Sam Altman testimony: Musk thought OpenAI would fail
CNBC Television
0:10 W EL CO ME B AC K.
0:11 S AM A LT MA N TA KI NG T HE S TA ND F OR T HE F IR ST
0:14 TI ME T OD AY I N HI S T RI AL V ER SU S EL ON M US K.
0:16 K AT E R OO NE Y I S AT TH E CO UR TH OU SE W
0:17 IT H T HE D ET AI LS IN T OD AY 'S T EC H C HE CK.
0:19 K AT E.
0:21 H I, K EL LY.
0:22 S O S AM A LT MA N IS IN T HE C OU RT HO US E B EH IN D M E.
0:24 H E IS T ES TI FY IN G A S WE S PE AK A ND IS T AL KI NG A BO
0:26 UT E LO N M US K WA NT IN G A BS OL UT E C ON TR OL O F OP EN AI,
0:30 P US HI NG B AC K ON T HE NA RR AT IV E TH AT W E' VE H EA RD O VE R TH
0:32 E PA ST C OU PL E OF W EE KS T HA T OP EN AI D EC EI VE D E LO N M US K.
0:35 AC CO RD IN G TO A LT MA N O N T HE ST AN D T OD AY,
0:37 M US K T HO UG HT T HE AI L AB W OU LD F AI L.
0:40 Q UO TE, L OS T CO NF ID EN CE.
0:41 H E S AI D T HA T MU SK DI D NO T B EL IE
0:43 VE W E W ER E GO IN G TO B E S UC CE SS FU L.
0:44 S O TH ER E W AS A 0% C HA NC E OF O PE NA I A CT UA LL Y SU CC EE DI NG.
0:48 A ND T HE N E LO N M US K LE FT T HE B OA RD S EC ON D.
0:50 A ND RE LA TE D A CC OR DI NG T O A LT MA N,
0:52 H E SA ID T HA T M US K W AN TE D TO S TA RT A N EW A I EF FO RT O
0:55 VE R T ES LA A ND TH EN D ID N' T W AN T TO B E CO NF LI CT ED I N TH AT.
0:58 T AL KI NG AB OU T T HE R EA SO N W HY M US K L EF T TH E BO AR D,
1:01 A LT MA N IS A LS O TE ST IF YI NG T HA T M ER GI NG O PE NA I WI TH
1:03 T ES LA A CT UA LL Y CA ME U P MU LT IP LE T IM ES O VE R T HE Y EA RS,
1:07 AN D T HE N I T' S CO ME D OW N TO M US
1:08 T AT TE MP T T O C ON TR OL T HE C OM PA NY.
1:10 TH AT H AS B EE N A C EN TR AL T HE ME FO R T HE D EF EN SE.
1:13 A LT MA N T OD AY, HE S AI D T HA T M US K W AN TE D 9 0% O
1:15 F OP EN AI 'S E QU IT Y AT O NE P OI NT SA ID T HA T S OF TE NE D,
1:18 B UT I T WA S AL WA YS A M AJ OR IT Y.
1:19 A ND T HE N AL TM AN W EN T ON T O TA LK A BO UT HI M
1:22 B EI NG E XT RE ME LY UN CO MF OR TA BL E, I N H IS W OR DS.
1:25 WI TH A LL O F T HO SE A TT EM PT S B Y,
1:26 MU SK S HA RE D W HA T H E C AL LE D A HA IR R AI SI NG A NE CD OT E,
1:29 WH ER E HE TA LK ED A BO UT C ON TR OL O F O PE NA I,
1:31 WH AT W OU LD H AP PE N IF H E P AS SE D AW AY.
1:33 AN D TH EN H E SA ID, I HA DN 'T R EA LL Y TH OU GH T A BO UT I T.
1:35 I TH IN K I W OU LD P AS S IT O N T O MY C HI LD RE N.
1:37 T HA T W AS O NE AN EC DO TE W E GO T.
1:39 A LT MA N AL SO SA ID T HA T I T WA S A MO RA LE
1:41 B OO ST WH EN M US K AC TU AL LY L EF T EV EN TU AL LY,
1:42 T HA T HE W OU LD U SE ST AC K R AN KI NG F OR E MP LO YE ES,
1:44 AN D T HE N T HA T D EM OT IV AT ED S OM E OF T HE K EY T AL EN T.
1:47 Q UO TE.
1:47 I DO N' T T HI NK M R.
1:48 M US K, A S AL TM AN IS C AL LI NG H IM I N T HE RE,
1:51 UN DE RS TO OD H OW T O R UN A G OO D RE SE AR CH L AB.
1:53 H E D ID A LS O DI SC US S S OM E FE AR S T HA
1:55 T M US K WO UL D B AS H O PE NA I O N T WI TT ER.
1:57 AS W E H AV E SE EN P LA Y O UT I N T HE RE CE NT Y EA RS,
2:00 A ND A LT MA N D ID RE IT ER AT E T HI S LA
2:01 RG ER P OI NT TH AT W E HA VE H EA RD F RO M TH
2:03 E DE FE NS E S O F AR T HA T M US K W AN TE
2:04 D TH IS T O B E A F OR P RO FI T C ON TR OL,
2:07 TH EY S AY W AS W AS T HE A CT UA L IS SU E.
2:09 I T W AS N' T AB OU T M IS SI ON CR EE P.
2:10 A ND T HE N M US K I S N OW, TH EY S AY, T RY IN G T O D ER AI L OP EN AI A S H
2:13 E BU IL DS A CO MP ET IT OR, O F C OU RS E, X A I MU SK O N T HE O TH ER S ID E,
2:17 I S SU IN G O PE NA I O N G RO UN DS T HA T HE WA S D EC
2:19 EI VE D A ND T HA T A LT MA N HE LP ED S TE AL A C HA RI TY.
2:22 I N HI S WO RD S, O PE NA I D EN IE S TH AT.
2:25 KE LL Y, B AC K O VE R.
2:25 T O Y OU.
2:26 HO W M UC H MO RE W IL L WE H EA R FR OM A LT MA N?
2:28 A ND T HE N WH EN D O W E TH IN K WE 'L L HE AR FR OM M US K?
2:30 S O W E E XP EC T CR OS S- EX AM IN AT IO N.
2:32 H E' S S TI LL GE TT IN G B AS IC AL LY I NT ER VI EW ED BY H IS L AW YE RS.
2:35 AN D S O TH AT TE ND S TO B E K IN D OF A FR IE ND LI ER V IB E.
2:37 A ND T HE N W E WI LL G ET C RO SS -E XA MI NA TI ON, WH IC H TE ND
2:39 S T O BE A L IT TL E B IT MO RE C ON FR ON TA TI ON AL A ND T EN SE.
2:43 AN D TH EN M US K, W E A CT UA LL Y GO T IN W EE K O NE.
2:44 SO W E H AV E HE AR D MU SK 'S S ID E O F IT,
2:46 W HI CH T AL K AB OU T C ON FR ON TA TI ON AL.
2:48 H E RE AL LY W EN T BA CK A ND F OR TH W IT H TH E DE FE NS E A TT OR NE YS.
2:51 AN D H IS SI DE O F T HE S TO RY W AS B AS IC AL LY IT W AS A N ON P RO FI T.
2:54 I T' S NO W AN 8 50 B IL LI ON C OM PA NY, B IL LI ON DO LL AR C OM PA NY.
2:57 T HA T' S NO T F AI R.
2:58 TH EY S TO LE A C HA RI TY.
2:59 A ND W E HA VE H EA RD A C OM PL ET EL Y OP PO SI TE T
3:01 ON E A ND S ID E O F T HE ST OR Y F RO M O PE NA I.
3:04 R EA LL Y, AL TM AN U P T HE RE I S S AY IN G I T' S ST IL L A M IS SI