the treatment of the millions
1:30:30 of foreign workers in Qatar essentially amounts to modern-day slavery.
1:30:35 South Asian men would be promised by Qatari officials
1:30:38 of high pay and good conditions and then lured
1:30:41 to the country where they would then often have
1:30:43 their passports confiscated and with no way to leave,
1:30:46 forced into much lower paying labor jobs with much
1:30:50 worse conditions than they had initially been promised.
1:30:52 Over the past decade, [music] Qatar has spent more than 200 billion
1:30:56 dollars of its LNG and petroleum wealth to build
1:30:59 out stadiums and infrastructure for the World Cup
1:31:01 and put millions of their foreign laborers to work.
1:31:04 And according to some reports, at least 6,500 of those workers died
1:31:11 building everything simply due to atrocious working conditions.
1:31:16 That is simply unacceptable and it is a dark stain
1:31:20 on Qatar's success story and the World Cup in general.
1:31:23 At the same time, Qatar's LNG wealth was
1:31:26 also coming under threat in the later 2010s.
1:31:29 After an investment of more than 250
1:31:30 billion dollars into their own LNG industry,
1:31:33 Australia suddenly surpassed the Qataris for the number one
1:31:36 largest exporter of LNG at the end of 2018.
1:31:39 And the United States wasn't very far behind them
1:31:42 with billions worth of investments into the industry of their own.
1:31:45 Australian and American LNG were suddenly competing
1:31:48 with Qatari LNG for market share across Asia.
1:31:51 And not content with playing second or even third fiddle,
1:31:54 the Qataris decided to double down.
1:31:56 In 2019, they announced a 30 billion dollar plan to expand their LNG production
1:32:01 from the North Field with billions of more
1:32:03 dollars coming from Western energy giants like Shell,
1:32:06 Exxon, and Chevron among others.
1:32:08 The plan was that Qatar's LNG exports
1:32:11 would be increased by nearly two-thirds by 2026,
1:32:14 which hypothetically would have enabled Qatar to regain the position
1:32:18 of the world's largest exporter and to then keep it indefinitely.
1:32:21 But many people were worried at the time
1:32:23 that such a massive investment into even more LNG
1:32:26 production would have never paid off with the stiff
1:32:29 competition growing from the Australians and the Americans.
1:32:32 Where would all the excess Qatari LNG go to?
1:32:35 The Asian market's demand was already largely being met.
1:32:38 North America was growing increasingly energy
1:32:40 independent and less reliant on imports.
1:32:43 And Europe hardly bought any LNG at all with most
1:32:46 of their gas demand being met by the Russians,
1:32:48 Norwegians, and Algerians through their pipelines.
1:32:50 And then, of course,
1:32:52 everything changed when the Russians invaded Ukraine and the Europeans
1:32:55 began to cut out all of their gas imports from Russia.
1:32:58 Suddenly, out of nowhere, a brand new enormous market for LNG that is roughly
1:33:03 the same size as Asia's market opened up to the suppliers.
1:33:07 And Qatar immediately became one of the best positioned to capitalize on it.
1:33:11 There is perhaps no other country in the world
1:33:13 that will benefit more from Russia's invasion of Ukraine than Qatar.
1:33:16 A flurry of high-ranking European Union
1:33:19 and German energy executives have now been
1:33:21 flying back and forth with Doha to discuss new LNG contracts and shipments.
1:33:26 And now, the Qatari economy is expected to grow by more than
1:33:29 4% this year alone and it could potentially only be the beginning.
1:33:33 With Russian gas now being completely locked out of the European market,
1:33:37 LNG replacements from elsewhere will be
1:33:39 highly in demand and competitively priced.
1:33:43 And Qatar is currently estimating that at least half of their ongoing LNG
1:33:47 expansion in the North Field will now be headed straight for Europe by 2026,
1:33:52 ensuring them billions of dollars a year in extra revenues
1:33:56 from today and increased leverage over European demand and influence.
1:34:00 Naturally, Qatar's new-found wealth has also come with new-found
1:34:04 ambitions and abilities to influence the world around them.
1:34:08 And this has often gotten them into trouble.
1:34:10 Since they share the largest natural gas field in the world with Iran,
1:34:13 Qatar has always maintained that fairly close
1:34:16 working relationship with them out of necessity, which, like I said before,
1:34:19 has never sat well with Saudi Arabia, Iran's fiercest geopolitical rival.
1:34:24 But Qatar's and Saudi Arabia's foreign policies
1:34:26 clash in many more ways than just this.
1:34:30 Following the Arab Spring revolutions that swept
1:34:32 across the Arab world in the early 2010s,
1:34:34 Qatar and Saudi Arabia nearly always found themselves supporting
1:34:38 the opposite sides in every conflict all throughout the region.
1:34:42 Qatar came to support the wave
1:34:43 of democratic and Islamist revolts long-standing Arab regimes,
1:34:47 such as by supporting the Muslim Brotherhood's democratic
1:34:50 rise to power in Egypt with billions of dollars,
1:34:53 generous media coverage within Al Jazeera
1:34:55 of the uprisings in Bahrain against the monarchy,
1:34:58 and eventual backing of the Tripoli-based Government
1:35:00 of National Accord during the Libyan Civil War.
1:35:03 All of which the Saudis fiercely opposed and fought against.
1:35:07 There became increasing concerns within Riyadh
1:35:09 that Qatar's overt support for revolutions
1:35:12 against long-standing autocratic regimes across
1:35:15 the Arab world meant that one day,
1:35:17 they would also be bankrolling a revolution against the nearly century-old
1:35:21 absolute monarchy in Saudi Arabia with both money and generous media coverage.
1:35:27 By 2017, the Saudis had had enough
1:35:29 of their conflicting ambitions and all on the same day,
1:35:32 Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates,
1:35:34 Bahrain, Egypt, Jordan, Djibouti, Senegal, Mauritania,
1:35:37 the Comoros, the Maldives,
1:35:38 and the Saudi-supported Tobruk-based government in Libya,
1:35:41 as well as the Saudi-supported Hadi government in Yemen,
1:35:44 all announced the severing of their diplomatic relations with Qatar.
1:35:48 Saudi Arabia and the UAE went another step
1:35:50 further by also shutting down all of their ports
1:35:53 to Qatari-registered ships and shutting down all
1:35:56 of their airspace to the state-owned airline, Qatar Airways.
1:35:59 The Saudis also shut down their entire land border with Qatar,
1:36:02 effectively transforming the country into an island state.
1:36:05 And then, to make Qatar's isolation even more permanent,
1:36:08 the Saudis even proposed digging a canal across their entire land
1:36:12 border and filling it in with water from the Persian Gulf,
1:36:15 which would have literally transformed Qatar into an island.
1:36:19 They made several demands of Qatar in order to lift the blockade,
1:36:22 including that they shut down Al Jazeera,
1:36:24 reduce their diplomatic relations with Iran,
1:36:26 end their alleged support for foreign organizations considered to be terrorist
1:36:29 by the Saudis like the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt and Hamas in Gaza,
1:36:33 among others, agree to reparation payments and 10 years of monitoring,
1:36:38 and to align themselves fully with the geopolitical
1:36:41 interests of Saudi Arabia and the other Gulf states.
1:36:44 Naturally, Qatar refused all of the demands and the economic
1:36:47 consequences of the Saudi-led blockade over them immediately became apparent.
1:36:51 Qatar Airways had relied extensively on both Saudi and Emirati
1:36:55 airspace for a significant amount of their routes and nearly overnight,
1:36:59 they had to suddenly change all of their flight paths
1:37:01 to longer and more costly routes to avoid both countries entirely.
1:37:05 The Saudi-led blockade over Qatar would go on for another three
1:37:08 and a half years until January of 2021 and it largely
1:37:13 only ended out of the Saudi regime's own desire to rebrand
1:37:16 their image with the incoming Biden administration over in the United States.
1:37:21 Many figures in Washington have been
1:37:22 frustrated with the blockade for years because
1:37:25 both Saudi Arabia and Qatar are nominally strategic allies of the United States.
1:37:31 And even more strange, the United States, Qatar,
1:37:34 and the Saudis had all actually been cooperating together alongside
1:37:38 of each other for years in another major conflict in the region,
1:37:41 the civil war in Yemen.
1:37:43 In late 2014 or early 2015, a Shia Muslim-adjacent group called the Houthis
1:37:48 managed to seize control over the capital in Yemen and declared themselves
1:37:52 as the sole legitimate government of the country,
1:37:54 sparking a civil [music] war between
1:37:56 themselves and the previously Sunni Muslim-led government.
1:37:59 The sudden possibility of Yemen flipping into a Shia-led
1:38:02 country immediately sent shockwaves throughout the Islamic world and especially
1:38:08 in Saudi Arabia over the fear that a Shia-led
1:38:11 Yemen could end up aligning itself with the Iranians,
1:38:15 the world's most preeminent Shia power.
1:38:17 Were this scenario to take place, Saudi Arabia would be placed into its
1:38:22 worst imaginable geopolitical position with its
1:38:25 primary enemy Iran being theoretically capable
1:38:27 of blockading the Strait of Hormuz,
1:38:29 the leads between the Persian Gulf and the Arabian Sea,
1:38:32 and an Iranian-aligned Yemen theoretically
1:38:34 capable of simultaneously blockading the Bab
1:38:37 el-Mandeb Strait between the Red Sea and the Arabian Sea.
1:38:41 Were that to happen, Saudi Arabia would economically collapse because
1:38:45 the country relies so extensively on selling
1:38:47 their oil exports to countries in Asia on the backs of tanker ships.
1:38:51 The most direct route to Asia for these tanker
1:38:53 ships to take from Saudi Arabia are, of course,
1:38:56 from either the Saudi East or West Coast through
1:38:58 either the Strait of Hormuz or the Bab el-Mandeb Strait.
1:39:02 But if both of them are blockaded, then the only possible way that Saudi
1:39:06 oil could actually continue reaching their Asian
1:39:08 customers would be through the Suez Canal
1:39:11 and around the entirety of the African continent,
1:39:14 which would make Saudi oil far more expensive and less
1:39:17 competitive and potentially crash their economy in the process.
1:39:21 So, in order to prevent that from ever happening,
1:39:23 the Saudis gather together a massive military coalition
1:39:27 that included the Qataris and support from the Americans,
1:39:30 and they began invading and blockading Yemen in March
1:39:33 of 2015 in order to topple the Houthis from power.
1:39:40 Djibouti is a small country in the Horn of Africa that is most
1:39:42 well known in the Western world for its funny sounding name in English.
1:39:45 Indeed, Djibouti is a country that few
1:39:47 Westerners probably ever give a second thought about.
1:39:50 It's only about the size of New Hampshire and it
1:39:51 only has a small population of about 957,000 people,
1:39:55 the lowest population of any country on the entire mainland African continent.
1:39:59 And yet, despite its small size and funny sounding name,
1:40:02 Djibouti is one of the most serious and influential
1:40:04 geopolitical hotspots in the entire world because of this.
1:40:08 The sheer number of foreign military bases
1:40:11 that have been established on its territory.
1:40:13 I mean, just look at this map
1:40:14 of the area immediately around Djibouti's capital city,
1:40:16 which is also called Djibouti.
1:40:18 You've got an American military base here,
1:40:20 which is the only permanent military base the United
1:40:22 States has got anywhere on the African continent.
1:40:24 You've got a collection of French military bases up here,
1:40:27 a French operated airbase down here that the United
1:40:29 States also uses to fly drones out of.
1:40:31 You've got a Japanese military base over here,
1:40:33 which is literally the only overseas base that the Japanese operate anywhere.
1:40:37 You've got an Italian military base wedged in here by the Americans.
1:40:41 You've got another French naval base up here.
1:40:43 You've got German and Spanish soldiers who don't have bases
1:40:45 of their own but get stationed up in these hotels.
1:40:48 And then you've even got a Chinese People's Liberation Army
1:40:50 naval base over here on the other side of town,
1:40:52 opposite of the Americans and friends.
1:40:54 The first overseas military base that the People's
1:40:57 Republic of China ever built anywhere.
1:40:59 And other countries are still actively trying
1:41:01 to build their own bases here as well.
1:41:03 In 2021, Djibouti agreed to allow Saudi Arabia to begin
1:41:06 construction of a new military base in the country as well,
1:41:09 which will likely appear somewhere near the American base when completed.
1:41:12 And then for years now,
1:41:13 Djibouti has also been courted by the Indian and Russian governments
1:41:16 to construct some kind of base there for themselves as well.
1:41:19 All of this means that as of 2023,
1:41:21 little Djibouti in fact has by far the highest per capita concentration
1:41:25 of foreign military bases on its soil out of any country in the world.
1:41:29 [music] And that kind of begs the question, why and how did this little country
1:41:34 in the Horn of Africa essentially become the 21st
1:41:37 century's global military base for all of the world's
1:41:40 great powers to set up their operations in.
1:41:42 Well, a lot of Djibouti's significance
1:41:44 and value comes from its ideal geographic position.
1:41:47 You see, while Djibouti is indeed small,
1:41:49 it also sits precisely on the western side of the narrow Bab el-Mandeb Strait,
1:41:53 immediately opposite of Yemen.
1:41:55 At its narrowest point, this strait is but 28 km wide,
1:41:59 and it is those 28 km that all ships must pass through
1:42:03 in order to get between the Red Sea and the Gulf of Aden.
1:42:05 And in effect, because of the Suez Canal further to the north through Egypt,
1:42:09 it is these 28 km that all ships must pass through in order
1:42:12 to get between the Mediterranean Sea and the Indian Ocean, at least quickly.
1:42:16 This makes the Bab el-Mandeb Strait one of the most
1:42:18 geopolitically crucial maritime choke points in the world,
1:42:22 especially from the perspective of the global oil and gas industry
1:42:25 and the state security of dozens of countries from all around the world.
1:42:28 You see, while the Red Sea in the area around the Bab
1:42:30 el-Mandeb Strait never yielded very many
1:42:32 lucrative oil or natural gas discoveries,
1:42:34 the nearby Persian Gulf region on the other side of the Arabian Peninsula
1:42:38 literally contains the highest concentration of oil
1:42:41 and gas found anywhere on the planet.
1:42:43 Approximately half of all the world's known oil reserves
1:42:45 and around a third of all the world's current oil production,
1:42:48 in addition to around 40% of all the world's
1:42:50 known natural gas reserves are found only here,
1:42:53 scattered around the shores of Iran, Iraq, Kuwait,
1:42:55 Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Qatar, the United Arab Emirates, and Oman.
1:42:59 These reserves include the largest single oil field ever
1:43:02 discovered in the world here at Ghawar in Saudi Arabia,
1:43:04 and the largest single natural gas field ever
1:43:06 discovered in the world here at the North
1:43:08 and South Pars Field in the center of the Gulf shared between Qatar and Iran,
1:43:13 which all in itself represents around a fifth of all
1:43:16 the natural gas reserves ever found on the entire planet.
1:43:19 The Persian Gulf is therefore arguably the single most
1:43:22 important location on the entire planet in the 21st century,
1:43:26 as it is effectively the greatest single source
1:43:28 in the universe for the energy that humanity collectively consumes.
1:43:31 The eight countries around the Persian Gulf
1:43:33 harvest their oil and natural gas resources, load them up on a container ships,
1:43:37 and then ship them through the similarly narrow
1:43:39 Strait of Hormuz and into the Indian Ocean,
1:43:42 where they then travel onwards to markets all around the world.
1:43:45 For the ships carrying Persian Gulf oil and natural gas towards Asia,
1:43:48 the journey then takes them across the Arabian Sea and the Bay of Bengal,
1:43:51 then through the narrow Strait of Malacca,
1:43:52 and then onwards to the energy-hungry economies of China,
1:43:55 Taiwan, South Korea, and Japan.
1:43:57 But for the ships carrying Persian Gulf oil and natural
1:43:59 gas onwards from the Strait of Hormuz to Europe,
1:44:01 the quickest and most efficient path is for them
1:44:03 to then head west across the Gulf of Aden,
1:44:05 through the Bab el-Mandeb Strait past Djibouti,
1:44:07 up the Red Sea and through the Suez Canal across Egypt
1:44:10 and into the Mediterranean before then continuing
1:44:12 onwards to ports across the European continent.
1:44:15 As of 2022, approximately 20% of the European Union's oil imports and 24%
1:44:20 of their liquefied natural gas imports were all
1:44:22 coming in from countries around the Persian Gulf,
1:44:25 delivered almost entirely by containers passing through
1:44:28 the Bab el-Mandeb Strait and the Suez Canal.
1:44:30 Were either of these choke points to become somehow obstructed or blockaded,
1:44:34 the European Union would in a flash lose a major import route for huge
1:44:38 volumes of their oil and gas supply that powers their societies and economies.
1:44:42 And the only possible alternative route for Persian
1:44:45 Gulf oil and gas to reach the European market would be by then sailing the very
1:44:49 long way around the entirety of the African continent,
1:44:52 a route that adds weeks to delivery times
1:44:54 and consequently adds higher cost to the prices of imports.
1:44:58 This risk was most laid bare back in March of 2021,
1:45:01 when a container ship ran aground within the Suez Canal and blocked
1:45:03 it all off to trade for a period of 6 days,
1:45:06 resulting in hundreds of ships queuing up
1:45:08 to pass through the canal to collectively
1:45:09 prevented an estimated 9.6 [music] billion
1:45:12 dollars worth of trade from taking place.
1:45:15 Were the Bab el-Mandeb Strait to become blocked for whatever reason instead,
1:45:18 the result would largely be the same.
1:45:21 And that is a massive fear to Saudi Arabia.
1:45:24 You see, if there were ever a textbook definition
1:45:27 of what a petrostate looks like, it is Saudi Arabia.
1:45:30 The country controls 15% of the entire world's proven reserves of oil,
1:45:34 largely around its territory bordering the Persian Gulf.
1:45:37 The Saudis are the largest oil exporter in the entire world,
1:45:40 and they also maintain the largest oil production capacity in the entire world.
1:45:44 The Saudi state is defined by its vast oil reserves and production
1:45:48 and ability to sell and export that oil to markets around the world.
1:45:52 40% of the entire Saudi GDP is simply the country's oil industry,
1:45:57 while on average over the past decade,
1:45:59 Saudi oil revenues have provided a whopping
1:46:01 75% of the government's entire annual budget
1:46:05 that funds everything from ambitious construction
1:46:08 and infrastructure projects to the Saudi Armed Forces.
1:46:11 Therefore, if Saudi Arabia's ability to export oil abroad and earn
1:46:14 revenue to fund their government was ever put into jeopardy,
1:46:17 it could end up literally meaning the collapse
1:46:19 of the central Saudi state and even the Saudi absolute monarchy.
1:46:23 Since nearly all of Saudi Arabia's oil fields are located
1:46:25 in the east of the country near to the Persian Gulf,
1:46:28 the easiest and most obvious method of getting their oil out to global markets
1:46:32 is by putting them on container ships
1:46:33 and sending them through the Strait of Hormuz.
1:46:35 But that strait is vulnerable because at its narrowest point,
1:46:39 it is less than 34 km wide, and the entire northern shoreline of the strait
1:46:44 is controlled by their greatest geopolitical rival,
1:46:47 the Islamic Republic of Iran.
1:46:50 Throughout the decades,
1:46:50 the Iranians have frequently threatened and boasted about their ability to shut
1:46:54 down the Strait of Hormuz if they ever felt like it,
1:46:57 either by placing countless naval mines across the strait
1:47:00 and/or by lining the north shore of the strait
1:47:02 with area denial weapons like surface-to-ship and surface-to-air
1:47:05 missiles and just attacking everything that comes through it.
1:47:08 Such an action would probably trigger a military
1:47:10 response from the United States, but it would also,
1:47:13 at least [music] temporarily, crash Saudi Arabia's ability to export oil through
1:47:17 the Strait of Hormuz and keep their government functioning.
1:47:20 So, in order to mitigate that risk a bit,
1:47:22 the Saudis constructed what's known as the East-West Pipeline,
1:47:25 which can transfer limited volumes of their crude oil from their fields
1:47:29 around the Persian Gulf to ports over on the Red Sea,
1:47:32 where the oil can then continue on to world markets through either
1:47:35 the Bab el-Mandeb Strait in the south or the Suez Canal in the north.
1:47:38 But unfortunately for the Saudis,
1:47:40 even this ability has come under threat because of the civil war in Yemen.
1:47:45 Beginning in 2014, a generally Shia Muslim-adjacent
1:47:48 faction in Yemen known as the Houthis
1:47:50 rose up in revolt against the predominantly
1:47:52 Sunni Muslim and Saudi-backed government in the country,
1:47:55 and they quickly seized control over the capital city.
1:47:58 The Houthis have allegedly received weapons and financing from the Iranians,
1:48:02 and their zone of control primarily exists near
1:48:04 to the eastern shore of the Bab el-Mandeb Strait.
1:48:07 Were the Houthis to become successful and take control over
1:48:10 Yemen and remain aligned with Saudi Arabia's greatest geopolitical rival, Iran,
1:48:15 it is conceivable that the Houthis and Iranians
1:48:17 could coordinate a joint blockade action wherein the Iranians
1:48:20 block the Strait of Hormuz and the Houthis block
1:48:23 the Bab el-Mandeb Strait at the exact same time.
1:48:27 And in doing so, deny the Saudis pretty much any way to continue
1:48:30 exporting their oil to their largest customers in East Asia, like China.
1:48:34 The only way the Saudis could continue transporting their oil
1:48:37 to markets in Asia under this scenario would be the very,
1:48:40 very long and limited way across the East-West
1:48:43 Pipeline to the west coast, up the Red Sea,
1:48:46 through the Suez Canal, across the Mediterranean,
1:48:48 and through the Strait of Gibraltar,
1:48:50 and then around the entirety of the African continent just to get
1:48:54 to the same place where Saudi oil exports normally begin at anyway.
1:48:58 This is why the Saudis have been attacking
1:49:00 and bombing the Houthis in Yemen for years now,
1:49:03 and it's why the Saudis have been so interested in building
1:49:06 their own overseas military base on the opposite end of the Bab
1:49:09 el Mandeb Strait in Djibouti so that they can quickly respond
1:49:13 to the situation and free the strait up if that time ever comes.
1:49:16 But of course, the Bab el Mandeb Strait isn't just
1:49:19 of critical importance to the Saudis and their state security.
1:49:22 Following the Russian invasion of Ukraine in Europe,
1:49:24 the European Union has been steadily divesting itself away
1:49:27 from their previously high imports of Russian oil and gas.
1:49:31 One of the primary countries that has stepped up to supply
1:49:33 the Europeans with greater quantities of natural gas is Qatar,
1:49:37 a small country but with big resources.
1:49:40 The second largest reserves of natural gas of any
1:49:43 country on the planet after the Russians themselves.
1:49:46 The Qataris are currently investing tens of billions of dollars into expanding
1:49:49 their LNG production out of their North Field in the Gulf,
1:49:53 a large amount of which is slated to be exported further to Europe
1:49:56 as the European demand for alternative supplies
1:49:58 of gas away from Russia continues to increase.
1:50:01 Qatar is thus becoming a major component
1:50:03 of the European Union's new energy profile as the EU
1:50:06 continues to increase their LNG imports and divest
1:50:09 themselves away from Russian natural gas pipelines.
1:50:12 But just like the oil making its way to Europe, the cheapest, quickest,
1:50:16 and easiest way for Qatari LNG to make its
1:50:18 way to Europe is also through the Strait of Hormuz,
1:50:21 the Bab el Mandeb Strait, and the Suez Canal.
1:50:24 Consequently, the Bab el Mandeb and the Suez
1:50:26 Canal alike are both gaining in global importance.
1:50:29 [music] Even as far back as 2018 before all these major geopolitical shifts,
1:50:34 an estimated 6.2 million barrels worth of crude oil a day
1:50:38 were passing through the Bab el Mandeb Strait toward Europe,
1:50:40 Asia, and North America,
1:50:42 representing around 9% of all the traded oil in the world.
1:50:46 And it's not just oil and gas that makes the Bab el Mandeb so important either.
1:50:50 From China's perspective, the strait is a critical component making up
1:50:53 their shortest maritime export route to Europe as well.
1:50:56 China's economy is basically based around importing enormous amounts
1:51:01 of raw energy materials from the Persian Gulf states,
1:51:04 using those enormous raw energy materials
1:51:06 to produce enormous volumes of manufactured goods,
1:51:09 and then exporting those enormous volumes of manufactured goods
1:51:13 to the world's largest consumer markets in North America and Europe.
1:51:16 These manufactured exports represent around 30% of the entire Chinese economy,
1:51:21 and the quickest and cheapest way for their exports
1:51:23 to make it to the European market ends up passing through
1:51:26 the Bab el Mandeb Strait and the Suez Canal rather
1:51:29 than sailing the long way around either Africa or the Pacific.
1:51:32 Ultimately, the Bab el Mandeb Strait is one of the most critical
1:51:34 maritime chokepoints that keeps the pace of globalized trade alive and well.
1:51:38 Europe needs the strait to be secure to continue
1:51:40 importing large amounts of their oil and gas
1:51:42 from the Persian Gulf and large volumes of manufactured
1:51:45 products from China as cheaply and as quickly as possible.
1:51:48 Persian Gulf states and primarily Saudi Arabia need
1:51:50 the strait to remain secure so that they
1:51:52 can continue selling oil and gas to Europe
1:51:54 and Asia and keep their foreign policy options flexible.
1:51:57 China needs the strait secure to continue exporting their manufactured
1:52:00 goods to Europe as quickly and cheaply as possible.
1:52:02 While the United States wants the strait to remain secure
1:52:05 to keep global trade from falling apart and to keep
1:52:08 the European oil and gas supply steady in the face
1:52:10 of Russian aggression and energy warfare in Europe.
1:52:13 That's why the security of the Bab Strait is so important to so many people.
1:52:18 But it's also unfortunately placed
1:52:20 in a very geopolitically turbulent neighborhood.
1:52:24 Yemen, which occupies the entire north shore of the strait,
1:52:27 has been consumed by one of the most devastating civil wars
1:52:30 of the 21st century for nearly a decade now that is still continuing.
1:52:34 A civil war that has claimed the lives of hundreds
1:52:37 of thousands of people and has become an intense
1:52:39 proxy conflict between Saudi Arabia and Iran as each
1:52:42 vies for supremacy over the other in the country.
1:52:45 On the southern shore of the strait is Eritrea,
1:52:48 a ruthless totalitarian one-party dictatorship that has been ruled
1:52:51 by the same man ever since 1993 and which
1:52:54 is generally considered to have one of the most
1:52:56 abysmal human rights records and freedoms on the planet,
1:52:59 genuinely on a par with North Korea.
1:53:02 Eritrea was also locked in a conflict over disputed lands
1:53:05 with neighboring Ethiopia for decades until it was resolved only in 2019.
1:53:10 But the very next year after that, the Tigray War exploded in Ethiopia just
1:53:15 across the border as the Tigray region
1:53:17 of Ethiopia rebelled against the central Ethiopian government.
1:53:21 A horrible conflict which would ultimately between 2020
1:53:24 and 2022 descend into the bloodiest and most
1:53:27 violent conflict of the entire 21st century
1:53:30 and claim the lives of around 600,000 people.
1:53:34 The Eritrean army invaded the Tigray region at the behest
1:53:37 of the central Ethiopian government
1:53:39 and committed numerous atrocities and massacres.
1:53:42 And still, as of the production of this video,
1:53:44 has never agreed to any formal peace settlement.
1:53:47 And then there's also Somalia,
1:53:49 a country whose very name is essentially synonymous
1:53:52 in the Western world with anarchy and chaos.
1:53:55 The country has been locked in a multi-sided
1:53:57 civil war for more than 40 years now.
1:53:59 There is really no concept
1:54:00 of a centralized authority anywhere across the country.
1:54:03 Over the decades and lack of central authority in Somalia,
1:54:07 insurgents and pirates alike have thrived as they
1:54:10 realized their country enjoys a coastline directly
1:54:12 adjacent to one of the most strategically valuable
1:54:15 and lucrative maritime trade routes in the world.
1:54:18 And so, Somali pirate attacks on container and cargo vessels transiting the Bab
1:54:22 el Mandeb Strait have been frequent occurrences over the past 20 years.
1:54:26 Yemen, Eritrea, and Somalia are all generally unstable and fragile
1:54:30 countries who've been frequently involved
1:54:32 in both internal and external conflicts.
1:54:34 And all of that combines to put
1:54:36 maritime shipping through the Bab Strait into jeopardy,
1:54:39 which threatens the economies and security
1:54:41 of countries from all around the world.
1:54:43 This then led to the sense in many countries
1:54:45 that a military presence of some kind nearby to the strait
1:54:48 was necessary in order to ensure the strait's security
1:54:51 and the continued uninterrupted global flow of cheap oil,
1:54:54 cheap gas, and cheap manufactured goods through it could continue.
1:54:58 And so, for the most part,
1:54:59 that left only little Djibouti as an island of relative stability
1:55:03 in a very chaotic neighborhood for outside
1:55:06 powers to construct their military bases in.
1:55:08 Bases which would enable their military to project
1:55:10 power into the Bab el Mandeb Strait and keep the flow of global trade continuing
1:55:14 through the dangerous neighborhood and the various risks.
1:55:18 But Djibouti itself is also a fairly autocratic country since it
1:55:21 has been ruled by the very same president ever since 1999,
1:55:24 Omar Guelleh, and elections are generally
1:55:27 viewed as being unfair and undemocratic.
1:55:30 But that doesn't really matter because crucially,
1:55:33 ignoring some fairly minor border skirmishes with Eritrea back in 1999 and 2008,
1:55:37 Djibouti is a country that has remained relatively free of conflicts
1:55:41 in a region of the world that is usually full of them.
1:55:44 And part of the reason why is because recognizing their status as a small
1:55:48 and largely defenseless country in control
1:55:50 of extremely strategically valuable real estate,
1:55:54 President Guelleh has welcomed the presence
1:55:56 of foreign military to come and establish
1:55:58 their bases within his country that will
1:56:00 protect it from the chaos that surrounds it.
1:56:02 And Djibouti's strategic location is important even beyond
1:56:05 the shipping concerns through the Bab el Mandeb Strait.
1:56:09 This is because Ethiopia immediately to the southwest
1:56:11 of Djibouti is home to Africa's second largest population of more than 120
1:56:15 million people but is also completely landlocked,
1:56:19 which severely limits their ability to send exports or receive
1:56:21 imports to and from the rest of the world.
1:56:24 So, because Ethiopia and Eritrea have been locked in some
1:56:26 kind of territorial conflict for decades had a very tense relationship,
1:56:31 and because Somalia is,
1:56:32 well, Somalia, that basically just leaves Djibouti as the only possible nearby
1:56:37 source with maritime access for Ethiopia
1:56:39 to receive imports or send exports through.
1:56:41 That is why little Djibouti, a nation of less than 1 million people,
1:56:45 handles more than 95% of all the imports from around
1:56:50 the world that make their way into giant Ethiopia,
1:56:53 a nation with more than 120 times their own population.
1:56:57 Djibouti's location and relative stability
1:57:00 within its dangerous neighborhood grants it
1:57:01 outrageously outsized power and influence over
1:57:05 Ethiopia and the globalized trade network,
1:57:07 which makes it a potentially lucrative target to many outside powers,
1:57:12 [music] which is why the country has been more
1:57:14 than happy to allow military great powers from all around
1:57:17 the world to set up their bases there and dissuade
1:57:20 any potential hostile outside power from ever trying anything funny.
1:57:23 And that is why all today you have American,
1:57:25 French, Italian, Japanese, German, Spanish, Saudi Arabian,
1:57:29 and Chinese military bases all crowded together so nearby to each other
1:57:34 in attempts from the Russians and Indians to build their own as well,
1:57:37 all of whom want to project power into the Bab
1:57:39 el Mandeb Strait and protect their own interests in the region.
1:57:42 The American base in Djibouti is the only
1:57:44 permanent US military base on the mainland African continent,
1:57:47 and it enables the US military and their drones
1:57:49 to conduct operations in nearby Yemen against
1:57:51 Al-Qaeda elements and in nearby Somalia against Al-Shabaab
1:57:55 and ISIS elements with support from the French,
1:57:57 Japanese, Italians, Germans, and Spaniards.
1:57:59 The American base has also helped with refueling
1:58:01 Saudi warplanes as they bomb Houthi targets across Yemen.
1:58:05 While Saudi Arabia's own future base in Djibouti will
1:58:07 help them do this themselves after the Biden administration
1:58:10 in the United States withdrew all of their direct American
1:58:13 support for the Saudi war effort in Yemen back in 2021,
1:58:16 like helping them refueling their aircraft.
1:58:18 And then the Chinese naval bases there officially help fight against piracy
1:58:22 in the region and ensure that critical
1:58:23 maritime shipping lanes remain open and secure.
1:58:26 Though it has generated a fairly high degree of geopolitical angst
1:58:30 with the American military base that is only a few miles away from it.
1:58:34 Both the Americans and the Chinese have
1:58:36 lodged official complaints with the Djiboutian government accusing
1:58:39 the other of using their base to spy on their own base [music] with one
1:58:43 incident even being reported by the Americans
1:58:45 of Chinese troops in their base on the north side of town shining laser beams
1:58:49 into the cockpits of American planes flying nearby.
1:58:52 But nonetheless, Djibouti allows them both to remain along with all of the other
1:58:56 military bases in the country as well
1:58:58 because they all serve Djibouti's own purposes.
1:59:01 Who would dare attack little defenseless Djibouti
1:59:04 and provoke both of the emerging global superpowers,
1:59:08 the United States and China?
1:59:11 Djibouti's strategic calculus here is really nothing short of a genius play
1:59:15 and the best possible use of the geographic hand that they have been dealt.
1:59:23 Perhaps more than any other country today in the 21st century,
1:59:26 Saudi Arabia has the most uncertain future ahead of itself.
1:59:30 The country truly has almost countless problems ahead of it that it
1:59:33 must overcome in order to survive and they've only been able to overcome
1:59:36 all of these problems so far because of their dominance over a critical
1:59:40 resource that everyone in the world has wanted for the past 100 years,
1:59:44 but from which the world is currently starting to move away from, oil.
1:59:49 The Saudi Arabian state is one that is nearly
1:59:51 utterly defined by its control over this black liquidy resource.
1:59:55 As recently as 2018, the petroleum business in the country accounted
1:59:59 for a whopping 87% of the government's annual budget,
2:00:03 90% of the country's export earnings
2:00:05 and a massive 42% of the country's entire GDP.
2:00:10 This is because Saudi Arabia is known today to control approximately
2:00:13 a quarter of all the proven oil reserves in the world,
2:00:16 the second largest reserves of all the world's countries,
2:00:19 second only to Venezuela.
2:00:21 But unlike Venezuela's technically larger oil reserves,
2:00:24 which are highly crude, difficult and expensive to access,
2:00:27 Saudi Arabia's only slightly smaller reserves are
2:00:30 located under pressure just beneath the earth's surface
2:00:33 and they are extremely easy and cheap
2:00:36 to access and they're much easier to refine.
2:00:39 This is why for decades Saudi Arabia was
2:00:41 the largest producer of oil in the world
2:00:43 and is currently the world's second largest
2:00:45 producer just barely behind the United States.
2:00:48 Alongside Russia, these three countries are collectively referred to as the big
2:00:52 three of global oil production today because no single
2:00:55 other country comes anywhere close to matching them and they
2:00:58 combined produce approximately 40% of all the oil in the world.
2:01:02 But America's population is 332 million and so most of America's
2:01:06 oil production is consumed within the country and not exported abroad,
2:01:10 which is why America is only the world's 14th largest oil exporter.
2:01:14 Saudi Arabia has just about a tenth of the American population,
2:01:18 but produces nearly as much oil as it,
2:01:20 meaning that they simply have far more that they can never possibly consume
2:01:24 on their own and so they have far more left over to export to other countries.
2:01:28 Saudi Arabia is thus by far the largest exporter of oil in the world and oil
2:01:33 continues to provide roughly a third of all
2:01:35 the energy that humanity collectively consumes worldwide.
2:01:39 Countries like India, China, Japan,
2:01:40 South Africa and numerous European states all import
2:01:44 enormous volumes of their own oil supplies from Saudi
2:01:47 Arabia and are thus all heavily reliant
2:01:50 on keeping those flows of oil continuing for now.
2:01:53 It is this simple calculus that has given Saudi
2:01:56 Arabia enormous geopolitical power and clout over the past
2:02:00 century because they've just got more oil to give
2:02:02 others than anybody else and more than any other country,
2:02:06 Saudi Arabia is the one most capable of influencing
2:02:09 the global price of oil either negatively or positively.
2:02:13 This is because besides being by far the largest exporter of oil,
2:02:17 Saudi Arabia also has by far the largest spare capacity of oil production
2:02:22 and this is what truly gives the Saudi
2:02:25 state its unbelievable levels of global power.
2:02:28 Spare capacity in the oil business refers to the number of oil
2:02:31 wells that a country possesses that are not currently being used,
2:02:34 but which can be brought online again
2:02:36 in a very short notice to rapidly increase production.
2:02:40 Saudi Arabia wields the largest spare capacity of oil
2:02:43 production in the world and they usually keep
2:02:45 around 1 and 1/2 to 2 million barrels per
2:02:47 day of oil production reserved in this spare capacity.
2:02:50 By rapidly turning this spare capacity back online,
2:02:53 Saudi Arabia can rapidly increase its globally significant oil
2:02:56 production and dump those extra supplies onto the world market,
2:03:00 thus decreasing global prices of oil.
2:03:02 And by doing the reverse,
2:03:04 by shutting more wells offline and increasing its available spare capacity,
2:03:08 Saudi Arabia can rapidly decrease its globally
2:03:11 significant oil production and restrict global oil supplies,
2:03:14 thus increasing worldwide oil scarcity and increasing global oil prices.
2:03:19 This is why Saudi Arabia is often referred to as the central bank of world oil
2:03:24 and it's how the Saudi state can exert
2:03:26 significant leverage over every single country in the world,
2:03:30 including the world's most powerful country, the United States.
2:03:33 Well, America only imports a fraction of its
2:03:35 oil supply from Saudi Arabia these days,
2:03:37 overall oil prices in the United States can still be severely
2:03:41 impacted by the whims of the absolute monarchy in Saudi Arabia.
2:03:44 After the Russians invaded Ukraine in February of 2022,
2:03:47 the Western world immediately passed a series of sanctions against
2:03:50 Russia that shut that country's oil supply out of their markets,
2:03:54 which obviously reduced the supply of oil in their markets
2:03:57 and led to a rise in oil prices.
2:03:59 And when oil prices rise, it tends to increase inflation in every
2:04:02 other sector of the economy because nearly every
2:04:04 business in the world relies on oil
2:04:07 at some point in time in its production process,
2:04:09 which means that when oil prices go up, businesses have to raise their prices
2:04:13 in order to offset their increased production costs.
2:04:15 So, after the Russians invaded Ukraine and the global price
2:04:18 of oil shot up and inflation rates went up along with it,
2:04:21 the Biden administration in the United States requested that Saudi
2:04:24 Arabia turn more of their spare capacity on and ramp up
2:04:27 production to place more oil onto the global market in order
2:04:30 to decrease oil prices that would help tame global inflation.
2:04:33 But the Saudis instead did the complete opposite.
2:04:36 They ended up cutting more of their production
2:04:38 over and over these past several months,
2:04:41 adding more wells to their offline spare capacity and decreasing
2:04:45 the supply of global oil in coordination with Russia,
2:04:48 which is increasing oil prices around the world,
2:04:50 which is enabling the Russians to earn more money
2:04:53 on their own oil sales that is being plowed
2:04:55 into waging their war in Ukraine and it is
2:04:57 increasing inflationary pressures in gasoline prices in the United States.
2:05:01 [music] As of May 2023, the American Strategic Petroleum Reserve or SPR,
2:05:06 the usually massive emergency stockpile of petroleum
2:05:09 that the United States keeps stashed
2:05:10 away in tanks in Louisiana and Texas to release during an oil supply crisis,
2:05:14 has been gradually depleted every single day since the invasion of Ukraine
2:05:18 began to the lowest level seen in 40 years right now since 1983.
2:05:23 Doing so has helped tame gasoline prices in the country for now,
2:05:27 but with the reserve now heavily depleted Washington possesses very little
2:05:31 other options available to keep gasoline
2:05:34 prices from spiraling upwards leading up
2:05:36 to the November 2024 presidential election other than calling Saudi Arabia
2:05:41 and requesting them to turn more of their spare capacity back online,
2:05:44 which the Saudis will surely only do if they are given certain favors.
2:05:49 This is precisely how Saudi Arabia is able to wield its oil
2:05:52 might and exert geopolitical influence across the entire world in the process.
2:05:57 But Saudi Arabia's great challenge in the 21st
2:06:00 century is that this greatest of its
2:06:02 powers has a finite lifespan remaining and at a certain point in the future,
2:06:07 a day will come when this power will
2:06:09 completely evaporate altogether because over the next several decades
2:06:12 as countries around the world steadily continue moving
2:06:15 their economies away from oil as an energy source,
2:06:17 Saudi Arabia's great advantage of being the global
2:06:20 oil business's central bank will matter less and less.
2:06:24 And if the country does nothing to change itself between now and whenever
2:06:27 that uncertain future day arrives it will only be left with sand,
2:06:31 one of the worst human rights records on the planet,
2:06:34 an archaic religious absolute monarchy that most
2:06:36 of the outside world finds repugnant and a lack
2:06:40 of protection from the United States while being
2:06:43 surrounded by countless enemies from both within and without.
2:06:46 [music] If Saudi Arabia does nothing to change,
2:06:49 Saudi Arabia will no longer exist at all by the end of the century.
2:06:53 But change is also going to be very, very hard and uncertain.
2:06:58 And if you want to understand Arabia is going in the future,
2:07:01 you've got to understand where Saudi Arabia came from in the first
2:07:05 place and why the country would have almost certainly never managed
2:07:08 to exist at all in its current form were it not
2:07:11 for the very fortunate discovery of oil very early on into its history.
2:07:16 For thousands of years,
2:07:17 the Arabian Peninsula was divided between various different tribes,
2:07:20 sheikhs, kings and empires.
2:07:22 There was very little to note about the lands
2:07:24 in the center of the Arabian Peninsula where the House
2:07:26 of Saud first originated in history a little more than
2:07:29 300 years ago in a region known as the Najd.
2:07:32 The overwhelming majority of Saudi
2:07:33 Arabia's current lands are completely uninhabitable.
2:07:36 The country is after all the largest in the world today
2:07:38 that doesn't have a single river anywhere to be found within it.
2:07:42 Rainfall across most of the country's land is extremely scarce and so fresh
2:07:46 water for drinking and agriculture have
2:07:48 historically been extremely difficult to come by.
2:07:50 Across the south of the modern country is
2:07:52 a vast desert known as the Rub' al Khali,
2:07:55 better known in English as the Empty Quarter.
2:07:57 It is the largest continuous expanse of sand
2:07:59 that can be found anywhere in the world.
2:08:01 It is nearly completely devoid of life and it
2:08:04 is larger in area than the entirety of France.
2:08:07 The region of Najd deep within the interior of the Arabian
2:08:09 Peninsula was an extremely sparsely populated and isolated backwater separated
2:08:14 from the rest of the world by vast empty deserts and high
2:08:17 mountains with nothing of value to offer anyone in the outside world.
2:08:21 It was a place hardly anyone paid any
2:08:23 attention to and its extreme isolation from the rest
2:08:26 of the world was partially why an extremely
2:08:28 strict interpretation of Sunni Islam gradually developed there,
2:08:32 now sometimes known as Wahhabism.
2:08:34 It was an unlikely place from which one of the most powerful
2:08:37 nations of the modern world would arise from, but so it did regardless.
2:08:42 Across the 18th and 19th centuries,
2:08:44 two small and largely unknown family clans within
2:08:46 the Najd region cemented an alliance between themselves,
2:08:49 the House of Saud who had run the politics
2:08:51 and day-to-day governance of the lands they controlled and the clan
2:08:54 of Wahhab who had run the lands' religious affairs
2:08:56 based upon their own extremely strict interpretation of Sunni Islam.
2:09:00 The previously mentioned branch of the faith
2:09:02 that is sometimes referred to as Wahhabism.
2:09:04 After joining forces,
2:09:05 the Saud and Wahhab alliance went on to carve out the first Saudi state
2:09:09 that survived between 1744 and 1814 before
2:09:12 it was ultimately destroyed by the Ottomans.
2:09:14 A group of survivors managed to take back the Saud's ancestral capital at Riyadh
2:09:18 in 1818 and from there they carved out
2:09:20 the second Saudi state that survived for most
2:09:22 of the rest of the 19th century until
2:09:23 1891 when catastrophic infighting among the royal family
2:09:27 and conflict with a rival family clan known
2:09:29 as the Rashidis led to the state's ultimate collapse.
2:09:32 The surviving Saud family members were forced to flee from Riyadh as exiles
2:09:36 into nearby Kuwait where they were powerless
2:09:38 without any lands and without any wealth.
2:09:40 But with a very good historical claim to the supposedly
2:09:43 worthless lands of Najd in the interior of Arabia.
2:09:46 There and then the Saud family probably would have vanished
2:09:49 into irrelevance never to be seen or heard from again
2:09:52 were it not for the ambitions of a young
2:09:54 man of the family ultimately become known as Ibn Saud,
2:09:57 the man who would create the modern-day kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
2:10:01 Determined to restore his family's position of power,
2:10:04 a 27-year-old Ibn Saud in 1902 led a party of a couple dozen loyal men
2:10:08 from Kuwait to recapture his family's ancestral
2:10:11 seat in Riyadh from the rival Rashidi clan.
2:10:13 It was the beginning of a decades-long campaign
2:10:16 of conquest waged across Arabia for the young man.
2:10:19 But at first very few people from the outside world paid any attention to it.
2:10:23 The lands that now constitute Saudi Arabia back
2:10:25 then in the early 20th century may have only been home to as few as 2 million
2:10:29 people who were almost entirely very poor desert-roaming nomads.
2:10:33 And so the squabbling between two rival clans in these lands
2:10:36 was hardly noticed by any of the great powers of the day.
2:10:39 But things began shifting during World War I.
2:10:42 The Rashidi clan was allied to the Ottoman Empire and after the war broke out
2:10:46 the British began supplying weapons and cash
2:10:47 to Ibn Saud who was fighting against them.
2:10:50 That combined with Ibn Saud's own alliance to the ultra Sunni Wahhabi
2:10:54 clan provided tens of thousands of fanatical
2:10:57 and now well-armed troops proved decisive.
2:11:00 By the early 1920s the Najd region of Arabia had been entirely conquered.
2:11:04 But the campaigns weren't quite finished yet.
2:11:06 After World War I's conclusion and the collapse
2:11:08 of the Ottoman Empire in the Middle East,
2:11:10 the British appointed the Arab Hashemite family
2:11:12 as the new reigning monarchs in three newly created kingdoms:
2:11:16 Iraq, Jordan, and the Hejaz which crucially included
2:11:19 the two holiest cities in Islam, Mecca and Medina.
2:11:23 But relations between the British and the Hashemite
2:11:25 family quickly soured after the war's conclusion.
2:11:28 After the British transformed Jordan and Iraq into colonial
2:11:30 mandates and began letting Jews settle in Palestine.
2:11:33 The Hashemites ruling the kingdom of Hejaz
2:11:35 refused to ratify the 1919 Treaty of Versailles.
2:11:37 And so the British withdrew their support for the family
2:11:39 and backed up their other Arab wartime ally,
2:11:42 Ibn Saud and his expanding kingdom in the Najd.
2:11:45 Emboldened, Ibn Saud launched a new military campaign by invading the kingdom
2:11:49 of Hejaz in 1924 which was fully conquered within only a single year.
2:11:54 By 1925 the modern territory of Saudi Arabia
2:11:57 was fully under the control of Ibn Saud after
2:11:59 more than 20 years worth of nearly constant
2:12:01 warfare including the holy cities of Mecca and Medina.
2:12:04 A few years later on in 1932 Ibn Saud proclaimed the creation of a brand
2:12:09 new kingdom over all of these lands
2:12:11 and he named it after himself and his family,
2:12:14 the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia with himself
2:12:17 naturally as the new kingdom's absolute monarch.
2:12:20 The third Saudi state had been born covering a large amount of the lands
2:12:23 that the previous two Saudi states
2:12:25 from the 19th and 18th centuries had also encompassed.
2:12:28 The very basis of Ibn Saud's argument
2:12:31 and later the Saudi state's argument right up into the 2020s today that he was
2:12:35 merely restoring his own family's historical territorial claims.
2:12:39 But his new kingdom entered into a life in 1932 as a severely troubled one.
2:12:44 The kingdom had been created through decades worth of violent
2:12:47 warfare and conquest and many of the lands Ibn Saud
2:12:50 now controlled were forcefully conquered and included many people who
2:12:54 found his alliance with the extremely orthodox Wahhabists as off-putting.
2:12:58 Shia Muslim minority populations were found
2:13:00 in the eastern province near the Red Sea and in the south near Yemen who often
2:13:04 felt religiously persecuted by the Sunni fundamentalist Wahhabi-aligned regime.
2:13:09 And even less strict fellow Sunni Muslims
2:13:11 in the now conquered kingdom of Hejaz felt on edge.
2:13:15 Moreover, the exiled and furious Hashemite family continued to rule kingdoms
2:13:19 in neighboring Jordan and Iraq with very good claims to the Hejaz region.
2:13:23 Internal instability within the new kingdom was
2:13:26 rife and to try and preserve the peace
2:13:28 Ibn Saud married a daughter of every one of the other tribes he had conquered,
2:13:32 20 wives in all who would go on to produce
2:13:34 more than a hundred children for him including 45 sons,
2:13:38 six of whom would go on to later rule the kingdom after his death including
2:13:42 the current 87-year-old king today in 2023 who was born when Ibn Saud was 60.
2:13:48 And after decades of warfare the new kingdom's finances were in a pretty
2:13:52 terrible state with nothing but a tiny
2:13:54 tax base of 2 million impoverished people.
2:13:57 The only actually important thing that Ibn Saud's new
2:14:00 kingdom controlled to earn money from was its control over
2:14:03 the holy cities of Mecca and Medina which only brought
2:14:06 in modest amounts of religious tourism to the state's struggling coffers.
2:14:10 At this point in time it was far more likely that either Egypt
2:14:14 or Iraq with their plentiful agricultural farmland
2:14:17 around the Nile and Tigris-Euphrates rivers would
2:14:20 emerge as the dominant source of the Arab world's geopolitical power in the 20th
2:14:24 century just as they had both been
2:14:26 for literally all of human history beforehand.
2:14:29 But of course the discovery of oil suddenly changed everything.
2:14:33 You see oil had been discovered previously
2:14:35 in commercial quantities in nearby Iran, Iraq, and Bahrain.
2:14:39 And Ibn Saud had convinced himself that there was still
2:14:41 oil to be discovered within his kingdom nearby as well.
2:14:45 But it was the British who had discovered oil in Iran, Iraq, and Bahrain.
2:14:49 And Ibn Saud didn't exactly trust
2:14:51 the imperialist and colonial tendencies of them.
2:14:54 So instead Ibn Saud went to the Americans
2:14:57 to get them searching for oil in his kingdom.
2:15:00 In 1933, the year after his kingdom was proclaimed,
2:15:03 Standard Oil Company of California or Socal,
2:15:06 later known as Chevron, was granted the exclusive contract to begin the search.
2:15:10 It was only five years later in 1938 when they made the first discovery of oil
2:15:14 in Saudi Arabia at a well known
2:15:16 as Dammam number seven right by the Persian Gulf.
2:15:19 Initially Socal created a wholly-owned subsidiary
2:15:22 assigned to the oil they discovered
2:15:24 in Saudi Arabia that would eventually be named Arabian Oil Company, aka Aramco.
2:15:29 After Saudi Arabia managed to take full control over the subsidiary
2:15:32 company itself later on it became simply known as Saudi Aramco,
2:15:37 the modern state-owned Saudi oil giant.
2:15:40 From 1938 onwards more and more oil fields were steadily discovered across Saudi
2:15:44 Arabia's sparsely populated eastern province and production
2:15:48 steadily increased up to the point where
2:15:50 the country was the 22nd largest producer of oil in the world significant
2:15:54 enough to begin attracting the attention
2:15:56 of the American government during World War II.
2:15:58 Oil was becoming more important than ever before during that war
2:16:02 and the American president of the time
2:16:04 Franklin Delano Roosevelt knew that America
2:16:06 and the post-war Washington-led alliance structure needed as much oil as they
2:16:10 could possibly get to compete with the Soviet bloc in the war's aftermath.
2:16:14 Ibn Saud was a man who still had
2:16:16 many enemies with the British-backed Hashemites still in power
2:16:19 in Iraq and Jordan and many Saudis within the country
2:16:22 who didn't like his and the Wahhabists' absolute rule.
2:16:25 And so it eventually became time for him and FDR to finally meet.
2:16:29 They did so upon a ship in the Suez Canal
2:16:31 in February of 1945 mere weeks before FDR's own death.
2:16:35 And their agreement became the basis for the Saudi-American
2:16:38 relationship that has largely endured ever since.
2:16:41 The United States, despite being a secular constitutional republic,
2:16:45 would back the ultra Islamic absolute monarchy of Saudi
2:16:49 Arabia because both had something the other desperately wanted.
2:16:53 America wanted access to the increasingly important Saudi oil fields
2:16:57 both for itself and for its allies all around the world.
2:17:00 While the Saudis wanted America's security because as a sparsely populated
2:17:05 country with nothing of value whatsoever besides for oil they knew
2:17:09 they could never hope to defend themselves or their oil
2:17:12 on their own either against their own people or their external rivals.
2:17:16 But who would ever dare to attack them if they
2:17:19 had the backing of the most powerful country in the world?
2:17:22 Over time this basic arrangement between America and Saudi Arabia,
2:17:26 security guarantees in exchange for oil,
2:17:28 has continually evolved but remained more or less the same ever since.
2:17:33 Ibn Saud died in 1953 and his sons
2:17:35 have ruled the kingdom as absolute monarchs ever since.
2:17:38 Eventually more oil fields were discovered around the initial
2:17:41 Dammam number seven well like Safaniya in the Gulf,
2:17:44 the largest offshore oil field ever discovered in the world,
2:17:47 and the mighty Ghawar field,
2:17:49 the largest onshore oil field ever discovered and the largest single source
2:17:53 of human energy that we as a species have ever so far discovered.
2:17:58 It turned out that the lands Ibn Saud had
2:18:01 conquered for his kingdom were not so worthless or useless
2:18:04 after all because they contained within them the most valuable
2:18:08 oil fields that have ever been discovered on the planet.
2:18:12 Money began flooding into the kingdom
2:18:14 as the oil fields continued to be developed.
2:18:16 But the true era of wealth only came after the 1973 oil crisis.
2:18:21 After Israel defeated the combined Arab armies
2:18:24 of Egypt and Syria during the Yom Kippur War,
2:18:26 the OPEC oil cartel made up of major oil producing countries from all around
2:18:30 the world decided to embargo many of Israel's
2:18:33 most major supporters including the United States.
2:18:36 Saudi Arabia briefly participated in that embargo and the global price
2:18:40 of oil subsequently quadrupled and remained
2:18:43 high for more than a decade afterwards.
2:18:45 The flood of money into Saudi Arabia suddenly became a deluge of money over
2:18:50 the following decade and the kingdom became
2:18:52 one of the wealthiest countries in the world.
2:18:55 And the House of Saud became one of the wealthiest families in the world.
2:18:59 It was with this unbelievable money that Saudi Arabia
2:19:02 made its great bargain with the people of the kingdom.
2:19:05 The centuries-old alliance between the House of Saud
2:19:07 and the clan of Wahhab remained intact.
2:19:10 Meaning that the Saudi state was governed by a set of extremely
2:19:13 fundamentalist Sunni Muslim values that a lot of the state's minority groups,
2:19:18 like the Shia and less fundamentalist Sunnis,
2:19:20 didn't exactly get along with very well.
2:19:23 Which in a vacuum would have led to domestic instability.
2:19:26 But the enormous revenues that the state was earning from its oil business
2:19:30 enabled the government to basically just
2:19:32 bribe all of its citizens into complicity.
2:19:34 And so Saudi Arabia essentially became a massive
2:19:38 welfare state for all of its citizens.
2:19:40 Zero taxes were levied on anything or anyone because
2:19:43 oil was paying for all of the government's budget.
2:19:46 A flood of money went into subsidizing
2:19:48 everything for Saudi Arabia's citizens from health care,
2:19:51 education, food, water, fuel, electricity,
2:19:54 and whatever else you could possibly think of.
2:19:56 Nearly all of the citizens' needs
2:19:58 were completely being covered by the government.
2:20:00 And in exchange, it was expected that all of the citizens would accept
2:20:04 some of the strictest and most
2:20:05 totalitarian religious laws anywhere in the world.
2:20:09 And more importantly, accept the House of Saud's absolute legitimacy to rule
2:20:14 a medieval kingdom in a 20th century world.
2:20:17 As the 20th century continued progressing,
2:20:19 oil production in the United States diminished while
2:20:21 production in Saudi Arabia only increased to the point
2:20:25 where the kingdom even overtook America to become
2:20:27 the world's largest oil producer for decades.
2:20:30 America became increasingly committed to protecting the kingdom's
2:20:33 strategically important oil supply and by 1991,
2:20:36 as production in the United States continued to flounder,
2:20:39 America found itself importing nearly a third of all
2:20:42 of its imports from the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
2:20:45 America needed to protect Saudi Arabia at all costs.
2:20:49 But justifying doing so in Washington was growing increasingly
2:20:52 difficult because Saudi Arabia was growing even more totalitarian.
2:20:57 As more and more Westerners came to the country
2:20:59 for work in developing the numerous oil fields,
2:21:01 the country's ultra-orthodox Wahhabi establishment grew
2:21:04 increasingly agitated at their growing presence.
2:21:07 By 1979, it had just gotten to be too much for some.
2:21:10 And a group of hundreds of armed religious militants stormed
2:21:13 the Grand Mosque in Mecca and seized control over it.
2:21:17 Denouncing the Saudi king as a blasphemer
2:21:19 for increasingly Westernizing the country.
2:21:22 The Grand Mosque, one of the holiest sites in all of Islam,
2:21:25 thus became the site of a military siege that lasted for weeks
2:21:29 as Saudi security forces battled with the militants inside to regain control.
2:21:34 It marked the very first major direct challenge to the House of Saud's
2:21:38 legitimacy to rule over the kingdom since its establishment back in 1932.
2:21:43 And the Saudi monarchy chose to respond to the challenge by further embracing
2:21:47 the Sunni Wahhabi religious leaders and increasing
2:21:51 the severity of religious laws in the country.
2:21:53 All of the previous social reforms that were
2:21:55 taking place in the country were reversed.
2:21:57 Movie theaters were universally banned.
2:21:59 Women were completely removed from all of the media and newspapers altogether.
2:22:03 Women's dress codes were much more strictly enforced in public.
2:22:06 Homosexual activity was much more punished by the death penalty.
2:22:09 And the Saudi state-sanctioned religious police increased their patrols
2:22:13 on the streets to rigorously enforce the newly strengthened religious laws.
2:22:17 For the next 40-odd years, Saudi Arabia would be among the most
2:22:20 theocratic and totalitarian regimes anywhere on the planet.
2:22:24 As the ruling Saudi royal family
2:22:26 used strict Islamic religious laws to strengthen
2:22:29 their own legitimacy in the eyes of the ultra-conservatives of the country.
2:22:33 But the trend towards religious fundamentalism at home would eventually
2:22:37 go on to produce even more problems for the kingdom
2:22:39 in the future and even jeopardize its relationship with its
2:22:43 own greatest protector and security guarantor, the United States.
2:22:47 It was no coincidence that Osama bin Laden and Al-Qaeda
2:22:50 were initially both produced within
2:22:52 the ultra-religious environment of Saudi Arabia.
2:22:55 In 1990, when Saddam's Iraq appeared likely to invade Saudi Arabia,
2:22:59 bin Laden offered the Saudi king his own mujaheddin fighters who
2:23:02 were battle-hardened during the Afghan war against the Soviets to resist.
2:23:06 But the king refused and instead decided to allow the Americans to send
2:23:10 hundreds of thousands of their troops
2:23:12 to defend the kingdom against the invasion instead.
2:23:15 The presence of hundreds of thousands of Americans
2:23:18 within the kingdom granted by the king,
2:23:20 who is supposed to be the protector of the two Islamic holy cities,
2:23:23 infuriated bin Laden and Al-Qaeda.
2:23:26 And the outrage was never forgiven.
2:23:28 In 1995, bin Laden declared that the king of Saudi Arabia was a heretic.
2:23:32 And a war between the kingdom and Al-Qaeda has raged on ever since.
2:23:37 With Al-Qaeda continually seeking ways to overthrow the monarchy and replace it
2:23:41 with what it sees as its own
2:23:42 vision of restored fundamentalist Sunni theocratic rule.
2:23:46 But the fact that Osama bin Laden himself was born in Saudi Arabia
2:23:50 and that many of Al-Qaeda's fighters as well turned out to be Saudi citizens,
2:23:54 including 15 out of the 19 hijackers
2:23:57 responsible for carrying out the 9/11 attacks,
2:23:59 has remained a sore spot for relations between
2:24:02 the kingdom and the United States ever since.
2:24:04 But in addition to the growing
2:24:06 Sunni Islamist threat within the kingdom represented
2:24:08 by the likes of Al-Qaeda who felt
2:24:10 that the Saudi royal family wasn't quite religious enough,
2:24:13 external threats to the Saudis' rule in the kingdom
2:24:16 were greatly growing in numbers as well.
2:24:19 The emergence of the revolutionary Shia Islamist regime
2:24:22 in neighboring Iran in 1979 presented the Saudi
2:24:25 kingdom with its most major external arch-enemy
2:24:28 that it has been locked in an on-again, off-again cold war with ever since.
2:24:32 The revolutionary regime in Iran had overthrown
2:24:35 their own absolute monarch after all and replaced
2:24:37 him with a totalitarian Islamic theocracy ruled
2:24:40 by the country's Shiite clergy and their supreme leader, the Ayatollah Khamenei.
2:24:45 And they were intent on exporting their revolution to every other monarchist
2:24:50 regime in the Islamic world and overthrowing all of their kings as well,
2:24:54 including Saudi Arabia's monarchy and the other Gulf Arab states.
2:24:58 But for a time, both revolutionary Iran and absolute monarchist Saudi Arabia
2:25:03 found some common ground in their mutual enemy in Iraq, Saddam Hussein.
2:25:07 Saddam had led Iraq into a brutal invasion of Iran in 1980.
2:25:10 And then in 1990, Saddam invaded and annexed Kuwait
2:25:13 and was preparing the Iraqi army to invade Saudi Arabia next.
2:25:17 The United States and a massive
2:25:19 coalition involving Saudi Arabian troops intervened
2:25:22 and kicked the Iraqi army out of Kuwait and liberated the country in 1991.
2:25:26 But Saddam still remained in power and remained as a potential
2:25:29 threat to both the Saudis and the Iranians for the next decade.
2:25:33 Relations between Tehran and Riyadh were therefore fairly cordial.
2:25:37 But that all suddenly ended in 2003 when
2:25:40 the United States invaded Iraq in the aftermath
2:25:42 of the September 11th attacks and overthrew
2:25:45 Saddam and replaced him with a democratic republic.
2:25:48 A move that Saudi Arabia fiercely disagreed with Washington over.
2:25:52 And part of why they disagreed with it so strongly was
2:25:55 because they knew that with Saddam now out of the way,
2:25:57 the Iranians would make moves into exporting their revolution into Iraq next.
2:26:02 Which is exactly what they began doing.
2:26:05 Iraq, with a majority of its population being
2:26:07 Shia Muslim Arabs and immediately adjacent to Iran,
2:26:10 was one of the most obvious first targets
2:26:12 for the Iranians to export their revolution into.
2:26:15 Quickly after Saddam was removed by the Americans,
2:26:17 Iranian troops began entering into the country
2:26:19 and building militia organizations out
2:26:21 of the country's large Shia Muslim population
2:26:23 and indoctrinating them with Iran's revolutionary anti-monarchist zeal.
2:26:28 Naturally, to try and prevent Iraq
2:26:30 from becoming essentially an Iranian-controlled puppet,
2:26:32 the Saudis began funding and supplying
2:26:34 Iraqi Sunni Muslim militias to counteract them.
2:26:37 And the first major proxy war between Tehran and Riyadh had begun.
2:26:41 Then in 2011, the United States mostly withdrew all of their troops from Iraq.
2:26:45 And that very same year,
2:26:46 the Arab Spring revolutions began sweeping all across the Arab world.
2:26:51 As restless and angry Arab populations unsatisfied with their long-time
2:26:55 regimes began taking to the streets for change.
2:26:58 Popular revolutions eventually managed to topple
2:27:01 the long-standing regimes in Tunisia, Libya, Egypt, and Yemen.
2:27:04 While enormous civil wars exploded in Libya, Yemen, and Syria.
2:27:08 Fearful about the wave of revolution penetrating into their own
2:27:11 long-standing kingdom and their own potentially restless population,
2:27:15 the Saudis began massively increasing their purchases of American-made weapons,
2:27:20 tanks, jets, and ships to keep themselves in power
2:27:22 in a series of deals worth tens of billions of dollars.
2:27:26 But the confrontation between revolutionary Iran and monarchist
2:27:30 Saudi Arabia quickly came to a boiling
2:27:33 point over the small island of Bahrain just off of the Saudi coast.
2:27:37 Approximately 60% of the island's total population are Shia Muslims.
2:27:41 But the ruling monarchy there are Sunni Muslims.
2:27:44 Revolutionary Shia Iran on the other side of the Gulf further claims
2:27:48 Bahrain as a lost Iranian province
2:27:50 based on their own historical territorial claims
2:27:52 to the island and has repeatedly pressed the issue and insisted that the Shia
2:27:56 majority on the island are being repressed by the minority Sunni monarchy.
2:28:00 Back in 1986, Saudi Arabia and Bahrain finished the construction of the 25
2:28:05 km King Fahd Causeway that connects the island to the Saudi mainland.
2:28:10 It was ostensibly built to further facilitate
2:28:12 trade and travel between the two countries.
2:28:14 But one cannot help to notice that it can also
2:28:17 be used as a bridge for Saudi tanks and soldiers
2:28:20 to come storming into the island across were the island's
2:28:23 monarchy ever in jeopardy of falling during a revolution.
2:28:27 Were Iran to successfully foment a revolution in the island that would do
2:28:30 that and install a revolutionary Shia government
2:28:32 similar to their own in its place, the very existence of the Saudi state
2:28:36 itself would be directly put into question.
2:28:39 The island is only located about 60 km
2:28:41 away from Saudi Arabia's largest single oil field,
2:28:43 Ghawar, only about 50 km away from the headquarters of Saudi Aramco,
2:28:47 the state-owned oil company, and only about 80 km away from Ras Tanura,
2:28:52 which is the Saudi's largest oil export terminal,
2:28:54 and indeed the largest one in the world.
2:28:56 Moreover, Bahrain is placed directly off the coast
2:28:59 of the Shia Muslim majority areas of Eastern Saudi Arabia,
2:29:02 where nearly the entirety of Saudi Arabia's
2:29:05 oil reserves and infrastructure are also located.
2:29:08 Meaning that were the Iranians to successfully export their revolution
2:29:11 into Shia majority Bahrain and topple the Sunni monarchy there,
2:29:15 the next target would be the next
2:29:17 door Shia majority areas of Eastern Saudi Arabia,
2:29:20 which could put the entire Saudi oil business into jeopardy,
2:29:23 which could put the entire Saudi monarchy and state into jeopardy.
2:29:26 And that could never be tolerated.
2:29:29 So, when uprisings began in Bahrain aimed at toppling the monarchy in 2011,
2:29:32 Saudi troops indeed came storming across the bridge to help put them down.
2:29:37 Saudi Arabia came to back the rebels
2:29:39 seeking to overthrow Bashar al-Assad's regime in Syria,
2:29:42 because if it worked and he was removed, it would be Iran who would lose
2:29:46 a core component of their overall grand strategy.
2:29:49 The Assad regime in Syria has been a core ally
2:29:51 of the Iranians for decades over their mutual opposition to Israel.
2:29:55 And together with an Iranian-dominated Iraq,
2:29:57 they form Iran's so-called land bridge across
2:30:00 the Middle East towards the Mediterranean Sea,
2:30:03 enabling Iranian militias and proxies to safely and reliably
2:30:06 transport weapons to Iranian-aligned organizations like Hezbollah in Lebanon,
2:30:11 and across the Mediterranean Sea to Hamas in the Gaza Strip.
2:30:15 Who all share Iran's desire to destroy the Israeli state from existence.
2:30:19 It also, from Saudi Arabia's perspective,
2:30:22 makes it appear that Iran is attempting
2:30:24 to encircle them and overthrow their kingdom.
2:30:26 Thus, to shatter Iran's land bridge
2:30:28 and break out of their potential encirclement,
2:30:30 the Saudis backed up rebel forces in Syria while Iran backed up the regime.
2:30:34 The proxy war quickly extended into Libya as well,
2:30:37 as the Saudis backed the Tobruk-based House of Representatives
2:30:39 government against the Iranian-supported
2:30:41 Tripoli-based Government of National Accord.
2:30:44 But the absolute terror in the royal halls of Riyadh over being
2:30:47 encircled by the revolutionary Iranians came to a fever pitch in 2014,
2:30:52 when the Shia-adjacent Houthi movement suddenly managed to conquer the Yemeni
2:30:56 capital and was advancing on the city of Aden next,
2:30:59 the most significant port anywhere between the Red Sea and the Arabian Sea.
2:31:04 Were the Houthis to completely capture the entirety of Yemen,
2:31:06 it would have placed a highly militant and probably
2:31:09 revolutionary Shiite Muslim power closely aligned with the Iranians
2:31:13 across not only more than 1,300 km of their own
2:31:18 Shia Muslim subjects in the south of the country,
2:31:20 but also directly on the strategic maritime choke
2:31:23 point of the Bab al-Mandab Strait as well.
2:31:26 Were that to happen,
2:31:27 Saudi Arabia truly would be effectively encircled and checkmated,
2:31:31 surrounded by a hostile Iran who wants nothing more than to topple its monarchy.
2:31:36 And Iran's allies placed into power in Iraq, Syria,
2:31:39 and Lebanon, and potentially in Bahrain and in Yemen as well.
2:31:42 Iran could hypothetically mine or blockade the Strait of Hormuz regulating
2:31:46 all the maritime traffic between the Persian Gulf and the Indian Ocean,
2:31:49 while the Houthis could simultaneously use Iranian-supplied missiles
2:31:52 and weapons to blockade the Bab al-Mandab Strait as well.
2:31:55 Such a scenario would be an utter doomsday one for the Saudis,
2:31:58 because they would lose the easiest ability to export all
2:32:01 of their oil to their largest customers in East Asia.
2:32:04 The only way remaining for them to continue exporting oil at all
2:32:08 under that scenario would be via the Suez Canal through Egypt.
2:32:11 But even that too nearly came under risk.
2:32:14 After the revolution in Egypt toppled
2:32:16 the long-time dictator of that country in 2011,
2:32:19 the Muslim Brotherhood's candidate came to power in a democratic election next.
2:32:23 The Muslim Brotherhood is a Sunni Islamist organization that, like Iran,
2:32:28 is also staunchly opposed to the concept of monarchies in the Islamic world,
2:32:32 including the Saudi monarchy.
2:32:34 So, obviously, the Saudis despise them.
2:32:36 Were a Brotherhood government in Egypt to hypothetically
2:32:39 deny the Saudis access to the Suez Canal
2:32:41 in conjunction with the Houthis and Iranians shutting
2:32:44 down their access through al-Mandab and Hormuz Straits,
2:32:47 and nobody like the Americans did anything to stop it,
2:32:50 Saudi Arabia would just completely collapse very rapidly,
2:32:53 because they would lose any ability to actually
2:32:55 export any of their oil out of the country,
2:32:57 and 87% of their government's budget would just evaporate,
2:33:01 meaning their ability to bribe all
2:33:02 of their divided and repressed citizenry would end,
2:33:05 and their ability to buy massive amounts of weapons would end,
2:33:08 and their monarchy would just collapse into dust.
2:33:11 And thus, the Saudi-sponsored military coup in Egypt that luckily
2:33:16 for them panned out and overthrew the Muslim Brotherhood from power,
2:33:19 replaced it with a much more friendly military government.
2:33:22 But coups and plots were not work to dislodge the Houthis from power in Yemen.
2:33:26 Instead, the Saudis initiated a massive military intervention of their own
2:33:30 into the country with enormous bombing and missile attacks
2:33:33 and a devastating naval blockade to choke the Houthis into submission
2:33:37 and remove what they perceived
2:33:38 as Iran's revolutionary influence from the country.
2:33:41 Yemen thus became the focal point
2:33:43 for the Iranian-Saudi rivalry from 2015 onwards.
2:33:46 And the Saudis agreed to buy up tens of billions of dollars
2:33:49 more worth of additional American weaponry to wage that war with.
2:33:53 Weapons that would help contribute to what the United Nations
2:33:55 has described as one of the 21st century's greatest humanitarian catastrophes.
2:34:00 The Saudi Arabian defense budget exponentially
2:34:02 exploded to fight the war in Yemen,
2:34:05 and to fight all of these other proxy conflicts in Iraq and Syria and in Libya,
2:34:09 because the Saudi royal family saw external enemies circling all around them,
2:34:13 all being led and coordinated by the revolutionary Iranians.
2:34:17 And they decided to respond in the only way they knew how to do,
2:34:21 throw tens of billions of dollars at the problem they
2:34:24 earned from selling their oil and hope it all went away.
2:34:27 Saudi defense spending grew so high in the mid to late
2:34:30 2010s that it became roughly on a par with Russia,
2:34:33 and was only outmatched by the superpowers of China and the United States.
2:34:38 In 2015, Saudi Arabia was spending $2,748
2:34:42 per person in the country on its military,
2:34:45 while the United States was only spending $1,975 per person on theirs.
2:34:51 But throwing money at trying to overpower their enemies wasn't really working.
2:34:55 The Iranians only spent a few tens
2:34:57 of millions of their dollars arming the Houthis
2:34:59 in comparison to the tens of billions
2:35:01 that the Saudis were spending attempting to crush them.
2:35:03 And the war gradually transformed into a quagmire with the Houthis
2:35:07 no closer to being removed than when the war began.
2:35:10 And after nearly 400,000 deaths in the country caused by the conflict,
2:35:15 Bashar al-Assad has remained in power in Syria for over
2:35:17 a decade despite the Saudis' best efforts to remove him,
2:35:20 while Iraq increasingly falls under Iran's influence as well.
2:35:24 And then, in September of 2019,
2:35:26 a series of drone and cruise missile attacks bombarded Saudi
2:35:30 Arabia's oil refineries at Abqaiq and Khurais in the Eastern Province,
2:35:34 destroying the kingdom's largest oil processing and refinery facilities.
2:35:38 5.7 million barrels per day worth of Saudi oil
2:35:42 production were knocked offline in the kingdom by the attack,
2:35:46 representing what was nothing less than the biggest disruption ever
2:35:49 seen in the entire oil industry up to that point.
2:35:52 The Houthis down in Yemen quickly claimed responsibility
2:35:55 for the attack as a reprisal for the Saudi air campaign,
2:35:58 but they were more than 1,200 km away from the attack's location.
2:36:02 American intelligence later determined that the attacks probably
2:36:06 actually originated to the north and were probably fired
2:36:09 by the Iranians themselves either from within Iran itself
2:36:12 or from within their Shiite militia-controlled areas in Iraq.
2:36:15 It could have been interpreted as an act of war by the kingdom,
2:36:18 but the United States made it clear that they didn't see things that way
2:36:22 and would not militarily back the kingdom if
2:36:24 that's the route they chose to go down.
2:36:26 America wasn't prepared to go to war with Iran over the issue,
2:36:29 and with their military already struggling in Yemen,
2:36:31 the Saudis were left with no other choice but to back down and de-escalate.
2:36:36 The oil processing facilities were quickly
2:36:38 repaired and business went on as usual.
2:36:40 But the Saudis never forgot that America had just refused to defend them.
2:36:45 The days back when America was willing
2:36:47 to deploy hundreds of thousands of troops to protect
2:36:50 the kingdom and its oil back in 1991 during
2:36:52 the Gulf War appeared in Riyadh to be over.
2:36:55 The development of shale oil in the United States in the early
2:36:57 2010s had resulted in a massive increase in America's own oil production,
2:37:02 and by 2018, the year just before the Abqaiq attack,
2:37:05 America had finally surpassed Saudi Arabia and regained
2:37:08 its title as the world's largest producer.
2:37:11 America was relying less and less on Saudi oil for themselves, and by 2019,
2:37:16 only about 7% of America's oil imports were still even coming from the kingdom,
2:37:21 coming to how nearly a third of their oil imports
2:37:24 were from Saudi Arabia back in 1991 during the Gulf War.
2:37:28 As Washington began relying less on the Saudis themselves for their oil,
2:37:31 America's distaste for Saudi Arabia's totalitarian regime
2:37:35 and human rights practices became more pronounced as well.
2:37:38 An absolute monarchy in the 21st
2:37:40 century with extremely authoritarian religious laws waging
2:37:43 a brutal war in Yemen with hundreds of thousands of deaths on its hand,
2:37:47 all fueled by American weapons no less,
2:37:49 and responsible for carrying out assassinations
2:37:51 on journalists would not be a usual
2:37:54 ally of the United States were it not also for all of its oil.
2:37:58 And all of that oil was becoming less important to Washington.
2:38:02 Moreover, the world at large is beginning to move more and more away from oil
2:38:05 as an energy source as nations around the world
2:38:07 try and fight back against global climate change.
2:38:10 The countries of the European Union, many of whom are currently and historically
2:38:13 some of Saudi Arabia's largest oil customers,
2:38:16 are planning on completely phasing out their own fossil fuel usage by 2050.
2:38:20 And if they're successful, none of them will be customers of the Saudis
2:38:23 any longer within only 27 years from now.
2:38:26 Japan also plans to eliminate oil and gas as energy
2:38:29 sources at some point in the future this same century,
2:38:31 though without the same strict 2050 timetable as the Europeans.
2:38:35 One of the biggest reasons why the Americans
2:38:37 still sort of support Saudi Arabia today,
2:38:39 even though they import hardly any of their oil themselves is because
2:38:42 the Saudis still supply enormous amounts
2:38:45 of oil to many of America's closest allies,
2:38:47 like the NATO states in Europe and the Japanese.
2:38:50 But when this too ends,
2:38:52 America will have almost no reason left to continue protecting the kingdom,
2:38:55 and the deal established between FDR and Ibn Saud
2:38:58 nearly 80 years ago will finally come to an end.
2:39:01 And without a major protector, and with less and less customers to continue
2:39:04 selling their oil to, Saudi Arabia will have less
2:39:07 money to buy weapons to defend themselves
2:39:09 with and less money to subsidize their restless population with.
2:39:12 And their many, many enemies, both within the kingdom and outside of it,
2:39:16 will be emboldened like they have never been before
2:39:19 to finally take their chance at overthrowing the monarchy.
2:39:22 Thus, in order to avoid this dangerous
2:39:24 spiral toward destruction over the coming decades,
2:39:27 Saudi Arabia needs to radically transform its entire
2:39:30 society and economy if it is going to survive.
2:39:33 And this is why the current Crown Prince and soon-to-be king of the country,
2:39:37 Mohammed bin Salman,
2:39:38 or MBS, announced with much fanfare the Vision 2030 plan back in 2016,
2:39:44 which aims to do exactly that.
2:39:47 Sweeping reforms across the country have already
2:39:49 taken place as a part of Vision 2030, and more is still to come.
2:39:53 Women were finally granted the ability to drive in the country in 2018,
2:39:57 while their dress codes in public were slightly relaxed with the aim
2:40:00 of encouraging and enabling more women to enter into the Saudi workforce.
2:40:04 A push towards encouraging both religious and non-religious tourism
2:40:07 to the kingdom has been sent into overdrive with massive
2:40:10 new building developments being put into motion around the holy
2:40:12 city of Mecca in order to further encourage religious tourism,
2:40:16 and grand mega projects like the $500 billion futuristic city of Neom,
2:40:21 the Jeddah Tower in the city of Jeddah planned
2:40:23 to be the new tallest building in the world,
2:40:25 and the Red Sea Islands mega project in the Red Sea,
2:40:27 all set to attract a new set of non-religious tourists to the kingdom.
2:40:31 Saudi Arabia even managed to secure its own
2:40:33 Grand Prix on the Formula 1 calendar in 2021,
2:40:37 and even announced a brand new airline in 2023 called which include the purchase
2:40:42 of 72 brand new Boeing 787 Dreamliners at a price of $37 billion.
2:40:47 All combined, Saudi Arabia hopes to establish tourism from all around the world
2:40:52 to the kingdom in order to add diversification in the economy away from oil,
2:40:56 while investing hundreds of billions to trillions
2:40:58 of dollars at the same time into a brand
2:41:00 new sovereign wealth fund to invest in companies
2:41:03 all around the world to add even more diversification.
2:41:07 And to diversify away from their own usage of oil as a fuel source,
2:41:10 the government to invest aggressively in a solar energy,
2:41:13 which in the deserts of Saudi Arabia does have a lot of very high potential.
2:41:17 But Vision 2030 contains within it two critical problems for the kingdom.
2:41:21 First, while this process is ongoing and tons of tourists
2:41:24 from the western world begin coming to the country,
2:41:26 while religious laws in the country are relaxed or destroyed
2:41:29 altogether to continue encouraging them to come and visit,
2:41:32 it is certain to generate a high degree
2:41:34 of instability among Saudi Arabia's traditional Sunni Wahhabi fundamentalists.
2:41:39 Osama bin Laden and al-Qaeda previously went to war with the Saudi monarchy
2:41:43 over their allowance of US troops into the country to protect the kingdom.
2:41:47 So, what do you think will happen if and when
2:41:49 millions of western tourists are being allowed to enter the country?
2:41:52 Thus, Saudi Arabia needs as little external conflicts as possible while
2:41:57 it is focusing on dealing with this internal conflict for years.
2:42:01 Saudi Arabia thus wants to get out of its failed war in Yemen,
2:42:04 and in March of 2023, they even signed a historic agreement with Iran,
2:42:09 restoring relations with them and establishing a truce.
2:42:12 Riyadh couldn't possibly be foolish enough
2:42:14 to believe that the truce will last forever
2:42:16 as the revolutionary regime in Iran will
2:42:18 always remain militantly committed to overthrowing their monarchy.
2:42:22 The Saudis know that the truce with Iran is a temporary one,
2:42:25 but Iran also wanted to take it so they could spend
2:42:27 the next few years focusing their efforts on Israel and the United States,
2:42:31 while the Saudis wanted it to spend crucial
2:42:33 time focusing inwards in implementing these vital reforms.
2:42:37 From Riyadh's perspective,
2:42:39 the hope is that they will finish reforming their society
2:42:41 and emerge stronger before Iran decides to resume hostilities with them again.
2:42:47 But in order to further guarantee that Iran
2:42:49 and his proxies will stay off of their back,
2:42:51 the Saudis also need to entice the United States
2:42:53 to stick around as their protector for as long as possible.
2:42:57 They know that America is naturally losing interest in doing
2:43:00 that, but the Saudis still have levers that they can pull.
2:43:03 They have even suggested that they might be willing to recognize
2:43:06 Israel [music] and normalize relations with the Jewish state in exchange
2:43:10 for an ironclad US security guarantee of the kingdom and the elevation
2:43:14 of Saudi Arabia to the status of a major non-NATO ally,
2:43:17 as well as gaining access to a civilian nuclear energy program,
2:43:21 which could, in a pinch, enable them to develop a nuclear weapon
2:43:25 on their own if the Iranians suddenly develop one first.
2:43:29 Washington seems unprepared to accept those demands
2:43:31 for now over fears of being bound
2:43:33 by treaty to go to war with Iran if the kingdom comes under attack again,
2:43:37 and over fears of nuclear proliferation spreading across the Middle East.
2:43:41 But the Saudis could potentially always sweeten the deal
2:43:43 ahead of the November 2024 election by also agreeing
2:43:46 to turn more of their spare capacity wells back
2:43:48 online and flooding the oil market with their fresh supply,
2:43:52 decreasing global oil prices and inflationary pressures in America,
2:43:56 which is part of the reason why they've been cutting production for months.
2:43:59 They want that firm security guarantee bound in treaty from the United States.
2:44:04 And recognizing Israel will lead to even more tensions with the Sunni
2:44:08 Wahhabi fundamentalists within the country
2:44:10 and with revolutionary Iran outside of the country,
2:44:13 who is uncompromising on their aim
2:44:15 of destroying Israel and overthrowing the Saudi monarchy.
2:44:19 And the second problem related to Vision 2030 is that while
2:44:22 it is generating all of this religious instability within the kingdom,
2:44:25 it is also going to cost an absolute fortune.
2:44:28 Current estimates believe that the Saudis are going to end up spending
2:44:31 more than $3 trillion on this plan to reform and diversify the kingdom.
2:44:36 And in order to fund that enormous amount of money,
2:44:39 Saudi Arabia is gradually selling small amounts of shares
2:44:42 in the state-owned Saudi Aramco oil company to foreign investors,
2:44:45 while the Saudis simultaneously need higher global
2:44:48 oil prices for several more years to come in order to add even more money
2:44:53 into the state's coffers before it's all too late,
2:44:56 which is the other reason why they've been coordinating with the Russians
2:44:59 to decrease production together in order to keep oil prices elevated for longer.
2:45:03 It's not that Saudi Arabia and Russia are really aligned in any real sense,
2:45:08 it's just that their interests in having
2:45:09 higher worldwide oil prices are currently aligned.
2:45:13 So, that Moscow has more money to fight their war in Ukraine,
2:45:15 and Riyadh has more money to fund their crucially important reforms.
2:45:20 But doing so is also upsetting the United States to a pretty large degree,
2:45:24 who obviously prefers lower global oil prices both to deprive the Russians
2:45:28 of more money and to lower gasoline prices and inflation back at home.
2:45:32 The Saudis are currently playing a very,
2:45:33 very delicate balancing game as they must simultaneously
2:45:37 weigh their own self-interest to reform or die,
2:45:40 which will cost a lot of money and require high oil prices,
2:45:43 their relationship with the United States
2:45:45 as their biggest security guarantor and provider of arms,
2:45:48 who prefers lower oil prices,
2:45:50 their relationship with Russia as the second largest oil exporter in the world,
2:45:54 who can most help them manipulate oil prices to be higher,
2:45:57 but who is stuck in a proxy war with the United States in Ukraine,
2:46:00 and their relationship with China,
2:46:03 who is the Saudi's single largest oil customer,
2:46:05 but who is also locked in a sort of cold
2:46:07 war with the United States in the Pacific over Taiwan.
2:46:10 It is a balancing act between all
2:46:12 of these various interests that the Saudi royal family,
2:46:14 led by MBS, must carefully tread between for decades.
2:46:18 And if they ever stumble along the way during any part of it,
2:46:21 they will all immediately die and lose everything.
2:46:24 And at the same time, this careful balancing act must all be maintained as Iran
2:46:29 carefully eyes them with their gains in Iraq, Syria, Lebanon,
2:46:33 and Yemen, and as the 15,000 other members of MBS's own royal family
2:46:37 jockey and position themselves at court
2:46:39 in Riyadh for their own positions of power.
2:46:42 And as the religious fundamentalists within Saudi
2:46:44 Arabia increasingly feel that the House of Saud
2:46:47 at large is at last fully betraying them after the and the Wahhabists is ended.
2:46:55 Internal [music] strife within the kingdom is a certainty,
2:46:58 and the Saudi regime is already responding to it by cracking down on emerging
2:47:01 Islamist opposition within the kingdom whenever it
2:47:03 can and outside the kingdom whenever it can.
2:47:07 It's all a part of the very complex relationship between the Saudi kingdom
2:47:10 and radical Sunni Islamist organizations with roots
2:47:13 in the kingdom like al-Qaeda and even ISIS.
2:47:15 For decades, al-Qaeda sought to overthrow the Saudi monarchy,
2:47:18 and its strategy to do so has been to sow as much chaos
2:47:22 in the kingdom as possible by attacking
2:47:23 foreigners and discouraging any tourism to the country,
2:47:26 and attacking skilled workers in the oil
2:47:28 and gas industry and discouraging them from coming,
2:47:31 thus eventually leading to the kingdom's collapse by the erosion
2:47:33 of both its oil and its tourism industries.
2:47:36 The Saudi state has thus fought back against al-Qaeda ever since the 1990s.
2:47:41 But a new and perhaps even more menacing
2:47:43 internal and external threat suddenly appeared on the scene
2:47:46 in 2014 when ISIS exploded across the territory
2:47:49 of Iraq and Syria in a lightning series of conquests.
2:47:53 ISIS, too, just like al-Qaeda before it,
2:47:55 vowed that it would one day overthrow the Saudi Arabian
2:47:59 monarchy after it completed its conquest of Iraq and Syria first.
2:48:03 And the Saudi monarchy wasn't put any more
2:48:05 at ease after it turned out that thousands of ISIS's fighters had in fact come
2:48:10 from within the kingdom and were Saudi citizens.
2:48:12 Thus, in order to destroy the threat,
2:48:15 Saudi Arabia sent military officers to Syria
2:48:17 to help train and equip resistance fighters fighting against
2:48:20 ISIS and join the American-led military coalition
2:48:22 to destroy ISIS altogether by the end of 2014,
2:48:26 a coalition that would eventually encompass dozens of countries
2:48:29 from all around the world in the largest
2:48:31 military alliance seen in history since the alliance
2:48:34 to destroy Nazi Germany 70 years beforehand.
2:48:40 When you gaze out across a map of the world,
2:48:42 there are few other countries you'll see on it that appear
2:48:44 to be more twin-like than the duo of Yemen and Oman.
2:48:47 Both countries roughly evenly divide the southern
2:48:49 tip of the Arabian Peninsula between them.
2:48:51 They each have a very similar-looking shape,
2:48:52 and they're even a very similar sizes,
2:48:54 with Yemen being only slightly larger at around the same size as France,
2:48:57 while Oman is around the same size as Italy.
2:48:59 Neither of them have any permanent rivers flowing in their territory,
2:49:01 with both of them being restricted only
2:49:03 to seasonal streams known in Arabic as wadis.
2:49:05 And yet, despite having no permanent rivers,
2:49:08 they also both occupy the two rainiest locations that can
2:49:10 be found on the Arabian Peninsula in their upper highland regions.
2:49:13 Although, the rainfall levels seen in Yemen
2:49:15 are considerably higher than those found in Oman.
2:49:17 And in addition to their similar rainfall
2:49:19 levels and similar mountainous and desert topography,
2:49:22 they both contain similar amounts of geological resources, as well.
2:49:25 Both countries have a very comparable amount of proven oil and gas reserves,
2:49:28 with Oman only having slightly more of each.
2:49:31 And both countries occupy strategically
2:49:32 important territory that positions themselves
2:49:34 at the feet of extremely important global maritime trade routes.
2:49:38 Oman controls the valuable territory directly on the southern edge of the Strait
2:49:41 of Hormuz that funnels trade routes between
2:49:43 the Persian Gulf and the Indian Ocean,
2:49:44 while Yemen controls the similarly valuable territory
2:49:47 on the eastern side of the Bab el-Mandeb Strait,
2:49:49 which funnels trade routes between the Suez Canal and the Indian Ocean,
2:49:52 which gives both Yemen and Oman a degree of immense geopolitical
2:49:56 leverage owing to the spaces on the board that they each occupy.
2:49:59 Both countries are inhabited by ethnic Arabs
2:50:01 who share a similar language and culture,
2:50:03 and both countries overwhelmingly follow the Islamic faith.
2:50:06 Sunni Islam is the dominant branch of the faith
2:50:08 in each today in terms of raw numbers of followers.
2:50:11 Though Yemen is home to a very significant Zaidi Shia minority,
2:50:14 while Oman is home to a very significant
2:50:16 Ibadi minority that has traditionally ruled the country,
2:50:19 and which is often considered to be a completely separate branch
2:50:21 of the Islamic faith from the more well-known Sunni and the Shia.
2:50:25 There are a lot of similarities between Yemen and Oman,
2:50:28 not least of which is their shared border that runs for 183 miles or 294 km.
2:50:34 And yet, despite all of their similarities and neighboring locations on the map,
2:50:38 there are perhaps no other two bordering countries in the entire world
2:50:41 today who experience such radically different
2:50:44 realities today in the 21st century.
2:50:46 Yemen is these days most well-known for being
2:50:48 essentially the poster child of a failed state.
2:50:51 The country has been locked in a devastating
2:50:53 civil war for a decade now, ever since 2014,
2:50:56 that still doesn't see any end in sight,
2:50:58 and which has resulted in the deaths of hundreds of thousands of people.
2:51:01 Just last month in March of 2024,
2:51:04 the United Nations still described Yemen as experiencing
2:51:06 one of the worst humanitarian disasters in the world,
2:51:09 with millions of people remaining forcibly displaced from their homes,
2:51:12 and with roughly 6 million people remaining on the brink of famine.
2:51:16 In reality, Yemen ceased being a functioning country years ago,
2:51:19 and is more of a geographic expression these days than a real country.
2:51:23 Yemen's territory is still divided between multiple different
2:51:26 factions and warlords supported by various different outside powers,
2:51:30 and many of these factions in control of Yemen's
2:51:32 territory are widely recognized internationally as terrorist organizations,
2:51:36 such as the Houthis, who control most of the country's population centers,
2:51:39 and are considered a terrorist organization by Saudi Arabia,
2:51:42 the United Arab Emirates, Malaysia, and the United States.
2:51:44 And there's also Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula, or AQAP,
2:51:47 who also controls significant territory and is widely considered
2:51:50 a terrorist organization by dozens of countries all around the world.
2:51:54 Within the past decade alone, Yemen's territory has been bombed by foreign
2:51:58 countries from all around the world, and it remains one of the most
2:52:01 deeply dangerous and troubled countries on the planet.
2:52:04 The Human Development Index, or HDI,
2:52:06 is a composite index that combines scores in a country's per capita income,
2:52:10 access to education, and access to healthcare to figure out a score
2:52:13 between zero at the lowest and one at the highest.
2:52:16 Yemen's 2023 HDI score clocked in at an abysmal 0.424,
2:52:22 which is literally the eighth lowest score in the entire world,
2:52:26 and by far the lowest that can be
2:52:27 found anywhere in the world outside of sub-Saharan Africa.
2:52:31 And most sub-Saharan African nations are actually doing better than Yemen is,
2:52:35 according to the HDI.
2:52:36 And on top of the abysmal HDI score, Yemen also ranks near the very bottom
2:52:40 on the annual Corruption Perceptions Index for 2023,
2:52:43 as well, having come in as the fifth most corrupt country in the entire world,
2:52:48 somehow even beating out the corruption score for North Korea.
2:52:51 Yemen also has one of the lowest levels of GDP per capita in the world,
2:52:55 one of the highest levels of poverty in the world,
2:52:57 one of the lowest levels of literacy in the world, especially for Yemeni women,
2:53:00 and a whole host of other problems that are
2:53:02 genuinely just far too many to even count.
2:53:06 Meanwhile, Oman, just right next door across the border,
2:53:09 couldn't possibly be any more different.
2:53:11 Oman hasn't seen a war fought in its territory for decades since the 1970s.
2:53:16 Oman's 2023 HDI score stands at an impressive 0.819,
2:53:21 which is a massive difference between them and Yemen of 0.395 basis points.
2:53:27 To put that chasm of a difference in a further perspective,
2:53:30 Oman's HDI score is roughly equivalent to Romania,
2:53:33 while Yemen's is roughly equivalent to Mali.
2:53:35 So, imagine if Mali and Romania shared a border between each other.
2:53:39 This difference is significantly larger than even the much-discussed
2:53:43 HDI difference between Haiti and the Dominican Republic,
2:53:46 who share the same island of Hispaniola in the Caribbean,
2:53:49 and it's probably a larger gap than even
2:53:50 the difference in HDI between North Korea and South Korea.
2:53:53 In fact, the difference in HDI score across the border from Yemen to Oman
2:53:57 is the second largest HDI disparity between any two borders in the entire world,
2:54:05 even larger difference in HDI score
2:54:07 across Yemen's other border into Saudi Arabia.
2:54:10 There is literally nowhere else on the planet that has as stark of a difference
2:54:13 in HDI score immediately across borders as between Yemen and its two neighbors.
2:54:18 And it's not just the HDI score that Oman excels over Yemen with.
2:54:22 The nominal GDP per capita in Oman is currently
2:54:25 a whopping 34 times higher than it is in Yemen,
2:54:29 with Yemen's being the ninth lowest in the entire world,
2:54:31 and Oman's being roughly equivalent to Hungary.
2:54:33 Despite Yemen's population being significantly higher than Oman's,
2:54:37 and despite Yemen's control of the most
2:54:38 agriculturally fertile land in the Arabian Peninsula,
2:54:41 and its roughly similar amount of oil and gas resources as Oman,
2:54:44 Oman's economy is still more than five times larger than Yemen's is.
2:54:49 Oman's score in the Corruption Perceptions Index is about on a par with Italy,
2:54:53 which is much, much better than being the fifth lowest in the entire world.
2:54:57 And the list of differences really just continues to go on from there.
2:55:00 Oman is ultimately a stable, prosperous,
2:55:03 healthy nation that is notably ruled by one
2:55:05 of the very few absolute monarchies remaining in the 21st century.
2:55:09 While Yemen is basically an apocalyptic
2:55:12 nightmare right next door across the border.
2:55:15 So, how did this massive divergence between two otherwise
2:55:19 similar-looking countries develop into the way it is today?
2:55:22 It didn't just come out of nowhere, and it begins with a slight,
2:55:25 but notable differences between each of their geographies.
2:55:29 A very important component of both of these countries' geographies
2:55:32 are their mountains that separate their interiors from their coastlines.
2:55:35 In the case of Yemen, their more isolated mountainous highlands enabled
2:55:39 the Zaidi Shia Muslim movement to emerge
2:55:41 as a distinct religious identity in a region
2:55:44 otherwise dominated by the Sunni branch of Islam.
2:55:46 While in Oman, the presence of the country's
2:55:48 northern mountain chain separates the interior region
2:55:51 from a more narrow band of coastal
2:55:52 plains immediately budding up against the Arabian Sea.
2:55:55 It was within this isolated coastal plain geographically separated from the rest
2:55:59 of the Arabian Peninsula and the Middle East that a unique Islamic identity took
2:56:03 hold that became known a branch of Islam that is often regarded
2:56:07 as being distinctly separate from the larger
2:56:09 and more well-known Sunni and Shia branches.
2:56:12 The Ibadis, secure in their isolated coastal plain here,
2:56:15 developed around the port city of Muscat.
2:56:18 And because of their easy access to global
2:56:19 maritime trade routes out into the Indian Ocean,
2:56:22 they became more commercially focused, outward-looking,
2:56:24 and cosmopolitan in nature,
2:56:26 which has influenced the Ibadi sect's outlook on religious
2:56:28 tolerance and peaceful coexistence with other beliefs for centuries now.
2:56:32 The interior of Oman, conversely,
2:56:34 grew to become more inward-looking, theocratic, and fundamentalist in nature,
2:56:38 not too dissimilar to the pattern seen in modern-day Yemen and Saudi Arabia.
2:56:42 In Yemen, the southern coastal areas on the Gulf
2:56:44 of Aden grew to also become more outward-looking, trade-oriented,
2:56:47 and secular, while the interior mountainous highlands,
2:56:50 home to the Zaidi Shia movement,
2:56:51 grew to become more inward-looking and theocratic.
2:56:54 Just as in Saudi Arabia, where the coasts were more cosmopolitan
2:56:57 and the interior around modern-day Riyadh was the birthplace of the modern-day
2:57:01 ultra-conservative Wahhabi movement in Sunni Islam.
2:57:04 So, Yemen and Oman both struggled for centuries with this difference
2:57:07 in geography and outlook between
2:57:09 their coastal populations and interior populations.
2:57:12 While Yemen's northwestern mountains receive many times more rainfall
2:57:16 than anywhere else in Oman or in the Arabian Peninsula.
2:57:19 As a result, these mountainous parts of northwestern Yemen are
2:57:22 the most agriculturally productive in the Arabian
2:57:24 Peninsula anywhere outside of Iraq.
2:57:26 And so, they've always been the most densely populated
2:57:29 part of Arabia for thousands of years, as well.
2:57:32 Yemen's agricultural potential is many times higher than that of Oman's,
2:57:36 and as a result, Yemen has always had the greater population between them.
2:57:40 Even today, Yemen's 2024 population is nearly 35 million people,
2:57:45 while Oman has fewer than 5 million,
2:57:47 meaning that Yemen has roughly seven times the population of Oman.
2:57:51 But Yemen's much larger population base carries with it
2:57:54 certain challenges that have been absent in Oman.
2:57:57 In the late 20th century,
2:57:58 when large oil and gas reserves were discovered across both of them,
2:58:02 it turned out that each had pretty similar amounts,
2:58:05 though Oman's were slightly larger.
2:58:07 Oman's greatest inherent advantage, however,
2:58:10 was that its slightly larger amount of oil
2:58:12 and gas reserves were always going to be able to go much further in the way
2:58:15 of directly benefiting its much smaller population.
2:58:18 It was always going to be easier to have these similar amounts of oil and gas
2:58:21 resources benefit the population of Oman that's just
2:58:24 1/7 of the size of the population in Yemen.
2:58:27 And Yemen's population is only expected to continue growing further and further
2:58:32 beyond Oman's because as the two
2:58:34 countries development destinies diverged radically,
2:58:36 so too did each of their fertility rates.
2:58:39 Even though Yemen's fertility rate has
2:58:41 been continually declining since the late 1980s,
2:58:43 it is still today as of 2023 one of the highest seen anywhere in the world.
2:58:48 The average Yemeni woman continues to have 3.6 children during her lifetime.
2:58:53 Conversely, Oman's fertility rate has also
2:58:55 continually declined since the early 1980s,
2:58:58 but at a much faster pace than Yemen's to the point
2:59:01 where today the average Omani woman only has 2.5 children,
2:59:05 meaning that with its much larger
2:59:06 population base and much higher fertility rate,
2:59:09 Yemen's population is going to continue
2:59:11 growing multiple times larger than Oman's will.
2:59:14 By the midpoint of the century in 2050,
2:59:16 Yemen's population is currently projected
2:59:18 to reach a staggering 60 million people,
2:59:21 while Oman's isn't projected to grow much further than 6 million people,
2:59:25 meaning that by then the Yemeni population will
2:59:28 be about 10 times larger than Oman's will,
2:59:31 which simply means that Yemen's limited resources will continue being
2:59:34 spread out more thinly than Oman's will have to be.
2:59:37 In addition to geographic and demographic differences between the two,
2:59:40 there were also very notable historical differences between the two
2:59:43 that explain a lot of the current divergence between them as well.
2:59:46 Both countries were conquered or colonized
2:59:48 by non-Arab powers in the 16th century.
2:59:51 The Ottoman Turks took over most of northern Yemen in 1519 and would
2:59:54 control it for the next 400 years until the end of World War I,
2:59:58 while the Portuguese took over most Oman in 1507 just
3:00:02 a few years before the Ottomans took over northern Yemen.
3:00:05 But the people around Muscat in modern-day Oman
3:00:07 managed to push out their foreign occupiers much,
3:00:09 much earlier than the Yemenis did.
3:00:12 The Portuguese only stayed around in Oman
3:00:13 for about a century and a half until 1650,
3:00:16 when local Omani tribes from the interior region
3:00:18 managed to push them out and take over Muscat,
3:00:21 after which they declared the new Sultanate of Oman.
3:00:24 This makes modern Oman the oldest continuously
3:00:26 independent state in the Arab world today,
3:00:29 having remained largely independent ever since
3:00:31 then right up until the modern day.
3:00:33 From there, the Omanis utilized their centuries
3:00:35 of previous ship and trade experience and everything they
3:00:37 learned from the Portuguese to then pursue the Portuguese
3:00:40 Empire across the rest of the Indian Ocean.
3:00:43 And in the process, the Omanis created a vast maritime empire of their own
3:00:47 that at times dominated much of the Arabian
3:00:49 Sea and controlled overseas territories in modern-day Iran,
3:00:52 Pakistan, India, and all across Eastern Africa,
3:00:55 including the strategically important trade hub of Zanzibar.
3:00:58 The sprawling Omani Empire was eventually
3:01:00 partitioned in 1856 between the northern holdings
3:01:03 based around modern-day Oman and the southern
3:01:05 holdings based around Zanzibar in Africa.
3:01:07 And so the northern half became known as the Sultanate of Muscat and Oman,
3:01:10 essentially ruled by a more secular sultan in the coastal plain
3:01:13 around Muscat and a more theocratic Imam in the interior region.
3:01:17 Muscat and Oman eventually became a de facto British protectorate in 1872,
3:01:22 but the Sultanate always retained its
3:01:23 internal political independence and even ceased
3:01:25 being a British protectorate after only a few decades later in 1920,
3:01:29 when it received its full independence back.
3:01:31 The same wasn't true for Yemen, however,
3:01:34 which endured much longer and deeper colonization than Oman ever did.
3:01:38 Yemen's densely populated, mountainous, and largely Zaidi Shia northwest was
3:01:43 controlled by the Ottomans for centuries until
3:01:45 they withdrew from the area after their defeat in World War I in 1918,
3:01:50 while the rest of modern-day Yemen was steadily colonized by the British.
3:01:53 This other part of modern-day Yemen without
3:01:56 the rain and agriculture of the northwest is
3:01:58 significantly more sparsely populated than the northwest
3:02:01 of the country and is largely based around small,
3:02:03 dense clusters of civilization on the coast like in Aden.
3:02:07 Most of this territory in Yemen outside of the control
3:02:09 of the Ottomans eventually fell under the colonial influence of the British,
3:02:12 just like Oman eventually did, but the British came to Yemen much earlier
3:02:16 and stayed for much longer than they did in Oman.
3:02:19 The British were particularly interested in holding onto
3:02:21 the port of Aden in southern Yemen directly,
3:02:24 one of the most strategically valuable ports in the entire region because
3:02:27 it's a natural harbor that sits very close by to the Bab
3:02:31 al-Mandab Strait that all traffic between Europe and the Indian Ocean
3:02:34 has to use when transiting across the Suez Canal further north.
3:02:38 The British therefore directly colonized the city
3:02:41 of Aden in 1839 and administered
3:02:43 it directly as a colony for more than a century until the 1960s,
3:02:48 while the remaining sparsely inhabited
3:02:49 hinterlands of southern Yemen were administered
3:02:51 as a protectorate long after the Ottomans withdrew from the north in 1918.
3:02:57 The Zaidi Shia of the Yemeni mountains
3:02:58 frequently rebelled against Ottoman rule and failed.
3:03:01 And so after the Ottomans finally left
3:03:03 in 1918 after the last 400 years of control,
3:03:07 a theocratic Zaidi Shia religious leader seized power
3:03:10 in the vacuum and transformed northern Yemen into a theocratic
3:03:13 kingdom that became the precursor of the modern-day
3:03:16 Houthi movement in Yemen that we know today.
3:03:19 This theocratic kingdom in north Yemen was led by a Zaidi Shia Imam King
3:03:23 who launched frequent failed invasions into the southern
3:03:26 British Yemen trying to take it over,
3:03:28 while its autocratic Zaidi Shia absolute theocracy had no tolerance
3:03:32 for Yemen's other internal religious groups like Sunnis and Jews.
3:03:36 This led to mounting unrest within the kingdom, especially among the Sunnis,
3:03:40 which culminated with a violent coup d'état in the kingdom happening in 1962,
3:03:45 when Yemeni military officers overthrew the Imam King and attempted
3:03:48 to install an Arab nationalist style republic in its place.
3:03:52 The 1962 coup was directly supported by Gamal
3:03:55 Abdel Nasser's Arab nationalist government in Egypt,
3:03:58 while the deposed monarchy was supported by other
3:04:00 monarchies in the region like Saudi Arabia,
3:04:02 who were fearful of Arab nationalism and republicanism
3:04:05 spreading and toppling their own monarchies in the process.
3:04:08 What followed became the first of many devastating modern proxy
3:04:12 wars that have been fought in the territory of Yemen.
3:04:14 As Egypt threw enormous resources at the nationalist side,
3:04:17 including the overseas deployment of 70,000 of their own soldiers to fight,
3:04:22 while Saudi Arabia and the other Arab monarchies
3:04:24 threw their own resources at the monarchist side.
3:04:27 The civil war went on for a brutal eight years
3:04:30 until 1970 and is believed to have killed anywhere between 100,000
3:04:35 and 200,000 people in north Yemen before the nationalist republican
3:04:39 side eventually emerged victorious and proclaimed the new Yemen Arab Republic,
3:04:43 the very first republic to ever appear in an Arabian
3:04:46 peninsula that is otherwise completely dominated by monarchies still today.
3:04:51 The presence of an independent Arab republic in Yemen
3:04:53 and the violent toppling of its monarchy was
3:04:55 a precedent that none of the other monarchist powers
3:04:57 in the Arabian peninsula wanted to tolerate or accept.
3:05:01 But then, what happened in southern Yemen
3:05:03 somehow became even more radical and revolutionary.
3:05:06 As the civil war was raging in north Yemen,
3:05:09 a group of radical Yemeni communists managed to push
3:05:12 out the British from Aden in southern Yemen.
3:05:14 And then in 1967, they proclaimed
3:05:17 the independent People's Democratic Republic of Yemen,
3:05:20 the first and so far only openly communist Marxist-Leninist state to ever
3:05:26 emerge in either the Arab world or in the Middle East.
3:05:29 By 1970 then, Yemen was divided between an Arab nationalist republican
3:05:33 government in the north and a revolutionary communist government in the south.
3:05:37 And so the second proxy war in Yemen of the modern
3:05:40 era began as the lines of the Cold War overlapped it.
3:05:43 The Americans began supporting the nationalist north Yemen,
3:05:46 while the Soviets and the Eastern Bloc
3:05:47 began very heavily supporting communist south Yemen,
3:05:51 their only solidly communist foothold in the Middle East.
3:05:54 The rest of the Arab monarchies, not happy with the way that the republican
3:05:57 government came into being in north Yemen,
3:05:59 still ultimately all decided to begrudgingly supported anyway
3:06:03 rather than back the even more radical communist government
3:06:06 in the south that openly wanted to destroy their monarchies
3:06:10 in a wave of Marxist revolution for the Arabs.
3:06:13 North and south Yemen went on to fight two brief wars against each other.
3:06:16 And in 1978, a north Yemeni military officer named Ali Abdullah Saleh rose
3:06:21 to power as the country's new president after the previous one was assassinated.
3:06:26 After rising to power, Saleh then effectively began treating north Yemen
3:06:30 as his own and his family's personal property.
3:06:33 He was legendarily corrupt and embezzled ungodly amounts of the country's
3:06:37 oil and gas wealth and foreign aid for his own personal benefit.
3:06:41 He would end up ruling in Yemen for decades after he took over.
3:06:44 And in 2012, after he was finally overthrown,
3:06:47 a United Nations sanctions panel had concluded
3:06:50 that Saleh was able to use embezzlement, extortion,
3:06:52 and theft of public funds from the country's fuel subsidy program to rake
3:06:56 in approximately two billion dollars per year for his own personal gain.
3:07:02 By the same time in 2012, it was also estimated by the same UN
3:07:05 sanctions panel that Saleh had spent his decades
3:07:08 in power quietly amassing a personal fortune for himself
3:07:11 anywhere between 32 and 64 billion US dollars,
3:07:16 all hidden away in various offshore bank
3:07:19 accounts across at least 20 different countries.
3:07:22 This easily made him one of the wealthiest human
3:07:24 beings alive anywhere in the world at the time.
3:07:27 And all in a country where at the time back in 2012,
3:07:30 the nominal GDP per capita was less than $1,400 a year.
3:07:34 To put that in a context, Saleh's personal wealth in 2012 could have potentially
3:07:39 been nearly twice as large as Yemen's entire GDP
3:07:43 was at the same time because the man
3:07:45 had effectively plundered the entire country dry for decades.
3:07:49 After the Soviet Union began collapsing in 1990,
3:07:52 Moscow cut off all of its subsidies
3:07:54 and funding for the communist government in south Yemen.
3:07:57 And south Yemen's economy practically imploded overnight without that support.
3:08:01 In the aftermath, the powerless government in the south
3:08:03 agreed to unify the country with the north and keep north Yemen's Abdullah Saleh
3:08:08 as the unified country's head of state going forward.
3:08:11 But Saleh immediately began making terrible foreign policy
3:08:14 decisions nearly the moment the country was unified.
3:08:17 Merely months after Yemen became a unified country,
3:08:20 Saddam Hussein ordered the Iraqi army to invade and conquer Kuwait.
3:08:25 Saleh then rather foolishly chose
3:08:27 to politically support Saddam during the invasion.
3:08:30 And after Saddam was decisively defeated
3:08:32 and his army destroyed and Kuwait was liberated,
3:08:35 Kuwait and Saudi Arabia both decided to immediately end their large
3:08:39 amounts of foreign aid that they had previously been giving to Yemen.
3:08:42 And on top of that, the Saudis were so infuriated with Saleh's support of Saddam
3:08:47 that they expelled more than 850,000 Yemeni
3:08:51 guest workers from the country back to Yemen.
3:08:53 These hundreds of thousands of Yemenis have been working in the Saudi kingdom
3:08:57 earning higher salaries than what they were capable of back home in Yemen.
3:09:01 And they were sending large amounts of the money
3:09:03 they were earning back home to Yemen as remittances,
3:09:06 which was a huge positive for the Yemeni economy.
3:09:09 Their sudden expulsion and exile back to Yemen because
3:09:12 of Saleh's foreign policy proved to be a major
3:09:15 economic shock to the country at the same
3:09:17 time as Yemen was struggling to integrate the South.
3:09:20 By acquiring the formerly communist South Yemen,
3:09:23 Saleh had increased the amount of oil
3:09:25 and gas reserves in his country by roughly fourfold
3:09:28 since the vast majority of the country's oil
3:09:30 and gas was in the former South Yemen.
3:09:32 And like Germany experienced with the reintegration of the formerly
3:09:35 communist East Germany after the end of the Cold War,
3:09:38 the newly unified Yemen also struggled to integrate
3:09:41 the formerly communist command style economy in the South
3:09:44 into the deeply corrupt and crony capitalist
3:09:46 government of the North dominated by Abdullah Saleh.
3:09:49 The acquisition of so many more oil and gas reserves in South
3:09:53 Yemen was used to essentially line up Saleh's own pockets even further.
3:09:57 While the simultaneous shock of the 850,000
3:10:00 Yemenis arriving back in the country all
3:10:02 at once from Saudi Arabia and the further
3:10:04 struggles to integrate the South's formerly communist economy,
3:10:07 not to mention Saleh's own flagrant and massive corruption,
3:10:11 quickly led the recently unified Yemen right back to the breaking point.
3:10:15 The South rebelled against Saleh's regime in 1994,
3:10:18 only four years after the unification of the country happened.
3:10:22 And so another brief civil war exploded in the country.
3:10:25 And then to help put it down,
3:10:26 Saleh began welcoming fighters from what would eventually become Al-Qaeda
3:10:30 into the country to fight on his behalf against the South.
3:10:33 Al-Qaeda's presence in Yemen eventually morphed
3:10:35 into Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula, or AQAP, whose presence in Yemen
3:10:39 strained Saleh's relationship with the United States.
3:10:42 Especially after Al-Qaeda bombed an American missile cruiser known as the USS
3:10:46 Cole as it was docked in a harbor in Aden in 2000,
3:10:50 which killed 17 American sailors.
3:10:53 Then after 9/11, Washington took a much
3:10:55 more firm line with Saleh's government in Yemen.
3:10:58 And so Saleh began switching sides to a more pro-US foreign policy.
3:11:02 He allowed the United States begin conducting
3:11:04 drone strikes in Yemen against suspected Al-Qaeda targets.
3:11:07 While his public support for Washington enraged many of the more
3:11:10 religiously conservative Zaydi Shia Muslims of the mountainous interior.
3:11:14 That, combined with Saleh's long autocratic
3:11:17 and deeply corrupt rule in the country
3:11:19 and Yemen's long policies of attempted Sunnification of the Zaydi Shia,
3:11:23 led to significant unrest mounting beneath
3:11:26 the surface that eventually exploded after
3:11:28 the 2011 Arab Spring protests began sweeping all across the Middle East.
3:11:32 Full-blown revolution erupted in Yemen afterwards,
3:11:36 and Abdullah Saleh was finally overthrown from power in early 2012.
3:11:40 In the power vacuum that followed,
3:11:42 the Zaydi Shia of the northwest largely coalesced under the Houthi movement.
3:11:46 And fighting between them and the Sunni tribes in Yemen
3:11:49 began that eventually escalated to the point where in 2014,
3:11:52 the Houthis marched on the Yemeni capital and seized it
3:11:55 by force and then rapidly took control of the country's government,
3:11:58 which led to the devastating Yemeni civil war that has continued on ever since
3:12:03 that has become the third and current proxy
3:12:05 war fought in Yemen's territory in recent history.
3:12:08 This time between revolutionary anti-monarchist theocratic
3:12:11 Shia Islamist powers like Iran and Hezbollah, who support the Houthis,
3:12:15 and the more status quo monarchist powers like Saudi Arabia,
3:12:18 the United Arab Emirates, and Bahrain,
3:12:21 who oppose the Houthis for similar reasons why they opposed the Arab
3:12:24 nationalist Republicans in the same area during the civil war of the 1960s.
3:12:29 They fear that a revolutionary anti-monarchist Islamist victory
3:12:32 in Yemen that brings a Shiite clerical class
3:12:35 into power as a theocracy will become
3:12:37 a direct challenge to their own continued monarchical rule.
3:12:41 Yemen has been a battlefield for outside powers from all around
3:12:44 the world to fight in for more than 60 years now.
3:12:47 And while the country was impoverished and struggling before the current
3:12:50 civil war began in 2014 due to its many chronic issues,
3:12:54 it got much, much worse afterwards.
3:12:57 After the first civil war in the United Yemen erupted in 1994,
3:13:01 the country's GDP as measured in current US dollars proceeded
3:13:04 to crash by more than 76% within only two years by 1996.
3:13:10 It then took the country a decade and a half until 2010
3:13:13 just to recover its GDP from before the civil war in 1994.
3:13:17 And then Yemen's next civil war began only four years later after that in 2014,
3:13:23 which led the country's economy to crash
3:13:24 by another 55% by 2021 as the war continued.
3:13:29 While Yemen's oil production levels crashed right alongside the economy
3:13:32 by nearly just as much as the civil war intensified.
3:13:36 It has since then gone into the point where in 2023,
3:13:39 Yemen has basically become an irrelevant
3:13:41 oil producer in only 66th place worldwide,
3:13:44 producing even less oil today than Poland does.
3:13:48 Despite Yemen having 30 times as many
3:13:50 oil reserves in their territory as Poland has.
3:13:53 And while Yemen has been a hotbed
3:13:55 of instability and chaos and foreign interventions for decades,
3:13:58 Oman simply hasn't been in a great deal.
3:14:00 A lot of why was the very different leadership style that was
3:14:03 present in Oman at the same time as Abdullah Saleh ruled in Yemen.
3:14:07 Back in 1970, Oman was still just as hopelessly poor as Yemen was and was
3:14:11 effectively considered by most of the international
3:14:13 community as an isolated medieval Arab backwater.
3:14:16 The sultan who ruled the country was an absolute
3:14:18 monarch who dominated every facet of the country's
3:14:20 existence to the point where the national treasury was
3:14:23 kept in a chest within his own personal palace.
3:14:26 After the communists kicked the British out
3:14:27 of South Yemen and declared the communist government there,
3:14:30 South Yemen began sponsoring a neighboring communist insurgency
3:14:33 in the far western Dhofar region of Oman as well.
3:14:36 At the time, the then sultan of Oman was basically
3:14:38 an ultra-conservative and eccentric Luddite who
3:14:41 had outlawed virtually all technological development
3:14:43 in the country preferring to keep everything as close to the medieval
3:14:46 era as possible to the detriment of his own people.
3:14:48 He also used his absolute authority to outlaw fairly arbitrary things
3:14:52 like speeding anyone in the country for more than 15 minutes,
3:14:55 wearing sunglasses, smoking, and playing football.
3:14:58 The sultan was thus deeply unpopular in Oman as a result.
3:15:01 And so, fearful that communism could end up spreading
3:15:04 from South Yemen across Oman to replace the sultan,
3:15:07 the British decided to intervene
3:15:08 in their former protectorate in 1970 by sponsoring
3:15:11 a coup d'état led by the sultan's young son, Qaboos bin Said.
3:15:15 The coup that followed was entirely bloodless.
3:15:17 The sultan was successfully overthrown and exiled to England
3:15:20 while the young Qaboos took over in his place.
3:15:22 And as it turned out,
3:15:24 the new Sultan Qaboos was an incredibly competent administrator.
3:15:28 While he continued on with a system of absolute monarchy
3:15:30 in Oman with himself remaining as the ultimate political authority,
3:15:34 Sultan Qaboos was essentially a 20th and 21st century
3:15:37 version of an enlightened monarch like Frederick the Great.
3:15:40 He was a reformist who liberalized and revolutionized
3:15:42 Omani society for the benefit of the kingdom's people.
3:15:45 He welcomed foreign energy companies like Shell to expand
3:15:48 their oil and gas exploration and production in the kingdom,
3:15:50 and he heavily reinvested the kingdom's growing oil
3:15:53 and gas wealth back into the country itself.
3:15:56 When Sultan Qaboos took power in Oman in 1970,
3:15:58 the entire country was home to a mere three schools,
3:16:01 19 medical facilities, and only 10 km worth of paved roads.
3:16:06 Within a decade and a half by 1985,
3:16:08 Qaboos utilized the kingdom's oil and gas wealth to build out 500 new schools,
3:16:13 100 new medical facilities,
3:16:15 and more than 3200 km worth of additional paved roads,
3:16:19 which [music] greatly increased the development
3:16:21 of the nation and the people's quality of life.
3:16:23 Qaboos immediately outlawed slavery in Oman when he came to power.
3:16:27 He granted women in the kingdom the right to vote,
3:16:29 and he established a brand new parliament
3:16:31 that consisted of elected officials to support the monarchy.
3:16:34 He used this rapid development of the kingdom
3:16:36 and the support of British and Iranian troops deployed by the Shah to quell
3:16:39 the communist rebellion in the Dhofar province.
3:16:42 And as the country's wealth was continually reinvested
3:16:45 into the country's development
3:16:46 and the people's living standards continued rising,
3:16:49 the level of remaining unrest began to evaporate.
3:16:52 Far from plundering the country of its resources
3:16:55 and wealth dry like Abdullah Saleh did in Yemen,
3:16:57 Sultan Qaboos poured his nation's wealth into developing the kingdom
3:17:01 for the benefit of the people and sunk billions
3:17:04 of dollars into diversifying the country's economy away from oil
3:17:07 and gas to open up other major economic sectors like tourism.
3:17:11 Qaboos's strategy in modernization was so
3:17:13 enormously effective in Oman that in 2010,
3:17:16 the United Nations bestowed Oman with the honor of being first in the entire
3:17:20 world for the advancement of their HDI score over the past 40 years,
3:17:24 surpassing even the much more well-publicized example of China.
3:17:28 Oman's oil and gas production rates continued increasing
3:17:31 in this environment of stability as foreign companies
3:17:33 found it more prudent to invest in in comparison
3:17:36 to the basket case in neighboring Yemen.
3:17:38 Sultan Qaboos was also insistent on a forward-looking policy
3:17:41 that he called Omanization in the kingdom's oil and gas industry.
3:17:45 That is, the foreign energy companies that set
3:17:47 up operations in Oman would have to hire
3:17:49 local Omani workers and give them working
3:17:51 experience in the industry so that over time,
3:17:54 Oman would be able to reduce the reliance
3:17:55 on foreign employees and companies and begin
3:17:57 taking over control of more and more
3:17:59 of the kingdom's oil and gas for themselves.
3:18:02 Oman also simply didn't have the long history of divided rule
3:18:05 between separate regions of the country the same way that Yemen did.
3:18:09 Where Yemen had been divided between an Ottoman
3:18:11 north and a British south for more than
3:18:13 a century and then between a nationalist north
3:18:15 and a communist south for decades until the 1990s,
3:18:18 Oman had remained a mostly unified nation for centuries
3:18:21 and had been free of Britain's protectorate for decades.
3:18:24 Oman Oman didn't have to reintegrate a communist society
3:18:27 and economic system the same way that Yemen needed to do.
3:18:30 While Sultan Qaboos went further and enshrined
3:18:31 a policy of religious tolerance within Oman.
3:18:34 While he himself and most of the ruling
3:18:35 class in Oman followed the Ibadi branch of Islam,
3:18:38 all of his subjects were granted religious freedom
3:18:41 and were allowed to mostly follow whatever they wanted.
3:18:43 A policy that was again very separate
3:18:46 from the deeply sectarian politics over in nearby Yemen.
3:18:49 That frequently pitted the country's Zaidi
3:18:51 Shia community up against the Sunni community.
3:18:54 And alongside Sultan Qaboos's policy of reinvesting the country's oil wealth
3:18:57 back into the country to further the pace of development and modernization,
3:19:01 he also began pursuing a rather unique foreign policy
3:19:04 in the region that complemented his domestic strategy of stability very well.
3:19:08 Whereas Yemen was frequently the site
3:19:10 of various proxy wars all throughout its history.
3:19:12 And Abdullah Saleh pursued an interventionist foreign policy
3:19:15 that frequently got him and Yemen into trouble
3:19:18 by supporting Saddam's invasion of Kuwait and then
3:19:20 working with Al-Qaeda and later with the United States.
3:19:23 Sultan Qaboos put Oman down the path of radical
3:19:26 neutrality in the dangerous neighborhood of the Middle East.
3:19:29 Part of this strategy was aided by geography.
3:19:32 Because of Oman's northern mountain range,
3:19:33 the population core of the kingdom around the capital Muscat has
3:19:37 always been isolated and separated from the rest of the Middle East.
3:19:40 The political dominance of the Ibadi branch of the Islamic faith in Oman
3:19:44 has always been unique in the context of the greater Muslim world
3:19:47 and has put it apart from every other Muslim country that is
3:19:50 politically or democratically dominated by the much
3:19:52 larger Sunni or Shia branches instead.
3:19:55 This naturally set the Omani Sultanate up to become the go-to mediator
3:19:59 in disputes all across the region between the Sunni and the Shia.
3:20:02 Because as a separate Ibadi ruled state,
3:20:05 they could be viewed by both Sunni and Shia as a true neutral party.
3:20:09 Sultan Qaboos wielded this perceived neutrality of the Ibadi sect
3:20:12 and then effectively transformed Oman into the Switzerland of the Middle East.
3:20:16 He led Oman into continuing relations with the Ayatollahs
3:20:19 of Iran after the Islamic Revolution overthrew the Shah in 1979.
3:20:23 He led Oman to become the very first Gulf Arab
3:20:25 state to welcome an Israeli Prime Minister in 1994, Yitzhak Rabin.
3:20:30 In the 21st century, when the Saudi's sent tanks rolling across
3:20:33 their bridge into the island kingdom of Bahrain
3:20:35 in 2011 to put down a popular Shiite
3:20:38 revolution there against the kingdom's Sunni led monarchy,
3:20:40 Oman continued to remain neutral.
3:20:43 When the Houthis overran the Yemeni capital
3:20:45 and most of the country's population centers in 2014
3:20:47 and the Saudi's created a military coalition
3:20:50 in 2015 to intervene in Yemen against them,
3:20:52 Oman once again chose to remain neutral in the war.
3:20:55 And the following year in 2016, when diplomatic relations between Saudi Arabia
3:20:59 and Qatar broke down over a number
3:21:01 of issues and the Saudi's began championing a blockade and embargo of Qatar,
3:21:05 Oman once again still chose to remain neutral.
3:21:09 By remaining neutral in all of the multiple conflicts in the Middle East
3:21:12 and advancing itself as the go-to mediator
3:21:14 in all of the region's numerous disputes,
3:21:17 Oman was able to safeguard its own stability in a dangerous
3:21:20 neighborhood even further and cemented itself
3:21:23 as a highly valuable geopolitical asset.
3:21:25 And by doing so, it also made itself an indispensable ally
3:21:29 and friend to just about every single one of its neighbors.
3:21:32 And that further cemented Oman's value
3:21:34 to perhaps their greatest supporter, the United States.
3:21:37 Washington found Oman's friendly relations with every country
3:21:40 in the Middle East to be especially useful.
3:21:43 So much so that during the Obama administration, Oman was the site of high-level
3:21:47 diplomatic talks between the Americans and Iranians
3:21:49 that led to the so-called Iran nuclear deal between them in 2015.
3:21:53 Oman has hosted American troops in their country for decades
3:21:55 now out of the airbase RAFO Thumrait in the Dhofar region.
3:21:59 An airbase that the US Air Force has used
3:22:01 to support operations in Iraq and Afghanistan for decades now.
3:22:04 Oman's value to Washington is considered to be so great that ever since 2009,
3:22:09 the United States has maintained a comprehensive free trade agreement with Oman.
3:22:12 One of only 20 nations worldwide that the US
3:22:15 has these kinds of trade agreements with.
3:22:17 Sultan Qaboos ruled his kingdom for nearly 50 years continually from 1970 when
3:22:22 he overthrew his father to his death in 2020 just a few years ago.
3:22:27 During that time, he oversaw Oman's complete transformation from an isolated
3:22:31 medieval backwater into a modern developed 21st century nation.
3:22:35 Oman's GDP per capita was a paltry $382 per person
3:22:40 adjusted for inflation when he took the throne back in 1970,
3:22:44 which was about on a par with sub-Saharan
3:22:45 African nations at the time like Zambia and Zimbabwe.
3:22:48 Within two years of his death by 2022,
3:22:51 the nation's inflation adjusted GDP per capita had increased by more
3:22:54 than 65 times over to more than $25,000 per person.
3:22:59 He introduced the nation's first political constitution in 1996.
3:23:03 And for decades throughout his rule,
3:23:05 he undertook an annual tour of his kingdom to visit
3:23:08 with his own people and hear about their concerns directly.
3:23:11 His twin foreign policy of extreme neutrality
3:23:13 and his domestic policy of rapid reinvestment and development
3:23:16 transformed Oman into a wealthy bastion in the sea of chaos in the Middle East.
3:23:22 And though he was an absolute monarch who banned opposing political parties
3:23:26 and ran what has sometimes been described as a benevolent police state,
3:23:29 Sultan Qaboos was generally a beloved champion of the Omani people.
3:23:33 When the Arab Spring swept unrest across the region in 2011,
3:23:37 protests broke out in Oman just as they did elsewhere.
3:23:40 But Sultan Qaboos immediately addressed them with a promise
3:23:43 to create more jobs and boost incomes.
3:23:45 He opened up the government's finances
3:23:47 for the benefit of his people over himself.
3:23:49 And the protests quieted down and quickly went away.
3:23:52 His decades of forward-looking and prudent
3:23:55 leadership in Oman contrasts extremely
3:23:57 sharply with that of Abdullah Saleh's decades of rule in neighboring Yemen,
3:24:02 which were spent effectively plundering the country for his own personal benefit
3:24:05 that awarded him no affection when unrest came to Yemen after 2011, too.
3:24:10 And after the Sultan's death in 2020,
3:24:12 his forward-looking and sound policies appear to have continued under
3:24:15 the reign of his cousin and the current Sultan, Haitham bin Tariq.
3:24:19 Oman's decades of stability and rising oil and gas output
3:24:22 and rising economy attracted further foreign investment into the country,
3:24:26 which enabled Oman to extend its oil and gas
3:24:28 production and exports even further and earn even more money.
3:24:31 In the process though, Oman also transformed into effectively a petrostate.
3:24:35 Oil and gas currently represents 64% of the country's export revenue,
3:24:39 45% of the government's income, and half of its entire GDP.
3:24:43 This has exposed Oman to economic shocks
3:24:46 whenever the global price of oil decreases,
3:24:48 which is partially what sparked protests in the kingdom in the 2010s.
3:24:51 But the country has been aggressively investing into diversifying
3:24:54 itself away from oil by building out alternative economic sectors.
3:24:58 Like most of the other Gulf states, Oman has been particularly trying to build
3:25:02 out a robust tourism industry for itself.
3:25:04 In 2023, the kingdom welcomed more than 4 million tourists to the country.
3:25:09 And Oman currently has about $6 billion
3:25:11 worth of tourism related investments in dozens
3:25:14 of projects currently on the table to expand their tourism sector even further.
3:25:18 Meanwhile, Yemen is frequently considered as one of, if
3:25:20 not the most dangerous countries in the world to visit.
3:25:23 And so the country has virtually zero tourism
3:25:26 and this only further compounds Oman's economic advantages over Yemen.
3:25:30 The two neighboring countries have also diverged over
3:25:32 time in another very notable way as well.
3:25:35 Their radically different uses of their scarce water in agriculture.
3:25:39 While Yemen indeed has the most
3:25:41 agriculturally productive land in the Arabian Peninsula,
3:25:43 it has been very inefficiently used for decades
3:25:46 now to produce a plant known as qat.
3:25:48 Qat is a mildly narcotic plant that when
3:25:51 chewed releases natural stimulants to the person chewing.
3:25:54 And its use has fairly recently
3:25:56 become a very widespread phenomenon across Yemen.
3:25:59 In 2007, the United Nations conducted a specific report on the nature
3:26:03 of qat chewing in Yemen and found that as recently as the 1960s,
3:26:07 the chewing of qat was only an occasional pastime
3:26:10 in the country that was largely enjoyed only by the rich.
3:26:13 From there, however,
3:26:14 qat chewing somehow spread across Yemen to become a virtually ubiquitous hobby.
3:26:18 The 2007 UN study concluded that a whopping 72% of men in Yemen
3:26:23 and 33% of women chewed qat regularly with many chewing it every day.
3:26:29 It concluded that more than one in five qat users
3:26:31 in Yemen spent more than six hours a day chewing it.
3:26:34 While more than 93% of users spent more than two hours a day chewing it,
3:26:38 which takes away productivity from the workplace all across the country
3:26:42 and negatively impacts the Yemeni economy
3:26:44 even further than everything else already does.
3:26:47 The wide-scale cultivation of qat for this large-scale domestic consumption
3:26:51 within Yemen has also crowded out the nation's valuable and limited
3:26:54 agricultural land and supplanted the cultivation of more valuable cash crops
3:26:58 that Yemen used to export for revenue like coffee and fruits.
3:27:02 Qat production in Yemen is almost entirely consumed within Yemen.
3:27:06 And because qat is a very water-intensive crop to grow,
3:27:09 the cultivation of qat in Yemen is currently believed to consume
3:27:12 a massive 30% of the entire country's limited supply of irrigation water.
3:27:18 The ubiquitous consumption of qat in Yemen therefore increases the country's
3:27:22 poverty even further as it makes workers less economically productive,
3:27:25 consumes huge amounts of the country's increasingly scarce water supply,
3:27:29 and crowds out the growing of other crops
3:27:31 that would be more valuable to export in its place.
3:27:34 Meanwhile, while qat chewing is incredibly common in Yemen,
3:27:38 it is severely illegal in other nearby Arab states.
3:27:42 Qat smuggling is punishable by up
3:27:43 to life imprisonment in the United Arab Emirates.
3:27:45 While in Oman, it is even punishable by the death penalty.
3:27:49 Qat chewing is therefore an almost completely absent hobby in Oman.
3:27:52 As are all of qat's associated negative
3:27:54 economic effects that are present in Yemen.
3:27:57 And ultimately, these are the many,
3:27:58 many reasons why Oman is just in a much better place than Yemen is today.
3:28:03 It is the result of decades of diverging policies and leadership in the two
3:28:06 countries that have resulted in wildly different
3:28:09 institutions and realities emerging in both of them.
3:28:11 And as the civil war in Yemen continues
3:28:14 on and as the Houthis continue inviting international
3:28:16 outsiders like the US and UK to intervene
3:28:19 with their attacks on maritime shipping in the region.
3:28:21 The divergence between Oman and Yemen is likely
3:28:24 only going to continue growing even further with time.
3:28:27 It will take a massive shift in Yemen's
3:28:29 leadership and fortunes to bring about true change,
3:28:32 but that doesn't appear to be on the horizon anytime soon.
3:28:38 On the 29th of September 2023, the United States National Security Advisor who
3:28:42 reports directly to the President, Jake Sullivan,
3:28:44 was speaking at the annual Atlantic Festival listing off all
3:28:46 of the accomplishments that the Biden
3:28:47 administration had achieved in the Middle East.
3:28:50 After years of brutal warfare that had resulted in more than 300,000 deaths,
3:28:54 a 19-month-long truce in civil war-torn Yemen was continuing to hold.
3:28:59 The long-running civil war in Syria was
3:29:01 beginning to stabilize and settle down as well.
3:29:04 While Bashar al-Assad, the long-time Syrian dictator,
3:29:07 was finally being welcomed back into the Arab
3:29:09 League again after more than a decade-long suspension over
3:29:12 his handling of the war in Syria that had
3:29:14 claimed the lives of more than half a million people.
3:29:16 Brokered by China, Saudi Arabia and Iran had finally agreed on restoring
3:29:20 their relations in March of 2023 after having been severed six years previously.
3:29:25 Brokered by America,
3:29:26 Saudi Arabia and Israel were also on the cusp of normalizing their relations.
3:29:30 Iran's attacks against American military bases had stopped and there was
3:29:34 a general sense in much of the world that the chronically
3:29:36 violent and unstable Middle East was at last beginning
3:29:39 to calm down and enter into a new era of peace.
3:29:43 Jake Sullivan himself summed up the general foreign policy mood in the region
3:29:46 during that speech on the 29th of September when he said the following.
3:29:50 And the Middle East region is quieter today than it has been in two decades.
3:29:55 Now, challenges remain.
3:29:57 Iran's nuclear weapons program, the tensions between Israelis and Palestinians,
3:30:02 but the amount of time that I have to spend on crisis and conflict in the Middle
3:30:05 East today compared to any of my predecessors
3:30:08 going back to 9/11 is significantly reduced.
3:30:12 It would only take two weeks for those words
3:30:14 to immediately come back and haunt him.
3:30:17 On the 7th of October 2023, various Palestinian militant groups led by Hamas,
3:30:21 the organization who rules in the Gaza Strip,
3:30:24 launched a highly coordinated surprise land,
3:30:26 sea, and air offensive against Israel.
3:30:29 They managed to fire at least 5,000 rockets
3:30:31 against Israel while around 2,500 armed Hamas fighters
3:30:34 managed to break through the wall surrounding Gaza
3:30:37 and infiltrated into multiple villages of Israel itself,
3:30:40 where they massacred at least 1,400 Israelis and other citizens in a single day,
3:30:46 wounded more than 5,000 others,
3:30:48 and took around 200 more as hostages back into Gaza.
3:30:51 The attack represented the single bloodiest day
3:30:54 in the entire history of Israel and the first
3:30:56 time since 1948 that a hostile outside
3:30:59 military power managed to break into Israel proper.
3:31:02 It all came as a profound shock to the state of Israel,
3:31:06 which has since responded with an unprecedented
3:31:08 declaration of war against Hamas in Gaza.
3:31:10 That was followed up by the rapid
3:31:12 mobilization of 300,000 Israeli reserve troops,
3:31:16 the largest and quickest call-up of reserves in Israel's entire history.
3:31:20 The 16-year-long Israeli blockade of Gaza
3:31:23 then subsequently transformed into a complete
3:31:25 and total Israeli siege of Gaza with the Israelis blocking off all electricity,
3:31:30 fuel, telecommunications, water, and medicine from passing into Gaza through any
3:31:34 of their territory by land, sea, or air.
3:31:37 The Israeli Air Force began initiating a punishing
3:31:39 aerial campaign across the Gaza Strip that saw more
3:31:42 than 6,000 Israeli bombs dropped across the territory within
3:31:46 only the first six days of the war beginning,
3:31:49 more than double the amount of ordinance that the United States-led
3:31:52 coalition dropped in an entire month in the war against ISIS.
3:31:56 As the Israeli airstrikes continued on the 13th of October,
3:31:59 Israel ordered that more than 1.1 million
3:32:02 Palestinians immediately evacuate from the northern Gaza Strip
3:32:05 towards the southern Gaza Strip within 24
3:32:08 hours or be potentially considered as enemy combatants.
3:32:11 And then two weeks later on the 27th of October,
3:32:14 the Israeli ground forces launched their full-scale invasion into the northern
3:32:18 Gaza Strip and as of the production of this video,
3:32:21 have Gaza City, the biggest city in Palestine
3:32:24 with a pre-war population of more than 560,000 people, completely encircled.
3:32:29 Once the Israeli ground forces push into Gaza City,
3:32:32 they will likely experience what many
3:32:34 military analysts believe will be nothing less
3:32:36 than the most ferocious urban combat seen in history since the Second World War.
3:32:41 While Israel's stated military objective going forward is to completely
3:32:45 destroy Hamas as an institution and its estimated 40,000 fighters
3:32:49 held up in the Gaza Strip while securing the release
3:32:52 of the more than 200 hostages that they continue to hold.
3:32:55 And in pursuit of those war aims, the Gaza Health Ministry,
3:32:58 run by Hamas, claims that as of the production of this video,
3:33:01 the Israeli airstrikes and ground invasion have already killed nearly
3:33:05 10,000 Palestinians within the Gaza Strip and wounded nearly 25,000 more.
3:33:11 In addition to the estimated 1,000 or so Hamas fighters
3:33:14 who were killed within Israel during the initial October 7th invasion,
3:33:18 a truly catastrophic war has thus once again returned to the Middle East.
3:33:23 And the longer that the war continues,
3:33:26 the longer it risks spreading like a contagion to drag
3:33:29 in multiple other powers into an even greater Middle East-wide war.
3:33:33 The brief era of peace and stability
3:33:35 in the Middle East has once again been shattered.
3:33:37 And in order to understand why this is all suddenly happening right now,
3:33:42 you only have to go back a few years ago to 2017 in order
3:33:46 to understand how the countdown to war
3:33:48 in October of 2023 began originally ticking.
3:33:52 By the time that 2017 rolled around,
3:33:54 the de facto geopolitical situation of the area was roughly the same
3:33:57 as it had been for the past decade ever since 2007.
3:34:00 How it got there in 2007 was a very, very complicated story.
3:34:04 But to cover through it all very quickly,
3:34:06 the British Empire acquired this territory
3:34:08 in the eastern Mediterranean known as Mandatory Palestine after
3:34:11 defeating the Ottoman Empire in World War I
3:34:13 who had ruled the area for centuries beforehand.
3:34:16 Most of the people who lived in the mandate at that time were Arabs,
3:34:19 but Jewish immigration to the land was increasing in scale
3:34:22 as the Zionist movement in Europe sought to flee increasing
3:34:24 anti-Semitism in places like Russia and later Germany by establishing
3:34:28 an independent Jewish state in the land of their ancient ancestors.
3:34:32 The British openly stated that they would support the creation
3:34:34 of a Jewish state in Mandatory
3:34:36 Palestine through the Balfour Declaration of 1917,
3:34:39 though with vague and undetermined borders.
3:34:42 As more Jews increasingly came to Mandatory Palestine,
3:34:44 especially after the Nazis rose to power in Germany,
3:34:47 the Arabs of the territory resented seeing more of their land
3:34:50 getting taken over and so they revolted in 1936.
3:34:54 The British squashed that rebellion,
3:34:55 but they attempted to placate the Arabs by restricting
3:34:58 further Jewish immigration and land purchases within the mandate.
3:35:01 But this policy angered Jewish groups
3:35:03 in the mandate and so Jewish militant groups formed
3:35:05 who launched their own rebellion and violence
3:35:07 between themselves and the Arabs escalated even further.
3:35:10 By 1947, the British decided to give up
3:35:13 and withdraw from Mandatory Palestine altogether and so
3:35:15 they submitted the matter of what to do with it to the United Nations who,
3:35:19 in the wake of the Holocaust in Europe,
3:35:21 faced growing international pressure for the creation
3:35:23 of an independent Jewish state.
3:35:25 They came up with the 1947 UN Partition Plan
3:35:28 which called for partitioning Mandatory Palestine into three separate states,
3:35:33 an independent Jewish state, an independent Palestinian Arab state,
3:35:36 and an internationally run city-state in Jerusalem.
3:35:39 The Arab side in particular resented this proposal at the time
3:35:42 though as they argued it was too heavily biased towards
3:35:45 the Jewish side who were granted most of the mandate's land
3:35:48 despite only representing about 1/3 of the mandate's population at the time.
3:35:52 The Jewish side, meanwhile, had misgivings about the plan as well since
3:35:55 most of the big cities and the actual arable land went to the Arab state
3:35:59 while Jerusalem itself was surrounded by Arab territory.
3:36:02 But nonetheless, the Jewish side ultimately accepted the plan
3:36:05 while virtually the entire Arab world condemned the UN
3:36:07 plan and rejected it and the violence between the Palestinian
3:36:10 Arabs and the Jews in the mandate only worsened.
3:36:13 In 1948, Israel declared its independence from the mandate
3:36:16 based on the 1947 UN Plan boundaries,
3:36:20 but the Palestinians and a coalition of outside
3:36:22 Arab states refused to recognize them and immediately invaded,
3:36:25 determined to overturn the UN Partition Plan that they saw as just
3:36:28 another form of colonialism seeking to steal more of their land.
3:36:32 But Israel ended up winning that war and agreed
3:36:34 on an armistice with the Arab states who attacked them in 1949.
3:36:38 The so-called Green Line marked the military front line between the Israelis
3:36:42 and the Arab states as it stood when that armistice agreement was signed.
3:36:46 And though all of the Arab states at the time were very
3:36:48 clear that the Green Line did not mark any final or agreed-upon borders,
3:36:53 it did mark the de facto border between themselves and Israel nonetheless.
3:36:57 At the same time, the Gaza Strip fell under the control of Egypt,
3:37:01 the West Bank fell under the control of Jordan,
3:37:03 while Jerusalem itself became divided between Israeli control
3:37:06 in the west and Jordanian control in the east.
3:37:08 Israel's own expansion well beyond
3:37:10 their originally accepted 1947 UN Partition Plan
3:37:13 area also put them in control over large swaths of Palestinian Arab lands,
3:37:18 which resulted in about 700,000 of them who either fled or forcibly
3:37:23 pushed out in an event that became known as the Nakba
3:37:26 or the catastrophe with many of them fleeing towards the Gaza
3:37:29 Strip and the West Bank and others towards Jordan, Syria, and Lebanon.
3:37:33 And so an independent Palestinian state was immediately extinguished.
3:37:37 At the same time in 1949, there were approximately 1 million Jews
3:37:41 of Mizrahi and Sephardi ancestry who lived
3:37:44 all across the Muslim world as their ancestors had for thousands of years.
3:37:48 But over the decades that followed as Israel established itself further,
3:37:51 the vast majority of them were either forcibly expelled,
3:37:54 fled, or voluntarily migrated away in a mass Jewish
3:37:57 exodus away from the Muslim world and largely towards Israel.
3:38:01 As a result, fewer than 30,000 Jews continue to live in the Muslim world today,
3:38:06 down from around a million in 1948.
3:38:09 Today, these Middle Eastern and North African
3:38:11 Jews who left and their descendants comprise more
3:38:13 than 50% of the Israeli Jewish population
3:38:17 and represent the country's single largest ethnic group today.
3:38:20 While another 32% of the Israeli Jewish population
3:38:22 are of Ashkenazi ancestry from Eastern and Central Europe,
3:38:25 who represent the second largest group.
3:38:28 Ever since that time,
3:38:29 both the Palestinians and the Israelis have struggled defining
3:38:33 where one of their territories begins and the other ends
3:38:36 within the overall territory of the former British Mandate
3:38:39 and have with achieving universal recognition by the outside world.
3:38:43 Israel's mostly internationally recognized boundaries today consist
3:38:47 of that so-called green line dating back to 1949.
3:38:50 But there were also the additional
3:38:52 territories that came under Israel's control during
3:38:54 the later Six-Day War of 1967 that lay beyond the 1949 Armistice Green Line.
3:38:59 Territories that are usually referred to as either
3:39:01 the post-1967 territories or the Israeli-occupied territories.
3:39:06 They include the Sinai Peninsula seized from Egypt,
3:39:08 the Palestinian-inhabited territories that Israel seized from Egypt and Jordan,
3:39:11 the Gaza Strip, the West Bank, and East Jerusalem,
3:39:14 and the Golan Heights that were seized from Syria.
3:39:16 After Israel seized all of these territories back in 1967,
3:39:19 the United Nations Security Council passed Resolution 242,
3:39:23 which effectively considered them all as occupied
3:39:25 territories that the Israelis should immediately withdraw from.
3:39:28 While the Arab League convened at Khartoum in Sudan,
3:39:31 where they proclaimed the 1967 Khartoum Resolution,
3:39:34 explicitly laying out their foreign policy towards Israel going forward.
3:39:38 No peace with Israel, no recognition with Israel,
3:39:41 and no negotiations with Israel.
3:39:43 A policy that became known as the Arab world's three nos,
3:39:47 and the foundation upon which no Arab state would
3:39:49 recognize Israel's existence in any context or shape for decades.
3:39:53 Over the decades that followed from 1967,
3:39:56 Israel treated each of their post-1967 acquired territories very differently.
3:40:00 Israel agreed to return the Sinai Peninsula back to Egypt in 1979 in exchange
3:40:04 for a formal peace treaty with Egypt
3:40:06 and Egyptian recognition of Israel's right to exist.
3:40:09 Marking the first time that an Arab state would ever do such a thing,
3:40:12 and the first time that an Arab state would violate the three
3:40:15 nos agreed upon by the Arab League back in the 1967 Khartoum Resolution.
3:40:20 Israel then unilaterally decided to annex all of East Jerusalem in 1980
3:40:24 and subsequently proclaimed a unified Jerusalem as its own capital city.
3:40:28 Something that the United Nations would immediately
3:40:30 declare as legally null and void under
3:40:33 international law with Resolution 478 that considered
3:40:36 East Jerusalem to still be an Israeli-occupied territory,
3:40:40 and which also called upon all UN member states
3:40:42 to withdraw their embassies from Jerusalem in the aftermath,
3:40:45 which everybody eventually agreed to do.
3:40:47 By the time 2017 rolled around,
3:40:49 there wasn't a single other country in the world outside of Israel who
3:40:52 recognized Israel's annexation of East Jerusalem
3:40:54 or Jerusalem as the sole capital of Israel.
3:40:57 Israel also decided to unilaterally annex
3:40:59 the Golan Heights outright back in 1981, an action that the United Nations
3:41:03 similarly declared under the passing of Resolution
3:41:05 497 immediately afterwards as null
3:41:08 and void and without international legal effect.
3:41:11 The Golan Heights would continue to be universally recognized
3:41:13 by the entire international community
3:41:15 as Israeli-occupied territory of Syria for decades,
3:41:18 and this also continued to remain true by 2017.
3:41:22 That left the West Bank and the Gaza Strip,
3:41:24 which Israel has also treated very differently
3:41:26 from all of the other post-1967 territories.
3:41:29 Egypt renounced its claim to the Gaza Strip
3:41:31 in the peace treaty with Israel in 1978,
3:41:33 while Jordan formally renounced its claims to the West
3:41:35 Bank and East Jerusalem a decade later in 1988
3:41:38 before becoming the second Arab state to make
3:41:40 peace with Israel and recognize Israel's existence in 1994.
3:41:44 Those renunciations by Egypt and Jordan to the Gaza Strip,
3:41:46 the West Bank, and East Jerusalem,
3:41:48 and Israel's continued internationally unrecognized occupation
3:41:51 of all of them left them each
3:41:52 effectively as Palestinian-inhabited territories trapped in a state
3:41:55 of permanent legal limbo for decades.
3:41:58 As thousands of Israeli settlers began moving into all of them
3:42:01 and displacing and angering the Palestinians who lived within them even further.
3:42:05 After decades of violence between the Israeli authorities
3:42:07 and the settlers on one side and the Palestinians
3:42:09 on the other in both the West Bank and East Jerusalem and the Gaza Strip,
3:42:13 the Israelis and the Palestinians eventually agreed
3:42:15 upon the Oslo Accords of 1993 and 1995,
3:42:18 which established the Palestinian Authority as an interim
3:42:21 Palestinian government body that was eventually
3:42:23 assumed would one day take over full authority in the entire occupied West Bank,
3:42:28 East [music] Jerusalem,
3:42:29 and the Gaza Strip as the eventually fully independent state of Palestine.
3:42:33 But in the interim until then,
3:42:35 the Israeli and Palestinian sides agreed on what originally was
3:42:38 supposed to only be a temporary division of the West Bank
3:42:41 [music] into three distinctly different areas with varying levels of control
3:42:45 between the Palestinian Authority and the Israeli military and state.
3:42:49 Area A would be the territories assigned entirely
3:42:51 to the civil and security administration run by the Palestinian Authority.
3:42:55 Area B would be the territories assigned to only
3:42:57 the civil administration run by the Palestinian Authority,
3:43:00 but with a security administration that would
3:43:02 continue to be run by the Israelis.
3:43:04 And then, there was also Area C,
3:43:06 which would continue to be entirely run by both the Israeli civil
3:43:10 and military authorities without any influence
3:43:13 from the Palestinian Authority at all,
3:43:14 which effectively placed Area C under the continued de facto control of Israel.
3:43:19 Area C consists of approximately 61% of the West Bank's total territory and is
3:43:24 presently the home of all of Israel's settlements and settlers in the West Bank,
3:43:27 wedged all in between the Palestinian Authority's Area A and Area B,
3:43:31 and ringed all around Jerusalem, where more than 99% of all the land is
3:43:35 either strictly off-limits or heavily restricted for Palestinians to access.
3:43:40 Area C is also completely contiguous in area,
3:43:43 while the Palestinian Authority's administered territories in Areas A and B are
3:43:47 not contiguous and divided between 165
3:43:50 separate enclaves in between the contiguous Israeli-administered
3:43:53 Area C that is chock-full of Israeli settlements in a situation that has
3:43:57 sometimes been referred to as the Palestinian Archipelago of the West Bank,
3:44:02 and a system that has been very frequently compared to the system
3:44:05 of apartheid that white-ruled South Africa
3:44:08 enforced upon their black population until 1994.
3:44:12 It was initially intended by the Oslo Accords of 1995 that all of Area
3:44:16 C would be gradually transferred by the Israelis
3:44:18 over to the Palestinian Authority's administration.
3:44:21 But to date, that has never ended up happening.
3:44:24 Within 1 week of the Oslo II Accord being signed on the 28th of September, 1995,
3:44:29 that established the system of Areas A and B
3:44:31 in the West Bank and granted the Palestinian Authority limited control,
3:44:35 the Israeli Prime Minister who signed them, Yitzhak Rabin,
3:44:38 was assassinated by an Israeli right-wing extremist who was
3:44:41 opposed to the concept of any independent Palestinian entity.
3:44:44 And the next election that came the following year in 1996 brought
3:44:47 Benjamin Netanyahu into the office of Israel's
3:44:49 Prime Minister for the first time, which resulted in a stalling of any
3:44:53 further negotiations between the Palestinian Authority and Israel.
3:44:56 The supposedly temporary divisions within the West Bank agreed upon in 1995
3:45:00 immediately before Yitzhak Rabin's assassination
3:45:03 have remained indefinite ever [music] since,
3:45:05 and the pace of Israeli settlers moving into Area C has only continued.
3:45:10 At the current date in 2023, it's estimated that around 230,000 Israeli settlers
3:45:15 live in the post-1967 territory of East Jerusalem,
3:45:18 while another 470,000 Israeli settlers live within Area C of the West
3:45:23 Bank across at least 132 separate
3:45:26 settlements and more than 140 separate outposts,
3:45:29 where they have full civil and political
3:45:31 rights like every other Israeli citizen does,
3:45:33 and representing a fourfold increase in Israeli settlers in the West
3:45:37 Bank since the Oslo Accords were initially signed in 1995.
3:45:42 This is in comparison to around 300,000 Palestinians who also
3:45:46 live within Area C and are subject to Israeli military rule.
3:45:49 Another roughly 2.8 million Palestinians who
3:45:52 live confined within the Palestinian Archipelago of Areas A and B under
3:45:56 the Palestinian Authority's administration in the West Bank.
3:45:58 And another 362,000 Palestinians who
3:46:02 live within the Israeli-annexed East Jerusalem.
3:46:04 All of whom have almost zero say over how they are actually governed.
3:46:09 Israel's continued control over Area C in the West Bank
3:46:11 for decades and hundreds of thousands of settlers that they have allowed
3:46:14 to move into the territory since the 1990s have been frequently
3:46:19 labeled as a violation of Article 49 of the Fourth Geneva Convention,
3:46:23 which plainly states that, quote,
3:46:25 "The occupying power shall not deport or transfer parts of its
3:46:29 own civilian population into the territory that it occupies." In this case,
3:46:33 being the West Bank.
3:46:35 Meanwhile, by 2005, Israel maintained about 8,000 settlers
3:46:38 across 21 different settlements in the Gaza Strip.
3:46:41 But by then, the situation was becoming untenable.
3:46:44 At only about twice the size of Washington, D.C.,
3:46:46 the Gaza Strip was geographically much smaller than the West Bank was.
3:46:50 But with a population of 1.4 million Palestinians back then,
3:46:54 it was also substantially more densely populated
3:46:57 and urbanized than the West Bank was as well.
3:46:59 The high cost associated with defending only a few thousand settlers
3:47:03 in this crowded urbanized territory was becoming too costly for Israel to bear.
3:47:07 And so, in 2005, they decided
3:47:09 to unilaterally withdraw from the Gaza Strip altogether.
3:47:12 All of the 21 Israeli settlements inside of it were destroyed.
3:47:15 All 8,000 Israeli settlers within Gaza
3:47:17 were either evacuated or forcibly withdrawn,
3:47:20 while the military withdrew as well.
3:47:21 And for the first time, the entirety of the Gaza Strip's land
3:47:24 territory was passed over to the Palestinian Authority.
3:47:27 Although Israel continued maintaining control over
3:47:29 virtually all of Gaza's land crossings
3:47:32 with a fence they constructed around the entire territory back in 1994,
3:47:35 along with continued control over all of Gaza's airspace that included Israel's
3:47:39 destruction of the only airport in the Gaza Strip back in 2002.
3:47:43 And then, finally, came the Palestinian
3:47:45 Legislative Elections of January 2006 shortly afterwards,
3:47:48 in which the political party known
3:47:50 as Hamas achieved an unexpectedly decisive victory.
3:47:53 Before then, the Palestinian Authority had been
3:47:55 always controlled and dominated by the secular,
3:47:58 socialist, and Palestinian Arab nationalist party known as Fatah,
3:48:01 who had initially seek Israel's total destruction
3:48:04 and the establishment of a secular Palestinian
3:48:06 Arab socialist state over the entirety
3:48:08 of the former British Mandate area in its place.
3:48:11 But it subsequently made peace with Israel
3:48:13 during the Oslo Accords and then restricted
3:48:14 their ambitions to establishing an independent Palestinian
3:48:17 state limited only to the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip instead.
3:48:21 By contrast, Hamas was a Sunni Islamist
3:48:24 and Palestinian nationalist party who argued that Fatah had
3:48:27 become too complacent and too cooperative with Israel
3:48:30 and had abandoned the true original Palestinian cause.
3:48:33 Hamas continued to be fully committed to Israel's total destruction,
3:48:37 the same way that Fatah had used to be prior to the Oslo Accords.
3:48:40 And separately from Fatah, Hamas advocated for the eventual establishment
3:48:44 of a Sunni Islamist Palestinian state across
3:48:46 the entirety of the former British Mandate
3:48:48 area once Israel had been completely destroyed.
3:48:51 After a brief civil war within
3:48:53 the Palestinian Authority between Hamas and Fatah,
3:48:55 Hamas emerged victorious within the Gaza Strip and pushed
3:48:58 Fatah out completely by the middle of 2007, which has ever since led
3:49:02 to a continuous division within the Palestinian leadership.
3:49:05 The Sunni Islamists of Hamas based in the Gaza Strip,
3:49:08 who are fully dedicated to Israel's total
3:49:10 destruction and the eventual establishment of a Sunni
3:49:13 Islamic state across the entirety of the former British Mandate in its place,
3:49:17 and the secular, socialist,
3:49:18 and nationalist Fatah based in the Palestinian archipelago of the West Bank,
3:49:22 willing to work together with Israel to eventually establish an independent
3:49:26 Palestinian state based on the entirety of the West Bank,
3:49:29 East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip,
3:49:31 while recognizing Israel's own borders based on the 1949 Armistice Green Line.
3:49:36 The same way that Egypt and Jordan do.
3:49:38 But Israel responded to Hamas's uncompromising takeover of the Gaza
3:49:42 Strip in 2007 by initiating a complete land, air,
3:49:45 and sea blockade over the territory that harshly limited
3:49:48 the ability of Palestinians or goods to exit or enter.
3:49:51 A blockade that Gaza's other neighbor, Egypt,
3:49:54 agreed to fully participate in on their side of the border as well.
3:49:57 The 1994 era fence surrounding Gaza by land across Israel and Egypt
3:50:01 was then extensively upgraded into the modern system of high walls,
3:50:05 barbed wire, motion sensors, and even robotic machine guns.
3:50:08 While the Israeli Navy enforced a maritime
3:50:10 no-go zone around the Gaza Strip by sea, while the Israeli Air Force enforced
3:50:14 a no-fly zone over the Gaza Strip's airspace.
3:50:17 Israel's stated aims of enforcing the blockade over
3:50:19 the Gaza Strip were to restrict the ability
3:50:21 of the Hamas-led government inside from being able
3:50:23 to import weapons from abroad to use against Israel,
3:50:26 and to economically strangle the Hamas-led government and apply pressures
3:50:30 on it to either moderate its position or face a slow,
3:50:33 grinding collapse with a permanent scarcity of resources and supplies,
3:50:37 generating unrest amongst the Palestinians they were elected to govern.
3:50:41 But for the past 16 years that have followed this blockade of Gaza beginning,
3:50:45 Hamas has neither moderated its position nor collapsed from power.
3:50:49 While frequent fighting has consistently erupted
3:50:51 between them and Israel ever since.
3:50:53 And so, the joint Israeli-Egyptian blockade has continued on without a pause
3:50:57 now for the past 16 years that have followed ever since 2007.
3:51:01 A situation that has been frequently labeled
3:51:03 as one of the 21st century's vastest humanitarian catastrophes.
3:51:08 Israel's 16-year ongoing blockade of Gaza has
3:51:11 been frequently labeled by human rights advocates
3:51:13 as a form of collective punishment applied
3:51:15 to everyone who lives within the Gaza Strip.
3:51:18 While Israel has always counter-maintained that the policy is necessary
3:51:21 to protect their own citizens from attacks coming from Hamas.
3:51:24 Notably, Gaza's population has increased from about 1.4 million people when
3:51:29 the blockade began in 2007 to about 2.2 million people today in 2023.
3:51:34 Meaning that about 800,000 of the Palestinians within the Gaza Strip,
3:51:39 or about 40% of the entire population right now,
3:51:42 are currently children 16 years or younger who have been
3:51:46 born during this total blockade and who have literally never
3:51:49 known anything other than life confined within the walls enforced
3:51:53 by the Israeli military and stuck
3:51:55 under Hamas's continued uncompromising leadership.
3:51:59 And all of the accompanying poverty, hunger, resource scarcity,
3:52:02 and occasional ferocious violence that has come with it.
3:52:06 At only about twice the size of Washington, D.C.,
3:52:08 the Gaza Strip has since become one of the most
3:52:10 crowded and densely populated places anywhere in the entire world.
3:52:15 And surrounded by high walls and a naval blockade
3:52:17 on all sides and an enforced no-fly zone above it,
3:52:21 where hardly anyone is ever allowed to leave for any reason at all.
3:52:25 It is also frequently been referred to ever since
3:52:27 as constituting nothing less than the world's largest open-air prison,
3:52:31 wherein the highest ambitions for any of the millions
3:52:34 of people within the prison to have aspired towards
3:52:37 for the past 16 years have been limited only
3:52:40 to either escaping from it or becoming the prison's new warden.
3:52:44 This was the extremely complicated geopolitical state that Israel
3:52:47 and Palestine both found themselves in between 2007 and 2017,
3:52:52 with Israel effectively managing its post-1967 acquired and occupied
3:52:56 territories with a suffocating blockade enforced around the Gaza Strip,
3:52:59 increasing the numbers of its settlers in Area C of the West Bank,
3:53:03 accompanied by frequent talks of annexing parts or all of it directly,
3:53:06 prior outright annexations of East Jerusalem and the Golan Heights
3:53:09 that nobody else in the outside world recognized as being legitimate.
3:53:13 At the same time, Israel was maintaining international recognition based on its
3:53:17 1949 Green Line Armistice borders with most of the world's other countries.
3:53:21 Though with very notable exceptions continuing
3:53:24 in the Arab and Muslim worlds who had
3:53:25 largely never recognized Israel's existence ever since
3:53:28 the end of the British Mandate in 1948,
3:53:31 along with several anti-colonial or anti-Western
3:53:34 socialist states in North Korea, Cuba, and Venezuela.
3:53:37 By 2017, the only Arab states that had ever recognized Israel's
3:53:40 existence and made peace were Egypt in 1980 and Jordan in 1994,
3:53:45 with all the others continuing to hold ranks in solidarity
3:53:48 with the Palestinians and the three no's of the 1967 Khartoum Resolution.
3:53:53 The State of Palestine, meanwhile, based on its claims to the entire West Bank,
3:53:57 East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip from the Oslo Accords in 1993 and 1995,
3:54:02 and represented by the Fatah-led Palestinian Authority,
3:54:05 was recognized by most of the outside world as well and was
3:54:07 granted the status of a permanent observer at the United Nations in 2012.
3:54:12 Though very notably lacked any official
3:54:14 recognition across most of the Western world,
3:54:16 including none from Israel, the United States,
3:54:19 Canada, Australia, Japan, and most of Western Europe.
3:54:22 And despite its continued de jure claims to sovereignty in the entire West Bank,
3:54:26 East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip,
3:54:28 the Palestinian Authority really only maintained de facto
3:54:31 authority over the Palestinian archipelago within the West Bank,
3:54:35 with the rest of the West Bank in Area
3:54:36 C under continued Israeli colonial and military rule.
3:54:39 East Jerusalem being annexed directly into Israel itself,
3:54:43 and the Gaza Strip under the control of its rival Hamas government,
3:54:46 completely blockaded by the Israelis and Egyptians
3:54:49 with frequent violence erupting all around it.
3:54:51 This was the general situation that remained more
3:54:54 or less the same between 2007 and 2017,
3:54:58 until things finally started rapidly changing
3:55:01 even further in favor of the Israelis
3:55:03 after Donald Trump assumed the American presidency in January of 2017.
3:55:08 Within his first year of assuming office in December of 2017,
3:55:11 the Trump administration extended official US recognition
3:55:14 of Jerusalem as the capital city of Israel,
3:55:16 which effectively extended formal US recognition to Israel's
3:55:19 unilateral annexation of East Jerusalem as well.
3:55:22 An action that had previously gone unrecognized
3:55:24 by the entire international community since 1980.
3:55:27 The day after the US announcement was made,
3:55:30 the UN Security Council called for an emergency meeting where
3:55:32 14 out of the 15 members universally condemned the American decision,
3:55:37 but it was vetoed and overturned by the sole remaining member of the council,
3:55:41 the United States itself.
3:55:43 The vast majority of the world's leaders sharply
3:55:45 condemned the American decision because it effectively meant
3:55:48 that the United States would never recognize East Jerusalem
3:55:51 as being a part of any future independent Palestinian state.
3:55:55 To date, only a handful of other countries have followed the Americans'
3:55:58 lead in recognizing a unified Jerusalem as being exclusively Israel's capital.
3:56:03 Guatemala and Honduras,
3:56:05 and the only partially recognized state of Kosovo being the only other ones.
3:56:09 Hamas, still blockaded within the Gaza Strip,
3:56:12 immediately seized on the opportunity to demand a new Palestinian Intifada,
3:56:16 or uprising, be launched against the Israelis
3:56:18 in response to the American decision.
3:56:20 On the 14th of May, 2018,
3:56:22 the United States officially transferred its embassy to Israel
3:56:25 from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem with the new embassy's grand opening,
3:56:29 which sparked mass protests organized by Hamas within the Gaza
3:56:32 Strip near to the Israeli border wall that went
3:56:34 on for every single Friday for nearly an entire
3:56:38 year and a half until the end of 2019
3:56:40 that tens of thousands of Palestinians participated in and which
3:56:44 the Israeli Defense Forces responded to harshly with frequent
3:56:48 tear gas and sniper fire that resulted in the deaths
3:56:51 of at least 223 Palestinians and more than 9,200 injuries.
3:56:56 And in the same month in America recognized Jerusalem as Israel's capital,
3:57:00 the Netanyahu administration's ruling Likud party
3:57:03 in Israel passed a resolution that instructed Israeli
3:57:05 legislators to finally begin pursuing the full
3:57:08 unilateral annexation of the West Bank next.
3:57:11 An action that Israel had long resisted formally doing ever since 1967,
3:57:16 largely out of the fear of what
3:57:17 the international backlash towards them would end up being.
3:57:21 Then, after becoming the first outside country to recognize
3:57:23 Jerusalem as the capital of Israel in 2017, the United States under the Trump
3:57:27 administration chose to officially recognize the 1981
3:57:30 era Israeli annexation of the Golan Heights next in March of 2019,
3:57:35 making the United States the first and so far only other country
3:57:38 besides Israel itself to recognize the Golan
3:57:41 Heights as fully sovereign Israeli territory,
3:57:44 rather than a Syrian territory under the occupation of Israel.
3:57:48 These American recognitions of Israel's sovereignty
3:57:50 over East Jerusalem and the Golan Heights were each continued forward
3:57:54 with the Biden administration after 2021 as well,
3:57:57 and it has since become a policy that is widely viewed by countries all
3:58:00 around the world as an act of enormous hypocrisy on the part of Washington
3:58:05 as America has recognized Israel's unilateral annexations
3:58:08 of territories that the entire rest of the world
3:58:10 considers to be occupied in which America
3:58:12 itself considered to be occupied for decades.
3:58:15 While America simultaneously has fiercely
3:58:18 rejected Russia's unilateral annexations of territories
3:58:21 in Ukraine that are also considered to be occupied like Crimea,
3:58:24 Kherson, Zaporizhzhia, Donetsk, and Luhansk.
3:58:27 It has since made it appear
3:58:29 to many outside observers that America isn't actually
3:58:31 serious about upholding the norms of international
3:58:34 law but is only interested in selectively applying it to its rivals like Russia
3:58:38 when they occupy and annex territories while
3:58:40 ignoring it for their friends and allies
3:58:42 like Israel when they occupy and annex territories.
3:58:45 Then it was in the following year during a White House press
3:58:48 conference on the 28th of January 2020 when the Trump administration alongside
3:58:52 the Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu revealed what they each referred
3:58:55 to as the deal of the century better known as the Trump peace plan.
3:59:00 The Trump administration's political proposal to finally
3:59:03 resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict once and for all.
3:59:06 The plan envisioned an independent Palestinian state composed only
3:59:10 of various separated enclaves within the West Bank that would continue
3:59:13 to be divided and completely surrounded by significantly expanded Israeli
3:59:18 territory well beyond the mostly
3:59:20 internationally recognized 1949 Armistice Green Line.
3:59:23 The plan also completely rejected a Palestinian
3:59:26 capital based in East Jerusalem proper
3:59:28 which the Trump administration had effectively recognized
3:59:31 as fully Israeli territory back in 2017.
3:59:34 Instead, the plan proposed that a new Palestinian capital would be exiled
3:59:39 to the outskirts of Jerusalem and be separated from Jerusalem proper and all
3:59:42 of Jerusalem's holy sites by the Israeli constructed West Bank wall
3:59:47 that now fully encloses the city from the rest of the West Bank.
3:59:50 The plan even further demanded
3:59:51 that these limited concessions allotted to a future
3:59:54 independent Palestinian state would only be accepted
3:59:57 by Israel and the United States if the Palestinian agreed to a status
4:00:01 of total demilitarization and disarmament and agreed
4:00:04 to completely abandon all international legal action
4:00:07 against Israel and the United States as well.
4:00:10 And then even further during the press conference
4:00:12 that was announcing the plan in the White House,
4:00:14 Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli Prime Minister,
4:00:17 declared that the Israeli government would be immediately annexing the entire
4:00:21 Jordan Valley and all of the Israeli settlements within the West Bank.
4:00:25 This would have effectively resulted in an Israeli annexation of 30%
4:00:30 of the West Bank's territory and the third formal unilateral annexation
4:00:34 of the Israelis in the post-1967 territories that virtually the entire
4:00:38 world beyond the United States and Israel consider to be occupied territories.
4:00:43 The 2020 Trump peace plan was
4:00:44 ultimately resoundingly rejected by virtually all Palestinians
4:00:48 and even many Israelis alike along with most of the rest of the world.
4:00:52 Joe Biden and every other leading
4:00:54 Democratic 2020 presidential candidate labeled the plan
4:00:57 as a smoke screen for the Israeli annexation of the occupied West Bank.
4:01:01 The UN rejected the plan and reaffirmed its
4:01:03 own commitment to a two-state solution within the former
4:01:06 mandatory Palestine based on Israel's pre-1967 Green Line borders
4:01:10 and a Palestinian state in the entire West Bank,
4:01:13 East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip.
4:01:16 Mahmoud Abbas, the long-time undemocratic leader of the Fatah party
4:01:20 and the Palestinian Authority since he won his only election in 2005,
4:01:24 showed a map of the Trump peace plan at the United Nations
4:01:26 Security Council that he famously described
4:01:29 as turning Palestine into Swiss cheese.
4:01:32 And naturally both his own government in the Palestinian
4:01:34 archipelago of the West Bank and his rival
4:01:36 Hamas government in the Gaza Strip rejected the plan
4:01:39 as being too heavily biased towards the Israeli side.
4:01:42 Moreover, even the Israelis Yesha Council,
4:01:45 an umbrella organization representing the hundreds of thousands
4:01:48 of Israeli Jewish settlers in the West Bank,
4:01:50 rejected the Trump peace plan as well
4:01:52 on the simple basis that it granted the Palestinians
4:01:55 an independent state at all which they were
4:01:57 completely opposed to even in this extremely limited context.
4:02:02 But as it became clear that the 2020
4:02:03 Trump plan defining an enlarged Israeli state
4:02:06 and a shrunken Palestinian state would never be
4:02:08 implemented over the vast disagreements on all sides involved,
4:02:11 the Trump administration began making significant advances
4:02:14 for Israel on the diplomatic front anyway.
4:02:16 Behind the scenes, the Trump administration had been
4:02:18 mediating negotiations between Israel and the United Arab
4:02:21 Emirates that suddenly resulted in a shocking joint
4:02:24 statement between them on the 13th of August 2020.
4:02:27 Israel agreed that they would indefinitely suspend
4:02:30 all of their plans for annexing parts
4:02:31 of the West Bank like the Jordan Valley and their settlements in area C while
4:02:35 in exchange the United Arab Emirates agreed
4:02:37 to fully normalize their relations with Israel
4:02:40 with the first ever direct commercial flights launching
4:02:43 between them by the end of the month.
4:02:44 It was a shocking announcement because it represented only the third
4:02:48 time in history since the British mandate of Palestine expired in 1948
4:02:52 that an Arab state had ever recognized Israel after Egypt had done
4:02:56 so back in 1980 and after Jordan had done so in 1994.
4:03:00 From 1994 onwards for the next quarter of a century none
4:03:04 of the rest of the Arabs would officially break rank and make peace
4:03:07 with Israel sticking on paper to the 1967 three no's agreement that they
4:03:11 had all agreed upon back in Khartoum all that long time ago.
4:03:16 But now all of a sudden in the summer of 2020 seemingly out of nowhere,
4:03:20 the United Arab Emirates had become the third Arab
4:03:22 state overall and the first Persian Gulf state to openly
4:03:26 violate the 1967 Khartoum Resolution and make peace with Israel
4:03:31 without the final status of the Palestinians being resolved first.
4:03:35 And it would be far from the last to do so.
4:03:38 In a series of subsequent negotiations that came
4:03:39 to be known overall as the Abraham Accords,
4:03:42 the Trump administration was able to almost
4:03:43 immediately convince Bahrain after the United Arab Emirates
4:03:47 to become the fourth Arab state to fully
4:03:49 normalize their relations with Israel in September of 2020.
4:03:52 Then just 3 months after that in December
4:03:54 of 2020 during the closing days of the Trump administration,
4:03:57 the United States was able to convince Morocco to become the fifth
4:04:00 Arab state to fully normalize their relations with Israel as well.
4:04:03 That one was accomplished by Washington offering
4:04:06 that in exchange for Morocco recognizing Israel the United
4:04:09 States would extend its formal recognition to Morocco's
4:04:12 unilateral annexation of the disputed territory of Western Sahara,
4:04:16 a territory that Morocco had previously unilaterally declared to completely
4:04:19 annex as their so-called southern provinces all the way
4:04:23 back in the late 1970s but which remained unrecognized
4:04:26 by anyone else in the outside world for decades afterwards.
4:04:30 [music] With the United Nations having always
4:04:31 considered the Moroccan annexation like all other
4:04:33 unilateral annexations that have come following World
4:04:36 War II to be legally null and void.
4:04:39 So in exchange for Morocco's recognition of Israel then,
4:04:42 the United States became the first country in the world
4:04:44 to ever recognize Morocco's unilateral annexation of Western Sahara just as it
4:04:49 had become the first country to ever recognize Israel's unilateral annexation
4:04:52 of the Golan Heights and East Jerusalem in the couple years beforehand.
4:04:55 All of which would ultimately provide even
4:04:57 more hefty diplomatic ammunition to countries like Russia
4:05:01 to blast the United States with later
4:05:03 on over Washington's hypocrisy regarding its selective applications
4:05:07 of international law approving unilateral annexations of UN-recognized
4:05:11 occupied territories whenever Israel and now also
4:05:14 Morocco do it but fiercely rejecting it
4:05:17 whenever Russia does the same thing in Ukraine.
4:05:19 Three years later in 2023,
4:05:21 Israel would return the favor granted by Morocco by becoming the second state
4:05:25 in the outside world to formally recognize
4:05:27 Morocco's annexation of Western Sahara as well.
4:05:30 And then on January 6th, 2021 on the very same day that a mob
4:05:34 of pro-Trump supporters stormed the American
4:05:36 Capitol Building in Washington, D.C., another event of monumental geopolitical
4:05:41 importance was simultaneously taking place over
4:05:44 on the other side of the world within the symbolic capital city of Sudan,
4:05:48 Khartoum, the very location from which the Arab League had previously
4:05:52 proclaimed its three no's policy towards Israel more than 53 years previously.
4:05:58 That day on January 6th in that precise symbolic location,
4:06:02 the Sudanese government became the next Arab
4:06:04 government to formally sign on to the Abraham
4:06:06 Accords as well which initiated the process
4:06:09 of full Sudanese normalization with Israel as well.
4:06:12 In order to convince them, the Trump administration had agreed to remove Sudan
4:06:16 from America's state sponsor of terrorism list and provided
4:06:19 them with a $1.2 billion loan to help
4:06:22 clear Sudan's government debt to the World Bank.
4:06:24 And just like that, the Trump administration was able to increase
4:06:27 the pace of Israel's recognition in the Arab world from only two
4:06:31 across 72 years of history to four more in fewer than
4:06:35 5 months bringing the total up to six of them by 2021.
4:06:39 And all without the underlying issue of Palestinian statehood being resolved
4:06:43 first that had long prevented Israel's recognition by any of the Arabs.
4:06:48 By the time the Biden administration assumed office in Washington,
4:06:50 it was seeming as if Israel was indeed going to be
4:06:53 able to both eat their cake and still have it, too.
4:06:57 The Palestinians themselves were fully contained, divided,
4:06:59 and scattered with an uncompromising Hamas-led government still
4:07:03 dedicated to Israel's total destruction blockaded in Gaza,
4:07:06 a mostly cooperative and collaborating Fatah-led government isolated and divided
4:07:10 across areas A and B of the West Bank,
4:07:13 several million more completely removed Palestinian
4:07:15 refugees scattered across Jordan, Syria, and Lebanon,
4:07:18 and about 1.6 million Palestinian citizens of Israel
4:07:21 itself who comprised a minority of only about 20%
4:07:24 of Israel's citizen population despite Palestinians' total population
4:07:28 across all of the former mandatory Palestine area today
4:07:31 remaining a slight majority at about 51%
4:07:34 of the overall population compared to the Jews at about
4:07:37 47% to say nothing of the several million additional
4:07:41 Palestinian refugees beyond the former mandatory Palestine in Jordan,
4:07:45 Syria, Saudi Arabia, Qatar,
4:07:47 and Lebanon who have consistently argued for a right of return
4:07:50 to the area of the former British mandate that they or their ancestors
4:07:54 fled or were forced out from, a right that represents a major
4:07:57 component of Israeli-Palestinian negotiations that has
4:08:00 always been refused by the Israeli side.
4:08:02 From the Palestinian perspective, if more and more outside Arab
4:08:06 states continue normalizing their ties with Israel,
4:08:08 despite the Palestinians dire situation on statehood,
4:08:12 it could eventually have reached a tipping point where
4:08:14 the Israeli government would eventually feel secure enough in a region
4:08:17 with fewer overtly hostile enemies to finally begin
4:08:21 the process of formally annexing territories in the West Bank,
4:08:24 like the Jordan Valley and their numerous settlements,
4:08:27 if not the entire West Bank altogether.
4:08:30 Something that has long been a goal
4:08:31 of numerous right-wing and far-right Israeli parties for decades,
4:08:35 but which has so far always been resisted out of fears
4:08:37 of what the international response towards them would end up being.
4:08:41 But if the fear of a harsh international response was removed,
4:08:44 then what other deterrent would there have ever been?
4:08:47 For the incoming Biden administration in 2021,
4:08:50 the next goal for continuing on the Abraham Accords even
4:08:53 further and achieving the biggest prize of all would be
4:08:55 convincing the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia to become the next
4:08:58 Arab country to normalize its relations with Israel as well.
4:09:02 By this point in time, to most of the monarchist Gulf Arab states,
4:09:05 Israel was already naturally starting to be
4:09:07 viewed as less of an outright hostile enemy
4:09:09 and more of a potential ally that they
4:09:11 could maybe cooperate and do business with.
4:09:14 The theocratic Islamic Republic in Iran, ruled by the Ayatollahs,
4:09:18 and their ideology of radical Shiite Islamic revolution,
4:09:21 had long espoused a foreign policy that advocated for the eventual unification
4:09:26 of the entire Muslim world beneath
4:09:28 the authority of their own Shia dominated clergy,
4:09:31 which included three initial objectives to accomplish
4:09:34 first in very specific orders of importance.
4:09:37 Number one, destroy and remove all American
4:09:39 and Western influence in the Islamic world
4:09:41 that was perceived as a lasting vestige
4:09:43 of the age of colonialism and corruptive.
4:09:46 Number two, completely destroy the state
4:09:48 of Israel that is similarly viewed by Iran's
4:09:50 regime as a foreign Western colonial power
4:09:53 occupying lands that are historically and rightfully Islamic.
4:09:56 And number three, spread the Islamic revolution and the authority
4:09:59 of Iran's Shiite clergy to the rest of the Muslim world,
4:10:03 which necessitates overthrowing and toppling all of the various
4:10:06 monarchies that exist across the Muslim world
4:10:08 that Iran's clergy deemed to be heretical and contradictory
4:10:12 to where authority within Islamic states should truly lie,
4:10:16 with the clergy and not with the nobility.
4:10:18 Thus, ever since the Islamic revolution of 1979,
4:10:22 Iran has been consistently opposed to Israel's
4:10:24 entire existence and to the existence
4:10:27 of the Sunni Muslim monarchist regimes reigning in Saudi Arabia,
4:10:31 the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, and Jordan.
4:10:33 Just before 2020, when the Abraham Accords began
4:10:36 rapidly accelerating Israel's recognition across the Arab world,
4:10:40 the Iranians were making significant geopolitical
4:10:42 gains against the Arab monarchy specifically.
4:10:45 They'd successfully backed the Shia adjacent Houthi movement in Yemen and kept
4:10:49 them in power over most of the western side of the country,
4:10:52 immediately opposite from Saudi Arabia's
4:10:53 Shia majority and unstable southern border,
4:10:56 and directly across from the strategic Bab el-Mandeb Strait,
4:10:59 through which a large amount of Saudi Arabia's oil exports flow through.
4:11:02 Despite the Saudis spending nearly 265 billion dollars
4:11:08 in a years-long military intervention to crush the Houthis that failed,
4:11:12 Iran's Shia militia organizations were growing increasingly powerful
4:11:15 and influential in Iraq after the destruction of ISIS.
4:11:18 Bashar al-Assad's government was winning the civil
4:11:20 war in Syria against the Saudi supported side.
4:11:23 Hezbollah was growing even more powerful and more
4:11:25 heavily armed than the Lebanese government itself.
4:11:28 While the Gaza Strip, ruled by Hamas,
4:11:30 remained a thorn in the side of both Israel
4:11:32 and the anti-Islamist regime in Egypt of Abdel Fattah el-Sisi.
4:11:36 These pieces, carefully positioned by the Iranians over
4:11:39 decades across the board of the Middle East,
4:11:42 represents what Tehran likes to call its axis of resistance.
4:11:46 And Saudi Arabia was beginning to feel like the axis was encircling them.
4:11:50 And then in 2019, Iran itself, or its proxies,
4:11:53 even fired cruise missiles at Saudi Arabia that blew up
4:11:56 the Kingdom's biggest oil processing facilities at Abqaiq and Khurais,
4:12:00 that temporarily knocked half of the country's oil production offline.
4:12:03 An attack that the Kingdom's historic defender,
4:12:06 the United States, refused to retaliate over.
4:12:09 The Saudi monarchy quickly calculated after those attacks and after
4:12:11 their military quagmire in Yemen that in order for them
4:12:14 to have the best shot at surviving the coming
4:12:16 inevitable confrontations with Iran over the rest of the century,
4:12:19 they could no longer continue relying exclusively
4:12:22 on their status as the world's biggest exporter and supplier of oil to keep
4:12:25 the United States interested in defending them.
4:12:28 A country that was becoming increasingly self-reliant on their own
4:12:31 oil production through the shale and fracking revolutions.
4:12:34 They needed to lock down an ironclad
4:12:36 mutual defense treaty with the United States, just like the ones Washington has
4:12:40 with their closest allies like NATO, Japan, South Korea,
4:12:43 Australia, and the Philippines that would legally bind
4:12:45 the United States to come to the Kingdom's
4:12:47 defense if they were ever to be attacked by Iran or their proxies again.
4:12:51 And to help lock that treaty down, they began to also recognize that the enemy
4:12:55 of their enemy could also end up becoming their friend.
4:12:58 And that friend was potentially Israel, a country they had long opposed
4:13:02 on the basis of solidarity with the Palestinian Arabs,
4:13:05 but a country that posed no serious existential
4:13:08 threat to the monarchy in the Saudi Kingdom,
4:13:10 the same way that revolutionary Iran and its axis of resistance did.
4:13:14 That's part of the context that contributed
4:13:16 to the Sunni monarchies in the United Arab
4:13:18 Emirates and Bahrain agreeing to both recognize
4:13:20 Israel with the Trump administration's mediation in 2020.
4:13:23 And it's been a heavy part of the calculus that has been going on with the Biden
4:13:26 administration's attempts to mediate a further normalization
4:13:29 agreement between the Saudis and the Israelis next.
4:13:32 And thus, across 2022 and 2023, the Saudis, the Israelis,
4:13:37 and the Americans were all negotiating and discussing this process
4:13:40 to jointly solve all of their own unique problems of the 2020s.
4:13:44 Going into the negotiations,
4:13:46 the Saudis were deliberately artificially cutting their own
4:13:49 oil production lower and lower to the point where
4:13:51 their spare oil production capacity reached 3 million
4:13:54 barrels of oil per day by October of 2023,
4:13:57 meaning that essentially, within a single month's notice,
4:14:01 the Saudis could hypothetically decide to just
4:14:03 flip a switch and unleash the spigots
4:14:06 and dump an entire Brazil's worth of oil production onto the world market again,
4:14:11 which would, of course, dramatically reduce global oil prices,
4:14:15 greatly taper global inflationary pressures and fuel
4:14:18 prices leading into the upcoming American presidential election,
4:14:21 while simultaneously harming Russia's ability
4:14:24 to continue financing its war in Ukraine.
4:14:26 As Russia, being the second largest oil exporter in the world,
4:14:30 overwhelmingly relies on selling its own oil and gas
4:14:33 reserves to fund their own government and military expenditures.
4:14:36 And the lower global oil prices are,
4:14:38 the less money Russia has to continue funding its war in Ukraine.
4:14:42 The Biden administration, obviously,
4:14:44 would greatly desire this outcome of the Saudis unleashing their taps.
4:14:48 And to sweeten the deal even further, the Saudis would be willing to fully
4:14:51 normalize their relations with Israel as well,
4:14:54 granting the Biden administration a historic political achievement
4:14:58 that the Trump administration before it wasn't quite capable of acquiring.
4:15:02 All they were asking for in return was
4:15:04 for Washington to solve all of their own problems.
4:15:07 An ironclad mutual defense treaty permanently committing the United
4:15:10 States to the Kingdom's future defense against Iran,
4:15:13 and American nuclear energy technology to enable
4:15:15 the Saudis to establish a nuclear energy
4:15:17 industry that would include the ability to enrich
4:15:20 their own uranium that, in a pinch,
4:15:23 could enable the Saudis to rapidly develop their own nuclear
4:15:27 weapon in the event that the Iranians suddenly developed one first.
4:15:31 To the Biden administration in the United States,
4:15:33 a deal enabling greater cooperation between the Israelis and the Gulf
4:15:36 Arab monarchies was also highly desirable for multiple reasons.
4:15:41 It was well known by this point that America was attempting
4:15:43 to finally withdraw most of its military forces from the Middle
4:15:46 East in order to focus on countering what Washington views
4:15:49 as the far more pressing geopolitical challenges of the decade,
4:15:53 Russian military aggression and expansion
4:15:55 in Europe aimed at Ukraine, Georgia, Moldova,
4:15:58 and likely elsewhere in the former Soviet world,
4:16:00 and Chinese desires to fully and finally dominate Taiwan in East Asia.
4:16:05 The Biden administration's commitment to finally withdraw
4:16:08 from America's military presence in the region
4:16:10 to focus more aggressively on these other
4:16:12 theaters was most infamously symbolized
4:16:14 by the disastrous American withdrawal from Afghanistan in the summer of 2021
4:16:19 and the ensuing Taliban blitzkrieg that immediately
4:16:22 catapulted the Taliban right back into power again,
4:16:25 that undo nearly all of America's trillions of dollars,
4:16:28 thousands of lives, and decades of effort spent trying to dislodge them.
4:16:33 Washington knows that Iran and its axis of resistance
4:16:36 remains its most potent geopolitical threat in the Middle East,
4:16:40 who is the most capable force of throwing
4:16:41 the entire world economy into chaos by launching
4:16:45 wars in the Persian Gulf and all around
4:16:47 the world's most critical oil and gas trade routes.
4:16:50 The consequences of which would be spiking global oil and gas prices that would
4:16:54 most immediately benefit the Russian war
4:16:56 machine that is still raging across Ukraine.
4:16:59 This is why the United States, now more than ever,
4:17:02 needs its local allies in the Middle East who
4:17:04 have historically not cooperated well together because of the Palestinian
4:17:07 issue remaining unresolved to set aside their differences and finally
4:17:11 begin cooperating to contain Iran and its axis of resistance,
4:17:15 while Washington's own forces relocate to focus on containing
4:17:18 China in the Pacific and Russia in Eastern Europe.
4:17:22 This is why the United States wants Israel and Saudi Arabia,
4:17:25 its two biggest partners in the Middle East and the two
4:17:28 greatest Middle Eastern military powers beyond Iran and Turkey,
4:17:31 who have never had any formal relations before,
4:17:34 to finally begin working together along with the United Arab Emirates
4:17:38 and Bahrain against all of their mutual enemies in the region,
4:17:41 Iran's axis of resistance.
4:17:44 And then to Israel, Saudi Arabia, of all countries,
4:17:47 extending their recognition to the Jewish
4:17:49 state would be a permanent game-changer.
4:17:51 Saudi Arabia is the leading oil exporter of the world,
4:17:55 and with that comes enormous economic power.
4:17:58 Dominated by its world-leading oil exports,
4:18:01 Saudi Arabia wields what is by far the largest economy in the Arab world
4:18:05 that is more than two and a half times larger than the Egyptian economy,
4:18:09 despite having only a third of Egypt's population.
4:18:12 The Saudi economy is indeed so outsized compared to the rest of the Arab
4:18:16 world that it represents nearly 1/3 of the entire Arab all on its own.
4:18:22 Saudi Arabia is thus most often thought
4:18:25 of as the premier leading Arab state today,
4:18:27 despite having only the sixth largest overall population in the Arab world.
4:18:32 And it's not just because of Saudi Arabia's outsized economic power,
4:18:36 either, but for the religious legitimacy within the worldwide Islamic faith,
4:18:40 owing to their control and stewardship over the two
4:18:42 holiest cities and sites in Islam, Mecca and Medina.
4:18:46 If the Saudis recognized Israel's legitimacy,
4:18:49 then there's no telling how much further
4:18:51 their heavyweight would have carried with influencing
4:18:54 even more Arab and Muslim countries around the world to recognize Israel next,
4:18:59 especially in the context of Sudan, Morocco, Bahrain,
4:19:02 and the United Arab Emirates,
4:19:03 all recognizing Israel immediately beforehand, too.
4:19:07 But the Saudi monarchy knew that simply
4:19:09 recognizing Israel without addressing the underlying question
4:19:12 of Palestinian statehood at all would have been
4:19:14 a deeply unpopular move among their own people,
4:19:17 who continue to overwhelmingly value their solidarity
4:19:20 with their fellow Palestinian Arabs more than
4:19:23 the cold geopolitical calculus that the ruling family
4:19:27 prioritizes for the sake of their own survival.
4:19:30 And so, Riyadh was also demanding some limited and relatively