How medical reps used hammers
Lateral with Tom Scott
0:07 In the early 1900s, salesmen for the pharmaceutical
0:11 company Upjohn visited doctors in Michigan,
0:14 bringing along a pine board and a hammer.
0:18 Why?
0:19 I'll read that again.
0:22 In the early 1900s, salesmen for the pharmaceutical
0:26 company Upjohn visited doctors in Michigan,
0:29 bringing along a pine board and a hammer.
0:33 Why?
0:34 I'll say it.
0:35 What's Upjohn?
0:36 Yeah, what's up John?
0:38 Nothing much.
0:39 (sighs) (guffaws) (wheezes) It's a pharmaceutical company, Tom.
0:43 It was in the question.
0:44 (chuckles) Yeah.
0:45 So, what do we think, team?
0:47 There's a story about...
0:50 and so this is a US advertising story from a long, long time ago.
0:54 There's a tourist attraction called Rock City,
0:58 which is— it's a collection of curiosities and things
1:01 on top of a mountain with a good view.
1:04 And the way they advertised it is they sent
1:06 people out to offer to paint barns for free.
1:10 Your farm, your farmer's barn,
1:12 will get a brand new coat of paint, all be restored,
1:14 provided they could also paint "Visit Rock City"
1:18 on the top of it as a billboard.
1:20 And I'm trying to work out if there's something similar,
1:22 that pharmaceutical companies could come along with a pine
1:24 board and a hammer to advertise their drugs.
1:28 Oh, is that what they'd done?
1:29 We got— I— that was not where I went.
1:32 Oh, where did you go?
1:33 How did you go, Lizzy?
1:34 Picture this.
1:36 A calcium deficient area.
1:38 (cackles softly) Some people turn up, and they're like,
1:41 "Buy some vitamins from us." And people are like, "No." And then they're like,
1:44 "Watch us." (laughs) And then they smash a bone on the pine board.
1:49 And they're like, "Ey,
1:50 eat some calcium." But I think it's probably the advertising thing,
1:54 rather than them using them as bone smashing boards.
1:58 I wonder if there's some kind of demonstration they
2:00 do that involves using a pine board and a hammer.
2:03 That proves to people that they need some
2:04 kind of medicine that they didn't think they needed.
2:07 Hmm, that is what pharmaceutical companies make
2:11 a lot of money from, particularly in North America.
2:13 I would say, if you take Tom's theory,
2:17 and Lizzy and Katie's theory together, Lizzy and Katie are closer than Tom.
2:22 (belly laughs) Okay.
2:24 Hilarious.
2:25 It's bone smashing.
2:26 We worked it out.
2:28 You could have let me down in a less cruel way, but sure.
2:31 That was cruel?
2:33 Me?
2:34 Oh, I'm so sorry, Tom.
2:35 We're two people, so we've got more
2:37 thinking power between us, so it's only fair.
2:39 Yeah.
2:39 No, Tom, your ideas are really good.
2:41 They're so good.
2:42 Just not this time.
2:43 Never mind.
2:43 Just put me down cruelly.
2:45 That's better.
2:45 (laughs) You're trying so hard.
2:47 (snickers) Yeah.
2:48 You've got a podcast, Tom.
2:50 That's great.
2:50 Alright, alright, fine!
2:51 Thank you.
2:51 I regret...
2:52 (guests laughing) I regret entirely even mentioning that.
2:57 Okay, so in the question, who...
3:00 who, right, are these...
3:03 You know, who's being visited by who?
3:06 Think about— So is it reps visiting doctors
3:10 to try and get them to buy the drugs?
3:12 It's not reps selling drugs to individuals, okay?
3:16 Mhm, salesmen visiting doctors.
3:18 It's not "Step right up" by the snake oil.
3:20 It's trying to convince the doctors.
3:22 Okay.
3:23 So the doctors...
3:25 would understand more medicine than the average person.
3:28 So they would need convincing, using something that was...
3:31 Using a hammer!
3:32 Using— yeah.
3:33 I mean, convincing is definitely a thing you can do with a hammer.
3:37 (giggles) Okay, what— It's a pharma company, right?
3:40 Let's think about...
3:41 Yeah.
3:41 what they might be trying to sell.
3:43 Drugs, pills, potions.
3:45 Picture this.
3:47 Put a board out.
3:48 And they just put their hand on the board, and they're like,
3:51 "Hard to find good pain relief these days."
3:53 And then they hit their own hand with a hammer,
3:56 and they're like, "Didn't even feel it.
3:58 Buy paracetamol" or whatever.
4:01 So, yeah, I didn't mean to— in my sort of degrading of Tom,
4:04 I didn't mean to really enthusiastically
4:06 encourage Lizzy's love of smashing body parts.
4:08 (laughs heartily) (wheezes) This is not...
4:10 it's not that.
4:11 In fact Tom, you said...
4:12 What a sentence!
4:13 You said something, and you when, yeah, you— when you answered my last question,
4:17 Tom, you said something that could take you down a good lead.
4:20 A good route.
4:21 Pills, potions, and...
4:23 something else.
4:25 I was trying to work out what they might be selling.
4:27 So it was...
4:29 Bandages or equipment or...
4:31 It's not a surgical hammer.
4:33 No, stop thinking about smashing body bits.
4:36 Did they just go in and smash up all the stuff in the doctor's surgery,
4:39 and then they're like,
4:40 "Oh, it looks like you need to buy some stuff." (laughs) No,
4:44 yeah, it's not destruction.
4:46 Not a mafia pharmaceutical company.
4:48 Yeah.
4:48 Yeah.
4:48 Literally one of the things you said, Tom.
4:50 One of the— yeah.
4:51 Which one?
4:52 I can't remember what I said.
4:53 The two you gave just then were pills and potions.
4:55 Yes, was it the other one?
4:57 No, it was one of those two.
4:58 So think about one of those two.
5:00 Well, they're gonna be trying to sell pills, aren't they,
5:02 out of— Are they smashing up pills on the board?
5:05 Okay.
5:05 So they're like, "Right,
5:06 you wanna have some of this medicine?" And then they're like,
5:11 bam-bam-bam-bam-bam.
5:11 And they smash up some and then they roll 'em out.
5:13 'Cause you used to roll 'em.
5:15 No, no.
5:15 Hold on, hold on.
5:17 There are compounding pharmacies, and there are pharmacies that just sell pills.
5:23 So there are pharmacies where you— they're not just
5:26 selling the pills that were made in the factory.
5:27 They have the raw ingredients to make pills.
5:30 They have doses of the medicine that get measured out and put together.
5:34 So are they advertising something like...
5:37 "We'll— We hammer the pills together for you"?
5:39 (wheezes) No.
5:41 No, they're not.
5:43 Are they getting pills from competing pharmaceutical companies,
5:46 and smashing them open to show that they're just powder?
5:50 And that their pills are obviously better 'cause they've got something in?
5:55 Take that idea and do something different with it.
5:59 (Tom and Sophie laugh) Okay.
6:00 I see what you're saying.
6:01 So competing, you're right.
6:02 They are comparing with competing...
6:04 Mm.
6:05 They are comparing with competing pills.
6:08 So, it does involve taking competitors' pills and their pills,
6:11 and doing a comparison.
6:12 All piller, no filler.
6:14 Hm.
6:14 (wheezes) So they're trying to prove
6:16 that their pills are really strong, are they?
6:18 Ooh.
6:19 With their stuff?
6:19 So they're gonna smash up some other stuff and be like,
6:23 "This is weak calcium." Is the strength of the pill related
6:26 to the amount of like gunk that they've put in to pad it out?
6:30 'Cause that's the thing, right?
6:31 When they make drugs, they put like chalk or whatever to make the pill bigger.
6:35 And they're like...
6:38 it will crumble more easily if it's got a higher chalk content or something.
6:41 Okay, there's a lot of conversations around what...
6:43 some of you're saying, oh, well these pills will be better,
6:46 because they have this quality, whereas they wanna— Actually,
6:49 what kind of quality do you want...
6:51 or would you not want In a pill?
6:53 Yeah, you'd want them to be— break up and be absorbed by the body really fast.
6:57 But you'd want them to not break up inside the...
7:01 pill box, the canister.
7:04 Okay, yeah, go with Lizzy's idea that you don't want it to be...
7:07 (stifles laugh) (laughs) Sorry, sorry.
7:08 So they would try and smash some pills, and it would be quite hard,
7:11 and then they'd do theirs, and it'd be quite easy, would it?
7:14 So they're like, these pills are really hard to smash,
7:17 that you're using, but these ones will crumble in an instant.
7:21 Okay, which is good because...
7:23 'Cause it's better absorption?
7:25 Yeah.
7:25 So quicker, like if it's painkillers, then they quicker act— faster acting,
7:28 because they're gonna be breaking down quicker.
7:30 And so what is gonna happen?
7:32 Yeah, with a pine board and a hammer,
7:34 and you get one of the other pills, what will happen?
7:37 One of the competitor pills?
7:38 Will it dent the pine?
7:41 Because pine is a soft wood.
7:43 Mm.
7:44 So if you turn up, and you get your competitor's pill,
7:49 and you slam it with a hammer,
7:50 the pill will survive, and the wood will have a dent in it.
7:55 And then theirs will crumble, will it?
7:56 And that will convince the doctor that perhaps
7:59 these pills are not ideal for the patient.
8:01 Yeah, exactly.
8:02 We got there.
8:03 It was a good team collaboration.
8:05 So basically, so we got there.
8:07 Do I sound— I'm— You guys did— Everything I say sounds sarcastic.
8:11 I'm just gonna stop.
8:12 (others laughing) So basically, yeah, so...
8:14 Upjohn Pharmaceutical— I helped!
8:16 I'm proud of us.
8:17 (laughs) You said the word 'pills', Tom.
8:19 Hey listen, that was big.
8:21 Oh no, listen.
8:22 Okay, so, yeah.
8:23 Upjohn Pharmaceutical Companies would go around doctors
8:25 with a piece of pine and a hammer,
8:26 and they'd be like, here's our competitors' pills.
8:29 If we put it on the pine, and we hammer it,
8:31 the pill literally gets hammered into the wood,
8:34 whereas theirs were what's called 'friable'.
8:37 They were, they could be crushed by your fingers,
8:39 and that meant that they were more soluble,
8:41 and so the chemicals could be taken up by your body more easily,
8:44 and that was how they sold their pills with a pine board and a hammer.
8:48 The Lateral Producer's Club is at lateralcast.com
8:52 if you would like more Lateral, fewer adverts, and to support the show.
8:58 Caption+ by JS* caption.plus| @caption_plus